FedCourtsAI

Which Supreme Court cases matter? AI models call it before the Court acts

Three AI models (Claude from Anthropic, Codex from OpenAI, and Gemini from Google) read cases pending at the Supreme Court and predict what the Court will do. Every prediction is timestamped and saved to a public record before the Court acts, so anyone can check later how the models did. How it works.

This page ranks the cases the models think matter most. Each model gives every case a big-case score from 0 (routine) to 1 (landmark). Because the scores are recorded in advance, no one can redefine what counted as a big case after the term ends.

The score is an opinion, not a forecast: it isn't graded, and a high score doesn't mean the Court will take the case. Tap a case to see each model's predictions and its reasoning.

Updated Nov 16, 2026 · ledger commit b47ebdc

How to read this board

The big-case score

Each model gives every case it predicts a score from 0 to 1 for how much the case matters: 0 is a routine petition, 1 is a landmark. The Average column is the mean of the models' scores, and the board is sorted by it. The score is a pre-registered opinion, not a forecast. It says nothing about whether the Court will take the case, and it is never marked right or wrong; instead, a separate evaluator later grades the quality of its reasoning.

Treat the order as rough. The three models' scores for a single case are usually further apart than neighboring cases are from each other, so the gap between two adjacent ranks is smaller than the disagreement behind it. Rows also aren't strictly comparable when they answer different questions: the models tend to rate the stakes higher once a case reaches the merits stage than at the petition stage.

Where the average says "2 of 3 models", one model hasn't yet predicted the case's current stage. Its earlier score is shown inside the case but isn't included in the average. Scored forecasts, as opposed to these opinions, are on the leaderboard in the repository.

What an expanded case shows

Most cases open with a short plain-language summary, written by a separate AI model from the Court's filings (about the summaries). The line under each case's name on the board is a one-sentence version of that summary, and the tag beside the name is its topic. The docket number links to the case's page on the Supreme Court's website.

Below the summary, a timeline shows how far the case has come and what each possible decision would mean, naming the parties where the case's caption allows. Those sentences use fixed wording; they aren't written by a model.

A case can be predicted several times as it moves through the Court, and each prediction answers one question asked at one point in time. The timeline steps marked "predicted" are those points. The newest is selected to start with; choose another step to see the predictions made there.

There are three stages, each with its own question. Under each question, the board lists every model's newest prediction: its big-case score, the probability it gave, and (at the first two stages) the single outcome it thought most likely. The probability is what gets scored, so "chance the Court takes the case: 12%, prediction: turn it down" is one position, not two.

Prediction madeLedger event id
Will the Court take the case?
When the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docketevt-petition-arrival-disposition
After the Court called for a response to the petitionevt-order-call-for-response-disposition
Once the petition was distributed for conferenceevt-petition-disposition
After the Court first relisted the petition for another conferenceevt-order-relist-disposition
After the Court asked for the Solicitor General's viewsevt-order-cvsg-disposition
Once the Solicitor General filed the brief the Court invitedevt-brief-sg-disposition
Will the Court grant the emergency application?
When the application arrivedevt-motion-disposition
After the Court called for a responseevt-order-response-requested-disposition
Once a response was filedevt-brief-response-disposition
Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?
When the Court agreed to hear the caseevt-order-judgment
Once both sides' merits briefs were inevt-brief-judgment
After the case was arguedevt-argument-judgment

At the petition stage, "send it back for reconsideration" (a GVR) and "reverse without hearing argument" both count as the Court taking the case. For an emergency application, relief granted in part counts as a grant; predictions made under an earlier process version were scored with a partial grant as a denial. At the merits stage there's no single most-likely outcome to show; the predicted judgment and vote are in the linked prediction. Legal terms are explained in the glossary.

"Possible leak"

Models are free to search the web when they predict, and afterwards an evaluator reads what each one looked at. A prediction is tagged possible leak when the evaluator finds signs that the model may have seen how the case turned out before predicting it. The tag is a warning about that one prediction, not about the case. A case carries the tag when any of the predictions in its average does.

The Court's next conference is . 27 cases on this board are set for it so far.

Big-case score · 0 = routine, 1 = landmark

Case
Claude
Codex
Gemini
Average
Grant v. HigginsThe Court agreed to hear a challenge to Connecticut's assault weapons ban, consolidated with a related case, after gun owners and advocacy groups asked it to strike down the law.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.97
0.94
0.95
0.95

Eddie Grant, Jr., et al. v. Ronnell Higgins, in His Official Capacity as Commissioner of the Connecticut Department of Emergency Services and Public Transportation, et al.No. 25-566 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279009 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Firearms

The Court agreed to hear a challenge to Connecticut's assault weapons ban, consolidated with a related case, after gun owners and advocacy groups asked it to strike down the law.

What happened

Connecticut restricts certain semiautomatic firearms, including AR-15-style rifles, that its legislature classifies as assault weapons. Eddie Grant, Jr. and other individuals and gun-rights groups sued Connecticut officials, arguing the ban violates their right to keep and bear arms. A federal district court denied their request to block the law while the case proceeded, and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the restrictions fit within a historical tradition of regulating unusually dangerous weapons. The challengers then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution protects the right to possess semiautomatic rifles that are commonly owned for lawful purposes, including the AR-15, or whether a state may ban such weapons as unusually dangerous despite their widespread ownership.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted review, consolidating this case with a related petition, and the case has been briefed and argued; it now awaits a decision on the merits.

What each outcome would mean

Grant and the other challengers are asking the Court to overturn the Second Circuit's ruling, which upheld Connecticut's law. If the Court reverses, it would find the ban likely unconstitutional, a result favoring Grant and the other challengers. If it affirms, Connecticut's restrictions would stand, a result favoring the state officials who defended the law. If the Court vacates the decision, it would send the case back to the lower courts without deciding the constitutional question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 2, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Grant wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Higgins wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court's first plenary test of a hardware ban since Heller: whether states may prohibit AR-15-platform rifles, the most commonly owned rifle in the country, with equivalent bans in roughly ten states and the framework for all arms-ban litigation riding on the answer.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The judgment is likely to govern categorical AR-15-style rifle bans across numerous jurisdictions and clarify Bruen's common-use rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A major Second Amendment challenge to assault weapons bans affecting millions of firearms, clarifying the Bruen standard.

United States v. CarrollThe federal government asked the Supreme Court to hear its bid to substitute itself for President Trump as defendant in E. Jean Carroll's defamation lawsuit.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.95
0.96
0.95
0.95

United States v. E. Jean Carroll, et al.No. 26-142 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000142 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: Civil procedure

The federal government asked the Supreme Court to hear its bid to substitute itself for President Trump as defendant in E. Jean Carroll's defamation lawsuit.

What happened

E. Jean Carroll sued Donald Trump for defamation over statements he made in 2019 denying her sexual assault allegations. A jury eventually awarded her $83.3 million. Years earlier, the Justice Department had certified that Trump's statements fell within the scope of his job, which would let the government take his place as defendant under a law called the Westfall Act. The department later withdrew that certification, so the case proceeded against Trump personally. After trial and appeal, a new Attorney General tried to recertify and substitute the government back in. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals rejected that move, ruling it came too late and was barred by the statute, by waiver, and by fairness to Carroll.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether the appeals court wrongly read the Westfall Act as barring the government from certifying, after a trial has concluded, that an employee's conduct was within the scope of his federal job.

Where it stands

The petition was filed in July 2026. Carroll filed a brief opposing review on October 30, 2026, after receiving an extension and permission to file a combined response to this petition and a related one. The docket shows no further action since then.

What each outcome would mean

The United States, as petitioner, is asking the Court to overturn the lower court's decision, which left Trump as the defendant and let Carroll's jury award stand. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the government may recertify Trump's conduct as official after trial; granting review decides nothing by itself about who wins. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling stands, Trump remains the defendant, and Carroll's judgment is unaffected by this petition.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the United States' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The United States' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A sitting President's ~$100M personal defamation liability turns on whether the Westfall Act permits posttrial recertification; the decision would shape the scope-of-office shield for every future President.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.96·Chance the Court takes the case: 74%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Review would affect presidential tort exposure, the finality of Westfall Act certifications, and a nationally prominent judgment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes constitutional issue involving the scope of presidential immunity and the Westfall Act.

Trump v. CaliforniaThe Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court order blocking parts of an election-related executive order from applying before the November 2026 election.Civil proceduredecided
0.97
0.94
0.95
0.95

Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al. v. California, et al.No. 26A124 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000124 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Civil procedure

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court order blocking parts of an election-related executive order from applying before the November 2026 election.

What happened

President Trump issued an executive order directing federal agencies to compile citizenship lists for voters and to have the Postal Service propose mail-ballot rules, among other provisions. California and other states sued, arguing the order was unconstitutional and exceeded presidential authority. A federal district court agreed, ruling two sections of the order unlawful and blocking federal agencies from enforcing them against the plaintiff states for the November 2026 election. The First Circuit Court of Appeals declined to pause that injunction while the government's appeal proceeded. The federal government then asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the lower court's order blocking the executive order should be paused while the case continues on appeal. The government argues the states cannot yet sue because the order has not been fully carried out and any harm is speculative. The states respond that they face immediate, concrete costs and burdens in preparing for upcoming elections.

Where it stands

The application was referred to the full Court, which granted the stay on August 24, 2026, pausing the injunction pending the appeal and any later Supreme Court review. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson dissented.

What each outcome would mean

The government, as applicant, asked the Court to pause the injunction obtained by California and other states. By granting the stay, the Court allowed federal agencies to proceed with implementing the executive order's citizenship-list and mail-ballot provisions ahead of the November 2026 election while the First Circuit appeal continues, meaning California's injunction no longer blocks that implementation for now. The stay is temporary: it ends automatically if certiorari is denied, or upon this Court's judgment if certiorari is granted. The underlying legal dispute over the order's validity remains unresolved in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedAug 24, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court grants the application: 25%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Government application to stay lower-court injunctions against a presidential executive order on federal election administration, weeks before the 2026 midterms; enormous separation-of-powers and election-law stakes with heavy amicus participation.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.96·Chance the Court grants the application: 45%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A presidential emergency application against California concerning election administration has national institutional and political significance if decided.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 15%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile dispute over a presidential executive order regarding citizenship verification and mail-ballot rules, with significant implications for the upcoming November 2026 federal elections.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court grants the application: 30%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A presidential application to stay an injunction against an executive order on federal election administration, weeks before the 2026 midterms, with the SG as counsel and thirteen amicus filings at the stay stage.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court grants the application: 44%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A presidential emergency application over federal election administration has nationwide institutional and electoral stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 1.00·Chance the Court grants the application: 25%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major constitutional challenge by 23 states to a presidential executive order altering federal election administration.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court grants the application: 15%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A presidential executive order restructuring mail-in voting nationwide, on an emergency stay posture weeks before the midterm elections, with 23 states on one side, 12 on the other, and a dozen-plus amicus filings at the application stage.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns federal control of mail-ballot administration immediately before a nationwide election.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 20%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile dispute over a presidential executive order altering mail-in voting procedures nationwide right before the midterm elections.

United States v. TalbottThe federal government asks the Court to overturn a ruling that blocked it from discharging 28 transgender servicemembers under a Defense Department policy.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.95
0.95
0.95
0.95

United States, et al. v. Nicolas Talbott, et al.No. 26-272 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000272 · models differ by up to 0.00 · topic: Constitutional rights

The federal government asks the Court to overturn a ruling that blocked it from discharging 28 transgender servicemembers under a Defense Department policy.

What happened

In 2025, the Department of War adopted a policy, following a presidential executive order, that generally disqualifies people with gender dysphoria or a history of it from military service, including by discharging those currently serving. A group of transgender servicemembers and applicants sued, claiming the policy denies them equal protection under the Constitution. A district court blocked the policy nationwide. A divided panel of the D.C. Circuit narrowed that order, preserving it only for 28 named servicemembers already serving, while letting the policy apply to new applicants. The government asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether this military policy, which screens out people with gender dysphoria or a history of related treatment, violates the constitutional guarantee that the government treat people equally.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including amicus briefs and a brief opposing review filed in November 2026. The docket does not yet show whether the Court has acted on it.

What each outcome would mean

The government is asking the Court to reverse the lower court's ruling. If the Court takes the case and ultimately sides with the government, the policy could be applied to discharge the 28 servicemembers currently protected by the injunction. If it rules for Talbott and the other servicemembers, the discharge protections would continue. If the Court denies review, the D.C. Circuit's decision stands, keeping those 28 servicemembers protected from discharge while the broader lawsuit continues in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the United States' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The United States' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 93%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Constitutionality of the military's exclusion of servicemembers with gender dysphoria, brought by the Solicitor General after a circuit held a signature executive-branch policy likely unconstitutional — nationally salient whatever the disposition.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 94%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case concerns nationwide military personnel policy, equal protection, and judicial deference to military judgments.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile constitutional challenge to a major executive policy.

Viramontes v. Cook CountyGun owners and gun-rights groups challenged Cook County's ban on AR-15-style rifles, and the Supreme Court granted review, consolidated the case with a similar Connecticut challenge, and heard argument.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.93
0.95
0.95
0.94

Cutberto Viramontes, et al. v. Cook County, Illinois, et al.No. 25-238 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73275179 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Firearms

Gun owners and gun-rights groups challenged Cook County's ban on AR-15-style rifles, and the Supreme Court granted review, consolidated the case with a similar Connecticut challenge, and heard argument.

What happened

Cutberto Viramontes and other individuals and gun-rights organizations sued Cook County, arguing its ban on "assault weapons," including AR-15-style rifles, violates the Second Amendment. The county countered that these weapons are dangerous, military-style firearms not suited for ordinary self-defense and that every circuit to consider the question has upheld similar bans. The district court and the Seventh Circuit, relying on circuit precedent, ruled for the county, holding that Viramontes had not built a record showing the rifles were constitutionally protected "arms." Viramontes asked the Supreme Court to take the case and overturn that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether the Constitution's guarantee of a right to keep and bear arms protects the right to own AR-15-style and similar semiautomatic rifles, or whether governments may ban them as unusually dangerous weapons not commonly used for lawful self-defense.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, consolidated the case with a related challenge to a Connecticut ban (Grant v. Higgins), and the case was briefed and argued on December 2, 2026. After full briefing, one of the original petitioners asked to be dismissed from the case and the county respondents suggested the case might be moot; the petitioners have disputed that suggestion. The case awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Viramontes and the other gun owners and groups are asking the Court to strike down the county's ban. If the Court rules for Viramontes, Cook County's ban on AR-15-style rifles would be struck down, and similar bans elsewhere would be called into serious doubt. If the Court rules for Cook County, the ban would stand, leaving the county free to prohibit these rifles. The Court could also send the case back without resolving the merits if it finds the dispute moot or otherwise unsuitable for decision at this stage.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 2, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Viramontes wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Cook County wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the Second Amendment protects AR-15-platform rifles — the most widely owned rifle in America — decided on plenary review of consolidated CA7/CA2 cases, controls assault-weapons bans in roughly ten states and many localities.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.93·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case asks whether governments may ban the country's most popular rifle platform, with nationwide consequences for assault-weapons laws and Second Amendment doctrine.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Directly addresses the constitutionality of AR-15 assault weapon bans, a highly salient and politically charged issue under the Second Amendment.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.93·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about 88% chance) rule against Cook County's ban on AR-15-style rifles and reverse the appeals court decision that upheld it. The likely vote is 6–3, with the six conservative Justices in the majority. The main reasons: the Court waited through 22 conferences to pick this case, the federal government supports the gun owners, and the Court's recent decisions say that guns commonly owned by law-abiding people cannot be banned outright.

    Why this big-case score: First plenary ruling on whether states/localities may ban AR-15-platform rifles; affects bans in roughly ten states and many localities.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 89%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to reverse the lower court's decision, most likely by six votes to three. There is about an 89% chance that it reverses or otherwise sets aside that decision. The main reason is that the majority is likely to view AR-15-style rifles as commonly owned weapons protected by the Constitution, despite their military resemblance. The largest uncertainty is whether the Court settles that rule directly or sends the case back for more analysis under a corrected legal standard.

    Why this big-case score: The constitutional status of AR-15 possession has national consequences for categorical rifle bans and for the boundary between protected civilian arms and regulable weapon classes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (about an 88% chance) to overturn the lower court decision that upheld Cook County's ban on AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles. We predict the Court will reverse the judgment by a 6–3 vote, with Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, and Barrett in the majority and Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson dissenting. Under the Court's precedents, the Second Amendment protects firearms that are in common use by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes like self-defense, and because tens of millions of Americans lawfully own AR-15 rifles across more than forty states, the Court will conclude that categorical bans on possessing them are unconstitutional.

    Why this big-case score: Major Second Amendment test of state and local bans on AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles, resolving a deep circuit split affecting laws across roughly a dozen states and numerous municipalities.

Khalid Shaikh Mohammad v. United StatesThe Court declined to review accused September 11 defendants' bid to undo an appeals court order that blocked their guilty pleas under withdrawn plea agreements.Criminal lawdecided
0.90
0.97
0.95
0.94

Khalid Shaikh Mohammad, et al. v. United StatesNo. 26-13 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000013 · models differ by up to 0.07 · topic: Criminal law

The Court declined to review accused September 11 defendants' bid to undo an appeals court order that blocked their guilty pleas under withdrawn plea agreements.

What happened

Khalid Shaikh Mohammad and a co-defendant, facing capital charges before a military commission for the September 11 attacks, had signed plea agreements in which they would plead guilty in exchange for the government not seeking the death penalty. Two days later, the Secretary of Defense withdrew from those agreements. The military judge and a military appellate court ruled the withdrawal came too late, but the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, acting on the government's request, issued orders blocking the guilty pleas and giving effect to the Secretary's withdrawal. The defendants asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether the appeals court had authority to intervene this way when Congress gave the government no right to an ordinary appeal at this stage of a military commission case, and whether the appeals court was wrong to find the government's position so clearly correct that this unusual intervention was justified, when the military judge had followed existing precedent.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for several conferences, rescheduled at points, and on October 19, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Mohammad and his co-defendant, who asked the Court to take the case, sought to overturn the appeals court's decision so their guilty pleas under the original plea agreements could proceed without the death penalty. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the appeals court's decision in place: the Secretary's withdrawal from the plea agreements stands, the guilty pleas under those agreements cannot go forward, and the military commission case continues without that question being decided by the Supreme Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The 9/11 military-commission capital prosecution: a grant would decide whether the withdrawn plea deals sparing the alleged 9/11 plotters the death penalty can be revived, and would set the scope of government mandamus in criminal cases.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The enforceability of plea agreements in the September 11 military-commission prosecutions determines continued capital exposure and implicates executive authority, victims' interests, and the limits of prosecution mandamus. Exceptional stakes do not establish certworthiness.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
National Park Service, et al. v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United StatesThe government asked the Supreme Court to let construction continue on the White House East Wing ballroom while litigation over the project's legality proceeds, and the Court granted that request.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.92
0.94
—
0.93 2 of 3 models

National Park Service, et al. v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United StatesNo. 26A203 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000203 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The government asked the Supreme Court to let construction continue on the White House East Wing ballroom while litigation over the project's legality proceeds, and the Court granted that request.

What happened

A preservation group sued the National Park Service and other federal officials, arguing that demolishing and rebuilding the East Wing for a new ballroom exceeded the government's legal authority. A federal district court issued a preliminary injunction limiting construction to work "strictly necessary" for safety and security. The government appealed, and the D.C. Circuit, over a dissent, upheld the injunction, rejecting the government's arguments that the preservation group lacked standing to sue and that two federal statutes authorized the project. The government then asked the Supreme Court to pause the injunction.

What the Court is being asked

The immediate question was whether to pause the lower court's construction-limiting order while the government pursues further review, including a request that the Court agree to hear the case fully. Underlying that request are disputes about whether the preservation group was harmed enough to sue at all, and whether existing laws let the President authorize this kind of construction without additional approval from Congress.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice first issued a short-term stay on August 21, 2026, while the application was under review. On August 31, 2026, the full Court granted the stay, with four Justices dissenting, keeping the injunction paused while the government's forthcoming petition for Supreme Court review is filed and decided; the stay will end automatically if the Court denies that petition, or if it grants the petition, once the Court issues its final judgment.

What each outcome would mean

The National Park Service and other federal officials, as applicants, asked the Court to pause the injunction. By granting the stay, the Court allowed construction to continue for now, a result favoring the government's position, while the underlying legal dispute over the project's authorization continues. Had the Court denied the stay, the injunction limiting construction to safety-and-security work would have stayed in effect, favoring the National Trust for Historic Preservation, which brought the suit and won in the lower courts. The stay is temporary and does not resolve who is ultimately right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 1, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedAug 31, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-08-31: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Solicitor General emergency application to stay an injunction against the President's own White House construction project, with separation-of-powers questions about APA/NHPA review of the Executive Residence — nationally watched whatever the outcome.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.96·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns presidential control, congressional authorization, and construction at the White House, with major separation-of-powers and public-significance stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile separation of powers conflict regarding unilateral White House alterations.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-08-31: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 80%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A preliminary injunction running against the President and the Executive Office of the President over construction at the White House itself, affirmed 2-1 by the D.C. Circuit; the stakes are separation-of-powers review of presidential action under the NHPA/APA, with heavy public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.98·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns presidential authority, congressional control of federal property, and construction at the White House.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 75%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves a direct conflict between the Executive's national security claims regarding the White House and a federal court injunction halting construction.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-08-31: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court grants the application: 72%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An emergency clash between the President and a historic-preservation plaintiff over construction at the White House itself, with the D.C. Circuit split 2-1 after a 101-page merits opinion — separation-of-powers stakes plus maximal public visibility, whatever the disposition.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns presidential authority to alter the White House and the allocation of control over landmark federal property.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Duncan v. BontaCalifornia gun owners ask the Court to strike down the state's ban on possessing ammunition magazines holding more than 10 rounds.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.92
0.90
0.95
0.92

Virginia Duncan, et al. v. Rob Bonta, Attorney General of CaliforniaNo. 25-198 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274882 · models differ by up to 0.05 · topic: Firearms (also Constitutional rights)

California gun owners ask the Court to strike down the state's ban on possessing ammunition magazines holding more than 10 rounds.

What happened

Virginia Duncan and other California residents, along with a gun-rights group, sued in 2017 to block a state law requiring owners to give up, modify, or sell magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. After years of litigation, including an earlier trip to the Supreme Court that sent the case back for reconsideration, a federal district court ruled the ban unconstitutional. The full Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, reversing and upholding the law, finding that such magazines are not protected "arms" under the Second Amendment and that, even if they were, the ban fits the nation's history of regulating dangerous weapons. The petitioners also argue the law amounts to an uncompensated taking of their property.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state may ban possessing ammunition magazines that hold more than 10 rounds without violating the right to keep and bear arms, and whether requiring owners to give up lawfully acquired magazines without payment violates the rule against the government taking private property without compensation.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for many conferences since November 2025 without the Court recording a grant or denial, most recently for a June 2026 conference; the parties have continued to file letters about related appeals court rulings, including a letter from California in August 2026 noting that the case overlaps with other cases the Court has already agreed to hear.

What each outcome would mean

Duncan and the other challengers are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which upheld California's law. If the Court grants review and later rules for Duncan, California's magazine ban would be struck down, at least in part. If the Court instead affirms, the ban would remain in effect, and owners of larger-capacity magazines would need to modify, sell, surrender, or remove them from the state. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision upholding the ban stands, leaving California free to enforce it. A vacate-and-remand would set aside the Ninth Circuit's ruling without deciding the issue, sending the case back for further proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Duncan's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Duncan's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Record-breaking serial-relist vehicle (Clement/Murphy, final en banc judgment) that would decide whether states may ban magazines over 10 rounds — controlling the fate of magazine and assault-weapon bans in roughly a dozen states; among the most-watched petitions in the country.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling could set nationwide limits on state bans of commonly owned magazines and clarify Bruen's common-use methodology.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A high-profile Second Amendment challenge to California's magazine ban; closely watched following Bruen.

Department of Homeland Security v. D. V. D.The Supreme Court agreed to decide whether the government's policy for deporting people to third countries, not named in their removal orders, is lawful.awaiting the Court
0.90
0.92
0.95
0.92

Department of Homeland Security, et al. v. D. V. D., et al.No. 26-426 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000426 · models differ by up to 0.05

The Supreme Court agreed to decide whether the government's policy for deporting people to third countries, not named in their removal orders, is lawful.

What happened

Immigrants with final deportation orders sued, claiming the government's policy for removing them to "third countries" not named in their orders denies them adequate notice and a chance to raise fears of persecution or torture there. A district court sided with the immigrants, declaring the policy unlawful and setting it aside, and the First Circuit largely affirmed. The government asked the Supreme Court to pause that ruling, arguing it lacked jurisdiction and that its policy satisfies the law. This followed two earlier rounds in which the Supreme Court had already stayed related orders in the same case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked three things: whether courts had authority to hear this lawsuit at all given limits Congress placed on reviewing immigration enforcement actions; whether courts could order relief covering the whole class of affected immigrants, given a law restricting such broad orders; and whether the government's notice-and-opportunity procedures for third-country removals violate immigration statutes, due process protections, or treaty-based torture protections.

Where it stands

The Court granted the government's stay request, pausing the district court's order, and treated the stay application itself as a petition for certiorari, which it granted. The case has been fully briefed and was scheduled for argument in December 2026, with a decision still pending.

What each outcome would mean

The government (Homeland Security and related officials) asked the Court to pause the lower court's order and is now asking the Court to reverse the rulings against it. If the Court sides with the government, the third-country removal policy would stand, and courts could not block it on a class-wide basis or on the grounds the lower courts used. If the Court instead affirms the lower courts, the policy would remain blocked, and the government would have to follow court-ordered notice and hearing procedures before removing people to third countries. A ruling vacating the lower decisions would send the case back without resolving the dispute for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 9, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Department of Homeland Security wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: D. V. D. wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 87%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A headline executive-power immigration case: the lawfulness of third-country removals of thousands of noncitizens with final orders, the reach of 1252(f)(1) to classwide declaratory relief and APA vacatur (reserved in Aleman Gonzalez and Biden v. Texas), and the due process owed before removal to a country like South Sudan; granted on a stay application and expedited to December, with three Justices already noting they would deny the stay.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    National stakes for third-country removals, protection against persecution and torture, and the availability of classwide judicial remedies against immigration policies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major immigration case involving nationwide vacatur of DHS guidance, expedited for argument, with a 6-3 split on the stay.

Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder CountyEnergy companies ask the Supreme Court to decide whether federal law bars Boulder's state-law lawsuit seeking damages for harms linked to climate change.Environment, energy & propertyawaiting the Court
0.95
0.89
0.92
0.92

Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc., et al. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, et al.No. 25-170 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274859 · models differ by up to 0.06 · topic: Environment, energy & property

Energy companies ask the Supreme Court to decide whether federal law bars Boulder's state-law lawsuit seeking damages for harms linked to climate change.

What happened

Boulder County and the City of Boulder sued Suncor and Exxon Mobil in Colorado state court, claiming the companies' production, marketing, and sale of fossil fuels contributed to climate change and caused local harms like wildfires and droughts. Boulder seeks damages, not an order to stop emissions. The energy companies argued federal law bars these claims entirely. Colorado's trial court and, in a divided ruling, the Colorado Supreme Court disagreed, allowing the suit to proceed. Two justices dissented, arguing federal law should block the claims and urging the U.S. Supreme Court to weigh in.

What the Court is being asked

The Court must decide whether the Constitution's structure, or the federal Clean Air Act, prevents a state from using its own tort law to award damages for harms linked to greenhouse gas emissions that occur across state and international lines. A related question is whether the Court even has authority to review this case at this stage, since the Colorado Supreme Court's ruling did not end the lawsuit but sent it back for further proceedings.

Where it stands

The Court granted review and directed the parties to also brief whether it has jurisdiction to hear the case now. The case was argued on October 5, 2026, with the United States participating as amicus curiae in support of the energy companies, and it now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Suncor and Exxon Mobil are asking the Court to reverse the Colorado Supreme Court's decision, which allowed Boulder's lawsuit to continue. If the Court reverses, Boulder's claims would be barred, ending this lawsuit and likely affecting dozens of similar suits by other state and local governments nationwide. If the Court affirms, Boulder's case would continue in Colorado courts, though further defenses the energy companies have raised would still need to be resolved. If the Court instead finds it lacks jurisdiction to decide the issue now, the case would return to Colorado courts without a ruling on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 20, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Suncor Energy wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The County Commissioners of Boulder County wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 73%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide-stakes climate-liability case: whether federal law precludes the ~30 pending state and municipal climate-damages suits against energy producers; US and 26 states support petitioners, 19 states support respondents, 60+ merits amici, SG divided-argument motion.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 42%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could determine whether state and local climate-damages suits against energy producers may proceed nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves whether dozens of local government climate accountability suits can proceed in state courts, setting a major precedent for fossil fuel liability.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 77%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The survival of the entire genre of state and municipal climate-damages litigation turns on this case: dozens of parallel suits nationwide, a granted question the Court declined in Honolulu, the Solicitor General participating in divided argument, and one of the largest amicus dockets of the Term.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 57%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The judgment could govern dozens of climate-damages suits and define state authority over interstate and international emissions-related harms.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Landmark climate litigation case determining whether dozens of state-level tort lawsuits against major energy companies can proceed, with massive financial implications and significant public interest.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 68%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decides whether dozens of pending municipal and state climate-tort suits seeking billions against energy producers can proceed under state law; the Term's opening and likely most consequential environmental-federalism case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.89·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 77%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The availability of state climate-damages litigation against fossil-fuel producers has nationwide financial and federalism consequences, although the Court can decide a narrower preemption question without resolving climate policy generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 83%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Bellwether Supreme Court test of whether state common-law tort suits seeking billions of dollars in climate-change damages from fossil-fuel producers can proceed in state courts nationwide.

Apple v. Epic GamesApple asks the Court to decide whether it was properly held in civil contempt for charging a commission on purchases made outside its app ecosystem.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.90
0.90
0.90
0.90

Apple Inc. v. Epic Games, Inc.No. 25-1311 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500212 · models differ by up to 0.00 · topic: Civil procedure

Apple asks the Court to decide whether it was properly held in civil contempt for charging a commission on purchases made outside its app ecosystem.

What happened

Epic sued Apple years ago, claiming Apple's app store rules violated antitrust and competition laws. A court found Apple's rule against letting developers direct customers to outside payment options violated California's unfair competition law and ordered Apple to stop blocking such links. After that ruling became final, Apple allowed the links but began charging a new commission on purchases made through them. Epic argued this violated the court's order, and the district court held Apple in civil contempt. The appeals court mostly upheld that finding, ruling that Apple had violated the "spirit" of the order, though it sent part of the case back for further proceedings on the commission's size.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a party can be held in contempt of a court order for conduct the order's own wording never addressed, if a judge believes the conduct defeats the order's purpose, or whether contempt requires that the order's text clearly and specifically cover the conduct in question.

Where it stands

The Court granted review limited to this contempt question and the case was argued; briefing, including a brief from the federal government, is complete, and the case is awaiting decision. A related emergency request by Apple to pause lower-court proceedings while the case was pending was denied.

What each outcome would mean

Apple, which asked the Court to hear the case, is seeking to overturn the lower court's contempt finding. If the Court rules for Apple, the contempt finding would be reversed, likely undoing the commission restrictions imposed as a sanction and limiting when courts can use contempt based on an order's unstated purpose rather than its text. If the Court rules for Epic, the contempt finding and its consequences for Apple's commission practices would stand. The Court could also send the case back for further proceedings without deciding the issue for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 11, 2027
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Apple wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Epic Games wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    App Store link-out commissions govern a multi-hundred-billion-dollar distribution market, and the contempt standard the Court announces will control injunction enforcement across every federal court.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute concerns the rules and economics of a major mobile-app platform and is likely to affect a large digital marketplace.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes litigation between major tech companies over platform rules, carrying significant implications for antitrust and federal equity power.

Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al. v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, et al.The Court agreed to hear the federal government's bid to reverse a ruling that struck down a presidential proclamation barring asylum for migrants crossing the southern border without authorization.Immigrationpartly decided
0.90
0.94
0.86
0.90

Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al. v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, et al.No. 26-239 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000239 · models differ by up to 0.08 · topic: Immigration

The Court agreed to hear the federal government's bid to reverse a ruling that struck down a presidential proclamation barring asylum for migrants crossing the southern border without authorization.

What happened

In January 2025, President Trump issued a proclamation suspending entry for migrants crossing the southern border outside ports of entry and barring them from applying for asylum or other protections against removal. Several immigrant-advocacy organizations and individual migrants sued, arguing the proclamation and related agency guidance violated federal immigration law. A district court ruled for the challengers, certifying a broad class and blocking the policy. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit largely affirmed, holding the president lacked authority to eliminate asylum this way, though it narrowed the class definition. The government then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the proclamation and its implementing guidance, which cut off access to asylum for migrants who crossed the border a certain way, are lawful; whether a federal law limiting courts' power to block enforcement of certain removal provisions prevented the lower courts from issuing class-wide relief; and whether the class of affected migrants was properly defined under the rules governing class-action lawsuits.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the government's petition on November 13, 2026, limited to the first two questions presented (the asylum policy's lawfulness and whether the class-wide relief was barred by the removal-provision law). The case has not yet been briefed or argued on the merits.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, represented by Secretary Mullin and other officials, is asking the Court to overturn the appeals court's decision, which favored the migrants and organizations that sued. If the Court ultimately reverses, the asylum restrictions and related removal procedures could go into effect, and the class-wide injunction blocking them would likely be lifted. If the Court affirms, the lower court's decision striking down the asylum bar would stand, keeping the block on the policy in place. The Court could also vacate the decision and send the case back for further proceedings without resolving the dispute for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Court decidesTook the caseNov 13, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided

If the Court affirms: the lower court's ruling stands. · If the Court reverses or vacates: the ruling is overturned or sent back.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 4 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The legality of Proclamation 10,888's suspension of entry and asylum access at the southern border — the administration's flagship immigration policy — plus 1252(f)(1) classwide-relief and Rule 23 questions; a blockbuster whatever the Court does.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.98·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case tests presidential control of the southern border, access to asylum, and nationwide class relief affecting a central federal policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 1.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 98%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major challenge to a presidential proclamation suspending immigration and asylum access.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Lawfulness of a presidential proclamation suspending entry and cutting off asylum access at the southern border, with universal classwide relief: a cornerstone immigration policy and a major 1182(f)/asylum-statute question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide access to asylum, the limits of presidential immigration authority, and classwide remedies make this exceptionally consequential independent of the likelihood of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenges a major Presidential Proclamation on asylum, involves classwide relief, and is petitioned by the Solicitor General.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about 9 in 10) agree to hear this case. The federal government is asking the Court to review an appeals-court ruling that blocked a presidential proclamation barring asylum claims from migrants who cross the southern border between ports of entry. The Court almost always takes cases where a lower court has struck down a major federal policy. Holding the petition over for one more conference (a "relist") is the Court's usual step right before granting review.

    Why this big-case score: Validity of a presidential proclamation suspending asylum access at the southern border, plus recurring 1252(f)(1) and class-certification remedial questions; nationwide policy stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to take this case, with about a nine-in-ten chance of some form of review. The dispute concerns whether the President can block access to asylum at the southern border and how broadly lower courts may stop that policy. The Court has already considered the petition once and scheduled it again. Full briefing and argument are the most likely next major step, although the justices could wait for a related immigration case and then send this one back for reconsideration.

    Why this big-case score: The petition concerns nationwide access to asylum, presidential power over border entry and removal, and the availability of classwide judicial relief against federal immigration policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court is **very likely** (an **85% chance**, or about six in seven) to **grant** the federal government's request to review this case. The lower court struck down key parts of a major presidential proclamation that suspends asylum at the southern border and approved a broad class-action lawsuit covering future border crossers. When the Solicitor General—the federal government's top appellate lawyer—asks the Supreme Court to rescue a major national immigration policy after a divided lower-court ruling, the Court almost always agrees to hear the appeal.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile separation-of-powers and immigration challenge to Presidential Proclamation 10,888's southern-border asylum suspension, alongside post-CASA Rule 23(b)(2) class certification and 8 U.S.C. 1252(f)(1) remedial limits.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 83%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about five chances in six) overturn the appeals court ruling that blocked the President's January 2025 proclamation closing off asylum for people who cross the southern border illegally. The predicted judgment is a reversal by a 6–3 vote. The main reason: asylum is something the government may grant or refuse at its discretion, and the Court's majority is expected to hold that the government may refuse it to a whole category at once. The law's "may apply" wording is the main risk to this forecast.

    Why this big-case score: Decides whether a President may shut off asylum at the southern border by proclamation under 8 U.S.C. 1182(f), plus the reach of the INA's bar on classwide injunctions; a flagship immigration and executive-power case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to change part of the lower court's ruling, with about a three-in-four chance of some change. My best guess is a 6–3 decision affirming some parts and reversing others. The majority will likely allow broader government discretion to deny asylum and narrow the court order protecting the class, while preserving mandatory protections against persecution or torture. The key uncertainty is whether Congress's express right to apply for asylum prevents the government's categorical approach.

    Why this big-case score: The case tests nationwide asylum restrictions and the boundary between presidential border authority and Congress's mandatory immigration protections.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (84% chance) to overturn or narrow the lower court's ruling, most likely reversing it by a 6–3 vote. The Court took up two questions: whether the President can bar border crossers on U.S. soil from seeking asylum (discretionary protection allowing noncitizens fearing persecution to stay permanently), and whether a federal statute bars classwide injunctions (court orders blocking enforcement for a whole group rather than just named plaintiffs) in immigration removal cases. Because asylum is discretionary under federal law and a 6–3 majority previously strictly enforced that statutory ban on classwide removal injunctions, the Government has two strong paths to prevail.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes test of whether a Section 1182(f) Presidential proclamation can foreclose statutory asylum across the southern border for entrants on U.S. soil and whether Section 1252(f)(1) bars classwide injunctions against it.

Department of Health and Human Services v. Texas Medical AssociationThe federal government asks the Court to decide whether courts may void agency rules entirely, rather than only for the parties who sued.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.85
0.90
0.95
0.90

Department of Health and Human Services, et al. v. Texas Medical Association, et al.No. 26-491 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000491 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The federal government asks the Court to decide whether courts may void agency rules entirely, rather than only for the parties who sued.

What happened

Healthcare and air-ambulance providers sued federal health agencies over rules implementing the No Surprises Act, which protects patients from unexpected medical bills. The providers argued the rules improperly let insurers calculate reimbursement rates in ways that favored insurers. A district court agreed in part and struck down several provisions entirely, not just for the parties in the case. After a panel reversed in part, the full Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, upheld that broad approach, ruling that voiding a regulation completely is the normal remedy under the relevant federal statute governing judicial review of agency action. The government now asks the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the law that lets courts throw out unlawful agency rules allows them to eliminate those rules for everyone, including people and businesses not part of the lawsuit, or only for the parties actually before the court. If broader relief is allowed, the Court is also asked when that would be appropriate.

Where it stands

The petition was filed in October 2026. The deadline for the providers to respond was extended to December 14, 2026, and two outside groups have since filed briefs supporting the government's position. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The federal health agencies, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case and reject the broad remedy the lower court allowed. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the legal question, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Fifth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving in place the voiding of the challenged rules for everyone, not just the providers who sued, in that circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 16, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 14, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up the Department of Health and Human Services' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The Department of Health and Human Services' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether APA 706(2) authorizes universal vacatur governs the remedy in essentially every APA challenge to a federal rule; it is the question Trump v. CASA left open.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question concerns the availability and scope of universal vacatur under the APA across federal regulatory litigation, far beyond the immediate medical-payment rules. A decision could substantially alter remedies against federal agencies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Alabama v. CaliforniaThe Supreme Court stayed a lower court injunction that had blocked parts of a presidential election-integrity executive order, while Alabama's related stay request was denied as moot.Civil proceduredecided
0.90
0.88
—
0.89 2 of 3 models

Alabama, et al. v. California, et al.No. 26A139 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000139 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court stayed a lower court injunction that had blocked parts of a presidential election-integrity executive order, while Alabama's related stay request was denied as moot.

What happened

An executive order directed federal agencies to compile citizen voter lists for states, prioritize prosecuting election-related crimes, and have the Postal Service write rules on mail ballot security. California and other states sued, arguing the order was unconstitutional; Alabama and other states intervened to defend it. A federal district court in Massachusetts blocked parts of the order covering the November 2026 election, and the First Circuit refused to pause that injunction pending appeal. Alabama and the other defending states then asked the Supreme Court to stay the injunction while their appeal continued.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether the states challenging the executive order had legal standing to sue over it now, given that key details of how it would be carried out were still undecided, or whether their case was too premature for a court to decide. The states defending the order argued the challengers could not show a concrete, immediate harm.

Where it stands

The Court denied Alabama's stay application as moot and instead granted a related stay application (No. 26A124) referred by Justice Jackson, pausing the district court's injunction pending the appeal and any later petition for Supreme Court review. The decision included a per curiam opinion and two dissents.

What each outcome would mean

Alabama and other states defending the executive order had asked the Court to pause the injunction against it. By granting the stay in the related application, the Court allowed the executive order's challenged provisions to take effect while the First Circuit appeal and any further Supreme Court review proceed, a result favoring the defending states and the federal government over California and the other challenging states. The stay is temporary: it ends automatically if certiorari is later denied, or when judgment is issued if the Court takes up the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedAug 24, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 30%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Twelve states seek to stay a nationwide D. Mass. injunction against the President's mail-in voting executive order months before the 2026 midterms, in parallel with the Solicitor General's own application; 35 states sit on the two sides.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 41%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns nationwide federal election-administration rules immediately before the 2026 midterms.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 65%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile partisan battle over federal executive order on election citizenship verification, touching on federal vs state election administration powers.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court grants the application: 15%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Twelve intervenor states seek to stay a final judgment enjoining the federal elections executive order months before the 2026 midterms, alongside a parallel presidential application in the same matter; election administration in every state rides on it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.93·Chance the Court grants the application: 38%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns presidential control of federal election administration immediately before nationwide midterm elections.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 65%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide injunction affecting a presidential executive order on election administration just months before a major midterm election.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-08-24: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 10%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Twelve states seek to stay an injunction against a presidential election executive order months before the 2026 midterms; 24 states on the other side, bipartisan heavyweight amici, and core Elections Clause / executive-power stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court grants the application: 22%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns presidential control of mail-voting procedures immediately before a federal election and implicates election administration across many states.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 22%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia VotaThe Republican National Committee asks the Supreme Court to revive Arizona laws requiring proof of citizenship for voter registration and allowing removal of noncitizens from voter rolls near elections.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.85
0.90
0.90
0.88

Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota, et al.No. 25-1017 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281056 · models differ by up to 0.05 · topic: Election law

The Republican National Committee asks the Supreme Court to revive Arizona laws requiring proof of citizenship for voter registration and allowing removal of noncitizens from voter rolls near elections.

What happened

Arizona enacted laws in 2022 requiring state-form voter-registration applicants to show proof of citizenship and directing county officials to periodically check databases and cancel the registrations of voters confirmed to be noncitizens. Mi Familia Vota and other groups, along with the Democratic National Committee, the Arizona Democratic Party, and the United States, sued, arguing these laws were preempted by the National Voter Registration Act and, for the registration requirement, barred by an earlier consent decree. The district court and the Ninth Circuit largely agreed, ruling that the National Voter Registration Act and the consent decree blocked the proof-of-citizenship requirement, and that the law's removal provisions violated a federal rule against systematically purging voter rolls within 90 days of a federal election. The Republican National Committee, which had intervened to defend the laws, appealed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court must decide two questions. First, whether federal voter-registration law or an older consent decree prevents Arizona from requiring people who register using the state's own form to show documentary proof of citizenship. Second, whether federal law prevents Arizona from removing people confirmed to be noncitizens from its voter rolls in the 90 days before a federal election, or whether that timing restriction applies only to voters who were once eligible and later became ineligible, not to those who should never have been registered.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, and the case has been fully briefed and argued; it was set for argument on December 8, 2026, and now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

The Republican National Committee is asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision, which upheld rulings in favor of Mi Familia Vota, the Democratic National Committee, and other challengers. If the Court reverses, Arizona could enforce both the proof-of-citizenship requirement for state-form applicants and its program for removing confirmed noncitizens from voter rolls, including within 90 days of an election. If the Court affirms, the lower court's injunctions would stand, barring enforcement of both measures. The United States and some Arizona officials support reversal; other respondents, including the Democratic National Committee, defend the Ninth Circuit's ruling.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 8, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Republican National Committee wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Mi Familia Vota wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally watched election-law fight over documentary proof of citizenship and the NVRA's 90-day quiet period, RNC against the DNC and voting-rights groups with the United States in support, decided ahead of the 2028 cycle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.91·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set nationwide rules for citizenship verification and voter-roll maintenance close to federal elections.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes federal preemption and election law case with major implications for the 2026 federal election.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether States may demand documentary proof of citizenship on their own registration forms and purge noncitizens inside the 90-day window reaches every State's registration regime, sits at the center of the national election-integrity debate, and follows two emergency-docket interventions; the consent-decree question adds a federalism holding of its own.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The two questions concern documentary citizenship requirements for federal-election registration and the timing of systematic voter-roll removals, with consequences beyond Arizona for election administration and access to voting.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile case concerning state authority to demand documentary proof of citizenship for voter registration, with significant implications for federal election administration and NVRA interpretation.

Walid bin ‘Atash v. United StatesThe Supreme Court declined to review a Guantanamo detainee's bid to revive a plea agreement that would have spared him the death penalty.Criminal lawdecided
0.78
0.90
0.95
0.88

Walid bin ‘Atash v. United StatesNo. 25-1335 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500235 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review a Guantanamo detainee's bid to revive a plea agreement that would have spared him the death penalty.

What happened

Walid bin 'Atash is charged before a military commission with helping plan the September 11 attacks. In 2024 a military official accepted a pretrial agreement under which bin 'Atash would plead guilty in exchange for the government not seeking the death penalty. Two days later the Secretary of Defense withdrew from the agreement. A military judge and the Court of Military Commission Review both ruled that bin 'Atash had already begun performing promises in the agreement, so the withdrawal came too late. The United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit disagreed, ruling for the government and clearing the way for the case to proceed without the plea deal. One judge dissented. Bin 'Atash then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether it was clear and indisputable error to find that bin 'Atash had not yet started carrying out his side of the plea agreement, given that he had signed a detailed factual confession and taken other steps the government treated as required by the deal, before the government could still rely on an extraordinary order from the appeals court to undo the agreement.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for several conferences, including ones in September and October 2026, and the Supreme Court denied it on October 19, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Bin 'Atash, who asked the Court to hear the case, sought to overturn the D.C. Circuit's ruling that favored the government. Because the Court denied review, the D.C. Circuit's decision stands: the Secretary of Defense's withdrawal from the plea agreement is treated as valid, bin 'Atash's guilty plea and the death-penalty waiver do not take effect, and his case continues before the military commission without that agreement in place. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the D.C. Circuit's reasoning, only that it left that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the government may back out of the plea deals that would spare the accused 9/11 plotters the death penalty; a Guantanamo military-commission question with Hamdan/Boumediene lineage and intense public attention, even though the legal question itself is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Enforceability of a plea agreement removing death exposure in a September 11 military-commission prosecution has exceptional national significance, even though the specific withdrawal rule has a narrow application.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile case concerning the revocation of 9/11 defendants' plea agreements.

Bird v. Iowa Migrant Movement for JusticeIowa's attorney general asks the Court to revive the state's law criminalizing immigrants' reentry after removal, which lower courts blocked as conflicting with federal immigration authority.awaiting the Court
0.80
0.88
0.95
0.88

Brenna Bird, Attorney General of Iowa v. Iowa Migrant Movement for Justice, et al.No. 26-49 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000049 · models differ by up to 0.15

Iowa's attorney general asks the Court to revive the state's law criminalizing immigrants' reentry after removal, which lower courts blocked as conflicting with federal immigration authority.

What happened

Iowa enacted a law making it a state crime for a noncitizen to reenter or be found in Iowa after removal, requiring judges to order such people to leave the country, and barring courts from pausing prosecutions while federal immigration proceedings continue. Iowa Migrant Movement for Justice and two individuals sued, arguing the law is unconstitutional because federal law controls immigration. A federal district court blocked the law, and the Eighth Circuit affirmed, finding the challengers likely to succeed because the law conflicts with federal immigration authority. Iowa's attorney general, the only defendant who appealed, asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked two questions. First, whether people suing before any enforcement have been injured enough to bring the case, when the state's attorney general says she will not enforce the law against them. Second, whether a state law that largely mirrors federal immigration crimes can be blocked entirely because it might sometimes limit federal officials' discretion not to prosecute, even though the challengers do not claim lower courts disagree with each other on this point.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for several conferences since September 2026, most recently rescheduled before being distributed again; on October 19, 2026, the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Brenna Bird, Iowa's attorney general, asks the Court to take up the case and reverse the Eighth Circuit. If the Court grants review and later rules for Bird, Iowa's law could take effect, allowing the state to prosecute reentry independently. If it rules for Iowa Migrant Movement for Justice instead, the law would remain blocked. If the Court denies review, the Eighth Circuit's decision blocking the law stays in place, and the case would continue in the lower courts. The Solicitor General's invited brief will inform whether the Court takes the case at all.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Bird's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Bird's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether States may enact and enforce their own illegal-reentry crimes mirroring 8 U.S.C. 1326 is a live federalism fight across at least four States (Texas, Oklahoma, Florida, Iowa), backed here by 25 States and two Senators; a merits decision either way would be a major immigration-preemption ruling in the Arizona v. United States line.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope for independent state illegal-reentry and removal regimes has national immigration and federalism consequences; the standing question also reaches pre-enforcement challenges beyond immigration.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    This case presents a direct challenge to the scope of federal immigration preemption (Arizona v. United States), a highly salient national issue with 24 states participating as amici.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether states may enact parallel criminal illegal-reentry laws goes to the core of Arizona v. United States, and several states have similar laws; the Article III pre-enforcement standing question recurs too.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns state criminal immigration enforcement, federal preemption, and pre-enforcement standing. Review could affect several states' parallel immigration laws and the federal-state allocation of removal authority, well beyond the individual parties.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 75%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Allen v. CasterThe Supreme Court vacated a lower court order blocking Alabama's 2023 congressional map and sent the case back for reconsideration after its ruling in a similar Louisiana case.Election lawdecidedpossible leak
0.85
0.90
0.85
0.87

Wes Allen, Alabama Secretary of State, et al. v. Marcus Caster, et al.No. 25-243 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73275185 · models differ by up to 0.05 · topic: Election law

The Supreme Court vacated a lower court order blocking Alabama's 2023 congressional map and sent the case back for reconsideration after its ruling in a similar Louisiana case.

What happened

Alabama's 2021 congressional map was found likely to dilute Black voters' voting power, so Alabama passed a new 2023 map that kept certain regions, including the Gulf Coast, together in single districts. Voters led by Marcus Caster sued, arguing the new map still violated the Voting Rights Act by not creating a second district where Black voters could elect their preferred candidates. After a trial, a federal district court permanently blocked the 2023 map, finding it violated the Voting Rights Act and was enacted with discriminatory intent. Alabama appealed and asked the Supreme Court to take the case before the appeals court ruled.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a state's redistricting plan can be struck down for not creating an additional district where a racial group can elect its preferred candidates, when doing so would require splitting up a region the state says it has legitimate, non-racial reasons to keep together. It also asks whether requiring a state to draw such a district can itself violate the Constitution's equal protection guarantees, and whether private voters may sue to enforce the relevant voting-rights law at all.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted Alabama's petition, vacated the district court's judgment, and sent the case back to the appeals court with instructions to return it to the district court for further review in light of the Court's recent decision in a Louisiana redistricting case. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, dissented. A related emergency request by Alabama for a stay was denied as unnecessary once the Court acted.

What each outcome would mean

Alabama, which asked the Court to intervene, sought to overturn the lower court's ruling blocking its map. By vacating that ruling and sending the case back, the Court set aside the injunction against Alabama's 2023 map without deciding whether the map is lawful. The district court must now reconsider the dispute using the legal standards from the Court's recent Louisiana ruling. Caster and the other voters, who won the injunction below, no longer have that ruling in place while the case is reconsidered, and the map's ultimate legality remains undecided.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)May 11, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-05-11: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)possible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sequel to Allen v. Milligan: Alabama's congressional map and the constitutionality of VRA §2 itself, held alongside Louisiana v. Callais, with direct stakes for the 2026 midterm maps across several states.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 74%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)possible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case concerns Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, congressional representation, and the statute's constitutionality.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)possible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes congressional redistricting case involving Section 2 of the VRA, following Allen v. Milligan.

St. Mary Catholic Parish v. RoyThe Supreme Court heard a Catholic parish's challenge to Colorado's requirement that preschools receiving universal preschool funding admit families regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity, or religious affiliation.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.85
0.86
0.88
0.86

St. Mary Catholic Parish, Littleton, Colorado, et al. v. Lisa Roy, in Her Official Capacity as Executive Director of the Colorado Department of Early Childhood, et al.No. 25-581 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279026 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: First Amendment

The Supreme Court heard a Catholic parish's challenge to Colorado's requirement that preschools receiving universal preschool funding admit families regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity, or religious affiliation.

What happened

St. Mary Catholic Parish and other Catholic institutions sued Colorado officials, arguing that the state's universal preschool program unconstitutionally excluded them because their religious practice requires considering a family's views on marriage, sex, and gender before enrollment. Colorado's program funds preschool at providers of a family's choosing, including religious ones, but requires all participating preschools to offer equal enrollment opportunity regardless of several protected characteristics. After a bench trial, a federal district court ruled mostly for Colorado, and the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that Colorado's rule was neutral and generally applicable and that precedent barring religious exclusion from public benefits did not apply because Colorado had not explicitly targeted religion.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks the Court to decide what test determines whether a government rule that burdens religious practice is applied evenhandedly enough to avoid the toughest constitutional scrutiny, including whether a rule with some exceptions for other groups must also exempt comparable religious conduct. It also asks whether rules barring the government from denying public benefits based on a recipient's religious exercise apply only when a law explicitly singles out religion, or also when the exclusion arises from a seemingly neutral rule. A further question asks whether the Court should abandon its longstanding framework for evaluating such religious-liberty claims altogether.

Where it stands

The Court granted review limited to two of the three questions raised, heard oral argument on November 3, 2026, and the case now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

St. Mary Catholic Parish and the other petitioners are asking the Court to reverse the Tenth Circuit's ruling in Colorado's favor. If the Court sides with the petitioners, it would send the case back with instructions requiring Colorado to justify its exclusion of the Catholic preschools under a demanding legal standard, which could ultimately let them participate in the funding program while maintaining their enrollment practices. If the Court instead affirms, Colorado's rule would stand, and the preschools would remain unable to receive state preschool funding unless they comply with the equal-enrollment requirement.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: St. Mary Catholic Parish wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Roy wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 93%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Marquee free-exercise case on Smith's general-applicability standard at the religion/LGBTQ-nondiscrimination seam of a universal school-choice program; SG amicus support, a multistate amicus bloc, and 30+ merits amici mark it as one of the Term's most watched.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 93%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define how Carson and Smith govern facially secular conditions on public education benefits nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A headline Free Exercise case: a Catholic-school challenge to an LGBTQ-inclusive nondiscrimination condition on public preschool funding, an acknowledged 7-4 circuit split on Smith's general-applicability test, the United States as amicus for petitioners, and about fifty amicus entries; stakes fall short of the top tier only because the Court declined the question whether to overrule Smith.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 83%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case concerns the nationwide boundary between religious participation in publicly funded education and states' nondiscrimination conditions, with direct consequences for religious schools and LGBTQ families; the limited grant does not include overruling Smith.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely (about 85%) rule for the Catholic preschools and reverse the lower court, probably 6–3. That lower court had upheld Colorado's rule keeping them out of the state-funded preschool program. At argument, most of the conservative Justices questioned why Colorado lets other schools limit enrollment for many non-religious reasons but makes no room for religious ones. The likely holding is that the rule is not "generally applicable," meaning it does not apply evenly to everyone. That triggers the strictest form of court review, which Colorado likely fails.

    Why this big-case score: Major Free Exercise case on state funding conditions vs. LGBT nondiscrimination; resolves an acknowledged 7-4 split on Smith's general-applicability test and the reach of Carson v. Makin.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 94%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about a 94 percent chance—to overturn or otherwise undo the lower court's judgment. The most likely result is a 6–3 reversal favoring the Catholic preschools. The majority will probably say Colorado needs an especially strong justification before denying school funding because of religious admissions practices, even when its rule does not explicitly mention religion. The strongest uncertainty is whether the Court adopts that broader principle or instead rules narrowly on Colorado's exceptions, and whether it sends the legal test back for reconsideration.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially national rule for religious-school participation in public tuition programs, resolving a substantial conflict between religious admissions practices and LGBTQ nondiscrimination conditions without plenary reconsideration of Smith.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (85% chance) to reverse the Tenth Circuit's ruling and side with the Catholic parish preschools and parents in a 6–3 decision. Although Colorado requires preschools in its state-funded universal preschool program to accept students regardless of religion, sexual orientation, or gender identity, the State allows non-religious exceptions and custom enrollment preferences—such as for low-income families, disabled students, or specialty programs like Montessori and dual-language schools—while denying a religious exemption for Catholic preschools that require families to share their faith's beliefs.

    Why this big-case score: Major Free Exercise Clause challenge defining whether public universal-preschool funding programs may condition participation on sexual-orientation, gender-identity, and religious-affiliation nondiscrimination rules that forbid religious schools' faith-based admissions standards.

Zeldin v. Climate United FundThe federal government asks the Court to review whether a $16 billion court order forcing EPA to keep funding terminated climate grants can stand.awaiting the Court
0.80
0.88
0.90
0.86

Lee M. Zeldin, Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency, et al. v. Climate United Fund, et al.No. 26-589 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000589 · models differ by up to 0.10

The federal government asks the Court to review whether a $16 billion court order forcing EPA to keep funding terminated climate grants can stand.

What happened

EPA awarded billions of dollars in grants under a climate fund created by the Inflation Reduction Act. After a change in administration, EPA's new leadership raised concerns about conflicts of interest and oversight, and terminated grants to several nonprofit grantees. The grantees sued in federal district court, which blocked the terminations and ordered continued funding, including through Citibank, which held the money as the government's financial agent. A Court of Appeals panel initially sided with the government, but the full appeals court, split on various grounds, largely upheld the injunction. While the case was pending, Congress repealed the law authorizing the fund.

What the Court is being asked

The government asks the Court to decide two things. First, whether a separate federal law that generally sends contract-like disputes with the government to a specialized claims court means these grantees should not have been allowed to sue in ordinary district court to fight their grant terminations. Second, whether the grantees can still rely on the now-repealed climate fund law to keep their court-ordered funding in place.

Where it stands

The petition was filed on November 2, 2026, and a response is due December 4, 2026. The docket also shows a motion by one grantee to extend time, which the government opposed and the grantee defended in a reply; no ruling on cert has yet been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the lower court's decision, which favored the grantees, including Climate United Fund and Coalition for Green Capital. If the Court grants review and later rules for the government, the grantees' lawsuit could be barred from district court and the funding order could fall. If it rules for the grantees, the funding order could stand. If the Court denies review, the appeals court's decision favoring the grantees remains in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Zeldin's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Zeldin's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal government is asking the Supreme Court to review a court order stopping EPA from canceling about $16 billion in green-energy grants. We think the Court is very likely (about 85%) to agree to hear the case or otherwise send it back. The government wins such requests far more often than other parties do. The money involved is huge, the appeals court was deeply split, and the case raises whether such grant fights belong in a special claims court, a question the Justices have already flagged twice.

    Why this big-case score: $16B in terminated EPA grants, a fractured en banc D.C. Circuit, and the recurring Tucker Act question over grant-termination suits nationwide.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to take this case: I estimate an 86% chance of review, including any immediate corrective ruling. The dispute concerns roughly $16 billion in canceled climate grants and whether challenges belong in ordinary federal courts or a specialized court for claims against the government. A sharply divided appeals court and continuing disagreement over grant cancellations make review unusually attractive. Full briefing and argument are more likely than an immediate ruling, although the case's unusual bank-account arrangements could complicate review.

    Why this big-case score: The petition concerns access to approximately $16 billion in climate grants and the forum for challenges to federal grant terminations across many programs, with substantial fiscal and separation-of-powers implications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely (85% chance, or about six in seven) to grant the federal government's request to review this case. The dispute involves over $16 billion in terminated Environmental Protection Agency climate grants, and the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., was sharply divided when it kept in place a lower-court order blocking the terminations despite Congress having repealed the underlying grant statute. Because the Supreme Court has already stepped in twice on an emergency basis in similar cases to rule that federal grant-termination lawsuits generally belong in a specialized federal claims court rather than ordinary district courts, and because federal government petitions are granted at a high rate (about 73% historically), the Court is very likely to take this case to settle the issue nationwide.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile separation-of-powers, Tucker Act jurisdiction, and statutory-repeal dispute over $16 billion in terminated EPA Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund grants after an en banc D.C. Circuit split.

Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D.The Supreme Court stayed a district court order limiting third-country deportations and agreed to hear the government's full appeal in December.Immigrationdecided
0.78
0.94
0.85
0.86

Department of Homeland Security, et al., v. D.V.D., et al.No. 26A406 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000406 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Immigration

The Supreme Court stayed a district court order limiting third-country deportations and agreed to hear the government's full appeal in December.

What happened

DHS adopted guidance letting it deport people with final removal orders to countries other than those named in their case, sometimes with only brief notice and a chance to raise fears of torture or persecution. Several immigrants challenged the policy in a class action; the district court ruled the guidance unlawful, ordered DHS to give greater notice and more time to raise fears, and vacated the policy nationwide. The First Circuit largely affirmed, though it rejected one claim for lack of standing. After the First Circuit briefly dissolved its own stay of that ruling, DHS asked the Supreme Court to step in, arguing the lower courts lacked authority to grant such broad relief and that the guidance is lawful.

What the Court is being asked

The Court will decide whether the district court had authority to hear this lawsuit at all, whether it could issue relief covering the whole class of affected immigrants rather than just individuals, and whether the guidance on deporting people to third countries violates immigration law, constitutional due process protections, or treaty-based torture protections.

Where it stands

The Court granted DHS's request to pause the district court's order while the case proceeds, and treated the application itself as a petition for review, which it granted. The case will be briefed and argued in December 2026; three justices noted they would have denied the stay.

What each outcome would mean

DHS, as applicant, sought the stay and asked the Court to take up the case. The stay the Court granted means DHS's third-country removal guidance stays in effect, and the district court's order requiring added notice and procedures is paused, while the case continues. Because the Court also granted review, it will later decide the case on the merits: affirming would leave the lower courts' limits on the guidance in place, reversing would uphold DHS's guidance without those added procedures, and vacating would send the case back without resolving the dispute for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 29, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedSep 29, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-29: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 74%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Third emergency trip to the Court on the same third-country-removal policy, now at final judgment with a First Circuit affirmance; the stay ruling governs thousands of removals and shapes the cert vehicle on 1252(f)(1), FARRA channeling, and due process for noncitizens with final orders.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.93·Chance the Court grants the application: 86%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide third-country removal procedures implicate protection against persecution and torture, executive immigration and diplomatic authority, and the availability of classwide judicial remedies.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 95%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-09-29: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 80%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Third emergency round over DHS's third-country-removal policy; a classwide final judgment plus universal vacatur affirmed by the First Circuit, with Section 1252(f)(1)'s reach over declaratory relief and vacatur (reserved in Biden v. Texas) squarely presented and foreign-policy stakes attached.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court grants the application: 84%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns nationwide third-country removal procedures, protection against persecution or torture, and the scope of judicial review of executive immigration policy. Its consequences extend far beyond the named applicants and respondents.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 90%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A major immigration policy dispute over third-country removals, already on its second trip to the shadow docket.

Petersen v. Mi Familia VotaArizona legislative leaders ask the Court to overturn a ruling that struck down state voter-registration and mail-voting restrictions and revived a discrimination claim against a voter-roll law.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.70
0.90
0.95
0.85

Warren Petersen, President of the Arizona Senate, et al. v. Mi Familia Vota, et al.No. 25-1019 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281059 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Election law

Arizona legislative leaders ask the Court to overturn a ruling that struck down state voter-registration and mail-voting restrictions and revived a discrimination claim against a voter-roll law.

What happened

After the 2020 election, Arizona passed laws requiring documentary proof of citizenship and residence on its state voter-registration form, barring mail voting for registrants lacking such proof, and directing officials to check databases and cancel registrations of suspected noncitizens. Civil rights groups, the Democratic National Committee, and the United States sued, arguing the laws violated federal voter-registration law, a prior consent decree, and civil rights law. A federal district court struck down several provisions after a trial and rejected a claim that one law was enacted with discriminatory intent. The Ninth Circuit largely affirmed, but also revived the discriminatory-intent claim and sent it back for further review. Arizona Senate President Petersen and House Speaker Montenegro, who intervened to defend the laws, now ask the Supreme Court to reverse.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether federal voter-registration law, or an older consent decree, stops Arizona from requiring documentary proof of citizenship and residence on its state registration form; whether that same federal law stops Arizona from barring mail voting by registrants who have not supplied such proof; and whether the lower court wrongly disturbed the trial court's finding that a related voter-roll law was not enacted with discriminatory intent.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, after full briefing including an opposition from the United States and other respondents and a reply from the petitioners; the docket shows no action recorded since the second conference. Related petitions raising overlapping questions are pending at the same time.

What each outcome would mean

Petersen and Montenegro, who lost below, are asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case and decide the questions itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands: the voter-registration and mail-voting restrictions remain blocked, and the discrimination claim returns to the district court for further proceedings, a result favoring the groups and officials who challenged the laws. The United States has urged the Court to deny this petition while supporting review of a related one.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Petersen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Petersen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 34%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally salient proof-of-citizenship election litigation (NVRA preemption, mail voting, discriminatory intent) with a 25-state amicus bloc and DNC/DOJ as parties; but the lead vehicle for the fight is the companion RNC petition, capping this docket's independent significance.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 64%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling could materially define federal control of voter registration, proof-of-citizenship rules, and access to Arizona's dominant mail-voting system.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly salient election law dispute over proof-of-citizenship voting requirements with major implications for federal elections.

Trump v. ThakurThe federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that blocked it from ending university research grants based on their perceived viewpoint.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.80
0.90
0.85
0.85

Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al. v. Neeta Thakur, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al.No. 26-210 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000210 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: First Amendment

The federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that blocked it from ending university research grants based on their perceived viewpoint.

What happened

Several University of California researchers sued after federal agencies canceled their research grants, citing executive orders targeting programs on diversity, equity and inclusion and similar topics. A district court found the terminations likely violated the First Amendment and ordered the grants reinstated for one group of researchers, while finding a separate group's claims belonged in a different court. The Ninth Circuit largely agreed, holding that the agencies likely engaged in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination by cutting off already-awarded grants because of the perceived views expressed in the funded research. The government then asked the Supreme Court to review that First Amendment ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the government violates free speech protections when it factors in the viewpoint expressed by academic research in deciding whether to fund or stop funding that research through competitive grant programs, or whether such funding decisions are allowed even when based partly on viewpoint.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, with the researchers' opposition and the government's reply filed in October 2026. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026, and the docket shows no action on it since.

What each outcome would mean

The government, as petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which favored the researchers. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the constitutional question itself, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision favoring the researchers stands, and the preliminary order requiring the agencies to reinstate the grants remains in place while the case continues below.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Trump's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Trump's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Solicitor General petition asking whether the First Amendment constrains viewpoint-based termination of competitive federal grants — the constitutional core of the administration's mass grant-termination program, with a claimed ~$200B/year in competitive grantmaking and dozens of parallel suits riding on the answer.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide First Amendment dispute over federal research-grant policy could affect many agencies, billions of dollars in competitive funding, and the Executive's ability to redirect spending priorities.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment challenge to the administration's DEI executive orders affecting federal research grants.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will likely agree to hear this case (about a 72% chance). The federal government is asking the Court to overturn a ruling that it probably violated free-speech rights when it cancelled University of California research grants tied to diversity, equity and inclusion. The Court usually takes cases the government's top lawyer, the Solicitor General, brings. The issue also affects many similar lawsuits and large amounts of money. The main reason the Court might decline is that no other federal appeals court has ruled differently yet.

    Why this big-case score: Solicitor General petition on whether the First Amendment bars viewpoint-based termination of competitive federal research grants; governs a wave of grant-termination suits and large sums across agencies.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to agree to hear this case, with about an eight-in-ten chance of review. The dispute asks whether the federal government can cancel academic research grants because it disagrees with the viewpoints the research advances. The government's request, the nationwide importance of research funding, and the clear constitutional disagreement favor review. The lack of conflicting appeals-court rulings weighs against it. Expect full briefing and argument, rather than an immediate decision. This forecast does not predict who ultimately wins.

    Why this big-case score: The constitutional boundary between federal research-funding discretion and viewpoint discrimination has national consequences for academic freedom, scientific research, and successive administrations' spending policies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 56%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is modestly likely—about a 56% chance—to grant the Solicitor General's petition to review this case. When the federal government asks the Supreme Court to review a lower-court ruling that blocks an executive policy under the Constitution, the Court agrees to hear the case nearly three-quarters of the time. Here, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the First Amendment's free-speech guarantee barred federal agencies from canceling competitive university research grants that promoted diversity, equity, and inclusion. That strong baseline chance of review is tempered, however, because this appeal involves only a temporary injunction while final proceedings are still underway in the trial court, and no other federal appeals court has yet issued a conflicting ruling on the same First Amendment question.

    Why this big-case score: A merits ruling on whether the First Amendment bars the executive branch from terminating or selecting competitive research grants based on project viewpoints would govern billions of dollars in federal science and humanities funding and clarify the boundary between NEA v. Finley and Rosenberger.

National Association for Gun Rights v. LamontGun rights groups ask the Court to strike down Connecticut's ban on AR-15-style rifles and large-capacity magazines as a violation of the Second Amendment.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.70
0.94
0.90
0.85

National Association for Gun Rights, et al. v. Ned Lamont, in His Official Capacity as Governor of Connecticut, et al.No. 25-421 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73278426 · models differ by up to 0.24 · topic: Firearms

Gun rights groups ask the Court to strike down Connecticut's ban on AR-15-style rifles and large-capacity magazines as a violation of the Second Amendment.

What happened

The National Association for Gun Rights and a Connecticut resident sued to block Connecticut laws banning certain semiautomatic "assault weapons," including AR-15-style rifles, and magazines holding more than ten rounds. A federal district court denied a preliminary injunction, finding the challengers unlikely to succeed, and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the restrictions consistent with the nation's historical tradition of regulating unusually dangerous weapons even assuming the guns are commonly owned. The gun-rights groups ask the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a government may ban firearms and magazines that are commonly owned by law-abiding people for lawful purposes, or whether such a ban violates the constitutional right to keep and bear arms regardless of how dangerous the government considers the weapon to be.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference many times since January 2026 without the docket recording a grant or denial. The parties have filed supplemental briefs disputing the effect of a more recent D.C. court decision on a similar magazine ban, and the case remains awaiting the Court's decision on whether to hear it.

What each outcome would mean

The National Association for Gun Rights and its co-petitioner, who lost in the lower courts, are asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full briefing and argument and decide whether Connecticut's restrictions are constitutional, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision upholding Connecticut's ban stays in place, leaving the restrictions in effect and the challengers' suit unsuccessful.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the National Association for Gun Rights' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The National Association for Gun Rights' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 71%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Core post-Bruen question (state AR-15/LCM bans) with a fresh D.C. Circuit split, but the Court has taken companion vehicles (Grant v. Higgins, Viramontes) for the merits, so this petition's own disposition is likely a derivative GVR/deny.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling would define nationwide Second Amendment protection for widely owned AR-15-style rifles and magazines holding more than ten rounds.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Second Amendment challenges to state assault weapon bans are among the most high-stakes, closely watched constitutional issues nationwide.

Brumley v. RoakeLouisiana officials ask the Court to hear a challenge to a Ten Commandments classroom-display law, but only if it also takes up a similar Texas case.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.80
0.88
0.85
0.84

Cade Brumley, Superintendent, Louisiana State Education, et al. v. Darcy Roake, Reverend, Individually and on Behalf of Their Minor Children, Real Parties in Interest A. V. and S. V., et al.No. 25-1360 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500261 · models differ by up to 0.08 · topic: First Amendment

Louisiana officials ask the Court to hear a challenge to a Ten Commandments classroom-display law, but only if it also takes up a similar Texas case.

What happened

Louisiana's H.B. 71 requires every public school to display the Ten Commandments in each classroom. Public-school parents and children sued, arguing the law violates the First Amendment's religion clauses. A federal district court blocked the law, and a Fifth Circuit panel agreed. The full Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, then vacated that injunction, but only on the ground that the challenge was premature, since schools had not yet decided how to implement the displays; it did not rule on whether the law itself is constitutional. Louisiana filed a "conditional" petition asking the Supreme Court to hear this case only if it also takes up a similar Texas case, Nathan, where the Fifth Circuit upheld a comparable law on the merits.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the parents' challenge was premature because the law's practical effects were not yet known, and, separately, whether the law violates constitutional protections against government establishment of religion or interference with religious exercise.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently in December 2026, after rounds of extensions for the response and a reply from Louisiana; the docket shows no action yet on whether the Court will hear the case, and the case was rescheduled after the most recent distribution.

What each outcome would mean

Louisiana's officials, who lost the prematurity ruling's practical effect by having their injunction merely lifted rather than the case dismissed, are asking the Court to act, but only if it also takes the Texas case; the parents who sued oppose review entirely. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's prematurity ruling stands, leaving the law's constitutionality undecided for now. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the prematurity question, the constitutional questions, or both, with no party's position prevailing in advance.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Brumley's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Brumley's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will probably **not** take up this case (about a one-in-four chance that it does). Louisiana won in the lower court on its law requiring the Ten Commandments in classrooms. It filed this petition only as a backup, asking the Justices to hear its case if they agree to hear the similar Texas case, *Nathan v. Alamo Heights*. Even if the Court takes the Texas case, it can decide the main question without this one. So Louisiana's backup request is more likely to be turned down or set aside.

    Why this big-case score: The underlying question, whether a State may require the Ten Commandments to be posted in every public-school classroom notwithstanding Stone v. Graham, is nationally salient. This petition is the protective companion to the lead vehicle, so its own stakes are somewhat lower.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this Louisiana petition than hear it: I put the chance of review at about one in five, or 22%. The dispute concerns required Ten Commandments displays in public-school classrooms. But Louisiana already won removal of the lower court's temporary block and asks for review only if the Court takes a related Texas case. Asking the other side to respond shows interest, not a decision to hear the case. Declining review would not itself decide whether the displays are constitutional.

    Why this big-case score: Mandatory Ten Commandments displays in public-school classrooms implicate religious liberty, children's education, and the reach of Establishment Clause precedent, regardless of whether this protective petition is heard.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will **deny** this petition for review, with a **14% chance (about one in seven)** that the Court grants it. Although the dispute—whether Louisiana can require public school classrooms to display the Ten Commandments—is high-profile, Louisiana's officials actually won in the lower court, which threw out the challengers' lawsuit as premature. Louisiana filed this "conditional" petition only as a backup in case the Supreme Court takes up the challengers' own appeal or a parallel case from Texas, and the Court rarely grants an appeal filed by the side that already won below.

    Why this big-case score: Major First Amendment Establishment and Free Exercise Clause challenge to Louisiana's H.B. 71 mandating Ten Commandments displays in public school classrooms, testing whether Stone v. Graham survives Kennedy v. Bremerton School District.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether states may mandate Ten Commandments displays in every public-school classroom, with Stone v. Graham's survival after Kennedy squarely at issue and five states' laws in play; if this petition is granted it is consolidated into a landmark Religion Clauses case, though the petition itself is a derivative conditional cross-petition.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits decision could define the constitutional limits on mandatory Ten Commandments displays in public classrooms and access to pre-enforcement review, with consequences beyond Louisiana. This significance is distinct from this protective petition's grant prospects.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Show all 411 casesShow fewer
Allen v. MilliganAlabama officials appeal a district court order blocking the state's 2023 congressional map over claims it dilutes Black voters' influence and discriminates intentionally.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.85
0.90
0.78
0.84

Wes Allen, Alabama Secretary of State, et al. v. Evan Milligan, et al.No. 26-117 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000117 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: Election law

Alabama officials appeal a district court order blocking the state's 2023 congressional map over claims it dilutes Black voters' influence and discriminates intentionally.

What happened

Alabama's congressional map has been litigated for years. Courts found Alabama's 2021 map likely violated the Voting Rights Act by limiting Black Alabamians to one opportunity district out of seven; the Supreme Court affirmed that finding in 2023. The legislature then passed a replacement, the 2023 Plan, which again included only one majority-Black district. A three-judge district court enjoined the 2023 Plan, finding it both violated the Voting Rights Act and intentionally discriminated against Black voters under the Constitution. After the Supreme Court's decision in Louisiana v. Callais revised the legal test for these claims, the district court reconsidered and again blocked the map for the 2026 elections, ordering use of a court-drawn substitute. The state appealed to the Supreme Court. Appellees argue the appeal is moot because the 2026 elections already proceeded under the state's map after the Supreme Court stayed the injunction.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the district court was wrong to excuse the challengers from drawing alternative maps that matched the state's stated map-drawing priorities, such as keeping certain regions together and protecting incumbents; whether the lower court improperly found race-based voting patterns without adequately separating race from political party; whether the evidence supported finding a likelihood of discrimination overall; and whether the state's decision not to draw an additional majority-Black district itself amounted to unconstitutional discrimination.

Where it stands

The case has been distributed for three consecutive conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, with no action on the petition recorded since. Briefing is complete, including the state's jurisdictional statement, the challengers' motion to dismiss or affirm, and the state's reply.

What each outcome would mean

Alabama officials, who lost below, are asking the Court to overturn the district court's injunction against the 2023 Plan. If the Court notes probable jurisdiction and later reverses, the 2023 Plan could go into effect, and the challengers' claims of vote dilution and intentional discrimination would not stand. If the Court summarily affirms, the lower court's injunction against the 2023 Plan remains in place, and the court-ordered map continues to govern elections. If the Court dismisses the appeal as moot, as Milligan and the other challengers urge, the district court's ruling would stand without Supreme Court review of the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Allen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Allen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama is appealing a court order that blocked its congressional map for the 2026 election. The Supreme Court had already paused that order in June. We think it is very likely (about 85%) that the Court will act in Alabama's favor without full briefing. Most likely it will wipe out the lower court's order and send the case back, because the 2026 election has already happened under Alabama's map. A less likely alternative is reversing the order outright. A plain dismissal that leaves the order on the books is the main alternative.

    Why this big-case score: Post-Callais Alabama congressional map; second VRA/intentional-discrimination appeal in a nationally watched redistricting saga, though the vehicle is an expired preliminary injunction.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about an 86 percent chance—to take action favorable to Alabama, most likely by reversing the lower court without another round of hearings. Its earlier temporary order already questioned the lower court's approach to congressional districts and racial discrimination. Two repeat conference listings suggest continued attention. The main uncertainty is whether this particular appeal still presents a live dispute now that voting has occurred; the parties disagree about the injunction's continuing effect. This forecast concerns the appeal, not election results.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional representation and the nationwide interaction of Voting Rights Act remedies, race-neutral districting criteria, and intentional-discrimination claims are at stake.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (85% chance) to grant review and summarily vacate and send back ("GVR," which means grant, vacate, and remand) the lower court's preliminary injunction in *Allen v. Milligan* without holding full oral arguments. In May 2026, a three-judge federal court in Alabama ordered the state to use a court-drawn congressional map for the 2026 elections, but on June 2, 2026, the Supreme Court blocked that order in a written opinion explaining that the lower court misapplied recent voting-rights precedent. Because the November 2026 election has now taken place under Alabama's enacted map and further proceedings for future elections are waiting in the lower court, the Supreme Court is very likely to formally wipe out the temporary 2026 injunction and return the case to the district court.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile Alabama congressional redistricting appeal testing the post-Callais VRA Section 2 and Fourteenth Amendment intentional vote-dilution standards, though arising in an interlocutory posture from a stayed 2026-election preliminary injunction.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama is appealing a lower court order that blocked its congressional map. We think it is very likely (about 9 in 10) that the Supreme Court rules for Alabama. The most likely form is a short unsigned decision that reverses the lower court without oral argument. The Court already put that order on hold in June 2026, saying the lower court misapplied the Court's recent Voting Rights Act decision. The Court has now put the case on its conference list three times without acting, which often means an opinion is being written. One or more liberal Justices would probably dissent.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional map under VRA §2 and the Fourteenth Amendment, the first major application of Louisiana v. Callais; it decides a likely second Black-opportunity district and how far courts may find intentional discrimination.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 84%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about an 84% chance—to intervene in Alabama's challenge to an order blocking its congressional voting map. The likeliest result is a summary reversal, meaning the Court overturns that order without full briefing and argument. Alabama says the Court already criticized the order when temporarily blocking it in June. Recent voting-rights precedent strengthens that position, although the lower court's separate finding of intentional racial discrimination makes the result less certain. Additional consideration before a decision is likely.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional representation and the nationwide interaction of Voting Rights Act vote-dilution protections, partisan districting objectives, and intentional-discrimination claims are at stake.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—at an 88% probability—to rule in Alabama's favor at this stage by vacating (formally wiping out) the lower court's May 26, 2026 temporary order that blocked Alabama's 2023 congressional district map and sending the case back to the three-judge federal district court. In June 2026, the Supreme Court already paused that temporary order and explained that the lower court failed to follow recent Supreme Court precedent requiring challengers' proposed voting maps to match the state's non-racial mapmaking rules, such as keeping Gulf Coast counties together. Because the temporary order applied only to the 2026 elections—which have now taken place on November 3, 2026 under Alabama's 2023 map—the Supreme Court is expected to vacate the expired preliminary order and return the dispute to the district court for any remaining proceedings.

    Why this big-case score: Major Voting Rights Act Section 2 and Fourteenth Amendment congressional redistricting appeal returning to the Supreme Court after Allen v. Milligan (2023) and Louisiana v. Callais (2026).

Kian v. FloridaHamed Kian asks the Supreme Court to overturn its 1970 ruling that allows states to use six-person juries in serious criminal cases.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.85
0.82
0.85
0.84

Hamed Kian v. FloridaNo. 25-6623 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73282277 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Criminal law

Hamed Kian asks the Supreme Court to overturn its 1970 ruling that allows states to use six-person juries in serious criminal cases.

What happened

Hamed Kian, a Florida-licensed chiropractor, was convicted by a six-person jury of five felony counts of practicing chiropractic medicine while his license was suspended. Florida law permits six-person juries in all non-capital criminal cases. Kian argued on appeal that the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments require a twelve-person jury in serious criminal cases, pointing to the Supreme Court's 1970 decision in Williams v. Florida, which upheld six-person juries, as inconsistent with the Court's more recent reasoning in Ramos v. Louisiana about how to interpret the jury-trial right. Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed his conviction without a written opinion, and Kian petitioned the Supreme Court for review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution's guarantee of trial by an impartial jury in serious criminal cases requires exactly twelve jurors, meaning states like Florida could no longer use six-person juries for felony trials, or whether the earlier ruling allowing smaller juries remains valid law.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, and the case has been fully briefed and argued; it was set for argument on January 13, 2027, and the case has been circulated, meaning it now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Kian, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to reverse his conviction by holding that the Constitution requires twelve-person juries. If the Court affirms, Florida's six-person jury system remains valid and Kian's conviction stands. If the Court reverses, it would hold that serious criminal charges require twelve-person juries, likely overturning Kian's conviction and calling into question similar convictions in Florida and other states using smaller juries. If the Court vacates, it would send the case back to the Florida courts without deciding the jury-size question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 13, 2027
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Kian wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Florida wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether to overrule Williams v. Florida (1970) and require 12-person juries for serious state felonies: a constitutional criminal-procedure question touching Florida's and other states' jury systems, with dozens of amici and two 13-state coalitions.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.83·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 72%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether serious criminal trials require twelve jurors is a foundational jury-rights question with consequences for multiple states' noncapital prosecutions and pending direct appeals, despite this prosecution's modest individual profile.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 72%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Landmark Sixth Amendment challenge asking the Court to overrule Williams v. Florida (1970) and mandate 12-person juries in state felony prosecutions, implicating criminal jury statutes in six states and roughly 5,000 pending felony appeals in Florida.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether to overrule Williams v. Florida (1970) and constitutionalize the 12-person criminal jury; reaches thousands of pending direct appeals in at least seven states.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 74%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether serious criminal charges require twelve jurors is a fundamental nationwide trial-right question with substantial consequences for smaller-jury states, pending convictions, and criminal-court administration, though it is not a general expansion of the jury-trial entitlement.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 75%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Squarely reconsiders Williams v. Florida (1970) and whether the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments require 12-person juries in state felony prosecutions.

Allen v. CasterAlabama asks the Court to reverse a court order blocking its 2023 congressional map, which a lower court found violates the Voting Rights Act and the Constitution.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.80
0.94
0.78
0.84

Wes Allen, Alabama Secretary of State, et al. v. Marcus Caster, et al.No. 26-116 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000116 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Election law

Alabama asks the Court to reverse a court order blocking its 2023 congressional map, which a lower court found violates the Voting Rights Act and the Constitution.

What happened

Alabama's congressional map has long been challenged by Black voters and organizations who say it dilutes their voting strength by creating only one district, out of seven, where they can elect their preferred candidate. Federal courts blocked an earlier map in 2022, and the Supreme Court agreed in 2023 that it likely violated the Voting Rights Act. Alabama then passed a replacement, the 2023 Plan, which again included only one such district. After a trial, the district court found this plan also violated the law and was enacted with intentional racial discrimination, and ordered Alabama to use a court-drawn map instead. Alabama appealed, and after the Supreme Court decided a related case called Callais, the dispute returned to the lower court, which reached the same conclusion. Alabama now asks the Supreme Court to take up the case before a federal appeals court rules.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the lower court was wrong to find that Alabama's map likely dilutes Black voters' voting strength, including whether it properly required challengers to show their proposed alternative maps met the state's stated priorities, properly separated race from politics in analyzing voting patterns, and properly weighed historical and present-day evidence of discrimination. The Court is also asked whether Alabama violated the Constitution by declining to draw a map with a second district where Black voters could elect their preferred candidate.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for three conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, and the docket shows no action on it since.

What each outcome would mean

Alabama, the Secretary of State and other officials, asked the Court to take the case and reverse. The voters and organizations who sued, including Marcus Caster and others, argue the petition should be denied, in part because they say the dispute is moot since the Supreme Court already allowed the 2023 Plan to be used in the 2026 election. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments on whether the map is lawful, deciding the question itself rather than any particular outcome. If it denies the petition, the lower court's ruling against Alabama's map stands, at least for now, though the underlying case continues in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Allen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Allen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama asks the Supreme Court to wipe out a lower-court order that blocked its congressional map for the 2026 elections. The Supreme Court had already paused that order in June, and those elections have now taken place. We think it is fairly likely (about 72%) that the Court takes the case and, without full argument, cancels the lower-court order. The probable reason is that the dispute is now "moot", meaning there is no longer a live controversy. A dissent from the Court's liberal justices is likely.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama's congressional map under Section 2 after Louisiana v. Callais, a nationally watched voting-rights matter, though the injunction at issue covered only the 2026 cycle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to take Alabama's challenge, with about an 82% chance of some form of review. The most likely result is a short ruling overturning the lower court's temporary restriction on Alabama's congressional map, without another full hearing. The Court has already intervened in this dispute, and two closely connected cases are moving alongside it. The main uncertainty is whether the completed election makes the temporary restriction legally irrelevant, which could change how the Court ends the case.

    Why this big-case score: Application of the Voting Rights Act to Alabama's congressional map has major representation stakes and national implications for separating race from partisan districting objectives.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely (about a two-in-three chance, or 65%) to grant Alabama's request to review this congressional redistricting case before the federal appeals court rules, acting alongside two companion appeals that go directly to the Supreme Court. However, because the lower court's temporary order blocking Alabama's 2023 congressional map was already paused by the Supreme Court in June 2026 and the November 2026 election has now passed, the Court is most likely to resolve the petition summarily in its order—by vacating or reversing the temporary injunction and returning the case to the trial court for a final decision under the Court's recent *Louisiana v. Callais* voting-rights ruling—rather than holding a full round of oral arguments.

    Why this big-case score: Continuation of landmark Allen v. Milligan / Caster congressional redistricting litigation applying the new Louisiana v. Callais Section 2 framework.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama asks the Supreme Court to review a lower-court order that blocked its congressional map under the Voting Rights Act. The same dispute is pending in two companion appeals that the Court must decide. We think it is very likely, about four in five, that the Court takes action in Alabama's favor rather than simply declining the case. Most likely it will summarily reverse, meaning it overturns the order without full briefing and argument. The alternative is wiping the order out because the 2026 election it governed is over. The Court already paused this order in June.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama's congressional map and the post-Callais shape of VRA Section 2 liability; third trip to the Court, nationally watched.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely than not—about seven chances in ten—to accept Alabama's request for review. The likeliest single outcome is summary reversal: overturning the lower court's order without another full hearing. The Court previously intervened in this redistricting dispute, and closely related appeals give it a reason to handle these cases together. But the election has already occurred, raising a serious question about whether further relief is still needed. Expect another conference or two, not a request for the federal government's advice.

    Why this big-case score: The permissible boundaries of Voting Rights Act enforcement and intentional-discrimination review in congressional redistricting have nationwide implications, independent of grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely—about a 72% chance—to grant Alabama's request for immediate review and wipe out (`gvr`, meaning grant, vacate, and remand) the lower court's preliminary injunction blocking Alabama's 2023 congressional map. In June 2026, the Supreme Court already paused this exact injunction and stated that the lower court failed to follow the Supreme Court's recent Voting Rights Act decision in *Louisiana v. Callais*. Because the November 2026 election has now taken place and companion direct appeals (*Milligan* and *Singleton*) are being considered alongside this case, the Court is likely to vacate or summarily reverse the preliminary injunction without holding full oral arguments.

    Why this big-case score: High-salience Voting Rights Act Section 2 challenge to Alabama's 2023 congressional map testing the application of Louisiana v. Callais on remand from Allen v. Milligan, tempered by its interlocutory preliminary-injunction posture as the single-judge companion to the direct appeals in Nos. 26-117 and 26-118.

United States v. Devonte Devon JacksonThe federal government asks the Court to revive the prosecution role of an acting U.S. Attorney whom lower courts found was unlawfully installed under a federal vacancy-filling law.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.80
0.86
0.85
0.84

United States v. Devonte Devon Jackson, et al.No. 26-304 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000304 · models differ by up to 0.06 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The federal government asks the Court to revive the prosecution role of an acting U.S. Attorney whom lower courts found was unlawfully installed under a federal vacancy-filling law.

What happened

When Nevada's U.S. Attorney resigned, a first assistant briefly served as acting head under a federal vacancy law. The Attorney General later appointed Sigal Chattah as interim U.S. Attorney, and when her term neared its limit, she resigned and was immediately redesignated "First Assistant," continuing to lead the office. Several defendants indicted during her tenure argued she was serving unlawfully and moved to disqualify her. The district court agreed and disqualified her, but declined to dismiss the indictments. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the disqualification and dismissed the defendants' cross-appeal of the refusal to dismiss indictments.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a person named "first assistant" only after a leadership vacancy already began can automatically become the acting head of that office under the vacancy law's default rule, and separately, whether that same law bars an agency head from delegating essentially all of a vacant office's duties to one person as a workaround to the law's limits on acting officials.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed after full briefing, including an opposition brief filed in November 2026; the docket does not yet show a ruling on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, asks the Court to overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling against it. If the Court grants review and eventually rules for the government, Chattah's authority to lead the office could be restored and similar designations elsewhere could continue. If it denies review or rules for the respondents (Jackson and the other defendants), the Ninth Circuit's decision disqualifying Chattah stands, limiting how the government can fill such vacancies. A vacate-and-remand would leave the question unresolved and send the case back.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the United States' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The United States' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Solicitor General petition on whether the Executive may install acting U.S. Attorneys through post-vacancy first-assistant designations or blanket delegations; the answer governs leadership of fourteen U.S. Attorney's Offices today and every future presidential transition, and it sits inside the wider Appointments Clause and FVRA contest over Trump-era acting officials.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern executive-branch staffing under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, with consequences for federal prosecutions and leadership of Senate-confirmed offices across presidential transitions. These institutional stakes extend well beyond the individual defendants, independently of the chance of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High stakes due to invalidation of an Acting U.S. Attorney, disrupting prosecutions across multiple districts.

Republican National Committee v. EakinThe Republican National Committee asks the Court to overturn a ruling that struck down Pennsylvania's requirement that mail-in ballot envelopes be dated.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.75
0.85
0.90
0.83

Republican National Committee, et al. v. Bette Eakin, et al.No. 25-962 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281002 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Election law

The Republican National Committee asks the Court to overturn a ruling that struck down Pennsylvania's requirement that mail-in ballot envelopes be dated.

What happened

Bette Eakin and other voters sued Pennsylvania's county election boards after her mail-in ballot was rejected in 2022 for lacking a date on the return envelope. The Republican National Committee and allied Republican groups intervened to defend the requirement. A federal district court ruled that discarding undated or misdated ballots violates the Constitution, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed, finding the requirement burdens voters without sufficiently serving the state's interests in fraud prevention, solemnity, or election administration. The Pennsylvania Attorney General, who had intervened on appeal to defend the requirement, separately petitioned the Court as well. The Third Circuit denied rehearing by a divided vote.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a voting rule that imposes only ordinary burdens on voters is constitutional, whether a rule governing mail ballots should receive relaxed judicial review when in-person voting remains available, and, if closer review applies, how courts should weigh a mail-voting rule's burden against the state's reasons for it.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, with responses, a reply, and amicus briefs filed. The Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the views of the United States, and the case has not yet been scheduled for a decision on whether to grant review.

What each outcome would mean

The Republican National Committee is asking the Court to reverse the Third Circuit's decision, which Eakin and the other voters who sued had won. If the Court declines to hear the case, the Third Circuit's ruling stands, and Pennsylvania election officials remain barred from discarding mail ballots solely for missing or incorrect dates on the return envelope. If the Court takes up the case, it would decide the legal standard for reviewing such voting rules and could ultimately uphold the date requirement, leave the lower court's reasoning undisturbed, or send the case back for further review without resolving who prevails.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the Republican National Committee's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The Republican National Committee's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    RNC/DSCC fight over Pennsylvania's mail-ballot date requirement with a QP asking the Court to rein in Anderson-Burdick nationwide; a merits ruling would reshape constitutional review of every state ballot-casting rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition could reshape constitutional review of mail-voting rules nationwide and directly affects Pennsylvania election administration.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High salience based on parties (Republican National Committee) and timing (election year).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A plenary ruling would reset the Anderson-Burdick standard for every neutral ballot-casting rule nationwide, with the national party committees and 21 states already engaged; narrower if resolved as a Munsingwear vacatur.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 56%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could reshape constitutional review of ordinary election rules nationwide, beyond Pennsylvania's mail-ballot envelope dates. The developed record and competing accounts of disenfranchisement and state regulatory authority make the stakes substantial even if review is denied.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes election law dispute involving major political committees and an acknowledged circuit split on mail-voting rules.

StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice v. Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyJewish MIT students and an advocacy group ask the Court to revive their civil rights lawsuit against MIT over its response to campus protests following the October 7, 2023 attacks.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.75
0.82
0.90
0.82

StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice, et al. v. Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyNo. 25-1404 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73514289 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Employment & discrimination (also First Amendment)

Jewish MIT students and an advocacy group ask the Court to revive their civil rights lawsuit against MIT over its response to campus protests following the October 7, 2023 attacks.

What happened

StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice and two MIT students sued MIT under Title VI, a law barring race and national-origin discrimination at federally funded schools, claiming campus protests after October 7, 2023 created a hostile environment for Jewish and Israeli students and that MIT was deliberately indifferent to it. A federal district court dismissed the case, and the First Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, ruling both that the allegations did not show an actionable hostile environment and, separately, that MIT's response was not clearly unreasonable. The First Circuit denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether someone claiming a hostile environment under this law must show that the people harassing them acted with discriminatory intent, and whether the free-speech guarantee prevents such a claim from resting on speech that would otherwise be constitutionally protected.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for several conferences, most recently one scheduled after the snapshot date, after full briefing including MIT's opposition, the students' reply, and numerous amicus briefs; the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

StandWithUs and the students are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the First Circuit's ruling, which favored MIT. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions; if it denies review, the First Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of the students' lawsuit stands, and MIT prevails. Denial would not mean the Court agrees the lower court was right, only that the case ends there without further review.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: StandWithUs Center for Legal Justice's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Title VI hostile-environment standard and its First Amendment limits for campus antisemitism after October 7: nationally salient, recurring across many pending university suits, heavy amicus support including two U.S. Senators.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern nationwide university obligations toward Jewish students, the proof of discriminatory harassment, and the boundary between Title VI and protected political speech. Those stakes are substantial even if independent grounds prevent review in this vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Highly salient case concerning Title VI liability for campus antisemitism and First Amendment protections for protesters, with numerous high-profile amici.

National Park Service, et al. v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United StatesThe federal government asks the Supreme Court to overturn a court order that blocked construction of a new White House East Wing ballroom.awaiting the Court
0.72
0.90
0.85
0.82

National Park Service, et al. v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United StatesNo. 26-599 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000599 · models differ by up to 0.18

The federal government asks the Supreme Court to overturn a court order that blocked construction of a new White House East Wing ballroom.

What happened

In October 2025 the government began demolishing and rebuilding the White House's East Wing, including a ballroom funded by private donations. The National Trust for Historic Preservation sued, arguing the project lacked legal authorization and should be stopped. A district court issued a preliminary injunction halting above-ground construction, with an exception for work needed for security. The D.C. Circuit affirmed. In August 2026 the Supreme Court granted the government's request to pause that injunction while the government pursued this appeal, finding the government likely to succeed in showing the Trust had no legal right to sue. Four justices dissented. The government then filed this petition.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the lower court was wrong to block construction while the lawsuit continues. The petition raises whether the group suing had suffered the kind of concrete harm needed to bring the case at all, whether federal law authorized the renovation, and whether the balance of harms favored letting construction continue.

Where it stands

The government filed its petition for certiorari on November 5, 2026, with a response due December 7, 2026. The Court has not yet acted on whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The government, as petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the lower court's ruling that favored the Trust. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments on whether the injunction was proper, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies the petition, the lower court's injunction favoring the Trust would stand, though the government notes the project has largely proceeded under the Court's earlier stay. The petition also asks the Court to summarily reverse or send the case back for reconsideration without full briefing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 7, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The government asks the Supreme Court to throw out a court order that halted construction of the new White House East Wing. We think the Court will very likely agree to take up the case (about 88%). In August the Court already paused that order by a 5–4 vote, saying the government will probably win because the challenger, who objects to how the building will look, likely has no legal right to sue. The Court may either hear full arguments or simply reverse the lower court without them.

    Why this big-case score: Presidential construction project at the White House, a 5-4 stay with a per curiam opinion and a Chief Justice dissent; standing doctrine for aesthetic injury is the legal stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 94%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to take action on the government's appeal over the White House East Wing project: I estimate a 94% chance of review or another grant of relief. The most likely result is a summary reversal, meaning the Court overturns the lower court without a full argument cycle. Five Justices have already temporarily blocked the construction injunction and explained their objections. The final order will probably rely on those same objections, with a separate opinion opposing the result.

    Why this big-case score: The dispute concerns control of White House construction, congressional authorization, national-security equities, and potentially consequential limits on aesthetic standing.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely (an 88% chance, or nearly nine in ten) to grant the federal government's request for review and wipe out the lower court's ruling without holding a full new round of arguments—a step known as a "grant, vacate, and remand." In August 2026, a five-Justice majority already paused the lower court's order blocking construction of the new White House East Wing ballroom, concluding that the preservation group suing the government lacked legal standing (a concrete personal injury required to bring a federal lawsuit). Because that temporary pause would expire automatically if the Supreme Court simply turned this appeal away, the Court is very likely to grant the petition, set aside the lower court's decision, and send the case back down in line with its August opinion.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile constitutional and statutory dispute over Executive authority to demolish the White House East Wing and build a privately funded state ballroom without express congressional authorization, plus Article III standing to challenge alterations to historic national monuments.

Gator's Custom Guns v. WashingtonGun sellers ask the Court to hold that magazines holding more than ten rounds are constitutionally protected arms that Washington cannot ban.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.75
0.90
0.80
0.82

Gator's Custom Guns, Inc., et al. v. WashingtonNo. 25-153 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274837 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Firearms

Gun sellers ask the Court to hold that magazines holding more than ten rounds are constitutionally protected arms that Washington cannot ban.

What happened

Gator's Custom Guns and its owner, Walter Wentz, kept selling large-capacity magazines after Washington banned their manufacture and sale in 2022. The state sued them for violating its consumer protection law, and they argued the ban violated the Second Amendment. A trial court agreed and struck down the law, but the Washington Supreme Court reversed, ruling that such magazines are not "arms" protected by the Second Amendment at all, and that even if they were, they are not commonly used for self-defense. Gator's then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether magazines that hold more than ten rounds count as "arms" that are presumptively protected under the part of the Constitution covering the right to keep and bear weapons, or whether they can be treated as mere accessories outside that protection entirely.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for many conferences since September 2025, most recently for June 2026, and the docket shows no decision yet. The parties have filed several supplemental briefs pointing to new appeals court rulings on the same issue, the most recent filed in August 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Gator's and Wentz are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Washington Supreme Court. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether such magazines are constitutionally protected, which could lead to reversing, affirming, or vacating the state court's decision; a reversal would favor Gator's, while an affirmance would leave Washington's ban in place. If the Court denies review, the Washington Supreme Court's ruling upholding the ban stands, and Gator's loses without the Court deciding the constitutional question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Gator's Custom Guns' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Gator's Custom Guns' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally watched Second Amendment hardware-ban vehicle (magazine-capacity limits in ~14 states): top SCOTUS counsel, 25+ state amici, NRA/NSSF briefs, 20+ conference distributions, now riding alongside the granted assault-weapons cases.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 57%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition tests the constitutionality of a broadly consequential large-capacity-magazine ban under the Court's evolving Second Amendment framework.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenges to state bans on large-capacity firearm magazines are extremely high-profile, testing the limits of the Bruen framework.

Association for Education Fairness v. Montgomery County Board of EducationThe Supreme Court agreed to decide how parents challenging a school district's admissions lottery must prove the district discriminated against Asian American students.Constitutional rightspartly decided
0.80
0.80
0.85
0.82

Association for Education Fairness v. Montgomery County Board of Education, et al.No. 26-12 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000012 · models differ by up to 0.05 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court agreed to decide how parents challenging a school district's admissions lottery must prove the district discriminated against Asian American students.

What happened

A parents' group, the Association for Education Fairness, sued Montgomery County's school board over how it picks students for competitive magnet middle school programs. The group first challenged an earlier admissions process, then amended its lawsuit to challenge a replacement lottery system adopted during the COVID-19 pandemic, arguing both were designed to reduce Asian American enrollment. A federal district court dismissed the case, finding the group had not plausibly alleged either that the lottery disproportionately hurt Asian American students or that officials intended to discriminate. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, relying on a rule that Asian American students must show their admission rate fell below their share of applicants.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether someone challenging a school's race-neutral admissions rules as intentionally discriminatory must first prove the rules caused an overall numerical disadvantage to the affected racial group, before a court will even look at other evidence suggesting the rules were adopted for discriminatory reasons.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition on October 19, 2026, limited to that question. Briefing is underway: the petitioner's opening brief is due December 10, 2026, and the school board's brief is due January 19, 2027. The case has not yet been argued.

What each outcome would mean

The Association for Education Fairness, which asked the Court to take the case and is seeking to overturn the lower court's ruling, argues that courts should weigh evidence of discriminatory intent even without proof of an overall numerical disadvantage. If the Court rules for the Association, the case would likely return to the lower courts to reconsider the group's claims under a different legal standard, without deciding who ultimately wins. If the Court rules for the school board, the lower court's dismissal of the lawsuit would stand, leaving the admissions lottery in place and the group's challenge rejected.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseOct 19, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Association for Education Fairness wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The Montgomery County Board of Education wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would set the nationwide evidentiary standard for proving intentional race discrimination through facially neutral 'proxy' admissions criteria after SFFA, touching selective K-12 admissions in the largest districts and drawing sustained advocacy-group and press attention; a denial leaves a live circuit split and would likely draw a noted dissent. Stakes are high for a cert-stage docket but the underlying facts (a pandemic-era lottery) are modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question could govern proof of intentional racial discrimination in selective public-school admissions nationwide, with consequences for facially neutral substitutes for racial preferences. The particular lottery and pleading posture limit this vehicle's reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents a mature 2-2 circuit split on applying Arlington Heights to facially neutral school admissions, a major post-SFFA question.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a four-circuit split on how race-neutral proxies in selective K-12 admissions are tested after SFFA; affects many large districts' admissions policies.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The threshold for challenging alleged racial proxies in selective public-school admissions has nationwide importance after SFFA, though the limited question does not itself decide the legality of all socioeconomic admissions policies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile case concerning the use of race-neutral proxies in competitive school admissions, closely watched following the Students for Fair Admissions decision.

Trump v. Badar Khan SuriThe federal government asks the Court whether a detained noncitizen may challenge his detention in habeas when his claims also attack his removal's validity.Immigrationawaiting the Court
0.80
0.84
0.80
0.81

Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al. v. Badar Khan SuriNo. 26-380 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000380 · models differ by up to 0.04 · topic: Immigration

The federal government asks the Court whether a detained noncitizen may challenge his detention in habeas when his claims also attack his removal's validity.

What happened

Badar Khan Suri, a researcher at Georgetown University, was detained by immigration authorities after the Secretary of State determined his presence posed foreign-policy concerns. Suri filed a habeas petition claiming his detention was retaliation for his speech and associations, violating the First and Fifth Amendments. A federal district court ordered him released and blocked his removal while the case proceeded. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, rejecting the government's argument that immigration law stripped the district court of jurisdiction, while acknowledging its ruling conflicted with decisions from the Third and Second Circuits.

What the Court is being asked

Immigration law generally requires that challenges to a removal be brought only through a specific review process in the courts of appeals, not through a habeas lawsuit in district court. The Court is asked whether that rule also blocks a detained person from using habeas to challenge his detention, when the arguments he raises would also undercut the legality of removing him.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and the response deadline was extended to November 20, 2026. Amicus briefs supporting the government's position have been filed. The docket does not yet show the Court granting or denying the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands, meaning Suri's release and the block on his removal remain in effect, and detained noncitizens in that circuit could bring similar habeas challenges. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the jurisdictional question itself, ruling for neither side simply by agreeing to hear it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 20, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Trump's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Trump's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Solicitor General petition on whether detained noncitizens may bring habeas challenges outside the INA's petition-for-review channel, arising from the widely covered campus-speech deportation cases (Suri, Khalil, Mahdawi); the answer governs tens of thousands of detentions a year and the reach of 8 U.S.C. 1252(b)(9) and (g).

  • CodexBig-case score 0.84·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between immigration review-channeling and detention habeas jurisdiction has nationwide consequences for access to courts, liberty, and speech-related constitutional challenges. The presented question concerns jurisdiction, not a direct adjudication of the underlying speech claims.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of district court habeas jurisdiction over detained aliens under the INA is a recurring, high-stakes issue concerning the separation of powers and immigration enforcement.

Allen v. SingletonAlabama officials appeal a district court order blocking the state's 2023 congressional map, in a long-running dispute over Black voters' representation.awaiting the Court
0.70
0.88
0.85
0.81

Wes Allen, Alabama Secretary of State, et al. v. Bobby Singleton, et al.No. 26-118 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000118 · models differ by up to 0.18

Alabama officials appeal a district court order blocking the state's 2023 congressional map, in a long-running dispute over Black voters' representation.

What happened

Alabama's congressional map has been challenged since 2021 by several groups of voters, including state senator Bobby Singleton and others, who argued it diluted Black voting strength in violation of the Voting Rights Act and the Constitution. After earlier rounds reached the Supreme Court, a three-judge district court again blocked the state's map (the "2023 Plan") in May 2026, ruling that it likely violated federal law and intentionally discriminated against Black voters, and ordered the state to use a court-drawn map instead. Alabama appealed, and the Supreme Court temporarily paused that order while the appeal proceeds.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether the lower court wrongly excused the challengers from showing an alternative map that met the state's stated map-drawing goals just as well as the state's own map, whether the lower court mistook ordinary political patterns for race-based voting, whether the overall evidence supported a finding of likely discrimination, and whether Alabama violated the Constitution by not drawing a map with an additional district favorable to Black voters.

Where it stands

The case was distributed for conferences in October and November 2026, most recently November 13; the docket shows no action taken on the appeal as of the snapshot date.

What each outcome would mean

Alabama officials, led by Secretary of State Wes Allen, are asking the Court to overturn the district court's order, which favored Singleton and the other voters who challenged the map. If the Court agrees with Alabama, the 2023 Plan could go back into effect, and the challengers' claims would not succeed as decided below. If the Court agrees with Singleton and the other challengers, the district court's order blocking the 2023 Plan and requiring a court-drawn substitute would stand. The Court could also send the case back for further proceedings without resolving the dispute for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Allen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Allen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama is appealing a lower court order that blocked its congressional map, and the Supreme Court must rule on this kind of appeal. We think it is very likely (about 4 in 5) that the Court sides with Alabama. The most likely route is a short "summary reversal," meaning the Court overturns the order without full briefing or argument. The alternative is wiping the order out because the 2026 election it covered is over. The main reason is that the Court already paused this same order in June, saying the lower court misapplied its recent voting-rights decision.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional map after Louisiana v. Callais; third trip to the Court in the Milligan/Singleton/Caster litigation, with national VRA §2 stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about nine chances in ten—to take action overturning Alabama's lower-court redistricting order or sending it back. The most likely result is reversal without another full hearing because the justices previously found serious errors in the same order. A different possibility is that the election's completion leads the Court to cancel the order without deciding who is right. I expect a short further delay and, if the Court reverses, a dissent led by Justice Sotomayor.

    Why this big-case score: Congressional representation and protection against racial vote dilution are directly at stake, with substantial implications for implementing the Voting Rights Act and constitutional redistricting rules nationally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely (an 80% chance, or four in five) to grant relief on Alabama's appeal in this congressional redistricting case, most likely by vacating the lower court's preliminary injunction and sending the case back to the trial court ("grant, vacate, and remand," a disposition that counts as a grant). In May 2026, a three-judge federal court ordered Alabama to use a court-drawn congressional map for the 2026 election, but the Supreme Court paused that order in June 2026, allowing the November 3, 2026 election to proceed under Alabama's enacted 2023 map. Because the 2026 election has now taken place and the lower court only enjoined the map for 2026, the Supreme Court will likely wipe that temporary order off the books—or take up the case for full review—so the lower court can address future elections under recent Supreme Court precedent.

    Why this big-case score: Third Supreme Court round of the landmark Alabama congressional redistricting litigation, testing the application of Louisiana v. Callais (2026) to VRA Section 2 vote-dilution claims.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Alabama is appealing a court order that blocked its congressional map for the November 2026 election. The Supreme Court had already paused that order, and the election has now taken place under Alabama's map, so the dispute over that one election is probably over ("moot"). We think it is very likely, about 85%, that the Court will wipe out the lower court's order and send the case back, rather than simply dismissing the appeal and leaving the order on the books. Several Justices may write separately.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional redistricting after Louisiana v. Callais, with an intentional-discrimination finding against a State; high stakes, though the preliminary-injunction posture and likely mootness narrow what this order itself decides.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 76%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is likely to set aside the lower court's temporary redistricting ruling and send the case back, rather than hear a full new round of arguments. I put the chance of some review or judgment-setting-aside action at about three in four. Alabama's November 3 election has passed, creating a serious question about whether this temporary order still matters. An earlier Supreme Court stay also favors intervention. Simply dismissing the appeal remains a meaningful alternative, and setting aside the ruling would not necessarily decide the underlying voting-rights dispute.

    Why this big-case score: Alabama congressional representation, minority voting rights, and the nationwide relationship between Section 2 and equal protection are at stake, although a mootness disposition would decide little new law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court is very likely (about a four-in-five chance, 78%) to grant relief by vacating the lower court's order and sending the case back, rather than leaving the order in place. In May 2026, a three-judge federal court issued a preliminary injunction—a temporary court order—blocking Alabama from using its 2023 congressional map in the 2026 elections, but the Supreme Court paused that order in June 2026 so the November 3, 2026 election went forward under Alabama's map. Because the 2026 election is now over, the temporary 2026 order has expired, and the Supreme Court's standard practice is to wipe such an expired order off the books while the lower court considers future elections under the Court's recent Voting Rights Act precedent.

    Why this big-case score: Direct appeal in the landmark Alabama congressional redistricting litigation testing the post-Callais Section 2 and Fourteenth Amendment standards across three companion dockets.

Arizona v. Promise ArizonaArizona asks the Court to review a ruling that let an advocacy group sue over a voter-roll law without identifying any member it actually harmed.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.75
0.82
0.85
0.81

Arizona, et al. v. Promise Arizona, et al.No. 25-1022 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281063 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Civil procedure (also Election law)

Arizona asks the Court to review a ruling that let an advocacy group sue over a voter-roll law without identifying any member it actually harmed.

What happened

Arizona passed laws in 2022 to check voter rolls for noncitizens and to require proof of citizenship on its state registration form. Promise Arizona and another group sued, claiming the voter-roll law was enacted with discriminatory intent. After a trial, a federal district court rejected that claim. The Ninth Circuit vacated that finding and sent it back for further review, ruling first that Promise Arizona could sue on behalf of its members even though it had not identified any member actually harmed by the law, and second that the district court had not properly weighed the evidence of discriminatory intent. Judge Bumatay dissented, and eleven judges dissented from rehearing the case en banc.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an organization can sue in federal court over a law by claiming only that some unidentified members might be affected, without naming anyone actually harmed, and whether the appeals court overstepped its role by reweighing the trial court's factual findings instead of checking them only for clear mistakes.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, after the United States, as respondent, filed a brief opposing it while supporting a related petition. Arizona later filed a supplemental brief citing a new Ninth Circuit ruling it says undercuts the panel's standing decision below, and the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Arizona is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's rulings on standing and on how the evidence was reviewed. If the Court denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, and the case returns to the district court for further proceedings on whether the voter-roll law was discriminatory. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case and decide these questions itself; a grant does not decide who is right. Arizona has also asked the Court, as an alternative, to grant the petition, vacate the Ninth Circuit's decision, and send the case back for reconsideration in light of a newer Ninth Circuit ruling, without the Court itself deciding the questions.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Arizona's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Arizona's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Companion petition in the marquee Arizona proof-of-citizenship voting cluster (lead case 25-1017 granted for OT2026); its own Summers-standing and clear-error questions would be significant if decided, but it is the satellite, not the lead.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition joins nationally consequential election-law litigation and raises broadly important questions about associational standing, appellate review of discriminatory-purpose findings, and legislative good faith.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes election law dispute with an 11-judge en banc dissent.

Philip L. Rhoney, Acting Director of the Buffalo Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement v. Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da CunhaThe government asked the Court to review whether a detained immigrant who entered the country years ago must be held without bond, a question the Court has agreed to decide.Immigrationpartly decided
0.92
0.90
0.60
0.81

Philip L. Rhoney, Acting Director of the Buffalo Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement v. Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da CunhaNo. 26-104 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000104 · models differ by up to 0.32 · topic: Immigration

The government asked the Court to review whether a detained immigrant who entered the country years ago must be held without bond, a question the Court has agreed to decide.

What happened

Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da Cunha entered the United States without inspection around 2004 or 2005 and has lived here since, applying for asylum in 2016. In 2025 immigration officers arrested him, and the government argued a statute requiring detention without bond for people "seeking admission" to the country applied to him. A district court and the Second Circuit disagreed, ruling that a different statute, which allows release on bond, governed his case, and ordering a bond hearing; he was released. The government, represented by Philip L. Rhoney of ICE, appealed to the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide which of two immigration detention laws applies to someone who entered the country without authorization years earlier and has been living here since: a rule that requires detention without bond for people trying to gain entry, or a different rule that allows release on bond while removal proceedings continue.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition on October 1, 2026. The case has not yet been argued; the deadline for the government's opening merits brief was extended to November 30, 2026, and the respondent's brief is due January 13, 2027.

What each outcome would mean

The government is asking the Court to overturn the Second Circuit's ruling, which favored Barbosa da Cunha. If the Court affirms, Barbosa da Cunha's position prevails: people in his situation remain eligible for bond hearings. If the Court reverses, the government's reading would prevail, meaning such individuals could be held without bond during removal proceedings. If the Court vacates, it would send the case back without deciding the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesTook the caseOct 1, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided

If the Court affirms: the lower court's ruling stands. · If the Court reverses or vacates: the ruling is overturned or sent back.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court took the case. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Government petition to restore a nationwide mandatory-detention policy for noncitizens arrested in the interior; a 7-2 circuit split over 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) vs 1226(a) affecting potentially hundreds of thousands of detainees.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 71%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗
  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An SG petition in an immigration context from the 2nd Circuit likely involves a federal statute's validity or circuit split.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.92·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 55%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decides whether DHS may hold every noncitizen present without admission, a population in the millions, without a bond hearing for the length of removal proceedings; the policy has generated thousands of habeas petitions and a ten-circuit split.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 64%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question determines statutory bond eligibility for a broad class of noncitizens arrested inside the country after entering without admission, with substantial liberty, family, and nationwide immigration-enforcement consequences.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 75%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Immigration detention disputes frequently resolve circuit splits and affect thousands of detainees, but are typically technical statutory cases rather than blockbuster constitutional decisions.

Quinones v. Ramon Rodriguez VazquezThe federal government asks the Court to hold this case while it decides the same detention question in another pending case.Immigrationawaiting the Court
0.80
0.90
0.72
0.81

Andre Quinones, Acting Director of the Seattle Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. v. Ramon Rodriguez Vazquez, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly SituatedNo. 26-568 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000568 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Immigration

The federal government asks the Court to hold this case while it decides the same detention question in another pending case.

What happened

Ramon Rodriguez Vazquez, who entered the United States without authorization in 2009, was detained by immigration officers in 2025 and denied a bond hearing because officials said a federal law required his detention during removal proceedings. He filed a class-action lawsuit arguing the law did not require this. A district court and then the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with him, ruling that people in his situation are entitled to bond hearings. The federal government now asks the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a federal immigration law requires the government to detain, without any possibility of bond, people who are in the country without having been formally admitted, while their removal cases proceed, or whether such people may instead seek release on bond as the lower court held.

Where it stands

The government's petition was filed on October 28, 2026, with a response due by November 30, 2026. The government's own filing asks the Court to hold this petition pending its decision in a different case, Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, which already presents the same question and was granted review.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, having lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to act. If the Court takes up and ultimately reverses the Ninth Circuit's decision, Rodriguez Vazquez's class would lose their right to bond hearings under this provision. If the Court denies review or affirms the lower ruling, the Ninth Circuit's decision requiring bond hearings for this class stands. The government has asked the Court to simply hold this petition until it decides the related Barbosa da Cunha case, then dispose of this one accordingly, rather than deciding it independently now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 30, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Quinones' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Quinones' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 56%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The government asks the Supreme Court not to decide this immigration-detention case on its own, but to set it aside until the Court decides a nearly identical case it has already agreed to hear (Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha). If the government wins that case, the Court will most likely send this one back to the lower court to reconsider — which counts as a grant here. If the government loses, the Court will turn this petition away. We think that is slightly better than a coin flip (about 56%) in the government's favor.

    Why this big-case score: Class-wide challenge to the government's reading of 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) mandating no-bond detention of every alien present without admission — an issue of national reach, though this petition rides as a hold behind the granted lead case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is likely to keep this petition waiting for another case already accepted on the same immigration-detention question, then send it back to the lower court for another look. I put the chance of some grant of review at about four in five, chiefly through that brief send-back order rather than a separate hearing. The dispute concerns whether immigrants arrested inside the country can ask for release on bond while their removal cases proceed. Denial remains possible if the earlier case supports the existing lower-court ruling.

    Why this big-case score: The underlying statutory question governs access to bond hearings for a broad population of immigrants arrested inside the United States, although this petition is a follow-on vehicle to an already-granted case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely than not (about a 55% chance) to grant this petition, wipe out the lower court's ruling, and send the case back to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals for a new decision (a summary procedure known as "grant, vacate, and remand," or GVR). The federal government is appealing a ruling that noncitizens who entered the country without border inspection are eligible for bond hearings while in immigration custody. Because the Supreme Court already agreed on October 1, 2026, to decide this exact legal question in a lead case (*Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha*), the Court will hold this petition and then send it back for reconsideration if the government wins the lead case.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes statutory question whether 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) mandates detention without bond for millions of noncitizens present in the interior without admission, presented here in a class-action hold petition awaiting the lead decision in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, No. 26-104.

National Republican Congressional Committee v. BrownThe Supreme Court stayed a Fourth Circuit ruling that had struck down FCC guidance on discounted political ad rates, keeping that guidance in effect for now.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.75
0.82
0.85
0.81

National Republican Congressional Committee, et al. Applicants v. Sherrod Brown, et al.No. 26A274 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000274 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Supreme Court stayed a Fourth Circuit ruling that had struck down FCC guidance on discounted political ad rates, keeping that guidance in effect for now.

What happened

An FCC staff notice said political parties and joint fundraising committees, not just candidates, could qualify for broadcasters' discounted "lowest unit charge" on campaign ads. Democratic candidates Sherrod Brown, Jon Ossoff, Roy Cooper, and Kristen McDonald Rivet challenged that notice, arguing it unfairly benefited Republican committees that spend more through coordinated ads. The Fourth Circuit agreed with them and set the notice aside, over a dissent arguing the court lacked jurisdiction because the FCC itself had not yet finished reviewing the notice. The National Republican Congressional Committee and National Republican Senatorial Committee, who had intervened in that case, asked the Supreme Court to pause the ruling before new election-season ad rates took effect.

What the Court is being asked

The application asked the Court to pause the Fourth Circuit's decision while the Republican committees pursue further review, on the grounds that the appeals court acted before the FCC had finished its own review of the guidance and wrongly interpreted which political spending qualifies for discounted ad rates.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice asked for responses, which were filed along with amicus briefs and a reply. On September 4, 2026, the Court granted the stay, recalling and pausing the Fourth Circuit's mandate until a petition for certiorari is filed and resolved; Justice Jackson dissented.

What each outcome would mean

The Republican committees asked for the stay, and the Court granted it. That means the Fourth Circuit's decision striking down the FCC guidance is paused, so the guidance allowing discounted ad rates for party-coordinated and joint fundraising committee ads remains in effect while the committees seek Supreme Court review. If certiorari is later denied, the stay ends automatically and the Fourth Circuit's ruling against the guidance would take effect; if certiorari is granted, the stay continues until the Court decides the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedSep 4, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-04: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court grants the application: 60%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An emergency application over the FCC's lowest-unit-rate guidance, brought by both national Republican campaign committees against sitting-senator and candidate respondents weeks before the 2026 general-election advertising window, with the United States supporting — nationally covered whichever way it goes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.91·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns nationwide campaign-advertising prices immediately before the 2026 general election and raises recurring limits on judicial review of agency action.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 85%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes election law challenge concerning campaign finance ad rates, with impact on 2026 midterm spending.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-09-04: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 62%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An emergency application over preferential broadcast ad rates for party committees, filed two months before the 2026 midterms with the Solicitor General backing the applicants; the outcome directly shapes advertising economics in the Senate and House campaigns.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 76%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application affects nationwide pricing for coordinated political advertising immediately before the 2026 general election.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 15%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves election-related rules and major political committees on the eve of a likely election cycle.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-09-04: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court grants the application: 60%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Controls whether party coordinated ads get lowest-unit-charge rates for the 2026 general-election window that opens Sept 4 - a direct, immediate money lever in the fight for Senate control, litigated by both national party apparatuses with the FCC and DOJ aligned with the applicants.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court grants the application: 74%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application affects nationwide broadcast-advertising prices for party and joint-fundraising campaign speech immediately before a federal election.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile dispute over discounted television and radio advertising rates for political parties immediately ahead of the 2026 midterm elections.

Putra v. Juan Manuel Lopez-CamposFederal immigration officials ask the Supreme Court to review a Sixth Circuit ruling that limited their enforcement actions against Juan Manuel Lopez-Campos and others.awaiting the Court
0.80
0.91
0.70
0.80

Matthew Putra, Director of the Detroit Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. v. Juan Manuel Lopez-Campos, et al.scotus/73529868 · models differ by up to 0.21

Federal immigration officials ask the Supreme Court to review a Sixth Circuit ruling that limited their enforcement actions against Juan Manuel Lopez-Campos and others.

What happened

Matthew Putra, a Detroit ICE field office director, and other federal officials sued or were sued in a dispute with Juan Manuel Lopez-Campos and other respondents over immigration enforcement issues. The case was decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on May 11, 2026, in four consolidated matters. The federal officials, as petitioners, then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. Several outside groups, including state attorneys general and immigration policy organizations, filed briefs supporting the petitioners' request for review.

What the Court is being asked

The case involves a constitutional question and a related statutory question about the scope of federal authority in immigration enforcement. A letter from the respondents' counsel notes that a related case pending before the Court, raising the same constitutional issue, and asks that if the Court takes that related case, it should limit review to a narrower statutory question instead, like the one presented here and in a similar case.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a reply from the federal officials, and was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. The docket does not show any order granting or denying the petition since that conference, and the record includes a recent letter from the respondents addressing a related case.

What each outcome would mean

The federal officials, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions itself, deciding nothing in advance about who is right. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision would remain in place, leaving intact whatever limits that court placed on the federal officials' enforcement actions, a result favoring Lopez-Campos and the other respondents.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Putra's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Putra's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 54%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question (mandatory no-bond detention of every unadmitted noncitizen under 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A), plus a freestanding due-process holding) is among the Term's largest; this vehicle's own significance is discounted because the Court chose the Second Circuit companion as the lead and this petition is now most likely a held companion disposed of in the lead case's wake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.91·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute concerns mandatory immigration detention without individualized bond hearings for noncitizens arrested in the interior, with competing statutory readings across circuits and a constitutional liberty question. Its nationwide stakes are high independently of which petition becomes the lead vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile immigration policy case brought by the Solicitor General involving ICE enforcement.

Pennsylvania v. EakinPennsylvania asks the Supreme Court to review a ruling that its mail-in ballot date requirement violates voters' constitutional rights.Election lawawaiting the Court
0.72
0.82
0.85
0.80

Pennsylvania v. Bette Eakin, et al.No. 25-967 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281009 · models differ by up to 0.13 · topic: Election law

Pennsylvania asks the Supreme Court to review a ruling that its mail-in ballot date requirement violates voters' constitutional rights.

What happened

Pennsylvania law requires mail-in voters to handwrite a date on their ballot return envelope; ballots with a missing or incorrect date are discarded. Bette Eakin and other voters and organizations sued Pennsylvania's county election boards, arguing the requirement violates federal law and the Constitution. The Republican National Committee and allied groups intervened to defend the requirement. A federal district court ruled for Eakin, and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the requirement imposes a minimal but unjustified burden on voting rights. Pennsylvania, which had intervened on appeal to defend the requirement, and the Republican National Committee separately petitioned the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state's requirement that mail-in voters handwrite a date on their ballot envelope, with noncompliant ballots discarded, violates the First or Fourteenth Amendment. Pennsylvania also asks the Court, as an alternative to full review, to send the case back to the lower court in light of a Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision issued after the Third Circuit's ruling, which Pennsylvania says undercuts the lower court's reasoning about voters' ability to fix ballot errors.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including responses from various county election boards and a reply from Pennsylvania, and was distributed for the Court's June 25, 2026 conference. The Court has since invited the Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard; the docket shows no decision yet on whether to grant review.

What each outcome would mean

Pennsylvania, supported by the Republican National Committee, asks the Court to take up the case and reverse the Third Circuit's ruling, which Eakin and other voters won below. If the Court grants review and later reverses, Pennsylvania's date requirement would be upheld and county boards could again discard ballots with missing or incorrect dates. If the Court denies review, the Third Circuit's decision stands, and county boards must continue counting ballots despite date errors. A grant without a decision on the merits would mean only that the Court will hear full arguments before deciding the question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Pennsylvania's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Pennsylvania's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Constitutionality of Pennsylvania's mail-ballot date requirement in the largest swing state, with both parties' national campaign committees as parties and a potential nationwide recalibration of Anderson-Burdick scrutiny.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.84·Chance the Court takes the case: 39%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could reshape constitutional review of mail-ballot rules and election administration nationwide, with immediate stakes in a major swing state.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile challenge to Pennsylvania's mail-in ballot date requirement with major election implications.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A battleground state's mail-ballot rule struck down by a federal court of appeals, with an acknowledged 7-4 circuit split over Anderson-Burdick scrutiny for minimal burdens; a plenary decision would reshape federal review of state election rules before 2028, while a GVR or denial would be a mid-salience election-law story.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case concerns rejection of otherwise valid mail ballots in Pennsylvania and could reshape Anderson-Burdick review of routine voting rules nationally. A narrow state-law GVR would have less doctrinal reach than plenary review, but election-administration stakes remain substantial.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes election law case concerning the validity of state mail-in ballot requirements under the First and Fourteenth Amendments, potentially affecting many votes in a battleground state.

Genalo v. Carol Williams BlackThe government and an immigrant detainee disputed whether prolonged immigration detention without a bond hearing violates due process; the Court dismissed the case after a pardon mooted it.Immigrationawaiting the Court
0.80
0.78
0.80
0.79

Kenneth Genalo, Director of the New York Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. v. Carol Williams Black, et al.No. 25-886 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280386 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Immigration

The government and an immigrant detainee disputed whether prolonged immigration detention without a bond hearing violates due process; the Court dismissed the case after a pardon mooted it.

What happened

Keisy G.M., a lawful permanent resident, was detained by immigration authorities for 21 months under a law requiring detention of certain noncitizens with criminal convictions, without ever receiving a hearing on whether he posed a flight risk or danger. He sued for release, arguing his prolonged detention without a hearing violated due process. The Second Circuit agreed, ruling that due process entitled him to a bond hearing once detention became unreasonably prolonged, and ordered further proceedings. A companion case involving another detainee, Carol Black, was resolved the same way but later became moot when he left the country. The government asked the Supreme Court to review the Second Circuit's ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asked the Court to decide whether there is a point at which immigration detention without a hearing becomes long enough that the Constitution requires giving the detainee a hearing on flight risk and danger, and if so, whether the government must prove the need for continued detention by especially strong evidence. The Court also asked the parties to address whether G.M.'s case had become moot.

Where it stands

After the Court granted review and the case was briefed and argued, New York's governor granted G.M. a full pardon of the conviction underlying his case, eliminating the basis for his detention. The petitioners then filed a joint stipulation to dismiss, and the Court dismissed the case.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, asked the Court to reverse the lower court's ruling that detainees like G.M. are entitled to bond hearings after prolonged detention. Because the case was dismissed by the parties' joint agreement rather than decided, the Second Circuit's ruling in G.M.'s favor is not disturbed by this Court, but the dismissal also means the Supreme Court issued no decision on the legal questions presented, leaving the circuit disagreement over prolonged immigration detention unresolved by this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 21, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Genalo wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Carol Williams Black wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 89%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional test case on prolonged mandatory immigration detention — the question Jennings v. Rodriguez reserved — reaching thousands of 1226(c) detainees amid a large detention expansion, litigated by the Solicitor General against the ACLU with multi-state amicus participation.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 94%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case may set nationwide constitutional limits on prolonged mandatory immigration detention and bond-hearing remedies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifies the constitutionality of mandatory immigration detention under 1226(c) after Jennings.

Texas Top Cop Shop v. BlancheThe Court declined to hear a challenge by Texas Top Cop Shop and other businesses to a federal law requiring companies to report their owners' identities to the government.Business & financedecided
0.70
0.78
0.90
0.79

Texas Top Cop Shop, Incorporated, et al. v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General, et al.No. 25-1290 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73358839 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Business & finance (also Constitutional rights)

The Court declined to hear a challenge by Texas Top Cop Shop and other businesses to a federal law requiring companies to report their owners' identities to the government.

What happened

Congress passed the Corporate Transparency Act, requiring most corporations and similar entities to report information about their owners to a federal agency, with civil and criminal penalties for noncompliance. Texas Top Cop Shop and several other businesses and organizations sued, arguing the law was unconstitutional. A federal district court agreed and blocked the law, but the Supreme Court later stayed that injunction while the case continued. The federal appeals court put the case on hold pending further agency rulemaking. Meanwhile, a different appeals court, the Eleventh Circuit, upheld the same law in a separate case. Texas Top Cop Shop asked the Supreme Court to take its case directly, before the appeals court ruled, to resolve the disagreement between the courts.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether Congress had the constitutional power to require companies to report ownership information simply because they exist as legal entities, even without any business activity, and whether demanding this private information without individual suspicion or a warrant violates constitutional protections against unreasonable searches.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it, leaving the matter undecided at the Supreme Court level.

What each outcome would mean

Texas Top Cop Shop and the other businesses asked the Court to take up their case. Because the Court denied the petition, it will not review the constitutional questions now, and the lower courts' handling of the dispute continues without Supreme Court intervention. The denial does not mean the law is constitutional; it simply leaves the case as it stood, with the appeal still on hold at the Fifth Circuit and the law's requirements affected by ongoing federal rulemaking.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Commerce Clause and Fourth Amendment challenge to a statute that on its face reaches roughly 30 million state-chartered entities, with 25 states as amici; if decided on the merits it would be a major federalism ruling, though the August 2026 FinCEN final rule exempting domestic entities has shrunk the immediate practical stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern the constitutional limits of federal corporate-ownership reporting, with potentially broad effects on small entities and financial enforcement. State amici underscore the stakes, although the domestic-company exemption reduces immediate compliance urgency.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes constitutional challenge to the Corporate Transparency Act affecting millions of businesses.

Novotny v. MooreGun owners and gun rights groups ask the Court to strike down Maryland laws barring firearms in places like transit, parks, and bars.awaiting the Court
0.80
0.86
0.72
0.79

Katherine Novotny, et al. v. Wes Moore, Governor of Maryland, et al.scotus/73500225 · models differ by up to 0.14

Gun owners and gun rights groups ask the Court to strike down Maryland laws barring firearms in places like transit, parks, and bars.

What happened

Maryland expanded restrictions on carrying firearms in specific public locations, including mass transit, parks, healthcare facilities, places of amusement, and venues serving alcohol. Two groups of gun owners and gun rights organizations sued, arguing these restrictions violate the Second Amendment. A federal district court upheld most restrictions but struck down a rule requiring permission to carry on private property open to the public. A divided Fourth Circuit panel affirmed most of the restrictions, agreeing the private-property rule was unconstitutional but upholding nearly all the location-based bans, while one judge would have struck down most of them.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether laws banning firearm carrying in numerous places the public visits—transit, parks, healthcare facilities, entertainment venues, and places serving alcohol—are consistent with the right to keep and bear arms, given this nation's history of regulating firearms.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference multiple times, most recently for November 13, 2026, after full briefing including a response and reply; the docket does not yet show any action taken on it.

What each outcome would mean

Novotny and the other gun owners and organizations, who lost most of their challenge below, are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether Maryland's restrictions are constitutional, deciding nothing yet about who prevails. If it denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision upholding most of Maryland's restrictions stands, leaving those laws in effect, while the lower court's separate ruling striking down the private-property consent rule remains undisturbed either way.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Novotny's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Novotny's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of Bruen's 'sensitive places' carve-out is the largest open Second Amendment question after Wolford; a merits decision would govern every post-Bruen state carry-location statute. Scored on stakes if decided, not on grant odds.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling defining sensitive places could materially shape public firearm carry across transit, parks, healthcare, entertainment venues, and demonstrations nationwide; that significance is distinct from the probability of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifying the 'sensitive places' doctrine post-Bruen would have nationwide impact and receive heavy media coverage.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Gun owners ask the Supreme Court to strike down Maryland's bans on carrying guns in many public places, such as transit, parks, hospitals and stadiums. The Court discussed the case once and scheduled it for another conference, which signals real interest. We still think it more likely than not that the Court declines to hear it (roughly a one-in-three chance it takes the case or sends it back for another look under its recent Hawaii gun ruling). It will likely wait for other courts first, and a written dissent from some Justices is likely.

    Why this big-case score: Facial challenge to a comprehensive post-Bruen 'sensitive places' regime (transit, parks, health facilities, amusement venues, alcohol-serving places); the next major open Second Amendment question after Wolford.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to turn down this challenge to Maryland's restrictions on carrying guns in public places. I estimate a 44% chance it accepts the case or sends it back for reconsideration. The petition raises important disagreements, and the Court has returned it for another conference. But several earlier delays were scheduling changes, not repeated substantive consideration. A recent gun-rights decision concerns a different restriction, and the Court may prefer a narrower case before addressing Maryland's broad collection of rules.

    Why this big-case score: A merits ruling could define the constitutional limits on firearm bans across ordinary public destinations nationwide, well beyond Maryland.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely deny this petition for review, with about a one-in-five chance (22%) of agreeing to hear the case. The petitioners ask the Court to strike down Maryland laws banning concealed-carry permit holders from bringing firearms into nine types of public locations, including parks, mass transit, bars and restaurants serving alcohol, museums, health care facilities, school grounds, and government buildings. Although the Court held the petition across several preliminary conferences and relisted it once after its first conference—often a sign that a Justice is writing a dissent from the refusal to hear the case—every federal appeals court to decide these location bans has upheld them, and the Court recently turned away similar challenges from Hawaii and Illinois.

    Why this big-case score: Major facial Second Amendment challenge to nine categories of 'sensitive places' under Maryland's post-Bruen Gun Safety Act of 2023, testing whether 19th-century and Reconstruction-era laws can establish a historical tradition absent Founding-era analogues.

Oklahoma v. United StatesOklahoma and other states ask the Court to strike down a federal law that lets a private corporation help regulate horseracing, after a lower court upheld it.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.72
0.76
0.90
0.79

Oklahoma, et al. v. United States, et al.No. 25-1325 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500226 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Agencies & benefits

Oklahoma and other states ask the Court to strike down a federal law that lets a private corporation help regulate horseracing, after a lower court upheld it.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private nonprofit, to write and help enforce rules for thoroughbred racing, under oversight from the Federal Trade Commission. Oklahoma and other states, racing commissions, and horse-industry groups sued, arguing this setup hands government power to a private entity in violation of constitutional limits on delegating public authority. After back-and-forth through the courts, including a Supreme Court order sending the case back for another look following an unrelated ruling on private parties helping run federal programs, the Sixth Circuit again upheld the law, finding the FTC retains ultimate control over both rulemaking and enforcement. Oklahoma again asks the Supreme Court to intervene.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal law may give a private organization the power to propose rules that bind an entire industry and to investigate, charge, and sanction rule-breakers, when a federal agency reviews those actions only after they occur or takes effect. The petitioners say the private entity effectively controls policy and enforcement; the government and the private entity respond that the agency keeps final authority and the arrangement is constitutional.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for December 4, 2026, after an earlier conference date passed with the case rescheduled rather than acted on; the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case. The federal government's brief asks the Court to instead take up a related case from the Fifth Circuit and hold this petition pending that case's outcome.

What each outcome would mean

Oklahoma and the other states are asking the Court to take up their case and reverse the lower court's ruling, which upheld the law. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to hear the case and decide the constitutional question itself; a later decision could then affirm the law as written, reverse it, or send the case back without deciding. If the Court denies the petition, the Sixth Circuit's ruling upholding the law stands, leaving the Horseracing Authority's structure in place, at least in the states covered by that court. The government's filings suggest the Court could instead act on related petitions from a different appeals court and hold this case until that is resolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Oklahoma's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Oklahoma's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Facial constitutionality of a federal statute under the private nondelegation doctrine, with a square Fifth/Sixth Circuit split and the federal government petitioning; a significant separation-of-powers case, tempered by a single-industry regulatory subject.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 48%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The constitutional limits on private regulatory enforcement affect nationwide horseracing regulation and potentially other federally supervised private regulators, although this petition may remain a companion vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct constitutional challenge to a federal statute (HISA) raising a major private non-delegation question with a live circuit split.

Norfolk Southern Railway v. Robert Willmore MalloryNorfolk Southern asked the Court to decide whether Pennsylvania's jurisdiction law violates the Constitution's commerce protections; the Court denied review.Civil proceduredecided
0.70
0.82
0.85
0.79

Norfolk Southern Railway Company v. Robert Willmore Mallory, as Administrator of the Estate of Robert Thurston Mallory, et al.No. 25-1208 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281694 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Civil procedure

Norfolk Southern asked the Court to decide whether Pennsylvania's jurisdiction law violates the Constitution's commerce protections; the Court denied review.

What happened

Robert Mallory sued Norfolk Southern in Pennsylvania state court, claiming workplace chemical exposure caused his cancer, even though he worked in Virginia and Ohio and the railroad is not headquartered in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania courts had jurisdiction because Norfolk Southern registered to do business there. After this Court previously upheld that jurisdiction rule against a due-process challenge, the case returned to the trial court, where Norfolk Southern tried to raise a new constitutional argument about interstate commerce. The trial court ruled that Norfolk Southern had waited too long and waived that argument. Pennsylvania's appeals courts declined further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether Pennsylvania's law, which lets its courts hear lawsuits against any company registered to do business in the state even when the dispute has no connection to Pennsylvania, improperly burdens trade between states.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after briefing that included a waiver of response, a later response requested and filed, and amicus briefs. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Norfolk Southern, the company sued, asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the result below. By denying the petition, the Court left in place the lower courts' rulings, meaning the trial court's finding that Norfolk Southern waited too long to raise its interstate-commerce argument stands, and that argument was never decided on its merits. Mallory's estate, which had opposed review, keeps the benefit of that outcome, and the underlying lawsuit can continue in the Pennsylvania trial court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a constitutional limit on registration-based general jurisdiction would reshape where every national business can be sued; a sequel to a 5-4 decision, closely watched by the business and plaintiffs' bars, though not a culture-war case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The limits on registration-based general jurisdiction affect nationwide corporate litigation, forum selection, and interstate federalism, independently of whether this interlocutory vehicle obtains review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct sequel to the landmark 2023 Mallory decision, addressing a major constitutional question on the Dormant Commerce Clause and state jurisdiction.

National Republican Congressional Committee v. BrownRepublican campaign committees asked the Supreme Court to block an order forcing the FCC to rule on political ad rates; the Court denied it as moot.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.55
0.87
0.95
0.79

National Republican Congressional Committee, et al. v. Sherrod Brown, et al.No. 26A477 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000477 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Agencies & benefits

Republican campaign committees asked the Supreme Court to block an order forcing the FCC to rule on political ad rates; the Court denied it as moot.

What happened

The dispute concerns whether broadcasters must offer discounted "lowest unit charge" advertising rates to political parties and joint fundraising committees, not just individual candidates. Democratic candidates challenged an FCC public notice extending the discount, and the Fourth Circuit set it aside. The Supreme Court stayed that ruling in September, finding the Fourth Circuit likely lacked jurisdiction because the FCC had not yet ruled on the candidates' administrative appeal. The candidates then asked the Fourth Circuit to order the FCC to act, and it granted that request, ordering a decision by October 9. The Republican committees asked the Supreme Court to block that order too.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether it should pause, while appeals continue, a lower court order requiring a federal agency to issue a decision on a pending administrative appeal by a set deadline. The dispute underneath concerns whether the agency's order forcing quick action improperly overrode the Supreme Court's earlier stay and whether the agency had a clear legal duty to decide the matter on that timetable.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice referred the stay application to the full Court, which denied it as moot in a per curiam opinion. Justices Sotomayor and Jackson stated they would have denied the application (without reaching the mootness question).

What each outcome would mean

The National Republican Congressional Committee and National Republican Senatorial Committee, as applicants, sought to block the Fourth Circuit's order requiring the FCC to decide the candidates' pending appeal by a set deadline. The Court's denial, issued as moot, means it did not pause that order, but also did not rule on whether the Fourth Circuit was right to issue it. Because the case was declared moot rather than decided on the merits, the underlying dispute over the advertising rate rules was left unresolved by this ruling, and the practical effect for the parties depended on events that made the application moot rather than on who was right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 14, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-14: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 72%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Second emergency round over FCC lowest-unit-charge rules for party-coordinated ads weeks before the 2026 midterms, testing lower-court fidelity to a Supreme Court stay; real campaign-finance stakes, but a procedural (mandamus/jurisdiction) vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.81·Chance the Court grants the application: 84%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns broadcast-advertising costs for national party committees shortly before the 2026 midterms, plus the relationship between agency review, judicial mandamus, and a prior Supreme Court stay. Substantial electoral and institutional stakes, despite a narrow interim remedy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 88%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Emergency Supreme Court intervention in an election law dispute involving national party committees just weeks before the midterms.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-14: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 72%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Second emergency round over FCC lowest-unit-charge rules for party/candidate ad buys weeks before the 2026 midterms, with a lower court arguably acting against this Court's own stay; nationally consequential for campaign spending but a procedural (jurisdiction/mandamus) vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns political-advertising rates during the federal midterm election, potentially affecting campaign spending nationwide, and the relationship between agency review, appellate mandamus, and an earlier Supreme Court stay. The immediate question remains procedural.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itpossible leakfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes election law case directly impacting political party ad spending weeks before the 2026 midterms.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-14: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Election-eve dispute over broadcast lowest-unit-charge rates for party coordinated ads in the 2026 midterms, plus lower-court compliance with the Court's own stay order; high near-term political salience, but the legal question on the stay is procedural (mandamus/Hobbs Act jurisdiction).

  • CodexBig-case score 0.87·Chance the Court grants the application: 78%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The stay affects access to discounted broadcast advertising during the final weeks of a federal election and whether agency delay can forestall timely judicial review; its immediate political reach is substantial despite the narrow procedural question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 95%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes litigation involving national political parties, sitting candidates, and campaign finance rules immediately preceding the 2026 midterm elections.

Hall v. FlemingBethany Hall asks the Court to overrule a 2004 precedent that lets states exclude ministry-degree students from otherwise available tuition grants.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.72
0.84
0.78
0.78

Bethany M. Hall v. A. Scott Fleming, Director, Virginia State Counsel of Higher EducationNo. 26-193 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000193 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: First Amendment

Bethany Hall asks the Court to overrule a 2004 precedent that lets states exclude ministry-degree students from otherwise available tuition grants.

What happened

Bethany Hall, a Liberty University student, received a Virginia tuition grant but lost it after changing her major to ministry-related fields, which Virginia's grant program excludes from funding as "religious training or theological education." Hall sued the SCHEV director, arguing the exclusion violates her right to free exercise of religion. The district court dismissed her claim, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed, holding that Hall's case is squarely controlled by the Supreme Court's 2004 decision in Locke v. Davey, which upheld a similar Washington state scholarship restriction. A concurring Fourth Circuit judge agreed the lower courts were bound by Locke but wrote separately to argue the precedent was wrongly decided.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether it should overturn its own prior ruling that allows states to withhold general scholarship or grant funding from students specifically because they are pursuing degrees meant to train them for ministry, even while allowing that funding to be used at religious schools generally.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief in opposition, a reply, and numerous amicus briefs. It was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference and then rescheduled; the docket does not yet show any decision on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Hall, the student denied grant funding, is asking the Court to take up her case and overturn the lower court's ruling against her. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether to overrule the 2004 precedent, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fourth Circuit's ruling against Hall stands, leaving Virginia's exclusion of ministry-degree students from grant funding in place, along with similar laws in other states that rely on the same precedent.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Hall's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Hall's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will probably **not** take this case, but it is a serious contender: roughly a one-in-four chance (27%) that it agrees to hear it. Bethany Hall lost a Virginia tuition grant when she switched to a religious major. She asks the Court to overrule Locke v. Davey, a 2004 decision allowing states to refuse to fund religious-ministry degrees. Twenty-two states and many groups back her. The Court has narrowed Locke before but has been reluctant to discard it outright.

    Why this big-case score: A grant would put overruling Locke v. Davey squarely before the Court, reshaping how dozens of state aid programs treat religious study; 22 States and 13 other amicus filings signal broad stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.84·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down Bethany Hall's appeal than hear it, although I put her chance of obtaining review at about two in five. She asks the Court to overturn a ruling allowing states to withhold college aid for training religious ministers. Her case presents that issue directly and has substantial outside support. But the Court has preserved this exception in later decisions. Because the first conference setting was rescheduled, another calendar listing is very likely before a decision.

    Why this big-case score: A direct request to overrule Locke v. Davey could change nationwide constitutional rules for religious vocational education funding; fourteen petition-stage amicus briefs show substantial institutional interest.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to hear this appeal, with a one-in-four (25%) chance of granting review and a three-in-four (75%) chance of denying it. Although the case raises a high-profile religious freedom question—whether States may exclude college students majoring in theology or ministry from general tuition grants, asking the Court to overturn its 2004 decision in *Locke v. Davey*—lower federal courts are not divided on the issue. Moreover, the student bringing this case has already graduated and did not appeal the dismissal of her claims for past money damages, while a companion case brought by current students is scheduled for argument in the lower appellate court in January 2027, giving the Justices strong reason to wait for a cleaner case.

    Why this big-case score: Direct challenge asking the Court to overrule Locke v. Davey (2004) on whether States may exclude devotional theology/ministry majors from generally available college tuition grants after Trinity Lutheran, Espinoza, and Carson.

Mendenhall v. City and County of DenverThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Denver man's bid to overturn decades-old precedent letting police use secondhand information to get search warrants.Criminal lawdecided
0.70
0.78
0.85
0.78

Michael Mendenhall v. City and County of Denver, ColoradoNo. 25-1205 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281687 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Denver man's bid to overturn decades-old precedent letting police use secondhand information to get search warrants.

What happened

Police responded when a man reported being threatened outside Michael Mendenhall's home. An officer relayed the accuser's account to a detective, who wrote a sworn warrant affidavit based entirely on that secondhand information, without speaking to the accuser himself. A judge issued the warrant, and officers seized a baseball bat from Mendenhall's home; charges against Mendenhall were later dropped. Mendenhall sued Denver, arguing the warrant violated the Fourth Amendment because it relied on hearsay rather than firsthand testimony. The district court and the Tenth Circuit both ruled against him, citing a 1960 Supreme Court decision, Jones v. United States, that allows warrants based on reliable hearsay.

What the Court is being asked

Mendenhall's petition asks the Court to overturn its own 1960 ruling and hold that the Fourth Amendment's requirement that warrants be backed by a sworn "oath or affirmation" means only someone with firsthand knowledge of the facts can supply the information, not an officer repeating what someone else said. Denver answers that the existing rule is well established, consistent with the Constitution's text, and workable, and that Mendenhall's case is a poor vehicle for revisiting it.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court asked Denver to respond before the second conference. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Mendenhall asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Tenth Circuit's ruling against him. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Tenth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Jones remains good law and Mendenhall's lawsuit against Denver does not go forward on this claim. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning or with Denver's position; it simply leaves that ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided on the merits, a ruling on whether the Warrant Clause's oath requires a firsthand witness would reshape warrant practice nationwide; the stakes are high whichever way it came out.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Requiring firsthand sworn evidence for warrants would substantially reshape nationwide police and magistrate practice and constitutional protections for home searches; those stakes are high despite low grant odds.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Overruling Jones and requiring firsthand knowledge for search warrants would upend standard police practice nationwide.

International Partners for Ethical Care v. FergusonThe Supreme Court reviewed whether parents challenging Washington laws on runaway youth seeking gender-related care have standing to sue, after the Ninth Circuit found they did not.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.72
0.82
0.78
0.77

International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc., et al. v. Bob Ferguson, Governor of Washington, et al.No. 25-840 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280341 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court reviewed whether parents challenging Washington laws on runaway youth seeking gender-related care have standing to sue, after the Ninth Circuit found they did not.

What happened

Washington amended its laws so that when a runaway minor seeks certain health services at a licensed shelter, the shelter notifies the state child welfare agency instead of the parents directly; the agency must then try to notify parents, offer family reconciliation services, and offer referrals for behavioral health services. A group of parents and two organizations sued, arguing the laws unconstitutionally interfered with their parental rights, free speech, and religious exercise. They did not allege that any of their children had actually used these provisions, instead describing fears that this might someday happen. The district court dismissed the case for lack of standing, finding the harms too speculative, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether parents can sue over a law that changes who is notified and how a state handles runaway children seeking certain services, based on their worry that the law might someday affect their own family, or whether they must instead show a more concrete and immediate injury before they can bring such a challenge.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, received full briefing including from the federal government as amicus supporting the parents, and heard oral argument on December 7, 2026. The case now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

The parents and organizations who petitioned are asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling that they lacked standing. If the Court affirms, the lower court's dismissal stands, and these parents' lawsuit ends without any ruling on the underlying constitutional claims. If the Court reverses, the case would return to the lower courts, where the parents could continue pursuing their claims that the laws violate their constitutional rights. A ruling vacating the decision would send the case back without resolving the standing question in either side's favor.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 7, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: International Partners for Ethical Care wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Ferguson wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Parental rights meet youth gender-transition policy in a nationally watched culture-war posture; even a standing-only holding will shape dozens of pending parental-rights challenges and draw heavy coverage.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case links Article III standing to parental authority over minors' gender-transition care and is likely to shape challenges to similar laws nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    This case addresses the highly salient culture-war issue of transgender minors and parental rights, touching on both fundamental liberty interests and Article III standing doctrine.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Prediction: the Supreme Court will most likely (about a 70% chance) overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling and hold that these parents may sue in federal court ("have standing") to challenge Washington's laws on runaway minors seeking gender-related services. We expect a 6–3 vote along familiar lines, with the case sent back to the lower court rather than a ruling on whether the laws are constitutional. The main risks: the Court finds the parents' feared harm too speculative, or dismisses the case because most of the children are turning 18.

    Why this big-case score: Sets the Article III threshold for parental-rights challenges to state gender-identity policies, a heavily litigated and closely watched area; the holding is jurisdictional, not a merits ruling on the Washington laws.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 73%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to reverse the lower court's dismissal by six votes to three. There is about a three-in-four chance—73%—that it will overturn or otherwise undo that judgment. The likely reason is that the remaining parents have plausibly described a current loss of involvement in their child's care, giving them standing, meaning permission to sue in federal court. That would let their challenge proceed, not decide whether Washington's laws are constitutional. Speculative harm and concerns about whether claims remain live could still defeat the case.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally consequential access-to-court question at the intersection of parental authority, transgender minors' care, and Article III, although the judgment need not decide the laws' constitutionality.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (88% chance) to disturb the Ninth Circuit's decision and reverse the dismissal of this lawsuit, most likely by a 6–3 vote. The case asks whether Washington parents of children experiencing gender dysphoria have "standing"—the legal right to sue in federal court—to challenge a state law that withholds the usual 72-hour parental notice when a runaway child enters a youth shelter seeking gender-transition care or counseling. Because at least one family's child has already run away over gender-identity conflicts and other families have altered their parenting to prevent their children from leaving home, a majority will hold that the parents face a realistic risk of harm and may pursue their constitutional claims in court.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile intersection of Article III pre-enforcement standing doctrine and parental constitutional rights over minor children's gender-transition care and runaway-shelter notification, drawing United States merits participation and roughly thirty amicus briefs, though limited at this stage to threshold federal jurisdiction rather than the ultimate First and Fourteenth Amendment merits.

U.S. DOGE Service v. United States District CourtThe government asks the Court to block discovery into whether USDS, an entity that advised the President, must comply with public records requests.Agencies & benefitspartly decided
0.60
0.82
0.90
0.77

U.S. DOGE Service, et al. v. United States District Court for the District of Columbia, et al.No. 25-1103 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281386 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The government asks the Court to block discovery into whether USDS, an entity that advised the President, must comply with public records requests.

What happened

Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) filed a Freedom of Information Act request with the U.S. DOGE Service (USDS), which the government said was not covered by the law. A district court allowed limited discovery to determine whether USDS exercised independent authority rather than merely advising the President. The government sought mandamus (an order blocking the discovery) in the D.C. Circuit, which was denied. The Supreme Court earlier stepped in, narrowing part of that discovery and sending the case back. On remand, CREW withdrew some requests, and the D.C. Circuit again denied mandamus as to the rest. The government then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the appeals court properly followed the Supreme Court's earlier instructions and respected separation-of-powers limits when it let most of the discovery go forward. The Court is also asked whether courts may ever order discovery into an executive office entity's operations to figure out if it counts as covered by the public records law, or whether that determination must rest solely on formal legal authority.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the petition on October 13, 2026. The parties are now preparing merits briefs, with deadlines extended into December 2026 and January 2027.

What each outcome would mean

USDS and other government petitioners are asking the Court to overturn the lower court's decision allowing the discovery to proceed. If the Court sides with the government, it would block or sharply limit the discovery into USDS's structure and operations, including a deposition of its administrator, and would narrow when such discovery is allowed in future disputes over whether an entity counts as covered by the public records law. If the Court sides with CREW, the discovery could proceed, and the case would continue toward resolving whether USDS must respond to CREW's records request. A ruling sending the case back without deciding it would leave these questions for further proceedings below.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseOct 13, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The U.S. DOGE Service wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The United States District Court wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Separation-of-powers limits on discovery against Executive Office advisory bodies, and whether FOIA reaches DOGE; a discovery-posture dispute, but one the Court has already intervened in once and that governs future FOIA suits against presidential advisers.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Discovery into a presidential advisory body's independent authority implicates executive confidentiality, FOIA accountability, and oversight of government-wide DOGE activity; the immediate dispute is narrower than a final ruling on FOIA coverage.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile separation of powers dispute involving the Executive Office of the President and Elon Musk, concerning FOIA discovery.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Executive-privilege / separation-of-powers limits on discovery against an EOP advisory body, and the FOIA 'agency' test for presidential units; high-profile entity (DOGE), but the posture is an interlocutory mandamus over discovery scope, not a FOIA merits ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute concerns public access to DOGE records and judicial discovery into presidential advisory bodies. Its separation-of-powers and FOIA implications reach beyond these litigants, although the immediate judgment concerns discovery and mandamus rather than a final ruling on disclosure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes separation of powers case involving a prominent new Executive Office advisory body (DOGE) and FOIA.

N. R. v. EllisonFormer foster parents asked the Court to revive their challenge to Indian child-welfare laws after being denied a role in the children's case; the Court declined.Sovereignty & foreign relationsdecided
0.65
0.80
0.85
0.77

N. R., et al. v. Keith M. Ellison, Attorney General of Minnesota, et al.No. 25-1287 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73351824 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

Former foster parents asked the Court to revive their challenge to Indian child-welfare laws after being denied a role in the children's case; the Court declined.

What happened

Nathan and Kellie Reyelts served as foster parents to twins who qualified as Indian children under federal and state law. After more than a year, county officials moved the children to a relative identified by the Red Lake Nation. The Reyeltses sought to intervene in the children's case, seeking custody and arguing that the federal Indian Child Welfare Act and Minnesota's parallel law unconstitutionally treat Indian children differently from other children. The trial court denied intervention, in part because they raised that constitutional argument, and the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed, declining to reach the constitutional question.

What the Court is being asked

The case asked the Court to decide two things: whether laws giving different child-welfare protections to children eligible for tribal membership deny equal protection to those children and to non-Indian adults seeking to care for them, and whether it violates free-speech and petition rights for a court to deny someone a role in a child's case specifically because that person argued those laws are unconstitutional.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after briefing that included a request for a response and an extension of time for the respondents to reply. The Supreme Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Reyeltses, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case and reverse the Minnesota Supreme Court's decision. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that decision in place: the Reyeltses' exclusion from the children's case stands, and the constitutional questions about ICWA and MIFPA go unaddressed by the Court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Minnesota courts' reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question (whether ICWA/MIFPA's Indian-child classification and placement preferences violate equal protection, left open in Brackeen) is nationally significant; the posture, a permissive-intervention denial affirmed on state-law grounds, would most likely yield a narrow procedural ruling if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision reaching the equal-protection challenge could materially affect federal and state Indian-child-welfare placement rules nationally; the intervention and retaliation issues offer a narrower route with lower systemic stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes equal protection challenge to ICWA, directly following up on an unresolved issue in Haaland v. Brackeen.

FTC v. National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective AssociationThe federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that a private horseracing regulator's enforcement powers are unconstitutional.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.72
0.80
0.78
0.77

Federal Trade Commission, et al. v. National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, et al.No. 26-201 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000201 · models differ by up to 0.08 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that a private horseracing regulator's enforcement powers are unconstitutional.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private corporation, to write and enforce nationwide safety and anti-doping rules for thoroughbred racing, under oversight from the Federal Trade Commission. The National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association and others sued, arguing the arrangement hands government power to a private entity. After earlier rounds of litigation and a congressional amendment, the Fifth Circuit ruled that the Authority's rulemaking role is now constitutional but that its enforcement powers—investigating, subpoenaing, searching, fining, and suing covered persons—are not, because the FTC's oversight comes too late and too narrowly. The FTC and the Authority separately petitioned for review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law can let a private organization investigate, prosecute, and penalize rule violations in an industry it regulates, with only limited, after-the-fact review by a federal agency, or whether that arrangement gives away government enforcement power that the Constitution requires federal officials to control.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of December 4, 2026, after full briefing including responses from multiple respondents and a reply from the government; the docket shows no action since that distribution.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling that struck down the enforcement provisions, a ruling the horsemen's groups and other respondents won below. If the Court grants review, it will decide the enforcement question on the merits; a decision to affirm would leave the private Authority unable to enforce rules without more FTC control, while reversing would let the current enforcement scheme stand. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision against the enforcement provisions remains in effect for this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up the FTC's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The FTC's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Facial constitutionality of a federal statute under the private nondelegation doctrine, with direct implications for every self-regulatory-organization scheme (securities SROs, HISA) and an entire national industry's regulator.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define constitutional limits on private entities exercising federal enforcement power and determine the operation of a nationwide regulatory regime.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the constitutionality of a major federal statute (HISA) and the private nondelegation doctrine, with a clear circuit split.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 93%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about 93%) agree to hear this case. The federal government is asking the Court to review a Fifth Circuit ruling that struck down how the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act is enforced, finding that it gives a private body too much government power. Another appeals court has upheld the law, and every party, including the law's challengers, agrees the Supreme Court should take the case. The main risk is that the Court picks a companion case as its vehicle instead.

    Why this big-case score: A federal statute's enforcement scheme held facially unconstitutional under the private nondelegation doctrine; a doctrinal vehicle with reach beyond horseracing, though the regulated industry itself is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 96%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to hear this case: I estimate a 96% chance of review. A federal appeals court struck down the national horse-racing law's enforcement provisions, while another appeals court upheld them. The federal government and the challengers agree the Supreme Court should resolve that disagreement. I expect full briefing and argument, probably after one additional conference consideration. The main uncertainty is which related petition the Court chooses to lead the review, not whether the constitutional issue deserves attention.

    Why this big-case score: The validity of nationwide horseracing enforcement is at stake, with broader implications for private regulatory bodies and federal supervision of delegated enforcement powers.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 94%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to grant review (94% probability). The Fifth Circuit struck down the enforcement provisions of a federal statute—the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act—on the ground that Congress unconstitutionally gave federal law-enforcement power to a private organization without enough oversight by the Federal Trade Commission. Because that ruling invalidates an Act of Congress, directly conflicts with a Sixth Circuit decision upholding the same law, and all sides agree the Supreme Court should step in, the Court will almost certainly hear the case.

    Why this big-case score: Major separation-of-powers test of the private nondelegation doctrine after FCC v. Consumers' Research, determining the facial validity of a federal regulatory regime (HISA) and carrying broad implications for self-regulatory organizations like FINRA.

Anibowei v. BlancheAn immigration attorney asks the Court to decide whether border agents may search a traveler's cell phone without a warrant.awaiting the Court
0.80
0.82
0.68
0.77

George Anibowei v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General, et al.No. 26-208 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000208 · models differ by up to 0.14

An immigration attorney asks the Court to decide whether border agents may search a traveler's cell phone without a warrant.

What happened

George Anibowei, a naturalized citizen and immigration lawyer, had his phone seized and copied by border agents in 2016 without a warrant, and agents searched it four more times since. He sued, eventually pursuing only a claim that government directives allowing these searches violate the Constitution. The district court dismissed the claim, reasoning Anibowei had an adequate alternative remedy and, alternatively, that circuit precedent permits such searches. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, holding its prior decisions foreclosed Anibowei's argument that a warrant is required.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Fourth Amendment's usual warrant requirement applies when border agents want to examine the data stored on a traveler's cell phone, or whether the traditional rule allowing warrantless searches at the border extends to a phone's digital contents.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference; the federal government waived its right to respond, but the Court then asked for a response, due November 30, 2026 after an extension. Numerous amicus briefs have been filed supporting Anibowei.

What each outcome would mean

Anibowei, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it will decide the warrant question itself, deciding nothing in advance for either side. If it denies review, the Fifth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving in place the rule that border agents in that circuit may search phones without a warrant, and Anibowei's challenge to the directives fails.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 29, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 30, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Anibowei's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Anibowei's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down (deny) George Anibowei's request to hear his case, which asks whether border agents need a warrant before searching a traveler's cell phone. We put the chance the Court takes the case at about one in eight. The question is important, and lower courts disagree about it. The Court has also asked the government to respond. But the Court has passed on this same question several times before, including when the government itself asked.

    Why this big-case score: Whether border agents need a warrant to search travelers' phones governs searches of hundreds of millions of travelers; a grant would be one of the Term's major Fourth Amendment cases.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down George Anibowei's challenge to warrantless searches of phones at the border. I give it about a one-in-four chance of taking the case. The privacy issue is important, ten outside briefs have been filed, and the Court requested a government response. Still, courts agree on some search rules, and the Supreme Court has previously declined related disputes. A refusal to hear this case would leave the lower court's ruling standing without approving its reasoning.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling could set nationwide constitutional limits on searches of travelers' digital devices, including privileged legal communications; the snapshot records ten amicus briefs from varied constituencies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the Fourth Amendment border-search exception permits warrantless searches of travelers' cell phones (extending Riley v. California to the border) is a major, recurring constitutional question affecting tens of thousands of travelers annually.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision would set the Fourth Amendment rule for warrantless phone searches of hundreds of millions of border crossers (about 55,000 CBP device searches a year), resolving an acknowledged eight-circuit conflict the Solicitor General itself once called entrenched and important; a leading Fourth Amendment case of its Term if decided, though not a blockbuster of the presidential-power or abortion class.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on digital border searches could materially affect nationwide traveler privacy, federal inspection practices, and confidential attorney-client and journalistic information. Those stakes are substantial independently of the likelihood of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Addresses the major unresolved Fourth Amendment question of whether Riley applies to digital border searches, subject to a deep circuit split.

Havlish v. TalibanFamilies of terrorism victims and insurers ask the Court to let them seize blocked Afghan central bank funds to satisfy judgments against the Taliban.awaiting the Court
0.70
0.82
0.78
0.77

Fiona Havlish, et al. v. The Taliban, et al.No. 26-292 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000292 · models differ by up to 0.12

Families of terrorism victims and insurers ask the Court to let them seize blocked Afghan central bank funds to satisfy judgments against the Taliban.

What happened

Petitioners are families of victims of the September 11 attacks and other terrorist acts, plus insurers that paid billions in 9/11-related claims, who together hold large court judgments against the Taliban. They sought to collect by reaching roughly $3.5 billion in blocked funds, held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, belonging to Afghanistan's central bank, which the Taliban now controls. The district court denied their turnover requests, and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, ruling that the funds could be seized only if the bank already counted as a Taliban-controlled entity at the moment the funds were first blocked by the government, not later when the Taliban actually took over the bank. The full Second Circuit declined to rehear the case, over dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide, under the federal law letting terrorism victims collect judgments from a terrorist group's blocked assets, whether a plaintiff can reach assets that came under the terrorist group's control only after the assets were originally blocked, or whether the law applies only to assets already connected to the terrorist group at that earlier blocking date.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and then distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026; the docket does not show any action taken at that conference. Petitioners later filed a motion for leave to submit a supplemental brief, and the case was distributed again for a conference on November 13, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The families and insurers, as petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Second Circuit's ruling, which left the lower court's denial of turnover in place. If the Court grants review and later rules for petitioners, they could proceed to seize the blocked funds to satisfy their judgments against the Taliban. If it rules for the Taliban and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the funds would remain beyond petitioners' reach under the lower court's timing rule. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, leaving the funds protected from execution under that rule.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Havlish's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Havlish's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Families of 9/11 victims ask the Supreme Court to let them collect court judgments against the Taliban out of about $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank money. A federal appeals court said no, over strong dissents. I think the Court will most likely refuse to hear the case, giving it about a one-in-five chance of agreeing. The question matters and has strong backing from 31 states. But nobody has appeared to argue the other side, and the Court may first ask the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: About $3.5B in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves, thousands of 9/11 and other terrorism victims, and a TRIA timing rule that matters for every blocked-asset fight; foreign-affairs overlay.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.83·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this appeal, although I give it a 40% chance of taking the case. Terrorism victims seek access to $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank funds. The dispute asks whether the bank had to be controlled by the Taliban when the funds were frozen. Strong judicial disagreement and the Court's decision to consider the petition a second time make review plausible, but the unusual foreign-government setting and an imperfect conflict among appeals courts favor denial.

    Why this big-case score: Execution against $3.5 billion in Afghan central-bank assets implicates terrorism victims, sovereign immunity, sanctions, and executive foreign-relations authority, although the presented question is a narrow statutory timing issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will deny the petition for a writ of certiorari (a request that the Court review the lower court's ruling), with about a one-in-five chance (22% probability) of a grant. Although the case involves $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves sought by September 11 terrorism victims and divided the appeals court, reviewing it would force the Court into sensitive presidential foreign-recognition questions where the United States opposes turning over the funds and no opposing party has appeared to defend the judgment.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes foreign-relations and terrorism-judgment dispute over $3.5 billion in blocked Afghan central bank reserves and the scope of TRIA execution after a regime takeover.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Families of 9/11 victims and other terrorism victims are asking the Supreme Court to let them collect court judgments from billions of dollars of frozen Afghan central-bank money. The lower court said the money was off-limits because the Taliban took over the bank only after the U.S. froze it. We think the Court will more likely than not decline to hear the case. Still, there is a substantial chance it agrees, about one in three. The judges below were sharply divided, many States support the families, and the Court has already held the case over for a second conference. A likely next step is asking the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: 9/11 and terrorism-victim judgments (~$17B) against roughly $3.5B of blocked Afghan central-bank assets; touches TRIA, FSIA and the Executive's recognition power; 31 States as amici.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 34%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than to hear it: I estimate a 34% chance of review, about one in three. Families of terrorism victims seek access to billions in frozen Afghan bank funds. Their petition raises a serious disagreement about when those funds become available to satisfy judgments, and the Court has already postponed its decision once. But disputes about sovereign immunity and Afghanistan's legal status complicate the case. The Court may first ask the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: The dispute concerns approximately $3.5 billion in Afghan central-bank assets, compensation for terrorism victims, and the intersection of sanctions, sovereign immunity, and executive recognition authority. Its financial and diplomatic stakes are unusually high despite a technically narrow statutory question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny the petition for review, with about a one-in-eight chance (13%) of granting the case. Victims of the September 11 attacks seek $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank funds to satisfy judgments against the Taliban, challenging a lower-court ruling that the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act applies only if the Taliban controlled the bank on the exact day the funds were frozen. Despite strong lower-court dissents, no conflicting appellate rulings exist, and the recent one-week delay likely reflects a late procedural motion rather than an upcoming grant.

    Why this big-case score: Roughly $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves sought by thousands of 9/11 victims, implicating the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act, foreign central-bank immunity, and the President's constitutional recognition power.

Thornell v. JensenArizona prison officials asked the Supreme Court to pause a court order putting a private receiver in charge of prison healthcare; the application was denied.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.55
0.80
0.95
0.77

Ryan Thornell, et al. v. Shawn Jensen, et al.No. 26A370 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000370 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Constitutional rights

Arizona prison officials asked the Supreme Court to pause a court order putting a private receiver in charge of prison healthcare; the application was denied.

What happened

In a long-running lawsuit over healthcare in Arizona's prisons, a federal district court found constitutional violations and issued a detailed injunction in 2023 requiring reforms. After finding continued noncompliance, the court ordered the prison healthcare system placed into receivership, stripping the Department's director of authority over healthcare and transferring it to a court-appointed receiver for at least five years. The Department appealed to the Ninth Circuit and asked both that court and the district court to pause the receivership while the appeal proceeds. Both courts refused, with one Ninth Circuit judge dissenting. The Department then asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

The application asks whether the receivership order should be paused while the Department's appeal moves forward, on the grounds that a receivership is supposed to be used only as a last resort and the district court allegedly skipped less drastic options and did not adequately weigh the Department's progress. The underlying appeal separately raises whether courts have authority to impose this kind of receivership on a state prison system at all.

Where it stands

Justice Kagan requested a response from the respondents, received their opposition and the Department's reply, and then denied the stay application on October 1, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Department, which runs Arizona's prisons, asked the Court to pause the receivership. Granting the pause would have kept healthcare authority with the Department while its appeal continued. Denying it, which is what happened, allows the receivership to take effect and the receiver to assume control of prison healthcare operations while the Department's appeal proceeds in the Ninth Circuit, where the underlying dispute over the receivership's validity remains unresolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 1, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 1, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal court placing a State's entire prison healthcare system under a private receiver over the State's objection, with a PLRA least-intrusive-means challenge and a CASA-flavored equitable-authority question, is a live federalism controversy that prison-reform and state-sovereignty communities watch closely; it is not a headline case for the general public and is tied to one State's record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court grants the application: 62%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns control of healthcare for roughly 25,000 Arizona prisoners and a minimum five-year receivership, with potential implications for federal remedies against state institutions; those stakes are distinct from the probability of a stay.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 65%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal receivership over an entire state prison healthcare system is a massive structural intervention implicating significant federalism and PLRA concerns.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 20%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal court placing an entire state prison health system (about 25,000 inmates, nine complexes) under a private receiver over the State's objection is a major federalism and PLRA remedial-authority question, argued by Paul Clement; stakes are high for Arizona and for institutional-reform litigation generally, but the dispute is single-system and fact-bound rather than nationally structural.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.77·Chance the Court grants the application: 60%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns transfer of Arizona's prison healthcare system, serving more than 25,000 inmates, to a court-appointed receiver. It combines immediate health and safety stakes with substantial state-budget, federalism, and structural-remedy questions; the requested ruling remains interlocutory.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 65%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application challenges a district court's authority to impose a private receivership over a state prison system, presenting a significant federalism and equitable authority dispute under Trump v. CASA.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal receivership displacing a State's control of health care for roughly 25,000 prisoners, litigated by a former Solicitor General on federalism, PLRA and CASA grounds; regionally very large and a bellwether for institutional-reform remedies, though the legal question is fact-bound and the docket entry will be a short order.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 58%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Control of healthcare for roughly 25,000 Arizona prisoners, protection against continuing constitutional injury, and the limits of federal receiverships over state institutions give this application substantial systemic stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 85%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly visible and consequential case regarding state control of prison healthcare and the limits of the Prison Litigation Reform Act.

A. A. v. MastThe Supreme Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive their challenge to a Virginia adoption order that transferred a child they had raised in Afghanistan to another family.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.70
0.72
0.85
0.76

A. A., et al. v. Joshua Mast, et al.No. 26-164 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000164 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive their challenge to a Virginia adoption order that transferred a child they had raised in Afghanistan to another family.

What happened

A.A. and F.A. say they were raising a young girl, orphaned in Afghanistan, as kin and caretakers when a Virginia court granted Joshua and Stephanie Mast's petition to adopt her, without notifying A.A. and F.A. After the child came to the United States with them in 2021, the Masts took custody based on that adoption order. A.A. and F.A. then sued in Virginia courts to undo the adoption, citing fraud and lack of notice. A trial court and the Virginia Court of Appeals sided with them on state-law grounds, but the Supreme Court of Virginia reversed, ruling the challenge was barred by a six-month state filing deadline and that A.A. and F.A. had no constitutional right to notice because they were not the child's legal parents.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether, and under what circumstances, people who are not a child's legal parents but who have cared for the child have a constitutional right to be notified and heard before a court issues an adoption order that permanently removes the child from their care. The Masts countered that A.A. and F.A. had not properly raised this specific argument in the Virginia courts and that the Virginia Supreme Court's decision rested on an independent state-law waiver finding the U.S. Supreme Court could not review.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference more than once, drew responses and multiple amicus briefs, and on October 19, 2026, the Supreme Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

A.A. and F.A., as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case and overturn the Virginia Supreme Court's ruling against them. Denial leaves that ruling in place, meaning the Virginia Supreme Court's decision rejecting A.A. and F.A.'s challenge stands, and the adoption order giving the Masts legal custody of the child remains valid. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Virginia court's reasoning; it simply ends the case without a ruling on the constitutional question A.A. and F.A. raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 29%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision on whether nonparent caretakers hold a procedural-due-process liberty interest before an adoption is entered would reach kinship and foster placements nationwide, and the underlying Afghan-orphan dispute has drawn sustained national and international press; the stakes are high whether the petition is granted or denied.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of procedural protection for nonparent caregivers has substantial family-law consequences. An Afghan child's contested adoption also implicates cross-border guardianship and US military and diplomatic interests; these stakes are distinct from this petition's vehicle problems.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile international adoption dispute involving an Afghan war orphan, allegations of fraud by U.S. Marines, and significant amicus interest (6 cert-stage briefs).

Saadeh v. New Jersey State Bar AssociationA bar association member asks the Court to review a ruling that the First Amendment shields the association's leadership-selection process from his discrimination claim.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.72
0.74
0.80
0.75

Rajeh A. Saadeh v. New Jersey State Bar AssociationNo. 25-1002 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281042 · models differ by up to 0.08 · topic: First Amendment

A bar association member asks the Court to review a ruling that the First Amendment shields the association's leadership-selection process from his discrimination claim.

What happened

Rajeh Saadeh, a longtime member of the New Jersey State Bar Association, sued the association, arguing that its practice of reserving certain board and committee seats for members of specific demographic groups violated New Jersey's antidiscrimination law. A trial court agreed and ruled for Saadeh. On appeal, New Jersey's intermediate appellate court reversed, in an unpublished opinion, without deciding the state-law question. It held instead that the First Amendment's protection of expressive association shields the association's selection process, relying on a Supreme Court precedent about a private group's right to choose its own members and leaders. New Jersey's Supreme Court declined further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the First Amendment protects an organization's discriminatory practices from an antidiscrimination law when the organization says the practices express its commitment to diversity, equity, or inclusion. The association responds that Saadeh lacks the standing needed to sue in federal court, that there is no disagreement among lower courts requiring the Court's attention, that the case is a poor vehicle for deciding the issue because the challenged policy has since changed and the state-law question remains undecided, and that the lower court's ruling was correct.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, and the respondent filed a brief opposing review along with several amicus briefs on both sides. Most recently, the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the federal government's views on the case.

What each outcome would mean

Saadeh, who sued the association, is asking the Court to take up and reverse the lower court's decision. If the Court grants review and ultimately rules for Saadeh, the First Amendment ruling below would be overturned, and the case would likely return to lower courts to resolve the unanswered state-law discrimination claim. If the Court denies review, the New Jersey appellate court's decision favoring the association stands, leaving its selection process shielded from Saadeh's challenge. The Solicitor General's forthcoming views do not themselves decide the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Saadeh's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Saadeh's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the First Amendment shields DEI programs from antidiscrimination law is the successor question to SFFA and 303 Creative; 18 states and major advocacy groups are already engaged, and a merits ruling would reach universities, the ABA, and private DEI programs nationwide.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.83·Chance the Court takes the case: 39%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could reshape how antidiscrimination law applies to private organizations' diversity-conscious membership and leadership choices.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 75%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile clash between antidiscrimination law and First Amendment expressive association, testing the legality of DEI quotas post-SFFA.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether Dale-style expressive association shields race- and sex-conscious DEI selection from antidiscrimination law would reach private universities, bar groups, and corporate programs nationwide; eighteen States and the leading anti-DEI litigants are already amici.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between expressive association and antidiscrimination law could affect private associations and diversity programs well beyond this voluntary bar's leadership seats. National amicus participation supports substantial stakes, although the particular policy and vehicle could limit the decision's reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Michael James Jackson v. FloridaA death-row prisoner asks the Court to decide whether the Constitution requires a jury's death recommendation to be unanimous rather than by an 8-4 vote.awaiting the Court
0.70
0.82
0.72
0.75

Michael James Jackson v. FloridaNo. 26-76 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000076 · models differ by up to 0.12

A death-row prisoner asks the Court to decide whether the Constitution requires a jury's death recommendation to be unanimous rather than by an 8-4 vote.

What happened

Michael James Jackson was convicted of murdering an elderly couple in 2005 and sentenced to death after a jury recommended death by an 8-4 vote. His sentence was later vacated, and at his 2023 resentencing a new jury again recommended death by 8-4, this time under a revised Florida law allowing judges to impose death based on only eight of twelve jurors agreeing, rather than requiring unanimity. The Florida Supreme Court affirmed the new death sentences, rejecting Jackson's argument that nonunanimous recommendations are unconstitutional, and denied rehearing. Jackson now asks the United States Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution's jury-trial and cruel-and-unusual-punishment protections require that a jury's recommendation of a death sentence be unanimous, or whether a state may impose death based on a lesser supermajority of jurors, as Florida's law allows.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief in opposition and a reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. The docket shows the case was then rescheduled, with no record yet of the Court's action on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Jackson, the death-row prisoner, is asking the Court to take up his case and overturn the Florida Supreme Court's ruling upholding his death sentence. If the Court grants review, it would hear full briefing and arguments on whether nonunanimous jury death recommendations are constitutional, deciding the question for Jackson and potentially other capital defendants in Florida and Alabama, which have similar laws. If the Court denies review, the Florida Supreme Court's decision stands, leaving Jackson's death sentence in place and Florida's nonunanimous-recommendation law intact for now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Michael James Jackson's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Michael James Jackson's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely refuse to hear this case (about a one-in-six chance it agrees). The case asks whether Florida can impose a death sentence when only 8 of 12 jurors recommend it. The Court postponed its first look at the case, apparently to consider it alongside a nearly identical Florida case. That suggests real attention. But no live disagreement exists among state courts, and the Court has turned away similar challenges before. A written dissent from the refusal is quite possible.

    Why this big-case score: Whether the Sixth/Eighth Amendment requires a unanimous jury death recommendation; Florida's 8-4 rule governs one of the nation's most active death-penalty states.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down Michael James Jackson's appeal than to hear it: I put the chance of review at 24%, about one in four. He challenges Florida's rule allowing a death sentence when only eight of twelve jurors support it. The issue is important and clearly presented, but earlier decisions distinguish finding facts that permit death from choosing that punishment. The Court will probably put the petition back on its conference calendar before deciding whether to hear it.

    Why this big-case score: The constitutionality of nonunanimous capital-sentencing determinations has immediate life-or-death consequences and substantial implications for jury authority in Florida and Alabama.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review—meaning it will decline to hear the appeal and leave the lower court's ruling in place—with a grant probability of 14% (about one in seven). Although Michael James Jackson challenges Florida's 2023 law allowing a death sentence based on an 8–4 jury vote rather than a unanimous jury recommendation, the Court held in 2020 that the Constitution requires jury unanimity only for finding the initial facts that make a defendant eligible for the death penalty, which Jackson's jury found unanimously.

    Why this big-case score: First direct-review constitutional challenge to Florida's 2023 nonunanimous (8-4) capital sentencing statute, raising major Sixth and Eighth Amendment questions over jury unanimity in death penalty sentencing.

Owens v. TalibanTerrorism victims ask the Court to decide whether courts, not the Executive Branch, must independently determine whether an entity qualifies as a foreign state entitled to immunity from lawsuits.Sovereignty & foreign relationsawaiting the Court
0.60
0.86
0.78
0.75

James Owens, et al. v. The Taliban, et al.No. 26-294 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000294 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

Terrorism victims ask the Court to decide whether courts, not the Executive Branch, must independently determine whether an entity qualifies as a foreign state entitled to immunity from lawsuits.

What happened

Petitioners are victims, or relatives of victims, of al-Qaeda's 1998 embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania, attacks the Taliban allegedly supported. They won a nearly $5.2 billion default judgment against the Taliban and sought to collect it by attaching billions in blocked funds held by Da Afghanistan Bank, which they say the Taliban now controls. The district court denied attachment, relying on a Department of Justice letter describing the bank as Afghanistan's central bank. The Second Circuit affirmed, over a dissent, holding it was bound by that letter and a State Department website to treat Afghanistan as a foreign state. Rehearing en banc was denied, with five judges dissenting.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law governing when foreign governments and their agencies are shielded from lawsuits and asset seizures requires courts to work out for themselves whether an entity counts as a foreign state, or whether courts must instead accept the Executive Branch's own statements, including an informal website listing and a brief litigation letter, as conclusively deciding that question.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conferences on November 6 and November 13, 2026. The docket shows no action on it since those conferences.

What each outcome would mean

The Owens and Aliganga petitioners are asking the Court to reverse the Second Circuit's ruling, which favored the Taliban and Da Afghanistan Bank by keeping disputed funds immune from attachment. If the Court grants review, it would hear full briefing and argument and decide whether courts must independently interpret the immunity law rather than defer to Executive statements. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, leaving the funds immune and the petitioners unable to collect their judgment through this route.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Owens' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Owens' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Victims of terrorist attacks who hold court judgments against the Taliban want to collect them from frozen Afghan central-bank money. The appeals court held the money is protected by foreign sovereign immunity, the legal rule that shields foreign governments from most U.S. lawsuits, relying on State Department statements. We predict the Supreme Court will probably refuse to hear the case, but the chance it takes it is real: about three in ten. The Court has already held the petition over from one weekly conference to the next, and it may ask the federal government for its views first.

    Why this big-case score: Billions in frozen Afghan central-bank assets sought by terrorism-judgment creditors (9/11 and embassy-bombing victims), plus a separation-of-powers question about executive say over FSIA 'foreign state' status.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this appeal than to hear it; I put the chance of review at about one in three. Terrorism victims seek access to billions of dollars held for Afghanistan's central bank. Their petition asks whether judges must independently decide the bank's legal protection from seizure. A divided lower court and the Supreme Court's renewed consideration make review plausible, but the claimed conflict with other courts is imperfect. The Court may first ask the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: Access to $3.5 billion in blocked Afghan central-bank assets for terrorism victims, together with the allocation of sovereign-immunity decisions between courts and the Executive, gives this dispute substantial financial, humanitarian and foreign-relations stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to deny review than to grant it, with about a two-in-five (44%) chance of granting the petition. Victims of the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings seek to attach $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves to satisfy claims against the Taliban, arguing that under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (the federal law governing when foreign governments can be sued in U.S. courts) the central bank is now controlled by the Taliban rather than a recognized foreign state. Although a sharp five-judge dissent in the lower court and a recent conference relist make this a close call, the lack of a direct conflict among federal appeals courts and the diplomatic sensitivity of seizing foreign central-bank reserves tilt the odds narrowly toward denial.

    Why this big-case score: Roughly $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves, major FSIA/TRIA statutory questions, and a 5-judge Second Circuit en banc dissent make this a high-stakes foreign-sovereign-immunity and terrorism-victim compensation dispute.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Terrorism victims holding court judgments against the Taliban want to collect from frozen Afghan central-bank money in New York. The appeals court said the money is protected by foreign sovereign immunity, mainly because it deferred to Executive Branch statements. The Supreme Court has now held the case over for a second conference. I predict it will probably turn the case down, but the chance it agrees to hear it is about one in four (27%). A likely next step is asking the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: Roughly $3.5B in frozen Afghan central-bank assets sought by 9/11 and terrorism victims, plus a general FSIA question on deference to Executive statements, with a five-judge en banc dissent below.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of taking it up (27%). Victims of embassy bombings seek access to billions of dollars in frozen Afghan central-bank funds. They argue that judges, not government officials, must decide whether those funds are protected from seizure. The Court has already considered the petition once and scheduled it again, showing real interest. But separate obstacles to recovery make this a difficult case for resolving the broader legal question.

    Why this big-case score: Multibillion-dollar terrorism-victim recovery, Afghan central-bank reserves, and the separation of judicial immunity determinations from executive recognition make the stakes unusually high independently of grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny review in this case, with about a one-in-seven chance (14%) of granting the petition. Victims of the 1998 United States embassy bombings seek to seize $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central bank funds held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York to satisfy claims against the Taliban, arguing that the central bank is no longer protected by foreign sovereign immunity (the legal rule shielding foreign governments and their central banks from lawsuits and asset seizures in United States courts). Although five appellate judges dissented below and the financial stakes are massive, no opposing party has filed a response, there is no disagreement among federal appeals courts, and two companion petitions by September 11 victims offer a cleaner legal path to the same funds.

    Why this big-case score: Controls whether terrorism victims can attach $3.5 billion in blocked Afghan central bank reserves at the NY Fed and tests executive recognition power and FSIA immunity after a 5-judge Second Circuit en banc dissent.

Wilcox v. TrumpThe Supreme Court declined to hear Gwynne Wilcox's challenge to her removal from the National Labor Relations Board.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.50
0.88
0.85
0.74

Gwynne A. Wilcox v. Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al.No. 26-5 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000005 · models differ by up to 0.38 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Supreme Court declined to hear Gwynne Wilcox's challenge to her removal from the National Labor Relations Board.

What happened

Gwynne Wilcox was removed by President Trump from her position on the National Labor Relations Board before her term ended, without the cause the law governing the Board normally requires. She sued, and a district court ruled in her favor, ordering her reinstated. The government appealed, and the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit reversed, holding that the law protecting Board members from removal without cause violates the separation of powers. The full D.C. Circuit declined to rehear the case. Wilcox then asked the Supreme Court to take up the matter.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether Congress may limit the President's power to remove members of the National Labor Relations Board to cases of neglect of duty or wrongdoing, or whether the President may remove them at will. It also raises a backup question: if that protection is unconstitutional, whether the right fix is to strip the Board of some of its powers rather than erase the removal protection entirely.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference more than once, and the government filed a brief opposing it after the Court asked for a response. The Supreme Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Wilcox, who lost below, asked the Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the D.C. Circuit's ruling in place: the removal protection for NLRB members is unenforceable, and Wilcox's removal stands. The denial does not itself decide whether the D.C. Circuit was right; it simply leaves that court's judgment as the final word in this case. The docket shows the denial came after the Court's decision in a related case, Trump v. Slaughter, which addressed similar removal-protection questions for a different agency.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided on the merits it would settle whether the NLRB, the labor-law adjudicator for the private sector, keeps any tenure protection after Slaughter; closely watched and stayed once by the Court itself, but the doctrinal question Slaughter left is narrow (an adjudicatory-body carve-out) and the outcome is largely foreordained.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.88·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presidential control of the NLRB implicates the independence of national labor adjudication and the separation of powers. A decision could affect employers, workers, unions, and other adjudicatory agencies, even though an intervening precedent reduces the need for another plenary case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Genalo v. D. C.ICE officials ask the Court to review, before a lower appeals ruling, a dispute over immigration enforcement authority involving a respondent identified as D.C.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.85
0.78
0.74

Kenneth Genalo, in His Official Capacity as Director of the New York Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. v. D. C.No. 26-379 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000379 · models differ by up to 0.25

ICE officials ask the Court to review, before a lower appeals ruling, a dispute over immigration enforcement authority involving a respondent identified as D.C.

What happened

This case comes from the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. The petitioners are Kenneth Genalo, the field office director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement's New York office, and other federal officials, represented by the Solicitor General. The respondent is identified only as D. C., represented by The Bronx Defenders. The petition does not describe the facts of the underlying dispute or what the Second Circuit had ruled or was expected to rule. The federal government asked the Supreme Court to take up the case before the court of appeals issued a judgment, a step called certiorari before judgment. Iowa and other states later filed a brief as amici curiae, meaning friends of the court, supporting a position in the case.

What the Court is being asked

The record does not include the questions presented or briefing that would explain the legal issue in detail, so the specific rule or standard at stake cannot be summarized from this record.

Where it stands

The petition for certiorari before judgment was filed on September 21, 2026. The response deadline, originally October 21, 2026, was extended to December 8, 2026 after a motion to extend was granted in part; the case awaits the respondent's response and has not yet been distributed for conference.

What each outcome would mean

The federal officials, led by Genalo, are asking the Court to take up the case before the Second Circuit rules. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case directly, bypassing a full court of appeals decision, and would decide the legal question itself without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the case would continue in the Second Circuit, which would proceed to decide it in the ordinary course.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 8, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Genalo's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Genalo's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 75%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely agree to hear this case (about a three-in-four chance). The federal government asks the Court to decide whether immigrants with criminal records who are held a long time while facing deportation must get a hearing on release on bond. The Court already agreed to decide this question in an earlier case, which ended when that detainee was pardoned. The main doubt is that the appeals court has not ruled yet, and the Court rarely steps in that early.

    Why this big-case score: Nationwide rule on bond hearings and burden of proof for prolonged immigration detention of noncitizens with criminal records; the Court already granted the question once.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 87%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to take this case: I estimate an 87% chance. The government offers it as a replacement for an earlier case the Court had agreed to hear but could no longer decide [R1–R2]. That makes review unusually likely. The unfinished lower-court appeal is the main caution. I expect full briefing and argument rather than an immediate ruling. This predicts whether the Court takes the case, not which side ultimately wins.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential limits on judicial intervention in immigration enforcement.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (an 88% chance, or nearly nine in ten) to grant the federal government's request for review (`certiorari`, meaning the Court agrees to hear the appeal) in *Genalo v. D. C.* This case asks whether the Constitution requires bond hearings for noncitizens held in mandatory immigration detention for months while their deportation cases proceed. Just three months earlier, in June 2026, the Supreme Court agreed to decide these exact same two questions in *Genalo v. Black*, and when *Black* was dismissed after the detainee received a pardon, the Solicitor General filed this case as its direct replacement.

    Why this big-case score: Major nationwide constitutional question on whether the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause requires individualized bond hearings during prolonged mandatory immigration detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c), left open in Jennings v. Rodriguez (2018) and already granted in Genalo v. Black (No. 25-886).

Herridge v. ChenA journalist asks the Court to limit when civil plaintiffs can force reporters to reveal confidential sources.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.65
0.73
0.85
0.74

Catherine Herridge v. Yanping ChenNo. 26-461 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000461 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

A journalist asks the Court to limit when civil plaintiffs can force reporters to reveal confidential sources.

What happened

Yanping Chen sued federal agencies, alleging officials unlawfully leaked her private records to Fox News reporter Catherine Herridge, who then published stories questioning Chen's ties to the Chinese military. After years of discovery failed to identify the leaker, Chen subpoenaed Herridge to learn her source's identity. Herridge refused, citing a reporter's privilege under the First Amendment. The district court ruled Chen had overcome that privilege and held Herridge in contempt when she still refused to answer. The Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed, applying its existing two-factor test for overcoming the privilege and declining to adopt a broader privilege rooted in federal common law.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide when, if ever, someone suing the government can force a journalist to name a confidential source, and whether courts should weigh a broader set of interests—such as the importance of the story or the harm from disclosure—rather than apply a narrower test focused only on whether the information is essential and other options have been tried.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the docket shows no action recorded since. The government has waived its right to respond, Chen has filed a brief opposing review, and several amici have filed briefs on both sides.

What each outcome would mean

Herridge, the journalist, is asking the Court to take up the case and overturn the lower court's ruling against her. If the Court grants review and ultimately sides with Herridge, it would make it harder for civil litigants to compel reporters to name confidential sources, and Herridge would not have to identify hers. If the Court instead affirms, Chen's position would prevail, and Herridge would remain subject to the contempt order requiring disclosure. If the Court denies review, the appeals court's decision stands, leaving Herridge obligated to disclose her source under the existing rule. A grant does not by itself decide who wins.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Herridge's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Herridge's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A reporter's-privilege contempt case with elite counsel, press-freedom amici, a Senator as amicus below, and a Justice already on record at the stay stage; if decided it would be the Court's first word on Branzburg's reach in civil discovery in fifty years. Discounted because the posture is a non-party civil discovery sanction and the public petition is sealed in part.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.73·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Compelled identification of a journalist's confidential sources raises nationally consequential press-freedom and federal evidentiary-privilege questions, balanced against enforcement of individual Privacy Act rights. Significance is substantially greater than grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment reporter's privilege case, though highly unlikely to be granted given the prior 8-1 stay denial.

Trump v. Alishea Sophia KingdomThe Court denied the Trump administration's request to pause a court order blocking a federal prison policy limiting transgender inmates' access to hormone treatment and related accommodations.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.60
0.78
0.85
0.74

Donald J. Trump, President of the United States, et al. v. Alishea Sophia Kingdom, et al.No. 26A416 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000416 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Court denied the Trump administration's request to pause a court order blocking a federal prison policy limiting transgender inmates' access to hormone treatment and related accommodations.

What happened

Federal inmates diagnosed with gender dysphoria, led by Alishea Sophia Kingdom, sued over a 2026 Bureau of Prisons policy ending hormone treatment, social accommodations, and surgeries previously available for gender dysphoria, arguing the policy was adopted without adequate justification. A federal district court agreed that the inmates were likely to succeed on their claim that the policy was arbitrary and capricious, and blocked the government from enforcing it. The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit declined to pause that order while the government's appeal continued. The government then asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

The government asked the Court to pause the lower court's order while the case continues, arguing it is likely to win on the merits because the prison agency reasonably explained its policy change and the lower court exceeded limits on court orders affecting prison conditions. The inmates countered that the agency ignored its own decades of experience providing this care and that its stated reasons do not hold up.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice requested a response, and after receiving briefing from both sides along with amicus filings, the application was referred to and denied by the full Court. Justices Thomas and Alito noted they would have granted it.

What each outcome would mean

The government, represented by the Solicitor General on behalf of President Trump and other officials, asked for the pause. Because the request was denied, the lower court's order blocking the 2026 policy remains in effect, meaning the Bureau of Prisons must continue providing the prior treatment approach while the underlying lawsuit and appeal proceed. Had the Court granted the request, the agency could have enforced its new policy immediately while litigation continued. The denial does not decide the underlying legal dispute, which remains before the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 21, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 21, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-21: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide, classwide block on a signature Executive Order policy governing medical care for roughly 2,000 transgender federal inmates; the next step after Skrmetti, Orr, and B.P.J. in the Court's gender-identity line, on the shadow docket, with APA-deference and PLRA questions that would plainly draw certiorari.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.77·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide federal-prison policy affecting access to gender-affirming treatment, with substantial bodily and mental-health stakes for affected inmates and broader consequences for administrative review and limits on prison injunctions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court grants the application: 75%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves a nationwide injunction of a major executive policy concerning gender dysphoria treatment in federal prisons, raising significant separation of powers and PLRA issues.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-21: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 72%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide class of federal inmates with gender dysphoria; a stay would let BOP taper hormone therapy and withdraw accommodations class-wide while the appeal proceeds. High salience as executive-order implementation and Skrmetti aftermath, but it is an interim order, not a merits ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court grants the application: 68%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide federal-prison treatment policy, interruption of existing care, and the permissible scope of classwide prison-conditions relief create substantial human and institutional stakes independent of the stay's likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court grants the application: 75%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile case challenging a nationwide executive branch policy affecting federal prisons, likely to draw significant public and media attention.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-21: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 63%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide class of roughly 1,000 federal inmates, Executive Order 14168, and the Court's third transgender-policy emergency application in two Terms; high public salience, though the legal question (APA review of a prison medical policy) is narrower than the headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 61%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns nationwide federal-prison treatment of gender dysphoria, the consequences of interrupting ongoing care, executive control of prison policy, and statutory limits on classwide interim relief. These are substantial stakes independent of the stay's likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 90%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile case challenging a new BOP policy on gender dysphoria and implicating the scope of the PLRA and APA deference.

Ream v. Department of the TreasuryJohn Ream asks the Court to strike down the federal ban on distilling spirits at home, arguing Congress lacked power to enact it.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.75
0.85
0.73

John Ream v. Department of the Treasury, et al.No. 26-93 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000093 · models differ by up to 0.25

John Ream asks the Court to strike down the federal ban on distilling spirits at home, arguing Congress lacked power to enact it.

What happened

John Ream wants to distill whiskey at home but says a federal law banning distilling in a dwelling house stops him. He sued the Treasury Department, arguing the ban exceeds Congress's power. A district court dismissed his case, finding he lacked standing because he had not taken concrete steps toward distilling or faced a specific threat of prosecution. The Sixth Circuit reversed on standing but ruled against him on the merits, holding the ban is a valid way to help collect taxes on distilled spirits. One judge dissented on standing. A different appeals court, the Fifth Circuit, had reached the opposite conclusion in a similar case called McNutt.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a long-standing federal ban on producing spirits in a home goes beyond the powers the Constitution gives Congress, including its power to tax and to regulate interstate commerce. A related question is whether the Court should overturn or narrow a past decision, Gonzales v. Raich, that gave Congress broad authority to regulate local, noncommercial activity. The government agrees review is warranted but wants the Court to take up a different case, McNutt, covering only the tax-related question, and to hold Ream's case until that one is decided.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, most recently for October 16, 2026, and the docket shows no action on it since that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Ream, who lost on the merits below, is asking the Court to take up his case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case in full and decide the constitutional question itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision upholding the ban stands, leaving Ream unable to distill at home. The government has suggested the Court instead grant review in the related McNutt case and hold Ream's petition pending that outcome, which would delay any decision on Ream's case specifically.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Ream's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Ream's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 47%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A square circuit split on whether a 150-year-old federal criminal prohibition exceeds Congress's enumerated powers, with 15 states and ten organizations as amici and a request to revisit Gonzales v. Raich; significant for federalism doctrine, though the taxing-power question the Court would actually decide is narrower than the headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The challenge concerns the nationwide home-distilling prohibition and constitutional limits on the taxing and commerce powers; the request to reconsider Raich gives it broader federalism stakes even though a narrower companion-case disposition is more likely.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct challenge to the constitutionality of a federal statute with a sharp circuit split and Raich implications.

Department of Labor v. Sun Valley OrchardsThe government asked the Supreme Court whether a federal agency, rather than a court, may fine a farm over its foreign-worker visa program.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.62
0.79
0.78
0.73

Department of Labor, et al. v. Sun Valley Orchards, LLCNo. 25-966 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281007 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The government asked the Supreme Court whether a federal agency, rather than a court, may fine a farm over its foreign-worker visa program.

What happened

Sun Valley Orchards, a New Jersey farm, hired foreign and domestic workers through the H-2A agricultural visa program. The Department of Labor found that the farm violated program rules on housing, meals, transportation and work guarantees, and an agency judge imposed over $500,000 in penalties and back wages. Sun Valley sued, arguing this agency process violated its right to have the case heard by a court under Article III. The district court sided with the Department. The Third Circuit reversed, ruling that the claims involved "private rights"—resembling a breach-of-contract suit seeking money—that the Constitution reserves for courts, not agency judges. The Department of Labor asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution lets the Department of Labor itself decide, through its own in-house judges, whether a farm must pay penalties and back wages for violating the terms of employing foreign agricultural workers, or whether such cases must instead go to a federal court. A related question is whether the underlying immigration law actually gives the Department authority to resolve these cases internally at all.

Where it stands

The Court granted review and the case was argued on November 10, 2026. It now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

The Department of Labor, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to reverse and uphold its authority to decide these cases itself. If the Court affirms, the Third Circuit's ruling stands: Sun Valley's win remains in place, and the Department could no longer use its in-house judges to impose penalties and back wages for H-2A violations in that circuit, instead needing to sue in federal court. If the Court reverses, the Department's internal enforcement process would be upheld, and Sun Valley's challenge to the penalties against it would fail. The Court could also vacate and send the case back for further proceedings without deciding who is right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Department of Labor wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Sun Valley Orchards wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 45%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Post-Jarkesy boundary case for agency adjudication of monetary penalties, with direct consequences for H-2A enforcement (a sixth of the agricultural workforce) and, by extension, other benefit-condition and employer-sanction schemes; a broad cross-ideological amicus field on both sides marks the stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 44%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define both Congress's authorization of in-house monetary adjudication and Article III's public-rights boundary for federal benefit programs.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 45%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Post-Jarkesy test of Article III limits on agency adjudication across federal benefit/immigration programs; SG petition, invalidated application of a federal statute, and 20+ merits amici from the Chamber, AFL-CIO, and the conservative legal movement.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 40%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define Article III limits on binding agency monetary adjudication across H-2A and related regulatory programs.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 26%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably affirm, meaning the lower-court ruling for the farm stays in place: there is only about a one-in-four chance the Court disturbs it. The Labor Department fined Sun Valley Orchards through its own in-house judges, and the appeals court said such penalties must go before an ordinary federal court. At argument, most of the conservative Justices doubted the government's claim that this was an immigration matter agencies may decide themselves. Expected split: 6–3, with Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson dissenting.

    Why this big-case score: First test of how far SEC v. Jarkesy reaches into agency civil-penalty adjudication under a claimed public-rights (immigration/privilege) exception; the government says many penalty schemes ride on it, but the program directly at issue is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.79·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 32%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely than not to leave the lower court's ruling in Sun Valley's favor intact, with about a two-in-three chance of no change. I predict a 5–4 affirmance: the Labor Department cannot conclusively decide these disputed workplace fines and back-pay obligations in its own administrative process instead of a federal court. Several Justices questioned whether immigration authority extends that far. The government still has a meaningful chance of winning because the obligations are conditions of a federal worker-visa program.

    Why this big-case score: The case tests the boundary between federal agency adjudication and Article III courts after Jarkesy, with consequences for immigration-related labor enforcement and potentially other administrative monetary remedies.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 55%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court is slightly more likely than not—at a little over half (55%)—to reverse the lower court's ruling by a 7–2 vote and revive the Department of Labor's $557,000 back-pay and penalty order against Sun Valley Orchards. Although the Court generally requires government civil-penalty cases to go before life-tenured federal judges and juries rather than agency hearing officers, a narrow majority is likely to rule that enforcing wage and housing promises tied to temporary H-2A foreign farmworker visas falls within Congress's longstanding immigration authority.

    Why this big-case score: Major post-Jarkesy separation-of-powers test of whether Article III's public-rights exception permits agencies to adjudicate civil penalties and back pay against U.S. employers under federal immigration and guestworker programs, with broad implications across administrative enforcement.

Citibank v. Climate United FundCitibank asks the Supreme Court to lift an injunction ordering it to disburse frozen climate-grant funds despite the government's instructions to withhold them.awaiting the Court
0.65
0.76
0.78
0.73

Citibank, N.A. v. Climate United Fund, et al.No. 26-594 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000594 · models differ by up to 0.13

Citibank asks the Supreme Court to lift an injunction ordering it to disburse frozen climate-grant funds despite the government's instructions to withhold them.

What happened

The EPA awarded billions in grants to nonprofits under the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, with Citibank holding the money as the government's financial agent. After a change in administration, EPA froze and then terminated the grants, citing fraud and oversight concerns, and directed Citibank not to release funds. The grantees sued Citibank and EPA. A district court issued a preliminary injunction against both, and a sharply divided en banc D.C. Circuit affirmed, with no majority opinion explaining the result as to Citibank specifically. Citibank now asks the Supreme Court to review that outcome. A related petition by the government concerning the same underlying dispute is noted as separately filed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether Citibank, which says it merely followed the government's instructions as its financial agent, can be held under a court order to pay out the grant funds, when neither lower court explained why an injunction against Citibank itself was justified or applied the usual factors courts use before ordering such relief.

Where it stands

The petition was filed November 2, 2026, with a response originally due December 7, 2026. After motions and replies about the briefing schedule, the Court on November 12, 2026 extended the response deadline to December 15, 2026, for all respondents. The petition itself has not yet been acted on.

What each outcome would mean

Citibank, which lost below, is asking the Court to take up its case and set aside the injunction. If the Court grants review, it would decide the merits of whether Citibank can be ordered to disburse the funds; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the injunction requiring Citibank to disburse funds, as affirmed by the en banc appeals court, stays in place. The case also involves a related petition from the federal government concerning the broader dispute over the grant terminations.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 15, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Citibank's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Citibank's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Citibank is asking the Supreme Court to lift a court order that forces it to release frozen climate-grant money, and it filed alongside the federal government's own request for review in the same dispute. We think the Court is somewhat more likely than not, about three chances in five, to take up Citibank's request or send it back for reconsideration. The main reason is that the government's companion request, involving about $16 billion, is very likely to be heard, and Citibank's fate follows it.

    Why this big-case score: Tag-along to the Solicitor General's petition over the $16 billion Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund terminations and the Tucker Act's reach over grant suits; Citibank's own question is narrow and derivative.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 64%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I give Citibank about a two-in-three chance of obtaining Supreme Court action on its petition. The most likely single outcome is that the Court sends the case back for another look after resolving the government's closely linked challenge. Citibank argues that it should not have to release climate-grant money while the government directs it to keep that money frozen. The link to the government's case substantially improves its chances, but the bank's narrow, contract-related issues may not warrant separate review.

    Why this big-case score: The underlying dispute concerns roughly $20 billion in climate grants and federal control over awarded funds; this bank-specific petition has narrower, derivative stakes for government financial agents.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 54%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court has a 54% chance—slightly better than a coin flip—of granting Citibank's petition, most likely through a "grant, vacate, and remand" order, which sets aside the lower court's ruling and sends the case back for a fresh look without full oral argument. Citibank was ordered by a lower court to release billions of dollars in frozen federal climate grants despite instructions from the Environmental Protection Agency to pause payments. Because the federal government simultaneously filed its own Supreme Court appeal challenging the same $20 billion ruling, the Justices are likely to take up the government's lead case while holding Citibank's companion petition and later sending Citibank's case back once the government's authority is decided.

    Why this big-case score: Controls $16B-$20B in Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund accounts and tests whether federal financial agents can be enjoined when following government instructions.

Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa ChurchThe Supreme Court stayed a district court injunction that had blocked border wall construction waivers in the Big Bend region of Texas, pending any further appeal.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.62
0.79
0.78
0.73

Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al. v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, et al.No. 26A560 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000560 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Supreme Court stayed a district court injunction that had blocked border wall construction waivers in the Big Bend region of Texas, pending any further appeal.

What happened

The Secretary of Homeland Security issued waivers under a 1996 immigration law allowing him to bypass environmental and other legal requirements to speed border barrier construction in the Big Bend Sector. Friends of the Ruidosa Church and other groups sued, arguing the waivers were unlawful. A Texas federal district court agreed, finding the challengers were likely to succeed on their claim that the waivers violated a doctrine requiring clear congressional authorization for major decisions, and it blocked construction. The government asked the Supreme Court to pause that injunction while it pursued review, and also asked the Court to treat the request itself as a petition for review and immediately overturn the lower court.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the lower court had authority to hear this challenge at all, given a law limiting such challenges to constitutional claims, and whether the Secretary's waivers were properly authorized in an area the lower court found had comparatively low rates of illegal border crossings.

Where it stands

The Court received the stay application, asked for and received a response and reply, and on November 9, 2026 granted the stay. The construction injunction is paused while the government's anticipated petition for review proceeds, with Justice Jackson noting she would have denied the stay.

What each outcome would mean

The government asked the Court to pause the injunction. By granting the stay, the Court allowed border wall construction in the Big Bend Sector to resume while the government pursues further review, pausing the lower court's block on the waivers. If the government's certiorari petition is later denied, the stay ends automatically, and construction could again face the injunction. If certiorari is granted, the stay continues until the Court decides the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court grants the application: 76%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Halts roughly 340 miles of planned border-barrier construction (about a quarter of the southern border) and tests whether a major-questions claim can be dressed as a constitutional claim to evade IIRIRA's review bar; nationally newsworthy but turns on a narrow statutory-jurisdiction question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.83·Chance the Court grants the application: 86%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns extensive border-barrier construction in the Big Bend region, environmental and historic-resource protection, and the limits of judicial review of DHS waiver authority. Its significance exceeds the immediate construction dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile separation-of-powers and border-wall dispute over IIRIRA section 102(c) waivers across 510 miles of the Big Bend Sector (including Big Bend National Park) and whether the major questions doctrine supplies a standalone constitutional cause of action.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court grants the application: 74%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Halts roughly 340 miles of planned border-barrier construction across a quarter of the southern border and tests whether a major-questions claim counts as a constitutional claim under IIRIRA's jurisdiction strip; nationally salient but turns on one unusual statutory review scheme.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court grants the application: 87%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns extensive border construction, environmental and historic-preservation protections, and the boundary between statutory and constitutional review of federal waiver decisions. Those stakes are distinct from the probability of a stay.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 75%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes Solicitor General application seeking to stay a 300-mile border-wall preliminary injunction across the El Paso and Big Bend Sectors, implicating $4.5 billion in OBBBA border-barrier contracts, the scope of IIRIRA § 102(c)(2)(A)'s jurisdiction-stripping bar on non-constitutional claims, the major questions doctrine after Learning Resources, and universal/sector-wide injunction overbreadth under Trump v. CASA.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court grants the application: 74%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal government has asked the Supreme Court to pause a Texas federal judge's order that stopped border-wall construction along roughly 300 miles of the Big Bend region. We think the Court is likely to grant the pause, about a three-in-four chance. The law Congress passed lets lower courts hear only constitutional challenges to these construction waivers. The judge's ruling rested on a theory that most of the Justices are unlikely to treat as constitutional. A partial pause, or an order that is part yes and part no, is the main way this forecast could miss.

    Why this big-case score: Covers construction of a border wall along about 300 miles (a quarter of the southern border) and the first court ruling ever to sustain a substantive challenge to an IIRIRA section 102 waiver; it also tests whether a major-questions claim counts as 'constitutional' for a jurisdiction-stripping statute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.79·Chance the Court grants the application: 80%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to pause the lower court's order blocking border-wall construction in the Big Bend region, with about an **80% chance** of an unqualified grant. The government's strongest argument is that Congress expressly allowed legal waivers for border construction and sharply limited court review. The opposing groups present serious evidence of lasting environmental and property damage, which keeps denial plausible. A pause would allow construction while legal challenges continue; it would not finally settle every constitutional question.

    Why this big-case score: The application concerns extensive border construction in the Big Bend region, potentially irreversible environmental and cultural damage, and the reach of statutory limits on judicial review of federal waiver authority.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 85%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (an 85% chance, or about five in six) to grant the federal government's emergency request to pause a Texas federal judge's order that blocked border-wall and road construction across 517 miles of the Big Bend region. In 1996 and 2005, Congress gave the Secretary of Homeland Security broad power to waive environmental and other laws to speed up border barriers and barred lower courts from hearing challenges unless they involve a violation of the U.S. Constitution, and a majority of the Justices will likely conclude that the challengers' arguments about the scale of the project are disagreements over statutory interpretation rather than true constitutional claims.

    Why this big-case score: First judicial invalidation of IIRIRA § 102(c) border-barrier waivers in 20 years, halting DHS construction across a 517-mile border sector (including Big Bend National Park) funded by the $46.5 billion OBBBA appropriation and testing whether the major questions doctrine and Presentment Clauses can overcome § 102(c)(2)(A)'s jurisdiction-stripping bar under Dalton v. Specter.

Youth 71Five Ministries v. WilliamsA Christian youth ministry asks the Court to revive its claim that Oregon illegally stripped its grant funding over faith-based hiring practices.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.60
0.73
0.85
0.73

Youth 71Five Ministries v. Charlene Williams, Individually and as Director of Oregon Department of Education, et al.No. 25-776 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279903 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: First Amendment

A Christian youth ministry asks the Court to revive its claim that Oregon illegally stripped its grant funding over faith-based hiring practices.

What happened

Youth 71Five Ministries, a Christian nonprofit serving at-risk youth, had received Oregon grant funding for years. When Oregon added a rule barring grantees from discriminating in employment based on religion, among other traits, it withdrew 71Five's grant after learning the ministry requires staff to affirm a Christian statement of faith. 71Five sued, claiming violations of its free exercise, religious autonomy, and expressive association rights. The district court denied preliminary relief and dismissed the case. The Ninth Circuit affirmed denial of relief on the free-exercise and religious-autonomy claims, but ruled for 71Five on its expressive-association claim, ordering a narrower injunction protecting hiring outside grant-funded activities.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions. First, whether a religious organization may sue state officials directly, under a federal civil-rights law, claiming the government violated its right to control its own religious affairs, or whether that right can only be raised as a defense once already sued. Second, whether a state violates religious freedom protections by requiring a religious organization to give up its right to hire only people who share its faith as a condition of receiving public grant money.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after briefing extensions and a round of amicus filings, most recently for the April 17, 2026 conference. The docket shows no record yet of the Court's action on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Youth 71Five Ministries, which lost on two of its three claims below, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case fully and decide the legal questions; granting does not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place its rulings against 71Five on the free-exercise and religious-autonomy claims, while 71Five's narrower injunction on expressive-association grounds remains intact and the case continues in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Youth 71Five Ministries' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Youth 71Five Ministries' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether states may condition public grant funding on religious organizations abandoning coreligionist hiring, plus whether church autonomy supports affirmative §1983 claims — a significant extension of the Trinity Lutheran/Espinoza/Carson line with a multi-state amicus coalition, though narrower than a marquee culture-war blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.73·Chance the Court takes the case: 29%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition could set nationally important rules for religious organizations' coreligionist hiring and access to generally available public funding.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile Free Exercise challenge against state funding conditions, building on Trinity Lutheran and Carson.

Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority v. National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective AssociationHorseracing regulators ask the Court to overturn a ruling that a federal horseracing law's enforcement powers are unconstitutional.awaiting the Court
0.62
0.78
0.78
0.73

Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, Incorporated, et al. v. National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, et al.No. 26-199 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000199 · models differ by up to 0.16

Horseracing regulators ask the Court to overturn a ruling that a federal horseracing law's enforcement powers are unconstitutional.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private nonprofit, to write and enforce national safety and anti-doping rules for thoroughbred racing, under Federal Trade Commission oversight. Horsemen's associations, racetrack groups, and Texas sued, arguing the arrangement unlawfully hands government power to a private entity. After Congress amended the law to expand FTC oversight, the Fifth Circuit upheld the rulemaking structure but ruled the law's enforcement provisions—letting the Authority investigate, subpoena, search, fine, and sue without FTC approval—unconstitutional. The Sixth Circuit, reviewing a similar challenge, upheld HISA's enforcement provisions, creating a split between the circuits.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law can let a private organization investigate, subpoena, search, fine, and sue people on its own, without needing a federal agency's approval first, without that violating the constitutional rule against handing government power to private parties unsupervised.

Where it stands

The petition and a companion petition from the federal government have been fully briefed, including responses from multiple respondent groups and a reply from the petitioners. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, and no decision on whether to grant review has yet been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

The Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority and related petitioners are asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling against them. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether HISA's enforcement provisions are constitutional, with no outcome assured for either side. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's ruling striking down those enforcement provisions as unconstitutional stands, leaving in place a split with the Sixth Circuit, which upheld similar provisions in a separate case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (about nine in ten) to agree to hear this case. The case asks whether the federal law creating a private Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority unlawfully hands government enforcement power to a private body. The Fifth Circuit appeals court struck the enforcement provisions down, while the Sixth Circuit upheld them. The federal government has filed its own appeal, and every party, including the challengers, agrees the Court should decide the question. The Court almost always reviews a lower-court decision that strikes down an Act of Congress.

    Why this big-case score: A federal statute held facially unconstitutional under the private-nondelegation doctrine; a doctrinal sequel to FCC v. Consumers' Research that governs a national industry.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to hear this case: I estimate a 92% chance of review. Two federal appeals courts disagree about whether a private horse-racing regulator can enforce national rules under federal supervision. All responding groups support review of that issue, and the federal government has filed a related request. The Court will probably hear full arguments rather than resolve the dispute in a short order. I expect a brief further review before the announcement, without a request for another government opinion.

    Why this big-case score: The facial constitutionality of a national regulatory statute and the permissible enforcement role of private regulators give this case substantial structural and industry-wide significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to grant review in this case (about an 88% chance, or nearly nine in ten). A federal appeals court struck down the enforcement rules of the federal Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act as an unconstitutional transfer of government power to a private organization, directly conflicting with another federal appeals court that upheld the same law after an earlier Supreme Court remand. Because a federal law was invalidated, the U.S. government has filed a companion appeal, and all opposing parties agree the Supreme Court should hear the case, review is almost certain.

    Why this big-case score: Major constitutional private-nondelegation challenge to a federal regulatory statute (HISA) with a square Fifth/Sixth Circuit split after a prior Supreme Court GVR.

Novartis Pharmaceuticals v. FitchNovartis asks the Court to decide whether a Mississippi law expanding drugmakers' discount obligations under a federal drug-pricing program is unconstitutional.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.72
0.73
0.72
0.72

Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation v. Lynn Fitch, Attorney General of MississippiNo. 26-457 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000457 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: Agencies & benefits

Novartis asks the Court to decide whether a Mississippi law expanding drugmakers' discount obligations under a federal drug-pricing program is unconstitutional.

What happened

Novartis sells drugs at a discount to certain health providers under a federal program known as Section 340B. Novartis limits which outside "contract pharmacies" can receive these discounted drugs on providers' behalf. Mississippi passed a law barring manufacturers from restricting delivery of discounted drugs to a provider's contract pharmacy. Novartis sued Mississippi's attorney general, arguing the law is blocked by federal law. A district court and, on appeal, the Fifth Circuit both ruled against Novartis, holding the state law does not conflict with the federal program. Novartis then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state law that imposes broader drug-discount obligations on manufacturers participating in the federal program, beyond what federal law itself requires, is invalid because federal law overrides conflicting state law in this area.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference; Mississippi waived its right to respond but was then asked to respond, with that response now due December 28, 2026. No action on the petition itself has yet been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Novartis, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments and decide whether Mississippi's law is valid; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's decision upholding Mississippi's law stands, and Novartis remains subject to it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesResponse due Dec 28, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Novartis Pharmaceuticals' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Novartis Pharmaceuticals' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether 22 state laws forcing 340B contract-pharmacy delivery survive the Supremacy Clause governs billions in drug discounts across a federal program; a decision would be a major health-policy and preemption ruling, though the doctrinal question is technical.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of state authority over the federal 340B drug-discount program has substantial nationwide consequences for manufacturers, safety-net providers, contract pharmacies, and federal program administration, independent of the likelihood of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes nationwide dispute over state regulation of the federal 340B drug discount program, affecting major pharmaceutical companies and state healthcare programs.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Novartis asks the Supreme Court to strike down Mississippi's law forcing drug makers in a federal discount-drug program (340B) to deliver discounted drugs on terms beyond what federal law requires. We think the Court will probably turn the case down: about a one-in-six chance it agrees to hear it. The Court asking Mississippi to respond and the federal government's support for drug makers make review plausible. But the strongest court disagreement on this issue is being reheard, and the Court may prefer to wait for that.

    Why this big-case score: Whether some 22 state laws reshaping the federal 340B drug-discount program survive the Supremacy Clause affects billions of dollars of transactions nationwide and the United States has backed the manufacturers in seven circuits.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.73·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline Novartis's appeal than hear it; I put the chance of review at about one in four. The dispute asks whether Mississippi can require drugmakers to supply discounted medicines through outside pharmacies under a federal program. The Court's request for a response shows interest, and the issue has national importance. But the alleged disagreement among appeals courts is not clear-cut, and this appeal concerns an early-stage ruling. Further briefing, and possibly federal government advice, will likely come before any decision.

    Why this big-case score: The reach of state contract-pharmacy mandates within a nationwide federal drug-discount program has substantial financial, healthcare-access, and federalism consequences, independently of the chance of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Novartis's request to hear this case, with about a one-in-seven (14%) chance of granting review. Novartis argues that federal drug-pricing law (the 340B Program) overrides a Mississippi statute requiring drugmakers to deliver discounted medications to outside contract pharmacies. Although the Court asked Mississippi to file a response, every published federal appeals court decision has upheld similar state laws, the Supreme Court recently turned down the same issue from Arkansas, and this appeal comes at an early preliminary-injunction stage before full facts were developed.

    Why this big-case score: Addresses federal preemption of roughly 20 state statutes regulating contract-pharmacy delivery under the multibillion-dollar Section 340B Drug Pricing Program.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Supremacy Clause challenge to a 22-state wave of 340B contract-pharmacy laws affecting billions in drug transactions, with the United States participating as amicus in seven circuits.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute concerns state regulation of a major federal drug-discount program, contract-pharmacy access, and federal-state authority across many states; the economic and healthcare stakes substantially exceed this preliminary-injunction dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High commercial and regulatory stakes across the pharmaceutical industry and safety-net hospital systems nationwide regarding whether states can mandate unlimited contract-pharmacy delivery of discounted drugs under Section 340B, with similar statutes enacted in roughly 20 states.

Nelsen v. Christa Gail PikeTennessee asked the Supreme Court to vacate a federal appeals court's stay of Christa Pike's execution, and the Court granted that request.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.45
0.85
0.85
0.72

Kenneth Nelsen, Warden v. Christa Gail PikeNo. 26A428 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000428 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

Tennessee asked the Supreme Court to vacate a federal appeals court's stay of Christa Pike's execution, and the Court granted that request.

What happened

Christa Pike was convicted of murder and sentenced to death in Tennessee in 1995. After years of unsuccessful state and federal appeals, her execution was set for September 30, 2026. The day before, hours after the Supreme Court denied an earlier stay request, Pike filed a motion asking a federal court to reopen her old habeas case, arguing a state attorney's recent courtroom remarks were new evidence supporting her claim that her trial lawyers had failed to present mitigating evidence. The district court sent that motion to the Sixth Circuit as a successive habeas petition. Hours before the execution, a divided Sixth Circuit panel granted a short stay to consider the issue; one judge dissented. Tennessee's warden, Kenneth Nelsen, then asked the Supreme Court to vacate that stay.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether the appeals court's stay should remain in place while it considered whether Pike's motion was really a disguised, barred attempt to re-raise a previously rejected claim, or whether the stay should be lifted so the execution could proceed.

Where it stands

The Court granted the application, vacating the Sixth Circuit's stay of execution. Justice Sotomayor dissented, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson.

What each outcome would mean

Tennessee, through Warden Nelsen, asked the Court to vacate the stay so the execution could proceed. Granting the application, as the Court did, removed the pause the Sixth Circuit had ordered, allowing the execution to go forward and ending the lower court's additional review of Pike's motion. Had the Court denied the application instead, the Sixth Circuit's stay would have remained in effect, delaying the execution while that court examined whether Pike's claim was properly before it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 1, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedSep 30, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-30: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 72%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A state's same-day application to vacate a federal stay of a capital sentence; Pike is Tennessee's only woman on death row and would be the first woman executed there in roughly two centuries, so press attention is national, but the legal question (whether a Rule 60(b) motion is a disguised successive petition) is narrow and settled by Gonzalez v. Crosby.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court grants the application: 82%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An execution-day application determines whether an existing stay protecting a prisoner's life remains in force. Immediate stakes and public significance are high, although the apparent Rule 60(b) issue is narrow rather than a broad doctrinal vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-09-30: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court grants the application: 78%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High public salience (a capital case drawing national coverage, the first execution of a woman in Tennessee in two centuries, a published 2-1 circuit stay) but doctrinally routine: a shadow-docket vacatur under Hill/Gonzalez with at most a short dissent, settling no open legal question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 78%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Immediate life-or-death consequences in a capital case, with disputed childhood-abuse mitigation and the integrity of federal habeas review at issue. Very high individual and public stakes, although a short interim order need not establish a broad new rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 90%·Prediction: grant itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital case stay vacatur application; high stakes as it determines if an execution proceeds.

Johnson v. FlemingThree Virginia students ask the Court to hear their challenge to state tuition grant programs that fund some religious college majors but not others.awaiting the Court
0.70
0.72
0.72
0.71

Cameron Johnson, et al. v. A. Scott Fleming, Director of the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia, et al.No. 26-240 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000240 · models differ by up to 0.02

Three Virginia students ask the Court to hear their challenge to state tuition grant programs that fund some religious college majors but not others.

What happened

Cameron Johnson, Luke Thomas, and Trace Stevens are Virginia students at Liberty University who sought state tuition grants. Virginia's programs fund some religious degrees but exclude others the state classifies as religious training or theological education. A federal district court dismissed Johnson's and Thomas's claims and denied Stevens a preliminary injunction, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Locke v. Davey, which it read as barring any challenge to such exclusions. The Fourth Circuit denied an injunction pending appeal without explanation. The students then asked the Supreme Court to take the case before the Fourth Circuit finished deciding the appeal, noting a related case, Hall v. Fleming, already pending at the Court.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Religion Clauses let a state fund some religious college majors through a grant program while excluding other, similar religious majors, and whether the Court should overturn its own prior ruling that the students say wrongly allows states broad power to exclude religious vocational training from such programs.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 16, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked the respondents to file a response, due as extended to November 17, 2026. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

The students are asking the Court to take up their case now, before the Fourth Circuit rules, and to reverse the lower courts' rulings against them. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case and decide the question itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies the petition, the lower court rulings rejecting the students' claims and denying their preliminary injunction request would stand, and the case would continue, if at all, in the Fourth Circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 17, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Johnson's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Johnson's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Three Virginia students at Liberty University ask the Supreme Court to hear their challenge to state grants that fund some religious majors but not theirs, even before the appeals court rules. We think the Court is somewhat more likely to turn this petition down than to take it (about a 38% chance it is taken or sent back). A very similar case, Hall v. Fleming, is already before the Court. The Court will probably decide whether to hear Hall first and either hold this case until then or set it aside.

    Why this big-case score: The petition asks the Court to overrule Locke v. Davey and to bar states from funding some religious degrees but not others. That would reach every state with a similar exclusion in its grant program (22 states filed as amici), though the posture is interlocutory.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear these students' challenge to Virginia's refusal to fund certain religious degrees. I estimate an 18% chance of review, including an order sending the dispute back for another look. The Court's request for a response and seven supporting friend-of-the-court briefs show attention to a significant religious-freedom question. But the students are asking the Court to intervene before the appeals court finishes, and a related case may offer a more straightforward path.

    Why this big-case score: The questions concern religious exclusions from public student aid and expressly invite overruling Locke v. Davey, with potential consequences beyond Virginia; procedural obstacles reduce review odds, not those stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is unlikely to grant this petition (about a 15% chance, or roughly one in seven), and will instead deny review. Although the case raises a major religious-liberty challenge to Virginia's exclusion of ministry-related college majors from state tuition grants—attracting seven friend-of-the-court briefs and prompting the Court to ask Virginia for a response—the students filed a "petition for certiorari before judgment," asking the Supreme Court to step in before the federal appeals court has even ruled. Because a companion case from Virginia (*Hall v. Fleming*) already has a final appeals-court ruling on the same core constitutional issue, the Court will likely leave this unfinished appeal to the lower court.

    Why this big-case score: Directly challenges the vitality and scope of Locke v. Davey (2004) regarding state tuition grant exclusions for religious and ministerial degrees after Trinity Lutheran, Espinoza, Carson, and Catholic Charities, drawing seven cert-stage amicus briefs including a 22-State coalition.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A companion petition asking the Court to overrule Locke v. Davey, the last 'play in the joints' precedent after Trinity Lutheran, Espinoza and Carson; 22 states and seven other amici at the cert stage, and a ruling would govern religious-degree exclusions in every state tuition program. Scored below the lead case because this is a cert-before-judgment companion whose stakes are largely shared with Hall v. Fleming (No. 26-193).

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether states may exclude religious degree programs from generally available tuition aid, potentially overruling Locke, has substantial national religious-liberty and education-funding stakes despite this petition's before-judgment posture.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Ashton v. TalibanFamilies of 9/11 and embassy-bombing victims ask the Court to send their case back for reconsideration of whether the Taliban can claim sovereign immunity from asset-execution claims.Sovereignty & foreign relationsawaiting the Court
0.60
0.82
0.72
0.71

Kathleen Ashton, et al. v. The Taliban, et al.No. 26-293 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000293 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

Families of 9/11 and embassy-bombing victims ask the Court to send their case back for reconsideration of whether the Taliban can claim sovereign immunity from asset-execution claims.

What happened

Thousands of family members and estates of terrorism victims hold judgments against the Taliban and have tried to collect from frozen Afghan central bank assets held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. The Second Circuit ruled against them, holding that the bank and the Taliban are protected by sovereign immunity because the Executive Branch still formally recognizes Afghanistan as a state, and separately that the bank did not count as a Taliban "instrumentality" for a terrorism-judgment statute because of when its assets were frozen. Rehearing en banc was denied over dissents. The petitioners then asked the Supreme Court to review the case.

What the Court is being asked

The petitioners argue that a more recent Supreme Court decision, issued after the lower court ruled, clarified that courts—not the Executive Branch—must decide through ordinary legal analysis whether an entity counts as a foreign state entitled to immunity. They ask the Court to set aside the lower court's ruling and send the case back so the appeals court can apply that clarified approach to decide whether the Taliban and the bank are immune.

Where it stands

The petition was filed in August 2026, and an amicus brief was filed in October 2026. The case was distributed for conference in early November 2026 and then distributed again for a second conference in mid-November 2026; the docket shows no decision yet on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The Ashton petitioners, who lost in the Second Circuit, are asking the Court to step in. If the Court grants the petition, it could vacate the lower court's ruling and send the case back for reconsideration under the newer legal standard, deciding nothing yet about who ultimately wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Second Circuit's ruling favoring the Taliban and the bank on immunity stands, leaving the petitioners unable to collect on their judgments through this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Ashton's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Ashton's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Prediction: the Supreme Court will most likely refuse to hear this case (deny certiorari). We put the chance it takes the case in some form at about one in four. These victims of terrorism ask the Court to send their dispute over frozen Afghan central-bank money back to the appeals court in light of a recent ruling. That ruling concerned Cuba and fits this case only loosely. The Court has delayed its decision once, along with two related petitions. That delay raises the odds somewhat, but most such petitions are still turned away.

    Why this big-case score: Billions in frozen Da Afghanistan Bank assets, 9/11 victims' TRIA execution rights, and FSIA treatment of an unrecognized regime; this petition itself asks only for a narrow GVR.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.83·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of granting some form of review. Families of terrorism victims want access to Afghan central-bank money. Their request has received additional consideration, but a separate legal obstacle may remain even if the Court accepts their argument about government immunity. If the Court intervenes, it would more likely send the case back for another look than immediately decide who gets the money. No written explanation is expected if review is denied.

    Why this big-case score: Access to billions in Afghan central-bank assets for thousands of terrorism victims raises substantial sovereign-immunity, recognition, and foreign-relations stakes, independently of review prospects.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny this petition for review, with only about a one-in-eight chance (13%) of taking the case or sending it back to the lower court. The petitioners, families of September 11 victims holding terrorism judgments against the Taliban, seek to collect $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central bank funds and ask the Court to send the case back in light of a recent sovereign-immunity ruling (*Cimex*). However, the appeals court already ruled that the federal terrorism-judgment statute overrides foreign sovereign immunity, and it blocked recovery for an independent reason that *Cimex* does not affect: the Afghan central bank was not controlled by the Taliban on the day the United States froze the funds.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes foreign-relations and sovereign-immunity dispute over whether 9/11 terrorism judgment creditors can attach $3.5 billion in blocked Afghan central bank reserves under the FSIA and TRIA.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Prediction: the Supreme Court will most likely turn this petition away, but there is about a 30% chance it grants some relief. Victims of 9/11 and other terrorism are trying to collect court judgments from Afghan central-bank money frozen in New York. This petition asks the Court to send the case back to the appeals court for a fresh look after a recent Supreme Court ruling on when foreign governments are immune from suit. The Court has already put it on a second conference, which signals interest. It may ask the federal government for its views before deciding.

    Why this big-case score: About $3.5B in Afghan central-bank reserves, 9/11 judgment creditors, and FSIA/TRIA questions entangled with Executive recognition and foreign policy.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to decline review, with about a seven-in-ten chance of no grant and a 28% chance of taking action that favors further review. The petition concerns terrorism victims' access to frozen Afghan central-bank funds. The Court's decision to consider it at another meeting makes review more plausible than usual. But the new ruling cited by the victims does not directly resolve the lower court's main obstacle: when the bank must have come under Taliban control. Related petitions remain another possible path to review.

    Why this big-case score: Billions in Afghan central-bank reserves, compensation for terrorism victims, sovereign immunity, and the boundary between judicial power and diplomatic recognition.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant this petition, with about a one-in-five chance (22%) of review, and will most likely deny it. Families of September 11 victims seek $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank funds to satisfy terrorism judgments against the Taliban, and five Second Circuit judges dissented when the appeals court blocked recovery. Even after an initial relist—delaying consideration to another conference—the Court typically denies review where, as here, no other federal appeals court has disagreed on this unique post-2021 Afghanistan dispute and the Executive Branch opposes turning over the central-bank reserves.

    Why this big-case score: Roughly $3.5 billion in frozen Afghan central-bank reserves and compensation for 9/11 and 1998 Embassy bombing victims are at stake across three consolidated petitions, implicating separation-of-powers questions under the FSIA and TRIA.

Majestic Realty v. SalazarThe Court declined to hear shopping center owners' bid to overturn a ruling requiring them to allow an activist's leafletting on their property.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.70
0.68
0.75
0.71

Majestic Realty Co., et al. v. Alex SalazarNo. 25-1322 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500223 · models differ by up to 0.07 · topic: Constitutional rights (also First Amendment)

The Court declined to hear shopping center owners' bid to overturn a ruling requiring them to allow an activist's leafletting on their property.

What happened

Majestic Realty and related companies own shopping centers in Redlands, California, that ban leafletting and similar activity. Alex Salazar, an activist, asked to distribute leaflets about men's child-support obligations; the centers refused under their policy. Salazar sued, arguing California's constitution protected his activity, relying on a 1979 California Supreme Court case affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court. The trial court denied him a preliminary injunction, but the California Court of Appeal reversed, ruling Salazar was likely to succeed and that the owners' federal constitutional objections had already been rejected. The California Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state violates property owners' rights against uncompensated takings and against being forced to host speech when it requires commercial property owners to let people conduct unwanted expressive activity, like leafletting, on their land, and whether the Court's 1980 precedent allowing this should be overturned.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the docket shows the petition was denied on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Majestic Realty and the other property owners asked the Court to take the case and overturn the California Court of Appeal's ruling. The denial leaves that ruling in place, meaning Salazar's preliminary injunction against the centers' leafletting ban stands, and the case returns to the lower courts for further proceedings. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning or decided the constitutional questions the owners raised; it simply leaves the existing precedent and the appellate decision undisturbed for now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would put the overruling of PruneYard (1980) squarely in play, reshaping speech access on private commercial property in California, New Jersey, Colorado and Massachusetts and the ballot-initiative signature economy that rides on it; stakes if decided are high even though the grant odds are low.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Overruling PruneYard could materially change state-protected expressive access to shopping centers and the boundary between property rights and compelled speech. Those substantial constitutional stakes are distinct from the low likelihood of review in this preliminary-injunction posture.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A direct challenge to PruneYard by the Pacific Legal Foundation raises major Takings and First Amendment questions.

Thomas Crowther, et al. v. Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, et al.Two former university employees ask the Court to decide whether Title IX lets employees sue for sex discrimination in their jobs, rather than only under Title VII.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.55
0.72
0.85
0.71

Thomas Crowther, et al. v. Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, et al.No. 25-183 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274866 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Employment & discrimination

Two former university employees ask the Court to decide whether Title IX lets employees sue for sex discrimination in their jobs, rather than only under Title VII.

What happened

MaChelle Joseph, a women's basketball coach, and Thomas Crowther, an art professor, both lost their jobs at Georgia public universities and sued under Title IX, the law barring sex discrimination at federally funded schools. Joseph alleged her program got fewer resources than the men's team and that she was fired for complaining; Crowther alleged bias in a sexual-harassment investigation that led to his non-renewal. The district courts split on whether Title IX allows such employment claims, given that Title VII already covers workplace discrimination. The Eleventh Circuit held that Title IX does not provide a private right to sue over employment discrimination, dismissing Joseph's claim and ordering dismissal of Crowther's.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law that bars schools receiving federal money from discriminating "on the basis of sex" lets employees, not just students, sue directly under that law for job-related discrimination, or whether only the separate federal employment-discrimination law provides that remedy for workers.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, received briefing including a Solicitor General brief supporting the universities, and heard argument on November 30, 2026; the case now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Crowther and Joseph, as petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Eleventh Circuit's ruling against their Title IX employment claims. If the Court affirms, the Eleventh Circuit's decision stands: employees like Crowther and Joseph could not use Title IX to sue over job discrimination, leaving Title VII as their only avenue. If the Court reverses, employees of federally funded schools could sue directly under Title IX for workplace sex discrimination, and the case would return to the lower courts to address Crowther's and Joseph's claims on that basis. The Court could also vacate and send the case back without resolving the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Nov 30, 2026
  2. Decided

If the Court affirms: the lower court's ruling stands. · If the Court reverses or vacates: the ruling is overturned or sent back.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 35%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Categorical question about Title IX employment coverage for every federally funded school; heavy institutional amicus interest, though Title VII remains available so practical stakes are bounded.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 18%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case will determine nationwide whether educational employees may bypass Title VII's limits through Title IX, resolving an entrenched circuit conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 35%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 42%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decides whether every employee of a federally funded school or university may sue under Title IX for sex discrimination in employment, resolving an 8-3 circuit split and reshaping implied-right-of-action doctrine; broad institutional reach, though Title VII remains available to most of the affected workers.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 35%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case determines access to a nationwide employment-discrimination remedy for workers at federally funded educational institutions. Its significance is substantial, but Title VII, administrative Title IX enforcement, and student-protective retaliation claims limit the consequences of an adverse ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 35%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
GEO Group v. NwauzorGEO Group asks the Court to overturn rulings that it must pay Washington's minimum wage to immigrant detainees who work at its privately run federal detention facility.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.60
0.74
0.78
0.71

The GEO Group, Inc., a Florida Corporation v. Ugochukwu Nwauzor, et al.No. 25-828 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279966 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Employment & discrimination (also Immigration)

GEO Group asks the Court to overturn rulings that it must pay Washington's minimum wage to immigrant detainees who work at its privately run federal detention facility.

What happened

GEO Group operates a federal immigration detention facility in Tacoma, Washington, under contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Detainees there could work in a voluntary program, usually earning $1 a day. Washington state and a class of detainees sued, arguing this violated the state's minimum wage law. After a jury trial and related proceedings, GEO lost, was ordered to pay back wages and turn over profits, and was enjoined from continuing the program without paying minimum wage. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, rejecting GEO's arguments that the federal Constitution shields it from the state law. GEO's request for rehearing by the full Ninth Circuit was denied, with several judges dissenting.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state can require a private company holding federal immigration detainees to pay them the state's minimum wage for work performed in a federal program, even though the state does not impose that same wage requirement on detainees held in its own government-run facilities, and even though federal law caps what the government will reimburse the company for such pay.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference in April 2026; the Court then invited the Solicitor General to weigh in, and the government's brief, filed in September 2026, recommended that the Court take the case. The parties have since filed supplemental briefs, and the case has been distributed for conference again, most recently for November 13, 2026, without a recorded decision yet on whether to hear it.

What each outcome would mean

GEO Group is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit, which ruled against it. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions itself; a grant alone would not determine who wins. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, meaning GEO must comply with Washington's minimum wage law and the damages awards against it remain in place. A denial would not mean the Court agrees the lower court was right, only that the case ends there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up GEO Group's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: GEO Group's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 4 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Supremacy Clause limits on state regulation of federal immigration-detention contractors, with the SG as amicus, a $37M judgment, a nationwide private-detention footprint and a companion petition (No. 26-71); significant for immigration federalism but a narrow wage question rather than a blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially important boundary between state wage protections and federal immigration contractors' immunity, with consequences for detained workers and government contracting beyond the approximately $37 million judgment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High stakes involving federal-state supremacy, immigration detainee compensation, and a major circuit split with a large monetary judgment.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think the Supreme Court will probably agree to hear this case (about a 72% chance). GEO Group runs a federal immigration detention center in Washington State under contract with the federal government. The question is whether Washington can make GEO pay detainees in a voluntary work program the state minimum wage. The Court asked the federal government's top lawyer, the Solicitor General, for advice, and the government recommended taking the case. It also pointed out that another federal appeals court decided a similar question the opposite way.

    Why this big-case score: Supremacy Clause limits on state labor law applied to federal immigration-detention contractors; national reach for detention operations and a ~$37M judgment, but a narrow doctrinal slice.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely than not to hear GEO Group's challenge, with about a seven-in-ten chance of review. The case asks whether Washington can require minimum wages for immigration detainees working at a privately operated federal detention center. The federal government's top Supreme Court lawyer recommends review, and the justices have scheduled another discussion. But opponents dispute the claimed disagreement among courts and say changed detention standards reduce the case's future importance. A grant would not itself decide who wins.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of state wage protections for immigration detainees and constitutional protection of federal contractors has substantial nationwide labor, detention, and federalism stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will grant review in *The GEO Group, Inc. v. Nwauzor*, making it likely—at a 72% chance—that the Justices will hear the appeal. The case asks whether the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, which makes federal law supreme over conflicting state laws, bars Washington from forcing a private contractor running a federal immigration detention center to pay detained workers the state minimum wage of over $17 per hour instead of the $1-per-day federal program allowance. A grant is likely because the Court asked the U.S. Solicitor General—the federal government's top appellate lawyer—for the government's views, the Solicitor General strongly urged the Court to take the case, seven appellate judges dissented below, and the Court has relisted the petition for a second look at conference.

    Why this big-case score: Major Supremacy Clause dispute over whether states may impose minimum-wage mandates on federal immigration detainees working in contractor-run ICE detention facilities.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether states may impose minimum-wage law on federal immigration detainees at contractor-run federal facilities: a Supremacy Clause question for the whole private-detention model, a $37 million judgment, a suspended federal work program, and a live federal-state conflict over immigration enforcement. Significant and politically salient, though doctrinally incremental on United States v. Washington (2022).

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute connects immigration detention, detainee compensation, and state regulation of federal contractors, with potential effects beyond one facility. Its stakes are substantial, although the particular wage statute and contract could limit the eventual holding.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile clash between state labor laws and federal immigration detention, impacting thousands of detainees and federal contractors.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the Solicitor General filed the brief the Court invited. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-sg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Supremacy Clause / intergovernmental-immunity question about state labor law reaching federal immigration-detention contractors nationwide; ~$37M judgment, a 3d Cir. tension, and the United States urging review.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 86%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Consequential for immigration detainees' compensation and state regulation of federal detention contractors, with potential implications for federal contracting beyond immigration.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major constitutional and federalism question concerning whether states may impose minimum-wage laws on federal immigration detainees in contractor-operated ICE detention facilities, carrying nationwide operational consequences for federal detention contracting and intergovernmental immunity doctrine.

Trump v. Cable News NetworkTrump asks the Court to revive his defamation lawsuit against CNN over its use of the phrase "Big Lie" in coverage of his 2020 election challenges.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.60
0.86
0.65
0.70

Donald J. Trump v. Cable News Network, Inc.No. 26-223 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000223 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: First Amendment

Trump asks the Court to revive his defamation lawsuit against CNN over its use of the phrase "Big Lie" in coverage of his 2020 election challenges.

What happened

Trump sued CNN for defamation, arguing that CNN's repeated use of the phrase "Big Lie," paired with comparisons to Hitler and Goebbels, falsely accused him of knowingly lying about the 2020 election. A federal district court dismissed the suit, ruling that CNN's statements were protected opinion rather than factual claims capable of being proven false, and separately found Trump had not adequately alleged CNN acted with the required malice. The court also denied Trump's bids for reconsideration and to amend his complaint. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, agreeing the statements were not verifiable factual assertions.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether news organizations can be held liable for defamation when they use a harsh label, combined with provocative imagery, that a reasonable reader could understand to accuse someone of specific false facts—or whether using such a label and imagery instead keeps the statements protected as opinion, even when the label is tied to pointed factual claims.

Where it stands

CNN waived its right to respond, but the Court later asked for a response anyway, and the petition was distributed for the October 9, 2026 conference. The docket does not record any action taken at that conference. CNN's deadline to respond has since been extended to November 25, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Trump, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Eleventh Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of Trump's lawsuit stays in place, and CNN's win stands. A denial would not mean the Court agrees the lower court was right—only that the case ends there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Trump's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Trump's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Donald Trump's request to revive his defamation lawsuit against CNN over its "Big Lie" coverage — we put the chance it agrees to hear the case at about one in twenty. The Court asked CNN to file a response, which shows someone looked at the petition, but that often happens when a prominent party files. The lower court's short ruling treated the phrase as opinion rather than a provably false fact, and the case is a poor vehicle for the Court.

    Why this big-case score: A sitting President's personal defamation suit against a national news network draws heavy public attention; the doctrinal question (Milkovich fact/opinion line for pejorative labels) is real but narrower than a direct challenge to New York Times v. Sullivan.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.86·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Donald Trump's request to review the dismissal of his defamation lawsuit against CNN. I put the chance of review, including a short order sending the case back, at about one in eight (12%). Asking CNN to respond shows some interest, but the case may turn on how existing rules apply to particular political statements rather than a clear disagreement among courts. A denial would leave the dismissal in place without necessarily endorsing its reasoning.

    Why this big-case score: A President's personal defamation suit against a major news network presents potentially broad consequences for political reporting and the fact/opinion boundary; significance is high even though review is unlikely.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Donald Trump's request to review the dismissal of his defamation lawsuit against CNN, with only about a 1 in 25 chance (4%) of taking the case. Although the Court asked CNN to file a written response after the network initially waived its right to do so, the lower courts applied settled free-speech law in holding that CNN's references to Trump's 2020 election challenges as "the Big Lie" were protected political opinion rather than provably false statements of fact.

    Why this big-case score: High public and political salience involving the sitting President's personal-capacity defamation suit against a major news network over 'the Big Lie' characterization and First Amendment opinion doctrine under Milkovich.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A sitting President's defamation suit against a major network on the Milkovich opinion/fact line, with Sullivan-adjacent stakes; high public salience but the legal question is fact-bound and narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally prominent political figure's defamation suit against a major news organization presents consequential questions about factual allegations embedded in political rhetoric. A broad ruling could affect press protections well beyond these parties; stakes are distinct from grant odds.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Patrick Morrisey, Governor of West Virginia, et al. v. Jonathan R., Minor, by Next Friend, Sarah Dixon, et al.West Virginia officials ask the Court to shut down foster children's lawsuit seeking court-ordered reform of the state's foster-care system.awaiting the Court
0.62
0.76
0.72
0.70

Patrick Morrisey, Governor of West Virginia, et al. v. Jonathan R., Minor, by Next Friend, Sarah Dixon, et al.No. 26-297 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000297 · models differ by up to 0.14

West Virginia officials ask the Court to shut down foster children's lawsuit seeking court-ordered reform of the state's foster-care system.

What happened

Foster children sued West Virginia officials in 2019, claiming the state's foster-care system violated their constitutional and statutory rights through understaffing, abuse, and inadequate placements. After years of litigation, a federal district court dismissed the case, ruling it lacked power to grant the sweeping institutional changes the children sought and so could not redress their claims. The Fourth Circuit reversed, holding that federal courts have both the power and duty to oversee reform of state institutions. It also declined to review West Virginia's challenge to the lower court's class-certification order, reasoning that order was no longer appealable once the dismissal was reversed. West Virginia now asks the Supreme Court to review both rulings.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a lawsuit can proceed when the only remedy that would work requires a federal court to take over management of a state agency, and whether a rule letting courts quickly review class-certification orders prevents an appeals court from reviewing such an order later, after it becomes part of a final judgment on appeal.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of November 6, 2026, after the children waived their right to respond; the Court then asked for a response, and the deadline for that response has since been extended to December 8, 2026. No conference has yet considered the petition on its merits.

What each outcome would mean

West Virginia, which lost in the Fourth Circuit, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case and decide whether the lawsuit can proceed and whether the class-certification order was reviewable. If the Court denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's ruling stands, and the case returns to the lower courts, where the children's lawsuit would continue and the class-certification order would not be reviewed on this appeal.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 8, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    West Virginia asks the Supreme Court to review an appeals-court ruling that let a class-action lawsuit seeking a court-supervised overhaul of the state's foster-care system go forward. I predict the Court will most likely turn the case down, though the chance it agrees to hear it is meaningful: about three in ten. Twenty-two states support West Virginia, and the Court asked the children's lawyers to respond. But the case is still at an early stage, since no court order has yet been entered against the state, and the Court refused an earlier appeal in the same lawsuit.

    Why this big-case score: Article III limits on structural-reform injunctions over state agencies; child-welfare class actions pending in many States; 22-State amicus coalition.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 43%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to decline this case than hear it: I estimate a 43% chance of review. West Virginia challenges federal supervision of its foster-care system and an appeals court's refusal to examine the lawsuit's class certification, which allows children to sue as a group. Disagreement among appeals courts about when that certification can be reviewed makes the petition substantial. But no final reform order has been imposed, and all three lower-court judges agreed some relief could be considered.

    Why this big-case score: Potential nationwide limits on federal oversight of state foster-care institutions; the separate class-action appellate issue has broader procedural significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny West Virginia's petition for review, with about an one-in-five (18%) chance of a grant. West Virginia asks the Court to block a class-action lawsuit seeking broad court-ordered reforms to the state's foster-care system and to review the lower court's certification of the plaintiff class. Although one appeals judge dissented on whether the appellate court should have reviewed the class-certification order now, all three appeals judges agreed that dismissing the entire lawsuit before trial was premature because no court order managing the agency has actually been issued yet.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, Question 1 could reshape federal equitable authority to issue structural-reform injunctions over state agencies nationwide after Trump v. CASA, Inc., and Question 2 addresses appellate review of class certification under Rule 23(f) and the merger rule.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    West Virginia asks the Supreme Court to stop a lawsuit in which foster children seek a federal-court overhaul of the State's foster-care system. We predict the Court will probably say no (roughly a 30% chance it takes the case). Signs of interest are real: the Court asked the children's lawyers to respond, and 22 States filed in support. But the case is still at an early stage, because no court order has yet changed the system, and the Court turned away an earlier appeal in this same lawsuit in 2022.

    Why this big-case score: Federal-court power over state institutional-reform litigation (foster care, said to be pending in 34 States) plus a Rule 23(f) merger split; national reach, but it is a standing/class-cert vehicle, not a merits ruling on any program.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to decline this case than hear it; I put the chance of review at about two in five, or 42%. West Virginia challenges federal oversight of its foster-care system and a ruling preventing immediate review of class-action certification. The appellate-procedure dispute presents the stronger reason for review because other appeals courts have taken a different approach. But the broader challenge may be premature: no reform order has been entered, and every panel judge agreed some lawful relief could be available.

    Why this big-case score: The requested restriction on federal oversight of state institutions could affect child-welfare and other institutional-reform litigation nationally; the appellate-review question also reaches class actions generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very unlikely to hear this appeal, with about a one-in-eight chance (12%) of granting review and an 88% chance of denying West Virginia's petition. In this lawsuit over West Virginia's foster-care system, a federal trial judge threw out the entire case before trial, ruling that courts lack power to order broad agency reforms, and all three appellate judges agreed that dismissing the whole lawsuit before deciding whether the state broke the law was premature. Although one appellate judge dissented over whether the appeals court should also review the trial court's "class certification" order—the ruling allowing thousands of foster children to sue together as a group—the case is still in the middle of proceedings in the trial court, which can reconsider the group status and pending motions on its own, making Supreme Court intervention unlikely now.

    Why this big-case score: Statewide structural-reform class action challenging West Virginia's foster-care system supported by a 22-State amicus coalition; if decided on the merits, a ruling on Article III redressability for institutional-reform decrees or Rule 23(f) merger on conditional cross-appeals would have broad doctrinal impact across federal civil and institutional-reform litigation.

Herlihy v. DBMPAsbestos claimants ask the Court to decide whether DBMP's bankruptcy, created through a corporate split to isolate asbestos liabilities, was filed in bad faith.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.60
0.78
0.72
0.70

Michael Herlihy, et al. v. DBMP, LLCNo. 26-394 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000394 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Business & finance

Asbestos claimants ask the Court to decide whether DBMP's bankruptcy, created through a corporate split to isolate asbestos liabilities, was filed in bad faith.

What happened

Michael and Ann Herlihy and the Estate of Peter Bergrud sued DBMP and its corporate family over asbestos exposure that caused mesothelioma. CertainTeed, DBMP's corporate predecessor, split itself into two companies, keeping most assets in one and assigning asbestos liabilities to the other, DBMP, which then filed for bankruptcy. This triggered an automatic pause on lawsuits against DBMP. The claimants asked the bankruptcy court to lift that pause, arguing DBMP's filing was made in bad faith since it was financially healthy. The bankruptcy court and district court disagreed, and a divided Fourth Circuit panel affirmed, with a dissenting judge calling the maneuver an abuse of bankruptcy law.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a company's use of this corporate-split-and-bankruptcy strategy to handle tort liabilities, when the company is not in financial distress, counts as bad faith sufficient to justify lifting the automatic pause on lawsuits during the bankruptcy.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference. After DBMP initially waived its right to respond, the Court requested a response, due November 30, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Herlihys and the Bergrud estate, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up their case and reverse the Fourth Circuit's ruling, which left DBMP's bankruptcy protections in place. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case and decide the legal question; this would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands, leaving the pause on the claimants' lawsuits against DBMP in effect while the bankruptcy proceeds.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 30, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Herlihy's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Herlihy's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear this case (about a 7% chance it takes it). Asbestos victims are challenging the "Texas Two-Step," where a healthy company spins its injury liabilities into a new shell company and puts only that shell into bankruptcy, which freezes the lawsuits. The Court has asked the company to respond, and several groups and States back the victims. But the Court turned down two similar challenges, most recently in June 2026.

    Why this big-case score: Texas Two-Step good-faith question affects thousands of asbestos claimants and recurring mass-tort bankruptcies, with a claimed 3d/4th Cir. split; narrow §362(d) posture limits it somewhat.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, although I put the chance of review at about one in four, or 24%. The case challenges a corporate maneuver that puts asbestos claims into bankruptcy while the operating business continues outside it. Conflicting legal standards, five supporting outside briefs, and the Court's request for a response make review plausible. But this appeal concerns lifting a pause on particular lawsuits, rather than directly dismissing the bankruptcy, which may make it a less suitable case for settling the broader dispute.

    Why this big-case score: The question affects access to the civil courts for many asbestos claimants and the use of solvent-company restructurings to obtain bankruptcy protections; the particular vehicle is a narrower stay-relief appeal.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to hear this appeal, with about a one-in-seven chance (14%) of granting review. Although the case raises an important disagreement among federal appeals courts over the "Texas Two-Step"—a controversial corporate restructuring tactic used here by building-products company CertainTeed to place its asbestos lawsuits into a separate subsidiary's bankruptcy—this specific lawsuit has serious procedural flaws that make it a poor test case. Rather than asking to dismiss the entire bankruptcy at the outset, two individual plaintiffs waited years into the bankruptcy to ask for a special exemption from the automatic pause on lawsuits (known as the "automatic stay"), and the lower court found they forfeited a key legal argument along the way. Even though the Supreme Court asked the company to file a written response after the company initially waived its right to respond, the Court will likely deny review once that response highlights these procedural obstacles.

    Why this big-case score: High stakes if decided: resolving the Fourth/Third Circuit split over the Chapter 11 good-faith requirement for 'Texas Two-Step' divisional-merger bankruptcies would reshape mass-tort corporate reorganization practice nationwide.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will probably **not** take this case, giving it about a one-in-five chance of review. Asbestos victims are challenging the "Texas Two-Step," in which a profitable company splits off its injury liabilities into a new company that then files for bankruptcy. The Court has asked the company to respond and several groups, including a coalition of states, back the petition, which raises the odds. But the case comes in the middle of an ongoing bankruptcy, and the claimed disagreement between appeals courts is debatable.

    Why this big-case score: Texas Two-Step legitimacy governs tens of thousands of stayed asbestos suits and a recurring mass-tort bankruptcy strategy; a state coalition filed in support.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, although I estimate about a one-in-four chance it agrees to review it. The dispute concerns whether a financially healthy business can shift asbestos claims into a separate company and use bankruptcy to pause victims' lawsuits. Conflicting legal standards, five supporting outside briefs, and the Court's request for a response make review a serious possibility. But this appeal concerns lifting a lawsuit pause, not dismissing the bankruptcy itself, which may make it an imperfect case for resolving the broader dispute.

    Why this big-case score: Whether solvent enterprises can channel mass asbestos liabilities into bankruptcy through a Texas Two-Step affects many injured claimants, access to civil courts, and nationwide mass-tort restructuring practices.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny this petition for review, with about a one-in-seven (14%) chance of granting it. Although the Court asked DBMP to file a response and five outside groups filed briefs supporting the asbestos claimants on an important dispute over "Texas Two-Step" corporate bankruptcies, the Court turned down a nearly identical asbestos bankruptcy appeal from the same appellate court just five months ago. Moreover, this appeal involves only two individual claimants asking to pause the bankruptcy freeze ("automatic stay") for their own state lawsuits rather than a direct request to dismiss the entire bankruptcy case, making it a flawed procedural vehicle for a national ruling.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided on the merits, a ruling on whether the Texas Two-Step and Chapter 11 section 524(g) asbestos trusts require financial distress would reshape mass-tort bankruptcy practice nationwide and govern tens of thousands of tort claims.

Poore v. United StatesA man sentenced under a longer prison term asks the Court to decide whether judges may defer to Sentencing Commission commentary when interpreting sentencing rules.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.50
0.74
0.85
0.70

Raymond Poore v. United StatesNo. 25-227 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73275168 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Criminal law

A man sentenced under a longer prison term asks the Court to decide whether judges may defer to Sentencing Commission commentary when interpreting sentencing rules.

What happened

Raymond Poore pleaded guilty to illegally possessing a firearm. At sentencing, the district court classified his earlier state conviction for battery, committed as a party to the crime, as a "crime of violence," which raised his guideline range. That classification rested on commentary accompanying the relevant sentencing guideline, not the guideline's own text. Poore argued this commentary deserved no deference after two recent Supreme Court decisions limiting when courts defer to agencies' interpretations of their own rules. The Seventh Circuit disagreed, holding itself bound by earlier circuit precedent, and affirmed his 42-month sentence. Poore asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether recent rulings limiting how much courts must defer to an agency's own interpretation of its rules also limit how much deference courts give to the Sentencing Commission's explanatory notes when those notes interpret the sentencing guidelines, including here where the notes classified Poore's offense as a "crime of violence."

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for multiple conferences since January 2026, most recently April 17, 2026, and the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case. The government opposes review, arguing in part that the case is moot because Poore has completed his prison term.

What each outcome would mean

Poore, the petitioner, asks the Court to take up his case and reverse the Seventh Circuit's ruling, which the government, as respondent, defends. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on the deference question and decide it; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Seventh Circuit's decision upholding Poore's longer sentence stands, though this would not mean the Supreme Court agrees with that ruling.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Poore's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Poore's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 57%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents the post-Loper Bright fate of Stinson deference across an acknowledged 6-6, twelve-circuit split affecting thousands of federal sentencings (Katyal counsel, NCLA amicus, CFR, nine relists) - but this docket is now the trailing hold behind the granted companion vehicle, so its own disposition will be a footnote.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns a mature circuit split over a rule that can materially affect federal sentences across half the country.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises major question on whether Loper Bright applies to Sentencing Commission commentary, amidst 12-circuit split.

Calvary Chapel San Jose v. CaliforniaA church fined over $1 million for ignoring a county's pandemic mask rule asks the Court to find the rule unconstitutional and reduce the penalty.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.55
0.78
0.75
0.69

Calvary Chapel San Jose, et al. v. California, et al.No. 25-703 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279552 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: First Amendment

A church fined over $1 million for ignoring a county's pandemic mask rule asks the Court to find the rule unconstitutional and reduce the penalty.

What happened

During the COVID-19 pandemic, Santa Clara County required face coverings in indoor spaces, including churches, with narrow exceptions for young children and people with medical conditions. Calvary Chapel San Jose and its pastor refused to comply, and the county fined them more than $1.2 million. California's trial court and court of appeal both upheld the fines, finding the mask rule neutral and generally applicable and the fines proportional to the church's conduct. California's supreme court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a health rule with several narrow exceptions still counts as evenhanded, or whether those exceptions mean the rule should instead face the toughest level of judicial review when it burdens religious practice. The petition also asks the Court to create a new exemption for religious ceremonies from the general rule that neutral laws don't need special justification, or to abandon that general rule entirely, and whether fines of this size for violating a mask rule are so large compared to the conduct involved that they cross a constitutional line against excessive financial penalties.

Where it stands

The petition and the county's brief opposing review have both been filed, along with the church's reply and several outside groups' supporting briefs. The case was distributed for the justices' conference on April 24, 2026, and the docket shows no action since.

What each outcome would mean

Calvary Chapel, the church, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the rulings against it. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the questions itself, deciding nothing yet about who is right. If it denies review, the California Court of Appeal's decision upholding the fines and the mask rule stands, leaving the county's win in place and the church responsible for the fines as ordered.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Calvary Chapel San Jose's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Calvary Chapel San Jose's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A $1.2M fine on a church for COVID-era worship, an explicit ask to overrule Employment Division v. Smith, seven cert-stage amici including a multistate brief, and marquee religious-liberty counsel make this closely watched, though the decision below is unpublished and the rule long rescinded.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 29%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling could reshape Smith, church autonomy, pandemic-era Free Exercise doctrine, or constitutional limits on million-dollar civil fines against a church.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High salience due to 7 cert-stage amicus briefs from prominent conservative and religious liberty organizations regarding COVID-19 fines.

Nielsen v. WatanabeA federal prison nurse asks the Court to overturn a ruling letting a former inmate sue him for damages over his medical care.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.60
0.78
0.68
0.69

Francis Nielsen v. Kekai WatanabeNo. 25-417 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73278422 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Constitutional rights

A federal prison nurse asks the Court to overturn a ruling letting a former inmate sue him for damages over his medical care.

What happened

Kekai Watanabe, injured in a prison fight at a federal facility in Honolulu, alleges that nurse Francis Nielsen refused his requests for hospital care and that he went undiagnosed for months before doctors found a fractured tailbone. Watanabe sued Nielsen for damages, invoking a line of cases, including Carlson v. Green, in which the Supreme Court has allowed such suits against federal officials despite the absence of a statute authorizing them. A federal district court dismissed the claim, reasoning that Watanabe's case differed too much from Carlson to qualify. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed, holding the claim was not meaningfully different from Carlson. The full Ninth Circuit declined to rehear the case over several judges' dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether prisoners in Watanabe's situation may sue individual federal officers for money damages over inadequate medical care, or whether that kind of claim is different enough from the Court's past cases that courts may not recognize it without Congress's say-so. The parties also dispute whether the Court should go further and eliminate this category of suit entirely, or even abandon the broader line of cases allowing damages suits against federal officials.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, and the case has been argued and now awaits decision. The government participated in the oral argument as well, supporting Nielsen's position.

What each outcome would mean

Nielsen, the prison nurse, is asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision, which allowed Watanabe's case to go forward. If the Court sides with Nielsen, Watanabe's suit would be dismissed, cutting off this avenue of compensation, and courts generally would be barred from hearing similar damages claims by federal prisoners over medical care. If the Court sides with Watanabe, the Ninth Circuit's decision allowing the case to proceed would stand, and Watanabe could continue pursuing his claim in the lower courts. A ruling could also address, more broadly, whether this entire category of suits against federal officials should continue to exist.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Nielsen wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Watanabe wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 93%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Likely vehicle for confining (or inviting the overruling of) Carlson v. Green and the remaining Bivens remedy, with direct stakes for all federal-prisoner damages suits; significant within federal-courts doctrine, though not a headline case for the general public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 89%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define how much of Carlson remains available to federal prisoners and materially affect constitutional damages actions nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Bivens case with the Solicitor General and nineteen States as amici and divided argument; the judgment will govern damages suits by every federal prisoner over medical care and may confine Carlson v. Green to its facts, though an outright overruling of Bivens is unlikely and the doctrine is already narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.73·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case can substantially narrow federal prisoners' constitutional damages remedies for denial of medical care and tests the survival of Carlson. Its nationwide remedial stakes exceed its individual injury dispute, although its immediate reach is federal prison litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 95%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifies the remaining boundaries of Bivens in the prison medical care context, which is significant for civil rights litigation but doctrinally predictable.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about nine in ten) reverse the lower court and block this former federal prisoner's lawsuit for money damages against a prison nurse over delayed medical care. Such suits rest on a court-created right to sue federal officers that the Court has refused to expand for decades, and at argument most Justices seemed to see this case as different from the one earlier case allowing such claims. Expected vote: about 7-2, with Justices Sotomayor and Jackson dissenting, and without formally overruling the earlier precedents.

    Why this big-case score: Decides whether Carlson v. Green's Eighth Amendment Bivens remedy survives for ordinary federal-prisoner medical-care claims (roughly two-thirds to three-quarters of all Bivens filings), with petitioner asking to overrule Bivens outright; doctrinally important, moderate public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to overturn the lower court's ruling: I put that chance at 88 percent and expect a seven-to-two vote. The likely decision would prevent Watanabe's personal damages suit against the prison nurse because his medical-treatment claim differs meaningfully from the emergency in an earlier Supreme Court case. Several Justices appeared open to that narrower approach. I expect the Court to leave some earlier protections intact rather than abolish all such lawsuits against federal officials.

    Why this big-case score: The case determines the practical availability of personal constitutional damages claims for medical mistreatment throughout the federal prison system and puts a longstanding Supreme Court remedy at risk, although the modal ruling is narrower than its elimination.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 94%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (94% chance) to reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision in an expected 6–3 ruling and throw out federal prisoner Kekai Watanabe's damages lawsuit against prison nurse Francis Nielsen. For 46 years, the Court has refused to expand *Bivens*—a 1971 precedent allowing people to sue federal officers personally for constitutional violations without a statute from Congress. Rather than formally overruling *Bivens* altogether, a conservative majority will likely hold that non-fatal prison medical disputes where administrative grievances, court injunctions, and Federal Tort Claims Act suits against the government are available must be left to Congress.

    Why this big-case score: Puts the continued vitality of Bivens and Carlson v. Green directly at issue and resolves whether federal prisoners retain a constitutional damages remedy for medical mistreatment, a category representing roughly two-thirds to three-quarters of all Bivens suits nationwide.

AstraZeneca UK Limited v. AtchleyAstraZeneca and other drug and medical-device makers ask the Court to shut down terrorism-financing lawsuits brought by American victims of attacks in Iraq.Sovereignty & foreign relationsawaiting the Court
0.62
0.72
0.72
0.69

AstraZeneca UK Limited, et al. v. Joshua Atchley, et al.No. 26-245 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000245 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

AstraZeneca and other drug and medical-device makers ask the Court to shut down terrorism-financing lawsuits brought by American victims of attacks in Iraq.

What happened

Joshua Atchley and hundreds of other Americans, or their families, were killed or injured by the Iraqi militia Jaysh al-Mahdi, which had taken over Iraq's Ministry of Health. They sued AstraZeneca and other pharmaceutical and medical-device companies under the federal Anti-Terrorism Act, claiming the companies paid bribes and supplied free goods to the Ministry knowing the militia was diverting them to fund attacks on Americans. A district court dismissed the case, but the D.C. Circuit twice revived it, most recently after this Court sent the case back for reconsideration in light of its ruling in a different case, Twitter v. Taamneh. The D.C. Circuit held the companies could be sued both for directly causing the harm and for aiding and abetting the militia's attacks.

What the Court is being asked

The companies ask the Court to decide two questions: first, whether a company can be sued for aiding and abetting terrorism when its assistance is not tied to any specific attack and when it did not act with any desire to help an attack succeed; and second, whether a company can be held directly responsible for a terrorist attack merely because it did business with a government agency that mostly performed legitimate functions but had allegedly been infiltrated by terrorists.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief opposing review, a reply, and amicus briefs. After being distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026, the Court did not grant or deny the petition; instead it invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard.

What each outcome would mean

AstraZeneca and the other drug and device makers, as petitioners, are asking the Court to overturn the D.C. Circuit's decision, which ruled in favor of Atchley and the other victims. If the Court eventually grants review and later reverses, the victims' lawsuit would likely be narrowed or dismissed. If the Court denies review, or grants review and affirms, the D.C. Circuit's decision allowing the lawsuit to proceed would stand, and the case would continue in the lower courts. A decision to vacate would set aside the D.C. Circuit's ruling and send the case back without resolving the issues for either side. The Solicitor General's views, once filed, may influence whether the Court takes the case at all.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up AstraZeneca UK Limited's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: AstraZeneca UK Limited's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Big drug companies are asking the Supreme Court to throw out lawsuits by U.S. service members and their families. The suits say the companies' business with Iraq's Health Ministry funded a militia that attacked Americans. We think the Court will most likely refuse to hear the case: about a one-in-five chance it agrees. Two things push the odds up: another appeals court applies the law differently, and the Court already sent this case back once. Two things hold them down: the case is at an early stage, and the dispute turns heavily on its particular facts. The Court may first ask the federal government for its views.

    Why this big-case score: Defines post-Taamneh ATA aiding-abetting and proximate-cause limits for corporate defendants doing business with foreign governments; 21 major pharma defendants, years of litigation, Chamber amicus; but a statutory, pleading-stage question rather than a constitutional one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this case, although I put the chance of review at about one in four, or 24%. The dispute asks when companies supplying an Iraqi government ministry can be held responsible for terrorist attacks allegedly financed through corrupt payments and diverted goods. The Court has examined an earlier version of the case, and the companies claim that appeals courts disagree. But the alleged conduct is unusually fact-specific, and the lawsuit has not reached a final judgment.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially substantial consequences for terrorism victims, multinational businesses, and humanitarian operations in conflict zones, but the questions concern statutory liability and pleading rather than a broad constitutional rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to hear this appeal, with about a one-in-seven (14%) chance of granting review and an 86% chance of denying the petition. Although the case involves major healthcare companies and returns to the Court after it previously ordered the lower court to reconsider the lawsuit under recent Supreme Court precedent, the D.C. Circuit thoroughly applied that precedent on remand, the case is still at an early preliminary stage before trial evidence has been gathered, and no outside groups filed supporting briefs.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes Antiterrorism Act litigation against five major multinational healthcare corporations returning to the Court after a 2024 GVR, testing the post-Twitter v. Taamneh boundaries of secondary and direct terrorism liability for companies operating in conflict zones.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Drug and medical-device companies that supplied Iraq's Health Ministry ask the Supreme Court to throw out a lawsuit by U.S. service members and their families. The suit says the companies helped fund a militia that attacked them. The Court has asked the Solicitor General (the government's Supreme Court lawyer) for the government's view. That request makes review far more likely than usual. Still, we put the chance that the Court takes the case at a bit under even, about 44%. The main reason against is that the case is at an early stage: no trial or final judgment yet.

    Why this big-case score: Scope of ATA secondary and direct liability after Taamneh for multinationals dealing with foreign governments; recurring, high-dollar, D.C./2d Cir. split claimed.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to decline review, although I give the drug companies about a 46% chance of getting the case heard or sent back for reconsideration. The lawsuit concerns alleged payments that helped finance attacks on Americans in Iraq. The Court's request for the federal government's advice makes this a serious candidate for review. But the case is still at an early stage, and the alleged disagreement among appeals courts may depend more on different facts than different legal rules.

    Why this big-case score: Substantial consequences for terrorism victims, multinational suppliers, humanitarian operations, and the relationship between private liability and US foreign policy; narrower than a general constitutional landmark.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 43%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will likely deny review in this case, though the odds of the Court taking the case are substantial—about two in five (43%). Five global pharmaceutical and medical-device companies ask the Court to dismiss a lawsuit claiming that corrupt payments and free medical supplies they allegedly gave to Iraq's terrorist-infiltrated Ministry of Health helped fund attacks on Americans during the Iraq War. Because the Court has asked the U.S. Solicitor General—the federal government's top appellate lawyer—for the government's views a second time after an earlier remand, the Court is watching the case closely, but the early procedural stage of the lawsuit makes a denial slightly more likely than full review.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes Antiterrorism Act and JASTA corporate secondary-liability suit against five global pharmaceutical and medical-device groups over Iraq War attacks, testing the scope of aiding-and-abetting and proximate-cause standards after Twitter, Inc. v. Taamneh and Smith & Wesson.

Daniel Defense v. LowyGun manufacturers ask the Court to throw out a lawsuit by shooting victims, arguing the victims cannot show their injuries are legally traceable to the companies' marketing.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.73
0.72
0.68

Daniel Defense, LLC, et al. v. Karen Lowy, Individually and as Parent and Next Friend of N. T., et al.No. 26-60 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000060 · models differ by up to 0.13

Gun manufacturers ask the Court to throw out a lawsuit by shooting victims, arguing the victims cannot show their injuries are legally traceable to the companies' marketing.

What happened

Karen Lowy and Antonio Harris were shot in 2022 outside a Washington, D.C. school by a young man using weapons made by Daniel Defense and other manufacturers. They sued the manufacturers in Virginia federal court, claiming deceptive marketing encouraged the shooter to use these products violently. A district court dismissed the case, ruling the victims could not show their injuries were sufficiently connected to the marketing. The Fourth Circuit reversed, holding the complaints plausibly alleged that connection, under either of two legal tests it considered. One judge dissented.

What the Court is being asked

The manufacturers ask the Court to decide what a person suing over harm caused by someone else's criminal act must show to prove the harm is legally connected to the defendant's conduct, when the complaint does not allege that the person who committed the act actually saw the defendant's marketing. The manufacturers say appeals courts disagree on how strong that connection must be; the victims respond that the asserted disagreement does not really exist and would not change the outcome here.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for December 4, 2026, after the victims filed a brief opposing review and the manufacturers filed a reply. No order on the petition has been recorded yet.

What each outcome would mean

The manufacturers, who lost in the Fourth Circuit, are asking the Court to take up and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on what showing is required and decide the question itself, without yet determining who wins. If it denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands, and the victims' lawsuit continues in the lower courts, where the manufacturers could still raise other defenses, including a federal law shielding gun makers from certain liability claims.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Daniel Defense's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Daniel Defense's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Gun and accessory makers ask the Supreme Court to throw out a lawsuit by victims of a school shooting, arguing the victims cannot link their injuries to the companies' advertising because they do not even claim the shooter saw it. The Court asked the victims to respond, a sign of interest, and many states backed the companies. We still expect the Court to decline the case — about a one-in-six chance it takes it — mainly because the lawsuit is still at an early stage and the companies have other defences left in the lower courts.

    Why this big-case score: A Fourth Circuit holding that school-shooting victims have Article III standing to sue a dozen firearm-industry manufacturers over marketing the shooter is not alleged to have seen; 22 States, the NRA and NSSF filed amicus briefs, and the traceability question reaches well beyond firearms.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.73·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this appeal: I put the chance of taking the case or otherwise granting relief at 18%, about one in six. Firearms companies challenge whether shooting victims have shown enough connection between their injuries and the companies' advertising to sue in federal court. The Court's request for a response signals interest, but the lower court offered alternative reasons for allowing the lawsuit to proceed. That makes this a less straightforward opportunity to resolve the disagreement among courts.

    Why this big-case score: The case concerns potentially substantial firearm-industry liability and a third-party causation rule for access to federal court that could affect litigation far beyond firearms. It does not directly ask the Court to decide the underlying statutory immunity or Second Amendment questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny the petition for review, with an 86% chance of denial (about a one in seven chance of a grant). In this case, victims of a 2022 Washington, D.C. school shooting sued firearms manufacturers over their social-media marketing, and a federal appeals court allowed the lawsuit to move forward past an initial threshold challenge to the victims' "standing" (their constitutional right to sue in federal court). Even though the Court asked the victims to file a written response to the manufacturers' petition, the Supreme Court is unlikely to step in right now because the appeals court's ruling is preliminary and the manufacturers can still ask the trial judge to dismiss the lawsuit immediately under a federal law that shields gun makers from liability for crimes committed by third parties.

    Why this big-case score: A decision clarifying the Article III traceability standard for third-party acts—and determining whether firearms manufacturers face federal-court tort and consumer-protection suits for mass shootings based on social-media advertising—would have major doctrinal and commercial significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decided either way it would fix the Article III traceability standard for third-party-harm suits and set the terms for marketing-based liability against the firearms industry; nationally newsworthy, but the question is a jurisdictional threshold rather than a merits ruling on gun liability.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An Article III causation ruling could affect firearm-marketing litigation and third-party-injury suits across industries; the petition concerns a school shooting but does not directly present the scope of the Second Amendment or PLCAA immunity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes challenge to gun manufacturer liability post-shooting under Article III.

Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America v. O'DayPhRMA asks the Supreme Court to overturn a Ninth Circuit ruling that upheld Oregon's drug-pricing disclosure law against First Amendment and takings challenges.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.62
0.67
0.75
0.68

Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America v. Sean O'Day, in His Official Capacity as Director of the Oregon Department of Consumer and Business ServicesNo. 25-1018 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281057 · models differ by up to 0.13 · topic: First Amendment (also Constitutional rights)

PhRMA asks the Supreme Court to overturn a Ninth Circuit ruling that upheld Oregon's drug-pricing disclosure law against First Amendment and takings challenges.

What happened

Oregon's HB 4005 requires drug manufacturers to report pricing information, including narrative explanations for price increases, to a state agency, which generally must post the information online. Trade secrets are normally shielded from posting, but Oregon can still disclose them if it decides that doing so serves the public interest. PhRMA, a pharmaceutical trade group, sued, arguing the reporting rule unconstitutionally compels speech and that the public-interest exception amounts to an uncompensated taking of trade secrets. A federal district court ruled for PhRMA on both claims. The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding the disclosures counted as commercial speech that survived First Amendment review, and that the takings claim failed because drug makers lack a reasonable expectation of secrecy in a heavily regulated industry.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law requiring companies to report product-specific pricing information to the government may be judged under a more lenient free-speech standard, and whether that standard was satisfied here based on the government's stated interest in reducing gaps in market information. It is also asked whether a business in a heavily regulated industry can be denied any claim that government-compelled disclosure of its trade secrets requires compensation, simply because it operates in that industry.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, and the Court has invited the Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard. No decision on whether to grant review has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

PhRMA is asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which went against PhRMA and in favor of Oregon's director of consumer and business services. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the free-speech and takings questions itself; a later decision could side with either party or send the case back without resolving it. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling upholding HB 4005 stays in place, and Oregon's reporting and disclosure requirements continue to apply to PhRMA's members.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would set the First Amendment framework for the growing wave of state transparency mandates (drug pricing, AI, climate) and decide whether 'highly regulated industry' status extinguishes takings protection for trade secrets — industry-wide stakes far beyond Oregon.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set nationwide constitutional limits on compelled business disclosures and public release of pharmaceutical trade secrets.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes constitutional challenge by PhRMA to state drug-price transparency laws implicating major First Amendment and Takings Clause doctrines.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would set the scrutiny tier for compelled government reporting requirements nationwide, reaching state drug-price transparency laws in roughly twenty states and the broader wave of narrative disclosure mandates; the takings question is narrower and rides on a facial-challenge posture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 43%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern compelled corporate explanations and protection of trade secrets in regulated industries, with implications beyond prescription-drug pricing. Substantial economic and constitutional stakes, but a facial-challenge vehicle may sharply limit the reach of any decision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes constitutional challenge to state compelled disclosure of pharmaceutical trade secrets, implicating First Amendment and Takings Clause protections.

City of Cleveland v. PickettCleveland asks the Supreme Court to overturn a lower-court decision allowing a class-action lawsuit over its water-lien policy to include homeowners who suffered no economic harm.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.60
0.76
—
0.68 2 of 3 models

City of Cleveland, Ohio v. Albert Pickett, Jr., Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al.No. 25-677 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279523 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Civil procedure

Cleveland asks the Supreme Court to overturn a lower-court decision allowing a class-action lawsuit over its water-lien policy to include homeowners who suffered no economic harm.

What happened

Cleveland Water places liens on properties when customers fall far behind on water bills. A group of Black homeowners sued, claiming the policy violates the Fair Housing Act because it disproportionately burdens Black residents in Cuyahoga County, even though the policy does not mention race. A federal district court certified a class of affected Black homeowners and residents to pursue both an injunction and money damages. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the class could include members who had not suffered any economic loss, because the alleged racial disparity itself was enough to give every class member standing to sue.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a lawsuit seeking money damages for a whole group of people can include group members who were never actually harmed, so long as they claim a policy's effects fell unevenly across races even though the policy itself does not treat people differently by race. Cleveland argues each class member must show a concrete loss; the homeowners argue that being subjected to a racially skewed policy, or having a lien placed on their property, is itself enough of a harm.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief opposing review and Cleveland's reply, and was distributed for several conferences in May 2026. Most recently, Cleveland filed a joint motion asking the Court to defer consideration of the petition; the docket does not show the Court's action on that motion.

What each outcome would mean

Cleveland, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to reverse the Sixth Circuit's decision. If the Court grants review and later sides with Cleveland, the class of homeowners allowed to seek damages would likely be narrowed to exclude those without an economic loss, though the separate class seeking only an injunction would be unaffected. If the Court instead sides with the homeowners, the broader damages class certified by the lower courts would stand. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's ruling allowing the broader class remains in effect, and the case continues in the lower courts without Supreme Court review of this issue.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the City of Cleveland's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The City of Cleveland's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: dismiss itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents the LabCorp question (uninjured class members / Article III) the Court already granted once and DIG'd, with prominent counsel and organized amici; a merits ruling would reshape class-action practice, though the underlying dispute is a local water-lien policy.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: dismiss itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition could shape nationwide Article III and Rule 23 limits on damages classes while affecting disparate-impact suits and municipal utility practices.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
GEO Group v. FergusonGEO Group asks the Court to review a ruling that let Washington apply health and safety rules to its privately run immigration detention facility.awaiting the Court
0.62
0.76
0.65
0.68

The GEO Group, Inc., a Florida Corporation v. Bob Ferguson, Governor of Washington, et al.No. 26-71 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000071 · models differ by up to 0.14

GEO Group asks the Court to review a ruling that let Washington apply health and safety rules to its privately run immigration detention facility.

What happened

GEO Group operates a private detention facility in Tacoma, Washington, under contract with federal immigration authorities. Washington passed a law applying health and safety standards, already used for other confined-population facilities, to private detention facilities. GEO sued, arguing the law unconstitutionally targets the federal government through its contractor and is preempted by federal law. A federal district court agreed in part and blocked several provisions. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected GEO's argument that the law directly regulates the federal government or is preempted, but sent back to the district court the question whether the law discriminates against GEO compared to similar facilities. GEO then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state may apply detailed health and safety requirements to a company that runs a detention facility under federal contract, without those requirements counting as improper regulation of the federal government itself, and whether the way the lower court compared this facility to other state-regulated facilities was correct.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, most recently for November 13, 2026, after earlier conferences in October; the docket does not show that the Court has yet acted on it.

What each outcome would mean

GEO Group, which lost on these issues at the Ninth Circuit, is asking the Court to reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the state law improperly regulates or discriminates against a federal contractor; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, meaning the state's law remains in effect and the case returns to the lower courts, where a related discrimination claim is already being litigated.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up GEO Group's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: GEO Group's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Supremacy Clause intergovernmental-immunity question about state regulation of federal immigration-detention contractors; the SG calls the issue exceptionally important and similar laws are pending in several states, but the posture is interlocutory and confined to one facility.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between state health-and-safety regulation and federal immigration operations carried out by contractors has substantial national federalism and detention-policy consequences, although this petition concerns one facility and an interlocutory ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves state regulation of federal immigration contractors, implicating the Supremacy Clause and federalism.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think it slightly more likely than not (about 55%) that the Supreme Court will take up GEO Group's challenge to Washington's health-and-safety law for its Tacoma immigration detention center. That includes a "GVR": the Court sends the case back to the lower court to reconsider after deciding a related case. That related GEO case against Washington is being handled on the same conference schedule, and the federal government has urged the Court to hear it. The main risk is that this case is still at an early, preliminary stage, so the Court could hear only the related case.

    Why this big-case score: Supremacy Clause limits on state regulation of federal immigration-detention contractors; recurring across states, with the federal government's interest implicated, but tied to one facility and an interlocutory posture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is somewhat more likely than not—about a 62% chance—to grant some form of review. The most likely route is to wait for a related case and then send this case back to the lower court for another look, rather than hear separate arguments. The dispute concerns Washington's power to regulate a company operating a federal immigration detention center. Federal support for the related challenge helps GEO, but unfinished lower-court proceedings and differences between the cases leave a substantial chance of denial.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of state control over federal detention contractors has substantial immigration, federalism, and contractor-wide implications, although this petition may resolve through a companion-case remand.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 26%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny review in *The GEO Group, Inc. v. Ferguson*, with about a one-in-four chance (26%) of granting the petition. Although the case raises a major constitutional dispute over whether Washington State can impose health, safety, and inspection rules on a private company operating a federal immigration detention center—an issue that split the federal appeals court and led the Supreme Court to relist the case for a second conference—the appeals court has not yet made a final ruling and instead sent the case back to the trial court for further proceedings. Because a related case involving the same facility (*GEO Group v. Nwauzor*) is already before the Supreme Court after a final judgment, the Justices are likely to turn down this premature appeal and wait for the lower courts to finish their work.

    Why this big-case score: High-stakes Supremacy Clause and intergovernmental-immunity challenge to state health, safety, and inspection regulation of a federal ICE detention facility, though in an interlocutory remand posture alongside a pending related petition (No. 25-828).

Trevino v. HobbsThe Supreme Court vacated a Ninth Circuit ruling against voters challenging a Washington legislative map, sending the case back for reconsideration in light of a newer decision.Election lawdecided
0.45
0.72
0.85
0.67

Jose A. Trevino, et al. v. Steven Hobbs, Secretary of State of Washington, et al.No. 25-918 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280426 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Election law (also Civil procedure)

The Supreme Court vacated a Ninth Circuit ruling against voters challenging a Washington legislative map, sending the case back for reconsideration in light of a newer decision.

What happened

Hispanic voters sued Washington over a state legislative district, Legislative District 15, claiming it diluted Latino voting strength in violation of the Voting Rights Act. A federal district court agreed, struck down the district, and adopted a replacement map. Jose Trevino and Alex Ybarra, who had intervened to defend the original district, appealed, arguing they had the right to challenge both the liability ruling and the new map, and that the new map itself was a racial gerrymander. The Ninth Circuit ruled against them, finding they mostly lacked standing to appeal and that the replacement map did not improperly rely on race. The state and the Secretary of State did not appeal.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether voters and a legislator affected by a court-ordered remedial redistricting map have the legal right to challenge that map, and the liability finding behind it, in court. It also asks whether the new map should have faced the toughest level of judicial review because race played some role in drawing it.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the petition, vacated the Ninth Circuit's judgment, and sent the case back for further consideration in light of its recent decision in a related Louisiana redistricting case.

What each outcome would mean

Trevino and Ybarra, who intervened to defend the original district, asked the Supreme Court to overturn the Ninth Circuit's decision, which had favored Soto Palmer and the other voters who successfully challenged the district. By vacating and remanding, the Court set aside the Ninth Circuit's decision without deciding who is right. The case now returns to the lower courts, which must reconsider the standing and gerrymandering questions in light of the newer ruling, with the outcome still undetermined for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Oct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A state legislative district in one region of Washington, but the first post-Callais test of whether intervenors can attack a Section 2 liability judgment the State declined to appeal, and whether a court-drawn remedial map faces strict scrutiny; a GVR would be a footnote, plenary review would be a major voting-rights case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern standing to challenge judicial redistricting and when race-conscious Voting Rights Act remedies trigger strict scrutiny, with implications beyond Washington; significant vehicle defects limit this petition's reach, not the underlying stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenges to VRA Section 2 remedial maps and racial gerrymandering are highly salient and closely watched.

Kimberly Ann Polk v. Montgomery County Public SchoolsA former substitute teacher asks the Court to revive her free-exercise and free-speech claims against a school district's gender-identity policies.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.62
0.78
0.62
0.67

Kimberly Ann Polk v. Montgomery County Public Schools, et al.No. 26-8 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000008 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: First Amendment

A former substitute teacher asks the Court to revive her free-exercise and free-speech claims against a school district's gender-identity policies.

What happened

Kimberly Polk, a part-time substitute teacher for Montgomery County Public Schools, objected on religious grounds to policies requiring staff to use students' preferred pronouns and to withhold information about a student's gender identity from parents without the student's consent. When she would not affirm compliance, the district did not retain her as a substitute. She sued, raising free-exercise and free-speech claims. The district court dismissed those claims, and a divided Fourth Circuit panel affirmed, holding that established precedents permitted the policies. After that ruling, the Supreme Court decided a separate case addressing similar parent-notification policies, and the district later revised its guidelines and reinstated Polk with an accommodation.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a long-standing rule letting neutral, generally applicable policies burden religious exercise without heightened court scrutiny should still apply here, or whether this dispute is instead like other cases where such burdens automatically trigger the toughest level of judicial review. The Court is also asked whether requiring a teacher to use certain pronouns and withhold certain information counts as the school's own speech that it can control, or as the teacher's protected speech.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, most recently for November 13, 2026, after earlier being rescheduled; the docket does not yet show a decision on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Polk, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the school district's policies violated her constitutional rights, without yet deciding who is right. If it denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision rejecting Polk's claims stands, and the school district's win remains in place. A grant would not itself decide the outcome; it would simply mean the case proceeds to briefing and argument on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Kimberly Ann Polk's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Kimberly Ann Polk's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 33%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A substitute teacher asks the Supreme Court to hear her challenge to a Maryland school district's former rules on student pronouns and on keeping students' gender transitions from parents. We predict the Court will most likely decline to hear it, but we give about a one-in-three chance of some favourable action. The likeliest favourable action is sending the case back to the lower court to reconsider in light of a 2026 Supreme Court ruling on a similar policy. The main obstacle is that the district has since changed its policy and let her return to teaching.

    Why this big-case score: Teacher pronoun mandates and the reach of Smith/Garcetti in K-12 schools draw 17 amicus filings including 12 states, but post-Mirabelli policy changes narrow the practical stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, with about a seven-in-ten chance of denial and a 28% chance of some form of review. The dispute raises important questions about teachers' religious objections to school pronoun and parent-communication rules. But the school district has changed its policy and offered this teacher an accommodation, making this a weaker case for a nationwide ruling. If the Court intervenes, it could send the case back for reconsideration rather than decide the constitutional issues itself.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision could materially affect public-school teachers' speech and religious-exercise rights, student gender-identity policies, and communication with parents nationwide; those stakes are distinct from this petition's vehicle weaknesses.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in this case, with about a one-in-five chance (22%) of granting it. Kimberly Polk, a substitute teacher in Maryland, argues that her school district violated her constitutional rights to free speech and religion by requiring her to agree to use students' preferred gender pronouns and keep transitions private from parents. Although a dissenting appeals judge and eight supporting briefs urge the Court to step in, the school district has already revised its parent-privacy rule after a March 2026 Supreme Court ruling (*Mirabelli v. Bonta*) and reinstated Polk while offering a name-only accommodation, making this case a poor vehicle for a major ruling.

    Why this big-case score: High-visibility First Amendment conflict over whether Garcetti strips public K-12 teachers of free-speech protection against compelled pronoun use and gender-transition policies.

United States v. Office of the New York State Attorney GeneralThe federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that an acting U.S. Attorney was unlawfully appointed and improperly obtained grand jury subpoenas against New York's Attorney General's office.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.55
0.82
0.65
0.67

United States v. Office of the New York State Attorney GeneralNo. 26-348 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000348 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The federal government asks the Court to review a ruling that an acting U.S. Attorney was unlawfully appointed and improperly obtained grand jury subpoenas against New York's Attorney General's office.

What happened

After the Senate-confirmed U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York left office, the Attorney General eventually named John Sarcone III as First Assistant, asserting he automatically became Acting U.S. Attorney, and separately designated him a "Special Attorney" with all the powers of a U.S. Attorney. Sarcone then obtained grand jury subpoenas against the Office of the New York State Attorney General, seeking records about its past enforcement cases against the National Rifle Association and Donald Trump. New York's Attorney General's office moved to quash the subpoenas, arguing Sarcone lacked lawful authority. The district court agreed, quashed the subpoenas, and disqualified Sarcone from the investigations; the Second Circuit affirmed, over one judge's dissent.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a person named "first assistant" only after a vacancy begins can still automatically become the acting head of the office under the federal vacancies law, and whether a rule making that vacancies law the only way to install an acting official blocks an agency head from separately delegating all of the office's powers to someone who was never validly made the acting officer.

Where it stands

The government filed its petition on September 15, 2026, and after an extension, New York's Attorney General's office filed its brief opposing review on November 2, 2026. The brief in opposition says the Court should deny review, or if it grants review, should also take up a related case called Jackson. The docket does not yet show further action on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case in full and decide the legal questions, deciding nothing yet about who is right. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling stands: Sarcone's appointment and the delegation to him were invalid, the subpoenas against New York's Attorney General's office remain quashed, and Sarcone stays disqualified from the investigations.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The FVRA questions (post-vacancy first assistants; full delegation of a vacant PAS office) decide who may lead several U.S. Attorney offices and touch grand-jury subpoenas aimed at the New York AG's Trump and NRA investigations, but this petition asks only to be held for No. 26-304 (Jackson), so its own disposition will be a companion order rather than the merits vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court takes the case: 74%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions affect executive-branch vacancy management and prosecutorial authority nationwide, with additional stakes for federal investigations of a state attorney general. This petition is a follow-on vehicle with substantial procedural complications, not the government's preferred lead case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    FVRA interpretation impacts the President's ability to fill executive branch vacancies, a recurring structural separation-of-powers issue.

Kendrick Jarrell Beaird v. United StatesKendrick Beaird asks the Supreme Court to decide whether courts must defer to the Sentencing Commission's commentary when interpreting the federal Sentencing Guidelines.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.60
0.59
0.82
0.67

Kendrick Jarrell Beaird v. United StatesNo. 25-5343 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73277583 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Firearms

Kendrick Beaird asks the Supreme Court to decide whether courts must defer to the Sentencing Commission's commentary when interpreting the federal Sentencing Guidelines.

What happened

Beaird pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm after a felony conviction. At sentencing, the district court applied a sentencing enhancement based on commentary defining a "large capacity magazine" as one holding more than 15 rounds, which increased his guidelines range. Beaird argued courts should not defer to that commentary, but the Fifth Circuit held itself bound by circuit precedent requiring deference under this Court's 1993 decision in Stinson v. United States, and affirmed his sentence of 72 months. Beaird's petition to the Supreme Court also raised Second Amendment and Commerce Clause challenges to the underlying firearm statute, but the Court granted review only on the deference question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether its longstanding rule—that courts must give controlling weight to the Sentencing Commission's explanatory commentary on the Guidelines unless that commentary is plainly wrong—remains correct, particularly in light of a more recent decision limiting similar deference to agencies interpreting their own regulations. The question affects how much independent judgment courts must exercise when a Guideline's text and the Commission's commentary on it may point in different directions.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari limited to the deference question, and the case was argued on October 13, 2026. It now awaits decision. The United States, while defending Beaird's conviction, agrees with him that the lower court applied too much deference and asks the Court to send the case back for further review; a court-appointed attorney was asked to argue the opposing position, defending the existing deference rule.

What each outcome would mean

Beaird, who lost below, asks the Court to reverse. If the Court holds that no deference (or only limited deference) is owed to the commentary, it would vacate the Fifth Circuit's decision and send the case back for the lower courts to reconsider the sentencing enhancement without simply deferring to the commentary—a result Beaird and the United States both support, though for the government this would not necessarily mean a lower sentence. If the Court instead holds that the existing deference rule still applies, as the court-appointed amicus urges, the Fifth Circuit's decision and Beaird's sentence would stand. The Court could also rule in a way that applies some, but not unlimited, deference, with consequences depending on how that standard applies to Beaird's case on remand.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 23, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Kendrick Jarrell Beaird wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The United States wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the deference rule for Guidelines commentary across every federal sentencing; doctrinally significant after Kisor and Loper Bright, though low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The granted question concerns interpretive authority across federal sentencing commentary, with recurring consequences for sentencing ranges nationwide; it does not reopen the petition's constitutional firearms questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 22%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolving a 6-6 circuit split over whether Stinson v. United States survives Kisor v. Wilkie and Loper Bright governs the interpretive weight of Sentencing Guidelines commentary across roughly 66,000 federal sentencings per year.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the deference rule for Sentencing Guidelines commentary, which touches a large share of federal sentences; doctrinally significant post-Kisor/Loper Bright, but the case itself is a single guidelines enhancement.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 93%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The treatment of Sentencing Commission commentary affects federal sentencing across many guidelines and implicates judicial independence and criminal-law safeguards, but the granted question is technical and does not reach the petition's gun-rights challenges.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 91%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a deep, multi-circuit en banc conflict over whether Stinson deference to Sentencing Guidelines commentary survives Kisor v. Wilkie and Loper Bright, affecting guideline calculations across tens of thousands of federal criminal sentencings annually.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 30%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the interpretive weight of Guidelines commentary across roughly 60,000+ federal sentencings a year and tests how far Loper Bright/Kisor reach beyond executive agencies; technical, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.59·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 24%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A systemwide rule for interpreting federal sentencing commentary affects many guideline calculations and sentencing appeals, but the granted question does not decide the constitutionality of firearm possession bans or executive-agency deference generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.82·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 28%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves an entrenched 6-6 circuit split over whether Stinson v. United States still governs judicial deference to U.S. Sentencing Guidelines commentary after Kisor and Loper Bright, directly affecting advisory Guidelines calculations across roughly 66,000 federal criminal sentencings annually.

United States v. HembreeThe Court declined to hear a dispute over whether a federal gun-possession law could be applied to a man whose only prior conviction was for simple drug possession.Firearmsdecided
0.50
0.65
0.85
0.67

United States v. Charles HembreeNo. 25-1219 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73248556 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Firearms

The Court declined to hear a dispute over whether a federal gun-possession law could be applied to a man whose only prior conviction was for simple drug possession.

What happened

Charles Hembree was convicted under a federal law barring firearm possession by anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year in prison, based on a prior conviction for simple methamphetamine possession. He argued this violated his Second Amendment rights. The district court rejected that argument, and he pleaded guilty while preserving his right to appeal. The Fifth Circuit reversed, ruling that the government had not shown a historical tradition supporting permanent disarmament based on a simple-possession conviction. The federal government then asked the Supreme Court to review the case.

What the Court is being asked

The government did not argue the Fifth Circuit's reasoning was wrong. Instead, it asked the Court to hold the case until it decided a related case about a different firearms law, and then, if appropriate, send Hembree's case back to the lower court for another look in light of that decision. Hembree opposed this, arguing the related case would not change the outcome here.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for a conference in September 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition and also granted Hembree's request to proceed without paying court fees.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, asked the Court to hold the case and potentially send it back to the lower court for reconsideration. By denying the petition, the Court left the Fifth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Hembree's conviction remains reversed on Second Amendment grounds. The government's request to have the case reconsidered in light of the related ruling did not succeed, and no further proceedings in this case will occur as a result of this petition.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question (whether 922(g)(1) is unconstitutional as applied to a nonviolent felon) is a major, nationally watched Second Amendment issue with a live circuit split; but this petition asks only for a hold-and-GVR, and the likeliest action leaves a narrow Fifth Circuit as-applied ruling in place.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The constitutionality of permanent firearm disqualification for a simple drug-possession felony has substantial criminal-enforcement and Second Amendment stakes. This petition's narrow, derivative request for a Hemani GVR limits its independent significance relative to a plenary test of the felon-possession statute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
BMG Rights Management v. VetterMusic publishers asked the Supreme Court to decide if a songwriter's copyright termination reclaims only U.S. rights or worldwide rights; the Court affirmed the lower ruling.Intellectual propertyawaiting the Court
0.45
0.70
0.85
0.67

BMG Rights Management (US) LLC, et al. v. Cyril E. Vetter, et al.No. 25-1391 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500293 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Intellectual property

Music publishers asked the Supreme Court to decide if a songwriter's copyright termination reclaims only U.S. rights or worldwide rights; the Court affirmed the lower ruling.

What happened

Cyril Vetter and Donald Smith wrote "Double Shot (Of My Baby's Love)" in 1962 and assigned worldwide copyright interests to a publisher. Decades later, Vetter used a federal copyright law provision to terminate part of that assignment, and separately acquired renewal rights from Smith's heirs. Vetter sued Resnik Music Group, which had acquired the publisher's interest, seeking a declaration that he owned the song worldwide. The district court and the Fifth Circuit both ruled for Vetter, holding that his termination recaptured rights globally, not just in the United States. Music publishing companies, who later bought Resnik's interest, then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether an author who takes back rights under a federal copyright law provision, after earlier assigning those rights worldwide, gets back only the rights tied to the United States or all the rights originally granted worldwide. The publishers say the law limits what an author recovers to domestic rights, while Vetter argues the statute's terms do not separate domestic from foreign rights that trace back to the same original U.S. grant.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 16, 2026 conference. On October 19, 2026, the Court announced that because it lacked a quorum of qualified justices and the remaining justices determined the case could not be heard and decided in the next term, the judgment below was automatically affirmed under a federal statute governing such situations, with the same effect as an affirmance by an equally divided Court.

What each outcome would mean

BMG Rights Management and other music publishers, as petitioners, asked the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling in Vetter's favor. Because the Court lacked a quorum, it could not decide the merits; instead, the law required automatic affirmance of the Fifth Circuit's judgment, leaving Vetter's worldwide ownership ruling in place. This outcome carries the same effect as a tie vote: it resolves this case for these parties but does not establish a nationwide rule on the legal question, since the Court issued no opinion on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up BMG Rights Management's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: BMG Rights Management's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Industry-wide stakes for music, film, and publishing (worldwide scope of U.S. copyright termination, Berne/comity questions), but a technical statutory question with little public-salience beyond the creative industries.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The geographic reach of copyright termination could materially affect international music, film, and publishing licenses and catalog valuations, although the immediate dispute concerns one song and the issue is commercially specialized.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major copyright case with massive industry implications, drawing heavy amicus support from MPA, RIAA, etc., despite lack of circuit split.

K.M.K. v. Washington Interscholastic Activities AssociationA high school wrestler and her mother asked the Supreme Court to block Washington's policy letting transgender athletes compete in girls' sports while their court appeal continues.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.55
0.79
0.65
0.66

K.M.K., By Her Next Friend and Mother, Stephanie Lynne Brown v. Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, et al.No. 26A458 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000458 · models differ by up to 0.24 · topic: Employment & discrimination

A high school wrestler and her mother asked the Supreme Court to block Washington's policy letting transgender athletes compete in girls' sports while their court appeal continues.

What happened

K.M.K., a Washington high school wrestler, says she was sexually assaulted during a match against a transgender opponent and now fears facing transgender competitors again. She and her mother, Stephanie Brown, sued the state athletic association, school officials, and her district, claiming the gender-identity participation policy violates Title IX's sex discrimination ban and Brown's parental rights. A federal district court denied a preliminary injunction, finding the claims unlikely to succeed and the harm speculative. The Ninth Circuit also denied emergency relief pending appeal, applying a heightened standard for the mandatory injunction requested and citing feasibility and privacy concerns.

What the Court is being asked

The applicants ask the Court to block enforcement of the policy while their appeal proceeds, resolve disagreement among appeals courts over whether a stricter standard applies to court orders requiring action rather than orders preventing it, and decide whether letting transgender athletes compete on girls' teams violates sex discrimination law and parental rights. Alternatively, they ask the Court to treat the request as a petition for full review and hear the case this term.

Where it stands

The application was submitted to Justice Kagan, who requested a response from the respondents; both sides have filed briefs and replies, along with amicus briefs supporting the applicants. Recent letters to the Court note that a Washington ballot initiative addressing the issue passed and is set to take effect December 3, and that the wrestling season's competitions begin after that date.

What each outcome would mean

K.M.K. and Brown, as applicants, are asking the Court to pause the lower courts' rulings while the underlying appeal continues. Granting the injunction would bar enforcement of the policy against K.M.K. during her wrestling season, letting her avoid being matched against transgender opponents without penalty. Denying it would leave the district court's and Ninth Circuit's rulings in place, meaning the policy continues to apply as the case proceeds in the lower courts. Either way, the order would be temporary and would not resolve the underlying legal claims, which remain pending on appeal.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: K.M.K. gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: K.M.K. does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 20%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First post-B.P.J. emergency application asking the Court to hold that a gender-identity participation policy itself violates Title IX, with a parental-rights claim riding Mirabelli; nationally watched subject, ADF counsel, but interim relief in one student's case rather than a merits ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court grants the application: 30%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application implicates transgender participation in school sports, Title IX, parental opt-outs, and the mandatory-injunction standard, with potentially broad consequences despite its individual emergency posture.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 5%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile dispute over Title IX and transgender athletes in women's sports.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Emergency application to enjoin a state athletic association's gender-identity participation policy for one wrestler, months after B.P.J. reserved whether Title IX forbids such policies and Mirabelli granted parents interim relief; egregious facts, elite movement counsel, a 9-2 circuit split on the mandatory-injunction standard, and 22 states with similar policies raise the stakes, but the relief sought is individual rather than programmatic.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court grants the application: 38%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns transgender participation in school athletics, parental notice and opt-out rights, and the standard for mandatory injunctions. These questions have substantial national implications, although the immediate requested protection concerns an individual student.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 75%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Transgender participation in girls' school sports after West Virginia v. B.P.J. is a nationally watched issue, but this is an interlocutory request for a narrow opt-out/notice injunction on an undeveloped record, so stakes as a vehicle are moderate.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.79·Chance the Court grants the application: 24%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application implicates nationwide disputes over transgender participation in school sports, Title IX, parental authority, and emergency injunction standards, despite its individual-athlete posture.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile cultural issue regarding transgender athlete participation, although presented in an emergency posture with an undeveloped record.

D. A. v. Tri County Area SchoolsThe Supreme Court declined to hear two Michigan students' bid to revive their free-speech lawsuit over being told to remove "Let's Go Brandon" sweatshirts at school.First Amendmentdecided
0.55
0.68
0.75
0.66

D. A., a Minor, By and Through his Mother, B. A., et al. v. Tri County Area Schools, et al.No. 25-1143 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281630 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

The Supreme Court declined to hear two Michigan students' bid to revive their free-speech lawsuit over being told to remove "Let's Go Brandon" sweatshirts at school.

What happened

Brothers D.A. and X.A. wore sweatshirts bearing the phrase "Let's Go Brandon" to their Michigan middle school. School officials told them to remove the sweatshirts, saying the phrase is widely understood as a stand-in for a vulgar phrase about President Biden and violated the school's dress code banning profanity. The students sued, arguing their speech was political and nondisruptive. The district court ruled for the school, and a divided Sixth Circuit panel affirmed, holding school officials could reasonably treat the phrase as vulgar under a Supreme Court precedent allowing schools to restrict lewd or profane speech. One judge dissented. The full Sixth Circuit declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The students asked the Court to decide how far schools can go in treating a sanitized or coded phrase as equivalent to profanity it is said to stand for, when deciding whether they may restrict student speech that is otherwise political and causes no disruption. They argued lower courts disagree about whether this rule applies only to speech that is clearly and plainly profane or lewd, or more broadly to speech an administrator reasonably believes carries a vulgar meaning.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, the Court asked the school district to respond, and after further briefing the Court denied the petition, ending the case at the Supreme Court.

What each outcome would mean

The students, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case and overturn the Sixth Circuit's ruling for the school district. Because the Court denied review, the Sixth Circuit's decision stands: the school district's treatment of the sweatshirts as restrictable did not violate the students' First Amendment rights, and the students' lawsuit remains dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would fix the reach of Fraser's lewd-speech exception to Tinker for every public-school student, on a culturally salient political slogan, with FIRE and Williams & Connolly opposite each other; widely watched, but doctrinally incremental rather than structural.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between protected political apparel and school-regulable vulgarity affects public-school students nationwide and carries substantial viewpoint-discrimination stakes. The dispute is significant but confined to student speech rather than political expression generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment student speech case involving a popular political slogan, squarely presenting a circuit split on the Fraser exception.

Clemente Properties v. Pierluisi-UrrutiaThe Supreme Court declined to hear the Clemente family's bid to revive takings and immunity claims over Puerto Rico's use of Roberto Clemente's name.decided
0.45
0.68
0.85
0.66

Clemente Properties, Inc., et al. v. Pedro R. Pierluisi-Urrutia, et al.scotus/73548979 · models differ by up to 0.40

The Supreme Court declined to hear the Clemente family's bid to revive takings and immunity claims over Puerto Rico's use of Roberto Clemente's name.

What happened

Roberto Clemente's sons and related companies, who control trademarks tied to his name and image, sued Puerto Rico's government and officials, saying a license-plate and registration-tag program honoring Clemente infringed their trademark rights and took their property without compensation. A federal district court dismissed the case, and the First Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed dismissal of the takings claim and most trademark claims, ruling Puerto Rico has sovereign immunity (protection from certain lawsuits) that the Lanham Act does not clearly remove, while reviving some individual-capacity trademark claims for further proceedings.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide two things: whether a rule requiring full compensation for government seizures of property should apply to intangible property like trademarks, not just physical property, and whether Puerto Rico can claim the same immunity from lawsuits that states have, and if so, whether a federal trademark law already removes that immunity.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference three times, most recently November 6, 2026, and the Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Clemente Properties and the family members asked the Court to overturn the First Circuit's ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that ruling in place: the dismissal of the takings claim and most trademark claims against Puerto Rico and its officials stands, while the individual-capacity claims the First Circuit had revived continue in the lower courts. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the First Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Two genuinely open federal questions (per se takings of intangible property; whether Puerto Rico has sovereign immunity at all) with broad reach, but on a narrow license-plate fact pattern with preservation limits.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could affect constitutional protection of intellectual property nationally and Puerto Rico's exposure to federal suits. The celebrity trademark increases public salience, but the immediate controversy concerns a bounded licensing dispute rather than a nationwide program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents significant constitutional questions on the application of the Takings Clause to intangible property and sovereign immunity of Puerto Rico.

AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals v. Mosaic HealthDrugmakers ask the Court to shut down an antitrust lawsuit by safety-net clinics over cuts to discounted-drug sales through pharmacies.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.52
0.65
0.80
0.66

AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP, et al. v. Mosaic Health, Inc., et al.No. 25-1070 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281354 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Business & finance

Drugmakers ask the Court to shut down an antitrust lawsuit by safety-net clinics over cuts to discounted-drug sales through pharmacies.

What happened

Mosaic Health and Central Virginia Health Services, clinics serving low-income patients, sued five drugmakers, alleging they conspired to restrict a discount drug program for safety-net providers. A district court dismissed the suit and denied leave to amend. The Second Circuit reversed, holding the clinics had plausibly alleged an illegal conspiracy and that a rule limiting lawsuits by indirect purchasers did not bar their claims because they sought lost profits rather than overcharges. The drugmakers petitioned the Supreme Court, arguing the appeals court's rulings on both issues conflict with other circuits' decisions.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide two questions. First, whether a rule barring purchasers who did not buy directly from a manufacturer from suing for antitrust damages also blocks claims for profits lost when a purchase never happened, or applies only to claims about being overcharged. Second, whether companies' joint lobbying and shared membership in a trade group can count as supporting evidence that they illegally conspired, even without proof of what was said.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, most recently in September 2026, and on October 5, 2026 the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded since.

What each outcome would mean

The drugmakers, AstraZeneca and others, are asking the Court to reverse the Second Circuit's decision, which had ruled for the clinics and let their lawsuit proceed. If the Court takes the case and eventually rules for the drugmakers, the clinics' lawsuit could be narrowed or dismissed. If it rules for the clinics, the case would continue in the lower courts under the Second Circuit's standards. If the Court denies review, that appeals court ruling stands and the suit proceeds there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Four dominant diabetes-drug makers, a putative nationwide class of 340B safety-net providers, and the reach of Illinois Brick's bright-line rule; doctrinally a pleading/antitrust-standing case rather than a headline constitutional one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern cross-industry antitrust damages and conspiracy pleading, with substantial consequences for 340B safety-net providers and pharmaceutical distribution. This is not a direct decision on the legality of the entire 340B program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes antitrust challenge addressing Twombly pleading standards for trade associations and Illinois Brick indirect purchaser limits, drawing Chamber of Commerce amicus support.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Two cross-cutting antitrust questions (the reach of Illinois Brick and whether joint lobbying/trade-association activity can count toward a Twombly plus factor) with Chamber and NAM backing, layered on the $80B-plus 340B program; important to the antitrust and pharma bar, but technical and unlikely to be a headline case for the general public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential for antitrust standing, conspiracy pleading, and the 340B contract-pharmacy channel nationwide; broader commercial implications, but a technical dispute rather than a sweeping constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves major pharmaceutical companies, safety net clinics, and fundamental antitrust principles (Illinois Brick and Twombly), prompting a CVSG.

Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of GovernorsCustodia Bank asks the Court to decide whether a federal law requires Federal Reserve Banks to grant master accounts to eligible nonmember banks like itself.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.70
0.72
0.66

Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, et al.No. 26-62 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000062 · models differ by up to 0.17

Custodia Bank asks the Court to decide whether a federal law requires Federal Reserve Banks to grant master accounts to eligible nonmember banks like itself.

What happened

Custodia, a Wyoming-chartered bank serving digital asset companies, applied for a master account with the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, which gives a bank direct access to the Federal Reserve's payment system. The Reserve Bank denied the application, citing risks from Custodia's crypto-focused business. Custodia sued the Reserve Bank and the Federal Reserve Board, arguing federal law requires approval for any eligible institution regardless of risk. The district court and the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals both ruled against Custodia, holding that Reserve Banks have discretion to deny such applications. One Tenth Circuit judge dissented, and the full court later declined to rehear the case over three dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a 1980 banking law, which says Federal Reserve services "shall be available" to nonmember banks, strips Reserve Banks of discretion to deny deposit accounts to individual eligible applicants, or whether that discretion survives from an older, separate provision allowing Reserve Banks to decide whether to accept deposits.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including responses from both the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City opposing review and a reply from Custodia. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it up.

What each outcome would mean

Custodia, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to reverse that result. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether Reserve Banks have this discretion, without yet deciding who is right. If the Court denies review, the Tenth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Federal Reserve Banks free to deny master accounts to eligible nonmember institutions based on risk assessments, and Custodia's loss becomes final.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Custodia Bank's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Custodia Bank's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Custodia Bank, a Wyoming crypto-focused bank, asks the Supreme Court to rule that the Federal Reserve must give eligible banks a "master account," the account a bank needs to use the Fed's payment system. We predict the Court will likely **decline** to hear the case. We put the chance of review at about one in twelve (8%). No two federal appeals courts disagree on the question. The federal government opposes review. And a pending Fed rule could change or end the dispute.

    Why this big-case score: Whether Reserve Banks may deny master accounts to state-chartered nonmember banks matters to the whole fintech/crypto banking sector and to state chartering power, but the question presented is a narrow statutory one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Custodia Bank's appeal; I put the chance of review at about one in eight, or 12%. The dispute concerns whether eligible banks are entitled to direct access to the Federal Reserve's payment system. That matters for new banking businesses and state regulation, but no federal appeals courts currently disagree on the legal answer described in the filings. Problems with how constitutional arguments were raised also favor denial, most likely without an explanatory opinion.

    Why this big-case score: Access to Federal Reserve payment accounts affects financial innovation and the federal-state banking balance, with potential implications for Reserve Bank accountability; the presented question is statutory, not a direct challenge to the Fed's constitutional structure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors*, with only an 8% chance (less than one in ten) of granting the petition. Custodia, a state-chartered bank focused on digital assets, argues that federal law requires regional Federal Reserve Banks to grant it a "master account" (a direct bank account with the Federal Reserve used to clear payments). Although the case has drawn substantial interest, both federal appeals courts to consider the issue have agreed that Reserve Banks have legal discretion to reject high-risk applicants, leaving no split among lower courts for the Supreme Court to resolve.

    Why this big-case score: Whether regional Federal Reserve Banks have discretionary authority to deny master accounts to state-chartered depository institutions (and whether that authority raises Appointments Clause and presidential removal questions) has major implications for the dual-banking system, digital-asset banking, and the structure of the Federal Reserve System, as reflected by eleven cert-stage amicus briefs from States, Members of Congress, and banking/crypto trade groups.

Kroger v. SolanoKroger asks the Court to decide whether a class action can include members who suffered no injury, after the Ninth Circuit approved certifying such a class.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.65
0.72
0.66

The Kroger Co., dba Fred Meyer, Inc. v. Elisha Solano, Individually and on Behalf of Other Customers, et al.No. 26-244 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000244 · models differ by up to 0.12

Kroger asks the Court to decide whether a class action can include members who suffered no injury, after the Ninth Circuit approved certifying such a class.

What happened

Customers Elisha Solano, Kathleen Zach, and Denise Conroy sued Kroger's Fred Meyer stores, claiming Fred Meyer wrongly charged 10-cent bottle deposits on orange juice containers that were not eligible for deposits under Oregon's bottle law. A federal district court certified a class of affected customers, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed. Fred Meyer argued that because it had already refunded deposits to more than 1,275 class members, those customers had no injury and could not properly be included, but the Ninth Circuit disagreed, following its own precedent.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a class action for money damages may go forward when some people in the class have not been harmed at all, or whether a lawsuit covering a group that includes unharmed members cannot proceed as a class action under federal court rules.

Where it stands

Kroger's petition has been distributed for conference, and the Court asked the customers to respond; that response deadline has since been extended twice, most recently to December 4, 2026. The petition has not yet been granted or denied.

What each outcome would mean

Kroger, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether classes with uninjured members are allowed, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands, and the certified class, including members who received refunds, continues toward trial under Solano's win on this issue.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Kroger's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Kroger's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Kroger's request to hear this case, though the chance it agrees is real: about one in six. Kroger argues that a class action (one lawsuit brought on behalf of many customers) shouldn't include shoppers who already got their 10-cent bottle deposits back and so suffered no harm. The Court tried to decide this question in 2025 but dismissed that case on a procedural problem, and it asked the customers to respond here. Still, most cases that draw such a request are ultimately denied, and the Court recently passed on a similar case.

    Why this big-case score: The question (certifying Rule 23(b)(3) damages classes that include uninjured members) is recurring and matters a lot across class-action practice, though this dispute is about 10-cent bottle deposits.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 43%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to decline this case than hear it: I give review a 43% chance, a little better than two in five. The lawsuit concerns improper bottle deposits, but the larger issue is whether a group damages lawsuit may include people who suffered no legal injury. The Court has shown interest in that question before and requested a response here. Still, uncertainty about whether refunded customers were actually uninjured could make this a poor case for deciding the broader rule.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling could substantially alter nationwide damages-class certification and settlement leverage across consumer and other civil litigation, despite the small individual bottle-deposit loss.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely deny review in *The Kroger Co. v. Solano*, with a one-in-four (25%) chance of granting the petition. Kroger asks the Court to decide whether a federal court may certify a class-action lawsuit seeking money damages when some members of the group suffered no actual financial harm—here, customers who already received refunds for a 10-cent orange juice bottle deposit. Although the Justices agreed to hear this exact question in 2025 before dismissing that earlier case on a procedural technicality, disputes in this case over whether customers were still harmed at the moment of purchase under Oregon law make it an imperfect test case.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided, resolving the longstanding circuit split over whether Article III or Rule 23(b)(3) permits certifying damages classes containing more than a de minimis number of uninjured members—the exact question left unresolved when Laboratory Corp. v. Davis was dismissed as improvidently granted—would reshape federal class-action practice and settlement leverage nationwide.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question (uninjured members in Rule 23(b)(3) damages classes) is nationally significant and twice granted before, but this vehicle is a small Oregon bottle-deposit class decided in an unpublished memorandum.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.79·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on uninjured members of damages classes could reshape certification and settlement leverage across consumer, antitrust, and other federal class actions; the underlying bottle-deposit dispute is much narrower.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents the unresolved Labcorp question on certifying Rule 23(b)(3) classes with uninjured members, backed by major business amici, though arising from an unpublished Rule 23(f) denial in a local Oregon bottle-deposit dispute.

Rio Grande Foundation v. Maggie Toulouse OliverThe Court declined to hear a nonprofit's challenge to New Mexico's campaign-finance donor-disclosure law as applied to its legislative scorecard mailings.First Amendmentdecided
0.55
0.70
0.70
0.65

Rio Grande Foundation v. Maggie Toulouse Oliver, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of New MexicoNo. 25-1248 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73292884 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: First Amendment

The Court declined to hear a nonprofit's challenge to New Mexico's campaign-finance donor-disclosure law as applied to its legislative scorecard mailings.

What happened

Rio Grande Foundation, an issue-advocacy nonprofit, wanted to mail a "Freedom Index" scoring New Mexico legislators' votes close to an election but held back because doing so would trigger donor-disclosure requirements under the state's Campaign Reporting Act. It sued New Mexico's Secretary of State, arguing the law's disclosure rules violated the First Amendment as applied to groups that do not expressly campaign for or against candidates. A federal district court upheld the law, and a divided Tenth Circuit panel affirmed, rejecting Rio Grande's reading of the statute and finding its mailing an obvious attempt to influence voters. The full Tenth Circuit declined to rehear the case, with two judges dissenting.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a state's interest in informing voters is enough to justify requiring donor disclosure from groups that mention candidates in ads but do not explicitly urge votes for or against them, whether such disclosure rules can be properly limited in scope without requiring donors to flag their money for a specific ad, and whether these disclosure rules should face the toughest level of constitutional review rather than a somewhat less demanding one.

Where it stands

The Court considered the petition at conferences in June and September 2026, during which it requested a response from the state, and denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Rio Grande Foundation asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the Tenth Circuit's ruling, which favored the state. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Tenth Circuit's decision in place: New Mexico's disclosure law, as applied to Rio Grande Foundation's mailings, stands, and the organization must comply with its donor-disclosure requirements if it proceeds with similar mailings. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A post-AFPF challenge to a state electioneering-communication donor-disclosure law with a published, divided Tenth Circuit opinion and four amici; a merits ruling would reach every state's pre-election disclosure regime, though it is not a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could materially change donor anonymity and election-related disclosure obligations for issue-advocacy nonprofits nationwide; the particular dispute concerns New Mexico's disclosure scheme.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment issue concerning donor disclosure and campaign finance, continuing the trajectory of AFPF v. Bonta.

Texas v. BlackTexas asks the Court to decide whether a federal law letting a private horseracing authority write industry rules improperly hands lawmaking power to a private entity.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.68
0.72
0.65

Texas, et al. v. Jerry Black, et al.No. 26-335 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000335 · models differ by up to 0.17

Texas asks the Court to decide whether a federal law letting a private horseracing authority write industry rules improperly hands lawmaking power to a private entity.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private nonprofit, to write and help enforce nationwide rules for Thoroughbred racing, subject to Federal Trade Commission oversight. Texas and others sued, arguing this setup unconstitutionally delegates government power to a private group. The Fifth Circuit held that the Authority's enforcement powers were unconstitutional but that its rulemaking powers, after a congressional amendment letting the FTC override Authority rules, were constitutional. Texas, along with other parties, petitioned for review of the rulemaking question, while the Authority and the federal government separately petitioned on the enforcement question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether Congress gave too much lawmaking authority to a private organization by letting it write industry-wide rules that a federal agency must approve unless they conflict with the law, with the agency's only check being its own, separate rulemaking power to later change those rules.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a response from the federal government and from the Authority, both opposing review, and a reply from Texas. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, and the docket shows no action since.

What each outcome would mean

Texas, joined by other challengers, is asking the Court to overturn the part of the Fifth Circuit's ruling that upheld the Authority's rulemaking powers as constitutional. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case and decide whether that rulemaking structure is valid, deciding nothing in advance. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision upholding the rulemaking provisions stays in place, leaving the current system, including the FTC's override power, intact for this case. The federal government and the Authority, as respondents, both urge denial and instead ask the Court to grant separate petitions on the enforcement-powers question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Texas' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Texas' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Texas asks the Supreme Court to rule that the federal horseracing law unconstitutionally lets a private corporation write binding rules for the industry. The Court will very likely hear the government's companion appeal about the law's enforcement provisions, which the lower court struck down. Whether it also takes Texas's question is close to a coin flip. I put the chance of any grant at a bit under one in two (42%), so I narrowly predict denial: the federal government says no appeals courts disagree on this question, and the Court could choose a parallel Oklahoma case instead.

    Why this big-case score: Facial constitutionality of a whole federal regulatory regime and the first major application of Consumers' Research's private-nondelegation framework; narrow industry, but a doctrinally significant structural question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to refuse Texas's request to review who may write national horseracing rules. I estimate an 18% chance of any grant of review, including sending the case back for another look. Courts have agreed that federal oversight makes this rulemaking arrangement lawful, while a separate dispute concerns who may enforce the rules. The Court may delay Texas's petition while considering that related dispute, but I expect an eventual denial, probably without any Justice publishing a separate explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The validity of nationwide horseracing regulation is important in itself; the limits on private rulemaking could also affect other federally supervised self-regulatory systems and state regulatory authority.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely to deny Texas's petition for review (86% chance of denial, or about a one-in-seven chance of being granted). In this case, Texas argues that the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act unconstitutionally gives lawmaking power over the horseracing industry to a private nonprofit corporation rather than a government agency. While the Supreme Court is expected to hear a related appeal over the corporation's power to enforce rules and issue fines—an issue on which federal appeals courts disagree—every appeals court has agreed that Congress fixed the rulemaking issue in 2022 by giving the Federal Trade Commission full power to rewrite or cancel any rule. Because there is no disagreement among lower courts on the rulemaking question and both the federal government and the horseracing authority oppose adding it, the Court will likely turn down Texas's separate appeal.

    Why this big-case score: Major private-nondelegation challenge by Texas to the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act's rulemaking structure, cross-petitioning alongside the federal government's and Authority's petitions on HISA's enforcement powers.

National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association v. Horseracing Integrity and Safety AuthorityA horsemen's association asks the Court to decide whether letting a private racing authority draft binding rules violates limits on delegating government power to private entities.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.70
0.65
0.65

National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, et al. v. Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, Incorporated, et al.No. 26-430 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000430 · models differ by up to 0.10

A horsemen's association asks the Court to decide whether letting a private racing authority draft binding rules violates limits on delegating government power to private entities.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private nonprofit, to write and enforce nationwide rules for thoroughbred racing, subject to review by the Federal Trade Commission. The National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association and others sued, arguing this arrangement unconstitutionally hands government power to a private body. After earlier rulings and a congressional amendment giving the FTC power to change the Authority's rules, the case returned to the Fifth Circuit, which held that the Authority's rulemaking role is constitutional but that its enforcement powers (investigating, sanctioning, and suing people) are not, because the FTC's oversight comes only after enforcement actions occur. Both sides separately asked the Supreme Court to review the decision.

What the Court is being asked

The horsemen's association asks the Court to decide whether it violates the rule against delegating government power to private entities for a private organization's rules to take legal effect before the government agency overseeing it can revise or block them, even if the agency can change the rules later.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for the Court's conference on December 4, 2026, after briefing that included the federal government's and the Authority's opposition, an amicus brief, and the horsemen's association's reply. No order on the petition has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

The National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, as petitioner, is asking the Court to take up this additional question alongside related cases. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the timing of the FTC's authority over the Authority's rules matters constitutionally, without yet deciding who is right. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's ruling upholding the rulemaking arrangement as constitutional stays in place, leaving that part of the case over, though related petitions on other questions would still proceed separately.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Horsemen want the Supreme Court to also decide whether the horseracing law unconstitutionally lets a private company write binding rules. I predict the Court will probably say no to this request: about a one-in-five chance it takes the question. The Court is very likely to hear the government's related appeal about the law's enforcement powers. This rulemaking question has no disagreement among lower courts, so the Court will most likely set it aside until that case is decided and then decline it.

    Why this big-case score: Part of the HISA package: whether a federal statute that hands rulemaking to a private corporation is constitutional; the companion enforcement question is the larger one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this request for review, with about an 18% chance it accepts the case in some form. The horsemen challenge whether a private racing regulator can write rules before the federal government can change them. Although related cases raise serious questions about that regulator's enforcement powers, the lower courts agree on its rulemaking powers. The Court can examine the enforcement dispute without adding this separate question. A refusal here would not decide those related cases.

    Why this big-case score: National horseracing regulation and the constitutional limits on private rulemaking have consequences beyond this industry, although the timing-of-agency-review question is narrower than the companion enforcement dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny this conditional cross-petition for certiorari (grant probability of 12%, or about one in eight). While the Court is expected to grant the companion petitions filed by the Federal Trade Commission and the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority to resolve a disagreement among federal appeals courts over the Authority's enforcement powers, the federal appeals courts unanimously agree that Congress's 2022 statutory amendment gave the Federal Trade Commission sufficient control over the Authority's rulemaking power to satisfy the Constitution's limits on delegating government power to private entities. Both the federal government and the Authority oppose adding this separate rulemaking question to the case.

    Why this big-case score: Private-nondelegation challenge to the rulemaking framework of a nationwide federal regulatory statute (HISA) on remand after FCC v. Consumers' Research, cross-petitioning alongside the high-profile HISA enforcement petitions.

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist v. FredericA Catholic organization asks the Supreme Court to decide whether denying it a permit to build a shrine on land next to its church violated a federal religious-liberty law.First Amendmentpartly decided
0.60
0.64
0.70
0.65

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc. v. Joel Frederic, et ux.No. 25-1131 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281619 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: First Amendment

A Catholic organization asks the Supreme Court to decide whether denying it a permit to build a shrine on land next to its church violated a federal religious-liberty law.

What happened

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist wanted to build a grotto honoring the Virgin Mary on land next to its church in Park Hills, Kentucky. A local zoning board granted the permit and variances needed, but neighbors Joel and Elizabeth Frederic sued, arguing the board lacked authority because the site was not next to an "arterial street" as the zoning code required. Kentucky's courts agreed the board exceeded its authority. The Kentucky Supreme Court also rejected the organization's argument that denying the permit violated a federal law protecting religious land use, holding there was no substantial burden on religious exercise and no unequal treatment of religious institutions.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide two questions about a federal law protecting religious institutions from burdensome or unequal zoning rules. First, whether completely blocking a religious group from building a religious structure on its chosen property counts as a serious enough burden on religious exercise to trigger the law's protections, even if the group could build something smaller elsewhere. Second, whether a zoning rule that applies an arterial-street requirement to religious buildings, while exempting some other uses like parks and golf courses, treats religious institutions unequally compared to those other uses.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court asked for and received a response from the Fredericks after initially receiving a waiver of their right to respond. After full briefing, including many outside groups weighing in, the Court granted the petition but limited review to the first question about substantial burden. The case has been scheduled for argument in January 2027.

What each outcome would mean

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist, the petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the Kentucky Supreme Court's ruling against it. If the Court affirms that ruling, the finding that denying the permit did not substantially burden the organization's religious exercise would stand, and the Fredericks' legal victory blocking the grotto would remain in place. If the Court reverses, it would mean the denial did impose a substantial burden, which could require further proceedings on whether the zoning restriction can still be justified. Vacating would send the case back without deciding the substantial-burden question either way.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseOct 1, 2026

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 20, 2027
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Frederic wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A first-ever construction of RLUIPA's land-use substantial-burden and equal-terms provisions would reshape church-zoning litigation nationwide (20 states and 16 amici say so); the facts themselves (a 16x39-foot grotto) are small, so the stakes are doctrinal rather than headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could materially change nationwide RLUIPA protections for religious land use and municipal zoning, although this vehicle concerns a particular shrine and disputed preservation and record issues.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First Supreme Court construction of RLUIPA's land-use substantial-burden provision after 26 years of acknowledged lower-court disarray; 16 cert-stage amicus briefs including 20 States signal broad interest, but the ruling is statutory and zoning-specific rather than constitutional, so it is significant without being a blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally consequential clarification of RLUIPA's land-use substantial-burden standard, affecting religious construction and municipal zoning; the grant excludes the separate equal-terms question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile religious liberty case interpreting the substantial burden provision of RLUIPA.

Cantero v. Bank of AmericaMortgage borrowers ask the Court to hear a second round of their case over whether federal banking law blocks New York's requirement that banks pay interest on mortgage escrow accounts.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.64
0.75
0.65

Alex Cantero, et al., Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated v. Bank of America, N.A.scotus/73500214 · models differ by up to 0.20

Mortgage borrowers ask the Court to hear a second round of their case over whether federal banking law blocks New York's requirement that banks pay interest on mortgage escrow accounts.

What happened

Alex Cantero and other New York homeowners sued Bank of America, arguing it owed them interest on money held in mortgage escrow accounts, as required by New York law. The bank argued federal banking law preempts that state requirement for national banks. In 2024, the Supreme Court vacated an earlier Second Circuit ruling for the bank, and told the appeals court to use a more careful, comparative method for deciding preemption questions. On remand, a divided Second Circuit panel again ruled for the bank, holding the state law preempted, while one judge dissented. The panel acknowledged its decision conflicts with a First Circuit ruling reaching the opposite result for a similar Rhode Island law.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether federal law governing national banks overrides, or preempts, state laws like New York's that require banks to pay a minimum interest rate on mortgage escrow accounts.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference; the docket shows no decision from that conference. On October 5, 2026, the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views, and that invitation remains pending.

What each outcome would mean

Cantero and the other homeowners are asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether New York's law applies to national banks, with no outcome assumed in advance. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling for Bank of America stands, and the law is treated as preempted in that circuit, while a conflicting ruling favoring borrowers stands in the First Circuit. The Solicitor General's views, once filed, could inform whether the Court acts either way, but do not themselves decide the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 18, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Cantero's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Cantero's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Second trip of a unanimous 2024 vacatur; the National Bank Act preemption standard for 14 states' interest-on-escrow laws, a fresh OCC preemption determination, 26 states plus DC and the state bank supervisors as amici. Nationally important to banking regulation, but technical and low in public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question affects mortgage-escrow compensation across numerous states and the boundary between national-bank powers and state consumer protection; its doctrinal and financial reach is substantial even though the immediate dispute concerns a specialized banking practice.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct circuit split on the National Bank Act preemption standard, an issue the Court remanded two years prior.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    National Bank Act preemption of fourteen states' interest-on-escrow laws, a second trip after a unanimous 2024 decision, with 27 states and DC as amici and a fresh OCC preemption rule in play: high stakes for banking regulation and consumer law, but a technical subject with limited general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring mortgage-escrow obligations across multiple states and the reach of federal banking preemption give this dispute substantial consumer and regulatory stakes, though its immediate question is a specialized banking issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major federal preemption question over state interest-on-escrow laws affecting the national banking system under Dodd-Frank.

Gulf Coast Racing LLC. v. Horseracing Integrity and Safety AuthorityGulf Coast Racing and others ask the Court to decide whether a private horseracing authority's leaders must be appointed under the Constitution's rules for federal officers.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.77
0.62
0.65

Gulf Coast Racing LLC., et al. v. Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, Incorporated, et al.No. 26-332 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000332 · models differ by up to 0.22

Gulf Coast Racing and others ask the Court to decide whether a private horseracing authority's leaders must be appointed under the Constitution's rules for federal officers.

What happened

Congress created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority, a private nonprofit, to write and enforce nationwide safety and anti-doping rules for thoroughbred racing, subject to Federal Trade Commission oversight. Gulf Coast Racing and other horsemen sued, arguing the arrangement is unconstitutional. After earlier proceedings and a prior trip to the Supreme Court, the Fifth Circuit held that the Authority's rulemaking powers and its appointment structure were constitutional, but that its enforcement powers were not. Gulf Coast Racing, joined by the Authority, the federal government, and other challengers, separately asked the Supreme Court to review the decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the people who lead the Authority must be chosen the way the Constitution requires for federal officers, given the significant regulatory power they hold. A related question, which would arise only if the answer is no, is whether letting a private organization hold this much nationwide rulemaking and enforcement power is constitutional at all.

Where it stands

The petition and other related petitions have been distributed for the Court's conference. Briefing is complete, including opposition briefs from the Authority and the federal government and a reply from Gulf Coast Racing.

What each outcome would mean

Gulf Coast Racing asks the Court to take up this question. The Authority and the federal government, which lost on the enforcement-powers issue below, instead want the Court to grant their own petitions on that separate question while denying Gulf Coast Racing's. If the Court grants Gulf Coast Racing's petition, it would hear full arguments on whether the Authority's leaders need constitutional appointment; a decision could then uphold or reject the current structure. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's ruling that the Authority's directors do not need such appointment stays in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Gulf Coast Racing LLC.'s case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Gulf Coast Racing LLC.'s petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down this petition. We put the chance it takes the case at about one in five. Racetrack owners argue that the leaders of the horseracing safety authority should have been appointed like federal officers. The Court is expected to review the main dispute over the horseracing law through the government's own petitions. Both the government and the authority oppose adding this question, and no lower court has agreed with it. The Court will probably set this petition aside until it decides the main case, and then deny it.

    Why this big-case score: Whether a nationwide private-label regulator's board must be appointed under Article II matters to HISA, the horseracing industry and other public-private regulators, but this is a cross-petition beside the lead federal petitions.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.77·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to decline this request for review, with an 18% chance of accepting it or sending it back for reconsideration. The challengers raise an important question about whether privately chosen horse-racing regulators need constitutionally required appointments. But the Court can address the related enforcement dispute through other petitions without taking this additional question, which also faces a standing objection. The strongest reason for review is its connection to that larger dispute; the biggest uncertainty is whether four Justices want to broaden the case.

    Why this big-case score: The constitutional limits on assigning federal regulatory power to privately selected directors extend beyond the national horseracing regime to other public-private regulators.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very unlikely to grant this conditional cross-petition for certiorari (an 8% chance of a grant, meaning a petition to review a lower court decision, or a grant-vacate-remand order), and is expected to deny it. Although the Court is almost certain to hear the main appeals by the Federal Trade Commission and the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority over whether the Authority's enforcement powers are constitutional, Gulf Coast Racing's separate cross-petition asks whether the Authority's board members must be appointed by the President under the Constitution's Appointments Clause and whether its rulemaking powers are invalid. Because every federal appeals court has rejected those arguments and both the federal government and the Authority oppose expanding the case, the Court will likely deny this cross-petition.

    Why this big-case score: Conditional cross-petition in high-profile nationwide constitutional litigation over the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (HISA), presenting Appointments Clause (Lebron) and private-nondelegation questions alongside lead petitions Nos. 26-199 and 26-201.

Palestine Liberation Organization v. SokolowThe Palestine Liberation Organization asks the Court to undo a reinstated $655.5 million terrorism judgment, arguing the lower court wrongly revived a case once dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.70
0.78
0.64

Palestine Liberation Organization, et al. v. Mark I. Sokolow, et al.No. 26-372 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000372 · models differ by up to 0.33

The Palestine Liberation Organization asks the Court to undo a reinstated $655.5 million terrorism judgment, arguing the lower court wrongly revived a case once dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

What happened

American victims of attacks in Israel sued the PLO and Palestinian Authority under the Anti-Terrorism Act. A jury awarded them $655.5 million in 2015, but the Second Circuit vacated the judgment in 2016 for lack of personal jurisdiction, and the Supreme Court denied review. Congress later passed a law, the PSJVTA, creating jurisdiction based on the defendants' conduct after 2020. After the Supreme Court upheld that law in a related case, the Second Circuit recalled its earlier mandate and reinstated the original 2015 judgment. The PLO and Palestinian Authority sought rehearing, which was denied, and now ask the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an appeals court may use its own equitable power to reopen a closed case to bring back a money judgment that was thrown out for lack of jurisdiction years earlier, when the only new jurisdiction available came from a law Congress passed only after the case had already become final.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026, after both the victims and the federal government waived their right to respond. The Court has not yet acted on whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The Palestine Liberation Organization and Palestinian Authority are asking the Court to step in. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether reviving the judgment was proper, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, leaving the $655.5 million judgment reinstated in favor of the victims and their families, who prevailed below.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Palestine Liberation Organization's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Palestine Liberation Organization's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely turn down this petition (about a 4% chance it takes the case). The PLO and Palestinian Authority want the Court to throw out a $655 million terrorism-victims judgment. A lower court revived that judgment after Congress passed a law giving U.S. courts power over them. The petitioners point to no disagreement among lower courts. The Court has already upheld that law unanimously, and the U.S. government did not even bother to file a response.

    Why this big-case score: A $655.5M Anti-Terrorism Act judgment against the PLO/PA, a follow-on to Fuld v. PLO, with a novel question about reviving a judgment vacated for lack of personal jurisdiction; significant but sequel-like and fact-bound.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal: I estimate a 4% chance that it agrees to review the case. The PLO and Palestinian Authority challenge the revival of a $655.5 million terrorism judgment after an earlier dismissal for lack of authority over them. That is a serious legal issue, but this unusually complex case shows no clear disagreement among federal appeals courts. Both groups of respondents waived a response. I expect a denial without an explanation or another conference discussion.

    Why this big-case score: A $655.5 million terrorism judgment against the PLO and Palestinian Authority, with substantial asserted foreign-policy consequences and an important question about reviving judgments after a jurisdictional dismissal; the unusual statutory history limits its general reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Palestine Liberation Organization v. Sokolow*, with only a 2% chance (one in fifty) of granting the petition. In 2025, the Court unanimously upheld the federal law establishing personal jurisdiction (a court's authority over the parties) over the Palestine Liberation Organization and Palestinian Authority, and the Second Circuit then reinstated a $655.5 million jury verdict for American terrorism victims by recalling its earlier mandate (an appellate court's formal order ending an appeal). Because both the victims and the United States waived their right to file a response, the Court already denied an emergency stay in August 2026, and no circuit split exists, the Court is unlikely to revisit the case.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided on the merits, the case tests the constitutional limits of federal appellate mandate-recall power under Article III, Plaut v. Spendthrift Farm, and Pennoyer v. Neff when reinstating a $655.5 million Anti-Terrorism Act judgment against the PLO and Palestinian Authority previously vacated for lack of personal jurisdiction.

Thompson v. WilsonThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Maine lobsterman's challenge to a state rule requiring GPS trackers on fishing boats.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.55
0.67
0.70
0.64

Frank Thompson v. Carl Wilson, Commissioner, Maine Department of Marine ResourcesNo. 25-1105 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281388 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Maine lobsterman's challenge to a state rule requiring GPS trackers on fishing boats.

What happened

Maine requires federally permitted lobstermen to install GPS tracking devices on their boats, reporting location data to help regulators manage the lobster fishery. Frank Thompson and other lobstermen sued, arguing the requirement amounts to an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment, which protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. The district court dismissed the claim, applying a Supreme Court framework for evaluating searches of "closely regulated industries," and the First Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that ruling. Thompson alone then asked the Supreme Court to take up the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether tracking devices that must stay on lobster boats at all times, including when the boats are used for non-commercial purposes, amount to an unreasonable search, and whether courts evaluating such searches must consider protections against physical intrusion onto property, not just a business owner's reduced privacy expectations in a regulated industry.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after briefing including amicus filings and supplemental briefs from both sides. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Thompson asked the Court to review and reverse the First Circuit's decision, which had sided with Maine's commissioner, Carl Wilson, and upheld the tracking requirement. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the First Circuit's ruling in place: Maine's GPS tracking rule continues to apply to Thompson and other lobstermen, and the lower court's reasoning stands. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the rule is constitutional, only that it chose not to review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would settle whether the Jones/Carpenter property-based Fourth Amendment framework constrains Burger administrative searches and continuous electronic monitoring of mixed-use property, reaching every 'closely regulated' industry and every ASMFC lobster state; significant doctrinally, but a niche regulatory-surveillance dispute rather than a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Continuous tracking of mixed commercial and personal property raises substantial Fourth Amendment questions extending beyond lobster vessels to regulated businesses, although this vehicle concerns a particular fisheries program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional challenge involving the Fourth Amendment and GPS tracking of commercial vessels, drawing significant amicus interest from conservative legal groups.

Daisey Trust v. Federal Housing Finance AgencyThe Court declined to hear property investors' challenge to the funding structure of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which they said let the agency foreclose unlawfully.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.50
0.72
0.70
0.64

Daisey Trust, By and Through Its Trustee Eddie Haddad, et al. v. Federal Housing Finance Agency, et al.No. 25-1144 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281632 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Court declined to hear property investors' challenge to the funding structure of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which they said let the agency foreclose unlawfully.

What happened

Daisey Trust and related entities bought properties at foreclosure sales; the properties were still subject to mortgage liens held by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) oversees as conservator. Facing foreclosure, they sued FHFA, arguing its funding—assessments on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac with no spending cap—violates the constitutional requirement that government spending be appropriated by law, and improperly gives the agency open-ended power that Congress should have limited. A federal district court dismissed the suit, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, finding the funding scheme constitutional.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an agency's funding scheme must include a cap or other measurable limit on how much it can raise and spend to satisfy the rule that government money be spent only as authorized by law, whether Congress can declare that an agency's funds do not count as government money for that purpose, and whether the law authorizing FHFA's funding gives the agency clear enough limits on its discretion to collect and spend money.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for two conferences, with the Court requesting a response from FHFA after the first distribution. The Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Daisey Trust and the other investment entities asked the Court to take up their case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling. By denying review, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the lower court's ruling that FHFA's funding structure is constitutional stands, and FHFA's funding and foreclosure authority over these properties remains intact. Had the Court granted the petition, it would have heard full arguments and decided the funding questions itself, without that happening now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, an Appropriations Clause and nondelegation ruling on FHFA's self-funding would reach the conservator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and every non-appropriated financial regulator; stakes are high on a grant, though the likely denial makes the case a non-event.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling on FHFA's assessment-funded structure could affect federal housing-finance administration and other self-funded agencies. Those institutional stakes are substantial despite this foreclosure dispute's vehicle problems and low certiorari likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional challenge that could invalidate the funding of the FHFA would be a major decision affecting housing markets, although the chance of a grant is low.

Teck Metals v. Confederated Tribes of the Colville ReservationTeck Metals asks the Supreme Court to review a Ninth Circuit ruling allowing the Colville Tribes to pursue damages against it for lost cultural uses of a contaminated river.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.67
0.70
0.64

Teck Metals Ltd., fka Teck Cominco Metals Ltd., a Canadian corporation v. Confederated Tribes of the Colville ReservationNo. 26-130 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000130 · models differ by up to 0.15

Teck Metals asks the Supreme Court to review a Ninth Circuit ruling allowing the Colville Tribes to pursue damages against it for lost cultural uses of a contaminated river.

What happened

The Colville Tribes sued Teck, a Canadian mining company, claiming decades of discharges from its British Columbia smelter contaminated the Upper Columbia River, harming fish and other organisms. Beyond damages the Tribes sought jointly with Washington State, the Tribes separately sought damages tied to their unique cultural relationship with the river. A federal district court ruled that such cultural-related damages are not recoverable under the federal cleanup law known as CERCLA and granted Teck summary judgment on those claims. The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding the law does not categorically bar recovering lost-use damages that have a cultural dimension, and sent the case back for trial. The appeals court denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the federal law allowing lawsuits over damaged natural resources permits compensation when the harm is described as tribal members' felt loss of cultural connection to those resources, or whether such damages fall outside what the law allows.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference. Teck filed its reply after the Tribes opposed the petition, and briefing is complete. On October 5, 2026, the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views, so the petition remains pending without further action yet.

What each outcome would mean

Teck Metals, the company found liable below, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether this kind of cultural-loss damages claim is allowed under the law, resolving nothing until it rules. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, and the Tribes' claims for these damages proceed to trial in the lower courts. Because the Court has asked for the Solicitor General's views first, any decision on whether to hear the case will wait until that brief is filed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Teck Metals' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Teck Metals' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A major CERCLA remedies question (whether natural-resource damages reach culturally framed lost-use claims) with more than $500 million at stake in this case alone, a foreign sovereign and the federal government's own PRP exposure in play, but a technical statutory issue rather than a constitutional headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially substantial consequences for nationwide natural-resource damages, tribal cultural uses, and public and private CERCLA defendants, with cross-border interests. The interlocutory ruling has not fixed any damages award, limiting the immediacy of the stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High stakes CERCLA dispute involving novel tribal cultural connection damages, drawing five major industry and sovereign amici.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Scope of CERCLA natural-resource damages (whether trustees may recover for cultural / nonuse losses) with half a billion dollars at stake, industry, tribal and a foreign-sovereign amicus interest; significant for environmental and tribal law but a technical remedies question rather than a headline constitutional case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially important national boundary on CERCLA natural-resource damages, with substantial tribal cultural interests and public and private liability at stake; narrower than a general ruling on tribal sovereignty or environmental regulation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Khatibi v. LawsonA California physician asks the Court to decide whether state-mandated continuing education content for doctors counts as government speech exempt from free speech protections.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.55
0.66
0.70
0.64

Azadeh Khatibi, et al. v. Kristina D. Lawson, President of the Medical Board of California, et al.No. 25-1240 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73286452 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: First Amendment

A California physician asks the Court to decide whether state-mandated continuing education content for doctors counts as government speech exempt from free speech protections.

What happened

Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist who teaches continuing medical education (CME) courses, and Do No Harm, a physicians' organization, sued officials of the Medical Board of California. They challenged a state law requiring all CME courses to address "implicit bias," arguing this compels them to convey a message they disagree with, violating the First Amendment. The district court dismissed their claims, holding that CME courses approved for credit are government speech, not private speech subject to free speech protections. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, and the full court denied rehearing en banc over two dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether instruction that private teachers give in courses required for a professional license should be treated as the government's own speech, which would place it outside ordinary free speech protections, or as private speech that the government may not freely compel or control.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for several conferences, most recently one scheduled after the snapshot date, following full briefing including a brief in opposition and a reply. The docket does not yet show any action granting or denying the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Khatibi and Do No Harm, as petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling in favor of the Medical Board. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments on whether CME instruction is government speech, deciding the question itself without presuming either side correct. If the Court denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place the rule that California's CME content requirements count as government speech and are not subject to free speech challenge, a result favoring the Medical Board.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Khatibi's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Khatibi's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision would fix the reach of the government-speech doctrine over privately delivered, licensure-required instruction (CME/CLE nationwide) and settle whether implicit-bias training mandates compel speech; significant First Amendment doctrine, but a narrow class of regulation rather than a blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between government speech and privately delivered professional education could affect licensing-linked instruction beyond California medicine. The immediate challenge concerns a specific CME requirement, limiting its reach relative to a nationwide regulatory challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant First Amendment compelled speech challenge to state professional continuing education requirements.

Hadley v. City of South BendThe Supreme Court declined to hear a homeowner's bid to force compensation for severe property damage police caused while searching her house for a fugitive who was never there.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.55
0.65
0.70
0.63

Amy Hadley v. City of South Bend, Indiana, et al.No. 25-1158 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281642 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a homeowner's bid to force compensation for severe property damage police caused while searching her house for a fugitive who was never there.

What happened

Police in South Bend and St. Joseph County, Indiana, searched Amy Hadley's home for a fugitive based on a mistaken IP-address lead. No one connected to the fugitive was there. Officers fired dozens of tear-gas canisters, broke windows, and tore apart the interior, causing about $16,000 in damage. Hadley sued under the Takings Clause, which requires compensation when government takes property for public use. The district court dismissed her claim, and the Seventh Circuit affirmed, holding that circuit precedent treats property damage from a lawful police search as an exercise of "police power" rather than eminent domain, so no compensation is owed. The Seventh Circuit denied rehearing en banc.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether the rule that compensation is never owed for property damage caused by police exercising law-enforcement power, rather than the power to formally condemn property, is a valid reading of the Constitution's compensation requirement, and separately whether the government can avoid paying for intentionally destroying an innocent person's property while pursuing a fugitive.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference multiple times between September and October 2026. On October 19, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Hadley, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Seventh Circuit's ruling in place: Hadley and others in that circuit cannot recover compensation under the Takings Clause for property damage reasonably caused by police executing a valid search warrant. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision standing without deciding the underlying question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on whether the Takings Clause reaches police destruction of an innocent owner's home would settle a seven-circuit conflict, reach every SWAT deployment nationally, and draw wide press; it is not a marquee constitutional case of the Term.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could establish nationwide compensation rules for innocent owners whose homes police intentionally damage, with substantial property-rights and municipal-liability implications beyond the modest individual loss.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on whether the police-power exception exempts law enforcement from the Takings Clause when destroying innocent property would be a major constitutional property-rights decision.

Hellman v. CravenParents of private-school children with disabilities ask the Court to revive their challenge to a Massachusetts rule limiting where the state will deliver their children's special-education services.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.70
0.65
0.63

Ariella Hellman, on Their Own Behalf and as Next Friend of Their Child, E. H., et al. v. Katherine Craven, Chair, Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, et al.No. 26-97 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000097 · models differ by up to 0.15

Parents of private-school children with disabilities ask the Court to revive their challenge to a Massachusetts rule limiting where the state will deliver their children's special-education services.

What happened

Massachusetts law entitles all children with disabilities, including those in private school, to publicly funded special-education services. But a state regulation requires that privately enrolled children receive those services at a public school or other neutral site, not on their private school's campus, a rule the state adopted to comply with a state constitutional ban on aiding private schools. Two families whose children attend private Jewish schools sued, arguing the rule unconstitutionally forces them to choose between their children's services and their right to choose private schooling. A federal district court dismissed the suit, and the First Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the regulation does not infringe that right.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a rule against denying someone a government benefit because they have exercised a constitutional right applies to the right of parents to send their children to private school. The parents say the First Circuit wrongly treated that protection as limited to religious-liberty cases, while Massachusetts says the lower court correctly found no constitutional burden here at all.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, after which the Court asked Massachusetts to respond; Massachusetts has now filed its brief opposing review, and the petition awaits the Court's decision on whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The Hellman and Harrison families are asking the Court to take up and reverse the First Circuit's ruling, which left the Massachusetts regulation in place. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on the question and decide whether the rule violates their constitutional rights, deciding nothing at this stage about who is right. If the Court denies review, the First Circuit's decision stands, leaving the regulation in effect and the families' lawsuit over.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Hellman's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Hellman's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Massachusetts parents of children with disabilities ask the Supreme Court to hear their challenge to a state rule that cuts off special-education services when parents choose private school. We predict the Court will most likely turn the case down, putting the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in five. That is well above the usual odds: the Court asked the State to respond after it had declined to, and fourteen states and several groups filed supporting briefs. But the legal theory is novel and the case may look like an imperfect test of it.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling extending unconstitutional-conditions protection to the Pierce right would reach every state Blaine-style or general anti-aid provision and special-education benefit scheme; a 14-state amicus coalition signals breadth, though the immediate stakes are a single regulation.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down this appeal than hear it: I give the families about a three-in-ten chance of obtaining review. They challenge Massachusetts rules requiring children in private schools to travel elsewhere for publicly funded special-education services. Several supporting briefs and the Court's request for a response make the case stand out. But the lower court treated the rule as a permissible choice about delivering services, and the claimed disagreement with other courts is not an exact match.

    Why this big-case score: Whether parental educational choice protects access to established public benefits could affect special-education services and restrictions on aid to private-school pupils beyond Massachusetts; the immediate dispute concerns service location rather than a general entitlement to subsidized tuition.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny the petition for review, giving it a 4% chance of being granted (about one in twenty-five). Massachusetts offers state-funded special-education services to private-school students, but requires those services to take place at public or neutral sites rather than inside private schools. Although the Court asked Massachusetts to file a response to the parents' petition, longstanding Supreme Court precedent holds that the constitutional right to choose private schooling does not require states to deliver public services on-site at private schools, and lower federal courts are not genuinely divided on that rule.

    Why this big-case score: If granted, a ruling applying the unconstitutional conditions doctrine to the substantive due process right under Pierce v. Society of Sisters to attend private school would significantly reshape state public-benefit programs and school-choice funding nationwide beyond the religious free-exercise context.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Asks whether unconstitutional-conditions doctrine protects the Pierce right to choose private school; reaches the 14 secular no-aid state amendments and special-education delivery nationwide, but the immediate dispute is the location of services for two children.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question could materially extend parental educational-choice protections to conditions on public benefits, with nationwide implications for special education and private schooling; the immediate dispute concerns a narrower service-location rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If granted and decided on the merits, resolving whether the unconstitutional conditions doctrine applies to the Pierce v. Society of Sisters substantive due process right to private schooling would carry significant nationwide consequences for state special-education funding and school-choice programs beyond the Free Exercise Clause.

Department of Justice v. McNuttThe federal government asked the Supreme Court to uphold its longstanding ban on distilling spirits at home, after a lower court struck the ban down.Taxpartly decided
0.60
0.64
0.65
0.63

Department of Justice, et al. v. Scott McNutt, et al.No. 26-204 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000204 · models differ by up to 0.05 · topic: Tax

The federal government asked the Supreme Court to uphold its longstanding ban on distilling spirits at home, after a lower court struck the ban down.

What happened

Hobby distillers, including Scott McNutt and the Hobby Distillers Association, sued the Department of Justice and the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, arguing that the federal ban on producing distilled spirits in homes and connected areas goes beyond Congress's constitutional powers. A district court agreed and blocked enforcement against them. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, ruling the prohibition does not properly carry out Congress's power to tax, since it reduces rather than raises revenue and intrudes on authority reserved to the states. A different appeals court, the Sixth Circuit, had reached the opposite conclusion in a separate case called Ream. The government then asked the Supreme Court to review the Fifth Circuit's decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law banning home distilling, which Congress passed alongside its tax on distilled spirits, is a valid way of carrying out Congress's power to collect that tax, or whether it goes beyond what that taxing power allows.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the government's petition on October 19, 2026. The case has not yet been briefed on the merits or argued; the Court recently granted a motion to skip printing a joint appendix of record materials.

What each outcome would mean

The government is asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling, which favored McNutt and the other distillers. If the Court reverses, the home-distilling ban would be upheld and enforceable against them. If it affirms, the lower court's decision striking down the ban as unconstitutional would stand, and McNutt and the association would remain free from its enforcement. If the Court vacates the decision, it would send the case back without resolving the ban's constitutionality for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Court decidesTook the caseOct 19, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Department of Justice wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: McNutt wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court took the case. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First appellate invalidation of a federal statute on Necessary and Proper Clause grounds in years; a decision either way shapes the taxing-power/N&P doctrine, and the home-distilling subject is publicly resonant, though the direct economic stakes are modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could define Congress's Necessary and Proper authority to protect federal tax collection, though it arises from a narrow home-distilling restriction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the constitutionality of a 160-year-old federal statute restricting distillation, with a direct circuit split and DOJ petitioning.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Solicitor General petition to restore a 160-year-old federal statute the Fifth Circuit struck down on enumerated-powers grounds, with a square CA5/CA6 split and a Necessary and Proper Clause question that reaches past home distilling into the taxing power's regulatory perimeter. Real constitutional-structure stakes and broad popular interest, but a narrower doctrinal footprint than the Term's marquee separation-of-powers cases.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 96%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional challenge to a longstanding federal home-distilling prohibition presents consequential limits on tax-enforcement legislation and federal power, although the immediate regulated activity is relatively narrow.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the constitutionality of a long-standing federal statute regulating distilled spirits and the scope of Congress's taxing power.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 73%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First Supreme Court test in years of the Necessary and Proper Clause's reach over the taxing power, with a square circuit split over a 160-year-old federal criminal statute. The practical stakes (hobby distilling) are narrow, but the doctrinal stakes are broad.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The challenge tests constitutional limits on federal tax-enforcement regulation and criminal restrictions on home distilling. Its implications extend beyond hobby distillers, but a narrow tax-administration holding would limit its broader impact.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Presents a significant constitutional question on the Necessary and Proper Clause, though home distilling itself is a niche issue.

General Dynamics v. ScharpfShipbuilders ask the Court to review a ruling reviving a wage-suppression lawsuit, while the plaintiff's own lawyer has now asked the Court to pause the case.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.58
0.85
0.63

General Dynamics Corporation, et al. v. Susan ScharpfNo. 25-293 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73275236 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Business & finance

Shipbuilders ask the Court to review a ruling reviving a wage-suppression lawsuit, while the plaintiff's own lawyer has now asked the Court to pause the case.

What happened

Susan Scharpf and other naval engineers sued General Dynamics and other shipbuilding companies, claiming they secretly agreed not to recruit each other's engineers, suppressing wages for decades. A federal district court dismissed the case as filed too late, ruling that an unwritten agreement alone cannot excuse the delay. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed, holding that the plaintiffs had adequately alleged the companies took active steps to hide their agreement, allowing the case to proceed. The shipbuilders then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, to excuse a late-filed lawsuit, it is enough for plaintiffs to allege that companies kept an illegal agreement unwritten and secret, or whether they must show the companies took some additional active step to mislead people and prevent them from finding out.

Where it stands

The Court asked the Solicitor General in January 2026 to submit the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard. In May 2026, the shipbuilders submitted a request asking that the petition be held in abeyance, meaning paused rather than acted on; the docket does not show whether the Court has ruled on that request.

What each outcome would mean

General Dynamics and the other shipbuilders, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case and overturn the Fourth Circuit's decision reviving Scharpf's lawsuit. If the Court grants review and later rules for the shipbuilders, Scharpf's case would likely be dismissed as untimely. If the Court denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands, and the case returns to the lower courts, where Scharpf's lawsuit continues. The pending request to pause the case does not resolve these questions; it only affects when the Court acts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up General Dynamics' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: General Dynamics' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 50%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pleading standard for fraudulent-concealment tolling under 15 U.S.C. 15b would reach every Sherman Act conspiracy suit and drew Chamber/NAM and industry amici, but the question is technical and procedural; stakes are moderate, not landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential for nationwide antitrust limitations and worker no-poach suits, including substantial naval-industry exposure, but the presented issue is a technical tolling and pleading question rather than the legality of no-poach agreements generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes antitrust class action involving major defense contractors and the standard for tolling the statute of limitations.

Roybal v. GriffithThe Supreme Court vacated a Tenth Circuit ruling that had let a transgender former jail detainee's civil rights claims proceed, sending the case back for reconsideration under two newer rulings.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.50
0.79
0.58
0.62

Joseph J. Roybal, Sheriff, El Paso County, Colorado, et al. v. Darlene GriffithNo. 25-442 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73278467 · models differ by up to 0.29 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court vacated a Tenth Circuit ruling that had let a transgender former jail detainee's civil rights claims proceed, sending the case back for reconsideration under two newer rulings.

What happened

Darlene Griffith, a transgender woman, was jailed as a pretrial detainee in El Paso County, Colorado. She says jail policy housed her with male detainees, denied her female commissary items, and had a male deputy strip-search her, including abusive comments during the search. She sued the sheriff and jail staff. A federal district court dismissed her claims. The Tenth Circuit reversed in part, holding she had plausibly alleged an equal protection violation and a claim over the cross-sex strip search, while rejecting other claims. The sheriff and the deputy asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether courts must apply a more skeptical level of review to jail policies that separate detainees by biological sex, or whether courts should instead defer heavily to jail officials' security judgments. It also asks whether having a male officer search a transgender female detainee can violate her constitutional rights absent an emergency.

Where it stands

After the petition was fully briefed, the Court asked the Solicitor General for the federal government's views. The government recommended granting the case, setting aside the Tenth Circuit's decision, and returning it for reconsideration in light of two other Supreme Court rulings decided since the lower court ruled. The Court has now done exactly that: it granted the petition, vacated the Tenth Circuit's judgment, and sent the case back for further review in light of those rulings, without deciding the underlying questions itself.

What each outcome would mean

The sheriff and the deputy, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the Tenth Circuit's decision reviving Griffith's claims. By vacating that decision and remanding, the Court has not ruled on who is right; it has instead directed the Tenth Circuit to reconsider the case applying the reasoning of the newer rulings. Griffith's claims are not dismissed, but neither are they confirmed to proceed. The Tenth Circuit must now decide, with that fresh guidance, whether her equal protection and search claims can still go forward or must be dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Nov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 84%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Equal-protection standard for sex-based prison policies as applied to transgender inmates plus a cross-gender strip-search rule; nationally salient (23 States amici, SG participation) but post-Skrmetti/B.P.J. the doctrinal stakes are partly settled.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions implicate transgender detainees' equal protection, bodily privacy, and jail administration nationwide. Their potential significance is substantial even though a narrow remand, rather than a plenary ruling establishing new rules, is the likeliest disposition.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case touches on highly salient issues involving trans-identifying individuals in prisons, though a likely GVR limits its independent legal impact.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, it fixes the standard of review for every sex-based housing, commissary and search policy in US jails and prisons and follows Skrmetti and B.P.J. as the next transgender equal-protection ruling; narrower than those two because the prison setting bounds it, but with 23 state amici and the federal Bureau of Prisons directly affected.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court takes the case: 43%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern equal-protection scrutiny of sex-based detention policies and searches of transgender detainees, with implications for prison administration and detainee rights nationwide. The pleading-stage vehicle may substantially limit any ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High profile constitutional question with national impact and significant state interest.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the Solicitor General filed the brief the Court invited. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-brief-sg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Equal-protection and search claims of a transgender detainee against sex-segregated jail policies, with a 23-state amicus and a 3-3 split on QP1; stakes are national but the SG's GVR route would leave the questions to the Tenth Circuit on remand.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.79·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions affect transgender detainees' equal-protection and search rights, prison housing and staffing nationwide, and the scope of judicial deference to correctional officials. A summary remand would have narrower immediate reach than a plenary ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Moderate-to-high salience constitutional dispute over whether Turner v. Safley deference or VMI heightened scrutiny governs sex-based housing, commissary, and search policies applied to transgender inmates, drawing a 23-State amicus brief and a CVSG, though its prospective doctrinal stakes are substantially narrowed after West Virginia v. B.P.J. and United States v. Skrmetti.

Salazar v. Paramount GlobalThe Supreme Court heard arguments over whether a man who signed up for a sports website's free newsletter counts as a "consumer" under a 1988 video privacy law.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.55
0.62
0.70
0.62

Michael Salazar v. Paramount Global, dba 247SportsNo. 25-459 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73278510 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court heard arguments over whether a man who signed up for a sports website's free newsletter counts as a "consumer" under a 1988 video privacy law.

What happened

Michael Salazar signed up for a free email newsletter from 247Sports, a sports news website owned by Paramount Global. He watched free videos on the site while logged into Facebook, and the site shared his Facebook ID and viewing activity with Facebook without his consent. Salazar sued under the Video Privacy Protection Act, which bars a "video tape service provider" from disclosing a "consumer's" viewing history without consent. A federal district court dismissed his case, and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that Salazar was not a "consumer" because the law only covers people who rent, buy, or subscribe to audiovisual goods or services, and his newsletter subscription did not qualify. Salazar appealed to the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The case turns on how broadly to read the law's definition of "consumer." The law defines a consumer as someone who rents, buys, or subscribes to "goods or services" from a company that also deals in video materials. The Court must decide whether that phrase covers only audiovisual goods or services, or whether it includes anything the company offers, including things unrelated to video, such as a free email newsletter.

Where it stands

The Court granted review on January 26, 2026, and the case was argued on October 14, 2026. It now awaits a decision.

What each outcome would mean

Salazar, the person who sued and lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to reverse the Sixth Circuit's ruling. If the Court rules for Salazar, it would find that he does count as a "consumer" under the law, reviving his lawsuit and sending the case back for further proceedings on his privacy claim. If the Court rules for Paramount instead, it would uphold the Sixth Circuit's narrower reading, leaving Salazar's lawsuit dismissed and confirming that only subscriptions to video-related offerings can make someone a "consumer" under the statute.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Salazar wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Paramount Global wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 45%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decides whether the VPPA's 'consumer' definition sustains the large wave of pixel-tracking class actions against media and retail companies; high industry stakes (Meta, MPA, Chamber amici) but technical statutory subject matter with modest general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 66%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The VPPA rule will affect nationwide digital-media, advertising, and privacy litigation, as reflected by the broad industry amicus participation.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 35%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 45%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Hundreds of pending Meta-pixel VPPA class actions against media, retail, and streaming companies turn on this definition, drawing an eleven-brief business and media amicus lineup; high stakes for industry, though doctrinally a niche statutory-interpretation question rather than a landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 42%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The ruling will govern nationwide VPPA exposure for common web analytics and video-tracking practices across media, retail, and technology businesses.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    High impact for internet privacy and liability of streaming platforms under the VPPA, but technically narrow statutory question.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 75%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Decides the threshold 'consumer' element for the wave of VPPA pixel class actions against websites; large aggregate statutory-damages exposure, but a single-clause statutory question with other limiting elements left open.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The consumer definition affects nationwide video-privacy and tracking-pixel litigation, advertising practices, and potentially substantial statutory damages, but the question is a bounded statutory issue and does not settle provider coverage or qualifying personal information.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 72%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves an entrenched 2-2 circuit split over the scope of the Video Privacy Protection Act's 'consumer' definition with major implications for nationwide digital privacy and Meta Pixel class-action litigation.

Petersen v. Snohomish Regional Fire and RescueThe Court declined to hear eight firefighters' bid to revive their religious-accommodation lawsuit against a fire department over a COVID-19 vaccine mandate.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.55
0.67
0.65
0.62

David Petersen, et al. v. Snohomish Regional Fire and RescueNo. 25-1210 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281693 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear eight firefighters' bid to revive their religious-accommodation lawsuit against a fire department over a COVID-19 vaccine mandate.

What happened

Eight firefighters at Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue sought religious exemptions from a COVID-19 vaccination mandate imposed in 2021. The department placed them on leave rather than let them continue in patient-care roles unvaccinated, though it later reversed course in 2022. The firefighters sued under Title VII, the federal law requiring employers to accommodate religious beliefs unless doing so would cause undue hardship. A district court granted summary judgment to the department, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, finding undisputed medical evidence showed unvaccinated firefighters posed a greater risk of spreading the virus.

What the Court is being asked

The firefighters asked the Court to decide what an employer must prove to deny a religious accommodation: whether it is enough for the employer to show a reasonable basis for fearing the accommodation would cause hardship, or whether the employer must show the hardship would actually occur. They argued this question divides the appeals courts, with some circuits requiring proof of actual hardship and others accepting a reasonable, good-faith belief even if mistaken. The department answered that no real conflict exists and that the lower court found actual, not merely feared, hardship here.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after extended briefing and numerous amicus filings and supplemental briefs from both sides. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The firefighters, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling for the department. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the lower court's judgment against the firefighters stands and their lawsuit does not proceed further. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the Ninth Circuit was correct; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling would fix the post-Groff undue-hardship standard for every Title VII religious-accommodation claim (22 states and Groff himself as amici), but the question is statutory and the vehicle is a pandemic-era vaccine dispute, so it is significant rather than blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 26%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The proposed Title VII rule could materially affect religious accommodation across workplaces, and the petition attracts broad religious-liberty and state amici. Its pandemic-specific medical record and evidentiary disputes limit its reach as a vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High profile religious liberty and COVID-19 mandate petition supported by 22 states and multiple religious groups.

Stephen Joseph Johnson v. MontanaThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Montana man's challenge to his burglary conviction, which rested partly on a witness's testimony by two-way video.Criminal lawdecided
0.55
0.62
0.70
0.62

Stephen Joseph Johnson v. MontanaNo. 25-1273 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73322426 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Montana man's challenge to his burglary conviction, which rested partly on a witness's testimony by two-way video.

What happened

Stephen Johnson was convicted in Montana of criminal mischief, burglary, and bail jumping after crashing a car and hiding in a stranger's garage. The homeowner, Eugene Maw, testified against him remotely by two-way video because of his age, caretaking duties, and distance from the courthouse. Johnson argued this violated his right to confront witnesses face to face. The Montana Supreme Court disagreed, holding that a 1990 Supreme Court case governing remote testimony, not a later 2004 case about out-of-court statements, supplied the right standard, and upheld Johnson's conviction.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked which of two of its own precedents governs when a prosecution witness may testify at trial by two-way video rather than in person: an older ruling allowing remote testimony when it serves an important public policy and remains reliable, or a newer ruling that focuses on whether the witness was unavailable and the defendant had a prior chance to cross-examine. Johnson says courts are split on which rule applies; Montana says most courts agree and treat the two rulings as addressing different situations.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after the Court requested a response from Montana and after Johnson filed a reply. The Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Johnson asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Montana Supreme Court's ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that ruling in place: Johnson's conviction stands, and the Montana Supreme Court's use of the older standard for remote witness testimony remains the law in Montana. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with Montana's approach, only that it left the decision undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would settle whether Maryland v. Craig or Crawford governs two-way video testimony by prosecution witnesses nationwide, a recurring post-pandemic criminal-procedure question; the underlying prosecution (burglary, bail jumping) is otherwise unremarkable.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide constitutional standard for adult prosecution witnesses appearing by two-way video would materially affect criminal trials, although this individual prosecution has limited independent public significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile constitutional criminal procedure issue (Confrontation Clause & remote testimony) with a deep circuit/state court split.

Perez v. City of San AntonioTwo religious practitioners ask the Court to revive their challenge to a San Antonio park renovation project they say will destroy a sacred worship site.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.55
0.60
0.72
0.62

Gary Perez, et al. v. City of San Antonio, TexasNo. 26-15 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000015 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: First Amendment

Two religious practitioners ask the Court to revive their challenge to a San Antonio park renovation project they say will destroy a sacred worship site.

What happened

Gary Perez and Matilde Torres, leaders in the Lipan Native American Church, sued the City of San Antonio over a park renovation project affecting a riverbend in Brackenridge Park that they consider sacred. They argued the City's plans to remove trees and deter nesting cormorants would substantially burden their religious exercise, violating the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the First Amendment. A federal district court denied most of their requested injunction, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed, holding they had not shown a substantial burden and that the City's plan satisfied strict scrutiny. The Fifth Circuit denied rehearing en banc over several judges' dissents. Perez and Torres then petitioned the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The petitioners ask the Court to decide two questions: first, whether courts may reject a religious believer's own sincere understanding of what their faith requires when deciding if government action burdens that practice, rather than accepting the believer's account; and second, whether the government can show it used the least restrictive means available when it did not consider alternatives that would reduce the impact on religious exercise until after the lawsuit began.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of September 28, 2026. The docket shows no action recorded since that conference; briefing continued afterward, with the City's brief in opposition filed October 30, 2026, and the petitioners' reply filed November 12, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Perez and Torres, who lost in the lower courts, are asking the Court to take up their case and reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling. If the Court grants cert, it would hear full arguments on both questions and decide them; granting review does not by itself mean either side wins. If the Court denies cert, the Fifth Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place the ruling that the City's project did not substantially burden the petitioners' religious exercise and that the City's plan satisfied strict scrutiny. A denial would not mean the Supreme Court agrees with that outcome, only that the lower court's ruling remains final.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Perez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Perez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely turn this case down; the chance it agrees to hear it is about one in seven. Two leaders of a Native American church want to stop San Antonio from cutting trees and driving away birds at a riverside site in a city park where they hold ceremonies. The Court has asked the city to respond, and many outside groups support the leaders. That raises the odds. But the lower court ruled at an early stage of the lawsuit and mostly applied Texas law, so the case is a weaker candidate.

    Why this big-case score: Religious-liberty dispute over a Native American sacred site that tees up how courts measure a 'substantial burden' and the least-restrictive-means showing; broad doctrinal reach, but the claims ride mostly on Texas RFRA in a preliminary-injunction posture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this challenge to San Antonio's plans for a park that contains a Native American sacred site. I put the chance of review at 24%, roughly one in four. Asking the City to respond suggests interest, and the petition raises serious concerns about courts second-guessing religious beliefs. But the lower court also gave a separate reason for allowing the project, and the case mixes federal constitutional questions with Texas law and disputed facts.

    Why this big-case score: Protection of a Native American sacred site presents substantial religious-liberty stakes, and the questions could affect burden and strict-scrutiny analysis across faiths; the municipal-project and preliminary-injunction posture limit the immediate reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will likely deny review in *Perez v. City of San Antonio*, though the petition has a substantial, roughly two-in-five (42%) chance of being granted. Ceremonial leaders of the Lipan Native American Church challenge San Antonio's plan to remove trees and deter nesting cormorants at a sacred riverbend in Brackenridge Park. Although a six-judge Fifth Circuit dissent and twelve friend-of-the-court briefs strongly favor review, the Court recently declined a similar Indigenous sacred-site case (*Apache Stronghold*) and may hesitate to intervene in municipal park management.

    Why this big-case score: Significant Free Exercise and RFRA/RLUIPA dispute over Native American sacred sites on public parkland, featuring a six-judge Fifth Circuit en banc dissent and two widely recurring circuit-split questions on substantial burden and strict-scrutiny narrow tailoring.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits decision would fix who defines a religious burden (the claimant or the court) across Free Exercise, RFRA, RLUIPA and state-RFRA litigation, and would be the Court's first sacred-site ruling since Lyng; thirteen cert-stage amici spanning Native, Jewish, Sikh, Catholic and evangelical groups mark the stakes, but the facts are a local park project in a preliminary-injunction posture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential rules on judicial treatment of sincere religious beliefs and the government's least-restrictive-means burden, with irreversible stakes for an Indigenous sacred site; the immediate dispute concerns one municipal park project.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile Free Exercise challenge brought by Native American Church leaders, backed by numerous religious liberty amici, featuring circuit splits and a strong dissent by Judge Oldham below.

Distributed v. DavenportDefense Distributed asks the Court to decide whether its lawsuit over 3D-printed gun files belongs in Texas rather than New Jersey, and whether its computer files count as free speech.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.70
0.62
0.62

Defense Distributed, et al. v. Jennifer Davenport, Attorney General of New JerseyNo. 26-184 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000184 · models differ by up to 0.15

Defense Distributed asks the Court to decide whether its lawsuit over 3D-printed gun files belongs in Texas rather than New Jersey, and whether its computer files count as free speech.

What happened

Defense Distributed and the Second Amendment Foundation have fought New Jersey's attorney general for years over computer files that let users 3D-print firearm parts. A Texas federal court transferred the claims against the New Jersey attorney general to New Jersey; the Fifth Circuit later ruled that transfer unlawful and told the Texas court to ask for the case back. New Jersey's courts refused to send it back, and the Third Circuit upheld that refusal. The Third Circuit also ruled that the group's computer files did not qualify for First Amendment protection as pleaded, and affirmed dismissal of the case.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions. First, whether a court holding a transferred case may keep it after the original court's court of appeals has ruled the transfer improper and asked for the case to be sent back. Second, whether free-speech protection automatically covers computer code that conveys information, or whether courts may first require additional proof that the code is expressive before any such protection applies.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference; the New Jersey attorney general waived the right to respond but was then asked to respond, and her deadline to do so was extended to November 25, 2026. The docket shows no action since that distribution.

What each outcome would mean

Defense Distributed, joined by the Second Amendment Foundation, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Third Circuit's rulings on venue and on First Amendment coverage. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on one or both questions and decide them; a grant alone would not determine who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Third Circuit's decisions keeping the case in New Jersey and rejecting First Amendment coverage for the files as pleaded would stand, leaving the New Jersey attorney general's position intact.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Distributed's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Distributed's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case, though not with certainty — roughly a one-in-eight chance it agrees to hear it. Defense Distributed, a Texas group that shares files for making 3D-printed guns, says New Jersey's law against distributing those files violates free speech, and that the case should have been sent back to Texas. The Court asked New Jersey to respond, a sign of some interest, but the case was dismissed early, before the facts were developed, which makes it a less attractive one to take.

    Why this big-case score: 3D-printed-gun files and First Amendment coverage of computer code, with an acknowledged split against Junger, plus an unusual intercircuit venue standoff; nationally watched but the posture is a pleading-stage dismissal.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this challenge to New Jersey's restrictions on sharing computer files used to make firearms. I put the chance of review at about one in five. The Court's request for a response shows interest, and the case raises a serious disagreement about when computer code qualifies as protected speech. But problems with how the challengers described their files, plus a complicated dispute about where the lawsuit belongs, make this a less straightforward case to take.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling on when computer code receives First Amendment coverage could reach software communication well beyond downloadable firearm designs; the separate transfer question affects intercircuit judicial administration.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Defense Distributed v. Davenport*, with only about a one-in-eleven chance (9%) of granting the petition. Although the Court asked New Jersey to file a response to the petition—which challenges both a refusal by the federal court in New Jersey to send the case back to Texas and a New Jersey law restricting digital files for 3D-printed firearms—the case has serious procedural flaws that make it a poor candidate for a full Supreme Court ruling. Most importantly, the challengers failed to ask for a pause before the case was moved to New Jersey and later refused two opportunities from the trial judge to add basic technical facts to their complaint explaining how their computer files work.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, the case would resolve major questions regarding First Amendment coverage of functional computer code and 3D-printed firearm files as well as intercircuit authority over vacated Section 1404(a) transfers.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Acknowledged circuit split on First Amendment coverage of computer code, in the politically salient 3D-printed-gun context, plus an unusual inter-circuit venue standoff; substantial doctrinal reach if decided, though a pleading-stage coverage ruling would be narrow in immediate effect.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First Amendment coverage of communicative computer files could affect software publication beyond 3D-printed firearms; the separate transfer question concerns nationwide judicial administration. Pleading and vehicle limits may constrain the reach of any decision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct circuit split over venue combined with a high-profile First Amendment issue concerning communicative computer code.

Jouppi v. AlaskaKen Jouppi asks the Supreme Court to rule that Alaska excessively punished him by forfeiting his airplane over a passenger's six-pack of beer.Constitutional rightspartly decided
0.55
0.66
0.65
0.62

Kenneth J. Jouppi v. AlaskaNo. 25-246 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73275187 · models differ by up to 0.11 · topic: Constitutional rights

Ken Jouppi asks the Supreme Court to rule that Alaska excessively punished him by forfeiting his airplane over a passenger's six-pack of beer.

What happened

Kenneth Jouppi, an Alaska bush pilot, was convicted of a misdemeanor for knowingly flying alcohol into Beaver, a village that bans alcohol. Troopers found beer, some visible, loaded on his plane. Alaska law requires forfeiture of any aircraft used to import alcohol into such a village. Jouppi argued forfeiting his $95,000 plane was an unconstitutionally "excessive fine." A trial court agreed, Alaska's intermediate appeals court sent the case back for more fact-finding, and the Alaska Supreme Court reversed, upholding the forfeiture as not excessive given Jouppi's conduct and the harms of alcohol abuse in rural Alaska.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked how to judge whether a forfeiture punishment fits the crime: should courts weigh how serious the offense was only in a general sense, looking at the statute and the harms the lawmakers were addressing, or should they instead focus on what this particular person actually did and how culpable they were. Separately, the federal government argues that forfeiting property actually used to commit a crime should not require this kind of proportionality comparison at all, given a long history of seizing instruments of crimes like smuggling vessels.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari and the case has been fully briefed, including by the United States as amicus supporting Alaska, and argument was held. The case now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Jouppi, who is challenging the ruling below, is asking the Court to reverse the judgment in Alaska's favor. If the Court sides with Jouppi, it would hold that courts must weigh the specific offender's conduct and culpability, not just the offense in the abstract, and send the case back for the forfeiture to be reconsidered under that standard. If the Court sides with Alaska, it would leave the forfeiture of Jouppi's airplane in place, affirming that the punishment did not violate the Constitution's ban on excessive fines.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseJul 20, 2026

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 1, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Jouppi wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Alaska wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-07-20: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An IJ-litigated vehicle to set the nationwide Excessive Fines Clause excessiveness standard (open since Bajakajian, 1998), with vivid plane-for-a-six-pack facts and broad fines/forfeiture-policy stakes, though the QP itself is methodological and fairly narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 29%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition presents a nationally important Excessive Fines rule with substantial forfeiture consequences, though in a factually unusual criminal-aircraft setting.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Notable Excessive Fines civil forfeiture case attracting high-profile amici (including Cato and Tyson Timbs) challenging the level of abstraction for evaluating offense gravity.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    First merits examination of the Excessive Fines Clause excessiveness standard since Bajakajian (1998); governs fines and forfeitures nationwide amid heavy state/local revenue reliance; vivid facts ($95,000 plane forfeited over a six-pack) with broad press coverage and an Institute for Justice litigation campaign behind it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case can set a nationwide rule for how courts measure offense gravity under the Excessive Fines Clause, with consequences for punitive forfeitures beyond this unusual airplane seizure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifies the standard of review for Excessive Fines Clause proportionality but largely reaffirms principles from Timbs and Bajakajian without sweeping doctrinal shifts.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First merits look at how Bajakajian's gravity prong is measured since Timbs incorporated the Clause; reaches every mandatory instrumentality forfeiture, with a broad cross-ideological amicus field, but the posture is a single misdemeanor forfeiture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The treatment of individualized culpability in punitive forfeiture could affect property owners nationwide, although the immediate dispute concerns one aircraft and a specialized alcohol-importation law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Pena v. City of Los AngelesThe Court declined to hear a print shop owner's bid for compensation after police tear gas, used to flush out a fugitive, destroyed his store.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.55
0.65
0.65
0.62

Carlos Pena v. City of Los Angeles, CaliforniaNo. 25-1163 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281647 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a print shop owner's bid for compensation after police tear gas, used to flush out a fugitive, destroyed his store.

What happened

Carlos Pena owned a print shop where an armed fugitive fleeing police barricaded himself. After a standoff, a Los Angeles police SWAT team fired tear gas canisters into the shop, destroying Pena's equipment and inventory. Both sides agree the police acted reasonably and lawfully. The city never paid Pena for the damage, so he sued under the Takings Clause, which requires compensation when the government takes private property. The district court ruled for the city, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that reasonable, necessary property destruction in defense of public safety falls outside the Takings Clause. One judge agreed with the result but reasoned instead that a long-recognized privilege allowing police to search and arrest meant no property right was ever infringed.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether the government must pay compensation when police intentionally destroy an innocent person's property while trying to catch a fugitive, and whether a "public necessity" defense can excuse the government from paying compensation it would otherwise owe. Pena argued that courts of appeals disagree on these questions, with some recognizing a broad exemption for actions taken under police power, others applying a narrower necessity-based exemption, and one applying a search-and-arrest privilege, while at least one circuit rejects any such exemption.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference three times between September and October 2026. On October 19, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Pena asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling. The denial leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Pena will not receive compensation for his destroyed shop, and the city's win stands. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in Pena's case, while the broader disagreement among lower courts over whether the Takings Clause covers this kind of police destruction remains unresolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A widely covered 'SWAT takings' question with a companion petition, five cert-stage amici, and two Justices already on record calling it important; doctrinally significant for the Takings Clause (necessity/police-power exceptions) but a narrow-dollar dispute between a print-shop owner and one city.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could define nationwide compensation rights when reasonable police operations destroy innocent owners' property, with broader implications for public-necessity exceptions. Significant property-rights and municipal-liability stakes, despite the modest individual damages claim.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant Takings Clause issue with 5 cert-stage amicus briefs and an acknowledged circuit split.

Breanna Renteria, et al. v. New Mexico Office of the Superintendent of Insurance, et al.Two members of a Christian health-cost-sharing ministry ask the Court to revive their claim that New Mexico's insurance rules violate their religious-exercise rights and are preempted by federal law.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.35
0.64
0.85
0.61

Breanna Renteria, et al. v. New Mexico Office of the Superintendent of Insurance, et al.No. 25-113 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274796 · models differ by up to 0.50 · topic: First Amendment

Two members of a Christian health-cost-sharing ministry ask the Court to revive their claim that New Mexico's insurance rules violate their religious-exercise rights and are preempted by federal law.

What happened

Breanna Renteria and Laura Smith belong to Gospel Light, a health care sharing ministry (HCSM) whose members share medical costs according to shared religious beliefs instead of buying insurance. New Mexico's insurance regulator ordered Gospel Light to stop operating in the state unless it complied with state insurance law, finding it was acting as an unlicensed insurer. Renteria and Smith sued, seeking to block enforcement, arguing the action violated their free-exercise rights and was preempted by federal health-care law. The district court denied a preliminary injunction, and the Tenth Circuit affirmed over a dissent, finding the state law neutral and generally applicable and not preempted.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state law counts as neutral and evenhanded toward religion only if challengers prove officials acted with subjective hostility, or whether exemptions favoring secular organizations over religious ones can themselves show the law is not evenhanded; and separately, whether federal law recognizing these sharing ministries overrides the state's attempt to require them to follow state insurance regulations.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conferences in September and October 2025 without recorded action, after which the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief. The government's brief, filed in May 2026, recommended holding the case pending a decision in a related case and said the preemption question alone did not warrant review. Petitioners then filed a supplemental brief urging the Court to grant or decide the case now. The case was distributed again for a June 2026 conference, and the docket shows no decision yet on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Renteria and Smith, the petitioners, are asking the Court to overturn the Tenth Circuit's ruling, which left in place New Mexico's enforcement action against their ministry. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide the free-exercise and preemption questions; if it denies the petition, the Tenth Circuit's ruling favoring the state regulator stands, and New Mexico's order remains in effect. The Court could also hold the petition until it decides a related case on similar free-exercise questions, which would not resolve this case's outcome but would delay action on it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Free-exercise (Smith neutrality/general applicability) plus ACA-preemption stakes for health care sharing ministries nationwide, with a CVSG; but likely resolved as a companion/GVR in the shadow of St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy rather than as a landmark itself.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 71%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition implicates nationwide Free Exercise standards and the legal status of religious health-care-sharing ministries, though its interlocutory posture and overlap with a granted lead case reduce its standalone significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    This case is essentially a hold/tag-along to St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy (No. 25-581) and will likely be GVR'd, so its independent significance is lower.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 70%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Stakes if decided: modest on the likely GVR route, since the doctrine would be set in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy rather than here; a plenary grant would make it a notable Free Exercise / ACA-preemption case for the roughly 1.5 million members of health care sharing ministries, but that route carries little of the mass.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions implicate nationwide free-exercise comparator rules and the boundary between federal recognition of health care sharing ministries and state insurance regulation. The preliminary-injunction posture and ministry-specific contractual record limit the likely reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves major Free Exercise issues under Employment Division v. Smith and the intersection of religious liberty with state insurance regulation and the Affordable Care Act.

Hershey v. City of Bossier CityRichard Hershey asks the Court to revive civil-rights claims against police who stopped him from leafleting outside a concert venue, citing qualified immunity.awaiting the Court
0.50
0.64
0.70
0.61

Richard Hershey v. City of Bossier City, Louisiana, et al.scotus/73500291 · models differ by up to 0.20

Richard Hershey asks the Court to revive civil-rights claims against police who stopped him from leafleting outside a concert venue, citing qualified immunity.

What happened

Hershey, a paid pamphleteer, was distributing religious leaflets on sidewalks outside a Bossier City arena during a concert when police and security officers told him to leave and threatened arrest, while not removing a nearby leafleteer for a radio station. He sued the officers and the city, claiming a First Amendment violation. A Fifth Circuit panel held the officers had qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields officials from damages suits unless they violated clearly established law, because no prior case with similar facts existed. A separate panel majority let a related claim against the city proceed. Rehearing en banc was denied over dissent.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a legal rule letting courts find a violation "obvious" enough to deny immunity even without a closely matching prior case, a rule the Court previously applied to prison conditions, also applies to free speech and religious liberty claims, or whether it is confined to the prison context.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including an opposition brief and a reply, along with numerous amicus briefs supporting Hershey. It has been distributed for five consecutive conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, without any recorded action granting or denying it.

What each outcome would mean

Hershey, who lost on this issue in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the obviousness rule extends beyond prison cases to First Amendment claims, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the lower court's decision applying qualified immunity to the officers stands, leaving Hershey unable to pursue damages from them on this record. The city's related appeal on a separate municipal-liability question is noted as pending in a different docketed case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision would settle whether Hope v. Pelzer's obviousness route around qualified immunity is transsubstantive, with fifteen cert-stage amici and a religious-liberty framing; significant for Section 1983 litigation, but doctrinally a reaffirmation rather than a new rule, and the facts are a single leafleting encounter.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 26%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether obvious First Amendment violations defeat qualified immunity without factually matching precedent has substantial civil-rights and religious-speech stakes, though this petition concerns a narrow doctrinal exception rather than abolition of qualified immunity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment/qualified immunity case featuring a circuit split and a noted dissent from Judge Ho below; closely watched by civil rights advocates.

Michael Joseph Gasper v. WisconsinThe Supreme Court declined to review Michael Gasper's challenge to the warrantless police viewing of a video Snapchat had flagged as child sexual abuse material.Criminal lawdecided
0.55
0.68
0.60
0.61

Michael Joseph Gasper v. WisconsinNo. 25-1191 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281673 · models differ by up to 0.13 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review Michael Gasper's challenge to the warrantless police viewing of a video Snapchat had flagged as child sexual abuse material.

What happened

Snapchat's automated scanning system flagged a video in Gasper's account as child sexual abuse material and reported it to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which forwarded it to Wisconsin authorities without anyone viewing it first. A state analyst and then a local detective each viewed the video without a warrant, leading to a search warrant for Gasper's home and phone, where more such material was found. Wisconsin charged Gasper with possession and exploitation offenses. The trial court suppressed the evidence, but the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed, and the Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed on the separate ground that police viewing the video did not exceed the scope of Snapchat's private search.

What the Court is being asked

Gasper's petition raises three issues: whether people have a constitutionally protected privacy interest in material they upload to a cloud-based account, whether officers needed a warrant to view a file that a private company's automated scan had already flagged as matching known illegal material, and whether, even if a warrant was required, the evidence should still be allowed because officers relied in good faith on existing practice. Wisconsin responds that the Court lacks jurisdiction because Gasper has not yet been convicted and the case was sent back for more proceedings, and that the case is a poor vehicle for resolving these issues.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after Wisconsin filed a brief in opposition and an advocacy group filed a supporting brief. The Supreme Court denied the petition, ending this request for review.

What each outcome would mean

Gasper, who lost below, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Wisconsin Supreme Court's decision in place, meaning the video and related evidence remain admissible under the private search doctrine as that court applied it, and Gasper's case returns to the Wisconsin trial court for further proceedings, including unresolved suppression arguments. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Wisconsin court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would settle whether police may open a hash-matched CyberTip file without a warrant, a question governing a nationwide investigative pipeline handling tens of millions of provider reports a year and now dividing six circuits and several state high courts. Significant but not a landmark on the order of Carpenter.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions concern nationwide digital privacy and the warrant requirements for police review of automated child-abuse-material reports. Those stakes are substantial despite this petition's interlocutory posture and vehicle problems.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fourth Amendment application to CyberTips/NCMEC in the digital age is a significant privacy issue.

Derick Irisha Brown v. United StatesDerick Brown asks the Court to decide whether using an ordinary car makes a kidnapping a federal crime, even when the car never crosses state lines.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.68
0.55
0.61

Derick Irisha Brown v. United Statesscotus/73500244 · models differ by up to 0.13

Derick Brown asks the Court to decide whether using an ordinary car makes a kidnapping a federal crime, even when the car never crosses state lines.

What happened

Derick Brown was indicted on federal kidnapping charges after a three-year-old girl in her care died. Because the alleged crime happened entirely within Alabama, prosecutors relied on a law that applies when a defendant uses something that counts as an instrumentality of interstate commerce, pointing only to her use of a Toyota Sequoia. The district court rejected her argument that this made the law unconstitutional as applied, and a jury convicted her. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, holding that cars count as such instrumentalities automatically, even when driven only within one state. The full appeals court declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an ordinary car, driven entirely within one state, automatically counts as a connection to interstate commerce that lets Congress treat the conduct as a federal crime, or whether the government must show some actual link to interstate activity. Brown argues other appeals courts disagree on this question; the government argues there is no real conflict and that the lower court's reading is correct.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for three conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, after full briefing including an opposition brief, a reply, and amicus briefs. The docket does not yet show a decision on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Brown, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up her case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether cars automatically satisfy this jurisdictional requirement, without yet deciding who is right. If it denies review, the Eleventh Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Brown's convictions and life sentence in place and leaving automobiles treated as automatic instrumentalities of interstate commerce in that circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Derick Irisha Brown's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Derick Irisha Brown's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 33%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Derick Brown asks the Supreme Court whether using a car makes any kidnapping a federal crime, even when the car never leaves the state. We think the Court will more likely turn the case down, but there is a real chance, about one in three, that it agrees to hear it. The Court has put off deciding twice, which often signals interest. But it already rejected a nearly identical case, which points toward a refusal, perhaps with one Justice writing to disagree.

    Why this big-case score: Whether every car is per se an instrumentality of interstate commerce sets the reach of federal criminal jurisdiction (and Commerce Clause category two) over vast amounts of ordinary conduct.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.61·Chance the Court takes the case: 41%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down Derick Brown's appeal than hear it, although I give review a substantial 41% chance—about two in five. The case asks whether using a car makes an otherwise local kidnapping a federal crime. Repeated consideration and disagreement among appeals courts make it a serious candidate. But the government argues that the decisions are distinguishable, and Brown's ruling simply follows existing circuit precedent. I expect one more round of consideration, then denial, probably without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The question concerns the boundary between federal and state criminal authority and could affect numerous statutes, although the immediate case is an individual criminal conviction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Derick Irisha Brown v. United States*, with roughly an 88% chance of denial (a 12% chance of granting review). Brown asks whether using a car within a single state automatically counts as using an "instrumentality of interstate commerce" (a tool of trade between states) under the federal kidnapping law. Although the Court has postponed deciding whether to hear her petition twice, it denied review just three weeks ago in *McMichael v. United States*, the published Eleventh Circuit lead case raising the exact same question. Moreover, the Tenth Circuit decision she cites as conflicting limited its ruling to the broader phrase "motor vehicle" rather than "automobile."

    Why this big-case score: If granted, the case would define the outer limits of Congress's Category 2 Commerce Clause power over 'instrumentalities of interstate commerce' and determine whether intrastate use of an automobile suffices for federal criminal jurisdiction under 18 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(1).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think it is a bit less likely than not (about 42%) that the Supreme Court agrees to hear Derick Brown's appeal. The case asks whether every car counts as an "instrumentality of interstate commerce," a tool of trade between states. If it does, federal kidnapping law covers any kidnapping that involves a car, even one that never leaves the state. The Court has postponed its decision once and is considering it again, which often comes before agreeing to hear a case. But the federal government argues the lower courts do not really disagree, and the Justices may simply deny the appeal, possibly with a written dissent.

    Why this big-case score: Commerce Clause limit on treating every automobile as an instrumentality of interstate commerce; reaches many federal criminal statutes, not just kidnapping.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to decline this case than to hear it; I put the chance of review at 44%, a little under one in two. Brown asks whether using a car for a kidnapping entirely within one state automatically makes it a federal crime. Repeated consideration and disagreement among appeals courts make review plausible. But the government offers a meaningful distinction between those decisions. If the Court hears the case, full briefing and argument are much likelier than an immediate ruling.

    Why this big-case score: The question could materially limit federal criminal jurisdiction over local conduct involving automobiles, beyond the kidnapping statute itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely deny Derick Irisha Brown's petition for review, though she has roughly a one-in-three chance (32%) of the Court agreeing to hear her case. Brown asks whether using a car strictly within one state automatically turns a local kidnapping into a federal crime because cars are tools ("instrumentalities") of interstate commerce. Federal appeals courts are divided on that question, and the Supreme Court has already held her petition over for two extra private conferences, showing serious interest. However, because the kidnappers also used cell phones—which courts uniformly treat as tools of interstate commerce—the Court will likely conclude that this case is a flawed vehicle and wait for a cleaner test case.

    Why this big-case score: Resolving whether motor vehicles are per se instrumentalities of interstate commerce would define a major boundary of federal criminal jurisdiction under the Kidnapping Act and the Commerce Clause.

Flagstar Bank v. KivettFlagstar Bank asks the Court to decide whether federal banking law overrides state laws requiring interest on mortgage escrow accounts.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.63
0.75
0.61

Flagstar Bank, N.A. v. William Kivett, et al.No. 25-1350 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500252 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Business & finance

Flagstar Bank asks the Court to decide whether federal banking law overrides state laws requiring interest on mortgage escrow accounts.

What happened

California law requires lenders to pay interest on money held in mortgage escrow accounts. William Kivett and other borrowers sued Flagstar Bank for not paying this interest on their accounts. The district court ruled for the borrowers, awarding roughly $9 million, and ordered Flagstar to start paying interest going forward. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, relying on its earlier ruling that the National Bank Act does not override California's escrow-interest law. After the Supreme Court decided a related case, Cantero, and sent this case back for another look, the Ninth Circuit reconsidered but reached the same conclusion, over one judge's dissent. Similar disputes in other circuits have come out differently.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal banking law that lets national banks exercise their lending powers free of interfering state regulation blocks states from requiring banks to pay interest on mortgage escrow accounts. The question turns on how much a state interest requirement interferes with a bank's federally granted powers, and whether the lower court applied the right method for measuring that interference.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference more than once, and the Court has asked the Solicitor General to submit a brief giving the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded yet.

What each outcome would mean

Flagstar, which lost below, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants review and ultimately reverses, Flagstar would not have to pay interest on the escrow accounts, and the borrowers' judgment would be undone. If the Court affirms, the borrowers' award and the requirement that Flagstar pay interest going forward would stand. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling for the borrowers remains in place, but that denial would not mean the Court agrees with it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Flagstar Bank's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Flagstar Bank's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 57%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    National Bank Act preemption of state interest-on-escrow laws: a recurring federal-banking-uniformity question the Court already took once in Cantero, with the OCC, the Chamber and the bank trade groups engaged, but technical in subject and confined to twelve States' escrow statutes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 64%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question affects mortgage escrow pricing and the federal-state division of banking authority across multiple states. Its national commercial significance exceeds this class judgment, but the dispute remains sector-specific and the new OCC rule may narrow its prospective reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A follow-on to Cantero on the scope of National Bank Act preemption: the OCC calls it exceptionally important for the mortgage market and it is a three-way published split on the Court's own two-year-old test, but the concrete question (state interest-on-escrow laws in about twelve states) is narrow and a May 2026 OCC rule preempts them prospectively, so the decision mostly governs retrospective liability and the method.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question affects mortgage-escrow payments and the federal/state allocation of banking regulatory authority across multiple states. Its broader preemption implications outweigh the individual damages award, but the new OCC rule may limit the prospective reach of this particular dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Mead Johnson & v. GreearMead Johnson asks the Court to review an Illinois ruling that state courts there may hear out-of-state infant-formula injury claims against it.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.70
0.58
0.61

Mead Johnson & Company, LLC, et al. v. Clarissa Greear, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Child B. H., et al.No. 26-29 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000029 · models differ by up to 0.15

Mead Johnson asks the Court to review an Illinois ruling that state courts there may hear out-of-state infant-formula injury claims against it.

What happened

Dozens of plaintiffs from across the country, whose infants allegedly developed a serious intestinal illness after being fed Mead Johnson's and Abbott's preterm formula products, sued in St. Clair County, Illinois. Mead Johnson argued Illinois courts lacked personal jurisdiction over it because the company had moved its headquarters to Indiana before most suits were filed and because the plaintiffs and their injuries had no connection to Illinois. The trial court disagreed, and the Appellate Court of Illinois, Fifth District, affirmed on interlocutory appeal, finding both general and specific jurisdiction. The Illinois Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions about when a state's courts may exercise power over an out-of-state company. The first is whether a company can still be treated as "at home" in a state, and so subject to suit there on any claim, years after it moved its main offices elsewhere. The second is whether a state can hear claims brought by out-of-state residents over injuries that occurred outside the state, based on the company's broader business activities within the state.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including an opposition brief and a reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference after earlier being distributed once before and having a response requested. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will take the case.

What each outcome would mean

Mead Johnson, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to hear the case and reverse. If the Court grants review and later rules for Mead Johnson, the lawsuits by out-of-state plaintiffs would be dismissed from Illinois courts, likely requiring them to refile elsewhere. If it rules for the plaintiffs (Greear and others), the case returns to the Illinois trial court for further litigation there. If the Court denies review, the Illinois appellate ruling stands, and the lawsuits continue in Illinois courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Mead Johnson &'s case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Mead Johnson &'s petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely **turn down** this appeal by baby-formula maker Mead Johnson, but it is a real contender — roughly a one-in-four chance (27%) the Court takes it or reverses outright. The companies argue Illinois courts have no power to hear suits by families from 22 other states whose infants were never fed or treated in Illinois. The Court asked the families to respond, a sign of interest, and business and pediatric groups back the companies.

    Why this big-case score: Mass-tort forum-shopping and corporate personal jurisdiction (general jurisdiction after a headquarters move; BMS-style specific jurisdiction over thousands of out-of-state NEC claims), with Chamber and AAP amici — nationally significant for litigation venue, but doctrinally a reapplication of Daimler/BMS unless the Court takes the timing question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down this appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of taking action. Mead Johnson argues that Illinois courts cannot hear claims brought by families from other states after the company moved its headquarters. The Court's request for a response and several outside groups' filings show interest. But the case is still underway, and the headquarters facts are disputed. Those obstacles make review less likely even though the ruling could affect where many infant-formula lawsuits proceed.

    Why this big-case score: The dispute could affect the forum for nationwide premature-infant formula litigation and clarify constitutional limits on corporate jurisdiction after relocation; it would not itself decide whether the products are defective.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant review in *Mead Johnson & Company, LLC v. Greear* (about a one-in-six chance, or 16%), and will most likely deny the petition. Although the Court asked the plaintiffs to respond and four outside groups filed friend-of-the-court ("amicus") briefs supporting the formula makers, the Illinois appeals court applied existing Supreme Court rules on "personal jurisdiction" (which state courts have authority over out-of-state companies) to an unusual set of facts involving Mead Johnson's recent 2022 headquarters move from Illinois to Indiana. Because the lower court relied on both general and case-specific ties to Illinois during the years the product warnings were developed, the Supreme Court will likely view the dispute as too tied to one company's transition to serve as a clean test case.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, this case would be a significant civil-procedure ruling clarifying whether Daimler's exceptional-case general-jurisdiction footnote applies after a corporate headquarters relocation and whether Bristol-Myers Squibb/Ford Motor permit specific jurisdiction over out-of-state mass-tort claims based on pre-relocation headquarters conduct, with major stakes for the nationwide NEC preterm infant formula litigation.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Baby-formula makers Mead Johnson ask the Supreme Court to stop Illinois courts from hearing lawsuits by 51 families from other states whose infants were never fed or treated in Illinois. We predict the Court will most likely turn the case away, though there is about a one-in-six chance it takes the case or reverses outright without full argument. The Court has already asked the families to respond, and earlier Supreme Court rulings strongly favour the companies. Still, the early stage of the case makes it an awkward one for the Court to take.

    Why this big-case score: Personal-jurisdiction limits on mass-tort forum shopping, with ~12,500 NEC plaintiff families in two Illinois counties; important to business litigation but a reaffirmation of BMS/Daimler rather than a new doctrinal question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of taking it up. Mead Johnson argues that Illinois courts cannot hear these out-of-state families' claims against the company. Its argument raises serious concerns about the limits on a state's power over businesses, and the Court has asked the families to respond. But the cases are still at an early stage, and disputed facts could make them a poor vehicle for review. Denial would not decide whether the formula caused harm.

    Why this big-case score: The jurisdictional rules could affect nationwide product-liability litigation and the locations where infant-formula claims proceed; this petition does not itself decide product safety or liability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Mead Johnson's petition for review, with only about a 1 in 40 (2.5%) chance of a grant. Mead Johnson asks the Court to decide whether an Illinois state court violated constitutional due process—the fairness rules limiting where a defendant can be sued—by allowing 51 out-of-state families to sue the company in Illinois over preterm infant formula injuries that occurred in other states. Although the Illinois appellate court used an unusually broad theory of jurisdiction, the plaintiffs waived their right to respond and the lower court relied on case-specific factual findings that Mead Johnson still held itself out as headquartered in Illinois in sworn government filings and contracted to package products there, making this an unattractive vehicle for the Supreme Court to review.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided, the case would clarify whether general personal jurisdiction can rest on a corporation's historical headquarters at the time of injury and further police specific personal jurisdiction boundaries under Ford Motor Co. and Bristol-Myers Squibb in coordinated mass-tort product-liability litigation.

Edward Allyn Hudacko v. Regents of the University of CaliforniaA father asks the Court to revive his civil rights lawsuit over his son's gender-related surgery, which he says violated his parental rights and custody order.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.55
0.72
0.55
0.61

Edward Allyn Hudacko v. Regents of the University of California, et al.No. 26-180 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000180 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Constitutional rights

A father asks the Court to revive his civil rights lawsuit over his son's gender-related surgery, which he says violated his parental rights and custody order.

What happened

Edward Hudacko's divorce decree gave his ex-wife, Christine Underhill, authority over their son's medical care, but required Hudacko's consent for "any gender identity related surgery." Hudacko alleges a hospital implant procedure was performed on his son without his knowledge or consent, and that the doctors and others involved knew it required his approval. He sued under the federal civil rights law allowing suits against state officials. The district court dismissed his claims, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding the defendants were protected by qualified immunity—a doctrine shielding officials from suits unless they violated clearly established law—because Hudacko did not cite court decisions addressing similar facts.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions about qualified immunity. First, whether courts may look only to prior court rulings to decide if a right was "clearly established," or whether they may also consider other sources, such as professional standards or an official's own knowledge, as some circuits do. Second, whether all government officials should get the same immunity test, or whether courts should first ask whether officials like the ones here historically received immunity at all under older legal traditions.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, after which the Court requested a response from the respondents, due October 19, 2026. The respondents were later granted an extension, to November 18, 2026, to file that response.

What each outcome would mean

Hudacko, the petitioner, is asking the Court to take up his case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which went against him. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on the qualified immunity questions before deciding anything. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, leaving the dismissal of Hudacko's claims against Underhill, the university doctors, and the other defendants in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 18, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Edward Allyn Hudacko's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Edward Allyn Hudacko's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to **turn down** this father's appeal, though not with certainty: roughly a one-in-eight chance it takes the case. He sued doctors at a state university hospital over gender-related surgery on his son that he says needed his consent. The lower court dismissed the suit under "qualified immunity," a rule that protects officials unless earlier cases clearly forbade what they did. The Court asked the other side to respond, which raises the odds somewhat. But it rarely takes cases to rethink that immunity rule.

    Why this big-case score: Qualified-immunity doctrine and parental rights over a minor's gender-related medical care are both nationally contested, but the case arises on a fact-bound QI dismissal against private-turned-state actors.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline review, with about a one-in-five chance of taking some action granting the petition. A father challenges immunity that protected public medical professionals from his damages suit over treatment allegedly requiring his consent. The Court's request for a response and five supporting briefs show interest. But the dispute depends heavily on an unusual custody order, and one proposed change to immunity law was not raised below. Expect another conference distribution after the response process, probably followed by denial.

    Why this big-case score: The petition concerns parental participation in gender-related medical decisions and the scope of damages immunity for public clinicians. Those are nationally consequential issues, although this particular dispute turns on an unusually restrictive custody order.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Hudacko v. Regents of the University of California*, with only an 8.5% chance of granting the petition (about one in twelve). Although the Court requested a response from the university after five outside groups filed briefs supporting the father, the case is a poor candidate for a national ruling. Specifically, the father lost medical custody in divorce court under an order allowing the mother to approve hormone therapy, the lower court's ruling is non-binding, and the father's broader challenge to government-official immunity (qualified immunity) was never raised in the lower courts.

    Why this big-case score: If granted, a decision addressing either non-caselaw sources for clearly established law under Section 1983 or parental substantive due process rights over minor gender-related medical care would carry substantial doctrinal and public salience, though its reach could be cabined by the state custody-decree posture.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Parental-rights / gender-transition question that several Justices have called of great and growing national importance, coupled with a structural qualified-immunity question; a grant would draw broad attention, though the QI posture could keep the holding narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could reshape qualified immunity for public medical professionals and the evidentiary basis for clearly established rights, against a nationally salient parental-consent dispute. The unusual custody order limits the breadth of a fact-specific ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Trump v. ClintonDonald Trump asks the Court to revive civil claims a lower court dismissed as untimely and to overturn sanctions imposed on him and his lawyers.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.65
0.72
0.61

Donald J. Trump, et al. v. Hillary R. Clinton, et al.No. 26-518 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000518 · models differ by up to 0.27

Donald Trump asks the Court to revive civil claims a lower court dismissed as untimely and to overturn sanctions imposed on him and his lawyers.

What happened

After his first presidential term, Trump sued dozens of people and organizations, alleging they conspired to falsely tie him to Russian election interference. The district court dismissed the suit, finding the claims filed too late and otherwise legally deficient, and it sanctioned Trump and his attorneys for filing what it called a sprawling pleading containing frivolous claims. The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the dismissal and the sanctions, though it sent one defendant's case back to be dismissed on different grounds. The Eleventh Circuit later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the time limit for filing Trump's lawsuit should have been paused during his presidency because of the demands of the office, even though he filed other personal lawsuits while in office. It is also asked whether the lower courts improperly punished Trump and his lawyers with sanctions for making that argument about pausing the deadline, rather than for other problems with the lawsuit.

Where it stands

The respondents waived their right to respond, but the Court later requested a response, which has now been filed opposing review. The case has not yet been scheduled for a conference to decide whether the Court will hear it.

What each outcome would mean

Trump and his co-petitioners are asking the Court to reverse the Eleventh Circuit's decision, which upheld dismissal of the lawsuit and the sanctions against them. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the deadline should have been paused and whether the sanctions were proper, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Eleventh Circuit's decision stands, leaving the dismissal and the sanctions against Trump and his attorneys in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 27, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Trump's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Trump's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case (about a 6% chance it takes it). President Trump and his lawyers ask the Court to revive his lawsuit over the "Russia collusion" accusations and to erase nearly $1 million in court-imposed penalties. The Court asked the other side to respond, which shows it is paying attention. But the questions are narrow and tied to this case's facts, and no lower courts disagree on them, so review is still unlikely.

    Why this big-case score: Sitting President as petitioner and a near-$1M sanctions award against him and his counsel draw wide attention, but the legal questions (presidential equitable tolling as a plaintiff; inherent-authority sanctions) are narrow and fact-bound.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to turn down Donald Trump's request to review this case; I put the chance of review or another grant-based intervention at about one in ten. The case asks whether presidential duties pause deadlines for private lawsuits and whether arguing for that protection can support financial penalties. Requesting a response shows some interest, but the lower court also relied on other problems with the lawsuit. Those additional grounds make this a difficult case for resolving the broader presidential questions.

    Why this big-case score: Presidential access to private civil litigation and sanctions against presidential counsel have institutional and public significance, though the questions concern a narrow limitations and fee-award setting.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny the petition for review, with only a 4% chance (about one in twenty-five) of granting it. Although the Court asked Hillary Clinton and the other respondents to file a formal response to President Trump's petition, that request is a routine step to hear both sides before voting. The lower appeals court unanimously ruled that even if a President's constitutional duties paused the legal deadline for filing private lawsuits, the complaint still failed to state a valid legal claim, and the nearly $1 million fine for filing a frivolous lawsuit rested on wide-ranging litigation misconduct rather than a single novel legal argument.

    Why this big-case score: High-profile civil litigation brought by a sitting and former President against his 2016 presidential opponent and federal officials, presenting an unprecedented Article II equitable-tolling claim for private civil suits and challenging nearly $1 million in inherent-authority sanctions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    President Trump asks the Supreme Court to revive his lawsuit against Hillary Clinton and others and to overturn nearly $1 million in court-imposed penalties ("sanctions") against him and his lawyers. We think the Court will very likely turn the case down. We estimate about a 6% chance it agrees to hear it. The Court did ask the other side to file a response, which signals some interest. But the petition points to no disagreement among lower courts. The case also turns largely on its own particular facts, and the Court rarely takes cases like that.

    Why this big-case score: Sitting President as petitioner on presidential tolling and near-$1M sanctions against him and counsel; high public salience, but the legal questions are narrow and fact-bound.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Donald Trump's request to review rulings on his private lawsuit against Hillary Clinton and others. I estimate about a nine-in-one-hundred chance of review. The Court's request for a response shows some interest, but the lower court upheld sanctions on several grounds beyond Trump's argument that presidential duties should pause filing deadlines. The likely next step is another conference after the response arrives, followed by a denial without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A presidential private-litigation privilege and sanctions against the President and counsel raise substantial institutional stakes, although the underlying suit and fee award are case-specific.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny President Donald Trump's petition for review, with only a 4% chance (about one in twenty-five) of granting the case. Trump and his lawyers ask the Court to revive his dismissed civil racketeering lawsuit against Hillary Clinton and others over 2016 Russia-collusion allegations and to overturn nearly $1 million in court sanctions—penalties for filing an improper lawsuit—by arguing that the President's constitutional duties paused the four-year filing deadline while he served in office. Although the Court asked the respondents to file a formal response, review remains unlikely because the lower courts also dismissed the claims and upheld the sanctions on several independent grounds, including procedural forfeitures and filing baseless claims that Trump did not appeal.

    Why this big-case score: High public and political salience given the parties (President Trump v. Hillary Clinton et al.) and the Article II presidential equitable-tolling and inherent-authority sanctions questions, though doctrinally narrow and fact-bound.

The Coalition for Fairness in SoHo and NoHo, Inc., et al. v. City of New York, New York, et al.The Court declined to hear a property owners' group's challenge to a New York City fee charged to convert artist-only housing units to regular residential use.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.55
0.65
0.60
0.60

The Coalition for Fairness in SoHo and NoHo, Inc., et al. v. City of New York, New York, et al.No. 25-1187 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281681 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a property owners' group's challenge to a New York City fee charged to convert artist-only housing units to regular residential use.

What happened

Owners of apartments in New York's SoHo and NoHo neighborhoods, long restricted to certified artists under a 1970s zoning rule, challenged a 2021 city law letting them convert their units to unrestricted residential use for a fee of about $100 per square foot, paid into an arts fund. A trial court rejected their claim that the fee was an unconstitutional taking. New York's intermediate appellate court reversed, siding with the owners. New York's highest court then reversed again, ruling for the city on two grounds: the owners had no property interest the fee could burden, and the fee wasn't the kind of monetary demand that triggers heightened scrutiny under takings law.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether constitutional protections for people seeking government permits, which limit demands the government can attach in exchange for approval, cover money demands generally or only apply when money is sought as a substitute for requiring the owner to hand over an interest in real property.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference more than once, and after being rescheduled and distributed again, the Court denied it on October 13, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Coalition for Fairness in SoHo and NoHo and individual residents asked the Court to take the case and overturn the ruling in the city's favor. Because the Court denied the petition, the New York Court of Appeals decision stands: the fee remains in effect, and owners seeking to convert their units still must pay it. A grant would have let the Court decide whether such fees must meet the nexus and proportionality tests the owners sought to apply, without determining who would ultimately win that analysis.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case fixes whether Koontz reaches standalone monetary permit conditions (impact fees, in-lieu-of-nothing fees) nationwide, a live question for every land-use permitting authority; the SoHo/NoHo setting and a ~$450M aggregate fee make it newsworthy, but it is a doctrinal takings case rather than a headline constitutional dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The monetary-exactions question could affect land-use permit fees nationwide, although the immediate dispute concerns a distinctive New York City artist-loft conversion program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant Takings Clause challenge involving a local zoning arts fund fee, backed by PLF and prominent amici, serving as a sequel to Koontz and Sheetz.

Alaska Policy Forum v. Alaska Public Offices CommissionAlaska Policy Forum asks the Court to overturn a state ruling that its ranked-choice-voting commentary counted as ballot-measure advocacy requiring donor disclosure and registration.awaiting the Court
0.50
0.68
0.62
0.60

Alaska Policy Forum v. Alaska Public Offices Commission, et al.No. 26-88 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000088 · models differ by up to 0.18

Alaska Policy Forum asks the Court to overturn a state ruling that its ranked-choice-voting commentary counted as ballot-measure advocacy requiring donor disclosure and registration.

What happened

Alaska Policy Forum, a nonprofit, published articles, a press release, and a video criticizing ranked-choice voting before it became part of a 2020 ballot measure. A rival group complained to the Alaska Public Offices Commission, which found the Forum had engaged in advocacy requiring it to register, report its spending, and name its donors on its materials, while clearing an allied group that had produced similar content. Alaska's courts, up through the state supreme court, upheld the Commission's decision and rejected the Forum's First Amendment challenges.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether government can treat commentary on a policy topic as election-related advocacy, triggering donor-disclosure and registration rules, even when the speaker never mentions the ballot measure or election; whether the legal test Alaska used to draw that line is too unclear for speakers to follow; and whether requiring donor names to appear directly on the speech itself serves a strong enough government interest.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, after which the Court asked the respondents to respond; that response was later granted an extension to November 30, 2026. The docket shows no ruling yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Alaska Policy Forum is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Alaska Supreme Court's decision, which upheld the disclosure and registration requirements against the Forum. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the questions itself, deciding nothing yet. If it denies review, the Alaska Supreme Court's ruling stands, leaving the Forum subject to the state's reporting, registration, and disclosure requirements; a denial would not mean the Court agreed with that outcome, only that the state ruling remains in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 30, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Alaska Policy Forum's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Alaska Policy Forum's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this case — I put the chance of it agreeing to review at about one in six. A think tank is challenging Alaska's rule that it disclose its donors after publishing criticism of ranked-choice voting while a ballot measure was pending. The Court asked Alaska to respond, and an unusually large number of outside groups filed supporting briefs, which lifts the odds well above normal. But the Court has repeatedly turned away similar donor-disclosure challenges, and the dispute is tied to specific facts.

    Why this big-case score: First Amendment donor-disclosure and issue-advocacy line for nonprofits speaking on ballot-measure topics; heavy cert-stage amicus interest, but a state-law, somewhat fact-bound vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, with about a one-in-four chance of agreeing to review it. The dispute asks when a nonprofit's discussion of public issues can trigger election rules requiring disclosure of its donors. Twelve supporting outside briefs and the Court's request for a response make review more plausible than usual. But the claimed disagreements among courts are not all clear-cut, and the nonprofit's messages included election-related language. The most likely result is a denial without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially important nationwide limits on donor disclosure and compelled identification in nonprofit issue advocacy, beyond the underlying Alaska ballot-measure dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review—turning down the appeal—with only about a one-in-nine (11%) chance of agreeing to hear the case. Although the Court asked Alaska officials to respond after twelve outside advocacy groups supported the nonprofit challenger's free-speech claims, the Court has repeatedly turned away similar challenges to election donor-disclosure laws in recent years, and this dispute involves an older 2020 version of Alaska's statute with no fine imposed.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision clarifying the constitutional line between 501(c)(3) issue speech and regulable ballot-measure advocacy, or requiring donor earmarking and striking down on-communication donor disclaimers under AFPF v. Bonta, would reshape state and local campaign-finance regimes nationwide, though superseded 2020 Alaska statutory provisions could narrow any ruling.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this case; the chance it agrees to review it is about one in nine. A nonprofit is challenging Alaska rules that forced it to register and reveal donors after it criticized ranked-choice voting during a ballot campaign. The Court asked Alaska to respond and sixteen outside groups filed supporting briefs, which raises the odds above normal, but the Court has repeatedly turned away similar donor-disclosure challenges, and this dispute is fact-specific without a clear conflict among lower courts.

    Why this big-case score: First Amendment donor-disclosure and issue-speech line for nonprofits around ballot measures; 16 cert-stage amicus briefs signal wide interest among advocacy groups, though the dispute itself is a small state enforcement matter.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 26%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, with about a one-in-four chance of taking it up. Alaska Policy Forum challenges rules requiring donor disclosure for messages criticizing ranked-choice voting without mentioning the ballot measure. Sixteen supporting briefs and the Court's request for a response make the petition unusually substantial. But the claimed disagreements among courts may be less direct than the petition suggests. Expect another conference distribution after the response arrives, and probably no explanation if review is denied.

    Why this big-case score: Potential nationwide consequences for nonprofit issue advocacy, donor privacy, and campaign-finance disclaimers, though the dispute arises from a particular state's ballot-measure rules.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Alaska Policy Forum v. Alaska Public Offices Commission*, with only about a one-in-nine chance (11%) of taking the case. Although sixteen outside advocacy groups filed friend-of-the-court briefs supporting the nonprofit petitioner and the Court asked Alaska respondents to file a response by November 30, 2026, the Justices have repeatedly turned away nearly identical First Amendment challenges to state campaign-finance donor-disclosure and ad-disclaimer laws—including a New Mexico think tank's appeal denied in October 2026—and Alaska's high court interpreted the pre-2021 law narrowly so general nonprofit donors need not be disclosed.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, a ruling redefining the First Amendment boundary between issue speech and campaign advocacy or subjecting on-communication donor disclaimers and low-threshold ballot-measure disclosures to stricter tailoring after AFPF v. Bonta would reshape state campaign-finance regulation and nonprofit advocacy nationwide.

Mohan v. WatkinsFederal officials ask the Court to review whether a prisoner's lawsuit over post-surgery medical care can proceed under a decades-old precedent allowing such damages claims.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.40
0.78
0.60
0.59

Brij Mohan, et al. v. Jordan WatkinsNo. 25-952 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280995 · models differ by up to 0.38 · topic: Constitutional rights

Federal officials ask the Court to review whether a prisoner's lawsuit over post-surgery medical care can proceed under a decades-old precedent allowing such damages claims.

What happened

Jordan Watkins, a federal detainee and later prisoner, alleges that after hernia surgery, medical staff including Dr. Brij Mohan ignored his complaints of severe pain and swelling, gave him ineffective medication, and denied follow-up care. Watkins sued for damages, relying on a 1980 Supreme Court case, Carlson v. Green, that allows such suits against federal officials for ignoring prisoners' serious medical needs. A district court dismissed his claims, but the Seventh Circuit reversed, holding the case fit within that precedent. Mohan and other officials, represented by the Solicitor General, asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the rule allowing prisoners to sue federal officials for money damages over inadequate medical care still permits a claim like this one, where a detainee alleges officials ignored ongoing post-surgery pain rather than an acute medical emergency. The petitioners argue the case differs enough from the earlier ruling that courts should not extend it here, while Watkins argues his situation fits the existing rule.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a response and reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference on June 11, 2026, then redistributed for a conference on June 18, 2026. The docket does not yet show any decision on whether the Court will take the case.

What each outcome would mean

The officials, led by Dr. Mohan, are asking the Court to overturn the Seventh Circuit's ruling that let Watkins' lawsuit proceed. If the Court grants review and later rules for the officials, Watkins' damages claim could be cut off entirely. If the Court denies review, the Seventh Circuit's decision stands, and Watkins' lawsuit continues in the lower courts. A grant without a decision yet would mean the Court will hear full arguments before deciding who wins.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Mohan's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Mohan's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sidecar to Nielsen v. Watanabe (25-417), the granted lead case on Carlson/Bivens vitality; the doctrine at stake is significant for prisoner civil-rights litigation, but this petition itself is a likely held-and-GVR'd companion, not the main event.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.78·Chance the Court takes the case: 61%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could determine whether Carlson remains a practical damages remedy for inadequate medical care across the federal prison system.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the heavily litigated boundary of Bivens extensions, though the outcome is highly predictable given recent Court precedent.

Young v. Colorado Department of CorrectionsA former Colorado corrections officer asks the Court to revive his workplace discrimination lawsuit over a mandatory diversity training he says targeted White employees.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.55
0.66
0.55
0.59

Joshua F. Young v. Colorado Department of Corrections, et al.No. 26-310 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000310 · models differ by up to 0.11 · topic: Employment & discrimination

A former Colorado corrections officer asks the Court to revive his workplace discrimination lawsuit over a mandatory diversity training he says targeted White employees.

What happened

Joshua Young, who is white, worked for the Colorado Department of Corrections and had to complete a mandatory training on equity, diversity and inclusion. He later sued, claiming the training's content and aftermath created a racially hostile work environment under federal employment discrimination law. Lower courts dismissed his claims twice: first without prejudice, then, after he amended his complaint, with prejudice. The Tenth Circuit affirmed the second dismissal, reasoning that a single training session, without repetition or further incidents of harassment, was not enough to plausibly allege a hostile work environment.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a single mandatory training session that an employee says conveyed negative racial stereotypes and pushed race-conscious conduct can, by itself, be considered serious enough to count as workplace harassment, even without the training being repeated or accompanied by other race-related incidents.

Where it stands

The respondents waived their right to respond, but the Court later requested a response, due November 23, 2026. The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and the docket shows no action on it since; a motion for an extension of time was filed by the respondents on November 13, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Young, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up and reverse the Tenth Circuit's decision. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case in full and decide the legal question, without yet determining who wins. If it denies review, the Tenth Circuit's ruling dismissing Young's claims with prejudice stands, and the lawsuit remains over. A denial would not mean the Court agrees with the lower court's reasoning, only that the decision stays in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Young's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Young's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A former Colorado prison officer, who is white, says a mandatory diversity training was racist enough by itself to make his workplace legally "hostile." The appeals court threw out his lawsuit. We predict the Supreme Court will most likely refuse to hear the case: about a 9% (roughly one in eleven) chance it takes it. Asking Colorado to respond shows some interest. But the ruling turns on this one complaint's details, and the courts are not clearly divided on the rule.

    Why this big-case score: Whether employer-mandated DEI training can by itself create a racially hostile work environment under Title VII is a recurring, politically salient question affecting many employers; the vehicle is a fact-bound pleading dismissal.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Joshua Young's challenge to Colorado's workplace diversity training. I give review an 18% chance—roughly one in six. The Court's request for a response and support from a coalition of states show genuine interest. But the appeals court said that one sufficiently serious incident can be unlawful; it found Young's particular allegations inadequate. That makes the dispute look more like disagreement over these facts than a clear conflict between courts. I expect a decision in early 2027.

    Why this big-case score: A decision could substantially affect mandatory workplace diversity training nationwide, although the presented issue is a narrower hostile-environment pleading question rather than the legality of all such training.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Young v. Colorado Department of Corrections* (about a seven-in-eight chance of denial, or a 12% chance of a grant). Although the Court asked Colorado to respond to the petition and twenty states filed a supporting friend-of-the-court brief, federal appeals courts agree that a single mandatory workplace diversity training session—without repeated incidents or workplace harassment—does not meet Title VII's high bar for a "severe or pervasive" hostile work environment, and this second lawsuit over the same 2021 training is a poor procedural vehicle.

    Why this big-case score: High-salience Title VII question regarding whether mandatory workplace DEI and anti-racism trainings can by themselves constitute a severe racially hostile work environment, backed by a 20-state amicus coalition and Pacific Legal Foundation.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Colorado prison employee who is white says a mandatory racial-equity training was so offensive that it created a hostile workplace in violation of federal anti-discrimination law; the lower courts dismissed his case. We think the Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear it, with roughly a one-in-seven chance that it takes the case. The Court asked the State to respond and twenty States support the employee, which raises the odds, but the dispute largely turns on the facts of one training rather than a clear legal disagreement among courts.

    Why this big-case score: Whether mandatory DEI/anti-racism training alone can create a Title VII hostile environment is a nationally contested workplace question with 20 States as amici; the QP is framed narrowly (severity of a single training) which caps the stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Joshua Young's challenge to mandatory racial-equity training, with about a one-in-seven chance that it takes the case. The Court has asked Colorado to respond, and two supporting briefs show meaningful interest. But the disagreement may concern how settled workplace-harassment rules apply to these particular allegations, rather than conflicting legal rules that require Supreme Court intervention. Expect another round of scheduling after Colorado responds, followed most likely by a denial without an explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling could substantially affect mandatory diversity training and racial-harassment pleading nationwide, although the question is narrower than the general legality of diversity programs.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Young v. Colorado Department of Corrections*, with only about a 1.5 percent chance (roughly one in sixty-five) of granting the petition. A former Colorado prison officer claims that a single mandatory online diversity training created a racially hostile work environment under federal employment-discrimination law, even though no supervisor or coworker harassed or disciplined him before he resigned four months later. The state waived its right to file a response, no outside groups filed supporting briefs, and the federal appeals courts agree that a single training session without ongoing workplace mistreatment does not meet the legal standard for a hostile work environment.

    Why this big-case score: While a Supreme Court ruling on when mandatory workplace DEI trainings create a racially hostile work environment under Title VII would have broad national salience, this petition arises from a single online training module already addressed in an earlier unappealed Tenth Circuit opinion and is unlikely to draw major institutional attention at the cert stage.

Nielsen v. Cumulus Media New HoldingsNielsen asks the Court to review a ruling that let Cumulus pursue an antitrust claim over Nielsen's pricing of bundled and standalone radio-ratings data.awaiting the Court
0.50
0.64
0.62
0.59

The Nielsen Company (US), LLC v. Cumulus Media New Holdings Inc.No. 26-370 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000370 · models differ by up to 0.14

Nielsen asks the Court to review a ruling that let Cumulus pursue an antitrust claim over Nielsen's pricing of bundled and standalone radio-ratings data.

What happened

Nielsen sells radio audience data separately for local markets and nationally. Cumulus, a broadcaster, wanted to buy Nielsen's national data plus only some local data, buying the rest from a competitor, Eastlan. Nielsen's policy tied full national data to buying local data everywhere Cumulus operates; Nielsen later offered national data alone, but at a much higher price. Cumulus sued under antitrust law, and a district court issued a preliminary injunction against Nielsen's pricing practices. The Second Circuit affirmed, holding that an exceptionally high standalone price can amount to an unlawful "constructive tie" even without a formal bundling requirement.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a seller that offers its products both separately and bundled, without pricing either below its own costs, can still be held liable for illegally forcing customers to buy both together, simply because a court views the separate price as too high compared to the bundled discount.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference. After that conference, the Court requested a response from Cumulus, due December 7, 2026; the docket shows no further action since.

What each outcome would mean

Nielsen, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case and decide whether Nielsen's pricing can count as an unlawful tie, with no outcome assumed in advance. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision affirming the injunction against Nielsen stands, and the case continues in the lower courts under that ruling.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 7, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Nielsen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Nielsen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Prediction: the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Nielsen's request to hear its case (we put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in eight, 13%). Nielsen argues a court wrongly treated its high standalone price for a ratings product as illegally forcing a customer to buy a bundle. The Court asked the other side to respond, and two outside groups backed Nielsen, which raises the odds above normal. But the ruling only upheld a temporary order while the lawsuit continues, which usually makes the Court wait.

    Why this big-case score: A Section 2 tying/bundled-pricing rule touching a 20-year LePage's/PeaceHealth divide matters across the economy, but the case itself is a two-firm radio-ratings dispute on a preliminary injunction.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Nielsen's appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of taking it. The dispute asks when discounted product bundles become illegal pressure to buy unwanted products. A requested response and two supporting outside briefs suggest interest, but the case involves a temporary court order and an unfinished factual record. The Court will probably reconsider the petition after the response arrives. If it accepts the case, full briefing and argument are much likelier than an immediate ruling.

    Why this big-case score: The boundary between lawful bundled discounts and monopolistic tying could affect pricing across many industries, although this vehicle concerns a preliminary injunction in a commercial radio-data dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *The Nielsen Company v. Cumulus Media New Holdings*, with an 8% chance (roughly one in twelve) of granting the petition. Although Nielsen has strong business support and asks an important antitrust question—whether charging a high standalone price alongside a discounted bundle of radio ratings data violates federal monopoly law—the case arrives at an preliminary stage before trial, involves an ongoing bankruptcy stay, and turns on case-specific pricing negotiations rather than a clean legal disagreement among lower courts.

    Why this big-case score: A Supreme Court merits ruling on whether above-cost bundled discounts or unbundled standalone pricing can constitute 'constructive tying' under Section 2 of the Sherman Act would have broad doctrinal and commercial importance across U.S. industries.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nielsen, the ratings company, asks the Supreme Court to review an appeals-court ruling that its pricing likely broke federal antitrust law. The court found that Nielsen charged so much for a product sold alone that customers were effectively forced to buy a bundle. We think the Court will probably turn the case down, about a one-in-eight chance of taking it. The legal question has split the lower courts and drawn outside support. But the case is at an early stage: the ruling under review is only a preliminary injunction, a temporary order issued before trial. The Court will probably ask the other side to respond first.

    Why this big-case score: Revives the long-standing LePage's v. PeaceHealth split on bundled discounts under Sherman Act Section 2; significant for antitrust doctrine and multiproduct sellers, though a private commercial dispute on a preliminary-injunction record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal; I put the chance of review at about one in seven, or 14%. Nielsen argues that courts disagree about when discounted product bundles unlawfully pressure customers to buy unwanted products. That issue could affect many businesses. But this case concerns a temporary court order, rests partly on detailed negotiations, and has not yet drawn a request for the other side's response. The likeliest outcome is a denial without an explanatory opinion.

    Why this big-case score: A rule governing above-cost bundled pricing and constructive tying could affect multiproduct businesses well beyond radio ratings, although this is an interlocutory private commercial dispute rather than a nationwide governmental program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny The Nielsen Company's request to review this case, with only a 4% chance (about one in twenty-five) of taking it up. Nielsen asks the Court to overturn a preliminary lower-court order that faulted Nielsen for charging Cumulus Media a high standalone price for national radio-ratings data unless Cumulus also bought local data in a discounted bundle. Although the case raises an important antitrust question about bundled discounts, the dispute is still at a preliminary stage in the lower courts and Cumulus initially waived its right to respond, making the Supreme Court unlikely to step in now.

    Why this big-case score: Significant Sherman Act Section 2 question on whether a standalone price alongside a discounted bundle can constitute a 'constructive tie' without below-cost pricing, affecting multiproduct firms broadly if decided on the merits.

Fairfield Sentry v. Citibank NA LondonLiquidators for Madoff-linked investment funds asked the Supreme Court to revive foreign claims against banks that a federal appeals court had barred; the Court declined to hear the case.Business & financedecided
0.45
0.65
0.65
0.58

Fairfield Sentry Ltd., et al. v. Citibank NA London, et al.No. 25-1089 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281372 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Business & finance

Liquidators for Madoff-linked investment funds asked the Supreme Court to revive foreign claims against banks that a federal appeals court had barred; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Fairfield Sentry and related funds, based in the British Virgin Islands, invested heavily with Bernard Madoff and collapsed into liquidation when his Ponzi scheme was exposed. Their liquidators sued banks and investors in American courts, using a bankruptcy tool called Chapter 15, to recover over $6 billion in redemption payments made before the fraud came to light. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that a Bankruptcy Code "safe harbor" for securities transactions barred all of these claims, reversing a lower ruling that had allowed some claims to proceed.

What the Court is being asked

The liquidators asked the Court to decide whether a bankruptcy law provision that shields certain securities-related payments from being clawed back, written for ordinary domestic bankruptcies, also applies to block foreign liquidators from pursuing claims under foreign law over foreign transactions. They argued that doing so improperly stretched an American legal protection beyond the country's borders and conflicted with rulings from other appeals courts.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it; Justice Alito did not take part in the decision.

What each outcome would mean

Fairfield Sentry and the other liquidators asked the Court to take up the case and reverse the Second Circuit's ruling. The banks and other investors, including Citibank and HSBC entities, opposed review and defended the lower court's decision. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Second Circuit's ruling in place, meaning the liquidators' claims against the banks and investors remain barred by the securities safe harbor. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that the case will not be reviewed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    About $6 billion in Madoff feeder-fund clawback claims, a Second Circuit ruling on Chapter 15's reach that matters to cross-border insolvency practice and the UNCITRAL Model Law framework, elite counsel on both sides and former bankruptcy judges as amici; significant in financial and bankruptcy circles but technical and of limited general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition puts approximately $6 billion in asserted recoveries and the treatment of foreign-law claims in cross-border insolvencies at stake. A decision could materially affect securities safe harbors and international bankruptcy cooperation, though its immediate subject is specialized commercial litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes bankruptcy case involving the Madoff Ponzi scheme and the extraterritorial application of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, affecting billions of dollars and international comity.

Padula v. Jaciel Cirrus RojasThe federal government asks the Supreme Court to review a Seventh Circuit ruling involving an immigration enforcement dispute with Jaciel Rojas.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.90
0.25
0.58

Frank Padula, Acting Director of the Chicago Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. v. Jaciel Cirrus RojasNo. 26-572 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000572 · models differ by up to 0.65

The federal government asks the Supreme Court to review a Seventh Circuit ruling involving an immigration enforcement dispute with Jaciel Rojas.

What happened

This case involves Frank Padula, the Acting Director of the Chicago Field Office of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, along with other federal officials, against Jaciel Rojas. The dispute reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, which issued a decision on July 30, 2026. The federal government, represented by the Solicitor General, then asked the Supreme Court to take up the case. The docket record provided does not describe the underlying facts of the dispute or the reasoning behind the Seventh Circuit's decision.

What the Court is being asked

The record provided does not include the petition's statement of the question presented, so the specific legal issue the government wants the Supreme Court to decide cannot be described here.

Where it stands

The petition for a writ of certiorari was filed on October 28, 2026. Rojas has since waived his right to respond to the petition, meaning no response brief will be filed unless the Court requests one.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, through Padula and other officials, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Seventh Circuit's decision, which went in Rojas's favor below. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, with no party yet guaranteed to win. If the Court denies the petition, the Seventh Circuit's ruling stays in place, leaving Rojas's win below undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Padula's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Padula's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal government is asking the Supreme Court to reverse a ruling that an immigrant living in the U.S. without lawful entry is entitled to a bond hearing instead of mandatory detention. The Court already agreed on October 1 to decide this exact question in another case. So this petition will probably be set aside until that case is decided, then sent back to the lower court if the government wins or turned down if it loses. We put the chance of some form of grant at about even (52%).

    Why this big-case score: The issue itself (whether 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) mandates no-bond detention for everyone present without admission) affects a very large detained population and is already granted in a lead case; this docket is a follow-on vehicle, which tempers its own stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.90·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to send this case back to the appeals court after deciding another case about the same immigration-detention rule. I put the chance of review or a summary remand at about four in five. The dispute asks whether people arrested inside the country may seek release on bond while their immigration cases proceed. Because the Court has already accepted a related case, this petition is more likely to wait for that ruling than receive a separate hearing.

    Why this big-case score: The statutory detention question affects bond-hearing eligibility for a large nationwide population and a central federal immigration policy, although this petition is likely to be a companion rather than the lead vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is likely (about a 68% chance, or roughly two in three) to grant this petition through a summary "grant, vacate, and remand" (GVR) order, which sends the case back to the lower court without full briefing or oral argument. The federal government is appealing a Seventh Circuit ruling that allowed an undocumented immigrant arrested inside the country to seek release on bond rather than face mandatory detention. Because the Supreme Court already agreed on October 1, 2026, to decide that exact legal question in a lead case from the Second Circuit (*Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha*), it will hold this petition until *Barbosa da Cunha* is decided and will likely vacate the Seventh Circuit's ruling if the government prevails in the lead case.

    Why this big-case score: While the underlying 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) mandatory-detention question affects hundreds of thousands of interior removal proceedings nationwide, certiorari was already granted on that question in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha (No. 26-104), making this a follow-on Solicitor General hold petition expected to be resolved by summary GVR or denial rather than plenary review.

City of Bossier City v. HersheyBossier City asks the Court to review a ruling that let a pamphleteer's lawsuit over his removal from a concert venue proceed against the city.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.64
0.55
0.58

City of Bossier City, Louisiana v. Richard Hershey, et al.scotus/73500228 · models differ by up to 0.09

Bossier City asks the Court to review a ruling that let a pamphleteer's lawsuit over his removal from a concert venue proceed against the city.

What happened

Richard Hershey says he was distributing religious pamphlets on a sidewalk outside a Bossier City arena during a concert when police officers and private security guards, citing the venue's private-event status, ordered him to leave under threat of arrest, while allowing another leafleteer distributing commercial material to continue. Hershey sued the city and individual officers. The district court dismissed all claims, and a divided Fifth Circuit panel affirmed dismissal of the claims against the individual officers on qualified-immunity grounds but revived Hershey's claim that the city had failed to train its officers on First Amendment rights. The full Fifth Circuit denied rehearing by a 10-7 vote.

What the Court is being asked

The case concerns when a city can be sued over a single incident for not training its employees on constitutional rights. The city asks whether such a claim requires showing that the officers' conduct violated a clearly established right, and whether it requires showing a complete absence of training on the constitutional right generally, rather than training tailored to the specific situation that arose.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief in opposition and a reply, and has been distributed for five consecutive conferences, most recently November 13, 2026. The docket shows no action yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Bossier City, which lost on the municipal-liability claim below, is asking the Court to take up and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review and later rules for the city, Hershey's claim against the city would likely be dismissed. If it rules for Hershey, the city's potential liability for failing to train its officers would go forward in the lower courts. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision allowing Hershey's claim against the city to proceed stands, and the case returns to the lower courts for further proceedings on that claim.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling would set the outer bound of single-incident Monell failure-to-train liability for every municipality, and the paired petition (25-1389) on Hope v. Pelzer's reach beyond the Eighth Amendment would reshape qualified-immunity 'obviousness'. Doctrinally significant for section 1983 practice nationwide; not a headline-stakes case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could reshape single-incident municipal failure-to-train liability nationwide, affecting civil-rights remedies and local-government exposure. The particular leafleting dispute is narrow, and the case does not directly ask the Court to abolish qualified immunity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises a Monell failure-to-train issue concerning First Amendment rights and single-incident liability, but is overshadowed by the qualified immunity issue in the cross-petition.

Wisconsin Voter Alliance v. MillisThe Supreme Court declined to review a voter group's bid to revive its lawsuit over Wisconsin's handling of federal election-law complaints filed against the state's own elections commission.Election lawdecided
0.35
0.58
0.80
0.58

Wisconsin Voter Alliance, et al. v. Don M. Millis, Commissioner, Wisconsin Elections Commission, et al.No. 25-1288 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73357827 · models differ by up to 0.45 · topic: Election law

The Supreme Court declined to review a voter group's bid to revive its lawsuit over Wisconsin's handling of federal election-law complaints filed against the state's own elections commission.

What happened

The Wisconsin Voter Alliance and two of its members twice filed complaints with the Wisconsin Elections Commission, alleging the commission itself was violating the Help America Vote Act, a federal law setting minimum election administration standards. The commission returned both complaints without deciding them, saying it had a conflict of interest in judging complaints against itself. The petitioners sued, but a federal district court dismissed the case for lack of standing, finding no concrete injury. The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal in February 2026.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether this federal election law gives private citizens and organizations a right to sue in federal court when a state fails to follow the law's required complaint procedures, and whether being completely denied those procedures and remedies counts as a real, concrete harm that courts can address, or only a technical violation that courts cannot review.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after the respondents waived their right to respond and an amicus brief was filed. The petitioners filed a supplemental brief in September 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The Wisconsin Voter Alliance and its members asked the Court to take up their case after losing in the lower courts. Had the Court granted review, it would have heard full arguments on whether the law creates enforceable rights and whether the denial of complaint procedures is a concrete injury, deciding the question for all sides. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Seventh Circuit's ruling in place: the lawsuit remains dismissed, and the commission's handling of these complaints is not subject to federal court review on the claims raised here.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a ruling on private (section 1983) enforcement of HAVA and on organizational standing for election-integrity groups after Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine would reshape election-administration litigation nationally; but the vehicle is a fact-bound standing dismissal, so the likely decision footprint is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Private enforcement of federal election-administration requirements and organizational standing have nationwide significance, but this petition concerns access to administrative adjudication rather than an election result or an immediate voting restriction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves election integrity, a deep circuit split on HAVA enforcement under 1983, and high-stakes Article III standing bounds under TransUnion and AHM.

Parker v. GatesThe Supreme Court declined to review sanctions imposed on lawyers for Kari Lake and Mark Finchem over their 2022 Arizona election lawsuit.Civil proceduredecided
0.40
0.62
0.70
0.57

Andrew D. Parker, et al. v. Bill Gates, as a Member of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, et al.No. 25-882 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280380 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to review sanctions imposed on lawyers for Kari Lake and Mark Finchem over their 2022 Arizona election lawsuit.

What happened

Attorneys Andrew Parker and his firm represented candidates Kari Lake and Mark Finchem in a 2022 lawsuit challenging Arizona's electronic vote-counting procedures. A federal district court dismissed the suit for lack of standing and separately sanctioned Parker and co-counsel under court rules, finding they made false and misleading factual claims and pursued an injunction request that was both frivolous and poorly timed before the election. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the sanctions in a divided panel decision; rehearing before the full court was denied, though six judges dissented, warning the sanctions could chill legitimate litigation. Parker then asked the Supreme Court to review the sanctions ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raised four questions: whether a court may sanction attorneys partly to discourage future lawsuits it views as politically unpopular; whether sanctions may rest on finding that legal arguments are novel or unlikely to succeed; whether a court may interpret a complaint in the way least favorable to the attorneys who wrote it before sanctioning them; and whether a request for an election-related court order can be sanctioned as poorly timed when it was filed roughly four months before the election and also sought relief for future elections.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference multiple times, with the Court requesting a response from the opposing parties along the way. After further conferences, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Parker and his firm, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the sanctions. Maricopa County officials, the respondents, opposed review, defending the lower courts' rulings. Because the Court denied the petition, the Ninth Circuit's decision upholding the sanctions against Parker and his co-counsel stands, and the case is not reviewed further by the Supreme Court. A denial does not mean the Court agreed the sanctions were proper, only that it chose not to hear the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Rule 11 / s.1927 sanctions on the lawyers who brought the 2022 Arizona voting-machine suit for Kari Lake and Mark Finchem; a decision would set the standard for construing pleadings under Rule 11 and speak to sanctions in election litigation, but only $122,200 and two attorneys are directly at stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Attorney sanctions in election litigation raise significant advocacy and judicial-neutrality concerns; a ruling could affect nationwide sanctions practice, but this is not a direct challenge to an election result.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition challenges sanctions against attorneys for prominent 2022 election challenges, raising highly salient questions about the bounds of political litigation and Rule 11, drawing national attention and an en banc dissent.

Garcia v. HobbsThe Court vacated a Ninth Circuit ruling that Benancio Garcia's challenge to a Washington legislative district was moot, sending the case back for reconsideration.Civil proceduredecided
0.40
0.62
0.70
0.57

Benancio Garcia, III v. Steven Hobbs, Secretary of State of Washington, et al.No. 25-901 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280412 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Civil procedure (also Election law)

The Court vacated a Ninth Circuit ruling that Benancio Garcia's challenge to a Washington legislative district was moot, sending the case back for reconsideration.

What happened

Benancio Garcia III sued Washington's Secretary of State and the State, arguing that Legislative District 15 was an unconstitutional racial gerrymander that sorted him by his Hispanic ethnicity. While his case was pending, a different judge, in a separate lawsuit over the same district brought under the Voting Rights Act, ordered the district redrawn. A three-judge panel then dismissed Garcia's claim as moot, reasoning that the new district replaced the one he challenged. Garcia appealed, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a lawsuit claiming a voting district improperly sorted people by race becomes moot, meaning there is nothing left for a court to decide, once that district is replaced through a separate court order, when the replacement map keeps or deepens the same kind of racial sorting the plaintiff objected to, and when that separate order is still being appealed.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition, set aside the Ninth Circuit's judgment, and sent the case back for further consideration in light of its decision in a different redistricting case, Louisiana v. Callais.

What each outcome would mean

Garcia, who brought the original lawsuit, asked the Court to revive his case after the lower courts dismissed it as moot. By sending the case back, the Court did not decide whether his claim is moot or who should win; it only told the Ninth Circuit to reexamine its ruling using the standards set out in the newer Callais decision. The dismissal of Garcia's claim is no longer in effect, and the Ninth Circuit must now reconsider the mootness question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Oct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single Washington state legislative district and a mootness question; the recurring VRA-vs-Equal-Protection sequencing issue and the post-Callais context lift it above a routine petition, but a GVR would draw little notice.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 84%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question concerns access to equal-protection review when parallel Voting Rights Act litigation replaces a challenged district. It has recurring redistricting significance, but this petition's immediate issue is mootness, not the substantive validity of race-conscious maps.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile dispute over racial gerrymandering and VRA remedies, though the procedural posture (mootness) limits its impact.

Grand v. City of University HeightsDaniel Grand asked the Supreme Court to decide whether a zoning finality rule for property-takings claims also blocks religious-liberty lawsuits over local permit disputes.First Amendmentawaiting the Court
0.45
0.62
0.65
0.57

Daniel Grand v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.No. 25-965 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281006 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

Daniel Grand asked the Supreme Court to decide whether a zoning finality rule for property-takings claims also blocks religious-liberty lawsuits over local permit disputes.

What happened

Daniel Grand, an Orthodox Jew living in University Heights, Ohio, invited neighbors to pray with him at his home. The city sent a cease-and-desist letter, saying he needed a special-use permit to use his house as a place of religious assembly. Grand applied for the permit, faced a contentious public hearing, and then withdrew his application, saying he did not intend to operate a formal house of worship. He sued the city and officials, raising First Amendment, equal-protection, due-process and federal land-use law claims, along with allegations of surveillance and harassment. The district court dismissed most claims as not ripe because no final zoning decision had been reached; the Sixth Circuit affirmed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a rule developed for property-takings cases—requiring a final decision from local zoning authorities before a lawsuit can proceed—also applies to claims that government threats chilled someone's religious exercise, worship, and assembly, even when those claims arise in a zoning dispute.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition, and the case was briefed and argued; it is scheduled for oral argument on December 9, 2026, and awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Grand, who brought this case, is asking the Court to reverse the lower court's ruling that his claims were not ripe for review. If the Court sides with Grand, his claims could go forward in the lower courts without his having to obtain a final zoning determination first. If the Court sides with the city, the finality requirement would continue to apply, and Grand's claims would remain barred unless he pursues further proceedings before local zoning authorities.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Dec 9, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Grand wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The City of University Heights wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally watched religious-liberty case with a broad cross-ideological amicus coalition, but the question is justiciability: the likely outcome is a remand on ripeness, not a merits ruling on religious exercise.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set a nationwide boundary between First Amendment chilling injury and land-use finality for religious exercise in the home.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Settles whether Williamson County finality reaches First Amendment/RLUIPA land-use claims — a recurring religious-liberty and zoning question with heavy amicus interest — but a remand-shaped ripeness ruling, not a substantive Free Exercise holding.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally consequential religious-liberty and federal-courts access case affecting local land-use disputes, but the likely ruling concerns justiciability rather than a substantive right to conduct every religious use without a permit.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High doctrinal significance for First Amendment Free Exercise and RLUIPA justiciability across the federal circuits (resolving whether Williamson County's Takings Clause finality requirement applies to land-use religious-liberty and chilling-effect claims), though potentially narrowed by case-specific procedural facts.

Petróleos de Venezuela v. Helmerich & Payne International DrillingThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Venezuelan state oil company's challenge to a ruling that let a U.S. drilling company's expropriation lawsuit proceed.Sovereignty & foreign relationsdecided
0.42
0.60
0.70
0.57

Petróleos de Venezuela, S.A., et al. v. Helmerich & Payne International Drilling Co.No. 25-1256 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73302615 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Venezuelan state oil company's challenge to a ruling that let a U.S. drilling company's expropriation lawsuit proceed.

What happened

Helmerich & Payne International Drilling Co., a U.S. company, sued Petróleos de Venezuela, S.A. and its subsidiary PDVSA Petróleo, S.A. after Venezuela nationalized the assets of H&P's Venezuelan subsidiary in 2010. PDVSA argued that a legal principle called the act-of-state doctrine, which generally bars U.S. courts from judging the validity of a foreign government's official acts, should block the suit because the seized property never entered the United States. The district court and the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals both ruled against PDVSA, holding that a federal law called the Second Hickenlooper Amendment prevented the act-of-state doctrine from barring the claim regardless of where the property was located.

What the Court is being asked

The question was whether a law limiting a court doctrine that normally shields a foreign government's official acts from judicial review applies to a damages claim even when the seized property, or anything exchanged for it, never came into the United States.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026, leaving the lower court's decision in place. Justice Kavanaugh did not take part in the decision.

What each outcome would mean

PDVSA, the company that asked the Court to take the case, sought to overturn the D.C. Circuit's decision allowing H&P's lawsuit to continue. By denying review, the Court leaves that ruling in place: H&P's case against PDVSA can proceed in the lower courts, and the act-of-state doctrine does not block it even though the disputed property stayed in Venezuela. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 21%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Scope of the Second Hickenlooper Amendment and the act-of-state doctrine for foreign expropriations, in a 15-year Venezuela oil-rig case already before the Court once; important to the foreign-relations bar and sovereign litigants, but a narrow statutory question that rarely controls outcomes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The territorial scope of the Second Hickenlooper Amendment matters to foreign-expropriation litigation and sovereign relations, but this is a specialized statutory issue presented through an interlocutory commercial dispute, not a generally applicable constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
NHK Spring v. Seagate TechnologyNHK Spring asks the Court to decide whether its U.S. price negotiations can expose it to antitrust liability for sales completed entirely overseas.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.57
0.70
0.57

NHK Spring Co., Ltd., et al. v. Seagate Technology LLC, et al.No. 25-1358 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500259 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Business & finance

NHK Spring asks the Court to decide whether its U.S. price negotiations can expose it to antitrust liability for sales completed entirely overseas.

What happened

NHK, a Japanese manufacturer, pleaded guilty to a criminal conspiracy fixing prices of suspension assemblies, a hard-drive component, sold in the United States and elsewhere. Seagate, an American company, and its foreign affiliates sued NHK for antitrust violations, arguing the affiliates overpaid abroad for assemblies priced through negotiations conducted in the United States. The district court ruled that a federal antitrust law limiting lawsuits over foreign commerce barred most of these claims. The Ninth Circuit reversed in part, holding Seagate's foreign affiliates might proceed because the U.S.-negotiated prices allegedly set what they paid overseas, and sent the case back for further proceedings.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal law restricting antitrust lawsuits over foreign transactions allows foreign companies to sue over purchases made entirely outside the United States, when the only U.S. connection is that part of the price-setting process happened here. NHK argues this conflicts with another appeals court's ruling that such domestic negotiations are not enough by themselves to trigger American antitrust law.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference in September 2026. The Court has since invited the Solicitor General to file a brief expressing the federal government's views on whether the case should be heard.

What each outcome would mean

NHK, which lost before the Ninth Circuit, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review and ultimately rules for NHK, it would narrow or eliminate the foreign affiliates' ability to sue under U.S. antitrust law for purchases made abroad, likely ending part of Seagate's case. If it rules for Seagate, the Ninth Circuit's decision allowing the case to proceed would stand. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling remains in effect and the case returns to the district court for further proceedings on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up NHK Spring's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: NHK Spring's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An FTAIA extraterritoriality question over global component supply chains, with a published Ninth Circuit opinion openly at odds with the Seventh: significant for multinational business and the antitrust bar, technical for everyone else.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 23%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The territorial reach of private antitrust damages across multinational supply chains has substantial commercial and international-comity stakes, but this is a technical statutory dispute with potentially narrow, fact-dependent reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes circuit split on the extraterritorial reach of US antitrust law under the FTAIA.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A published Ninth Circuit opinion extending the Sherman Act's reach to foreign-to-foreign component sales under the FTAIA, in open disagreement with the Seventh Circuit's Motorola decision; a decision would matter to every multinational supply chain and to the antitrust bar, but the question is technical, the record is interlocutory, and public attention would be modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The territorial reach of private antitrust damages affects multinational supply chains and international comity, but the dispute is commercially focused and may turn on unusual contractual and procedural facts.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant implications for international business transactions and the extraterritorial reach of U.S. antitrust law.

Singh v. Second Judicial District Court of NevadaSikh Society leaders ask the Court to stop a Nevada lawsuit over the group's governance and property, arguing courts may not referee internal religious disputes.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.62
0.55
0.57

Jasvinder Singh, et al. v. Second Judicial District Court of Nevada, Washoe County, et al.No. 26-157 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000157 · models differ by up to 0.07

Sikh Society leaders ask the Court to stop a Nevada lawsuit over the group's governance and property, arguing courts may not referee internal religious disputes.

What happened

Northern Nevada Sikh Society members who once served on its Management Committee sued the Society's current leaders, claiming they violated the Society's bylaws by forming committees without approval, trying to move the Society's temple into a trust, and withholding membership records. The leaders asked the Nevada courts to dismiss the suit, arguing the "ecclesiastical abstention doctrine" bars civil courts from deciding internal church governance matters. The trial court refused to dismiss, and the Nevada Supreme Court agreed, holding that courts may use "neutral principles of law" to decide such disputes even outside property-ownership cases, so long as they do not have to interpret religious doctrine.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether civil courts may resolve internal governance disputes within a religious organization—such as who leads it, who counts as a member, and how it manages its property—using ordinary legal rules, or whether such disputes must be left entirely to the religious organization itself whenever its membership and leadership rules are defined in religious terms.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference and the Court asked the respondents to respond; that response deadline has since been extended to November 23, 2026. The docket does not show any further action on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The Sikh Society leaders, as petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Nevada Supreme Court's decision and shut down the lawsuit. If the Court grants review and eventually sides with the leaders, the case against them would likely end, leaving Society governance outside court control. If it rules for the former committee members instead, their lawsuit over bylaws and the temple trust could proceed in Nevada courts. If the Court denies review, the Nevada Supreme Court's decision allowing the suit to continue stands, and the case returns to the trial court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Singh's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Singh's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely **turn down** this case, with about a one-in-seven chance (14%) that it agrees to hear it. The case asks whether courts may settle a leadership fight inside a Sikh temple society by reading its bylaws, or whether the First Amendment keeps courts out of a religious group's internal affairs. The Court asked the other side to respond, and lower courts disagree on the question, both of which help the petition. But the case comes up before trial, which raises a question of whether it is ready for review, and the Court recently passed on a similar case.

    Why this big-case score: A grant would set the reach of the church-autonomy doctrine's neutral-principles exception beyond property disputes, which matters to every religious body's internal governance; the case's own facts are a local temple dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 23%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of agreeing to review it (23%). The dispute asks how far civil judges may go in enforcing a Sikh religious organization's rules about leadership and management. Several religious groups support review, and the Court has requested an answer from the other side. But the Nevada court described the disputed procedures as secular and religious membership qualifications as uncontested, making this a less straightforward test case than the challengers suggest.

    Why this big-case score: A decision could materially define civil courts' authority over religious organizations' membership and governance nationwide, although the underlying dispute concerns one congregation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will deny the petition for a writ of certiorari—a formal request asking the Court to review a lower court's ruling—with a grant probability of 14% (about one in seven). Although the Court asked the respondents to file a response and three outside religious groups filed supporting briefs, the case is at a preliminary stage in Nevada state court, and the dispute centers on whether board members of a Sikh temple's nonprofit corporation followed corporate bylaws when trying to move the temple's building into a trust, making it a poor candidate for major constitutional review under the First Amendment's church-autonomy doctrine (the rule protecting religious groups' control over their internal governance).

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision clarifying whether the First Amendment's church-autonomy doctrine confines the neutral-principles approach to property-ownership disputes would govern civil-court jurisdiction over internal governance, bylaw, and tort claims against religious organizations nationwide.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down this case, giving it about a one-in-six chance of agreeing to hear it. The case asks whether courts may settle a leadership dispute inside a Sikh religious society by applying the society's bylaws. Some signs point toward review: the Court asked the other side to respond, three outside groups filed supporting briefs, and lower courts disagree on the question. But the Court recently declined a similar case, and this one is still at an early stage in the state courts.

    Why this big-case score: Acknowledged split on the reach of the neutral-principles exception to church autonomy; recurring and nationally relevant to religious bodies, though the dispute itself is a small congregational governance fight.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 26%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of taking the case. The dispute asks how far civil courts can go in enforcing a religious group's rules for membership and leadership. Lower courts disagree, three outside groups support review, and the Justices have requested a response. Those are meaningful signs of interest, but the lawsuit is still at an early stage and may involve ordinary organizational rules rather than religious decisions. Another conference distribution is likely before a decision.

    Why this big-case score: A decision could materially define nationwide protection for religious organizations' internal governance, although the immediate litigation concerns one congregation's bylaws.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in this case, with about a one-in-nine chance (11%) that the Court agrees to hear it. The dispute involves rival factions of a Sikh temple in Reno, Nevada, and raises an important First Amendment question that has divided lower courts: whether secular courts can apply ordinary corporate-bylaw rules ("neutral principles of law") to resolve internal church leadership disputes. Although three outside religious groups filed briefs supporting review and the Court asked the challengers to respond, the case is still in its earliest stage in Nevada state court and mixes church-leadership claims with a dispute over transferring temple real estate into a trust, making it an unattractive vehicle for a landmark ruling.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision would resolve a recurring federal and state split over whether Jones v. Wolf's neutral-principles approach allows civil courts to adjudicate internal religious governance and bylaw disputes beyond property ownership.

Department of the Air Force v. Prutehi GuahanThe Air Force asks the Supreme Court to decide whether its permit renewal application was reviewable and whether NEPA applied before it sought that permit.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.50
0.66
0.55
0.57

Department of the Air Force, et al. v. Prutehi Guahan, fka Prutehi LitekyanNo. 25-579 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279024 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Air Force asks the Supreme Court to decide whether its permit renewal application was reviewable and whether NEPA applied before it sought that permit.

What happened

Since the 1980s, the Air Force has destroyed hazardous-waste munitions by open burning and detonation at Tarague Beach on Guam, under permits issued by Guam's environmental agency under a federal hazardous-waste law. In 2021, the Air Force applied to renew its permit without first conducting an environmental review under a separate federal law requiring agencies to study the environmental effects of major actions. Prutehi Guahan, a Guam-based nonprofit, sued, arguing that review was required first. A federal district court dismissed the suit, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed, ruling that the permit application was reviewable and that the environmental-review law still applied. The Air Force appealed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked two questions: first, whether an agency's request to renew a hazardous-waste permit counts as a final decision that courts can immediately review, before the permitting agency has acted on it; and second, whether an agency applying for such a permit must separately complete a general environmental study, even though the permitting process itself requires some environmental review.

Where it stands

The case was argued on October 7, 2026, after the Court granted review in March 2026. It now awaits a decision on the merits.

What each outcome would mean

The Air Force, as petitioner, is asking the Court to overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which favored Prutehi Guahan. If the Court affirms, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands: the permit application is reviewable now, and the Air Force must comply with the environmental-review law before seeking such permits, meaning Prutehi Guahan's suit can proceed. If the Court reverses, it would mean either that the application cannot be challenged until the permitting agency acts, or that no separate environmental study was required, cutting off Prutehi Guahan's claim. A vacatur would send the case back without resolving these questions for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 20, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: The Department of the Air Force wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Prutehi Guahan wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A significant administrative-law case — APA finality and NEPA's reach over federal facilities' permitting, with military-operations stakes and an indigenous-community challenge from Guam — but doctrinal rather than headline-grabbing; closely watched in environmental and admin-law circles, not broadly salient.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The ruling could affect federal permit-renewal practice nationwide, but the likely decision is a technical and narrow APA-finality holding.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 92%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant administrative-law vehicle — APA finality for agency permit applications plus NEPA displacement by a specific environmental statute — with military operations, territorial communities, an 11-state amicus bloc on each side, and the Chamber of Commerce engaged; consequential for agencies and NEPA litigation but not a marquee public controversy.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 74%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set a nationally important boundary on final agency action and NEPA review when federal facilities seek environmental permits.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 87%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring administrative-law question (finality of a federal agency's own permit application to a non-federal regulator) plus NEPA/RCRA displacement, with state coalitions on both sides; significant for federal facility permitting but technical rather than headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 89%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The local environmental stakes on Guam are substantial, and the finality question could affect challenges to federal agencies' permit applications nationwide. A narrow procedural ruling would leave the broader NEPA/RCRA displacement question unresolved.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Moderate-to-high doctrinal significance for federal administrative law (clarifying APA 'final agency action' when federal agencies apply to state or territorial regulators under cooperative-federalism environmental statutes like RCRA) and military munitions operations in Guam, though likely resolved on a narrow threshold finality ground without reaching the broader NEPA-displacement question.

O'Donnell v. City of ChicagoThe Supreme Court declined to hear Chicago drivers' challenge to the city's practice of impounding and selling vehicles over unpaid parking tickets without compensation.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.50
0.56
0.65
0.57

Ryan O'Donnell, et al. v. City of Chicago, Illinois, et al.No. 25-1098 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281381 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear Chicago drivers' challenge to the city's practice of impounding and selling vehicles over unpaid parking tickets without compensation.

What happened

Ryan O'Donnell and Michael Goree each had their vehicles towed, impounded, and sold by the City of Chicago after accumulating unpaid parking tickets, under a city ordinance allowing escalating enforcement including vehicle disposal. Neither received payment or credit toward their debts from the sales. They sued the City and URT United Road Towing, the city's towing contractor, arguing the ordinance amounts to an unconstitutional taking of property. A federal district court dismissed the claims, and the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the city's vehicle forfeiture scheme is an exercise of police power to enforce traffic laws, not a taking.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a city violates constitutional protection against uncompensated property seizures when it impounds and sells vehicles to enforce unpaid traffic fines, keeping all proceeds without crediting the debt or returning any surplus value, and whether there is any limit on a local government's power to confiscate property this way while enforcing its own laws.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference multiple times, with the Court asking for a response from the City after initial waivers. The Court denied the petition, with a statement by Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Gorsuch, respecting that denial.

What each outcome would mean

O'Donnell and Goree asked the Court to overturn the Seventh Circuit's ruling in favor of Chicago and URT. The denial leaves the Seventh Circuit's decision in place, meaning the city's practice of impounding and selling vehicles without compensating owners for surplus value remains in effect, and O'Donnell and Goree's lawsuit stays dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply leaves that ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on whether the Takings Clause limits police-power forfeiture of vehicles for unpaid tickets would reach tens of thousands of Chicago motorists and every municipal impound-and-sell program; but the most likely grant route is a GVR trailing Hadley/Pena, which decides nothing itself.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The limits on municipal confiscation for unpaid traffic debt implicate important property rights and financially vulnerable motorists; the pleaded facial challenge and ordinance-specific setting constrain the likely reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the boundary of the Takings Clause under the police power, directly implicating the scope of the recent Tyler v. Hennepin County decision.

United Biologics v. Amerigroup TennesseeUnited Allergy Services asks the Court to revive its antitrust suit claiming rivals conspired to drive it from the Tennessee allergy-care market.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.61
0.65
0.57

United Biologics, LLC, dba United Allergy Services v. Amerigroup Tennessee, Inc., dba Amerigroup Community Care, et al.No. 25-1388 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500290 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Business & finance

United Allergy Services asks the Court to revive its antitrust suit claiming rivals conspired to drive it from the Tennessee allergy-care market.

What happened

United Allergy Services (UAS) supplies equipment and technicians to primary care doctors who offer allergy testing and treatment, competing with Amerigroup and an allergy practice known as the Center. UAS sued them, claiming they conspired to push it out of the Tennessee market by pressuring doctors who worked with UAS. A federal district court dismissed UAS's antitrust claims, finding UAS could not sue because it was not a direct competitor, though related state-law claims proceeded and later lost at summary judgment. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, ruling UAS's antitrust claims failed under a Supreme Court rule limiting who can sue over harms that pass through a chain of buyers and sellers, and separately because UAS's claimed losses were too speculative.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a legal rule that normally stops a business from suing over losses passed down a chain of buyers and sellers also blocks a company that was itself the direct, intended target of a boycott from suing to recover its own lost profits, even though another business (the doctors) stood closer to the alleged wrongdoers in that chain.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, and the case was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference. On October 5, 2026, the Court invited the Solicitor General to file a brief giving the federal government's views before deciding whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

United Biologics, LLC (UAS) is asking the Court to take up its case and reverse the Sixth Circuit's ruling. If the Court eventually grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether UAS can sue despite not being the most direct target of the alleged conspiracy, deciding nothing yet about who is right. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision stands, leaving UAS's federal antitrust claims dismissed and Amerigroup and the Center's win in place. The pending call for the Solicitor General's views means the Court has not yet decided whether to grant or deny the petition.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up United Biologics' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: United Biologics' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean antitrust-standing question on the reach of Illinois Brick beyond overcharges, paired with a same-day CVSG in a companion petition and watched by the antitrust and business bar; consequential doctrinally but not a front-page case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of private antitrust damages for exclusionary boycotts affects new entrants and nonintegrated businesses beyond allergy care. Substantial nationwide enforcement stakes, but a technical standing dispute rather than a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Antitrust standing under Illinois Brick is a significant commercial issue with a circuit split, though it lacks the broad public prominence of a major constitutional dispute.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 41%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Scope of Illinois Brick for a boycott target's lost-profit damages, with a paired CVSG petition (25-1070) on the same question and Chamber of Commerce interest; a significant business/antitrust-standing case if decided, not a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.61·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of private antitrust recovery for targeted businesses has national importance beyond allergy services, including exclusionary boycotts and supply chains. The case is commercially consequential but turns on a technical damages-standing question rather than a broad constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Moats v. National Credit Union Administration BoardThe Court declined to hear a former credit union executive's challenge to a law that blocked him from suing in federal court to stop an agency's enforcement case against him.decided
0.45
0.68
—
0.56 2 of 3 models

Jeffrey Moats v. National Credit Union Administration Board, a Federal Administrative Agency, et al.No. 26-45 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000045 · models differ by up to 0.23

The Court declined to hear a former credit union executive's challenge to a law that blocked him from suing in federal court to stop an agency's enforcement case against him.

What happened

Jeffrey Moats led a Texas credit union until regulators placed it under the National Credit Union Administration's control and fired him. The NCUA later charged him with financial misconduct and sought penalties through its own in-house proceeding, run by an administrative law judge. Moats sued in federal district court, arguing that the judge was unconstitutionally shielded from removal and that he was entitled to a jury trial, among other claims. The district court dismissed his suit, ruling that a federal statute stripped it of jurisdiction to interfere with the agency's proceeding. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, relying on its related ruling in a similar case involving bank regulators.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a law barring courts from interfering with notices or orders issued in this kind of agency enforcement action also blocks a lawsuit that challenges the constitutionality of the agency's structure and procedures themselves, rather than challenging a specific order. It also asks whether Congress may constitutionally cut off court access for this kind of structural challenge at all, requiring the challenger to go through the full agency process first.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Moats asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fifth Circuit's ruling in place: Moats cannot bring his constitutional challenge in federal district court while the NCUA's enforcement proceeding is pending, and he must pursue his claims through the agency process and later appeal to a federal appeals court if he receives an adverse order. The denial does not decide whether the Fifth Circuit's reasoning was correct.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on whether Congress may expressly channel structural separation-of-powers claims away from district courts would be a significant administrative-law decision (the question Axon left open), but the case itself is a single credit-union enforcement matter and the likelier outcome is a denial or a hold-and-GVR that decides nothing.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits decision could determine access to immediate Article III review of structural constitutional challenges across financial regulators and other agencies. That potential reach exceeds the individual enforcement dispute, although the Court could decide only the Federal Credit Union Act's jurisdictional provision.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Applies established precedent on explicit preclusion; lacks circuit split or major national impact.

Council For Responsible Nutrition v. JamesA supplements trade group's bid to challenge New York's ban on selling weight-loss and muscle-building supplements to minors was denied by the Court.First Amendmentdecided
0.45
0.59
0.65
0.56

Council For Responsible Nutrition v. Letitia James, in Her Official Capacity as New York Attorney GeneralNo. 25-1145 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281633 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

A supplements trade group's bid to challenge New York's ban on selling weight-loss and muscle-building supplements to minors was denied by the Court.

What happened

New York passed a law barring the sale of diet pills and supplements marketed for weight loss or muscle building to anyone under eighteen. The Council for Responsible Nutrition, a trade group of supplement makers, sued New York's Attorney General, arguing the law violates the First Amendment by restricting commercial speech without adequate justification. A federal district court denied the Council's request to block the law while the case proceeds, and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, finding the law likely satisfies the constitutional test for commercial speech regulation. The Council then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks about the standard courts use when the government restricts commercial advertising or sales based on how a product is marketed. Specifically, it asks whether the government must produce specific evidence linking its restriction to the harm it targets, rather than relying on general reasoning or common sense, and whether courts owe deference to a legislature's choice of regulatory approach over less speech-restrictive alternatives. The Council says appeals courts disagree on these questions; New York disputes that any such disagreement exists.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after full briefing including amicus briefs supporting the Council. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Council for Responsible Nutrition asked the Supreme Court to take up its case and overturn the Second Circuit's ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Second Circuit's decision in place, meaning the lower courts' refusal to block New York's law stands, and the Council's lawsuit against the law continues in the lower courts without Supreme Court review of these particular questions. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Second Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a ruling on the evidentiary burden and tailoring inquiry under Central Hudson would recalibrate commercial-speech review nationwide and reach a wave of state youth-protection laws keyed to marketing; but the vehicle is a preliminary-injunction ruling about a niche product category, so the stakes are doctrinal rather than headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.59·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could affect commercial-speech scrutiny and the use of marketing to define regulated products across industries, although this vehicle concerns a single state's supplement-sales restrictions and preliminary relief.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment commercial speech case involving state regulation of dietary supplements and minors, with significant industry interest.

Herzon v. AriasFederal drug agents ask the Court to block a damages lawsuit over a warrant-based arrest, arguing courts may not extend a Fourth Amendment damages remedy to this situation.awaiting the Court
0.40
0.64
0.65
0.56

Noah A. Herzon, et al. v. Robert AriasNo. 26-111 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000111 · models differ by up to 0.25

Federal drug agents ask the Court to block a damages lawsuit over a warrant-based arrest, arguing courts may not extend a Fourth Amendment damages remedy to this situation.

What happened

DEA task-force members arrested Robert Arias in a shopping mall parking lot under an arrest warrant. Arias sued six agents, claiming they used excessive force and that others failed to stop it, seeking damages under a Supreme Court precedent, Bivens, that allows such suits in some circumstances. A federal district court ruled against Arias, partly because a federal law lets people file misconduct complaints against agents administratively. The First Circuit reversed on the excessive-force claim, holding it was similar enough to the original Bivens case to proceed, but upheld dismissal of the failure-to-intervene claim. The agents, represented by the federal government, now ask the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a damages lawsuit against federal officers for excessive force, originally allowed only for a warrantless home arrest, should also be allowed when officers use a warrant and the arrest happens outside the home. The petition also asks, if the Court does not decide this now, that it instead wait to act until it decides a related case about this same type of lawsuit in a different setting.

Where it stands

The petition for review was filed in July 2026. The respondent's deadline to reply has been extended twice, most recently to December 7, 2026, and the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The federal officers are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the First Circuit's ruling, which allowed Arias's excessive-force claim to go forward. If the Court grants review and later rules for the officers, Arias's claim would be cut off. If it rules for Arias, his lawsuit could proceed. If the Court denies review, the First Circuit's decision favoring Arias stands, and his case continues in the lower courts. The Court could also delay deciding on this petition until it resolves the related case it mentioned.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 7, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Herzon's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Herzon's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal government's lawyers (the Solicitor General) are asking the Supreme Court to overturn an appeals-court ruling that lets a man sue federal drug agents for money over alleged rough treatment during his arrest. We think it is very likely (about four in five) that the Court acts for the government. The most probable route is to wait for a closely related case it is already deciding and then send this one back to the lower court to reconsider in light of that decision.

    Why this big-case score: Scope of Bivens for Fourth Amendment excessive-force claims against federal officers; a recurring question under a 3-2-1 circuit split, though likely resolved derivatively via Nielsen v. Watanabe.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is likely to take some action on this petition—about a 78% chance—but probably will not hear it separately. Federal officers ask whether they can be sued personally for allegedly using excessive force during an arrest outside a home. The government's top Supreme Court lawyer supports review, and appeals courts disagree. The likeliest result is to wait for a related case, then cancel the lower court's judgment and send this case back for another look under the new guidance.

    Why this big-case score: The availability of damages for excessive force by federal officers affects ordinary policing nationwide, although this petition presents a bounded extension question rather than a request to overrule Bivens outright.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely, at about four in five (78%), to grant this petition—either for full review or to send the case back to the lower court after deciding a related pending case (*Nielsen v. Watanabe*). The U.S. Solicitor General—the federal government's top appellate lawyer, whose petitions the Court grants at a high rate—is asking the Justices to resolve a disagreement among federal appeals courts over whether private individuals can sue federal drug-enforcement agents for money damages under *Bivens* (a 1971 precedent allowing certain constitutional lawsuits against federal officers) when agents allegedly use excessive force while executing an arrest warrant in a public parking lot.

    Why this big-case score: Solicitor General petition seeking to resolve a 3-2-1 circuit split on whether Bivens extends to Fourth Amendment excessive-force claims arising from warrant-authorized arrests outside the home, or whether the DOJ Inspector General Act forecloses Bivens in its core DEA arrest context.

Guerrero v. JohnsonTexas asks the Supreme Court to bar a death row inmate from pursuing a renewed habeas claim that he is intellectually disabled and so ineligible for execution.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.45
0.66
0.55
0.55

Eric Guerrero, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division v. Dexter JohnsonNo. 25-1003 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281043 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

Texas asks the Supreme Court to bar a death row inmate from pursuing a renewed habeas claim that he is intellectually disabled and so ineligible for execution.

What happened

Dexter Johnson was sentenced to death in 2007. At trial, an expert found his IQ too high to qualify as intellectually disabled under the diagnostic standards then used, so he did not raise a claim under Atkins v. Virginia, the Supreme Court decision barring execution of intellectually disabled people. After a 2013 revision to psychiatric diagnostic standards deemphasized IQ cutoffs, Johnson sought to raise an Atkins claim for the first time in a second federal habeas petition. The Fifth Circuit authorized him to proceed, reasoning that his claim had been "previously unavailable" under the law governing repeat habeas petitions. The federal district court agreed the claim could proceed, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed that ruling in an interlocutory appeal, prompting Texas's petition.

What the Court is being asked

The case turns on a federal law limiting repeat habeas petitions, which allows a new claim only if it relies on a new constitutional rule that was previously unavailable to the prisoner. The Court must decide whether a rule counts as "previously unavailable" merely because a claim relying on it would have failed earlier under then-prevailing diagnostic standards, or whether the rule is only "previously unavailable" if it did not yet exist, or could not practically have been invoked, at the time of the prisoner's earlier case.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, and the case was argued on November 4, 2026. It now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Texas, which lost below, is asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit and block Johnson's renewed claim. If the Court reverses, Johnson's Atkins claim would be barred from proceeding, leaving his death sentence in place unless he has other avenues for relief. If the Court affirms, Johnson's claim would continue toward a decision on the merits in the lower courts, without the Court having decided whether he is in fact intellectually disabled. The Court could also vacate and send the case back for further proceedings without resolving the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Guerrero wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Johnson wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 87%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital case resolving an entrenched 4-circuit split on AEDPA's successive-petition gatekeeping; consequential for habeas practice and death-row litigation, but procedurally technical and of moderate public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.74·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital case with nationwide consequences for AEDPA's successive-petition gateways and federal-state finality interests.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifies the standard for successive habeas petitions under AEDPA, affecting many capital and non-capital prisoners relying on evolving medical or factual standards.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 83%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital case that sets the gate for every successive federal habeas petition under 2244(b)(2)(A) and 2255(h)(2), with the SG and a multistate coalition weighing in; consequential for habeas practice and for Atkins litigants, but technical and unlikely to draw broad public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital case about access to successive habeas review for intellectual-disability claims, with implications for the parallel federal-prisoner gateway. High individual and habeas-system stakes, but a specialized procedural issue rather than a general reconsideration of capital punishment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a circuit split on AEDPA's successive-petition bar, affecting capital habeas litigation and Atkins claims.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to side with Texas and **reverse** the Fifth Circuit, very likely (about 85%), by a 6–3 vote along ideological lines. Federal law lets a prisoner file a second habeas petition (a renewed challenge to the conviction or sentence in federal court) only if it relies on a constitutional rule that was "previously unavailable." The Court will probably hold that the 2002 Atkins ruling was available to Johnson all along. Under that holding, a later change in medical diagnostic manuals does not reopen his intellectual-disability claim.

    Why this big-case score: Capital AEDPA case resolving an acknowledged circuit split on successive-petition gateways; important to habeas practice and Atkins litigation but technical and low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 94%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to overturn the lower court's ruling: I estimate a 94% chance, with reversal by a 6–3 vote the most likely result. The dispute concerns whether a prisoner can bring another federal challenge to his death sentence after medical standards change. The likely majority will say that an existing constitutional rule does not become newly available merely because new medical standards make a claim stronger. This would restrict another hearing, not decide whether Johnson actually has an intellectual disability.

    Why this big-case score: A capital prisoner's access to review of intellectual disability is at stake, and the successive-petition rule also governs other state prisoners and the parallel federal statute; the issue remains a technical collateral-review gateway rather than the validity of the death penalty itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 89%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (89% probability) to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling in *Guerrero v. Johnson* by an expected 7–2 vote. Federal law generally bars state prisoners from filing a second federal habeas corpus petition (a challenge to an unconstitutional conviction or sentence) unless it relies on a new, retroactive Supreme Court constitutional rule that was "previously unavailable." Because the Supreme Court banned executing intellectually disabled prisoners in 2002—years before Dexter Johnson's first federal petition—a clear majority of Justices signaled at oral argument that later changes in medical diagnostic manuals did not make that constitutional rule "previously unavailable."

    Why this big-case score: Resolves an entrenched circuit split over AEDPA's successive-petition bar in 28 U.S.C. 2244(b)(2)(A) and 2255(h)(2), with direct consequences for capital Atkins litigation and federal post-conviction finality.

Quashaun Melsun Reel v. North CarolinaThe Supreme Court declined to hear Quashaun Reel's challenge to a drug search that followed police knocking at his home during a "knock-and-talk" investigation.Criminal lawdecided
0.45
0.60
0.60
0.55

Quashaun Melsun Reel v. North CarolinaNo. 25-1099 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281382 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear Quashaun Reel's challenge to a drug search that followed police knocking at his home during a "knock-and-talk" investigation.

What happened

Police in High Point, North Carolina, visited Reel's home after receiving tips about drug activity, intending to conduct what officers call a "knock-and-talk." An officer followed a visitor to the front door, smelled marijuana when Reel opened it, and after Reel shut the door, officers forced their way in and found drugs. Reel's motion to suppress the evidence was denied. The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed, over a dissent, and the North Carolina Supreme Court affirmed without an opinion.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether officers conduct a Fourth Amendment search when they enter the area immediately around a home to carry out a knock-and-talk investigation with the purpose of gathering evidence against the homeowner, rather than simply to speak with them. Reel's petition says lower courts disagree on how much an officer's purpose matters to this analysis; North Carolina's brief in opposition says there is no such disagreement and that Reel did not raise this purpose argument in the lower courts.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after the state waived and then was asked to respond, and after full briefing including amicus briefs. The Supreme Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Reel, the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the North Carolina courts' rulings. Because the Court denied review, the North Carolina Supreme Court's decision stands, leaving in place the denial of Reel's motion to suppress and his resulting conviction. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning; it simply leaves that outcome undisturbed without deciding the constitutional question Reel raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would set the nationwide rule for a pervasive police practice (knock-and-talks) and clarify Jardines/Collins, so the stakes are real but doctrinal and mid-tier: one criminal suppression case, no headline party, no split of national prominence.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question could materially constrain nationwide police knock-and-talk practices at homes, but this individual suppression case has substantial preservation and fact-bound vehicle concerns.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High profile Fourth Amendment issue regarding implied license and knock-and-talk.

Cohen v. Judicial Conduct Board of PennsylvaniaThe Court declined to hear a former Pennsylvania judge's challenge to his suspension over partisan Facebook posts, leaving his discipline in place.First Amendmentdecided
0.45
0.60
0.60
0.55

Mark B. Cohen v. Judicial Conduct Board of PennsylvaniaNo. 25-1215 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281699 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: First Amendment

The Court declined to hear a former Pennsylvania judge's challenge to his suspension over partisan Facebook posts, leaving his discipline in place.

What happened

Mark Cohen, a Philadelphia judge, kept posting on a personal Facebook page that identified him as a judge and once featured him in his judicial robe. The posts praised Democratic politicians and criticized Republicans. Pennsylvania's Court of Judicial Discipline found this violated the state's judicial conduct code and suspended him without pay for his final three months in office. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court unanimously affirmed, ruling that a more flexible balancing test, rather than the toughest level of First Amendment scrutiny, applied to restrictions on a sitting judge's speech outside an election campaign. Cohen asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether rules limiting what a sitting judge may say must meet the most demanding First Amendment test, the one used for direct restrictions on political speech, rather than a more flexible balancing test weighing a judge's speech interests against the government's interest in an impartial judiciary.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, the Court requested a response from the state judicial conduct board, and both sides filed briefs. The Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Cohen, the judge seeking review, asked the Court to overturn the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's ruling against him. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that ruling in place: Cohen's suspension stands, and the lower court's approach to judges' speech remains the law in Pennsylvania. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Pennsylvania court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision undisturbed without deciding the First Amendment question Cohen raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would fix the First Amendment standard for disciplining sitting judges' off-bench speech in every state; a real doctrinal question for a large professional class, but a niche area with modest public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could define First Amendment protection for sitting judges' noncampaign political speech nationwide, with consequences for judicial independence and ethics enforcement; its direct regulated population is nevertheless specialized.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, would clarify the First Amendment rights of tens of thousands of judges nationwide.

Public Interest Legal Foundation v. NagoA voter-integrity group asks the Court to decide whether federal law requires Hawaii to disclose its statewide voter registration list.awaiting the Court
0.55
0.58
0.52
0.55

Public Interest Legal Foundation, Inc. v. Scott T. Nago, Chief Election Officer of the State of HawaiiNo. 26-98 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000098 · models differ by up to 0.06

A voter-integrity group asks the Court to decide whether federal law requires Hawaii to disclose its statewide voter registration list.

What happened

Public Interest Legal Foundation asked Hawaii's state election office for a copy of the state's full list of registered voters, citing a federal transparency law. The state declined, telling the group to request records separately from each county. The Foundation sued, and a federal district court dismissed the case, finding the claim was not yet ready for review. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed on that point, ruling the Foundation could sue, but it still ruled against the Foundation on the merits, holding that a statewide voter list itself is not the kind of record the federal law requires states to disclose. Other appeals courts have reached the opposite conclusion on this question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law requiring states to make public the records documenting how they maintain accurate voter rolls also requires states to disclose the master statewide list of registered voters itself, or whether that law covers only records about the maintenance process and not the list that process produces.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference, and Hawaii's election officer was asked to respond after initially waiving that right. The response deadline has been extended twice, most recently to November 25, 2026, so the Court has not yet acted on whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The Foundation is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments and decide whether statewide voter lists must be disclosed under this law, deciding the issue for everyone rather than ruling for either side at this stage. If the Court denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, meaning Hawaii would not be required to turn over its statewide list to the Foundation, and the rule allowing states within that circuit to decline such requests remains in effect.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 22, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up the Public Interest Legal Foundation's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The Public Interest Legal Foundation's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably turn down this case, but the chance it agrees to hear it is meaningful: about three in ten. A voter-rights group wants Hawaii's full list of registered voters under a federal law that makes voter-roll maintenance records public. Federal appeals courts disagree on whether that law covers the list itself, and the Court has asked Hawaii to respond. Both are signs of interest. Still, most cases that get that far are refused.

    Why this big-case score: Acknowledged circuit split over whether the NVRA public-inspection provision reaches the statewide voter list itself, a live national fight over voter-roll access; but the statutory question is narrow, and the case is a private records suit, not a constitutional one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than hear it, although review has about a two-in-five chance. The dispute asks whether federal law requires states to let the public inspect statewide voter-registration lists. Appeals courts disagree, and the Supreme Court asked Hawaii to respond after it initially waived a response. Those are meaningful signs of interest, but they do not guarantee review. A refusal to hear the case would leave the lower-court result in place without deciding which interpretation is right nationwide.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of public access to statewide voter rolls affects national election oversight and voter privacy, but the question concerns statutory disclosure rather than the validity of an election or a direct restriction on voting.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will **deny** the petition for review, with about a **one-in-five chance (22%)** that the Court agrees to hear the case. The Public Interest Legal Foundation asks the Court to decide whether the National Voter Registration Act requires Hawaii to release its entire statewide list of registered voters to the public, noting that the Ninth Circuit disagreed with the First Circuit on that question. Although the Supreme Court asked Hawaii to file a response, the Court is still likely to turn the case away because only two federal appeals courts have directly decided this specific statutory issue and other courts have questioned whether the challengers suffered enough concrete harm to sue in federal court.

    Why this big-case score: Nationwide statutory dispute over public and advocacy-group access to computerized statewide voter registration lists under Section 8(i)(1) of the National Voter Registration Act, carrying significant practical consequences for state election administration and voter-roll transparency across covered states.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Acknowledged circuit split on whether the NVRA public-disclosure provision reaches every State's statewide voter list; recurring nationwide election-administration question, with parallel federal enforcement litigation.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring federal election-administration question with nationwide consequences for access to statewide voter files and voter privacy, but not a direct ruling on ballot eligibility or an election result.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would resolve major circuit splits on post-TransUnion informational standing and whether statewide voter registration rolls are subject to mandatory public disclosure under the NVRA.

Congious v. Aaron Ivy ShawChasity Congious asks the Court to hear her case after lower courts ruled that a jail doctor was not liable for failing to prevent her baby's death during childbirth.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.65
0.55
0.55

Chasity Congious, By and Through Her Guardian, Kimberly Hammond, on Behalf of Herself and as Mother and Next Friend of Z. C. H., Deceased v. Aaron Ivy Shaw, DONo. 26-187 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000187 · models differ by up to 0.20

Chasity Congious asks the Court to hear her case after lower courts ruled that a jail doctor was not liable for failing to prevent her baby's death during childbirth.

What happened

Chasity Congious, a pretrial detainee, gave birth alone in her jail cell; her baby was later found unresponsive and died ten days afterward. Congious sued Dr. Aaron Shaw, the jail's medical director, claiming he denied her adequate medical care in violation of her constitutional rights. The district court granted summary judgment to Shaw, finding he lacked personal knowledge that Congious faced a serious risk of harm and was entitled to qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields officials from damages unless they violated clearly established rights. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, agreeing Shaw lacked the required subjective awareness. One judge agreed with the outcome but would have ruled solely on qualified immunity grounds.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide what legal standard applies when a pretrial detainee claims jail officials failed to provide needed medical care: whether the detainee must show the official actually knew of and disregarded the risk of harm, or whether it is enough to show the official should have known of the risk, judged by what a reasonable official would have recognized.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for a conference, after which the Court requested a response from Shaw, which has since been filed. The docket shows no further action since that response was filed.

What each outcome would mean

Congious is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the lower court's ruling for Shaw. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide which legal standard applies, though granting review would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's ruling for Shaw stands, leaving Congious without relief on this claim, though a denial would not mean the Court agreed the lower court was correct.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Congious' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Congious' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn this case down: about a one-in-twenty chance it agrees to hear it. The case asks whether jail officials who deny a pretrial detainee medical care are judged by what they actually knew or by what they should have known, a question on which the federal appeals courts disagree. The Court asked the doctor to respond, which shows some interest. But the doctor also won on a separate legal shield for officials (qualified immunity), which makes this a poor case for settling the disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: The Kingsley medical-care split matters a lot to every jail-conditions suit, but this case is a single fact-bound Section 1983 claim against one jail doctor.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal; I put the chance of review at about one in seven, or 14%. The case raises an important disagreement over how to judge medical care for people awaiting trial, and the Court has asked the doctor to respond. But the doctor may remain protected by qualified immunity, a rule shielding officials when the law was not clearly established. That obstacle makes this a less suitable case for resolving the broader disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: The standard for pretrial detainees' medical-care claims affects jail accountability nationwide; the fatal childbirth and disability context increases the stakes, independently of the petition's vehicle problems.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I predict the Supreme Court will deny review in this case, with an 8% chance of granting the petition (about one in twelve). Although the petition raises an important disagreement among federal appeals courts over whether a pretrial jail detainee suing for inadequate medical care must prove a doctor consciously knew of the risk or only that the doctor acted unreasonably, this case is a flawed vehicle for resolving that question. The lower courts also ruled that the jail medical director is shielded by qualified immunity—a legal doctrine that protects government officials from lawsuits unless they violated clearly established law at the time—which would likely block the lawsuit even if the Supreme Court changed the constitutional standard going forward.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves an entrenched 5-4 circuit split after Kingsley v. Hendrickson on whether pretrial detainee Fourteenth Amendment medical-care claims require subjective or objective deliberate indifference.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If granted and decided, the case would settle a decade-old 4-5 circuit split over whether Kingsley's objective standard governs pretrial detainees' medical-care claims, a rule that reaches every jail in the country; the facts (a detainee giving birth alone in a cell, the newborn dying) are newsworthy. Significant for civil-rights and corrections law, not a term-defining case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question could change the constitutional medical-care standard for pretrial detainees nationwide, affecting jail practices and civil-rights liability. The pregnancy and disability facts intensify the human stakes, but the legal question concerns a defined category of detention claims.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolving a deep circuit split on the standard for pretrial detainees' medical care claims under the Due Process Clause has significant implications for civil rights litigation and jail administration nationwide.

Americans for Citizen Voting - Michigan v. Michigan Board of State CanvassersA ballot petition group asked the Supreme Court to order Michigan officials to place its citizenship-voting initiative on the November ballot; a Justice denied the request.Election lawdecided
0.55
—
—
0.55 1 of 3 models

Americans for Citizen Voting - Michigan, et al. v. Michigan Board of State Canvassers, et al.No. 26A275 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000275 · models differ by up to 0.00 · topic: Election law

A ballot petition group asked the Supreme Court to order Michigan officials to place its citizenship-voting initiative on the November ballot; a Justice denied the request.

What happened

Americans for Citizen Voting – Michigan (ACVM) gathered over 700,000 signatures for a ballot initiative requiring proof of citizenship to vote. Michigan election officials found the petition three signatures short after rejecting several voter affidavits meant to fix disputed signatures, and the Board of State Canvassers deadlocked, keeping the measure off the ballot. ACVM and voter Fred Smith asked the Michigan Supreme Court for a court order (mandamus) forcing certification. That court did not act. With the state's ballot-finalization deadline approaching, ACVM and Smith asked the U.S. Supreme Court for emergency relief ordering Michigan officials to place the petition on the ballot while the appeal continues.

What the Court is being asked

The applicants argue that election officials violated their rights by rejecting sworn voter affidavits without letting them see the comparison signatures used to challenge those affidavits, and by treating similarly situated voters and challenges inconsistently. They ask the Court to order the petition onto the ballot immediately, without waiting for the state courts to rule, given the pending deadline.

Where it stands

Justice Kavanaugh, acting as Circuit Justice, requested a response from Michigan officials, received replies from both sides, and denied the application on September 3, 2026. An amicus brief was also filed the same day.

What each outcome would mean

ACVM and Smith, as applicants, asked the Court to order the petition placed on the ballot while their appeal continued. Granting that request would have required Michigan officials to include the measure on the November 3 ballot on a temporary basis, without deciding the underlying legal claims. Denying it, which is what happened, leaves the Board of State Canvassers' decision keeping the petition off the ballot in effect for this election, while the underlying dispute over the rejected signatures and affidavits can still proceed in the Michigan courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedSep 3, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-03: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A statewide proof-of-citizenship/voter-ID constitutional amendment kept off Michigan's November 2026 ballot draws national election-law attention, but the application turns on a state-law signature-sampling dispute, so the Court's disposition itself is likely a one-line order with modest doctrinal footprint.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.76·Chance the Court grants the application: 13%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns access to a statewide ballot for a voter-identification amendment supported by more than 700,000 submitted signatures.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-09-03: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 7%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A statewide proof-of-citizenship voting amendment backed by 700k+ signatures, decided on the emergency docket days before Michigan's ballot finalizes — high political salience whichever way it resolves.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 10%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-09-03: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 5%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A statewide constitutional-amendment initiative on citizen-only voting and photo ID in a major swing state, on the eve of ballot finalization for the November 2026 general election — nationally salient subject matter and real electoral stakes, though the legal question is procedurally narrow.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Google v. VirtaMoveThe Supreme Court declined to hear Google's challenge to the Patent Office's practice of denying patent review requests based on a patent's age.Intellectual propertydecided
0.55
0.67
0.40
0.54

Google LLC v. VirtaMove, Corp., et al.No. 25-1230 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73265705 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Intellectual property

The Supreme Court declined to hear Google's challenge to the Patent Office's practice of denying patent review requests based on a patent's age.

What happened

Google asked the Patent Office to review two VirtaMove patents it saw as invalid, through a process called inter partes review. The Office refused, citing VirtaMove's "settled expectations" in a patent that had been in force over fourteen years. Google asked the Federal Circuit for a writ of mandamus, an order directing the agency to reconsider without weighing the patent's age. The Federal Circuit denied relief, relying on its recent decisions holding that such challenges to the "settled expectations" factor cannot succeed on mandamus review. Google then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions. First, whether the Patent Office has the legal authority to turn down review requests simply because a patent has been in effect a long time, even though the patent law does not set any age-based cutoff for seeking this kind of review. Second, whether courts have any power at all to check the Patent Office when it denies review for reasons Google says conflict with the statute, or whether that decision is entirely beyond judicial review.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court later asked for a response from the respondents. After the Solicitor General's office and VirtaMove filed briefs opposing review and Google filed a reply, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Google, which lost in the lower court, asked the Supreme Court to take up its case. Because the Court denied the petition, the Federal Circuit's decision stands: the Patent Office's refusal to review VirtaMove's patents remains in place, and Google's mandamus challenge is over. Google may still pursue other avenues, such as arguing patent invalidity as a defense in the ongoing infringement lawsuit VirtaMove brought against it, or separately challenging the Patent Office's policy. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Patent Office's approach; it simply leaves the lower court's ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the PTO may effectively bar inter partes review of patents over six years old, and whether any court can review that policy, reshapes the AIA review system for the whole patent bar and raises a Loper Bright-era agency-discretion question; large for patent and administrative law, modest for the general public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Review could materially affect access to administrative patent-validity challenges across technology and pharmaceutical markets, and the judicial supervision of agency discretion. The dispute has substantial cross-industry stakes but is a specialized patent-procedure case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A challenge to the PTO's non-statutory grounds for denying IPR institution, significant for tech patent litigation but limited by 314(d)'s strong bar on judicial review.

Nexstar Media Group v. DirecTVThe Supreme Court declined to review Nexstar's bid to throw out DirecTV's antitrust lawsuit over blacked-out TV channels during a pricing dispute.Business & financedecided
0.40
0.52
0.70
0.54

Nexstar Media Group, Inc., et al. v. DirecTV, LLCNo. 25-1243 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73287447 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court declined to review Nexstar's bid to throw out DirecTV's antitrust lawsuit over blacked-out TV channels during a pricing dispute.

What happened

DirecTV accused Nexstar and two affiliated broadcasters, Mission and White Knight, of conspiring to demand inflated fees to carry their stations, causing negotiations to collapse and DirecTV subscribers to lose access to those channels. DirecTV sued under federal antitrust law. A district court dismissed the case, ruling DirecTV could not sue because it never paid the allegedly inflated prices. A divided Second Circuit appeals court reversed, holding DirecTV could proceed because it was the sole target of the alleged scheme and had a long history of dealing with the broadcasters. One judge dissented, saying DirecTV's claimed losses were too speculative.

What the Court is being asked

The broadcasters asked the Court to decide whether a company that walks away from a deal, rather than paying an allegedly inflated price, can still sue under antitrust law for the business losses that followed. They argued other appeals courts require someone to have actually paid the inflated price before suing. DirecTV countered that no court has adopted such a strict rule and that the lower court's decision rested on facts specific to this dispute.

Where it stands

The Court considered the petition at conferences in June and September 2026, and after full briefing, denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Nexstar, Mission, and White Knight asked the Court to take up the case and reverse the appeals court's decision. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Second Circuit's ruling in place, meaning DirecTV's lawsuit can continue in the lower courts, where discovery was already underway. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Second Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision standing without the Court deciding the underlying legal question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A doctrinally significant but technical question (non-purchaser antitrust standing, untouched by the Court since AGC in 1983) between two large media companies in a consumer-visible retransmission dispute; moderate stakes, not a marquee case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question affects access to private antitrust damages for buyers priced out by alleged cartels, with implications beyond television retransmission negotiations. Commercial and doctrinal stakes are substantial, but the pleaded course of dealing permits a narrow, fact-dependent resolution.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Moore v. RomeroTwo police officers ask the Court to revive the dismissal of a fatal-shooting lawsuit after an appeals court let part of it proceed.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.35
0.57
0.70
0.54

Donovan Moore, et al. v. Ashly Romero, as Personal Representative for the Estate of Stephen Romero, Deceased, et al.No. 25-1295 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73369985 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Constitutional rights

Two police officers ask the Court to revive the dismissal of a fatal-shooting lawsuit after an appeals court let part of it proceed.

What happened

Officers Donovan Moore and Jeff Kurtz shot and killed Stephen Romero during a domestic-disturbance call after he reached for a holstered gun. His wife, Ashly Romero, sued, claiming excessive force, failure to intervene, and inadequate city training. A federal district court dismissed all claims, ruling the officers had qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields officials from suits unless they violated clearly established rights. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed dismissal of most claims but reversed as to the second round of shots, allowing that part of the excessive-force claim to proceed. The full appeals court declined to rehear the case, over several judges' dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide two things: first, when officers use force in stages during one encounter, whether courts must weigh the reasonableness of each stage by looking at everything that happened before it, from the start of the encounter onward, rather than treating later stages in isolation; and second, whether courts reviewing an early motion to dismiss a case, where video evidence shows the key events, must apply the same legal standard for qualified immunity that would apply later at trial preparation, rather than a standard more favorable to the suing party.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for five separate conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, after full briefing including amicus briefs and a reply. The docket does not yet show a decision on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Officers Moore and Kurtz, who lost the relevant part of the ruling below, are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse it. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions about how to assess multi-stage police shootings and how video evidence should factor into early-stage immunity rulings. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision stands, and Ashly Romero's excessive-force claim over the second round of shots continues in the lower courts; a denial would not mean the Court agrees with that ruling, only that it leaves it in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Moore's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Moore's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 50%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound qualified-immunity / deadly-force case at the pleading stage; meaningful for police-use-of-force doctrine after Barnes v. Felix and for the video-at-12(b)(6) question, but unlikely to produce a broad new rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fatal police shooting with potential nationwide implications for qualified immunity at the pleading stage when body-camera evidence exists. Important to police accountability and officer litigation exposure, but a narrow, fact-specific disposition is more likely than a wholesale doctrinal change.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High stakes due to the frequent issue of police use-of-force, qualified immunity, and body camera evidence, especially post-Barnes v. Felix.

Wealthy v. CorneliaThe Court declined to hear Wealthy's bid to revive its defamation and false-advertising suit against Spencer Cornelia and others over a YouTube anti-SLAPP dismissal.Civil proceduredecided
0.40
0.57
0.65
0.54

Wealthy, Inc., et al. v. Spencer Cornelia, et al.No. 25-1329 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500230 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Civil procedure (also First Amendment)

The Court declined to hear Wealthy's bid to revive its defamation and false-advertising suit against Spencer Cornelia and others over a YouTube anti-SLAPP dismissal.

What happened

Wealthy, Inc. and Dale Buczkowski sued Spencer Cornelia and others over YouTube videos that allegedly made false statements about Buczkowski, including claims about his education, criminal conduct, and a death. A federal district court granted summary judgment against Wealthy, finding it a limited-purpose public figure who could not show actual malice, and denied the defendants' separate motion to dismiss under Nevada's anti-SLAPP law. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the summary judgment but reversed the anti-SLAPP ruling, reviving that motion and triggering a mandatory fee award against Wealthy.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two issues: first, whether state laws that let defendants get early dismissal of speech-related lawsuits, with fee awards against losing plaintiffs, can be applied in federal court at all, and if so, in what form, given that federal courts of appeals have split three ways on the question. Second, whether the appeals court wrongly labeled Wealthy a limited-purpose public figure, a status that raises the bar for proving defamation, without the detailed findings that Supreme Court precedent requires.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after the Court asked for a response from Cornelia and received a reply from Wealthy. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Wealthy asked the Court to take up its case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place: the anti-SLAPP motion stays revived, and Cornelia and the other defendants keep the mandatory fee award that ruling triggered. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning on anti-SLAPP laws or public-figure status; it simply leaves that decision standing without ruling on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would settle whether state anti-SLAPP special motions and their fee-shifting operate in federal court, a recurring Erie/Rules Enabling Act question that shapes media and defamation litigation across circuits; the parties themselves are small online-coaching businesses and YouTube commentators, so the case is important for the doctrine, not for its facts.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on state anti-SLAPP motions in federal court could materially affect speech litigation, forum choice, and fee exposure across many states. These systemic stakes exceed the underlying private dispute; the fact-specific public-figure question is less broadly consequential.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Deep circuit split on application of Shady Grove to state anti-SLAPP statutes; significant impact on federal civil practice.

Tesla v. Granite Vehicle VenturesTesla asks the Court to decide whether courts may review the Patent Office's refusal to reconsider patent challenges it denied based on a timing factor not found in the statute.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.55
0.62
0.45
0.54

Tesla, Inc. v. Granite Vehicle Ventures LLC, et al.No. 26-136 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000136 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Agencies & benefits

Tesla asks the Court to decide whether courts may review the Patent Office's refusal to reconsider patent challenges it denied based on a timing factor not found in the statute.

What happened

Granite Vehicle Ventures sued Tesla for patent infringement. Tesla asked the Patent and Trademark Office to conduct inter partes review, a process for challenging issued patents, of the patents involved. The agency declined, citing the likely timing of the district court trial as a reason, among others. Tesla asked the Federal Circuit for a writ of mandamus, a court order compelling an official to act, arguing the agency had exceeded its statutory authority. The Federal Circuit denied the request, holding that such non-institution decisions are generally not reviewable absent a constitutional claim.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law making the Patent Office's decision not to review a patent "final and nonappealable" also blocks courts from considering a claim that the agency relied on a factor the patent review statute does not authorize, or whether courts may still check that the agency stayed within the limits Congress set.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for December 4, 2026, after being rescheduled from an earlier conference; the docket does not show that the Court has yet acted on it.

What each outcome would mean

Tesla, which lost in the Federal Circuit, is asking the Court to take up its case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case in full and decide whether courts can review this kind of challenge to the Patent Office's reasoning; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Federal Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place the rule that such challenges are generally not reviewable, and Granite Vehicle Ventures' patents remain free from inter partes review on this record. The federal government, representing the Patent Office, opposes Tesla's petition.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Tesla's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Tesla's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Tesla asks the Supreme Court to decide whether courts can review the Patent Office's refusal to reconsider (through "inter partes review") a patent Tesla is accused of infringing. We predict the Court will turn the case away; the chance it takes it is about one in eleven. The government opposes, Tesla came via an emergency-style "mandamus" request that the law makes hard to win, and the Court just declined a nearly identical Google case. A related Intel case is the likelier vehicle if the Court acts.

    Why this big-case score: Reviewability of PTO discretionary IPR denials affects a large share of patent litigation and draws broad industry amici, but the question is technical and statutory.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down Tesla's request, with about an 18% chance of taking some action granting review. Tesla raises an important question about whether judges can check the Patent Office's reasons for refusing patent challenges. But this case reached the Court through an exceptional procedure with a demanding standard, and the federal government opposes review. The apparent second look was only a scheduling change. If related litigation produces a new rule, the Court could instead send Tesla's case back for reconsideration.

    Why this big-case score: Judicial control of patent-review institution policies has substantial nationwide innovation and litigation consequences, although the immediate dispute is technical and procedurally constrained.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely to deny Tesla's petition for review, with only a 6% chance (about one in seventeen) of granting it. Tesla asks the Court to order the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to reconsider its refusal to review three self-driving-vehicle patents that Tesla was sued for infringing. Although outside industry groups filed briefs supporting Tesla, the Supreme Court turned down a nearly identical appeal by Google just two weeks ago, has repeatedly declined similar patent-office challenges in past years, and can leave Tesla to challenge the patents in its ongoing trial-court case and patent-office reexaminations.

    Why this big-case score: Significant patent and administrative-law stakes for the technology and manufacturing sectors regarding PTAB discretionary IPR denials, though presented in a narrow mandamus vehicle.

Calce v. City of New YorkSeveral New York City residents ask the Court to revive their challenge to city and state bans on stun guns and tasers.Firearmsawaiting the Court
0.40
0.66
0.55
0.54

Nunzio Calce, et al. v. City of New York, New York, et al.No. 26-46 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000046 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Firearms

Several New York City residents ask the Court to revive their challenge to city and state bans on stun guns and tasers.

What happened

Nunzio Calce and other individuals, along with two gun-rights groups, sued New York City and its police commissioner, arguing that laws banning possession of stun guns and tasers violate the right to keep and bear arms. One plaintiff, Amanda Kennedy, was herself charged after using a stun gun to fend off an attacker. A federal district court ruled for the city, holding that the plaintiffs had not shown stun guns and tasers are "in common use," a showing it said was required before the challenged bans could even be considered a restriction on constitutionally protected conduct. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether people challenging a ban on a category of weapon must first prove that the weapon is commonly owned before courts will treat the ban as touching on the right to keep and bear arms at all, or whether that common-use question instead belongs to a later part of the analysis, where the government bears the burden. The petition also asks the Court to decide whether stun guns and tasers are covered at all, and whether the city and state bans on them are unconstitutional.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for a conference, after which the Court asked New York City to respond, a request not yet shown as satisfied since the city sought and received an extension of time to respond. No conference has yet considered the case with the city's response in hand.

What each outcome would mean

Calce and the other individuals and organizations are asking the Court to take up their case and reverse the lower court's ruling. If the Court grants review and ultimately rules for Calce, the bans could be struck down or sent back for reconsideration under a more favorable legal standard. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision upholding the bans stands, and the city may continue enforcing them. A grant would not itself decide who is right; it would only mean the Court will hear full arguments on the question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Calce's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Calce's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    New York City and State ban stun guns and tasers, and the challengers ask the Supreme Court to hear their Second Amendment case. We think the Court will most likely set the petition aside until it decides a related weapons-ban case it already agreed to hear (*Viramontes v. Cook County*). It would then either send this case back to the lower court for a fresh look or turn it away. We put the chance that the Court takes some action in the challengers' favor at a little under one in two (46%).

    Why this big-case score: A stun-gun ban is narrow in practical reach, but the first question (whether 'common use' belongs at the textual or the historical step, and who bears the burden there) bears on every arms-ban case; it is overshadowed by Viramontes, which presents the framework in a bigger case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear this challenge to New York's restrictions on stun guns and similar electric weapons. I give the challengers about a one-in-three chance of obtaining review or an order sending the case back for another look. The Court's request for a response and a possible conflict with earlier decisions make intervention plausible. But the lower court emphasized missing evidence, which could make this a poor case for settling the broader constitutional question.

    Why this big-case score: The challenge concerns access to less-lethal defensive weapons and a Second Amendment burden-of-proof question potentially affecting other weapons bans; its direct reach is narrower than a nationwide firearms rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny the petition for review, with a little over a one-in-four chance (28%) of granting it. Petitioners challenge New York State and New York City laws that ban civilians from possessing tasers and stun guns, arguing that the lower courts wrongly required them to prove how many people own those weapons nationwide before applying the Second Amendment. Because the Court is already hearing another Second Amendment case this term (*Viramontes v. Cook County*) raising the same threshold legal question, the likeliest path to a grant is for the Court to hold this petition and later send it back to the lower court for reconsideration (known as a "grant, vacate, and remand"), though the thin factual record presented in the trial court makes an outright denial the most probable result once New York City files its response.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision would resolve a major post-Bruen methodological split over the threshold 'in common use' burden and determine the constitutionality of New York State and New York City's categorical bans on tasers and stun guns, though the broader threshold question is already teed up in Viramontes v. Cook County.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ban on non-lethal arms in the largest US city plus the common-use-at-step-one question that governs every arms-ban case; but the modal resolution is a GVR riding Viramontes/Grant, which would make the case itself procedurally modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The placement of common-use proof within the Second Amendment framework could affect arms-ban litigation nationally, although the immediate dispute concerns electronic weapons and the likely remedy is a narrow remand.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Department of the Interior, et al. v. Shoshone-Bannock Tribes of the Fort Hall Reservation, et al.The federal government asks the Court to revive a land exchange with a fertilizer company that an appeals court blocked as unlawful.Environment, energy & propertyawaiting the Court
0.55
0.64
0.42
0.54

Department of the Interior, et al. v. Shoshone-Bannock Tribes of the Fort Hall Reservation, et al.No. 26-96 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000096 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Environment, energy & property

The federal government asks the Court to revive a land exchange with a fertilizer company that an appeals court blocked as unlawful.

What happened

In 1900, Congress ratified an agreement under which the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes ceded part of their Fort Hall homeland, while reserving the Tribes' right to hunt, fish, and graze there until the land left public ownership. That law said the ceded land could be disposed of only under certain older categories of land law. In 2020 the Bureau of Land Management transferred part of that land to J.R. Simplot Company, a fertilizer producer, to expand a waste storage site, relying instead on a general 1976 public-lands law. The Tribes sued, and a federal district court ruled the transfer unlawful. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, agreeing that the 1900 law's listed categories were exclusive and that the 1976 law did not override them. The government and Simplot are asking the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a later, general public-lands law allows the government to transfer land that an older, specific law said could be disposed of only under certain named categories of land law, none of which include the newer statute.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including an opposition brief and a reply, and amicus briefs were filed supporting the petitioners. The case was distributed for the Court's conference of December 4, 2026, and no decision on whether to hear it has yet been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, joined by Simplot, is asking the Court to take up the case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling that favored the Tribes. If the Court grants review, it will decide the legal question itself, with no party yet favored by that step alone. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision blocking the land transfer stands, leaving the Tribes' win in place. The case also reflects a district court ruling that struck down the transfer on three additional grounds the Ninth Circuit did not address, which would remain regardless of how this specific question is resolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A divided-CA9 public-lands/Indian-law dispute the government says clouds FLPMA disposal authority over 4M+ acres under 35+ turn-of-the-century statutes; major for federal land management and tribal treaty-era rights, modest general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition affects federal control of millions of Western acres and tribal interests, but presents a specialized land-management question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant statutory interpretation case involving federal public lands authority under FLPMA versus historical Indian land acquisition acts.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 66%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably agree to hear this case, about a two-in-three chance. The federal government is asking the Court to decide whether a 1976 public-lands law lets it trade away land an Idaho tribe sold to the United States in 1900. The government wins Court review far more often than other petitioners do, and several appeals judges dissented below. The main obstacles are that no other appeals court disagrees and the lawsuit isn't finished yet. Congress may also settle the dispute through pending legislation.

    Why this big-case score: Federal land-disposal authority over ~4M acres of former reservation land and Indian-law canons; regionally significant, nationally mid-tier.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 79%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I predict the Supreme Court will take this case, with about a four-in-five chance of granting review. The federal government asks whether it can exchange land once owned by the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes despite an older law limiting disposal. The ruling could affect federal land management beyond this property. Review is not certain: other legal obstacles remain, and Congress may approve the exchange itself. If that happens, the Court might erase the lower ruling and return the case rather than hear arguments.

    Why this big-case score: Substantial implications for federal land exchanges, tribal land-use rights, and western development, although the reach beyond the Fort Hall lands is contested.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 67%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to grant review (67% probability, or about a two-in-three chance) in this dispute over whether the federal Bureau of Land Management can swap 713 acres of public land in Idaho—ceded by the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes in 1898—to a fertilizer company under a 1976 federal land-management statute, despite a 1900 law limiting how those lands could be sold. Although the case is at an intermediate stage and Congress is considering a bill that could approve the land swap directly, the U.S. Solicitor General (the federal government's top Supreme Court lawyer) asked the Court to take the case, seven Ninth Circuit appellate judges dissented below, and historical petitions brought by the federal government are granted nearly three-quarters of the time.

    Why this big-case score: Significant statutory question for western public-lands administration under FLPMA and 19th/early-20th century Indian land-cession statutes, with multi-state, mining, and fertilizer industry implications, though primarily affecting western federal land exchanges rather than broad national constitutional law.

Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore Field Office, United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.A man who won his immigration detention case asks the Supreme Court to decide whether he can collect attorney's fees from the government under a federal fee-shifting law.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.45
0.62
—
0.54 2 of 3 models

Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore Field Office, United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.No. 25-1223 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73253921 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Civil procedure (also Immigration)

A man who won his immigration detention case asks the Supreme Court to decide whether he can collect attorney's fees from the government under a federal fee-shifting law.

What happened

Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, held in ICE custody after years on supervised release, won a habeas corpus case in federal district court, which ordered his release because his removal was not likely to happen soon. He later sought attorney's fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), which lets a prevailing party recover fees from the government in "any civil action." The district court denied fees, citing Fourth Circuit precedent holding that a habeas case is not a "civil action" under that law. The Fourth Circuit affirmed. Montoya Palacios asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling, and the government agreed the case was worth taking up because federal appeals courts disagree on the question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law letting winning parties collect attorney's fees from the government in "any civil action" covers lawsuits in which immigration detainees go to court to challenge their detention. The government argues habeas cases are too distinctive to count as ordinary civil actions, while Montoya Palacios argues the law's broad wording and long legal tradition both treat habeas cases as civil actions.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, and the case has been argued and is awaiting decision. Briefing and oral argument are complete; the case was argued on January 11, 2027.

What each outcome would mean

Montoya Palacios, who won his case below, is now asking the Court to reverse the Fourth Circuit's ruling that blocked his fee request. If the Court reverses, he and similarly situated detainees in the Fourth and Fifth Circuits could seek attorney's fees after winning habeas cases against the government. If the Court affirms, the Fourth Circuit's rule stands, and detainees there remain unable to recover fees even after winning release, while the law would still allow fees in other circuits that read it differently. A vacate-and-remand would set the lower ruling aside without deciding the fee question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 11, 2027
  2. Decided

If the Court affirms: the lower court's ruling stands. · If the Court reverses or vacates: the ruling is overturned or sent back.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 65%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A technical fee-shifting question with unusually large practical stakes: it governs access to counsel across tens of thousands of immigration-detention habeas cases filed since 2025, with both the government and multiple circuits calling the split exceptionally important.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 56%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case affects fee eligibility in thousands of federal immigration-habeas matters, though it presents a bounded statutory question rather than a constitutional merits dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 65%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Williams v. PennsylvaniaThe Supreme Court declined to review a Pennsylvania man's challenge to his rape conviction, which rested on DNA evidence obtained from an old warrant and his discarded trash.Criminal lawdecided
0.55
0.65
0.40
0.53

Scott R. Williams v. PennsylvaniaNo. 25-1277 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73331499 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review a Pennsylvania man's challenge to his rape conviction, which rested on DNA evidence obtained from an old warrant and his discarded trash.

What happened

In 1995, police collected DNA evidence from a sexual assault but could not identify a suspect. In 2000, to preserve the case before a deadline expired, they filed a "John Doe" warrant describing the unknown attacker only by generic genetic markers shared by all humans, without attaching an actual DNA profile. Decades later, using a genealogy database and DNA from Scott Williams's mother, police identified Williams as a suspect. Without a warrant, they collected DNA from his son's discarded utensils at a school event and from chew-spit bottles in Williams's trash, then built a DNA profile matching the 1995 evidence. Williams was convicted of rape and aggravated assault. Pennsylvania's courts upheld the conviction, ruling the old warrant was specific enough and that no warrant was needed to test the discarded DNA.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions about police use of DNA. First, whether a warrant naming an unknown suspect only by genetic markers common to everyone, without including his actual DNA profile, is specific enough to satisfy the Constitution's warrant requirements. Second, whether police need a warrant before extracting and analyzing DNA from items a person has thrown away or left behind, including items used by a family member.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Williams asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Pennsylvania courts' rulings. The Court's denial means it will not hear the case, leaving the Pennsylvania Superior Court's decision in place: the warrant was valid, no warrant was needed to test the discarded DNA, and Williams's conviction stands. The denial does not mean the Court agreed that the lower court was right, only that it chose not to review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a ruling on whether police need a warrant to profile shed DNA obtained through genetic genealogy, and on John Doe DNA-warrant particularity, would reshape cold-case investigation nationwide; the stakes are high even though the vehicle is weak.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The warrantless analysis of discarded DNA and relatives' genetic material could affect investigative genealogy and genetic privacy nationwide; the separate John Doe warrant question is narrower. These stakes do not imply likely review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    DNA privacy and John Doe warrants are salient Fourth Amendment issues, though likely not vehicle-ready here.

Goldman Sachs Bank USA v. Rhea Ann BrownThe Supreme Court agreed to decide whether banks can be forced into arbitration over claims they illegally kept demanding payment from bankruptcy filers.Business & financepartly decided
0.40
0.62
0.58
0.53

Goldman Sachs Bank USA, dba Marcus by Goldman Sachs v. Rhea Ann Brown, et al.No. 25-1408 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73520108 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court agreed to decide whether banks can be forced into arbitration over claims they illegally kept demanding payment from bankruptcy filers.

What happened

Rhea Ann Brown and Gregory Kevin Maze each filed for bankruptcy, which under federal law automatically stops creditors from trying to collect old debts. They allege Goldman Sachs Bank kept demanding credit card payments from them anyway, even after being warned. They sued Goldman in bankruptcy court seeking damages under the law protecting debtors from such collection efforts. Goldman asked the court to send the dispute to arbitration instead, citing an arbitration clause in its card agreement. The bankruptcy court, a district court, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals all refused to compel arbitration, finding it would conflict with bankruptcy law's goals.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, and under what circumstances, a bankruptcy court can refuse to enforce an arbitration agreement and instead keep a debtor's damages claim for illegal debt-collection efforts in bankruptcy court rather than sending it to arbitration.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted Goldman's petition for certiorari on November 6, 2026, after the case had been distributed for several conferences. The case will now proceed to full briefing and argument on the merits.

What each outcome would mean

Goldman Sachs, which lost in the lower courts, asked the Supreme Court to take the case and is seeking to overturn the Fourth Circuit's ruling. If the Court ultimately reverses, Goldman's arbitration agreement would be enforced, sending Brown and Maze's claims to arbitration rather than bankruptcy court. If the Court affirms, the Fourth Circuit's decision keeping the dispute in bankruptcy court would stand, and Goldman would have to defend against the claims there. If the Court instead vacates the decision, the case would return to the lower courts without a final ruling on the arbitration question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseNov 6, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Goldman Sachs Bank USA wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Rhea Ann Brown wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-06: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether the FAA yields to the Bankruptcy Code for private automatic-stay damages claims would govern arbitration clauses in essentially every consumer-credit contract across hundreds of thousands of consumer bankruptcies a year, and would be the Court's first word on arbitration in bankruptcy; it is a significant business and consumer-finance case, not a headline constitutional one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The arbitrability of automatic-stay damages claims matters nationally to consumer creditors, debtors, and bankruptcy class actions, but the question is a specialized forum dispute rather than a broad restructuring of bankruptcy rights.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves the intersection of the Bankruptcy Code and the FAA, resolving an arguable circuit split on whether automatic stay violations can be arbitrated; highly significant for consumer finance and bankruptcy practice.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 79%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to rule for Goldman Sachs and reverse the appeals court, about an 80% chance. The issue is whether bankrupt credit-card customers who say Goldman kept trying to collect after they filed for bankruptcy can sue in bankruptcy court, or whether their card agreements force them into private arbitration. The current Court almost always enforces arbitration agreements unless Congress clearly said otherwise, and the bankruptcy law here says nothing clear. We expect a 7-2 vote, with Justices Sotomayor and Jackson dissenting.

    Why this big-case score: Settles a recurring FAA-versus-Bankruptcy-Code conflict affecting consumer debtors and card issuers nationwide; important to practitioners but low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to reverse the lower court by a 6–3 vote. There is about an eight-in-ten chance it changes the ruling in some way. The likely reason is that consumers' claims for money after unlawful bankruptcy debt collection can go to arbitration, a private dispute process they agreed to use, without stripping bankruptcy courts of their own enforcement powers. Complications involving the consumers' revised complaint could instead produce a narrower ruling. The forecast does not decide whether Goldman actually broke the law.

    Why this big-case score: A nationally consequential boundary between consumer bankruptcy enforcement and contractual arbitration, but not a wholesale reconsideration of bankruptcy jurisdiction or the FAA.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 79%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (about a four in five chance, or 79%) to disturb the Fourth Circuit's ruling, most likely by reversing it in a 7–2 vote. In this case, two bankrupt consumers sued Goldman Sachs for continuing to send automated Apple Card collection notices after they filed for bankruptcy, violating the "automatic stay" (a federal law that immediately halts debt-collection efforts during bankruptcy). Although the consumers' credit-card contracts required private arbitration instead of court lawsuits, the lower courts refused to enforce those arbitration clauses. Because the Supreme Court strictly enforces the Federal Arbitration Act unless Congress clearly says otherwise in the statute's text—and the bankruptcy provision allowing consumers to sue for money damages mentions no exception for arbitration—the Court is expected to rule that private damages claims for stay violations must be sent to arbitration when they do not interfere with administering the bankruptcy estate.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a circuit split on the enforceability of arbitration agreements under the FAA for Bankruptcy Code § 362(k) automatic-stay damages claims, affecting consumer lending and bankruptcy administration nationwide.

Southern Company Services v. DrummondSouthern Company asks the Court to review a ruling that pension plans must use reasonable assumptions when calculating certain retirement benefits under federal law.awaiting the Court
0.60
0.45
0.55
0.53

Southern Company Services, Inc., et al. v. William Drummond, et al.No. 26-443 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000443 · models differ by up to 0.15

Southern Company asks the Court to review a ruling that pension plans must use reasonable assumptions when calculating certain retirement benefits under federal law.

What happened

William Drummond and Richard Odom, participants in the Southern Company Pension Plan, sued the company, its pension plan, and its benefits committee, claiming the plan used outdated mortality and interest-rate assumptions that reduced their monthly retirement payments below what federal pension law requires. A district court dismissed their claims, ruling that the law does not require plans to use any particular or reasonable assumptions. The Eleventh Circuit reversed, holding that the law's requirement that two forms of retirement benefit be of equal value implicitly requires reasonable, realistic assumptions, and that Southern Company's benefit calculations could therefore proceed past dismissal.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal pension law provision requiring two forms of retirement payout to be of equal value also requires that the assumptions used in that calculation be reasonable, even though the law's text does not use the word "reasonable" in that provision.

Where it stands

Southern Company filed its petition on September 29, 2026. Drummond and Odom waived their right to respond, but the Court later asked for a response, now due December 18, 2026, after a filing deadline extension. The case has not yet been scheduled for the Court to decide whether to hear it.

What each outcome would mean

Southern Company, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. The petition also asks the Court to hold this case until it rules on two similar pending petitions raising the same question. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether reasonableness is required; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Eleventh Circuit's ruling favoring Drummond and Odom stands, and their lawsuit continues in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 18, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Southern Company Services' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Southern Company Services' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Southern Company asks the Supreme Court to overturn an appeals-court ruling that pension plans must use reasonable, up-to-date assumptions (like life expectancy tables) when converting a retiree's pension into a joint pension that also covers a surviving spouse. Two nearly identical petitions are pending, and the Court asked for responses in all three. We predict this petition will most likely be turned down, but give about a one-in-four chance that the Court takes the issue up in a companion case and then sends this one back for reconsideration.

    Why this big-case score: Whether ERISA's actuarial-equivalence rule for joint-and-survivor annuities implies a reasonableness constraint on assumptions affects defined-benefit plans holding trillions in assets and a wave of class actions; technical, but economically large.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review of this pension dispute; I put the chance of taking action in the company's favor at about one in eight, or 13%. The Court has asked the retirees to respond, showing some interest, but the appeals courts identified in the petition agree on the legal rule. The main alternative is to wait for a related case and then send this one back for reconsideration. The dispute concerns whether pension calculations must use reasonable assumptions.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring national pension-benefit question with meaningful consequences for retirees and plan administration, but a technical statutory dispute rather than a broadly transformative constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Southern Company Services' petition for review, with only about a one-in-fourteen (7%) chance of granting it (including a potential grant, vacate, and remand—an order sending the case back to the lower court—if the Court takes up and reverses a pair of earlier companion cases from the Sixth Circuit). The case asks whether the federal pension law (ERISA) requires employers to use reasonable life-expectancy and interest-rate assumptions when converting a retiree's single-person pension into a joint pension that also covers a surviving spouse. Although the Court asked the retirees to file a response after they initially waived one, both federal appeals courts to decide this question (the Sixth and Eleventh Circuits) agreed that reasonable assumptions are required, leaving no disagreement among the lower courts for the Supreme Court to resolve now.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, resolving whether ERISA § 1055(d)(1)(B) requires 'reasonable' actuarial assumptions when converting single-life annuities into joint-and-survivor annuities would govern defined-benefit pension plans nationwide holding trillions in assets and dozens of pending class actions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pure ERISA statutory question affecting defined-benefit plans with very large aggregate assets and dozens of pending class actions, but technical, low public salience, and this docket is a hold-request companion to the Sixth Circuit petitions rather than the likely lead vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The actuarial-assumptions question could affect defined-benefit pension administration, survivor benefits, and recurring ERISA class actions nationally. Its financial and regulatory stakes are substantial, although the issue is technical and confined to a particular benefit calculation.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine ERISA actuarial equivalence question in a baseline salience case; no apparent broader public significance.

Strulovitch v. BainSamuel Strulovitch asked the Court to pause a New York court order restricting his participation in a religious court proceeding; the Court denied the request.First Amendmentdecided
0.40
0.60
0.60
0.53

Samuel Strulovitch, et al. v. Moshe Bain, et al.No. 26A382 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000382 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

Samuel Strulovitch asked the Court to pause a New York court order restricting his participation in a religious court proceeding; the Court denied the request.

What happened

Strulovitch and Moshe Bain are embroiled in a commercial dispute over ownership of a nursing home. Strulovitch, an Orthodox Jew, brought the dispute to a beis din (a rabbinical court), which later issued a "seruv," a religious censure, against Bain for seeking a court order that blocked Strulovitch from pursuing the matter there. A New York trial court then preliminarily barred Strulovitch from pursuing any proceeding, religious or civil, outside that court, and ordered him to work to have the seruv withdrawn. Strulovitch appealed, but the state appellate court did not rule on his request to pause that order while the appeal proceeded, so he asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

Strulovitch asked a single justice to pause the state court's order while his state court appeal continues, arguing it violates his religious freedom by stopping him from pursuing his case before a religious tribunal and by forcing him to seek withdrawal of a religious ruling he agrees with. Bain opposed the request, and the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty filed a supporting brief.

Where it stands

Justice Sotomayor asked Bain to respond to the application, received that response, and then denied the stay request, without prejudice to Strulovitch seeking relief again if necessary once he has exhausted his remedies in the state courts.

What each outcome would mean

Strulovitch, as the applicant, sought a pause of the state court order while his appeal continues. Had the pause been granted, the restrictions on him would have been lifted temporarily during the appeal. Because it was denied, the state court order restricting his participation in the religious proceeding, and directing him to seek withdrawal of the seruv, remains in effect for now. The denial does not decide the underlying constitutional questions or the appeal itself, and the order notes Strulovitch may seek relief again later if state court remedies are exhausted.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedSep 29, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-29: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court grants the application: 17%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A first-impression clash between a state court's injunctive power and a religious tribunal (beis din/seruv), backed by Becket and the Notre Dame Religious Liberty Clinic; significant to religious-liberty doctrine and the Orthodox community, but a private commercial dispute with no government party and no national policy at stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court grants the application: 38%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The private commercial dispute presents consequential limits on civil-court interference with religious adjudication and compelled religious speech, but the immediate relief is party-specific and interlocutory.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes First Amendment clash regarding church autonomy and state interference with religious tribunals.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-09-29: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court grants the application: 22%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Novel First Amendment question (may a civil court bar a litigant from a religious tribunal and compel him to seek withdrawal of a religious censure) with real reach for religious arbitration, but a private commercial dispute on the interim docket with no election or public-program stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 40%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application raises consequential religious-autonomy and compelled-speech questions about civil control of rabbinical proceedings, but arises from a private ownership dispute and seeks temporary, party-specific relief.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves significant First Amendment free exercise and church autonomy questions regarding civil court interference with religious tribunals.

Yonay v. Paramount PicturesThe heirs of a magazine writer ask the Court to revive their copyright suit claiming Paramount's Top Gun: Maverick copied his 1983 article about Navy fighter pilots.Intellectual propertyawaiting the Court
0.55
0.62
0.42
0.53

Shosh Yonay, et al. v. Paramount Pictures CorporationNo. 26-61 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000061 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Intellectual property

The heirs of a magazine writer ask the Court to revive their copyright suit claiming Paramount's Top Gun: Maverick copied his 1983 article about Navy fighter pilots.

What happened

Shosh and Yuval Yonay, heirs of writer Ehud Yonay, sued Paramount Pictures, arguing that Top Gun: Maverick infringed the copyright in Yonay's magazine article "Top Guns" and that Paramount breached a related contract by not crediting him. A federal district court granted Paramount summary judgment, finding the works not "substantially similar," and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, concluding that what the works share is unprotected facts and ideas, while the article's original expression does not appear in the film. The Ninth Circuit also denied rehearing en banc.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a court may decide on its own, without a jury weighing in on how an ordinary viewer or reader would see the works as a whole, that two works are not similar enough to count as copyright infringement. The petition says this depends on which of two different tests courts use to compare works; Paramount answers that the tests are the same in substance and that no real disagreement among courts exists.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief in opposition and a reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference on December 4, 2026. The docket shows no action since that distribution.

What each outcome would mean

The Yonays, who lost in the lower courts, are asking the Court to take up their case. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear the case in full and decide the legal question; this would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Ninth Circuit's ruling for Paramount stands, and the Yonays' copyright and contract claims remain rejected.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Yonay's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Yonay's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down (deny) this petition from the family of the author whose magazine story inspired *Top Gun*, who say *Top Gun: Maverick* copied it — we put the chance the Court agrees to hear it at about one in twelve. The case raises a real disagreement among appeals courts about how to judge whether two works are too similar, and the Court asked Paramount to respond. But the Ninth Circuit is already reconsidering its own test in another case, so the Justices will probably wait.

    Why this big-case score: A clean, recurring copyright-doctrine question (the Ninth Circuit's extrinsic/intrinsic substantial-similarity test) affecting the circuit that hears most entertainment cases, on a high-profile film; stakes are doctrinal rather than constitutional.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to leave the lower court's ruling in place, with about an 18 percent chance of granting some form of review. The dispute concerns how judges compare creative works when deciding copyright claims involving Top Gun: Maverick. The Court's request for a response and three supporting briefs suggest interest, but do not promise a hearing. The lower court also addressed protection for combinations of creative elements, which may make this case a less clear example of conflicting legal rules.

    Why this big-case score: A potentially important, nationwide copyright-methodology dispute affecting creative works across media, but not a constitutional or government-wide controversy. The famous film raises public visibility without itself making review likely.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny the petition for review in *Shosh Yonay v. Paramount Pictures Corporation*, with only about a one-in-seventeen chance (6%) of agreeing to hear the case. Although the Court asked Paramount to file a response to the petition by the heirs of the journalist whose 1983 magazine article inspired the original *Top Gun* film, the lower courts unanimously concluded that the 2022 sequel *Top Gun: Maverick* shares only unprotectable historical facts about the Navy's real fighter-pilot school and general stock themes rather than any original expression from the article. Once Paramount files its response brief highlighting those factual differences, the Court is expected to deny review without any dissenting opinions.

    Why this big-case score: If granted, a Supreme Court ruling standardizing the substantial-similarity test and summary-judgment filtering across circuits in a high-profile dispute over Top Gun: Maverick would be a major copyright decision for the entertainment and publishing industries, though it lacks constitutional or broad political salience.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Top Gun: Maverick infringement suit with a famous caption, asking the Court to settle the decades-old Ninth/Second Circuit split on the substantial-similarity test that governs nearly every copyright infringement case; a grant would be a major copyright case, though the question is methodological rather than headline-grabbing.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question reaches the substantial-similarity standard across creative industries and the judge-jury allocation in copyright litigation. The Top Gun dispute adds public salience, although the potential holding concerns an infringement methodology rather than ownership of facts or all adaptation rights.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile copyright dispute over the 'Top Gun' franchise sequel; drew three amicus briefs at the petition stage.

Johnson v. United States CongressA veteran asks the Court to revive his suit challenging a federal statute that cut his disability benefits during incarceration.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.45
0.61
—
0.53 2 of 3 models

Floyd D. Johnson v. United States CongressNo. 25-735 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279865 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Agencies & benefits

A veteran asks the Court to revive his suit challenging a federal statute that cut his disability benefits during incarceration.

What happened

Floyd Johnson, an Army veteran, received disability benefits for PTSD connected to his service. A federal law, 38 U.S.C. § 5313, cuts benefits for veterans incarcerated more than 60 days after a felony conviction, and the Department of Veterans Affairs reduced Johnson's payments accordingly. Representing himself while in prison, Johnson sued in federal district court, naming Congress as defendant and arguing the law was unconstitutional. The district court dismissed the case. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit ruled that Congress could not be sued, and that even naming the right defendant would not help: it held that a separate law, the Veterans' Judicial Review Act, requires such constitutional challenges to go through the VA's own appeals system and specialized courts, not ordinary federal district courts.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether that specialized veterans' review system is the only place a veteran can challenge the constitutionality of a benefits statute, or whether veterans may instead bring such challenges directly in a regular federal district court, as this Court had allowed under the review system that existed before 1988.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, and the case was argued on October 5, 2026. It now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

Johnson, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to reverse that ruling. If the Court reverses, Johnson's case would go back to a district court, which could hear his constitutional challenge to the benefits-reduction law directly. If the Court affirms, veterans with similar claims would have to pursue them through the VA's internal appeals board and specialized veterans' courts rather than ordinary federal district courts, and Johnson's suit would remain dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. The Court could also vacate the ruling and send the case back without deciding the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 20, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Johnson wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The United States Congress wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Structurally significant for jurisdiction-channeling doctrine and for millions of veterans' access to district courts, with a broad cross-ideological amicus lineup, but a technical jurisdictional holding rather than a headline constitutional ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case determines the federal forum for facial constitutional challenges to veterans-benefits statutes and resolves an acknowledged circuit conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 25%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a deep circuit split on federal court jurisdiction over constitutional challenges to veterans benefits statutes.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring jurisdictional question governing every veteran's access to district courts, with a broad and ideologically diverse amicus coalition — significant for the veterans' bar and administrative-law watchers, but technical channeling doctrine with little general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 40%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case governs the judicial forum for constitutional challenges affecting veterans nationwide, but presents a specialized jurisdictional question rather than a broadly salient merits controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 64%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Settles where facial constitutional challenges to veterans'-benefits statutes are heard and whether the BVA must decide them; important to a large claimant population but a jurisdictional-channeling question rather than a headline merits ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.61·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case determines access to district courts for constitutional challenges to veterans' benefits statutes and may clarify agency adjudicators' duties, but does not itself decide entitlement to benefits or the validity of the incarceration reduction.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Baltazar v. DaleyThe federal government asks the Court to hear a case involving Warden Baltazar and Eva Daley, arising from a Tenth Circuit decision.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.58
0.55
0.53

Juan Baltazar, Warden, et al. v. Eva DaleyNo. 26-146 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000146 · models differ by up to 0.13

The federal government asks the Court to hear a case involving Warden Baltazar and Eva Daley, arising from a Tenth Circuit decision.

What happened

This case comes from the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, which issued its decision on November 3, 2025, and denied rehearing on April 3, 2026. The petitioners are Warden Juan Baltazar and other government officials, represented by the Solicitor General. The respondent is Eva Daley. The government was granted extra time to prepare its petition, which it then filed on July 30, 2026, asking the Supreme Court to review the Tenth Circuit's ruling. The docket does not describe what the underlying dispute was about or what the lower court decided on the merits.

What the Court is being asked

The record does not include the petition's questions presented or any briefs describing the legal issue, so the specific question the Court is being asked to decide cannot be stated from this docket alone.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the October 9, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked Daley to respond. Daley's deadline to respond has since been extended to November 23, 2026, so the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Baltazar and the other officials, representing the federal government, are asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear the case in full and decide the legal question itself, without yet indicating which side would prevail. If the Court denies the petition, the Tenth Circuit's decision will remain in place, leaving that court's ruling as the final word in the dispute between Baltazar and Daley.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 17, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Baltazar's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Baltazar's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal government asks the Supreme Court to decide whether people who win court challenges to their immigration detention can make the government pay their lawyers' fees under a federal fee-shifting law. A federal appeals court in Denver said yes. We think it is fairly likely — about two chances in three — that the Court agrees to hear the case, because the government is asking, appeals courts disagree on the question, and it comes up in a great many detention cases.

    Why this big-case score: Whether EAJA fees reach immigration-detention habeas governs fee exposure across a very large and growing volume of detention habeas cases; consequential for the government and the immigration bar, but a fee-statute question rather than a question about detention itself.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to hear this case: I put the chance at about four in five, or 78%. It concerns whether people who successfully challenge immigration detention can recover their lawyers' fees from the government. The federal government is asking for review, and lower appeals courts disagree about the governing law. Those features make review more likely than in a typical petition. I expect full briefing and argument, rather than an immediate ruling, although the petition itself was not available in the supplied record.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally consequential access-to-counsel and federal fee-liability issue, but a technical fee question rather than a decision on immigration detention's legality.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will likely grant this petition, vacate the Tenth Circuit's ruling, and send the case back for further review (a 62% probability of a grant, most likely via a summary "grant, vacate, and remand" order). The federal government asks whether a noncitizen who successfully challenges immigration detention through a habeas corpus petition can recover attorney's fees from the United States under the Equal Access to Justice Act. Because the Supreme Court is already reviewing that exact legal question this Term in *Montoya Palacios v. Liggins*, the Court will hold this case until *Montoya Palacios* is decided and then dispose of it to match that ruling.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a multi-circuit split on whether Equal Access to Justice Act fee-shifting under 28 U.S.C. 2412(d)(1)(A) applies to 28 U.S.C. 2241 immigration habeas proceedings, though this petition is a follow-on hold behind the already-granted lead case Montoya Palacios v. Liggins (No. 25-1223).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Federal-government petition from a published Tenth Circuit decision against a federal (immigration-detention) warden; the government's institutional stakes are real, but without the QP text the breadth of the issue is uncertain.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally consequential eligibility for EAJA fees in immigration-detention habeas litigation affects access to counsel and federal litigation costs. The question is narrower than detention authority or the merits of removal, and the underlying individual fee award is modest.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal government petition where the Court has called for a response, suggesting active interest.

Anderson v. Intel Corporation Investment Policy CommitteeFormer Intel employees ask the Court to decide what retirement-plan participants must allege to claim their plan's fiduciaries invested imprudently.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.45
0.56
0.55
0.52

Winston R. Anderson, et al. v. Intel Corporation Investment Policy Committee, et al.No. 25-498 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73278555 · models differ by up to 0.11 · topic: Employment & discrimination

Former Intel employees ask the Court to decide what retirement-plan participants must allege to claim their plan's fiduciaries invested imprudently.

What happened

Former Intel employees who participated in Intel's retirement plans sued the plans' fiduciaries, claiming they violated a federal pension law, ERISA, by investing heavily in hedge funds and private equity starting after the 2008 financial crisis. The employees said these investments underperformed and cost more than comparable options, breaching the fiduciaries' duty to invest prudently. The fiduciaries countered that they adopted a deliberate risk-reduction strategy, fully disclosed to participants, that performed as intended. The district court dismissed the case twice, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that claims based on comparing an investment's performance to other funds require identifying a benchmark fund with similar goals and risks. The employees appealed to the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether employees claiming a retirement-plan fiduciary invested imprudently, based on an investment underperforming other options, must identify a comparably similar fund as a point of comparison in order for their lawsuit to proceed, or whether courts should instead weigh all the allegations in a complaint together without requiring that specific kind of comparison.

Where it stands

The Court granted review, and the case was argued on October 6, 2026. It now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

The employees who sued are asking the Court to overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling, which upheld dismissal of their lawsuit against Intel's plan fiduciaries. If the Court affirms, the dismissal stands and the employees' claims end, with lower courts continuing to require a comparable benchmark fund in similar cases. If the Court reverses, the case would likely return to the lower courts for them to reconsider the employees' allegations under a different standard, without deciding whether the fiduciaries actually acted imprudently. If the Court vacates the ruling, the lower court would reconsider the case without a predetermined outcome for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 20, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Anderson wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The Intel Corporation Investment Policy Committee wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 65%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pleading-standard ruling that will govern the large and growing 401(k)/403(b) fiduciary-breach litigation industry across all circuits; high stakes for plan sponsors and participants, though technical and unlikely to lead general news.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case can set a nationwide pleading rule for ERISA imprudence suits affecting large retirement plans, but it is unlikely to alter fiduciaries' substantive duties broadly.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Important pleading standard for ERISA class actions, but relatively technical rather than broadly newsworthy.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 66%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the pleading standard for the ERISA excessive-fee/underperformance litigation wave against 401(k) fiduciaries — trillions in defined-contribution assets and hundreds of pending suits turn on it, with the SG, DOL, Chamber, ICI, and NAM all filing; high stakes for the benefits industry though modest general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 62%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set the nationwide pleading rule for ERISA imprudence suits involving retirement-plan investment performance.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 75%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 10%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the pleading bar for the large volume of 401(k) underperformance suits, but the question is narrow and both sides concede much of it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 12%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The pleading standard affects retirement-plan participants and fiduciaries nationwide, including suits involving alternative investments, but the question is narrower than the legality of hedge funds or private equity in retirement plans.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 18%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant ERISA pleading precedent governing class-action challenges to 401(k) and defined-contribution retirement plan investment options nationwide, resolving a circuit split on the meaningful-benchmark standard.

Charter Consolidated, Ltd., et al. v. Cape Intermediate Holdings Limited, Individually and as Successor in Interest to Cape Asbestos Company Limited, By and Through Its Receiver Peter D. Protopapas, et al.Companies fighting a court-appointed receiver's authority over a foreign asbestos defendant ask the Court to review whether that authority violates constitutional limits on state power.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.60
0.60
0.35
0.52

Charter Consolidated, Ltd., et al. v. Cape Intermediate Holdings Limited, Individually and as Successor in Interest to Cape Asbestos Company Limited, By and Through Its Receiver Peter D. Protopapas, et al.No. 26-328 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000328 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Civil procedure

Companies fighting a court-appointed receiver's authority over a foreign asbestos defendant ask the Court to review whether that authority violates constitutional limits on state power.

What happened

John and Margaret Tibbs sued numerous companies in South Carolina state court over Mr. Tibbs's lung cancer, which they attributed to asbestos exposure. One defendant, Cape Intermediate Holdings Limited (CIHL), an English company, did not appear, and a court-appointed receiver answered and pursued claims on CIHL's behalf against Charter Consolidated and other companies, alleging they were CIHL's alter egos. Charter Consolidated and the others challenged the receiver's authority and personal jurisdiction over them. The South Carolina Supreme Court upheld the receivership, as modified, and rejected the challenges. A British court had separately enjoined the receiver from acting for CIHL.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether constitutional limits on state power prevent a state court's receiver from making litigation and other internal decisions for a corporation based outside the state when the place where that corporation is organized has not recognized the receiver's authority.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for a November 6, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked the respondents for a response; the respondents' deadline to file that response has since been extended to December 28, 2026, and the case has not yet been scheduled for another conference.

What each outcome would mean

Charter Consolidated and the other companies are asking the Court to take up the case and overturn the South Carolina ruling. If the Court grants review, it will decide the constitutional question in a full case; a grant decides nothing about who ultimately wins. If the Court denies review, the South Carolina Supreme Court's decision upholding the receiver's authority over CIHL stands, and the receiver's claims against Charter Consolidated and the others may continue in the South Carolina courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesResponse due Dec 28, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would decide whether one state's court-appointed receiver can run an out-of-state (here English) corporation's litigation over its board's objection and a foreign court's injunction: significant for asbestos mass-tort practice, corporate federalism and international comity, but niche to a single South Carolina docket and unlikely to make front pages.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition raises consequential limits on state receivers' control of foreign corporations, with implications for asbestos litigation, corporate governance, and international judicial comity. Significant business and federalism stakes, but a specialized procedural dispute rather than a broadly transformative public-policy case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves state court extraterritorial reach and mass tort liability evasion, but ultimately a fact-bound equitable receivership dispute.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will probably turn down this case, though the chance it takes it up is real: about one in four. The case asks whether a South Carolina court can appoint a "receiver" (a court-chosen manager) to run lawsuits for an English company. A federal appeals court rejected that same practice in a separate case. The Court asked the other side to respond, and parties in the conflicting federal case are also asking for review. Those are signs of interest. But this case is still mid-trial, which makes it a less attractive one to take.

    Why this big-case score: A constitutional limit on state-court receiverships over out-of-state and foreign corporations, with a split against the Third Circuit, two companion petitions from that circuit, and recurring asbestos-litigation stakes; significant but specialized.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down this appeal, with about an 18% chance it agrees to review it. The dispute asks whether a South Carolina court can put someone in charge of litigation decisions for an English company. The request for a response and support from outside groups suggest genuine interest. But the challenged order is narrower than the challengers suggest, and unresolved procedural questions could prevent review. A decision is most likely after further briefing, rather than at the originally scheduled November conference.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially significant limits on state-court control of foreign corporations, with cross-border insurance and asbestos-litigation consequences, but a specialized receivership dispute rather than a broadly applicable individual-rights case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny this petition for review, with only a 6% chance (about one in seventeen) of granting it. Although the Court asked the respondents to file a response after three outside groups supported the petitioners, the case has severe procedural flaws: the state court's ruling is an interim decision that sends the case back for trial rather than a final judgment, the petitioners are third-party defendants trying to assert the rights of an absent English company that refused to appear in court, and the Supreme Court already turned down a nearly identical challenge to South Carolina's asbestos receivership law earlier in 2026.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, a ruling on the territorial and Due Process limits of state-court pre-judgment receiverships over out-of-state corporations would carry meaningful commercial and mass-tort significance, though primarily confined to specialized corporate-governance and receivership litigation.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A state-court/federal-circuit split on whether a state court may install a receiver to run an out-of-state (here foreign) corporation's litigation; it touches over a dozen South Carolina asbestos receiverships and a U.K. court's contrary injunction, but the doctrine is specialized and low-salience outside mass-tort practice.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially important limits on state receiverships over foreign corporations, with recurring asbestos-insurance consequences and international corporate-governance implications, but narrower than a broadly transformative constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Cross-border corporate receivership dispute involving the internal affairs doctrine and an English High Court anti-suit injunction, though posture is interlocutory and fact-bound.

Gays Against Groomers v. GarciaAn advocacy group and individuals ask the Court to revive their lawsuit against Colorado legislators over public-hearing speech rules the legislators say are protected by legislative immunity.awaiting the Court
0.35
0.64
0.55
0.51

Gays Against Groomers, et al. v. Lorena Garcia, Individually and as a Colorado State Representative, et al.No. 26-120 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000120 · models differ by up to 0.29

An advocacy group and individuals ask the Court to revive their lawsuit against Colorado legislators over public-hearing speech rules the legislators say are protected by legislative immunity.

What happened

Gays Against Groomers, Rocky Mountain Women's Network, and two individuals testified against a bill at Colorado legislative committee hearings. Committee rules barred "misgendering" or "deadnaming" witnesses, and petitioners say they were cut off, removed, or had testimony erased from the record for violating these rules. They sued the legislators, individually and in their official roles, claiming First Amendment violations. The district court dismissed the case, holding the legislators had legislative immunity. The Tenth Circuit affirmed, ruling that immunity covers both individual- and official-capacity suits and covers both adopting and enforcing the rules.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether legislative immunity, a protection historically meant to shield lawmakers personally from liability, can also be used as a defense when a lawsuit is aimed at the governing body itself through claims against officials in their official roles. It is also asked whether immunity covers not just writing rules but also enforcing them against individual speakers.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a reply, and was distributed for conference twice, most recently for November 13, 2026. No order granting or denying the petition is recorded yet.

What each outcome would mean

Gays Against Groomers and the other petitioners are asking the Court to reverse the Tenth Circuit's ruling in favor of Garcia and the other Colorado legislators. If the Court grants cert, it would hear full arguments on whether legislative immunity applies here and decide the question itself; a grant would not by itself indicate who wins. If the Court denies cert, the Tenth Circuit's decision stands, leaving the case dismissed and the legislators' immunity from this lawsuit intact.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Gays Against Groomers' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Gays Against Groomers' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely **decline** to hear this case. We put the chance it takes the case at about one in eight. Activists say Colorado legislators cut off their public testimony for "misgendering" a bill's namesake. The lower court held that the legislators are shielded from suit by "legislative immunity," a protection for lawmakers' official work. An earlier Supreme Court ruling already applied that shield to court orders as well as money damages. The disagreement between lower courts is also shallow. Some Justices may still write separately criticizing a refusal.

    Why this big-case score: Scope of state legislative immunity against official-capacity equitable claims plus a viewpoint-based public-comment rule on transgender speech; doctrinally meaningful and politically salient, but confined to legislative hearing procedure.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case, with about a one-in-five chance of taking it up. The dispute asks whether lawmakers can be sued to stop restrictions on public testimony, or whether protections for legislative work prevent that lawsuit. Four outside groups support review, and the free-speech concerns are significant. But the disagreement among lower courts is contested, and the latest scheduling change does not show that the Justices have already debated the case and asked to consider it again.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of immunity for restrictions on public testimony has substantial nationwide free-speech implications, but the immediate dispute concerns state legislative committee procedures.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny review in this case, with about a one-in-ten chance of agreeing to hear it. The challengers—advocacy groups and individuals who were cut off during Colorado state legislative hearings for refusing to use a transgender person's preferred name and pronouns—ask the Court to rule that "legislative immunity" (a legal protection that shields lawmakers from being sued over their lawmaking duties) does not block lawsuits seeking a court order against enforcing public-comment speech rules. Although the free-speech issue is prominent, the federal appeals court unanimously agreed that longstanding Supreme Court precedent protects state lawmakers from federal lawsuits over how they run their own committee hearings, and there is no real disagreement among the federal appeals courts on that rule for state legislators.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, the case would define whether federal courts may enjoin state legislative committee chairs' enforcement of public-comment speech and pronoun rules under the First Amendment and Ex parte Young.

Scanlan v. Coalition for Open DemocracyNew Hampshire election officials asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court order requiring revised guidance on student IDs before the general election, and the Court granted the pause.Election lawdecided
0.35
0.64
0.55
0.51

David M. Scanlan, Secretary of State of New Hampshire, et al. v. Coalition for Open DemocracyNo. 26A512 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000512 · models differ by up to 0.29 · topic: Election law

New Hampshire election officials asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court order requiring revised guidance on student IDs before the general election, and the Court granted the pause.

What happened

New Hampshire's HB 323 removed student IDs from the list of identification a voter can use to get a ballot, but left in place separate "safety valve" provisions allowing election officials to consider other evidence of identity. A group called the Coalition for Open Democracy sued, arguing that the Secretary of State's guidance went further than the law itself by telling officials not to consider student IDs at all. A federal district court agreed in part, enjoining that guidance weeks before the November election and ordering the Secretary to issue revised instructions. The First Circuit twice declined to pause that order while the state's appeal continued.

What the Court is being asked

The state asked the Court to pause the lower court's order while appeals continue, arguing that courts should not change election rules close to an election and that the district court misread state law. The Coalition answered that no statute was enjoined, only an executive directive that went beyond the law, and that the injunction simply held officials to the state's own description of its rules.

Where it stands

The Court granted the stay application on October 22, 2026, pausing the district court's October 2 and October 5 orders while the appeal proceeds in the First Circuit and while any further Supreme Court review is sought. Justice Jackson dissented.

What each outcome would mean

The state election officials sought this pause, and the Coalition for Open Democracy opposed it. The grant means the district court's injunction is paused: the Secretary's earlier guidance excluding student IDs remains in effect for now, rather than the revised guidance the district court had ordered. The pause is temporary and does not decide who is right; it lasts until the appeal is resolved or, if the state seeks Supreme Court review after that, until that review ends. Had the application been denied, the district court's injunction would have stayed in effect while the appeal continued.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 22, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesGrantedOct 22, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-22: the Court granted the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 33%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    State voter-ID guidance weeks before a general election under Purcell: real election-administration stakes and a live Purcell question, but the injunction is narrow (guidance on considering student IDs as non-dispositive evidence) and turns on state-law interpretation in one state.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court grants the application: 64%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Statewide voter-identification guidance immediately before a federal general election implicates student voting access and the reach of election-timing restraints, although this application need not settle the underlying constitutional challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 22%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Emergency Purcell election-law stay application by New Hampshire state officials regarding student ID voter verification ahead of the November 2026 general election, though narrow in scope because the statute itself (HB 323) was upheld and only an executive guidance sentence on discretionary safety-valve review was enjoined.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-22: the Court granted the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 42%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A state voter-ID administration dispute weeks before a general election that tests how far Purcell reaches a narrow, already-complied-with guidance injunction; significant to New Hampshire and to election-stay doctrine, but not a national question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.59·Chance the Court grants the application: 70%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Statewide voter-identification procedures affecting student voters shortly before a general election have substantial practical and constitutional stakes, although the immediate question is temporary relief rather than a nationwide merits ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court grants the application: 58%·Prediction: grant itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Emergency pre-election stay application by New Hampshire's Secretary of State and Attorney General challenging a federal district court's October 5 preliminary injunction altering voter-ID verification guidance 29 days before the November 3, 2026 general election, testing the reach of the Purcell principle where a district court enjoins administrative election guidance rather than the underlying statute.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-22: the Court granted the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 36%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A state election-administration stay two weeks before a general election, on student-ID use under a statutory safety valve; real but state-confined stakes, with Purcell-doctrine interest beyond New Hampshire.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court grants the application: 41%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Statewide voter-identification rules immediately before a federal general election affect student access to the ballot and the reach of Purcell, but the application concerns a narrow New Hampshire guidance rule rather than a nationwide remedy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Emergency election-law stay application by New Hampshire's Secretary of State invoking Purcell ahead of the 2026 midterm election, though substantively confined to a narrow executive gloss on a state statutory voter-ID safety valve rather than the underlying voter-ID statute.

Eric Alan Isaacson v. National Veterans Legal Services ProgramA class-action objector asks the Court to rule that judges may not award payments to class representatives for their work leading a lawsuit.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.35
0.58
0.60
0.51

Eric Alan Isaacson v. National Veterans Legal Services Program, et al.No. 26-302 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000302 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Civil procedure

A class-action objector asks the Court to rule that judges may not award payments to class representatives for their work leading a lawsuit.

What happened

Three nonprofit organizations sued the federal government over PACER court-record fees and eventually settled for $125 million. The settlement included $10,000 payments to each of the three organizations for their work leading the case. Eric Alan Isaacson, a class member who objected, argued these payments were unlawful. The district court approved the settlement and payments, and the Federal Circuit affirmed, joining several other circuits that allow such payments while disagreeing with the Eleventh Circuit, which has barred them.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether judges overseeing class-action settlements may approve payments to the people who served as lead plaintiffs, rewarding them for their work running the case, when no statute or formal court rule specifically authorizes such payments. Isaacson argues old Supreme Court precedent forbids this; the organizations and lower courts say that precedent does not apply to modern class actions.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed: the respondents filed a brief opposing review on November 12, 2026, after receiving two extensions of time. The docket shows no further action since then, and the case has not been scheduled for a conference in this record.

What each outcome would mean

Isaacson, the objector, is asking the Court to reverse the Federal Circuit's decision upholding the payments. If the Court grants review and ultimately rules for Isaacson, such payments could be barred or restricted in class actions nationwide. If it rules for the organizations, or simply denies review, the Federal Circuit's decision approving the settlement and the $10,000 payments would stand, leaving the current circuit split unresolved either way review is denied.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Eric Alan Isaacson's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Eric Alan Isaacson's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether Greenough/Pettus bar class-representative incentive awards touches nearly every common-fund class settlement, but the dollar stakes per case are small and public salience is low; a practitioner-important, not headline, case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether class representatives may receive common-fund service awards affects class-action settlements nationally. The legal stakes exceed these three $10,000 payments, but the question is a bounded civil-procedure issue rather than the legality of PACER fees or the entire $125 million recovery.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying litigation is the major PACER fee class action, and the circuit split over incentive awards is a highly watched issue for class-action practitioners.

Wagner v. United StatesKyle Wagner asked the Supreme Court to pause a federal appeals court's order detaining him before trial while he pursued further review; the Court denied that request.Criminal lawdecided
0.30
0.62
0.60
0.51

Kyle Wagner v. United StatesNo. 26A446 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000446 · models differ by up to 0.32 · topic: Criminal law

Kyle Wagner asked the Supreme Court to pause a federal appeals court's order detaining him before trial while he pursued further review; the Court denied that request.

What happened

Kyle Wagner was charged with cyberstalking and making interstate threats after online exchanges connected to protests against immigration enforcement in Minneapolis. A magistrate judge ordered him detained, but a district court later released him on conditions, including limits on internet use and movement. The government appealed, and a divided panel of the Sixth Circuit reversed, ruling that Wagner should be detained pending trial. Wagner asked the Sixth Circuit to pause that ruling while he sought Supreme Court review; it refused. He then asked the Supreme Court to pause the ruling and, separately, filed a petition asking the Court to take up his case.

What the Court is being asked

Wagner asked the Court to pause his detention while his broader appeal moves forward. The underlying dispute is about how closely appeals courts should examine a trial judge's decision to release or detain someone before trial: whether appeals courts must largely accept the trial judge's judgment, or may instead reexamine the evidence themselves and reach their own conclusion.

Where it stands

A single justice asked the government to respond to Wagner's request, and after receiving a response and reply, referred the application to the full Court. The Court denied the request for a pause.

What each outcome would mean

Wagner, the applicant, asked the Court to pause the Sixth Circuit's order detaining him while his case continued. Had the Court granted the pause, Wagner would have been released under the district court's conditions while his petition for review proceeded. By denying it, the Court leaves the Sixth Circuit's ruling in effect, meaning Wagner remains detained pending trial. This order does not decide the broader legal question Wagner raised or resolve his separate petition asking the Court to hear his case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court grants the application: 12%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question is a forty-year, acknowledged 5-4-3 circuit split on the standard of appellate review for Bail Reform Act detention orders, bearing on tens of thousands of bail determinations a year, and the applicant is a politically charged defendant detained largely on the basis of anti-ICE speech; the application itself resolves only a procedural stay, which tempers the score.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court grants the application: 20%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An individual detention dispute presents a potentially nationwide appellate-review rule under the Bail Reform Act, with substantial liberty and political-speech stakes; the immediate stay remains case-specific.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court grants the application: 5%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine criminal stay application without obvious nationwide implications.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question is a forty-year, acknowledged 5-4-3 circuit split on the standard of appellate review for Bail Reform Act detention orders, recurring across tens of thousands of hearings a year, with a politically salient speech-and-ICE backdrop; the application itself resolves in a one-line emergency order, which caps the stakes of this event.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court grants the application: 27%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns individual pretrial liberty, but the appellate-review question could affect federal detention decisions nationwide. The speech-related dangerousness allegations add public significance; the immediate stay remains case-specific.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court grants the application: 12%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Politically charged facts (anti-ICE speech, a self-described Antifa member detained pretrial) draw attention, but the legal question is a technical appellate standard-of-review issue under the Bail Reform Act, and a stay ruling is interim and non-precedential.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court grants the application: 18%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pretrial liberty and appellate review of federal bail decisions have national procedural significance; the disputed treatment of political speech adds public importance, although this application directly concerns one defendant's release.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 25%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile First Amendment/cyberstalking context, but standard of review for bail is an important recurring procedural issue.

Caryn Devins Strickland v. MoritzA former federal public defender asks the Court to revive her claim that the judiciary's internal process for handling her sexual harassment complaint violated her constitutional rights.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.45
0.63
0.42
0.50

Caryn Devins Strickland v. Nancy L. Moritz, Judge, In Her Official Capacity as Chair of the Judicial Conference Committee on Judicial Resources, et al.No. 25-1303 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73377829 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Employment & discrimination

A former federal public defender asks the Court to revive her claim that the judiciary's internal process for handling her sexual harassment complaint violated her constitutional rights.

What happened

Caryn Strickland worked for the Federal Public Defender's Office in the Western District of North Carolina. She alleged her supervisor sexually harassed her and that the judiciary's response, carried out under an internal Employment Dispute Resolution (EDR) Plan rather than under Title VII (the law barring workplace discrimination for most other employees), violated her due process and equal protection rights. After a six-day trial, the district court ruled against her, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed. Strickland asked for rehearing, which was denied for lack of a quorum after Fourth Circuit judges recused themselves.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution allows the judicial branch to resolve its own employees' harassment and discrimination claims through an internal process, instead of extending them the protections Congress gave other workers under Title VII. The Court is also asked whether a law directing the judiciary to study applying Title VII-type protections to its own employees means the judiciary's internal process must match Title VII's substantive protections.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a brief opposing review from the federal respondents and a reply from Strickland. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it.

What each outcome would mean

Strickland is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the Fourth Circuit's ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the constitutional and statutory questions itself, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fourth Circuit's decision rejecting Strickland's claims stands, and the judiciary's internal EDR process continues to govern such disputes rather than Title VII.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Caryn Devins Strickland's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Caryn Devins Strickland's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case, putting the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in twenty. Caryn Strickland, a former federal public defender, argues that the courts' internal complaint system for their own employees' harassment and discrimination claims is unconstitutionally unfair. The Court did ask the government to respond, which shows some interest. But no appeals courts disagree on the question, and the case turns on facts settled at trial, so the Justices will probably decline it.

    Why this big-case score: A constitutional challenge to how the federal judiciary handles its own employees' harassment claims; institutionally sensitive and closely watched, but a fact-bound post-trial record with no circuit split.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review, with about an eight-in-a-hundred chance of taking the case or otherwise granting relief. Strickland challenges how the federal judiciary handles employees' discrimination and sexual-harassment complaints. The Court's request for a response shows some interest, and the workplace-accountability issues matter beyond her case. But the petition does not demonstrate a clear disagreement among appeals courts, and parts of its broader challenge were not properly raised below. I expect another conference listing followed by denial, probably without an explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The adequacy of remedies for discrimination and sexual harassment throughout the federal judiciary has substantial institutional and workplace significance, even though this petition has important vehicle limitations and a low chance of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in this case, with only a 4% chance (about one in twenty-five) of granting the petition. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response to the former federal public defender employee's challenge to the judiciary's internal workplace harassment process, the lower courts rejected her claims based on detailed factual findings after a six-day trial. Crucially, there is no disagreement among federal appeals courts on this issue, the 2013 workplace plan she challenges has since been replaced, and the appeals court ruled that she waited too long—five years into the lawsuit—to raise her main argument about being excluded from Title VII (the primary federal workplace anti-discrimination law).

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, a ruling on whether the Fifth Amendment and Congressional Accountability Act require Title VII-equivalent protections and external review for federal judiciary employees under circuit EDR Plans would carry notable institutional significance for judicial branch governance, though limited doctrinal reach beyond federal judiciary employment.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional challenge to the federal judiciary's internal employment-dispute system for its ~30,000 employees: institutionally sensitive and watched by court-reform advocates, but fact-bound to one employee's post-trial record and with no circuit split.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns nationwide constitutional safeguards and remedies for federal judicial employees facing workplace discrimination, with substantial implications for judicial accountability. Its institutional significance exceeds its grant prospects; factual and preservation barriers constrain this vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Direct constitutional challenge to the federal judiciary's own Employment Dispute Resolution plan regarding sexual harassment, drawing high-profile amici.

Moylan v. Guam Society of Obstetrician and GynecologistsGuam's Attorney General asks the Court to revive his bid to lift a decades-old injunction against Guam's abortion law after the Ninth Circuit called the case moot.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.30
0.65
0.55
0.50

Douglas B. Moylan, Attorney General of Guam v. Guam Society of Obstetrician and Gynecologists, et al.No. 26-22 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000022 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Civil procedure (also Constitutional rights)

Guam's Attorney General asks the Court to revive his bid to lift a decades-old injunction against Guam's abortion law after the Ninth Circuit called the case moot.

What happened

In 1990, a federal court permanently blocked enforcement of a Guam law restricting abortion, based on Roe v. Wade. After the Supreme Court overruled Roe in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, Guam's Attorney General, Douglas Moylan, asked the district court to lift the injunction, arguing its legal basis was gone. The district court refused, and while his appeal was pending, the Supreme Court of Guam separately ruled that the underlying law had already been repealed by later legislation. Relying on that ruling, the Ninth Circuit dismissed Moylan's appeal as moot without deciding whether the injunction could survive Dobbs. The Ninth Circuit later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal appeals court may declare a case moot, and so avoid deciding it, when the challenge is to an ongoing court order that was based entirely on a legal rule the Supreme Court has since discarded.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court then asked the respondents to respond rather than acting on it. Several respondents have since received extensions, with their response now due in late November 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Moylan, as petitioner, asks the Court to take up the case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's mootness ruling. If the Court grants review and later rules for Moylan, the courts would have to decide whether the old injunction can still stand after Dobbs. If it rules for the respondents, who include the Guam Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Dr. William Freeman, and Guam's Governor, the Ninth Circuit's dismissal would stand and the injunction's fate would not be reexamined through this case. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision remains in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 24, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Moylan's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Moylan's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Guam's Attorney General wants the Supreme Court to take up a 1990 federal court order that blocked Guam's abortion ban under Roe v. Wade, which the Court has since overruled. The appeals court threw out his challenge as moot (no longer a live dispute) because Guam's own top court had ruled the ban was already repealed. We think the Court will most likely refuse the case: about a one-in-eight chance it acts. If it does act, it would more likely send the case back with brief instructions than hear full argument.

    Why this big-case score: A Roe-era abortion injunction draws attention, but the Supreme Court of Guam has already held the statute impliedly repealed, so the practical stakes are mostly symbolic and procedural (mootness / Rule 60(b)(5)).

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I estimate about a one-in-eight chance that it intervenes. Guam's attorney general wants an old abortion-related court order removed after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. But Guam's highest court separately ruled that the underlying abortion law had been repealed. Removing the federal order would therefore not, by itself, let the attorney general enforce that law. The request for a response shows interest, but does not overcome this practical obstacle.

    Why this big-case score: Abortion access in Guam and the treatment of longstanding federal injunctions give this dispute substantial stakes, although territorial repeal limits its immediate practical reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If granted, the case would address how federal courts handle Rule 60(b)(5) motions to vacate decades-old Roe-era injunctions after Dobbs and the interplay between federal equity, Article III mootness, and local implied-repeal doctrine, though its broader doctrinal reach is cabined by the territory-specific history of Guam P.L. 20-134.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Abortion-adjacent and Dobbs-cleanup framing gives it press salience, but the live question is mootness of a Rule 60(b)(5) appeal where the territory's highest court says the enjoined statute no longer exists, so a decision either way changes nothing on the ground in Guam and sets at most a narrow procedural rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Post-Dobbs abortion enforcement and the survival of longstanding federal injunctions raise substantial stakes, but the territorial implied-repeal ruling limits this vehicle's practical reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗
Blanche v. OzurumbaThe federal government asked the Supreme Court to review a Fourth Circuit ruling in a case involving Izuchukwu Ozurumba, and the Court agreed to hear it.partly decided
0.42
0.58
—
0.50 2 of 3 models

Todd Blanche, Attorney General v. Izuchukwu Ozurumbascotus/73500246 · models differ by up to 0.16

The federal government asked the Supreme Court to review a Fourth Circuit ruling in a case involving Izuchukwu Ozurumba, and the Court agreed to hear it.

What happened

This case comes from the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which issued its decision on September 2, 2025, and denied rehearing on December 30, 2025. The Attorney General, representing the federal government, petitioned the Supreme Court to review that decision. The respondent is Izuchukwu Ozurumba. The record provided does not include the petition's statement of the questions presented or the underlying facts of the dispute, so the specific legal issue and what the lower court decided and why are not described here.

What the Court is being asked

The docket snapshot does not include the questions presented document or other filings describing the substance of the dispute, so the specific legal question the Court agreed to decide cannot be stated from this record.

Where it stands

The Court granted the government's petition for certiorari on October 13, 2026, after the case was distributed for conference twice, in September and October 2026. The case has not yet been argued; the government has since filed motions related to merits briefing, including a request to dispense with a joint appendix and a request for an extension of time.

What each outcome would mean

The federal government, as petitioner, is asking the Court to overturn the Fourth Circuit's decision, which favored Ozurumba. If the Court affirms, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands and Ozurumba's position prevails. If the Court reverses, the federal government's position prevails instead, and the outcome below is undone. If the Court vacates, it would set aside the Fourth Circuit's decision and send the case back for further proceedings without deciding the dispute in either party's favor.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseOct 13, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Blanche wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Ozurumba wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Scope of the INA material-support bar (whether 'material' carries a significance threshold, and the fate of Chevron-era circuit precedent like Barahona after Loper Bright) recurs across thousands of asylum cases; significant in immigration law, not a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of the immigration material-support bar affects asylum and withholding eligibility nationwide, including people forced to assist armed groups. Significant immigration and national-security stakes, but a bounded statutory question rather than a general constitutional challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 85%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Circuit split on 'material support' bar for terrorism affecting asylum seekers; significant immigration and national security implications.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 79%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the reach of the INA terrorism-related inadmissibility bar, which screens a large volume of asylum and withholding claims from conflict zones; doctrinally important to immigration practice but low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of the terrorism-related immigration bar has serious consequences for asylum seekers coerced into ordinary labor and for national-security screening, but the granted question concerns a bounded statutory nexus rather than immigration authority generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Appears to be a standard statutory interpretation case involving the federal government; no indication of exceptional public stakes.

Parker-Hannifin v. JohnsonParker-Hannifin asks the Court to review whether a retirement-plan lawsuit alleging imprudent investment choices must point to a comparable fund as evidence.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.58
0.45
0.49

Parker-Hannifin Corporation, et al. v. Michael D. Johnson, et al.scotus/72483503 · models differ by up to 0.13

Parker-Hannifin asks the Court to review whether a retirement-plan lawsuit alleging imprudent investment choices must point to a comparable fund as evidence.

What happened

Five employees who participate in Parker-Hannifin's retirement savings plan sued the company and related plan committees, claiming they violated federal pension law by keeping a set of target-date retirement funds that underperformed other funds and by using higher-cost share classes when cheaper, identical versions were available. A district court dismissed the lawsuit, ruling the employees had not identified a comparable fund that could show the company acted imprudently. A divided panel of the Sixth Circuit reversed, holding that such a comparison is not always required and that, in any event, the employees had pointed to one. One judge dissented, saying the ruling conflicts with other appeals courts.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an employee who claims a retirement plan manager imprudently kept a poor-performing investment must show that the investment used for comparison shared similar goals, risks, and strategies with the challenged fund, or whether looser comparisons can support such a claim.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference multiple times, and the Court invited the Solicitor General to weigh in; the government's brief, filed in December 2025, recommended granting review. Both sides then filed supplemental briefs, and the case was distributed again for a conference in January 2026, with no decision yet recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Parker-Hannifin, the company and plan committees sued by the employees, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the lower court's decision. If the Court grants review and later rules for Parker-Hannifin, the employees' claim about the underperforming funds would likely be dismissed again, requiring more specific comparisons in future ERISA suits. If the Court rules for the employees instead, the Sixth Circuit's decision allowing the claim to proceed would stand. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's ruling permitting the lawsuit to continue remains in effect, and the case returns to the lower courts for further proceedings, including on a separate fee-related claim that was not part of this petition.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Parker-Hannifin's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Parker-Hannifin's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: take the caseused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely than not, a little better than even, to agree to hear this case about what workers must allege to sue their employer over poorly performing retirement-plan investments. The lower court's own dissenting judge said the ruling conflicts with other appeals courts, and the Justices asked the federal government's top appellate lawyer, the Solicitor General, for advice, which they do only for petitions they take seriously. The case's early procedural stage could still lead the Court to decline.

    Why this big-case score: Pleading standard for ERISA imprudent-investment suits against 401(k) fiduciaries: large practical stakes for plan sponsors and the plaintiffs' bar, but technical and of limited general newsworthiness.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I narrowly expect the Supreme Court to decline review, putting the chance of review or an order sending the case back at 46%—a little below one in two. The dispute concerns what workers must explain before suing over allegedly poor retirement-plan investments. The Court's request for the federal government's advice signals serious interest, and other appeals courts appear to demand stronger comparisons. But this lawsuit has additional allegations and a separate claim that could make it a less suitable vehicle. The government's recommendation is not yet in the supplied record.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring ERISA pleading question with substantial retirement-plan and litigation consequences, but narrower public significance than a major constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is modestly more likely than not to deny Parker-Hannifin's request for review, with about a two-in-five (38%) chance of taking the case. Although the Court asked the Solicitor General (the federal government's top appellate lawyer) for advice on whether retirement-plan lawsuits under ERISA (the federal employee-benefits law) must compare challenged investments to similar benchmarks, Justice Alito's recusal leaves an eight-Justice bench, another claim involving the same funds will proceed below regardless, and the lower court relied partly on case-specific facts.

    Why this big-case score: A merits ruling on ERISA's 'meaningful benchmark' pleading standard would govern motion-to-dismiss screening across hundreds of 401(k) target-date-fund class actions nationwide, matching Hughes and Cunningham in commercial significance though lacking broad constitutional salience.

Wassily v. BlancheTwo immigrants whose asylum status was terminated after criminal convictions ask the Court to decide whether they can still seek lawful permanent residence under a federal adjustment-of-status law.Immigrationawaiting the Court
0.30
0.58
0.60
0.49

Tamer S. Wassily, et al. v. Todd Blanche, Attorney GeneralNo. 25-842 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280343 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Immigration

Two immigrants whose asylum status was terminated after criminal convictions ask the Court to decide whether they can still seek lawful permanent residence under a federal adjustment-of-status law.

What happened

Tamer Wassily and Byron Velasquez Arreaga were each granted asylum years ago, then had that status terminated after criminal convictions. Both sought to adjust to lawful permanent resident status under a federal law allowing the government to adjust "the status of any alien granted asylum." Immigration judges and the Board of Immigration Appeals disagreed about whether termination of asylum status forecloses this path, ultimately ruling against both men. The Second Circuit consolidated their cases and held, over a dissent, that only noncitizens with current asylum status may adjust to permanent residence. The court denied their petitions for review, and the full Second Circuit declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a noncitizen who was once granted asylum, but whose asylum was later terminated, can still apply for lawful permanent residence under the relevant statute, or whether termination permanently forecloses that path. The Solicitor General's office, representing the government, has told the Court it agrees with petitioners that the courts of appeals are split on this question and that review is warranted, while still defending the Second Circuit's interpretation as correct on the merits.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, the case was briefed and argued, and it was fully briefed through a reply brief filed in early November 2026. The docket does not yet show a decision.

What each outcome would mean

Wassily and Velasquez Arreaga, who petitioned the Court after losing below, are asking the Court to reverse the Second Circuit's ruling that barred them from seeking permanent residence. If the Court affirms, the Second Circuit's rule stands: noncitizens whose asylum has been terminated remain categorically ineligible to adjust to permanent resident status, and Wassily and Velasquez Arreaga's removal proceedings would continue on that basis. If the Court reverses, former asylees like petitioners could still apply for permanent residence despite termination, with eligibility and final approval remaining subject to immigration officials' discretion. A ruling to vacate would send the case back without resolving the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Nov 30, 2026
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Wassily wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Blanche wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 74%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean statutory circuit split with real stakes for terminated asylees and their derivative spouses and children, sharpened by the current wave of asylum terminations, but technical adjustment-of-status doctrine rather than a headline constitutional or structural question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 67%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide immigration-eligibility rule affecting former asylees is consequential, though the case presents a technical statutory question rather than a constitutional one.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 42%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean statutory split on a recurring but narrow immigration-adjustment question affecting former asylees with terminated status; consequential for that class, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 57%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally applicable rule governing permanent-residence eligibility after asylum termination, with serious consequences for affected refugees and potentially derivative asylees, but a bounded statutory question rather than a wholesale redesign of asylum law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a circuit split on the eligibility of former asylees to adjust status, impacting a defined but important class of noncitizens.

Sigalovskaya v. BradenKarina Sigalovskaya asks the Court to revive her damages lawsuit against a federal agent, claiming the agent fabricated evidence to justify arresting her without a warrant.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.45
0.63
0.40
0.49

Karina Sigalovskaya v. Abigail Braden, Individually and in Her Official Capacity as a Special Agent for the Department of Homeland SecurityNo. 25-1250 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73298285 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Constitutional rights

Karina Sigalovskaya asks the Court to revive her damages lawsuit against a federal agent, claiming the agent fabricated evidence to justify arresting her without a warrant.

What happened

Sigalovskaya alleges that Homeland Security Investigations agents entered her home without a warrant in 2013, searched it, and separated her from her children while looking for her husband. She says Special Agent Abigail Braden then falsely claimed Sigalovskaya had confessed to a crime and forwarded that claim to prosecutors, leading to her arrest and three weeks of detention before charges were dropped. She sued Braden and other agents for damages under a Supreme Court precedent, Bivens, that allows such suits in limited circumstances. The district court dismissed her remaining claims, and a divided Second Circuit panel affirmed, with each judge writing a separate opinion offering different reasoning.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether its precedent allowing damages suits against federal officers for certain constitutional violations extends to a claim that an officer fabricated evidence to justify an arrest made without a warrant, and whether the existence of some other complaint process for misconduct by itself prevents such a suit from going forward even where the claim otherwise closely resembles one the Court has already approved.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, was the subject of a request for the government's response, and has since been fully briefed, including a reply from Sigalovskaya filed in September 2026. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Sigalovskaya is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the Second Circuit's decision, which went against her. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether her damages claim can proceed and would decide the legal question itself; a grant would not by itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, leaving Sigalovskaya's claim against Braden dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Sigalovskaya's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Sigalovskaya's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided on the merits it would settle whether Bivens survives on its own facts and how the new-context test works, a significant civil-rights question; but the likely path is a quiet denial, and even a GVR would be a narrow procedural event.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions implicate the nationwide availability of damages for unconstitutional federal arrests and the survival of established Bivens remedies, although the surviving claim and fractured decision below limit this vehicle's reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Mizrahi v. United StatesA man convicted of money laundering asks the Court to require juries, not judges, to decide facts that set the amount of criminal forfeiture.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.45
0.57
0.45
0.49

Martin Mizrahi v. United StatesNo. 25-1238 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73272491 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: Criminal law

A man convicted of money laundering asks the Court to require juries, not judges, to decide facts that set the amount of criminal forfeiture.

What happened

Martin Mizrahi was convicted at trial of fraud, money laundering, and related crimes for helping two other men convert fraud and drug-trafficking proceeds into Bitcoin. At sentencing, the trial judge, rather than the jury, found by a preponderance of the evidence that Mizrahi had laundered $4,545,704 in proceeds and ordered that amount forfeited. Mizrahi argued the Constitution required a jury to find those facts beyond a reasonable doubt. The Second Circuit affirmed, following a 1995 Supreme Court decision, Libretti, that forfeiture facts need not go to a jury, and the Second Circuit denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether its 1995 ruling that forfeiture amounts need not be decided by a jury should be overturned, in light of later rulings requiring juries to find facts that increase a defendant's punishment, including fines. Mizrahi argues forfeiture is really a fine and should get the same jury-trial protection. The government responds that forfeiture has no capped statutory maximum, so those later rulings do not apply, and that every appeals court to consider the issue agrees with that view.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including an amicus brief from former federal judges and others supporting review, and was distributed for the justices' conference on November 13, 2026. The docket does not yet show a decision on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Mizrahi is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether juries must decide the facts underlying criminal forfeiture, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling stands, leaving in place the forfeiture order against Mizrahi and the current rule that judges, not juries, may find those facts by a lower standard of proof.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Mizrahi's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Mizrahi's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Martin Mizrahi's request to hear his case. We put the chance it takes the case at about 7%, or roughly one in fourteen. He asks the Court to overrule a 1995 decision that lets a judge, rather than a jury, decide how much money a convicted defendant must forfeit (give up to the government). The Court did ask the government to respond, which shows some interest. But it has refused this same request about a dozen times, and every appeals court follows the 1995 rule. One Justice, most likely Justice Gorsuch, may write separately objecting to the refusal.

    Why this big-case score: Overruling Libretti would require jury findings in thousands of federal forfeiture orders a year and extend the Apprendi line; it is a recurring, institutionally significant question, though it does not carry headline salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline to hear Martin Mizrahi's appeal, with about a one-in-five chance that it agrees to review the case. He argues that a jury, rather than a judge, should decide the facts supporting the criminal forfeiture of his property. The Court's request for a government response and support from outside legal groups make the petition worth watching. But lower courts agree on the existing rule, and changing the Supreme Court's older precedent remains a substantial hurdle.

    Why this big-case score: Reconsidering the constitutional jury right in criminal forfeiture could change federal sentencing procedure nationwide, although the issue is narrower than a general restriction on asset forfeiture.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Martin Mizrahi v. United States*, with only about a 4.5% (roughly one in twenty-two) chance of granting the petition. Mizrahi asks the Court to overturn its 1995 precedent in *Libretti v. United States* and hold that the Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial requires a jury, rather than a judge, to find the facts supporting a $4.5 million criminal asset forfeiture order. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response after the government initially waived its right to respond, there is no disagreement among the federal appeals courts on this issue, the Court has repeatedly turned down the same question in prior terms, and the fact-specific summary order from the Second Circuit makes this case an unattractive vehicle for reconsidering a major sentencing precedent.

    Why this big-case score: Overruling Libretti v. United States (1995) to extend Apprendi and Southern Union to criminal forfeiture would transform federal criminal sentencing and forfeiture procedure nationwide under Rule 32.2, though the case has low public salience as a routine fraud and money-laundering prosecution.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Overruling Libretti would extend Apprendi to every federal criminal forfeiture order — broad practical reach across white-collar and drug sentencing, though a narrow doctrinal question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Reconsidering the constitutional jury-finding rule for criminal forfeiture could change federal sentencing practice nationally. The stakes extend beyond this defendant's monetary judgment, although the issue is specialized rather than a broad political controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
John David Trice v. TexasThe Supreme Court declined to review a Texas prisoner's challenge to his conviction under a state law letting juries convict of continuous child sexual abuse without agreeing on specific incidents.Criminal lawdecided
0.50
0.57
0.40
0.49

John David Trice v. TexasNo. 25-1195 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281702 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review a Texas prisoner's challenge to his conviction under a state law letting juries convict of continuous child sexual abuse without agreeing on specific incidents.

What happened

John David Trice was convicted in Texas state court of continuous sexual abuse of a child and other offenses, receiving a 40-year sentence. Texas law allows a jury to convict of continuous sexual abuse if it unanimously agrees the defendant committed two or more qualifying acts over 30 days, without agreeing on which specific acts occurred. Trice argued this violates the right to a unanimous jury verdict. The Texas Court of Appeals rejected this argument and affirmed his conviction, and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals refused further review. Trice then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law allowing jurors to convict of a continuing pattern of child sexual abuse, without all agreeing on which specific incidents took place, violates a defendant's constitutional right to a unanimous jury verdict.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and Texas filed a brief opposing review after initially waiving its right to respond. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Trice, the prisoner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Texas appeals court's ruling against him. The denial means the Court will not hear the case, leaving the Texas court's decision in place: Trice's conviction and sentence stand, and the state law's approach to jury unanimity in continuous sexual abuse cases remains unchanged in Texas. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling would settle whether continuous-sexual-abuse statutes in Texas and roughly nine other states, which let jurors disagree on the predicate acts, survive Ramos; that reaches thousands of long sentences, though the question is a specialist one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The constitutional limits on dispensing with agreement about predicate criminal acts affect Texas continuous-abuse prosecutions and analogous statutes in other states, with implications for jury rights and lengthy sentences. Significant criminal-procedure stakes, not a prediction of broad public attention or a high grant probability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Jack Rabbit v. VisaJack Rabbit asks the Court to review whether courts may direct a fixed antitrust settlement fund to be shared with people no court has found entitled to recover.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.62
0.55
0.49

Jack Rabbit, LLC v. Visa Inc., et al.No. 26-420 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000420 · models differ by up to 0.32

Jack Rabbit asks the Court to review whether courts may direct a fixed antitrust settlement fund to be shared with people no court has found entitled to recover.

What happened

This case grows out of a $5.6 billion settlement of antitrust claims that merchants accepted Visa and Mastercard cards and paid inflated fees. Jack Rabbit, a settlement class member, objected to a 2024 order letting millions of sub-merchants who use payment facilitators like Square also share in the fund. The district court and the Second Circuit found the settling parties intended to include these sub-merchants, but both courts said they were not deciding whether the sub-merchants actually have valid antitrust claims. Jack Rabbit appealed that approval and lost, then sought Supreme Court review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a court may order a fixed fund, created to pay people with valid antitrust claims, to be shared with people no court has determined are legally entitled to recover, simply because the settling companies meant to include them. It is also asked whether an appeals court may approve that kind of order while expressly declining to decide if those added people have any valid claim at all.

Where it stands

Visa and Mastercard have both waived their right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will consider whether to take it up.

What each outcome would mean

Jack Rabbit, the objecting class member, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the lower court's approval. If the Court grants review and ultimately agrees with Jack Rabbit, courts would have to determine that added claimants are legally entitled to recover before letting them share the fund, which could reduce or delay payments to the sub-merchants. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's approval stands, and the fund distribution to the sub-merchants, already underway, can continue unchanged.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Jack Rabbit's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Jack Rabbit's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely turn down (deny) this petition, about a 1-in-80 chance of review. A merchant that objected to how the $5.6 billion Visa/Mastercard card-fee settlement is being divided wants the Court to stop the money from also going to millions of small businesses that took card payments through payment processors. Both card companies didn't bother filing a response. The lower court treated the dispute as a question of what the settlement contract meant, in a short non-precedential ruling. And a related case the petition leaned on was already turned down in October.

    Why this big-case score: Allocation of a $5.6B interchange-fee settlement fund touches millions of merchants, but the question as decided below is contract interpretation of one settlement; the broader uninjured-class-member issue is the stake the petition borrows.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review: I give the petition about a three-in-one-hundred chance of being accepted, including a possible order sending it back for reconsideration. The dispute affects how a $5.6 billion card-fee settlement is divided among merchants. Although it raises important questions about who may receive class-action payments, the lower court treated it as interpretation of an existing settlement, making it an awkward vehicle for a broader ruling. I expect no further conference listing or separate judicial statement.

    Why this big-case score: Allocation of a $5.6 billion merchant settlement has substantial commercial stakes; a ruling on injury and statutory eligibility in settlement classes could affect class actions nationally, although this vehicle concerns a specialized settlement-enforcement order.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Jack Rabbit, LLC v. Visa Inc.* (a 1% chance of a grant, or 1 in 100). The petitioner, a single gas-station business objecting to how a $5.6 billion credit-card fee class-action settlement is administered, asks the Court to decide whether merchants who processed card payments through intermediaries like Square can be included in the settlement class without first proving they had a valid antitrust claim. However, the lower court issued only an unpublished summary order that never addressed this constitutional argument, the class settlement itself became final years ago, and all opposing parties waived their right to respond without any outside groups filing friend-of-the-court briefs in support.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, a ruling on Article III and Rule 23 limits on settlement-class membership and claims administration in the $5.6 billion Payment Card Interchange Fee MDL would have significant commercial and class-action impact, moderated by the case's idiosyncratic post-judgment contract-enforcement posture.

Amazon Logistics v. ClintonAmazon asks the Court to review a ruling that its California delivery drivers are exempt from arbitration agreements because some goods they deliver once crossed state lines.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.54
0.45
0.48

Amazon Logistics, Inc., et al. v. Dirk Clinton, et al.No. 26-47 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000047 · models differ by up to 0.09 · topic: Business & finance

Amazon asks the Court to review a ruling that its California delivery drivers are exempt from arbitration agreements because some goods they deliver once crossed state lines.

What happened

Delivery drivers who worked for Amazon Flex sued, claiming Amazon misclassified them as independent contractors rather than employees. Amazon sought to compel arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act, but the drivers argued they fell under an exemption for transportation workers "engaged in interstate commerce." California trial and appellate courts agreed with the drivers, ruling that because many delivered goods originated outside California, the drivers qualified for the exemption, regardless of how long goods sat in local warehouses or whether they were locally stocked groceries. The California Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a local delivery driver counts as engaged in interstate commerce, and therefore free from having to arbitrate disputes, simply because some delivered goods earlier crossed state lines, even when there was a lengthy break in the goods' journey or the goods were locally stocked items.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, after which the Court requested a response from the drivers. The drivers have since received two extensions of time, with their response now due November 16, 2026. No further action has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Amazon, which lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments on whether the drivers must arbitrate their claims rather than sue in court. If it denies the petition, the California Court of Appeal's ruling exempting the drivers from arbitration stands, and the drivers' lawsuit continues. Amazon separately asks that, even without full review, the Court send the case back for reconsideration in light of a more recent decision.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 16, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Amazon Logistics' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Amazon Logistics' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Amazon asks the Supreme Court to review a California ruling that its Amazon Flex delivery drivers are exempt from the federal law that enforces arbitration agreements. We think the Court will most likely turn the case away. There is roughly a one-in-four chance of some form of grant, most likely an order sending the case back to the California court to reconsider in light of the Supreme Court's 2026 *Flowers Foods v. Brock* decision. The Court's request that the drivers respond to the petition shows real interest. But *Brock* largely sided with the drivers' position, so the lower court's ruling may already fit it.

    Why this big-case score: FAA Section 1 scope for app-based last-mile delivery drivers recurs nationally and touches large worker classes, but the Court decided Flowers Foods v. Brock months ago and this asks a fact-bound follow-on.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.54·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely than not to decline Amazon's appeal, but I give it about a 38% chance of granting some relief. Amazon argues that local delivery drivers should not be exempt from mandatory arbitration simply because their goods once crossed state lines. The Court's request for a response shows interest. Still, its recent ruling does not clearly undermine the California decision. If it intervenes, it will probably send the case back for reconsideration rather than hear full arguments.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring nationwide arbitration-exemption question affecting last-mile delivery workers and a major employer, but a technical statutory dispute with an unpublished, fact-dependent decision below.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Amazon's request to hear this case, with only about a one-in-seventeen (6%) chance of granting review. Amazon asks the Court to decide whether California local delivery drivers in its Amazon Flex program are exempt from the Federal Arbitration Act—a federal law that generally requires workers to resolve disputes through private arbitration rather than lawsuits—because the packages and groceries they deliver sit in California warehouses or stores before customers order them. Although the Court asked the drivers to file a response to Amazon's petition, the Court unanimously ruled in *Flowers Foods v. Brock* in May 2026 that local delivery drivers can qualify for this exemption without crossing state lines, and it has repeatedly declined to review similar Ninth Circuit rulings, making this unpublished state-court decision an unlikely candidate for review.

    Why this big-case score: A decision resolving whether in-state warehouse storage or local grocery delivery removes last-mile gig-economy drivers from the FAA Section 1 exemption would have substantial commercial impact across e-commerce and delivery platforms, though as an incremental statutory follow-on to Flowers Foods v. Brock.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We forecast that the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Amazon's appeal, but the chance it does something is about three in ten. Amazon argues that a California court wrongly ruled its local delivery drivers exempt from arbitration. The California court ruled before the Justices decided a closely related case, *Flowers Foods v. Brock*, earlier this year. Because the Court asked the drivers to respond, its likeliest favorable move is to send the case back for the California court to reconsider in light of that new decision, rather than hear full argument.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring FAA Section 1 last-mile question that reaches a very large class of gig and delivery workers, but it follows a fresh merits decision (Brock) and comes up from an unpublished state intermediate-court opinion.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Amazon's request to review whether its local delivery drivers must resolve workplace disputes through private arbitration rather than in court. I put the chance of Supreme Court intervention at 28%, a little over one in four. The Court requested a response, and a recent related decision could justify sending the case back for reconsideration. But that decision does not clearly favor Amazon, and differences among delivery arrangements make immediate full review less attractive.

    Why this big-case score: The arbitration rights of a large delivery workforce and the boundary between interstate shipping and local retail delivery are economically consequential, but the question is a bounded statutory issue and could end in a routine remand.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Amazon's petition for review (a 94% chance of denial, and a 6% chance of a grant or remand). Amazon asks the Court to overturn a California appellate decision holding that local Amazon Flex delivery drivers are interstate transportation workers exempt from mandatory arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act. Although the Court requested a response from the drivers, the Court just unanimously ruled in May 2026 in *Flowers Foods v. Brock* that intrastate delivery drivers can qualify for this exemption, and every federal appeals court to consider Amazon Flex package drivers has agreed they are exempt.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, defining when warehouse storage or local retail fulfillment breaks interstate transit under FAA Section 1 would affect last-mile and gig-economy arbitration nationwide, though its incremental doctrinal stakes are moderated by four recent unanimous Supreme Court Section 1 decisions culminating in Flowers Foods v. Brock (2026).

Aldridge v. Regions BankThe Court declined to hear former Ruby Tuesday managers' bid to recover lost retirement benefits from Regions Bank under a federal benefits law.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.35
0.58
0.50
0.48

Jerry Aldridge, et al. v. Regions BankNo. 25-590 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279035 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear former Ruby Tuesday managers' bid to recover lost retirement benefits from Regions Bank under a federal benefits law.

What happened

Jerry Aldridge and other former Ruby Tuesday managers participated in company retirement plans for highly compensated employees, funded through a trust that Regions Bank administered. After Ruby Tuesday was sold and later went bankrupt, the managers say Regions failed to protect their benefits as required, costing them millions. They sued Regions under a federal retirement-benefits law, seeking money to replace lost benefits, and also brought state-law claims. The district court ruled against them on all claims, and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the type of relief they sought was not available under the federal law and that the law barred their state-law claims.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises two questions about a federal law governing employee retirement plans. First, whether a plan beneficiary may recover a particular form of compensation, called surcharge, from the bank managing their plan under a provision allowing "equitable" relief, or whether that compensation instead counts as an ordinary damages award, which the law does not permit under that provision. Second, if that compensation is unavailable, whether the federal law still blocks beneficiaries from pursuing related claims under state contract law, potentially leaving them without any remedy at all.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court invited the Solicitor General to weigh in on the government's views, which it did. The Court then denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The managers, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case and reverse the Sixth Circuit's ruling in Regions Bank's favor. The denial leaves that ruling in place: the managers cannot pursue their claim for compensation under the federal benefits law, nor their state-law claims, and they recover nothing further in this case. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Sixth Circuit's reasoning, including on the recovery question, which the government's brief said the lower court got wrong; it simply leaves that decision standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring ERISA remedies question (whether make-whole surcharge is ever available under 502(a)(3)) that governs millions of plan participants and an acknowledged circuit split, but technical, low general-public salience, and arising on an unusual top-hat/rabbi-trust record that would limit a decision's reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The availability of surcharge under ERISA has national significance for benefit-plan remedies and an acknowledged circuit conflict. The top-hat-plan and rabbi-trust posture limits this vehicle's reach; the stakes exceed its likelihood of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 75%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An ERISA case resolving a circuit split on the availability of surcharge as an equitable remedy; important to practitioners but moderate broader public salience.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A real, acknowledged circuit conflict over whether surcharge is 'appropriate equitable relief' under ERISA 502(a)(3) matters to the ERISA bar, but the top-hat/rabbi-trust posture would confine any decision and the preemption question is routine.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The surcharge question could materially affect remedies across ERISA plans nationwide, but this case's top-hat plan, separate trust, and unresolved liability issues may limit the reach of any decision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarification of ERISA remedies is significant for practitioners and affects many beneficiaries, but lacks broad political stakes.

Robinhood Markets v. SodhaThe Court agreed to hear Robinhood's challenge to a ruling that let investors pursue claims over financial information left out of its 2021 IPO documents.Business & financepartly decided
0.40
0.58
0.45
0.48

Robinhood Markets, Inc., et al. v. Vinod Sodha, et al.No. 25-944 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73280982 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Business & finance

The Court agreed to hear Robinhood's challenge to a ruling that let investors pursue claims over financial information left out of its 2021 IPO documents.

What happened

Investors sued Robinhood and its IPO underwriters, claiming the company's offering documents omitted interim second-quarter financial data showing a business slowdown, making earlier statements about strong growth misleading. A district court dismissed the suit, applying a rule requiring the omitted data to show an "extreme departure" from historical results before disclosure was required. The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding that ordinary materiality—not an extreme-departure showing—governs whether such omissions must be disclosed, and separately ruled on related disclosure requirements under SEC regulations. Robinhood asked the Supreme Court to review both rulings.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a company can be held responsible for a misleading registration statement just by showing that left-out financial information was significant to investors, or whether courts must also separately ask whether leaving it out actually made some specific statement in the documents misleading.

Where it stands

The Court asked the federal government for its views; the government recommended granting review on a reformulated version of the question and denying review of a second question Robinhood raised about separate disclosure rules. The Court granted the petition, limited to the question about materiality and misleading omissions.

What each outcome would mean

Robinhood, which lost on this issue in the lower court, asked the Court to take up the case and is seeking to overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling. If the Court ultimately sides with Robinhood, investors would need to separately prove that any omitted information made a specific statement misleading, not just that the information was significant, making the investors' claims harder to sustain. If the Court instead sides with the investors, the Ninth Circuit's more investor-friendly standard would stand, and the case would continue under that rule. The case has not yet been argued or decided on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTook the caseNov 13, 2026

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Robinhood Markets wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Sodha wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 5 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Section 11 strict-liability scope for interim financial data touches every IPO and periodic filing; SEC, Chamber/SIFMA engaged, but the question is technical securities doctrine rather than a headline constitutional issue.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of Section 11 omission liability affects IPO disclosures and securities litigation nationwide; this is consequential commercial law rather than a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Major Securities Act Section 11(a) case on IPO disclosure of intra-quarter financial data following Macquarie, affecting public offerings across capital markets without raising constitutional questions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 84%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court will very likely (about 84%) agree to hear Robinhood's appeal. Investors are suing Robinhood over its 2021 stock offering for leaving out early sales figures. The Court asked the federal government's top lawyer, the Solicitor General, for views. The government said the Court should take the first question: whether leaving out material facts creates liability even if no statement was actually made misleading. The Court has now held the case over for a second conference, which often comes before a grant.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring Securities Act Section 11 omissions question with heavy IPO-litigation stakes and SEC/Chamber/SIFMA interest, but technical and unlikely to draw broad public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 79%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to hear Robinhood's appeal, with about a four-in-five chance of accepting at least part of it. The likeliest outcome is review of only the first issue: whether leaving out important financial information makes an investment document misleading without a separate examination of what it actually said. The federal government's recommendation and the Court's renewed consideration support review. Investors counter that there is no genuine legal disagreement. A full hearing, rather than an immediate ruling, is expected if review is granted.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally significant rules for IPO disclosures and securities litigation, but a technical statutory dispute rather than a broad constitutional or economy-wide regulatory challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is moderately likely—at about a three-in-five chance (62%)—to grant Robinhood's petition for certiorari, meaning it will agree to hear the appeal. The case asks whether a company going public can be sued under federal securities law for leaving out mid-quarter financial numbers whenever an investor later claims those numbers were important, even if nothing the company actually said was misleading. After asking the U.S. Solicitor General (the federal government's top Supreme Court lawyer) for advice, the government told the Court that the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals got this important rule wrong and recommended that the Justices take up that question, and the Court has now held the case over ("relisted" it) for a second conference—a classic sign that a grant is likely.

    Why this big-case score: Significant federal securities-law case on intra-quarter disclosure duties in IPO registration statements under Section 11(a) and Item 303, featuring SEC/SG participation and broad capital-markets impact.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court asked for the Solicitor General's views. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-order-cvsg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Section 11 / Item 303 ruling on whether IPO issuers must disclose intra-quarter financial data would reshape offering-disclosure practice and the pleading of Securities Act class actions in the circuit that hears most of them; large for securities law and issuers, modest for the general public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 44%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could materially affect nationwide IPO disclosure duties and securities-litigation exposure for issuers and underwriters, but concern technical disclosure standards rather than a broad constitutional or governmental power.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.80·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile securities litigation involving Robinhood and major amicus support regarding the SEC's periodic reporting regime.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the Solicitor General filed the brief the Court invited. Decided 2026-11-13: the Court took the case. evt-brief-sg-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Section 11 misleading-omissions standard for interim financial data affects every IPO and the SEC periodic-reporting regime; important to securities bar and issuers, but technical and low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 84%·Prediction: granted-in-partfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A consequential nationwide securities-disclosure and IPO-liability question affecting issuers and investors, but a technical statutory dispute rather than a broad constitutional or public-policy watershed.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 78%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant securities-law question under Section 11(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 governing IPO disclosure obligations for interim financial data, backed by the Solicitor General, SEC, and major industry amici.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely (about 84 percent) set aside the Ninth Circuit's ruling that let investors sue Robinhood over its 2021 stock offering simply because it left out important recent financial results. The predicted judgment is "vacated", meaning the lower ruling is wiped out and the case sent back, by a 9–0 vote. The main reason: the federal government told the Court the lower court misread the law, which requires showing that an omission made a specific statement misleading, and the Court took up exactly that question.

    Why this big-case score: Significant for IPO issuers, underwriters and the securities bar (strict-liability Section 11 disclosure duty for interim results), but a technical statutory question with little general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about an 86% chance—to set aside the appeals court's decision in Robinhood's investor lawsuit. I expect all nine Justices to agree and send the case back. The likely reason is that leaving out information important to investors does not automatically make a company's actual statements misleading; courts must examine both questions. That would help Robinhood without necessarily ending the lawsuit, because investors could still pursue other disclosure requirements or show that specific statements really were misleading.

    Why this big-case score: An important nationwide rule for IPO disclosures and private securities suits, but a confined statutory question rather than a wholesale change to the disclosure regime.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (84% chance) to disturb the Ninth Circuit's decision, most likely by vacating it—wiping away the ruling and sending the case back to the lower courts—in a unanimous 9–0 vote. Federal securities law makes a company liable in a public stock offering for leaving out important facts only when a rule requires disclosure or when leaving the fact out makes something the company actually said misleading, and the Ninth Circuit wrongly skipped that second step; only a modest chance that the Justices dismiss the appeal without deciding it tempers the odds.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a direct circuit split over public-offering disclosure liability for intra-quarter financial metrics under Section 11(a) in a high-profile fintech IPO, though narrowed to a single statutory question.

United Airlines v. KincannonUnited Airlines asked the Court to review a class certified on behalf of employees who were denied vaccine-mandate religious accommodations; the Court declined to hear the case.Civil proceduredecided
0.55
0.48
0.40
0.48

United Airlines, Incorporated v. Genise Kincannon, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al.No. 26-183 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000183 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Civil procedure

United Airlines asked the Court to review a class certified on behalf of employees who were denied vaccine-mandate religious accommodations; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

United Airlines placed customer-facing employees who received religious accommodations to its COVID-19 vaccine mandate on indefinite unpaid leave. A group of those employees sued, arguing this failed to reasonably accommodate their religious beliefs under Title VII. A federal district court certified a class of these employees, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed, finding that questions about the sincerity of employees' beliefs, the reasonableness of the accommodation, and whether alternatives would have burdened United could be resolved using evidence common to the class. United asked for rehearing before the full Fifth Circuit, which was denied.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a group of employees can be treated as a single class when a jury might ultimately decide some of their claims differently than others, or whether class treatment requires that the evidence lead to the same answer for every member at once.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition. Justice Kavanaugh noted he would have granted it.

What each outcome would mean

United Airlines, which lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up the case. The denial leaves the Fifth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the class of employees Kincannon and the other plaintiffs represent remains certified, and the case returns to the district court to proceed on that basis. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Fifth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed. Had the Court granted the petition, it would have heard full arguments and decided the class-certification question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide-profile employer (United Airlines) COVID-vaccine religious-accommodation class action; a grant would reshape Rule 23 commonality/predominance doctrine across employment, mass-tort, and securities classes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition presents a nationally consequential Rule 23 commonality issue affecting employment and class-action litigation beyond the underlying dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes Rule 23 class certification dispute involving a novel three-stage 'class rostering' process and COVID-19 vaccine mandates.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Rule 23 commonality/predominance ruling would reach class actions well beyond Title VII, and the vaccine-mandate religious-accommodation setting with nearly 1,000 pilots and flight attendants is newsworthy; but the question is procedural and interlocutory, so not top-tier stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Review could materially affect Rule 23 commonality and predominance across employment class actions and other litigation. Religious accommodation and pandemic policies add public interest, but this is an interlocutory certification dispute rather than a direct nationwide ruling on vaccine mandates.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant procedural implications for class actions, but limited to Rule 23 mechanics and not a broader cultural or constitutional flashpoint.

Aubol v. Andeavor LogisticsIndividual Indian allottees ask the Court to decide whether they can sue a pipeline company for trespass under federal common law for staying on their land without authorization.Sovereignty & foreign relationsawaiting the Court
0.38
0.65
0.40
0.48

Sharon Aubol, et al. v. Andeavor Logistics, L.P., et al.No. 26-388 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000388 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

Individual Indian allottees ask the Court to decide whether they can sue a pipeline company for trespass under federal common law for staying on their land without authorization.

What happened

Sharon Aubol and dozens of other individual Indians hold federal trust allotments on the Fort Berthold Reservation in North Dakota. Andeavor Logistics has operated an oil pipeline across their allotments since 2013, after its right-of-way expired, without a new agreement. The allottees sued for trespass, breach of contract, and unjust enrichment. The district court dismissed their claims, holding they had no federal common-law cause of action for trespass because, in its view, that right belongs only to tribes asserting aboriginal title, not individual allottees with statutory trust interests. A divided Eighth Circuit panel affirmed, with one judge dissenting.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether individual Indians who hold a current right to possess land under federal law can sue for trespass using a trespass rule created by federal courts, rather than needing a tribe or the federal government to bring the claim on their behalf.

Where it stands

The petition for certiorari was filed on September 10, 2026, after the Court granted an earlier extension of time. The deadline for Andeavor's response was extended to December 8, 2026, and a group of tribal organizations has filed a brief supporting the allottees. The petition has not yet been distributed for a conference.

What each outcome would mean

The allottees, who lost in the Eighth Circuit, are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full briefing and argument and decide whether individual allottees have this trespass claim, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Eighth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving the allottees unable to pursue this trespass claim in that circuit, while similar claims remain available to allottees in the Ninth and Tenth Circuits under those courts' rulings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 8, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Aubol's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Aubol's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring federal Indian-law question (whether ~38,000 individual allottees in the Eighth Circuit alone can sue trespassers themselves) with a crude-oil pipeline and a nine-figure damages history behind it; consequential for Indian country and pipeline operators, but doctrinally technical and unlikely to draw broad public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Independent enforcement of individual Indian trust-allotment property rights has substantial consequences beyond this pipeline dispute, but the question concerns a specialized federal common-law remedy rather than a generally applicable property rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean circuit split on Indian law rights of action, but concerns private allottees rather than a major tribal sovereignty clash.

Buenrostro-Mendez v. BlancheImmigration detainees ask the Court to decide a statutory question about their detention, after the Fifth Circuit ruled against them.awaiting the Court
0.75
—
0.20
0.47 2 of 3 models

Victor Buenrostro-Mendez, et al. v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General, et al.No. 26-43 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000043 · models differ by up to 0.55

Immigration detainees ask the Court to decide a statutory question about their detention, after the Fifth Circuit ruled against them.

What happened

Victor Buenrostro-Mendez and other petitioners, represented by the ACLU and the Northwest Immigrant Rights Project, were held by immigration authorities and are challenging aspects of their detention. Their case reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which issued a decision against them on February 6, 2026, and denied rehearing on April 9, 2026. They then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. The respondents are Martin Frink, a warden, and federal officials including the Attorney General, represented by the Solicitor General.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide a question about how a federal statute governing immigration detention should be interpreted or applied. A September 25 letter from petitioners' counsel notes that this case presents a statutory issue distinct from constitutional questions raised in related cases, and urges that if the Court takes up a related matter, it should grant review only on the statutory issue raised here and in another related case.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a waiver of response from the warden, a brief from federal respondents, and a reply from petitioners. It was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, rescheduled once, then distributed again for the same conference date; the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Buenrostro-Mendez and the other detainees are asking the Court to take up their case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the statutory question itself, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision against the petitioners stays in place, and the case ends there. A denial would not mean the Court agrees with the lower court's reasoning, only that the decision stands.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Buenrostro-Mendez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Buenrostro-Mendez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.75·Chance the Court takes the case: 47%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question presented (whether noncitizens who entered without inspection and were arrested in the interior face mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2)(A) or bond eligibility under 1226(a)) governs the detention of a very large population and has produced an 8-2 circuit split; this petition is the Fifth Circuit companion to the lead vehicle the Court has already taken.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    No petition, questions presented, opposition text, or lower-court opinion was available to establish the substantive issue and its reach; the caption and counsel alone cannot reliably place the stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Immigration habeas class action, but with a baseline salience band and an unpublished lower court opinion.

Hoffmann v. WBI Energy TransmissionLandowners whose property was condemned for a natural gas pipeline ask the Court to decide whether state or federal law sets the compensation owed in such takings.Environment, energy & propertyawaiting the Court
0.40
0.60
0.42
0.47

Leonard W. Hoffmann, et al. v. WBI Energy Transmission, Inc.No. 25-159 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73274853 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Environment, energy & property

Landowners whose property was condemned for a natural gas pipeline ask the Court to decide whether state or federal law sets the compensation owed in such takings.

What happened

WBI Energy Transmission, a certificate holder under the Natural Gas Act, condemned pipeline easements across ranchland owned by Leonard Hoffmann and other McKenzie County, North Dakota landowners. After the parties settled on the easements' value, the landowners sought attorney's fees and expenses, arguing North Dakota law entitles condemnees to such costs as part of just compensation. The district court agreed and awarded over $383,000. The Eighth Circuit reversed, holding that federal law, not state law, measures compensation in private condemnations under the Act, and that the Fifth Amendment does not require payment of attorney's fees. The Eighth Circuit acknowledged its decision conflicted with rulings from four other circuits that had applied state compensation law in similar cases.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, when a private company condemns land under a federal law that lets it exercise eminent domain but says nothing about how to calculate compensation, courts must look to the law of the state where the land sits (which may provide more generous compensation, including attorney's fees) or whether a uniform federal standard limited to the property's fair market value applies instead.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, received briefing including from the United States as amicus curiae supporting the pipeline company, heard oral argument on November 9, 2026, and the case now awaits decision.

What each outcome would mean

The landowners, who lost below, are asking the Court to reverse the Eighth Circuit and hold that state law governs compensation, which would let them seek attorney's fees and other costs North Dakota law may allow. WBI Energy, which won below, argues for affirming the Eighth Circuit's rule that only the federal constitutional minimum—fair market value of the property, without attorney's fees—applies nationwide. The United States, participating in support of WBI, urges the same result. A ruling for the landowners would mean state compensation rules, including fee-shifting statutes, apply in these condemnations; a ruling for WBI would establish a single federal compensation standard for all such pipeline takings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Hoffmann wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: WBI Energy Transmission wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 45%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide rule for what pipeline condemnors must pay landowners under the Natural Gas Act — consequential for energy infrastructure and property owners across at least five circuits, but a technical choice-of-law question with modest general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 34%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The ruling will govern compensation in private Natural Gas Act condemnations nationwide, affecting landowners, pipeline costs, and a mature circuit split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Establishes a uniform standard for land compensation in Natural Gas Act takings, heavily impacting national pipeline infrastructure costs.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 44%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring question for every Natural Gas Act condemnation nationwide, with a four-circuit consensus at stake and broad property-rights and industry amicus interest, but technical, fee-focused, and unlikely to lead general news.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 38%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally consequential compensation rule for federally authorized pipeline condemnations, affecting landowners' litigation costs and infrastructure acquisition costs, but not a challenge to the power to condemn or a general redefinition of constitutional takings rights.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A significant eminent domain and federalism case that determines whether private pipelines using federal condemnation power must pay state-law compensation, which can be higher than the federal floor.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 12%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely affirm, meaning it leaves the lower court's ruling in place: there is only about a one-in-eight chance it overturns it. The case asks whether landowners whose property is taken by a private pipeline company under a federal law are paid under state rules, which can add attorney's fees, or under the federal constitutional standard. At argument, at least six Justices appeared to favor the federal standard. The expected vote is about 8-1, with Justice Gorsuch the likeliest dissenter.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a 4-1 circuit split on the compensation measure in every private Natural Gas Act condemnation; real stakes for landowners and pipeline builders, but a technical statutory question with modest public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 10%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about nine chances in ten—to leave the lower court's ruling intact. I predict a unanimous decision for WBI, meaning the landowners cannot recover their lawyer fees as part of payment for the pipeline easement. The main reason is that questioning across the Court favored using federal payment rules when Congress lets a private company take land for a pipeline. The expected ruling applies broadly to compensation under the Natural Gas Act, without giving companies all the federal government's legal protections.

    Why this big-case score: A nationwide rule for pipeline condemnations affects landowner compensation, infrastructure costs, and federal-state authority, but the immediate dispute is a statutory compensation question rather than a wholesale change to takings doctrine.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 9%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about a nine-in-ten chance—to affirm the Eighth Circuit's ruling for WBI Energy Transmission, with less than a one-in-ten chance of overturning it, most likely by a unanimous 9–0 vote (or 8–1). When Congress lets an interstate natural-gas pipeline use federal eminent domain—the government's power to take private land for public use—the Court will hold that federal constitutional "just compensation" rules (fair market value, without attorney fees) apply nationwide rather than state fee-shifting laws.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves an entrenched circuit split over federal versus state compensation rules for interstate natural-gas pipeline condemnations under 15 U.S.C. 717f(h), carrying practical nationwide stakes for energy infrastructure and landowners without broader constitutional reach.

Utah v. Morris Thomas MullinsUtah's bid to review a ruling that threw out a man's juvenile life-without-parole sentence over hints he could change was denied.Criminal lawdecided
0.35
0.57
0.50
0.47

Utah v. Morris Thomas MullinsNo. 25-1115 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281394 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Criminal law

Utah's bid to review a ruling that threw out a man's juvenile life-without-parole sentence over hints he could change was denied.

What happened

In 2002, Morris Mullins was sentenced to life without parole for a murder he committed at 17. Years later, citing new Supreme Court rulings on juvenile sentencing, Mullins argued his sentence was illegal because the sentencing judge had suggested he had "a chance to change." The Utah Supreme Court, divided 3-2, agreed and vacated his sentence, holding that judges' comments raised significant concerns the judge believed Mullins capable of change and had not properly considered his youth, making life without parole unconstitutional. The court sent the case back for resentencing. Utah asked the Utah Supreme Court to reconsider; it refused.

What the Court is being asked

Utah asked the Court to decide whether a sentencing judge can still impose life without parole on a juvenile convicted of murder even if the judge finds, or suggests, that the juvenile is capable of change rather than permanently beyond hope of reform. Mullins countered that the Court lacked authority to hear the case at all because no final sentence has yet been imposed, since his case was sent back for resentencing.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for several conferences between September and October 2026. On October 19, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Utah, which asked the Court to take the case and overturn the ruling below, sought to restore the possibility of a life-without-parole sentence for Mullins. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Utah Supreme Court's decision in place: Mullins's original sentence stays vacated, and the case returns to a Utah court for resentencing, where a lesser sentence may now be considered. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Utah Supreme Court's reasoning, only that it left that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A genuine open question under Miller/Montgomery/Jones on juvenile life without parole, but the practical footprint is small: Utah abolished JLWOP prospectively in 2016, few states still impose it, the record is a pre-Miller 2002 sentencing, and the respondent faces a consecutive Arizona life sentence regardless. Doctrinally interesting to sentencing lawyers; not a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clarifying the Eighth Amendment limits on juvenile life without parole would have substantial constitutional and human stakes, but the narrow corrigibility question, disputed vehicle, and shrinking affected sentencing population limit its breadth.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Eighth Amendment juvenile LWOP limits post-Jones v. Mississippi.

Richard Stuart Ross v. United StatesA man whose seized funds were returned after the government dropped its forfeiture case asks the Court to say he still counts as having won, entitling him to attorney's fees.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.40
0.60
0.42
0.47

Richard Stuart Ross v. United StatesNo. 26-91 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000091 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Civil procedure

A man whose seized funds were returned after the government dropped its forfeiture case asks the Court to say he still counts as having won, entitling him to attorney's fees.

What happened

Federal agents seized millions from Richard Stuart Ross's bank trust account, suspecting the money was linked to a fraud scheme, and the government sued to forfeit it. Ross contested the forfeiture of part of the money; courts entered a default forfeiture judgment on the uncontested portion. The government later moved to dismiss its forfeiture claim to the contested $1.21 million without prejudice and returned those funds to Ross. The district court denied Ross attorney's fees, finding he had not "substantially prevailed," and the Second Circuit affirmed that denial while also vacating an unrelated certificate the government conceded was improperly granted.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether someone who gets the government to drop a forfeiture case and return his property, without a court ruling in his favor, counts as having "substantially prevailed" under the federal law that awards attorney's fees in such cases. A related question is whether losing the chance at those fees because the case was dismissed without prejudice, rather than with prejudice, counts as the kind of harm that should have led the court to dismiss the case on different terms.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference; the government waived its right to respond but was later asked to respond, and that response's deadline has twice been extended, now to December 7, 2026. No conference has yet considered the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Ross, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether Ross's recovery of his money counts as "substantially prevailing," deciding nothing by the grant itself. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling against Ross's fee claim stands, leaving him without the attorney's fees he sought despite getting his money back.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 7, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Richard Stuart Ross' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Richard Stuart Ross' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down (deny) Richard Ross's request to hear his case. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in eight. Ross wants the government to pay his lawyers' fees after it dropped its attempt to seize his property under civil-forfeiture law and gave the property back. Several advocacy groups and two senators back him, and the Court has asked the government to respond. Those are signs of interest. But four appeals courts agree on the main question against him, and the Court usually takes cases where lower courts disagree.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring federal civil-forfeiture fee question with broad amicus and Senate interest, but a statutory fee-shifting rule of limited reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Richard Ross's appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of granting some form of review (22%). Ross wants the government to pay his legal bills after it dropped an effort to take his property and returned the money. Eight supporting briefs and the Court's request for a government response show meaningful interest. But the lower courts are not clearly divided on the main question, and another statutory obstacle could prevent Ross from recovering fees even if his main argument wins.

    Why this big-case score: A nationally consequential question about access to counsel and recovery of litigation costs after federal civil forfeiture, with potential implications for other fee-shifting statutes; narrower than a constitutional ruling on forfeiture itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Richard Stuart Ross v. United States*, with a 90% chance of denial (a one-in-ten chance of granting review). Although eight friend-of-the-court briefs were filed supporting Ross and the Court asked the federal government to file a response, every federal appeals court to consider the issue agrees that the government does not owe a property claimant attorney's fees when a civil forfeiture case is voluntarily dismissed without a final court ruling on the merits. In addition, the trial court found that a separate statutory exception for cases involving multiple competing claims independently barred Ross from recovering fees, making this case a poor vehicle for the Justices to take up.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, the case would determine whether government voluntary dismissals without prejudice in civil asset forfeiture actions trigger CAFRA's 'substantially prevails' fee-shifting mandate or Rule 41(a)(2) plain legal prejudice, an issue of significant practical consequence for property rights and civil forfeiture litigation nationwide.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A statutory fee-shifting question under CAFRA that would reshape the government's incentives in civil forfeiture litigation nationwide; closely watched by the forfeiture-reform coalition (eight cert-stage amici, two Senators) but technical rather than headline-grabbing if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally consequential for access to counsel and government incentives in civil forfeiture, with possible implications for other fee-shifting statutes, but a narrower procedural dispute than a challenge to forfeiture itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Marion Alexander Lindsey v. South CarolinaThe Supreme Court declined to hear a death-sentenced South Carolina inmate's challenge to how courts assess his ineffective-assistance claim and a judge's adoption of the state's proposed order.Criminal lawdecided
0.35
0.66
0.40
0.47

Marion Alexander Lindsey v. South CarolinaNo. 25-1176 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281656 · models differ by up to 0.31 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear a death-sentenced South Carolina inmate's challenge to how courts assess his ineffective-assistance claim and a judge's adoption of the state's proposed order.

What happened

Marion Lindsey was convicted of murder and sentenced to death in South Carolina. He sought state post-conviction relief, arguing his trial lawyer failed to adequately investigate and present mitigating evidence at sentencing. The post-conviction court denied relief by signing an order drafted by the state that contained numerous errors; after the state supreme court sent the order back for correction, the judge re-adopted the same findings with only cosmetic changes. The South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed the denial of relief, over two dissenting justices. Lindsey then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The case raised two questions. First, when courts decide whether a defendant was harmed by his lawyer's mistakes, must they weigh all the mistakes together, or can they reject the claim by considering each mistake separately? Second, does it violate a defendant's constitutional rights for a judge in a death penalty case to adopt, essentially unchanged, an order written by the state without showing independent judicial consideration?

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Lindsey, as the petitioner, asked the Court to overturn the South Carolina Supreme Court's decision upholding the denial of relief. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that state court decision in place, meaning Lindsey's conviction and death sentence stand and he does not receive a new hearing on his ineffective-assistance or proposed-order claims through this petition. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed. The docket notes related federal habeas proceedings are pending separately.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital case with a life at stake and two recurring process questions (cumulative Strickland prejudice; verbatim adoption of a party's proposed order), but neither question is a headline issue and the posture is a fact-heavy state post-conviction record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.66·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital sentence and recurring questions about cumulative ineffective-assistance prejudice and independent judicial review give this case substantial stakes. A ruling on cumulative prejudice could extend beyond capital cases, although neither question challenges capital punishment generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital case involving a circuit split on cumulative error in Strickland claims, though likely a poor vehicle lacking strong cert-stage signals.

Radiall USA v. RamadeiThe Court declined to hear Radiall's bid to revive its challenge to a jury verdict favoring a former employee's family leave retaliation claim.decided
0.35
0.56
0.50
0.47

Radiall USA, Inc. v. Gary T. RamadeiNo. 26-436 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000436 · models differ by up to 0.21

The Court declined to hear Radiall's bid to revive its challenge to a jury verdict favoring a former employee's family leave retaliation claim.

What happened

Gary Ramadei sued his former employer, Radiall USA, for retaliating against him for taking medical leave, among other claims. A jury found for Ramadei on his family-leave retaliation claim, awarding him about $187,000 in damages, later increased to over $770,000 with fees and interest. The trial court had instructed the jury using a standard allowing Ramadei to win by showing his leave was only a motivating factor in his firing, rather than requiring him to show it was the determining cause. After the trial, the Supreme Court issued a decision ending a long-standing practice of courts deferring to certain agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes. On appeal, Radiall argued this change undermined the lower causation standard, but the Second Circuit held Radiall had not properly preserved that argument and affirmed the judgment.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether family-leave retaliation claims require proof that taking leave was the determining cause of a firing, rather than merely one factor among others, and whether an appeals court may decline to decide such a purely legal question on the grounds that a party failed to raise it early enough, when the earlier courts were bound by existing precedent and the argument only became available after a later Supreme Court ruling changed the legal landscape.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, after the respondent waived his right to respond and two amicus briefs were filed. The Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Radiall, which lost below, asked the Court to take up the case and reverse. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Second Circuit's decision in place, so the judgment for Ramadei, including the damages award, stands. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Second Circuit's reasoning on causation or on preservation of legal arguments; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed without deciding the underlying questions.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A genuine, acknowledged circuit split over the causation standard for FMLA retaliation claims (motivating factor under a DOL regulation versus the Nassar but-for default), sharpened by Loper Bright; a decision would govern a high-volume federal employment claim nationwide and would be the Court's first word on which Chevron-era statutory holdings survive, but the issue is technical and the parties are a mid-sized employer and one former facility manager.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could standardize FMLA retaliation causation nationwide and clarify preservation of challenges to agency-deference precedents after Loper Bright. Those recurring employment and appellate-procedure stakes exceed this individual damages dispute, but the case is not a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile FMLA split post-Loper Bright, but vehicle problems below (waiver/forfeiture) make it unlikely to be decided on the merits.

Ramesh Sunny Balwani v. United StatesThe Court declined to hear Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani's bid to overturn his fraud convictions in the Theranos case.Criminal lawdecided
0.45
0.65
0.30
0.47

Ramesh Sunny Balwani v. United StatesNo. 25-1330 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500238 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Criminal law

The Court declined to hear Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani's bid to overturn his fraud convictions in the Theranos case.

What happened

Balwani was convicted on fraud and conspiracy charges connected to the collapse of Theranos, the blood-testing company he ran with Elizabeth Holmes, and is serving a prison sentence. On appeal, he argued that prosecutors relied on testimony later acknowledged as false about Theranos's work with the military, and that two government witnesses gave specialized scientific opinions without the trial court ever screening that testimony for reliability. The Ninth Circuit affirmed his convictions, finding the testimony problems did not require a new trial, and denied rehearing. Balwani then asked the Supreme Court to take up the case.

What the Court is being asked

Balwani asked the Court to decide two things: first, whether a more forgiving error standard should apply when prosecutors not only let false testimony stand uncorrected but also relied on it in closing arguments the defense had no chance to rebut; and second, whether an appeals court may excuse a trial judge's total failure to screen expert-type testimony for reliability simply by finding, after the fact, that the witnesses were qualified by background and experience.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it; Justice Thomas did not take part.

What each outcome would mean

Balwani, who lost in the lower court, asked the Court to take up his case. The denial means the Court will not review the Ninth Circuit's decision, so that ruling and his convictions stand. Had the Court instead granted review, the case would have been scheduled for full briefing and argument, and the Court would have decided the legal questions about false testimony and expert-evidence screening without yet determining who wins.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Theranos is one of the most-covered fraud prosecutions of the decade, so any decision would be headline news, and a ruling on the standard of review for unpreserved Napue claims or on appellate reconstruction of Rule 702 gatekeeping would reach every criminal trial; the questions themselves are procedural and mid-sized, not landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Theranos prosecution gives the case substantial public-interest stakes, while the questions about prosecutorial use of false testimony and expert-evidence gatekeeping could affect federal criminal trials broadly. That significance is distinct from its low probability of review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile defendant (Theranos trial), but fact-bound legal issues lacking broad significance.

Capital Group Companies v. PoverAn asset-management company asks the Court to decide how much money a retirement-plan participant may recover on the plan's behalf when suing over mismanaged investments.awaiting the Court
0.35
0.60
0.45
0.47

The Capital Group Companies, Inc., et al. v. Cathy PoverNo. 26-267 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000267 · models differ by up to 0.25

An asset-management company asks the Court to decide how much money a retirement-plan participant may recover on the plan's behalf when suing over mismanaged investments.

What happened

Cathy Pover, a former Capital Group employee, sued the company and plan fiduciaries, alleging they kept underperforming investment funds in the retirement plan to collect fees, breaching duties owed under a federal pension law. Capital Group asked the court to send the dispute to arbitration under a plan provision barring group or representative claims. The district court refused, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that provision unenforceable because it would block Pover from pursuing the plan-wide recovery the law allows. A dissenting judge disagreed with that reading and would also have let an arbitrator decide the arbitration question itself.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a plan participant who sues over fiduciary mismanagement of a retirement plan with individual accounts may seek money for losses in other participants' accounts, or only for losses in her own account.

Where it stands

Capital Group petitioned for review in August 2026; Pover waived her right to respond, but the Court then asked for a response, which after an extension is due December 2, 2026. The petition has been distributed for one conference so far, and amici have filed briefs supporting review.

What each outcome would mean

Capital Group, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case and decide the legal question; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision favoring Pover's broader view of recoverable relief stands, and the case continues in the lower courts under that rule. A denial would not mean the Court agreed with that outcome, only that the lower court's ruling remains in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 2, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Capital Group Companies' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Capital Group Companies' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this case, with roughly a one-in-eight chance it agrees to take it. An investment company wants the Court to decide whether one employee suing over a retirement plan can recover money for other employees' accounts. The Court asked the employee to respond after she first declined, which shows some interest, and appeals courts disagree on the issue. But that disagreement is lopsided and new, and the case arrives at an early stage of an arbitration dispute, which makes it a less attractive candidate.

    Why this big-case score: Scope of plan-wide monetary relief in ERISA 502(a)(2) defined-contribution suits: large stakes for retirement-plan class litigation and individual-arbitration clauses, but technical and of little general-public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn this case away than hear it; I give review about a three-in-ten chance. The case asks whether one retirement-plan participant can recover investment losses affecting other participants' accounts. Federal appeals courts disagree, and the Court's request for a response shows interest. But this case also involves the wording of an arbitration agreement, which could complicate resolving that broader question. I expect another scheduling step after the response, followed most likely by denial without an explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of retirement-plan fiduciary remedies and enforceability of individual arbitration affect retirement savers and employers nationwide, although the issue is technical rather than a broad constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn away this appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of agreeing to hear it. Capital Group asks the Justices to enforce a workplace retirement-plan rule requiring individual arbitration—private dispute resolution outside court—and barring an employee from recovering investment losses for coworkers' 401(k) accounts. Although federal appeals courts recently split seven-to-one over that federal retirement-law question and the Justices asked the employee to respond, unusual contract wording and procedural differences make this case an imperfect test case.

    Why this big-case score: A merits ruling would govern whether employers nationwide can pair 401(k) and ESOP arbitration clauses with class waivers to limit fiduciary-breach recoveries to a single worker's account across trillions in retirement assets.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this case, with roughly a one-in-eight chance it agrees to. The retirement-plan company asks whether one 401(k) participant can sue to recover losses for other participants' accounts. The Court asked the other side to respond, an industry group filed a supporting brief, and one appeals court disagrees with seven others. But that disagreement is new and arose in a different procedural setting, and the Court has passed on similar disputes before. It may first ask the federal government's view.

    Why this big-case score: Scope of ERISA 502(a)(2) relief for defined-contribution participants; governs class certification and arbitration of 401(k) fiduciary suits nationwide, but a specialist question with little public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than hear it: I put the chance of review at about one in four, or 24%. The dispute asks whether one retirement-plan participant can recover money lost from other participants' accounts. Federal appeals courts disagree, and the Supreme Court has requested a response, both reasons to take the petition seriously. But complications involving arbitration and other available remedies could make this a poor test case. I expect another conference distribution, then a denial without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The permissible scope of retirement-plan recovery has substantial nationwide consequences for participants, plan fiduciaries, and arbitration, but the question is technical rather than broadly constitutional.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to take up this appeal, with roughly a one-in-four chance (24%) of granting review, so the expected outcome is a denial. Although federal appeals courts are divided 8–1 over whether a single retirement-plan participant can use a federal benefits law to seek money for coworkers' 401(k) accounts—and prevent enforcement of an individual arbitration agreement—Capital Group's particularly broad contract wording and unresolved threshold disputes make this specific lawsuit a flawed test case.

    Why this big-case score: A merits ruling would determine whether 401(k) participants can seek plan-wide monetary recovery under ERISA § 502(a)(2) or be confined to single-account arbitration, reshaping fiduciary litigation across trillions in retirement assets.

Spartan Securities Group v. SECSecurities firms ask the Court to overturn a jury verdict and financial penalty, arguing their private regulatory filings were not securities fraud.awaiting the Court
0.40
0.55
0.45
0.47

Spartan Securities Group, Ltd., et al. v. Securities and Exchange CommissionNo. 26-341 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000341 · models differ by up to 0.15

Securities firms ask the Court to overturn a jury verdict and financial penalty, arguing their private regulatory filings were not securities fraud.

What happened

The Securities and Exchange Commission sued Spartan Securities Group, Island Capital Management, and two of their officers, alleging they helped fraudsters take shell companies public. A jury rejected 13 of the SEC's 14 claims but found the defendants liable on one count, involving statements made to a private regulator, FINRA, and to a stock clearinghouse, DTC, rather than to investors directly. The trial court ordered Island to pay over $150,000 in disgorgement, meaning repayment of gains tied to the misconduct, to the U.S. Treasury, plus penalties. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The petitioners ask the Court to decide two things: first, whether a private statement made only to a regulator or clearinghouse, never seen by any investor, counts as fraud connected to the purchase or sale of a security under the relevant securities-fraud rule; and second, whether courts may order a company to give up its gains to the government when no specific investor was identified as harmed, rather than limiting such orders to traditional principles requiring a link to actual victims.

Where it stands

The federal government, representing the SEC, waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, but the Court instead asked for a response, due November 23, 2026, and the docket shows no further action since.

What each outcome would mean

Spartan Securities Group and the other firms are asking the Court to reverse the Eleventh Circuit's ruling, which upheld the jury verdict and disgorgement order in the SEC's favor. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments on whether the lower court applied the right legal standards. If it denies the petition, the Eleventh Circuit's decision stands, leaving the liability finding and disgorgement order against the petitioners in place. A denial would not mean the Court agrees with the lower court's reasoning, only that the case ends there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Spartan Securities Group's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Spartan Securities Group's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case (about a one-in-six chance it takes it up, counting an order sending the case back for another look). A securities firm and its affiliates are challenging a fraud verdict and an order to pay over profits to the U.S. Treasury rather than to harmed investors. The Court asked the government to respond after it had declined to, which signals some interest. But most petitions are still rejected at that stage, and the Court just decided a related disgorgement case (Sripetch v. SEC) in June 2026.

    Why this big-case score: Whether SEC disgorgement under 15 U.S.C. 78u(d)(7) may go to the Treasury with no identified victim affects billions in annual SEC awards and a question Sripetch left open; QP1 (nonpublic statements to FINRA/DTC under 10b-5) is narrower.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down this case, with about a one-in-five chance of taking it up or sending it back for another look. Its request for a government response signals interest, especially in whether the SEC may collect profits without identifying harmed investors and send the money to the Treasury. But the claimed disagreement among courts is not completely clear, and the separate challenge to securities-fraud liability depends partly on disputed facts. Another conference scheduling is likely before a decision.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling could materially affect SEC disgorgement and securities-fraud enforcement nationwide, although this is a technical enforcement dispute rather than a broad public controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Spartan Securities Group, Ltd. v. SEC*, giving the petition about a one-in-six chance (16%) of being granted, either for full briefing and argument or for an immediate remand—sending the case back to the lower court—in light of the Supreme Court's June 2026 decision in *Sripetch v. SEC*. Although the Court asked the government to respond to the petition's challenge to disgorgement—a court order requiring a wrongdoer to give up ill-gotten profits—paid to the U.S. Treasury, the lower court upheld that $114,520 award on the independent ground that the challengers themselves had agreed it was impractical to distribute the money to individual investors.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, the case would resolve the question left open in Liu v. SEC and Sripetch v. SEC regarding whether and when SEC disgorgement may be deposited into the U.S. Treasury under 15 U.S.C. § 78u(d)(5) and (d)(7), a recurring remedies issue in federal securities enforcement.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably refuse to hear this case (about a one-in-ten chance it takes it in some form). Brokers and a transfer agent challenge an SEC fraud finding and an order to give up about $150,000 in fees. The Court asked the government to respond, a mild sign of interest. The disgorgement question follows directly from the Court's 2026 *Sripetch* decision. Still, the small award and fact-heavy record make it a weak vehicle. If the Court acts, the most likely step is sending the case back to the lower court for another look in light of *Sripetch*.

    Why this big-case score: Follow-on to Sripetch on SEC disgorgement (a multi-billion-dollar annual remedy) plus a Rule 10b-5 'in connection with' question, but on a small ($150k) award and fact-bound record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal; I estimate about an 18% chance it accepts the case or sends it back for another look. The Court has asked the government to respond, showing some interest. The strongest issue concerns whether the securities regulator can recover profits for the Treasury rather than investors. But disputed facts and an agreement that payments to investors were impractical make this a difficult case for resolving that issue. Another scheduling round is very likely before a decision.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential limits on SEC securities-fraud liability and disgorgement to the Treasury, though arising from a specialized microcap enforcement record.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in this case, with about an 11% chance (roughly one in nine) of granting the petition. A defunct brokerage firm, a transfer agent, and two executives challenge a federal appeals court ruling holding them liable for making false statements to financial regulators about "shell" companies (inactive companies used in fraud schemes) and ordering the transfer agent to forfeit $114,520 in ill-gotten fees ("disgorgement") to the U.S. Treasury rather than to harmed investors. Although the Court asked the Securities and Exchange Commission to file a response, the Court already decided a major disgorgement case five months ago, and the challengers previously agreed in the trial court that returning the $114,520 directly to individual investors was impractical, making this a poor test case for supreme court review.

    Why this big-case score: Presents the recurring post-Liu and post-Sripetch question whether 15 U.S.C. 78u(d)(7) permits SEC disgorgement awards to be paid to the U.S. Treasury without returning funds to wronged investors, alongside the scope of Section 10(b) for broker-dealer FINRA Form 211 submissions.

ON24 v. Leadersel Innotech ESGON24 asks the Court to review a Ninth Circuit ruling that let shareholder Leadersel's securities fraud claims over ON24's IPO disclosures go forward.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.35
0.49
0.55
0.46

ON24, Inc., et al. v. Leadersel Innotech ESGNo. 25-1376 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500275 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Business & finance

ON24 asks the Court to review a Ninth Circuit ruling that let shareholder Leadersel's securities fraud claims over ON24's IPO disclosures go forward.

What happened

Leadersel, representing a class of investors, sued ON24 and related parties, claiming ON24's 2021 IPO documents misleadingly described the risk of customer non-renewal as merely hypothetical when, according to the complaint, ON24 already knew some customers were not renewing and others had signaled they would not. A district court dismissed the case with prejudice, finding the allegations inconsistent and the risk disclosures adequate. The Ninth Circuit reversed in part, reviving most of the claims in an unpublished ruling, and later denied rehearing. ON24 then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether a company's warning that a risk might happen in the future becomes misleading once that risk has started to occur, even if it hasn't fully played out. It is also asked whether a company can be held liable for leaving out information connected to something it disclosed, even if that omission did not make any specific statement misleading, and whether rules requiring disclosure of known business trends extend to facts the company says were not significant enough to matter.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for multiple conferences, most recently one scheduled after the snapshot date, following full briefing including a response and a reply. The docket shows no action yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

ON24 is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision, which had revived Leadersel's lawsuit. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide these disclosure questions itself, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision stands, and Leadersel's lawsuit against ON24 continues in the lower courts. The Court could also hold the petition pending a related case, Robinhood Markets v. Sodha, without resolving it now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up ON24's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: ON24's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think it is slightly more likely than not (about 52%) that the Supreme Court will act on this petition from ON24 and its IPO underwriters, most likely by holding it and then sending it back to the lower court for another look. A closely related securities case, Robinhood v. Sodha, raises the same question about when leaving information out of an IPO filing (the document a company files before first selling shares to the public) counts as misleading. The government has urged the Court to take that case. If the Court takes it and rules for the companies, this case would likely go back to the Ninth Circuit too.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring Section 11 omissions/risk-disclosure questions affecting IPO issuers and underwriters nationally, but a fact-bound unpublished Ninth Circuit memorandum disposition.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline ON24's request for review. I put the chance of review or an order sending the case back for another look at 24%, about one in four. The dispute asks how much a company must tell investors about customer losses and future business risks. The Court's request for an answer signals interest, but the lower court's fact-sensitive ruling is a weak lead case. An overlapping securities case offers a plausible route to a later remand instead.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially important nationwide rules for IPO risk disclosures and Item 303 obligations, but this unpublished, pleading-stage securities case is a narrower vehicle than its industry-wide questions suggest.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny ON24’s petition for review, with about a one-in-four (25%) chance of granting it. After its 2021 initial public offering, ON24 was sued by investors claiming its registration documents described customer losses as a future risk when those losses were already happening. Although the Court asked the investors to respond to ON24’s appeal, the lower court’s ruling is an unpublished, fact-specific decision, and the Justices are already considering a better-positioned case (*Robinhood Markets v. Sodha*) that raises the same securities-law questions. Unless the Court holds ON24’s appeal waiting for a decision in *Robinhood* and later sends it back to the lower court for a fresh look, the Court will turn the appeal away without a full hearing.

    Why this big-case score: Significant federal securities law questions on Section 11 omissions, Item 303, and hypothetical risk disclosures in IPO registration statements, though posture is an unpublished Ninth Circuit memorandum shadow-riding the lead petition in Robinhood Markets, Inc. v. Sodha (No. 25-944).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a Section 11 risk-factor and Item 303 disclosure case for IPO issuers and underwriters, in the Facebook/Macquarie/Robinhood line the Court has been circling; significant for the securities bar and issuers, but derivative of Robinhood, from an unpublished interlocutory ruling, and with no cert-stage amicus support, so mid-tier rather than headline.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A broad decision could materially affect IPO disclosures, risk warnings, and securities litigation nationwide, but this unpublished pleading-stage dispute is a narrower vehicle than the questions presented suggest.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises important securities questions, but the decision below is an unpublished memorandum, limiting the broader significance unless it is GVR'd.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 33%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think the Supreme Court will most likely turn this case away, with about a one-in-three chance it acts on it instead. The key is a closely related pending case, Robinhood v. Sodha, on the same securities-disclosure law, which the government has urged the Court to hear. If the Court takes Robinhood and rules for the company there, it will likely send this case back to the lower court to reconsider in light of that ruling (a "GVR"). Otherwise, this petition will probably be denied.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring Securities Act Section 11 disclosure questions that matter to IPO issuers and underwriters, but an unpublished, interlocutory Ninth Circuit memo that would most likely ride on the companion Robinhood case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.49·Chance the Court takes the case: 56%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is slightly more likely than not to intervene: about a 56% chance. The likeliest path is to wait for a related securities case, then send ON24's case back for another look under that ruling, rather than hear it separately. Both petitions were scheduled again for the same conference, and the related case has government support for review. Still, disputed facts and separate grounds for the investors' claims could lead the Court to decline review instead. Sending it back would not decide who ultimately wins.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally consequential standards for IPO disclosures and securities litigation, but a fact-specific unpublished decision and likely companion remand limit this docket's standalone significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 31%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny review in *ON24, Inc. v. Leadersel Innotech ESG*, with a roughly three-in-ten chance (31%) of granting the petition or sending the case back to the lower court for reconsideration. Although the Court postponed its decision for another private conference alongside a related securities case, *Robinhood Markets v. Sodha*, the *ON24* appeal comes from a short, non-binding lower-court ruling with factual disputes that make it a poor standalone candidate for full Supreme Court review. If the Court acts favorably on ON24's petition at all, it will most likely hold the case until *Robinhood* is decided and then return it to the appeals court to apply that new ruling.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision resolving the standard for actionable risk-factor disclosures, Section 11(a) misleading omissions, and Item 303 trends would substantially shape federal securities litigation and public-company disclosure obligations nationwide.

Sprint v. FCCSprint and T-Mobile ask the Court to review FCC fines for mishandling customer location data, or send the case back for another look given a related ruling.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.64
0.45
0.46

Sprint Corporation, nka Sprint LLC, et al. v. Federal Communications Commission, et al.scotus/73539054 · models differ by up to 0.34

Sprint and T-Mobile ask the Court to review FCC fines for mishandling customer location data, or send the case back for another look given a related ruling.

What happened

The FCC fined Sprint and T-Mobile a combined $92 million for failing to protect customers' location data, which third parties misused without customer consent. The companies paid the fines and asked a federal appeals court to overturn them, arguing the data was not covered by the relevant privacy law, that the penalty exceeded a statutory cap, and that the process violated their right to a jury trial. The D.C. Circuit rejected all these arguments and upheld the fines. While the case was pending further review, the Supreme Court decided a related case, FCC v. AT&T, involving similar forfeiture orders against other carriers.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether it should send this case back to the lower court for reconsideration in light of its ruling in the related AT&T case and the government's legal concessions there. If it does not do that, the companies ask the Court to decide two further questions: whether the customer location data at issue counts as protected information under the law only when tied to phone calls specifically, and whether courts, rather than the agency itself, should decide how many separate violations a company's conduct amounted to for purposes of a cap on penalty amounts.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including the government's brief opposing review and the companies' reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026, then redistributed for a conference on November 13, 2026. No order on the petition has yet been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Sprint and T-Mobile, as petitioners, are asking the Court to act. If the Court sends the case back for reconsideration, the lower court would take another look without the Supreme Court deciding who is right, in light of the intervening AT&T decision. If the Court instead grants full review, it would hear arguments and decide the legal questions itself, with no outcome yet determined. If the Court denies review, the lower court's decision upholding the $92 million in fines against Sprint and T-Mobile stands.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Sprint's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Sprint's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A $92M forfeiture against a major carrier, with CPNI-scope and Loper Bright/penalty-counting questions, and amicus support from CTIA and the Chamber; but it follows FCC v. AT&T, the location-data programs have ended, and there is no split, so stakes are moderate rather than landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationwide mobile-location privacy duties, over $92 million in penalties, and limits on agency penalty discretion give this substantial regulatory stakes; preservation issues and the already-decided constitutional framework narrow its reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    While the underlying data privacy issues and $92 million forfeiture are significant, the core legal questions were already settled in the recent FCC v. AT&T decision.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    T-Mobile and Sprint are asking the Supreme Court to throw out about $92 million in FCC privacy fines, or at least to send the case back to the lower court in light of the Court's June 2026 decision in a similar AT&T/Verizon case. We think the Court will most likely refuse to hear the case (about a 15% chance it takes any action in the carriers' favor). The Court already refused Verizon the same kind of do-over, and the government is strongly opposed. One Justice, probably Justice Thomas, may write separately to object.

    Why this big-case score: A $92M forfeiture against a major carrier that follows up FCC v. AT&T; the CPNI and penalty-counting questions matter to telecom regulation, but location-data programs have ended and the main constitutional question is already settled.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this appeal than take it up: I estimate a 30% chance of review, including sending the case back for another look. Sprint and T-Mobile argue that a recent decision changes how their payment of FCC penalties should be treated. That gives them a real opening, reinforced by the Court's decision to discuss the petition again. But the government identifies obstacles, including arguments not properly raised earlier. If the Court intervenes, a short remand is much likelier than a full hearing.

    Why this big-case score: Nationwide location-data privacy obligations and limits on FCC monetary penalties are consequential, although the principal requested relief is a case-specific remand after AT&T.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Sprint and T-Mobile's petition for review (about a one-in-seven chance, or 14%, of a grant). Sprint and T-Mobile ask the Court to overturn or send back over $92 million in Federal Communications Commission fines for failing to safeguard customer cell-phone location data. However, the Supreme Court already upheld the constitutionality of the Commission's fine process in a nearly identical case in June 2026 (*FCC v. AT&T, Inc.*), and all three federal appeals courts to review these fines agree that cell-phone location data is protected by federal privacy law.

    Why this big-case score: Over $92M in combined FCC forfeitures against Sprint and T-Mobile over wireless customer location data privacy (47 U.S.C. 222) and post-AT&T/Loper Bright administrative enforcement questions.

Samsung Electronics America v. BrewerSamsung asks the Court to decide whether Georgia can treat business registration as consent to general jurisdiction without clearer notice to companies.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.35
0.61
0.42
0.46

Samsung Electronics America, Inc. v. Jordan BrewerNo. 26-4 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000004 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Civil procedure

Samsung asks the Court to decide whether Georgia can treat business registration as consent to general jurisdiction without clearer notice to companies.

What happened

Jordan Brewer, badly burned when a battery in his vape pen exploded, won a $10.9 million default judgment against Samsung in Georgia state court after Samsung failed to answer the complaint. Samsung spent years trying to undo that judgment, arguing among other things that Georgia courts lacked personal jurisdiction over it. Georgia's courts repeatedly rejected Samsung's attempts to set aside the judgment, relying on Georgia Supreme Court precedent holding that a company's registration to do business in the state subjects it to general jurisdiction there. The Georgia Supreme Court denied further review. Samsung then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether requiring out-of-state companies to answer lawsuits in Georgia, based solely on their registration to do business there, violates constitutional due process when Georgia's registration law itself does not say that registering counts as agreeing to be sued there — that rule comes only from Georgia court decisions, some issued after Samsung first registered.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference once, after which the Court asked Brewer to respond; Brewer filed an opposition brief, and Samsung filed a reply. The case was then distributed for a second conference, which has not yet occurred as of this summary.

What each outcome would mean

Samsung, which lost in the Georgia courts, is asking the Court to take up its case and ultimately overturn the ruling against it. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the jurisdictional question itself, deciding nothing yet about who is right. If it denies review, the Georgia Court of Appeals ruling stands, leaving Samsung subject to the judgment and Brewer's win intact. Brewer's brief also argues the Court lacks authority to hear the case at all because Samsung did not properly raise the federal question in the Georgia courts, a separate ground on which review could be denied.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Samsung Electronics America's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Samsung Electronics America's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Samsung's request to hear this case — we put the chance it agrees at about 7 in 100. Samsung argues Georgia courts cannot hear lawsuits against it just because it registered to do business there, since Georgia's law never warned that registering meant agreeing to be sued there. The Court did ask the other side to respond, a mild sign of interest, but it refused a similar Georgia case in 2023, and this one has procedural problems.

    Why this big-case score: Consent-by-registration jurisdiction after Mallory is a recurring, commercially significant due-process question touching many States' statutes, but this petition comes from an intermediate state court in a default-judgment posture with a single amicus.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.61·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Samsung's appeal; I put the chance it takes the case at 14%, about one in seven. Samsung argues that registering to do business in Georgia did not give fair warning that it could be sued there on unrelated claims. The Court's request for an answer shows interest, but not a promise to hear the case. Complicated rules surrounding Samsung's failure to answer the original lawsuit make this a difficult vehicle for resolving the broader issue.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling could define the notice required before business registration exposes corporations to suit on unrelated claims nationwide, but this vehicle is an individual product-liability default judgment with substantial procedural complications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Samsung's request to hear this appeal (about an 8% chance of review). Although the Court asked the injured Texas plaintiff to respond to Samsung's argument that simply registering to do business in Georgia should not allow Georgia courts to hear lawsuits unrelated to the state, the case is still in pre-trial discovery and entangled in state-law procedural disputes over whether Samsung waited too long to challenge the trial court's orders.

    Why this big-case score: Challenge to Georgia's implied-consent-by-registration general jurisdiction doctrine (Cooper Tire) following Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Ry. Co., brought by Samsung (represented by Mayer Brown) after a call for response; tests whether corporate registration without explicit statutory notice satisfies Fourteenth Amendment due process.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Samsung's appeal (to deny "certiorari", the Court's discretionary review). We put the chance it takes the case at about 6 in 100. Samsung argues that Georgia courts cannot hear any lawsuit against it just because it registered to do business there, when no Georgia statute said registration carried that consequence. The question is real. But the other side shows Samsung probably never raised it properly before Georgia's highest court, and the Justices already declined a similar Georgia case in 2023.

    Why this big-case score: Post-Mallory consent-by-registration jurisdiction matters to every multistate corporation, but this vehicle is a fact-bound default judgment with a contested preservation record, so the case as framed is mid-stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to decline Samsung's request for review, with about an eight-in-a-hundred chance that it takes the case or grants another form of relief. Samsung raises an important question about whether registering to do business lets a state hear almost any lawsuit against a company. But this case has serious procedural complications: Samsung may not have properly raised its constitutional argument earlier, and its admissions may independently support the state court's authority. A denial without explanation is the likeliest result.

    Why this big-case score: The notice required for corporate consent to general state-court jurisdiction affects nationwide businesses and forum choice; this substantial default judgment is nevertheless a procedurally troubled vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Samsung Electronics America's petition for review (a 3% chance of a grant, or about one in thirty-three). Samsung asks the Court to overturn a $10.86 million Georgia default judgment by ruling that registering to do business in Georgia cannot subject an out-of-state company to general "all-purpose" jurisdiction (authority to hear any lawsuit against it) when that rule comes from state court decisions rather than explicit statutory text. However, the Supreme Court recently upheld registration-based jurisdiction in 2023, has repeatedly declined similar follow-on challenges—including a challenge to this same Georgia rule—and is unlikely to intervene where a Georgia resident was injured in Georgia and Samsung renewed its registration for decades after Georgia's courts announced the rule.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided on the merits, clarifying whether judicial construction of a corporate registration statute and post-decision annual renewals satisfy Fourteenth Amendment Due Process notice for general jurisdiction after Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Ry. Co. would carry moderate national significance for multistate corporate litigation.

Jack v. WhateleyVirginia's DMV commissioner asks the Court to review a ruling that treats personalized license plate messages as private speech protected by the First Amendment.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.50
0.42
0.46

Saundra M. Jack, Commissioner, Virginia Department of Motor Vehicles v. Curtis M. WhateleyNo. 26-584 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000584 · models differ by up to 0.08

Virginia's DMV commissioner asks the Court to review a ruling that treats personalized license plate messages as private speech protected by the First Amendment.

What happened

Curtis Whateley got a Virginia personalized license plate reading "FTP&ATF," meaning "Fuck the Police & Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms." After a complaint, the DMV recalled the plate as vulgar and potentially promoting violence. Whateley sued, claiming the recall violated his free speech rights. The district court dismissed his suit, ruling that personalized plates are government speech, which is not subject to ordinary First Amendment limits. The Fourth Circuit disagreed, holding that the personalized character combinations are private speech, and sent the case back for further proceedings on whether the recall was constitutional under the rules that apply to private speech on government property.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether personalized messages that drivers choose for their license plates count as the government's own speech, which the state can freely control, or as private speech by the driver, which the government may regulate only within First Amendment limits. The petition says courts around the country disagree on this question.

Where it stands

The commissioner filed a petition asking the Court to take up the case on October 29, 2026. The respondent's response is due December 3, 2026, and the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Virginia's commissioner, who lost at the Fourth Circuit, is asking the Court to take the case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether Virginia's personalized plates are government speech, deciding nothing yet. If it denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's ruling stands, meaning Whateley's claim proceeds in the lower court under private-speech rules, and Virginia's recall of his plate would face First Amendment scrutiny.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 3, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Jack's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Jack's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Virginia asks the Supreme Court to decide whether the letters on personalized "vanity" license plates are the state's own speech, which it may control, or the driver's private speech, which the First Amendment protects. We predict the Court will most likely turn the case down, at about a one-in-six chance of taking it. Courts genuinely disagree on the question. But the lower court sent the case back for more proceedings rather than ending it, and the Justices declined a similar Tennessee case last year.

    Why this big-case score: Government-speech line for vanity plates touches every state's plate program and the Walker/Shurtleff doctrine; a plate case, not a landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline Virginia's appeal than to hear it: I estimate a 32% chance of review, roughly one in three. Courts disagree about whether personalized license-plate messages are the driver's speech or the state's, making this a serious candidate. But the lower courts have not finished deciding whether Virginia's restrictions are lawful, and Virginia could still win there. If the justices take the case, full briefing and argument are much more likely than an immediate ruling.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring national First Amendment question about personalized license plates, with consequences for state speech programs but a relatively bounded immediate subject.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny Virginia's petition for review, with an 18% chance (roughly one in five) of a grant. After Virginia recalled a driver's `"FTP&ATF"` personalized license plate as offensive, the Fourth Circuit ruled that custom vanity plate messages are private speech protected by the First Amendment rather than government speech. Although state supreme courts in Tennessee and Indiana have reached the opposite conclusion, the Fourth Circuit merely sent the case back to the trial court to decide whether Virginia's recall is still valid as a reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rule, making the Supreme Court likely to wait for a final judgment before stepping in.

    Why this big-case score: Resolving whether state vanity license plates are government speech under Walker or private speech subject to First Amendment forum analysis affects millions of personalized plates nationwide and an acknowledged federal-state split, though the interlocutory remand posture narrows its immediate remedial scope.

Rivera-Perez v. FlowersA federal prisoner asks the Court to decide whether credits he earned for completing prison programs can shorten his supervised release.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.56
0.35
0.45

Raul Rivera-Perez v. Caryn Flowers, WardenNo. 26-396 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000396 · models differ by up to 0.21

A federal prisoner asks the Court to decide whether credits he earned for completing prison programs can shorten his supervised release.

What happened

Raul Rivera-Perez earned more than 700 days of credit under the First Step Act for completing recidivism-reduction programming in prison. The Bureau of Prisons applied some credits to move him into prerelease custody early but treated the rest as unusable. He filed a habeas petition arguing the remaining credits should shorten his term of supervised release, the period of monitored freedom that follows imprisonment. The district court agreed. A divided Second Circuit panel reversed, holding the credits cannot reduce supervised release, only accelerate its start, and ordered the case dismissed as moot. The Second Circuit's ruling agreed with the Sixth Circuit but conflicted with the Ninth Circuit, which allows credits to shorten supervised release.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law letting prisoners earn credits for completing rehabilitation programs allows those credits to shorten the time a person must spend on supervised release afterward, rather than only moving up when that supervised period begins.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the November 6, 2026 conference. Before that conference, the Court asked for a response from the government, which had originally waived its right to respond; that response is now due December 14, 2026 after an extension, and an outside group has filed a brief supporting the petition. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Rivera-Perez, who lost in the court of appeals, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, deciding nothing yet about who is right. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, meaning Rivera-Perez and others in that circuit and the Sixth Circuit could not use leftover credits to shorten supervised release, while prisoners in the Ninth Circuit still could under that circuit's contrary rule.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 14, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Rivera-Perez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Rivera-Perez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Raul Rivera-Perez's appeal, but we put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in three, which is far higher than usual. The case asks whether prison "time credits" earned under the First Step Act can shorten the period of supervision after release. Federal appeals courts disagree, and the Court asked the government to respond. However, the Court refused a similar case earlier this year, and the government will probably oppose review again.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring First Step Act time-credit question affecting thousands of federal prisoners each year; statutory, not constitutional.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than hear it, but review has a meaningful chance—about 36%, or a little more than one in three. The case asks whether credits earned through prison programs can shorten supervision after release. Federal appeals courts disagree, and this prisoner appears to present the issue more cleanly than an earlier rejected case. Still, asking the government to respond does not mean the Court will take the case. Another scheduling step and then an unexplained denial are the likeliest path.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring, nationwide federal sentencing-administration question affecting earned credits and the duration of supervision, but not a broad constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Rivera-Perez v. Flowers*, with a 42% chance (a little under even odds) of granting the case. The petitioner asks whether federal prisoners can use rehabilitation credits earned under the First Step Act to shorten their post-prison supervised release, an issue on which federal appeals courts are divided. Although the Court requested a response from the government and the case cleanly presents that conflict, the lower court's ruling matches the majority view that those credits only allow prisoners to leave prison up to a year early, making a denial slightly more likely than a grant.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a recurring circuit split over whether First Step Act earned time credits under 18 U.S.C. 3632(d)(4)(C) can reduce a federal prisoner's term of supervised release, affecting thousands of federal inmates.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to most likely turn down this case, but the chance it takes it is unusually high, about three in ten. The case asks whether federal prisoners can use "time credits" earned through rehabilitation programs to shorten their post-prison supervision. Federal appeals courts disagree, which the government has admitted, and the Court has asked the government to respond. Against that, the Court declined a similar case in April 2026, and the government is expected to oppose review.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring First Step Act credit question affecting thousands of federal prisoners each year; statutory and narrow, not constitutional.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely to turn this case away than hear it: I estimate about a two-in-five chance of review. Rivera-Perez argues that credits earned through prison programs should shorten supervision after release, and federal appeals courts disagree. That conflict and the Court's request for a government response make review a serious possibility. Still, the Court recently declined a similar case. I expect another conference listing after the government responds, followed most likely by a denial without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring federal sentencing-administration question affecting the duration of supervision for many prisoners, but narrower than a constitutional or systemwide criminal-procedure ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Rivera-Perez v. Flowers*, with only a 1% chance of granting the petition. Petitioner asks whether time credits earned by federal inmates under the First Step Act of 2018 can shorten post-prison supervised release (court-monitored supervision in the community after incarceration). All eight federal appeals courts to consider this question agree that those credits cannot reduce supervised release, the Supreme Court recently rejected the same issue in another case, and the federal government waived its response without the Court requesting one.

    Why this big-case score: Routine statutory interpretation question under the First Step Act of 2018 (18 U.S.C. 3632(d)(4)(C)) affecting calculation of federal supervised release terms, with uniform circuit precedent and moderate practical stakes for federal prisoners.

Julio del Rio, et al. v. CrowdStrike, Incorporated, et al.Air travelers whose flights were disrupted by the 2024 CrowdStrike software outage ask the Court to revive their lawsuit against CrowdStrike over its software defects.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.30
0.63
0.42
0.45

Julio del Rio, et al. v. CrowdStrike, Incorporated, et al.No. 26-355 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000355 · models differ by up to 0.33 · topic: Business & finance

Air travelers whose flights were disrupted by the 2024 CrowdStrike software outage ask the Court to revive their lawsuit against CrowdStrike over its software defects.

What happened

Julio del Rio and several other travelers had flights delayed or canceled after a faulty CrowdStrike software update caused a widespread computer outage in July 2024, which disrupted airline computer systems. They sued CrowdStrike in federal court for negligence and related claims, seeking damages for expenses like hotels, meals, and rebooking costs. The district court dismissed the case, ruling that a federal aviation law preempts their claims because the claims relate to airline services. The Fifth Circuit affirmed that decision without issuing a written opinion, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal law that blocks state-law lawsuits touching on airline prices, routes, or services also blocks claims against an outside software company whose product airlines used, where that company does not transport passengers, does not deal directly with passengers, and has no business relationship with them. The petition argues that federal appeals courts disagree about how broadly to define an airline "service" for these purposes, and that this case lets the Court resolve that disagreement.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference. The Court then asked CrowdStrike to respond, and CrowdStrike's deadline to do so has since been extended to December 18, 2026. No action on the petition itself is yet recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Del Rio and the other travelers are asking the Court to overturn the Fifth Circuit's ruling in favor of CrowdStrike. If the Court grants the petition, it would take up the case and decide whether the law covers claims like theirs, with no outcome yet determined. If it denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving their claims against CrowdStrike barred. A grant would not itself decide who wins; it would simply mean the issue gets full briefing and argument.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 18, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to **decline** to hear this case (roughly a 1-in-25 chance it takes it). Travelers sued CrowdStrike over the July 2024 software outage that grounded flights. The lower courts said a federal airline-deregulation law blocks those state-law claims. The Supreme Court has asked CrowdStrike to respond, which shows some interest. But the appeals court affirmed in a one-line order with no explanation, and the Court has left this disagreement among appeals courts unresolved for decades. That makes this case a weak candidate.

    Why this big-case score: The July 2024 CrowdStrike outage was a widely covered event and ADA 'service' preemption is a recurring split, but the question as framed (third-party software vendors) is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.63·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I put the chance of review at about one in nine, or 11%. Travelers want to sue CrowdStrike over flight disruptions caused by faulty software. Asking the company to respond shows some interest, but the lower appeals court issued no explanation, and the petition does not clearly establish conflicting appeals-court rulings about comparable software vendors. The broader issue—when federal airline law prevents ordinary state-law claims—is important, but that alone is unlikely to secure review.

    Why this big-case score: A decision could materially define airline vendors' exposure to state tort liability after widespread technology failures, but the issue remains a specialized statutory-preemption question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Julio del Rio v. CrowdStrike, Inc.*, putting the chance that the Court takes the case at 8% (fewer than one in ten). Airline passengers sued the cybersecurity company CrowdStrike after its faulty July 2024 software update grounded Delta flights, and lower courts threw out the lawsuit partly because a federal airline-deregulation law blocks state lawsuits related to airline services. Although the Supreme Court asked CrowdStrike to respond to the passengers' appeal, the lower appellate court issued an unpublished, one-word ruling and the trial judge also dismissed the claims on independent state-law grounds, making this a poor case for the Justices to hear.

    Why this big-case score: Addresses whether Airline Deregulation Act preemption shields third-party software vendors like CrowdStrike from passenger tort claims arising out of the July 2024 global IT outage.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case (about a 1-in-20 chance it agrees). Passengers sued CrowdStrike over the July 2024 software outage that grounded flights. The lower courts held that a federal airline-deregulation law blocks those state-law claims. The Court did ask CrowdStrike to file a response, which is a mild sign of interest. But the appeals court affirmed without writing an opinion, and the Justices have long left the underlying disagreement among the lower courts unresolved.

    Why this big-case score: Arises from the July 2024 CrowdStrike outage and the reach of ADA preemption to non-carrier vendors; salient facts, but a no-opinion affirmance on a long-tolerated split.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.62·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal: I estimate a 12% chance it takes the case. Passengers argue that federal airline law should not protect CrowdStrike from lawsuits over its software outage. The Court has requested a response, showing some interest, and lower courts disagree about the law's reach. But the appeals court supplied no explanation, and the case may not cleanly resolve that disagreement. Expect another scheduling step before a decision, probably without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential limits on airline-preemption protection for independent technology vendors and passenger remedies after a nationwide outage, but a statutory tort-liability dispute rather than a foundational constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review (94% chance of denial; 6% chance of grant) in *del Rio v. CrowdStrike, Inc.* Airline passengers sued cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike under state law for flight delays and cancellations caused by its July 2024 global software outage, and lower courts held those claims preempted—meaning blocked by federal law—under the Airline Deregulation Act. Although the Court requested a response from CrowdStrike, it rarely reviews one-word, non-precedential appellate orders where courts are not divided on the specific issue.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided on the merits, a ruling defining whether the Airline Deregulation Act preempts state-law tort claims against third-party software vendors arising from nationwide flight disruptions (the July 2024 CrowdStrike outage), and potentially resolving the circuit split over 'service of an air carrier' under 49 U.S.C. § 41713(b)(1), would carry meaningful commercial and statutory-preemption significance across the aviation and enterprise-software sectors.

Maxwell v. DinisA federal prisoner asked the Court to decide whether a claim seeking earlier transfer to a halfway house or home confinement can be brought through habeas corpus.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.40
0.48
0.45
0.44

William Maxwell v. Sandra Dinis, Acting WardenNo. 25-5930 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281102 · models differ by up to 0.08 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

A federal prisoner asked the Court to decide whether a claim seeking earlier transfer to a halfway house or home confinement can be brought through habeas corpus.

What happened

William Maxwell, a federal prisoner, sought transfer to a halfway house or home confinement based on time credits he says he earned under the First Step Act. After prison officials denied his request, he filed a habeas petition in federal district court. The district court dismissed the petition, finding he had not exhausted his required administrative appeals on the First Step Act claim. The court of appeals affirmed on a different ground: it held that habeas is never the right vehicle for this kind of claim unless a favorable ruling would entitle the prisoner to immediate release, and that Maxwell's claim, since it sought only transfer to less restrictive custody, had to be brought instead as a civil rights suit.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a prisoner's claim that officials wrongly withheld earned time credits, where the prisoner is seeking faster transfer to a halfway house or home confinement rather than outright release, can be raised through a habeas corpus petition, or whether it must instead proceed through a different kind of lawsuit.

Where it stands

The Court granted review limited to this question, and the case was argued on November 2, 2026. The case now awaits decision. The federal government, as respondent, told the Court it agrees the lower court's reasoning was wrong and urged the Court to send the case back for further proceedings, while a court-appointed lawyer argued separately in support of the lower court's judgment.

What each outcome would mean

Maxwell, the prisoner, is asking the Court to reverse the lower court's decision. If the Court affirms, the rule barring this kind of claim from habeas would stand, and Maxwell's case would remain dismissed, though he could potentially pursue other legal avenues. If the Court reverses, it would hold that such claims can be brought in habeas, and the case would likely return to the lower courts to resolve other issues, including whether Maxwell properly exhausted his administrative remedies and whether a separate statute bars judicial review of these placement decisions altogether. If the Court vacates, the lower court's decision would be set aside and the case sent back without a final resolution of the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Maxwell wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: Dinis wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Settles the procedural vehicle for a high-volume class of federal-prisoner First Step Act time-credit claims and a lopsided circuit split; important to prison litigation but a remedial-vehicle question, not a landmark.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Important access-to-habeas question for federal prisoners seeking statutory prerelease custody, but narrower than a general conditions-of-confinement or sentencing-rights decision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine federal prisoner litigation concerning the procedural vehicle (28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas vs. civil action) for challenging BOP community-confinement denials and liberal construction of pro se FTCA pleadings; significant for prison litigation practice but modest broader public salience.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Settles the procedural vehicle for a recurring, high-volume class of federal-prisoner First Step Act time-credit claims and resolves a split with the Fifth Circuit; doctrinally a habeas-scope question rather than a headline constitutional case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.59·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally consequential for federal prisoners seeking earned-credit transfers into the community and for the habeas/civil-rights boundary, but narrower than a ruling granting substantive credit or release entitlements.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 79%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves an entrenched 3-2 circuit split over whether federal prisoners' First Step Act prerelease-custody claims are cognizable in habeas under 28 U.S.C. 2241, affecting thousands of federal inmates, though the Solicitor General's confession of error and unreached threshold defenses (exhaustion and 18 U.S.C. 3621(b)) point toward a narrow vacatur and remand.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think the Supreme Court will very likely (about 85%) throw out the Fifth Circuit's ruling and send the case back. That court said a federal prisoner cannot use habeas corpus (a court petition challenging unlawful imprisonment) to demand an earlier move to a halfway house or home confinement under the First Step Act. The government itself now agrees that ruling was wrong, and most Justices seemed to agree at argument. We expect a 7–2 vote, with Justices Thomas and Alito likely dissenting or preferring to dismiss the case.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring, practically important habeas-vehicle question for First Step Act time credits across federal prisons, but narrow doctrinally and likely to be decided on a limited Preiser-based rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about an 86% chance—to set aside the lower court's judgment. I expect a 7–2 decision sending the case back, allowing Maxwell to use habeas corpus, the procedure for challenging unlawful custody, to seek earlier transfer from prison to a halfway house or home confinement. Both Maxwell and the government agree that this procedure is available. The ruling would not order his release or settle other legal obstacles. A possible dismissal and his approaching transfer create uncertainty.

    Why this big-case score: Important access-to-court question for prisoners claiming earned-time credits, with possible state-prisoner implications, but the likely holding is narrow and does not itself determine release eligibility.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (88% chance) to disturb the Fifth Circuit's decision in *Maxwell v. Dinis*, most likely by vacating the judgment (wiping away the lower court's ruling) by a unanimous 9-0 vote and sending the case back for further proceedings. Both the prisoner and the federal government agree that the Fifth Circuit was wrong to hold that federal inmates cannot use habeas corpus (a legal petition challenging unlawful detention) to seek earlier transfer out of prison into a halfway house or home confinement using earned First Step Act time credits, and the Justices across the ideological spectrum rejected the Court-appointed amicus lawyer's defense of that rule at oral argument while leaving procedural defenses like administrative exhaustion for the lower court to address on remand.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a circuit split over whether federal prisoners may use 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petitions to seek accelerated transfer from prison to prerelease custody under the First Step Act, a recurring procedural question affecting thousands of federal inmates.

Benjamin M. Bauer v. Anne Elizabeth Alma MarksA Minneapolis police officer asks the Court to revive his qualified immunity defense after lower courts let an excessive-force lawsuit over a protest shooting proceed to trial.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.35
0.57
0.40
0.44

Benjamin M. Bauer v. Anne Elizabeth Alma MarksNo. 25-1413 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73527306 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Constitutional rights

A Minneapolis police officer asks the Court to revive his qualified immunity defense after lower courts let an excessive-force lawsuit over a protest shooting proceed to trial.

What happened

In 2020, during unrest following George Floyd's death, Officer Benjamin Bauer shot Ethan Marks in the eye with a "less-lethal" projectile launcher, causing severe injuries; Marks later died, and his mother, Anne Marks, continued the suit. Marks sued for excessive force. The district court denied Bauer qualified immunity, finding disputed facts about the threat Marks posed. The Eighth Circuit affirmed. The Supreme Court earlier vacated that ruling and sent the case back for reconsideration under a newer decision on how courts should weigh the full sequence of events, not just the instant force was used. On remand, the Eighth Circuit again ruled against Bauer, saying it had already applied that approach. Bauer again asks the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, considering everything leading up to the shooting and not just the instant it happened, it was already clearly settled that using this kind of projectile on someone in Marks's position was an unreasonable use of force — the standard that determines whether an officer can be sued personally despite qualified immunity.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for several conferences, most recently November 13, 2026, and the docket shows no action on it as of the snapshot date.

What each outcome would mean

Bauer, the officer, is asking the Court to reverse the Eighth Circuit's decision, which left in place the denial of qualified immunity and allowed Marks's lawsuit to continue. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If it denies review, the Eighth Circuit's ruling stands, and the case returns to the lower courts for trial on Marks's excessive-force claim.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A George Floyd-protest less-lethal-munitions shooting and a second trip to the Court after a Barnes GVR; a summary reversal would be widely noted in the qualified-immunity debate, but any disposition is fact-bound and sets no new rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Police use of less-lethal projectiles, qualified immunity, and compliance with a Supreme Court remand have substantial civil-rights and policing stakes, but this fact-intensive interlocutory dispute is narrower than a categorical nationwide rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 60%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Stacey Ian Humphreys v. Georgia Board of Pardons and ParolesA death row inmate asked the Court to pause his execution while it considered his appeal, then withdrew that request.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.72
—
0.43 2 of 3 models

Stacey Ian Humphreys v. Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles, et al.No. 26A273 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000273 · models differ by up to 0.57 · topic: Constitutional rights

A death row inmate asked the Court to pause his execution while it considered his appeal, then withdrew that request.

What happened

Stacey Ian Humphreys, sentenced to death in Georgia, sued in Fulton County Superior Court arguing that a member of the state's Board of Pardons and Paroles had a conflict of interest and should be barred from voting on his clemency application. The court agreed the member was conflicted but ultimately ruled that only a quorum, not all five board members, was legally required to decide clemency, leaving the case to proceed with four members. The Georgia Supreme Court denied review. Humphreys then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the case, arguing the procedure violated his rights to due process and equal protection, and asked for a stay of his September 16, 2026 execution while that petition was considered.

What the Court is being asked

The application asked the Court to pause the execution temporarily so it would have time to decide whether to hear Humphreys's underlying appeal, which argues that letting fewer than five board members decide his clemency bid, after one member was found conflicted, treated him unfairly compared to other applicants and denied him a fair process.

Where it stands

Georgia filed an opposition and Humphreys filed a reply, but on September 25, 2026, Humphreys's counsel filed a letter withdrawing the stay application, and the docket records the application as withdrawn that same day.

What each outcome would mean

Humphreys, as the applicant, had asked the Court to pause his execution. Because he withdrew the request, the Court did not grant or deny a stay, and no order paused the execution on this application. The underlying petition asking the Court to hear his broader constitutional challenge, filed separately, is not resolved by this withdrawal and continues on its own track before the Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofSep 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court ruleswithdrawnSep 25, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-09-25: the Court withdrawn. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital execution stay is life-or-death for the applicant and draws regional press, but the underlying claim — a due-process challenge to Georgia clemency-board procedures — is doctrinally narrow under Woodard and unlikely to produce law beyond this case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.72·Chance the Court grants the application: 8%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An execution stay tied to the constitutional minimum for capital clemency is exceptionally consequential and could affect other state clemency systems, although the dispute's unusual Georgia-board facts narrow its reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 5%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Holly Ann Elkins v. United StatesThe Supreme Court declined to hear Holly Elkins's challenge to her cyberstalking conviction, which argued that using a phone alone cannot justify federal jurisdiction.Criminal lawdecided
0.50
0.60
0.20
0.43

Holly Ann Elkins v. United StatesNo. 25-1061 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281345 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear Holly Elkins's challenge to her cyberstalking conviction, which argued that using a phone alone cannot justify federal jurisdiction.

What happened

Holly Elkins was convicted of conspiring to stalk and cyberstalking her fiancé's ex-girlfriend, Alyssa Burkett, who was later murdered by Elkins's fiancé. Elkins argued the federal cyberstalking law could not constitutionally apply to her because her only connection to interstate commerce was intrastate phone use. The district court and the Fifth Circuit rejected that argument, treating phones as automatically within Congress's power to regulate, though the appeals court separately threw out a related firearm conviction on other grounds. Elkins asked the Supreme Court to review the Commerce Clause question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether Congress may rely on someone's use of a telephone, by itself, to support a federal cyberstalking charge, or whether prosecutors must also show that the phone use actually affected commerce between states. Elkins pointed to a Tenth Circuit decision treating vehicles differently, arguing some courts require proof of an actual commercial connection while the Fifth Circuit treats phone use as automatically sufficient.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, received full briefing including a response from the government and a reply from Elkins, and the Supreme Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Elkins, the petitioner, asked the Court to take up her case and overturn the Fifth Circuit's ruling. The denial means the Court will not review the question, leaving the Fifth Circuit's decision in place: Elkins's convictions for conspiracy and cyberstalking stand, upheld on the view that intrastate phone use alone satisfies the Commerce Clause. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with that approach, only that it chose not to decide the issue now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a ruling on whether intrastate use of a phone alone satisfies Lopez category 2 would reach many federal criminal statutes keyed on a 'facility of interstate commerce'; stakes are moderate-high on the doctrine but the likeliest merits answer would simply confirm the circuit consensus.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question could reshape federal criminal jurisdiction over intrastate conduct involving phones and other communications networks, beyond cyberstalking. The life sentence makes the individual stakes severe, although the disputed circuit conflict and alternative jurisdictional facts limit this vehicle's breadth.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Criminal statutory interpretation case; important for Commerce Clause limits but low general public stakes.

Walls v. Prince George's CountyThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Maryland landowner's bid to revive his lawsuit claiming the county's permit process unlawfully blocked development of his land.decided
0.30
0.52
0.48
0.43

Garnell Walls v. Prince George's County, Maryland, et al.No. 26-107 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000107 · models differ by up to 0.22

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Maryland landowner's bid to revive his lawsuit claiming the county's permit process unlawfully blocked development of his land.

What happened

Garnell Walls owns vacant land in Prince George's County, Maryland, where he hoped to build a home using a private well and septic system because public utility connections were prohibitively expensive. The county denied his request for a waiver to use such a system, and suggested he instead seek a legislative change to the county's water and sewer plan. Walls sued, claiming this amounted to an unconstitutional taking of his property without compensation. A federal district court dismissed his claim as not ready for review, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that Walls had not shown the county reached a truly final decision because he had not pursued the legislative amendment process.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a property owner must first try to get a local legislature to change the law before a court will hear a claim that the law took his property without compensation, and whether the timing requirement that a government decision be final before a takings claim can proceed is a rule the court must apply or one it can choose to set aside.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, most recently in November 2026, and the Court denied it without further explanation.

What each outcome would mean

Walls, the property owner, asked the Court to take up his case after losing in the lower courts. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fourth Circuit's ruling in place: Walls' lawsuit remains dismissed, and he would need to pursue the county's legislative amendment process, or otherwise obtain a more definitive decision from the county, before a court would consider his constitutional claim. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case, though not with certainty: we put the chance it takes the case, or sends it back to the lower court, at about one in eight. A Maryland landowner says county rules that block a well and septic system took his property without payment. The lower court said he had to ask the county council to change the rules before he could sue. The Court asked the county to respond, a sign of some interest. But the lower-court ruling was short and unpublished, and it turns on this case's particular facts, which makes the case a weak vehicle.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring takings-ripeness question (legislative exhaustion; prudential vs jurisdictional ripeness) with property-rights amici, but on a single-lot well-and-septic dispute from an unpublished opinion.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than hear it: I estimate about a one-in-four chance of review. A homeowner argues that he should not have to ask local lawmakers to change the rules before seeking compensation for restrictions on his land. The Court's request for a response and several supporting briefs make the petition noteworthy. But the lower court's narrow reasoning and a problem with how the broader issue was raised make review less likely.

    Why this big-case score: A decision could materially change property owners' access to federal takings litigation nationwide, though this dispute concerns one residential lot and a narrow finality question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Garnell Walls v. Prince George's County*, with about a one-in-seventeen chance (6%) of granting the petition. Property owner Garnell Walls argues that the County unconstitutionally took his land without compensation—a "regulatory taking"—by refusing to let him install a temporary well and septic system, and that lower courts wrongly dismissed his lawsuit as premature ("unripe") because he did not petition the County Council to amend its water-and-sewer plan. Although six supporting "friend of the court" briefs prompted the Justices to request a response from the County, the lower-court ruling is an unpublished decision and the record shows Walls may never have properly completed the initial administrative waiver application, making this a poor test case.

    Why this big-case score: Resolving whether Williamson County finality requires property owners to seek legislative rezoning/plan amendments after Pakdel and whether prudential ripeness can defeat Article III standing under Lexmark would meaningfully reshape federal land-use and takings litigation.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A justiciability question for Fifth Amendment takings claims (legislative exhaustion; jurisdictional vs prudential ripeness) that matters to the land-use bar and property-rights litigants nationally, but a single-lot well-and-septic dispute with low public salience; moderate stakes if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single-owner land-use dispute presenting potentially nationwide limits on legislative-exhaustion and prudential-ripeness barriers to takings suits; consequential for property owners and local governments, but not a direct nationwide invalidation of land-use regulation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Golden v. NBCUniversal MediaA consumer asks the Court to revive her privacy lawsuit against NBCUniversal over video-watching data shared with Facebook.awaiting the Court
0.35
0.57
0.38
0.43

Sherhonda Golden v. NBCUniversal Media, LLCNo. 26-398 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000398 · models differ by up to 0.22

A consumer asks the Court to revive her privacy lawsuit against NBCUniversal over video-watching data shared with Facebook.

What happened

Sherhonda Golden sued NBCUniversal, claiming it violated a federal video privacy law by sharing her Facebook ID and video-viewing history with Facebook through tracking code on Today.com, without her consent. The district court dismissed her claim, and the Second Circuit affirmed, applying its own prior ruling that such information counts as protected only if an "ordinary person" could decipher it, not just a tech company like Facebook. Golden argues NBCUniversal knew Facebook would understand the disclosure, and that other appeals courts apply a different, broader test that would have let her claim proceed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a company that shares coded information knowing the recipient can identify a person's video-watching history has broken the law, even if an average person looking at the same code could not figure out what it means.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference; the docket does not yet show a decision on it. NBCUniversal initially waived its right to respond but was then asked to respond, and its deadline to do so has since been extended to December 23, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Golden is asking the Court to take up her case and overturn the Second Circuit's ruling against her. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide which legal test applies, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's decision dismissing Golden's claim stands, and NBCUniversal's win in the lower courts remains in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Golden's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Golden's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Sherhonda Golden's appeal against NBCUniversal. We put the chance it takes the case, or sends it back to the lower court for another look, at about 7 in 100. The case asks whether a website that shares viewing data with Facebook breaks a federal video-privacy law. The Court asked NBCUniversal to respond, which is a mild sign of interest. But it has already declined this same question twice in the past year. It may set the petition aside until it decides a related video-privacy case, Salazar v. Paramount Global, likely by mid-2027.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring Meta-Pixel VPPA question with large class-action exposure across the media industry, but a statutory privacy issue of moderate public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Sherhonda Golden's appeal, with about a one-in-five chance of granting review or sending the case back for another look. Her lawsuit asks whether federal video-privacy law protects information Facebook can decode even when an ordinary person cannot. The Court's request for a response shows interest, and lower courts disagree. But it recently declined a similar case. Another pending video-privacy case could affect the timing, though it addresses a different part of the law.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of federal video-viewing privacy protection for online tracking has substantial consumer and industry consequences, but the question is a bounded statutory one.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (96% chance) to deny Sherhonda Golden's request to review her lawsuit against NBCUniversal under the Video Privacy Protection Act, a federal law that forbids video providers from sharing records of what videos a customer watches. Golden claims NBCUniversal violated this law when its Today.com website used tracking code to send her numeric Facebook ID and the titles of videos she watched to Meta, and the lower courts dismissed her case because an ordinary person looking at that computer code could not identify her. Although the Supreme Court asked NBCUniversal to file a written response to her petition, the Court already turned down two nearly identical appeals from the same appeals court inside the past year, and a separate video-privacy case currently before the Court (*Salazar v. Paramount Global*) deals with a different issue that cannot overturn the reason Golden lost below.

    Why this big-case score: A Supreme Court decision defining 'personally identifiable information' under the Video Privacy Protection Act for third-party tracking pixels would carry significant commercial consequences for digital media publishers and ad-tech platforms nationwide.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely refuse to hear this case; we put the chance it takes the case, or sends it back for another look, at about one in ten. The case asks whether NBCUniversal broke a federal video-privacy law by sharing viewing data with Facebook. The Court asked NBCUniversal to respond, which signals some interest. But the Court has already turned down this same question twice. The likeliest exception is that it holds the case until it decides a related video-privacy case, then returns it to the lower court.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring VPPA question with large class-action exposure for online video providers (Meta Pixel cases), but a narrow statutory question with modest public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 19%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely decline to hear Sherhonda Golden's privacy lawsuit against NBCUniversal. I estimate about a one-in-five chance of review or an order sending the case back for reconsideration. Federal appeals courts disagree about whether coded video-viewing data counts as identifying information, but the Court recently declined similar cases. It has requested NBCUniversal's response, so further scheduling is very likely. Another pending video-privacy case could prompt a delay, but it concerns a different part of the law.

    Why this big-case score: Potential nationwide consequences for online video tracking, consumer privacy, and statutory damages, but a bounded statutory-definition dispute rather than a constitutional restructuring.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Sherhonda Golden v. NBCUniversal Media, LLC*, with only a 4% chance of granting the petition (about one in twenty-five). Golden asks the Court to revive a lawsuit under the Video Privacy Protection Act alleging that Today.com shared her video-viewing history and Facebook ID with Meta through tracking code, or else to hold the case for *Salazar v. Paramount Global*, another pending case under the same statute. However, the Court has already declined twice in the past year to review the Second Circuit's rule that such coded data is not "personally identifiable information" because an ordinary person cannot read it, and that independent ground supports dismissal regardless of how *Salazar* is decided.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision on whether third-party tracking pixel disclosures constitute 'personally identifiable information' under the Video Privacy Protection Act would resolve a 3-1 circuit split and govern massive statutory-damages class exposure across online media publishers, though its reach is confined to a single statutory definition.

Oregon v. ManeyOregon asked the Supreme Court to review a prisoners' lawsuit over its pandemic response, then the parties jointly dismissed the petition.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.40
0.58
0.30
0.43

Oregon, et al. v. Paul Maney, et al.No. 25-960 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281004 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Constitutional rights

Oregon asked the Supreme Court to review a prisoners' lawsuit over its pandemic response, then the parties jointly dismissed the petition.

What happened

Prisoners in Oregon's custody sued the state and corrections officials, arguing that Oregon's overall response to COVID-19 across its prisons between March 2020 and May 2022 violated their constitutional protection against cruel and unusual punishment. A federal district court denied the officials' request for qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields government officials from damages lawsuits unless they violated clearly established rights. A jury, the court said, could decide whether the state's pandemic measures were reasonable overall. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, and later denied rehearing. Oregon then asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

Oregon asked the Court to decide two things: first, whether prisoners can bring a single constitutional claim challenging a state's overall, multi-year pandemic response across many facilities, rather than specific actions by specific officials; and second, whether it was already clear, back in 2020, that such a broad response could count as cruel and unusual punishment, especially since a judge had ruled in June 2020 that Oregon's early response was constitutional.

Where it stands

After the petition was filed, the respondents waived their right to respond, but the Court later asked for a response anyway. Before that response was due, the parties jointly asked to dismiss the petition, and the Court dismissed it in July 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Oregon, the officials who lost below, asked the Court to take up the case. The joint dismissal ends the case at the Supreme Court without any ruling on the questions raised. The Ninth Circuit's decision denying qualified immunity to the Oregon officials remains in place, meaning the prisoners' lawsuit can continue toward a jury trial on whether the state's pandemic response was reasonable. No broader legal rule was decided for other cases.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesDismissedJul 17, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-07-17: the Court dismissed it. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: dismiss itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    State-AG petition on aggregate Eighth Amendment liability and qualified immunity for a statewide COVID-19 prison response would matter to every state corrections system if decided, but the QPs are error-correction-flavored and the parties are settling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: dismiss itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling could materially affect statewide prison-emergency administration and qualified-immunity exposure, though the unpublished posture and pending dismissal reduce its practical salience.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: dismiss itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    COVID-19 Eighth Amendment challenges have constitutional significance but represent backward-looking disputes about emergency measures.

Pileggi v. Washington Newspaper PublishingNicole Pileggi asks the Court to send her online-privacy lawsuit against a news publisher back for another look once it decides a similar case already pending before it.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.20
0.68
0.40
0.43

Nicole Pileggi v. Washington Newspaper Publishing Company, LLCNo. 25-1040 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281327 · models differ by up to 0.48 · topic: Business & finance

Nicole Pileggi asks the Court to send her online-privacy lawsuit against a news publisher back for another look once it decides a similar case already pending before it.

What happened

Nicole Pileggi sued Washington Newspaper Publishing Company, which operates the Washington Examiner, claiming it violated a federal video privacy law by sharing her website video-watching history with Facebook without her consent. She argued that subscribing to the Examiner's free email newsletter made her a protected "consumer" under the law. The district court dismissed her claim, finding no connection between her newsletter subscription and the videos she watched on the website. The D.C. Circuit affirmed, joining the Sixth Circuit in holding that a person must subscribe to video content itself, not just any good or service, to qualify as a consumer under the statute.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide what kind of subscription qualifies someone for the privacy law's protection: whether signing up for any product or service from a company that also provides videos is enough, or whether the person must specifically subscribe to video content itself. The Court has already agreed to decide this same question in another case.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on May 14, 2026, after full briefing, including a response from Washington Newspaper. The docket shows no action since that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Pileggi is asking the Court to act. Washington Newspaper, which won below, agrees the petition should be held until the Court decides the related case, and says the petition should then be denied if that case favors the defendant, or granted and sent back to the D.C. Circuit if it favors the plaintiff. If the Court denies review, the D.C. Circuit's ruling against Pileggi stands. If the Court grants, vacates, and remands, it would set that ruling aside without deciding who is right, sending the case back for further proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Pileggi's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Pileggi's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 52%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Tag-along companion to Salazar v. Paramount Global (No. 25-459); its own disposition will be a one-line GVR or denial, though the underlying VPPA question matters commercially.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.68·Chance the Court takes the case: 62%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The VPPA question could materially reshape tracking-pixel privacy suits and statutory exposure for online publishers nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A mechanical hold for Salazar v. Paramount Global; the underlying VPPA issue is moderately significant for digital privacy, but this specific petition will be disposed of summarily.

TMX Finance Corporate Services v. SpicherTMX Finance asks the Court to let it pursue federal claims against a Pennsylvania enforcement action rather than having federal courts step aside under a doctrine called abstention.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.35
0.55
0.38
0.43

TMX Finance Corporate Services, Incorporated v. Wendy S. Spicher, Secretary, Pennsylvania Department of Banking and SecuritiesNo. 26-23 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000023 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Civil procedure

TMX Finance asks the Court to let it pursue federal claims against a Pennsylvania enforcement action rather than having federal courts step aside under a doctrine called abstention.

What happened

Pennsylvania's banking regulator investigated TMX-affiliated companies over car-title loans allegedly made to Pennsylvania residents at interest rates exceeding state caps, then brought an administrative enforcement action seeking over $52 million in penalties. TMX Finance Corporate Services, which says it only provided back-office support and never made loans itself, sued in federal court in Texas, arguing the proceeding violates constitutional limits on a state regulating activity outside its borders and improperly targets a company with no ties to Pennsylvania. The district court dismissed the suit under a rule requiring federal courts to step back when important state proceedings are already underway. The Fifth Circuit affirmed. Related companies raising similar claims lost in the Third and Fourth Circuits as well.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state's general interest in enforcing its own laws is strong enough to justify a federal court stepping back from a company's constitutional challenge, when the challenged conduct is a state trying to regulate business dealings that happened across its border in other states. TMX argues courts should weigh this federalism question more carefully rather than accepting any broadly stated state interest; Pennsylvania's regulator responds that courts correctly look only to the general importance of the type of proceeding, not the specifics of the dispute.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the same day the Court asked for a response, which Pennsylvania's regulator filed in November 2026 after two extensions. The docket shows no action yet on the petition itself.

What each outcome would mean

TMX Finance, which lost before the Fifth Circuit, is asking the Court to take up its case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full briefing and argument and decide the abstention question itself, deciding nothing yet about who prevails. If it denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's ruling stands, and TMX's federal suit remains dismissed while Pennsylvania's enforcement proceeding continues. Either way, no decision on the underlying constitutional claims occurs at this stage.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up TMX Finance Corporate Services' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: TMX Finance Corporate Services' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this petition (about a 9% chance it takes the case, roughly one in eleven). A loan-servicing company wants a federal court to hear its challenge to a Pennsylvania enforcement proceeding. The lower court declined, under a rule (called *Younger* abstention) that tells federal courts to stay out of some ongoing state proceedings. The Court asked Pennsylvania to respond, which is a mild sign of interest. But a nearly identical companion petition is pending, and if the Court acts it will more likely take that one and hold this case.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring Younger-abstention question about state enforcement against out-of-state firms; meaningful for federal-courts doctrine and interstate regulation, but technical and not headline-scale.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I estimate about a one-in-seven chance it takes action granting review. TMX argues that Pennsylvania should not be able to keep its constitutional challenge out of federal court while pursuing loans made outside Pennsylvania. The Court's request for a response shows some interest, but most such requests still end in denial. Disagreement among appeals courts helps TMX, while the unpublished ruling, possible argument-preservation problem, and related litigation make this a less straightforward case to choose.

    Why this big-case score: Access to federal court for constitutional challenges to cross-border state enforcement has significance beyond title lending, but this petition concerns a technical abstention issue rather than directly deciding the legality of that enforcement.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *TMX Finance Corporate Services, Inc. v. Spicher*, with only about a one-in-twenty (4.5%) chance of granting the petition. Petitioner, a Texas back-office affiliate of auto-title lenders, asks the Court to allow a federal lawsuit blocking a Pennsylvania administrative enforcement action over high-interest loans made to Pennsylvania residents in other states, which lower federal courts dismissed under *Younger* abstention (a rule keeping federal courts from interfering with ongoing state enforcement proceedings). Although the Court requested a response from Pennsylvania, the unpublished Fifth Circuit decision below creates no binding precedent, the alleged disagreement among federal appeals courts is weak, and a companion petition involving the actual lending companies is already pending.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided, clarifying whether Younger abstention's 'generic' state-interest test applies to state administrative enforcement actions targeting out-of-state companies' extraterritorial transactions would be a meaningful federal-courts ruling on cross-border state regulation, though still a procedural abstention decision rather than a landmark constitutional merits ruling.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on Younger's important-state-interest prong in the extraterritorial-enforcement setting would matter to federal-courts practice and to the growing interstate regulatory fights the petition invokes, but the case is procedural, the petitioner is a back-office affiliate of a title lender, and public attention would be modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question concerns access to federal court for constitutional challenges to interstate state enforcement, potentially reaching beyond consumer lending. The immediate dispute is narrower: one affiliate's challenge to Pennsylvania's usury enforcement.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves state regulatory authority over out-of-state entities (TitleMax) and Younger abstention, but lacks immediate national urgency.

Davie County v. SwinkThe Supreme Court declined to hear two counties' challenge to a ruling letting a former detainee's lawsuit over inadequate jail medical care proceed against them.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.40
0.57
0.30
0.42

Davie County, North Carolina, et al. v. Juiliana Swink, Administratrix of the Estate of David Ray Gunter, et al.No. 25-1091 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281376 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear two counties' challenge to a ruling letting a former detainee's lawsuit over inadequate jail medical care proceed against them.

What happened

David Ray Gunter, who had a mechanical heart valve requiring daily blood-thinning medication, was held in Davie County and Stokes County jails in North Carolina for fifteen days in 2012. Both counties had contracted with Southern Health Partners (SHP) to provide medical care. Gunter's lawsuit says he was not given his medication for several days and was underdosed the rest of the time, leading to blood clots requiring surgery. A federal district court granted summary judgment to the counties, but the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed, holding the counties could be held liable under federal civil rights law because their contracts gave SHP final authority over medical decisions. Gunter has since died; his estate's administrator, Juliana Swink, now represents his claims. The counties asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The counties asked the Court to decide whether a local government can be held responsible for a private healthcare contractor's harmful customs or practices simply because it hired that contractor to run medical care at its jail, or whether this amounts to forbidden liability based solely on an employment relationship. Swink answered that every appeals court to consider the issue agrees that a government can be held liable when it hands over final decision-making authority over inmate healthcare to a contractor, and that this is not the same as liability based solely on employment.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, the Court asked for a response, briefing was completed over the summer, and the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Davie County and Stokes County, as petitioners, asked the Court to reverse the Fourth Circuit's decision reviving Swink's claims against them. By denying the petition, the Court left the Fourth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Swink's lawsuit against the counties can continue in the lower courts. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Fourth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision standing without ruling on the underlying legal question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether a county is liable under Monell for a contracted jail medical provider's policies affects most US jails, which outsource inmate care, but the petition frames a doctrinal Monell question rather than a headline dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could materially affect municipal accountability and contracted jail healthcare nationwide, but the questions concern a specialized Section 1983 liability framework rather than a broad new individual right.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises a widely litigated Monell standard question under Section 1983 for outsourced municipal medical care, but lacks national socio-political impact.

Zook v. FuquaThe Court declined to hear three sheriff's deputies' bid to revive their bid to dismiss a fatal-shooting lawsuit over how courts may treat police video at an early pleading stage.Civil proceduredecided
0.30
0.57
0.40
0.42

Christopher Zook, et al. v. Scott FuquaNo. 25-1108 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281401 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Civil procedure (also Constitutional rights)

The Court declined to hear three sheriff's deputies' bid to revive their bid to dismiss a fatal-shooting lawsuit over how courts may treat police video at an early pleading stage.

What happened

Deputies Zook, Martinez, and Guzman shot and killed Jason Roybal after a vehicle pursuit in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Roybal's estate, represented by Scott Fuqua, sued the deputies for excessive force. The complaint alleged the deputies shot Roybal while he was unarmed and fleeing on foot; it did not mention that he had earlier fired a BB gun at officers or that he was running toward an occupied vehicle, facts shown on video. The deputies asked the district court to dismiss the case and to consider that video, but the court declined and let the case proceed. A divided panel of the Tenth Circuit affirmed, over a dissent.

What the Court is being asked

The deputies asked the Court to decide whether judges may look at video recordings when deciding, at the earliest stage of a lawsuit, whether a complaint describes a plausible claim, even if the complaint itself does not mention the video. They also asked whether a complaint can meet legal pleading standards by leaving out facts the plaintiff knew about, and whether a single past Supreme Court ruling on police shootings was specific enough to show these deputies clearly broke the law.

Where it stands

The Court considered the petition at more than one conference, requested a response from Fuqua, and received supplemental briefing from the deputies. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The deputies asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the Tenth Circuit's ruling, which had let Fuqua's lawsuit continue. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Tenth Circuit's decision in place: the case returns to the lower courts, where Fuqua's lawsuit against the deputies can proceed without the video being considered at this dismissal stage. The denial does not decide who is right on the underlying legal questions; it simply leaves the Tenth Circuit's ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring civil-procedure question (video evidence at Rule 12(b)(6) in section 1983 excessive-force suits) that matters to police-litigation practice but is technical and low-profile; the underlying shooting is a local incident with no national attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Review could establish a recurring nationwide rule for police video evidence at the pleading stage and affect early qualified-immunity litigation. Those procedural and civil-rights stakes are substantial, but the petition does not directly ask the Court to abolish or broadly reconstruct qualified immunity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Excessive force qualified immunity cases are frequently watched, but this primarily resolves a pleading standard circuit split.

Corey Duran Berry v. United StatesCorey Berry asked the Court to decide whether he was wrongly denied permission to appeal a ruling against him on his challenge to a firearm conviction.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.30
0.65
0.32
0.42

Corey Duran Berry v. United StatesNo. 25-7026 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73283862 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

Corey Berry asked the Court to decide whether he was wrongly denied permission to appeal a ruling against him on his challenge to a firearm conviction.

What happened

Berry pleaded guilty to carjacking offenses and a related firearm charge. After the Supreme Court later struck down part of the law underlying that firearm charge, Berry tried to challenge his conviction, but lower courts ruled he had not shown his conviction actually rested on the invalid part of the law. To appeal that ruling, he needed a "certificate of appealability," which requires showing that reasonable judges could disagree with the lower court's decision. The appeals court denied him that certificate, reasoning that circuit precedent foreclosed his claim, even though other circuits apply a more favorable rule. Berry asked the Supreme Court to review that denial.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a prisoner should be allowed to appeal when the legal rule that defeated his claim is binding in his circuit but other circuits have adopted a more favorable rule. The question is whether such a conflict among circuits by itself means judges could reasonably disagree with the lower court, entitling the prisoner to pursue the appeal.

Where it stands

The petition has been through multiple conferences, including a supplemental brief addressing a related case and a request by the government for more time to file its merits brief. The Court granted Berry's petition and motion to proceed without paying fees on October 13, 2026, and the case is now awaiting merits briefing and argument.

What each outcome would mean

Berry, the prisoner, asked the Court to overturn the lower court's denial of permission to appeal. If the Court affirms, the rule denying such appeals when home-circuit precedent forecloses the claim would stand, leaving Berry's conviction in place and unable to be challenged further on this claim. If the Court reverses, Berry would receive the certificate of appealability he sought, allowing his underlying challenge to proceed to a full appeal, though it would not resolve that challenge itself. If the Court vacates, the case would return to the lower court without deciding the issue for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Corey Duran Berry wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The United States wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring, nationally relevant AEDPA gatekeeping rule (whether home-circuit precedent can bar a COA despite an out-of-circuit split), but procedural and low-salience outside habeas practice.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 84%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide rule governing access to appellate review in federal and state-prisoner habeas cases, including capital cases; important procedural reach, but no direct resolution of conviction validity or substantive sentencing law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Technical federal habeas appellate procedure question under 28 U.S.C. 2253(c) resolving a 6-2 circuit split over whether binding circuit precedent categorically bars a certificate of appealability when another circuit disagrees; significant for federal post-conviction and en banc practice in the Fifth and Eleventh Circuits, though modest in broader public salience.

Broadcast Music v. North American Concert Promoters AssociationBroadcast Music asks the Court to decide whether appeals courts must defer to, rather than independently review, a trial court's music-licensing rate decision.awaiting the Court
0.45
0.57
0.25
0.42

Broadcast Music, Inc. v. North American Concert Promoters AssociationNo. 26-238 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000238 · models differ by up to 0.32

Broadcast Music asks the Court to decide whether appeals courts must defer to, rather than independently review, a trial court's music-licensing rate decision.

What happened

Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI) licenses musical works to concert promoters on behalf of songwriters and publishers, operating under an antitrust consent decree that lets a federal district court set rates when BMI and a licensee cannot agree. BMI and the North American Concert Promoters Association (NACPA) failed to agree on new rates, so a district court set a fee after trial. The Second Circuit vacated that decision, holding the district court misapplied legal standards governing how to pick and weigh comparable licensing agreements and define revenue, and sent the case back. BMI's request for rehearing was denied.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an appeals court should independently decide, without deferring to the trial judge, how a lower court picked and weighed comparison licenses and defined revenue in setting a fair licensing rate, or whether it should accept the trial judge's findings unless they are clearly wrong.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, with amicus briefs filed on both sides, and was distributed for the Court's conference of September 28, 2026; the docket shows no action recorded since then.

What each outcome would mean

BMI, which lost at the Second Circuit, is asking the Court to reverse that decision. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling stands, and the case returns to the district court to reset the rate using the appeals court's more independent review standard. If the Court grants review and later rules for BMI, appeals courts would have to defer more to trial judges' rate decisions, which could restore a result closer to the district court's original, higher rate. If it rules for NACPA, the Second Circuit's closer scrutiny of such rulings would be confirmed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Broadcast Music's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Broadcast Music's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down BMI's request to review this case, but the chance it steps in is real: about one in five. The case asks how closely an appeals court should second-guess a trial judge's finding of a "fair market" royalty rate for music played at concerts. The Court asked the other side to respond, and music groups have filed supporting briefs. A similar pending case, RiseandShine v. PepsiCo, could lead the Court to send this one back for another look instead.

    Why this big-case score: Sets the standard of review for every music performing-rights rate-court valuation and potentially for fair-market-value findings generally; commercially significant but technical.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear this dispute over music-performance royalties. I put the chance of any grant of review at about one in four, or 24%. Asking the concert promoters to respond shows interest, but does not promise a hearing. The central dispute is how closely appeals judges should revisit trial judges' valuation decisions. The Court could instead wait for a related trademark case and then send this case back for reconsideration; that possibility accounts for much of the chance of intervention.

    Why this big-case score: Significant for music-performance royalties and appellate review of valuation findings, but a technical consent-decree dispute rather than a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Broadcast Music, Inc.’s petition for review, with an estimated 14% chance (about one in seven) of granting the case. Although the Court asked the concert promoters' association to file a response—an initial sign of interest—and BMI has top-tier appellate counsel challenging how intensely appeals courts may second-guess a trial judge's fair-market-value calculations, several factors weigh heavily against review. Most importantly, the Second Circuit sent the case back to the trial court to recalculate the music-licensing rate, meaning the dispute is not yet final, and the legal rules governing music-licensing consent decrees apply only in New York federal courts rather than dividing federal appeals courts nationwide.

    Why this big-case score: Commercial rate-court dispute over the appellate standard of review for fair-market-value benchmark and revenue-base determinations under the BMI antitrust consent decree; significant financial stakes for the live-concert industry, but low public or constitutional salience.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Sets the royalty rate paid to roughly three million BMI/ASCAP songwriters for live concerts and the appellate standard for every future rate-court decision, against Live Nation/AEG; legally a Rule 52 standard-of-review question, so wide industry stakes but modest general public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute concerns concert-performance royalties and the appellate treatment of valuation evidence, with meaningful industry-wide and potential cross-context consequences, but a technical standard-of-review question rather than a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant standard of review question affecting the music industry and rate courts, with high-profile counsel, but not a landmark constitutional issue.

Genesis Financial Solutions v. FordGenesis asks the Court to decide whether federal arbitration law blocks Maryland's rule that arbitration clauses need their own separate consideration.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.56
0.25
0.42

Genesis Financial Solutions, Inc. v. Steve Ford, et al.No. 25-311 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73277388 · models differ by up to 0.31 · topic: Business & finance

Genesis asks the Court to decide whether federal arbitration law blocks Maryland's rule that arbitration clauses need their own separate consideration.

What happened

Steve Ford sued Genesis Financial Solutions and Spring Oaks Capital, which serviced and later collected his credit card debt, claiming violations of Maryland lending laws. Genesis and Spring Oaks sought to force the dispute into arbitration under a clause in Ford's card agreement. A federal district court refused, ruling that a separate clause letting Genesis change account terms at any time made its promise to arbitrate illusory, leaving the arbitration clause without the independent consideration Maryland law requires for such clauses. The Fourth Circuit affirmed, following its own recent precedent, and denied rehearing as untimely.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether federal arbitration law allows a state to require arbitration clauses, specifically, to be backed by their own separate exchange of promises beyond what supports the rest of the contract, or whether treating arbitration clauses this way improperly singles them out compared to other contract terms.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 14, 2025 conference; the docket shows no action recorded from that conference. The Court then asked for a response, and the response deadline has since been extended several times, most recently to November 27, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Genesis, supported by Spring Oaks, asks the Court to take up the case; both companies lost in the lower courts. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether Maryland's rule is valid and decide the question itself, without yet determining who wins. If it denies review, the Fourth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Ford's lawsuit able to proceed in court rather than arbitration.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Genesis Financial Solutions' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Genesis Financial Solutions' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case, but the chance it agrees to hear it is about one in five, well above the usual few percent. The Court asked the other side to respond, which signals some interest. The case asks whether federal arbitration law overrides a Maryland rule requiring separate "consideration" (something of value exchanged) for an arbitration clause alone. Against review: the appeals court's decision was a brief, unpublished ruling, and the disagreement among courts may be thinner than claimed.

    Why this big-case score: FAA preemption of a state rule requiring arbitration-specific consideration; it reaches many consumer credit contracts in the Fourth Circuit's states, but the doctrinal step is narrow and incremental.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than take it up. I put the chance of review or another grant-related action at about one in four (24%). Genesis argues that Maryland unfairly makes arbitration clauses meet a stricter contract test, and the Court has asked the other side to respond. That signals interest, not a commitment to hear the case. The lower decision is short and unpublished, and a related petition may offer a better vehicle for addressing the issue.

    Why this big-case score: The arbitration-formation question could affect standard consumer credit contracts and access to class litigation nationwide, but is a technical FAA issue rather than a broad constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Genesis Financial Solutions' petition for review, with less than a one-in-ten chance (8%) of granting the case. Although the Court asked the consumer plaintiff to file a response to the company's argument that the Federal Arbitration Act overrides Maryland's rule requiring separate mutual promises for arbitration clauses, the lower appellate court's ruling is a brief, unpublished two-paragraph decision entangled in contract-specific disputes over unilateral change-of-terms language.

    Why this big-case score: Commercial arbitration preemption dispute over Maryland's Cheek consideration doctrine; moderately important to consumer financial contracts in the Fourth Circuit, though framed around state-law contract formation and illusory-promise rules rather than a national constitutional or statutory watershed.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    FAA preemption of a state arbitration-only consideration rule touches every Maryland consumer-credit arbitration clause and the Kindred/Concepcion equal-treatment line, but it is one state's doctrine on an unpublished per curiam.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The FAA question could affect arbitration clauses across consumer-credit and other standard-form contracts, but concerns a specialized contract-formation rule rather than a broad constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Clear 5-1 circuit split on a major federal statute (FAA) regarding arbitration clauses, supported by a prominent amicus.

Delaine v. United StatesMario Delaine asks the Court to decide whether one of his past convictions counted as a "violent felony" that triggered a mandatory 15-year prison sentence.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.35
0.56
0.35
0.42

Mario Delaine v. United StatesNo. 26-231 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000231 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Criminal law

Mario Delaine asks the Court to decide whether one of his past convictions counted as a "violent felony" that triggered a mandatory 15-year prison sentence.

What happened

Delaine pleaded guilty to illegally possessing a firearm as a felon. Because prosecutors said he had three prior convictions for "violent felonies," the district court sentenced him under the Armed Career Criminal Act, which sets a 15-year mandatory minimum sentence instead of a much lower guideline range. Delaine argued that one of those convictions, a Florida felony battery conviction, should not count because the law only requires an intentional touch, not any intent or awareness that the touch would cause injury. The Sixth Circuit disagreed and upheld his 188-month sentence, siding with two other appeals courts; two different appeals courts have reached the opposite conclusion on similar state laws.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide what level of intent a law must require before a crime counts as a "violent felony" under this sentencing law. Specifically, is it enough that a person intentionally touched someone, even without meaning or knowing that injury would result, or must the law require that the person intended or was aware that the touch could cause injury?

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked the government to respond. The government's response deadline has since been extended twice, most recently to December 3, 2026, so the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Delaine, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide which interpretation of the sentencing law is correct, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision stands, leaving Delaine's 188-month sentence and the lower court's interpretation in place. Either way, the decision so far affects only Delaine's case, though the legal question could matter in similar cases nationwide.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 3, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Delaine's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Delaine's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Mario Delaine's request to hear his case. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in five. Delaine argues that a prior battery conviction should not count toward the 15-year minimum sentence under the Armed Career Criminal Act. Federal appeals courts disagree on this question. The Court asked the government to respond, which raises the odds above the usual few percent. Still, most cases that get such a request are denied.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring ACCA elements-clause question with a ten-year mandatory minimum at stake for many defendants; important to federal sentencing practice but technical and low-salience to the public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline Mario Delaine's appeal, although I put the chance of review at about two in five (38%). His petition asks whether an intentional touching that unexpectedly causes serious injury can trigger a fifteen-year federal minimum sentence. The Court's request for a government response and disagreement among appeals courts make review plausible. But the lower court offers reasons those cases may differ, and asking for a response does not mean the Court will hear the case.

    Why this big-case score: The question affects lengthy federal mandatory-minimum sentences and potentially analogous crime-of-violence provisions nationwide, but concerns a technical statutory boundary rather than the validity of ACCA as a whole.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant review in *Mario Delaine v. United States*, with roughly a one-in-seven chance (14% probability) of taking the case, so the petition will most likely be denied. Delaine challenges his 15-year mandatory minimum sentence under the Armed Career Criminal Act—a federal law imposing harsher penalties on repeat violent offenders—arguing that his prior Florida battery and assault convictions do not qualify as violent felonies. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response, the lower court's ruling aligns with other federal appeals courts on the battery issue and rests on an independent state-law ground on the assault issue.

    Why this big-case score: Significant federal criminal sentencing question concerning whether ACCA's elements clause (18 U.S.C. 924(e)(2)(B)(i)) requires mens rea as to resulting physical injury after Borden v. United States, affecting numerous state battery and assault predicates, though technical and statutory rather than broadly high-salience.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring ACCA elements-clause mens rea question with a 15-year mandatory minimum at stake across several States' injury-result battery statutes; important to federal sentencing but technical and narrow outside it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.61·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring federal sentencing question affecting ACCA's fifteen-year minimum and related elements clauses nationwide, with substantial liberty stakes but less general public salience than a major constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would clarify whether Borden requires a purposeful or knowing mens rea as to resulting bodily injury under ACCA's elements clause (and potentially address Marks's application to Borden), affecting federal criminal sentencing nationwide while remaining a technical statutory-interpretation dispute.

Christy Ann Martin v. John Fredrick MartinThe Supreme Court declined to review a Mississippi woman's challenge to a contempt order jailing her for not paying a divorce-related money judgment.Civil proceduredecided
0.20
0.40
0.65
0.42

Christy Ann Martin v. John Fredrick MartinNo. 25-1307 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73389781 · models differ by up to 0.45 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to review a Mississippi woman's challenge to a contempt order jailing her for not paying a divorce-related money judgment.

What happened

Christy Ann Martin was ordered in her divorce case to pay John Fredrick Martin $21,040.72 for property damage. When she did not pay, a Mississippi chancery court held her in civil contempt and sentenced her to six months in jail, suspended if she followed a payment plan. Martin argued the court never expressly found she could pay, and that incarcerating her for an unpaid civil debt was unconstitutional. The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed, finding the chancery court's decision supported by the evidence and incarceration a permissible contempt sanction. The Mississippi Supreme Court denied further review by a divided vote.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution's guarantees of fair treatment require a court to specifically find, on the record, that a person can actually pay before jailing them for failing to pay a private money judgment, and whether using contempt power this way amounts to unconstitutional imprisonment for debt when other collection methods remain available. The petition also asks whether placing the burden on the debtor to prove she cannot pay, rather than requiring the other side to prove she can, meets constitutional standards.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Martin, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up her case and overturn the Mississippi courts' rulings. The Court's denial leaves the Mississippi Court of Appeals' decision in place, meaning the contempt finding and suspended incarceration order against Martin stand, and John Fredrick Martin's win in the lower courts is unaffected. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying question (whether Bearden/Turner limit civil-contempt incarceration to collect a private money judgment) would matter if decided, but this is a two-party Mississippi divorce dispute over a $21,040.72 award with no amici and a record the Court is unlikely to reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential limits on incarceration for private civil debt, but presented through a narrow domestic-relations dispute with contested facts and preservation problems; significance is distinct from the low grant probability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The issue of incarcerating indigent debtors is a high-stakes constitutional question under Turner v. Rogers, though the vehicle here is poor.

Eric Alan Isaacson v. MosesThe Court declined to hear a class-member objector's challenge to a $5,000 incentive payment awarded to the named plaintiff in a class-action settlement with the New York Times.decided
0.40
0.50
0.35
0.42

Eric Alan Isaacson v. Maribel Moses, et al.scotus/73522552 · models differ by up to 0.15

The Court declined to hear a class-member objector's challenge to a $5,000 incentive payment awarded to the named plaintiff in a class-action settlement with the New York Times.

What happened

Maribel Moses sued The New York Times Company, claiming it automatically renewed California subscribers without required disclosures. The parties settled, and the district court approved the settlement, attorney's fees, and a $5,000 payment to Moses for her work as class representative. Eric Alan Isaacson, a class member, objected, arguing such incentive payments are unlawful under old Supreme Court precedent. The Second Circuit rejected that argument twice, most recently in an unpublished order affirming a second, improved settlement. Isaacson then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether old rulings limiting what representative plaintiffs may be paid from a shared settlement fund still bar courts from approving modest payments to class representatives, given that most appeals courts now allow such payments while one does not.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after the Court asked for a response from the other side; both respondents and the petitioner filed briefs. The Supreme Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Isaacson, the objector, asked the Court to overturn the Second Circuit's decision upholding the $5,000 payment to Moses. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Second Circuit's ruling in place: the settlement, including the incentive payment to Moses, stands as approved. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the payment was lawful; it simply leaves the lower court's decision undisturbed, and the broader disagreement among appeals courts over such payments remains unresolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down Eric Isaacson's appeal, with only about a one-in-seventeen chance (6%) that it agrees to hear it. Isaacson objected to a $5,000 "service award" paid to the person who led a class action against The New York Times. He argues that century-old Supreme Court decisions forbid such payments. One appeals court agrees with him, but five others do not. The Court asked the other side to respond, which is a mild sign of interest. Still, it has passed on this question before, and this small-dollar case is a weak vehicle for deciding it.

    Why this big-case score: Whether class representatives may receive service awards from common funds touches a large share of federal class settlements, but the dollars per case are small and the question is procedural rather than constitutional.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline this case; I estimate about a one-in-five chance, or 22%, that it agrees to review it. The dispute concerns whether people who represent a group in a class-action settlement may receive extra payments for their work. Federal appeals courts disagree, and the Court's request for a response shows some interest. But similar disputes have previously been turned away, and a response request does not mean the Court has decided to take the case.

    Why this big-case score: A categorical rule about class-representative service awards would affect settlement practice nationwide, although this petition concerns a modest award in private consumer litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Isaacson v. Moses*, with only about a 1 in 17 chance (6%) of taking the case. Petitioner Eric Alan Isaacson, a class member objecting to a consumer class-action settlement with The New York Times, asks the Court to ban "incentive awards"—modest bonus payments (here, $5,000) given to the lead plaintiff who stepped forward to bring the lawsuit—arguing that 1880s Supreme Court precedents forbid them. Although the Court asked the respondents to file a written response and one federal appeals court agrees with Isaacson, ten other federal appeals courts allow these payments, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly turned down nearly identical appeals in recent years.

    Why this big-case score: If granted, resolving the 10-1 circuit split over whether Trustees v. Greenough (1882) and Rule 23 permit class-representative incentive awards would reshape class-action settlement practice nationwide, though its broader public salience outside civil-procedure and consumer-litigation circles is moderate.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling would decide whether the incentive/service awards present in most class-action settlements are lawful at all, reshaping class practice nationwide and drawing the business lobby (the Chamber is already in); but the stakes in this case are a $5,000 award, the question is technical, and public attention would be modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The categorical validity of class-representative service awards affects nationwide class-action settlement practice, although this vehicle concerns a modest award and has limited broader public salience.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Parasmo v. United StatesA doctor convicted of illegally prescribing opioids asks the Court to decide how appeals courts should assess whether a flawed jury instruction on his intent was harmless.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.35
0.54
0.35
0.41

Frank Parasmo v. United StatesNo. 26-377 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000377 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Criminal law

A doctor convicted of illegally prescribing opioids asks the Court to decide how appeals courts should assess whether a flawed jury instruction on his intent was harmless.

What happened

Frank Parasmo, a New York physician, was convicted at trial of unlawfully distributing opioids to patients. After his conviction, the Supreme Court ruled in another case that such prosecutions require proof the doctor subjectively knew he was prescribing improperly, not just that his conduct was objectively unreasonable. Parasmo argued the jury in his case had been wrongly told to apply the objective standard. The Second Circuit agreed the instruction was flawed but, over a dissent, ruled the error was harmless because it found the evidence of guilt overwhelming. The dissenting judge argued the court had improperly weighed contested evidence itself rather than leaving that to a jury.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide how appeals courts should handle a situation where a jury was told to use the wrong legal standard on a factual question the defendant disputed at trial. Specifically, may an appeals court excuse that mistake by concluding on its own that the evidence against the defendant was strong, or must it instead ask only whether the defendant presented enough evidence that a jury could have ruled the other way, without the appeals court weighing whose evidence was stronger.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference, and the Court later asked for a response from the government despite an earlier waiver; the government's response deadline was extended to December 4, 2026. No decision on whether to hear the case has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Parasmo, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on the question and decide it, without yet determining who wins. If it denies review, the Second Circuit's ruling upholding Parasmo's conviction stands, and the case does not return to the Supreme Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Parasmo's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Parasmo's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case. We give it about a one in eleven chance of taking it up. Dr. Frank Parasmo, a physician convicted of over-prescribing opioids, argues the appeals court wrongly called a faulty jury instruction "harmless," meaning not serious enough to require a new trial, because it judged the government's evidence strong. The Court asked the government to respond, which raises the odds a little. But the Court seldom takes cases that turn on how strong the evidence was in one trial.

    Why this big-case score: A general Neder harmless-error standard for contested elements would reach many criminal appeals, but the vehicle is a single physician's Ruan conviction and the Ruan-specific split is narrow and fading.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.54·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Frank Parasmo's appeal; I put the chance it agrees to review the case at about one in five, or 22%. He argues that appeals judges upheld his criminal conviction by deciding a disputed question of intent that should have been left to a properly instructed jury. The Court's request for a government response and a disagreement among the lower-court judges make review more plausible, but the Justices may see a dispute about this particular trial rather than a broader legal conflict.

    Why this big-case score: The treatment of disputed criminal intent after defective jury instructions could affect criminal appeals nationally and prosecutions of prescribing physicians, but this is an individual criminal case rather than a direct challenge to a nationwide policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant review in *Frank Parasmo v. United States*, with roughly an 11% chance (about one in nine) that the Court takes the case. Dr. Parasmo, an 80-year-old physician convicted of unlawfully prescribing opioids, argues that after the trial judge gave a flawed jury instruction on criminal intent, the appellate court violated his Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial by weighing the disputed trial evidence itself and declaring the error "harmless" (meaning it would not have changed the jury's verdict). Although a dissenting appellate judge and the Court's request for a government response show the petition is receiving serious attention, the Supreme Court usually declines cases that turn on how strongly the trial evidence pointed toward guilt in a specific trial.

    Why this big-case score: If granted and decided, a ruling clarifying Neder v. United States on whether appellate courts may weigh the strength of the government's evidence when an erroneously instructed element was contested at trial would be a significant Sixth Amendment criminal-procedure precedent across federal and state appeals, though it arises in a fact-intensive single-defendant prosecution rather than a major public-law dispute.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A general Neder harmless-error rule for contested elements would reach every instructional-error appeal and the Ruan prescriber cohort, but it is a criminal-procedure standard rather than a headline issue.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question reaches appellate harmless-error review of disputed criminal elements, with immediate consequences for physician prosecutions after Ruan and potentially broad jury-trial implications; the vehicle remains an individual prosecution rather than a nationwide policy challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Granado v. RamirezA police officer asks the Court to revive his qualified immunity defense after an appeals court let a fatal shooting lawsuit proceed to trial.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.58
0.35
0.41

Jonathan Granado v. Juanita Ramirez, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Estevan Ramirezscotus/73500240 · models differ by up to 0.28

A police officer asks the Court to revive his qualified immunity defense after an appeals court let a fatal shooting lawsuit proceed to trial.

What happened

Officer Jonathan Granado shot and killed Estevan Ramirez, a fleeing passenger from a car that had evaded police, during a nighttime chase in 2021. Ramirez's mother, Juanita Ramirez, sued on behalf of his estate, claiming the shooting violated the Fourth Amendment. A federal district court granted Granado summary judgment based on qualified immunity, a legal protection shielding officials from suits unless they violated clearly established law. The Fifth Circuit reversed, holding that disputed facts—including whether Granado knew Ramirez was armed and whether Ramirez swung a gun toward officers while fleeing—must go to a jury. The full appeals court narrowly declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether the shooting violated the Fourth Amendment's ban on unreasonable force, whether the appeals court applied the right legal standard for excessive-force claims and for when conduct counts as clearly established as unlawful, and whether only the Supreme Court itself, rather than lower courts, can establish law clearly enough to strip an officer of immunity.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference multiple times, most recently for November 13, 2026, after earlier conferences in September and November produced no recorded action. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Granado, the officer, is asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's decision, which had ruled in favor of Ramirez's estate by allowing the lawsuit to proceed. If the Court grants review and eventually reverses, Granado would regain qualified immunity and the case would end in his favor. If it affirms, the lawsuit would continue toward trial. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision stands, and the case returns to the district court for further proceedings, including possibly a trial.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Granado's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Granado's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound qualified-immunity shooting case; a summary per curiam would be a notable but incremental entry in the Court's qualified-immunity line, and the broad QP 2/QP 3 questions (who can clearly establish law; the 1791 basis of immunity) are unpreserved and will not be reached.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Police deadly force and qualified immunity affect civil-rights accountability nationwide. The source-of-clearly-established-law question could have broad consequences, but the record-specific dispute and preservation objections make a narrow ruling more plausible than doctrinal reconstruction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly salient qualified immunity case with an originalist challenge, though likely to be resolved narrowly via summary reversal.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound qualified-immunity deadly-force case; the systemic stakes (Fifth Circuit excessive-force doctrine, 9-8 en banc) are real but the QP 2/3 vehicle questions are unlikely to be reached.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Police deadly force and qualified immunity have substantial national stakes, especially if the Court limits which precedents clearly establish law; this record nevertheless presents a fact-specific shooting dispute rather than a clean vehicle for wholesale doctrinal revision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Moderate-stakes Fourth Amendment deadly-force and qualified-immunity dispute arising from an 8-9 Fifth Circuit en banc poll, with doctrinal relevance to how Tolan v. Cotton and Barnes v. Felix interact with clearly established law.

Indian Harbor Insurance v. Town of VintonAmerican insurers ask the Court to decide whether federal or state law governs when a non-signatory can use equitable estoppel to force arbitration under an international treaty.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.45
0.48
0.30
0.41

Indian Harbor Insurance Company, et al. v. Town of Vinton, Louisiana, et al.No. 25-1383 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500284 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Business & finance

American insurers ask the Court to decide whether federal or state law governs when a non-signatory can use equitable estoppel to force arbitration under an international treaty.

What happened

Several Louisiana public entities sued American insurers over disputed hurricane-damage payments on surplus-lines insurance policies that also involved two foreign insurers. The policies' contract terms made each insurer's agreement a separate contract with the policyholder, and under those terms, no foreign party was a signatory to the American insurers' arbitration clauses. The American insurers tried to invoke the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, a treaty requiring enforcement of certain arbitration agreements, by arguing that equitable estoppel let them enforce the foreign insurers' arbitration clauses instead. Louisiana courts had ruled equitable estoppel cannot override Louisiana's ban on arbitration clauses in insurance policies. The Fifth Circuit agreed with the lower courts, holding state law, not federal common law, controls this kind of estoppel question, and affirmed denial of arbitration.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the rules governing when a company that did not sign an arbitration agreement may still invoke it under this treaty should come from federal common law or from the law of the state where the dispute arose. The insurers argue federal law should apply to keep international arbitration rules uniform nationwide; the public entities argue state contract law should continue to govern, as it does under similar domestic arbitration law.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a reply, and was distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026. The docket shows the case was "rescheduled" on November 3, 2026, with no indication yet of further action.

What each outcome would mean

The insurers, as petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling, which left in place the lower court decisions denying arbitration. If the Court grants review and hears the case, it would decide which body of law governs this estoppel question, with no outcome assumed in advance; if it later ruled for the insurers, the public entities could be required to arbitrate rather than litigate their claims. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision stands, meaning the public entities' lawsuits against the American insurers continue in court rather than arbitration.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Indian Harbor Insurance's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Indian Harbor Insurance's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The insurance companies are asking the Supreme Court to hear their appeal (to "grant certiorari"). The question is whether federal law or Louisiana law decides when an insurer can enforce an arbitration clause in a contract it did not sign, under the international arbitration treaty. I think the Court will probably turn the case down, but the chance it takes the case is real, about one in four (27%). Appeals courts disagree on the question, and the Court left it open in 2020. The other side says the disagreement is overstated and that this case is a poor one for settling it.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a question GE Energy expressly reserved on Convention arbitration with real stakes for international and surplus-lines insurance arbitration, but it is a technical choice-of-law question with little public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn away this insurers' appeal than hear it, though I give review about a one-in-three chance (32%). The insurers argue that federal appeals courts disagree about which law governs enforcement of international arbitration agreements by companies that did not sign them. That issue has wider commercial importance, and the Court requested a response. But separate insurance contracts and Louisiana's special insurance rules complicate this case, making it a less straightforward way to resolve the disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: The governing-law question could affect international arbitration beyond insurance, but this vehicle concerns specialized insurance contracts and does not itself decide the underlying hurricane-loss claims.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny the insurers' petition for review, with a 7% chance of a grant (about a 1-in-14 chance). Although the Court asked the four Louisiana local-government policyholders to file a response and the petition highlights a real disagreement among federal appeals courts over whether federal or state law governs who can enforce an international arbitration clause, this Hurricane Laura insurance dispute is a poor test case because the policyholders dismissed all foreign insurers with prejudice and their policy expressly creates separate domestic insurance contracts governed by Louisiana's anti-arbitration statute.

    Why this big-case score: The second question presented raises the recurring circuit split left open in GE Energy Power Conversion France SAS, Corp. v. Outokumpu Stainless USA, LLC, 590 U.S. 432 (2020), over whether federal common law or state law governs nonsignatory equitable estoppel under the New York Convention, but this Louisiana Hurricane Laura surplus-lines insurance dispute is a poor, vehicle-flawed posture that will almost certainly be denied.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A technical choice-of-law question under the New York Convention that GE Energy reserved; real money for insurers and Gulf Coast policyholders and a live issue for the international arbitration bar, but low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The choice of law for nonsignatory enforcement of international arbitration agreements has nationwide commercial significance beyond hurricane insurance litigation, but this vehicle is technical and shaped by Louisiana insurance law and public-entity plaintiffs.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a circuit split on whether state or federal common law governs equitable estoppel under the New York Convention, which is important for international arbitration but not broadly salient.

Louisiana v. Devon Energy ProductionLouisiana asked the Supreme Court to lift a lower court's pause on returning a coastal-damage lawsuit to state court; a single justice denied the request.Civil proceduredecided
0.30
0.58
0.35
0.41

Louisiana, et al. v. Devon Energy Production Company, L.P.No. 26A499 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000499 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Civil procedure

Louisiana asked the Supreme Court to lift a lower court's pause on returning a coastal-damage lawsuit to state court; a single justice denied the request.

What happened

Cameron Parish and Louisiana sued Devon Energy over claims that decades of oil operations damaged Louisiana's coastline. Devon removed the case to federal court, arguing it had acted under federal-officer direction. The district court disagreed and sent the case back to state court. Devon appealed that remand and asked for a stay; the district court refused, but the Fifth Circuit ruled that Devon's appeal automatically paused the case, keeping it out of state court for now. Louisiana then asked the Supreme Court to undo that pause.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether filing an appeal of an order sending a case back to state court automatically freezes that return to state court, even after the transfer paperwork has already gone out, while the appeal is pending. Louisiana argues no automatic freeze should apply once the transfer has happened; Devon argues the appeal necessarily pauses the whole case.

Where it stands

A single justice asked Devon to respond to Louisiana's application, received Devon's opposition and Louisiana's reply, and then denied the application. The underlying appeal remains pending in the Fifth Circuit, and no petition asking the full Court to hear the case has been acted on in this docket.

What each outcome would mean

Louisiana, joined by Cameron Parish, asked the Court to lift the pause. Granting that request would have let the case return immediately to state court while Devon's appeal continued. Denying it, which is what happened, leaves the Fifth Circuit's pause in place, so the case stays out of state court until Devon's appeal of the remand order is resolved. The denial does not decide whether the Fifth Circuit's stay was legally correct.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 26, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-26: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 9%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring procedural question (whether a post-transmittal §1447(d) appeal automatically stays a remand under Griggs) with a real circuit split and federalism stakes across the Louisiana coastal suits, but technical and low-salience outside that litigation.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court grants the application: 27%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application concerns control of state-court litigation during federal-officer remand appeals, with implications beyond this coastal-restoration suit. Significant federalism and environmental-enforcement stakes, but the immediate relief is procedural rather than a final liability judgment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.85·Chance the Court grants the application: 35%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile federalism issue regarding whether Coinbase/Griggs automatic stays apply to remand orders already transmitted to state courts, involving climate-related litigation against energy companies.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted after the Court called for a response. Decided 2026-10-26: the Court denied the application. evt-order-response-requested-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 14%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A real, acknowledged circuit split on whether a post-transmittal federal-officer remand appeal automatically stays state-court proceedings. It recurs in the climate/coastal/opioid removal wave, but it is a procedural federal-courts question rather than a merits blockbuster.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court grants the application: 28%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The automatic-stay question affects federal-officer removal litigation and state judicial authority beyond this coastal-enforcement suit. Those systemic stakes are substantial, but this interim application does not itself determine environmental liability or the merits of removal.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court grants the application: 15%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves a circuit split on a recurring jurisdictional issue (federal-officer removal and Griggs automatic stays) with broader federalism implications.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-10-26: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring procedural question (whether a § 1447(d) appeal automatically stays an already-transmitted remand) that matters across the Louisiana coastal-parish suits and federal-officer removal generally, but the application itself is interim relief on a procedural point the Court just declined to review.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A consequential federal-state forum dispute affecting coastal-restoration litigation and federal-officer removal appeals nationally, but this application concerns a temporary procedural stay rather than environmental liability itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring procedural split over whether a post-transmittal 28 U.S.C. 1447(d) appeal triggers an automatic Griggs/Coinbase stay of state-court remand proceedings in high-dollar Louisiana coastal-erosion litigation, though interlocutory and procedural in posture.

Fred Davis Clark v. United StatesA man ordered to pay hundreds of millions in restitution and forfeiture asks the Court to revive his bid to challenge those penalties after his prison sentence was commuted.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.30
0.56
0.35
0.40

Fred Davis Clark, Jr. v. United StatesNo. 25-1199 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281704 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

A man ordered to pay hundreds of millions in restitution and forfeiture asks the Court to revive his bid to challenge those penalties after his prison sentence was commuted.

What happened

Fred Davis Clark, Jr. was convicted of bank fraud and related crimes and ordered to serve 40 years in prison, pay about $179 million in restitution, and forfeit about $309 million. His prison sentence was later commuted, but the financial penalties were left in place. Clark dismissed his direct appeal without challenging those penalties, then filed a motion asking the district court to vacate them. The district court denied the motion, ruling that this type of claim cannot be raised this way under circuit precedent, and also denied him permission to appeal. The court of appeals agreed and declined to reconsider.

What the Court is being asked

Clark raises two questions. First, whether an appeals court must let a prisoner appeal when other circuits disagree with the rule that bound his case, even if his own circuit's precedent is settled. Second, whether a court can consider a challenge to financial penalties like restitution and forfeiture, through the kind of petition normally used to challenge imprisonment, when those penalties are large enough to restrict someone's freedom even without jail time.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including the government's opposition and Clark's reply. It was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and again for the conference on October 9, 2026, with no action yet recorded on the docket.

What each outcome would mean

Clark, the petitioner, is asking the Court to take up his case and reverse the lower courts. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on one or both questions and decide them, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the lower courts' rulings stand: Clark would not be allowed to appeal, and his financial penalties would remain in place without further review under this claim.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Fred Davis Clark's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Fred Davis Clark's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    QP1 (whether a circuit split alone makes a claim debatable for a certificate of appealability) is a recurring habeas-administration question that would matter to thousands of 2255 and 2254 appeals a year, but it is procedural and technical; QP2 (2255 cognizability of restitution/forfeiture) has a colorful backstory ($488M in penalties, a commuted 40-year sentence) but the SG persuasively disputes that any split exists. Moderate stakes, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The certificate-of-appealability question could affect access to appellate review across federal and state habeas cases; the monetary-sanctions question also has substantial consequences, although this petition presents an unusually complicated individual vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A technical AEDPA procedural issue (COA standard) with a circuit split, but not a high-profile substantive question.

Jane Elizabeth Roberts v. FergusonFormer Shriners Hospitals employees asked the Court to revive their suit over Washington's COVID-19 vaccination mandate; the Court declined to hear it.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.35
0.45
0.40
0.40

Jane Elizabeth Roberts, et al. v. Bob Ferguson, Governor of Washington, et al.No. 25-1327 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500229 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Constitutional rights

Former Shriners Hospitals employees asked the Court to revive their suit over Washington's COVID-19 vaccination mandate; the Court declined to hear it.

What happened

Jane Elizabeth Roberts and eleven other former employees of Shriners Hospitals for Children sued Washington's governor and Shriners after losing their jobs for refusing COVID-19 vaccination under a state mandate. They argued federal law required that acceptance of the vaccines, which had not received full FDA approval, remain voluntary. A federal district court dismissed their claims, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, relying on its own earlier ruling in a related case. The employees then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The employees asked the Court to decide two related questions. First, whether the Constitution's guarantee of due process bars a state from requiring someone to accept a drug that lacked full federal approval, backed by the threat of losing their job, when federal drug law says acceptance of such drugs must be voluntary. Second, whether a state can impose that kind of mandate when a separate federal law shields vaccine makers and administrators from lawsuits, effectively cutting off injured people's ability to sue once the drug is given.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, after the Court asked for a response from the respondents and received briefing from both sides. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

Note: the snapshot's party listing shows "Bob Ferguson, Governor of Washington" as respondent, though the petition itself names "Jay Robert Inslee," reflecting a change in officeholder during the case.

What each outcome would mean

The employees, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up their case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the dismissal of the employees' lawsuit against Washington's governor and Shriners Hospitals stands. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply ends this case without the Court deciding the constitutional and statutory questions the employees raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling on whether a State may condition licensed employment on an EUA-labeled COVID vaccine would draw national attention, but the questions as framed turn on a time-bound labeling distinction and a novel PREP Act theory, in a damages-only suit against a former governor and a private hospital.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions implicate occupational vaccination conditions, federal informed-consent protections, and access to remedies across healthcare employment. Those potentially broad stakes are tempered by a damages-only dispute about a past pandemic mandate and substantial vehicle obstacles.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenge to state vaccine mandates under FDCA/PREP Act is a notable issue, but its practical impact is diminished post-pandemic.

Hanaway v. SandersonMissouri asked the Court to revive a Halloween sign-posting rule for sex offenders that lower courts struck down as compelled speech; the Court declined to hear the case.First Amendmentdecided
0.30
0.50
0.40
0.40

Catherine L. Hanaway, in Her Official Capacity as Attorney General of Missouri, et al. v. Thomas L. SandersonNo. 26-34 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000034 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: First Amendment

Missouri asked the Court to revive a Halloween sign-posting rule for sex offenders that lower courts struck down as compelled speech; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Missouri law bars registered sex offenders from participating in Halloween, including a requirement to post a sign reading "No candy or treats at this residence." Thomas Sanderson, convicted of a sex offense years earlier, had been told by police the law did not apply to him and kept up his annual Halloween display until he was prosecuted. He challenged only the sign requirement as unconstitutional compelled speech. After a trial, a federal district court and then the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed, finding Missouri had not shown the sign added any real benefit beyond the law's other restrictions. Missouri and a Hazelwood police official then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a state can require people convicted of sex offenses to post a specific sign at their homes on Halloween, given trial evidence that the sign did not meaningfully help protect children or help police enforce the law's other restrictions, or whether that requirement forces people to express a government message in violation of free speech protections.

Where it stands

The Court considered the petition at conferences on October 9 and October 16, 2026, and on October 19, 2026, it denied the petition. Justice Alito noted that he would have granted it.

What each outcome would mean

Missouri and the Hazelwood police chief, as petitioners, asked the Court to reverse the Eighth Circuit's decision favoring Sanderson. With the petition denied, the Eighth Circuit's ruling stands: Missouri cannot enforce the sign-posting requirement, though its other Halloween restrictions on sex offenders remain in place. A grant would have brought the case before the Court for full briefing and argument, with no outcome yet decided; that did not happen here.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A narrow Halloween sign mandate with little practical reach, but a grant would be the Court's vehicle for the compelled-speech line between factual disclosures and Wooley-type messages, and 17 States are pressing it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.50·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A salient compelled-speech dispute over Halloween notices at sex offenders' homes, with multistate support and potential implications for factual-disclosure rules, but a narrow challenged provision and substantial distinctions from ordinary registries.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 45%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Shannon Cross v. Central Contra Costa Transit AuthorityA former transit bus driver asks the Court to revisit how judges apply a longstanding discrimination-case framework at summary judgment.Employment & discriminationawaiting the Court
0.30
0.55
0.35
0.40

Shannon Cross v. Central Contra Costa Transit AuthorityNo. 26-100 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000100 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Employment & discrimination

A former transit bus driver asks the Court to revisit how judges apply a longstanding discrimination-case framework at summary judgment.

What happened

Shannon Cross, a Muslim bus driver, was fired by the Central Contra Costa Transit Authority after colliding with a bicyclist and, the Authority says, after repeated traffic violations found on video. Cross sued under federal and California law, alleging the real reason was religious discrimination and retaliation, pointing to supervisors who told her she could not wear her hijab and to other drivers who kept their jobs after collisions. The district court granted summary judgment to the Authority, applying the McDonnell Douglas framework, a method courts use to evaluate discrimination evidence. The Ninth Circuit affirmed in an unpublished decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether applying this evidence-evaluating framework at the summary-judgment stage improperly lets judges credit an employer's disputed explanation instead of leaving that factual dispute for a jury, as the ordinary summary-judgment rule otherwise requires.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for November 13, 2026, after full briefing including an opposition brief, several amicus briefs, and a reply. The docket shows no action yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Cross, the petitioner, asks the Court to take up her case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's ruling for the Authority. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the framework can be used this way at summary judgment, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's decision affirming summary judgment for the Authority stands, and Cross's lawsuit remains dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear this case. We put the chance it takes the case at about 7 in 100. A bus driver says her employer fired her for wearing a hijab. She asks the Court to reconsider a decades-old test courts use to decide whether a discrimination claim can go to a jury. Some Justices have criticized that test. But this appeal comes from a short, unpublished lower-court decision that turns on its particular facts, and other cases raising the same question may make better vehicles.

    Why this big-case score: The McDonnell Douglas-at-summary-judgment question is significant for employment law generally, but this vehicle is an unpublished, fact-bound Ninth Circuit memorandum, so the case itself is modest unless chosen as the vehicle.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Shannon Cross's appeal; I put the chance it agrees to review the case at about one in eight. Asking her former employer to respond shows interest, especially because some Justices have questioned the rules courts use to evaluate workplace-discrimination evidence. But the lower court's unpublished decision turns heavily on disputed accident facts and employee comparisons. Those complications make this a less attractive case for deciding a broad legal question. Declining review would not decide whether discrimination occurred.

    Why this big-case score: Reconsidering the proof framework for workplace discrimination could affect employment litigation nationwide; this particular petition presents that issue through a disputed, unpublished individual termination case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court is very likely to deny Shannon Cross's petition for review, with only a 4.5% chance of granting the case (about one in twenty-two). Although the Court asked her former employer to respond to her petition—showing at least one Justice took an initial look at her challenge to how lower courts use the *McDonnell Douglas* legal test to dismiss workplace discrimination lawsuits before trial—the case has major factual hurdles, including a police report and a signed letter finding Cross at fault for a bus-bicycle crash plus video of thirty traffic violations, making it a poor vehicle for changing national law.

    Why this big-case score: If granted on the Question Presented, reconsidering or curtailing the McDonnell Douglas framework at summary judgment would substantially reshape federal employment-discrimination litigation, though the underlying dispute is a routine single-employee termination.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The abstract question (whether McDonnell Douglas belongs at summary judgment) is significant for all federal discrimination litigation, but this petition is a fact-bound challenge to an unpublished memorandum disposition, so the case as framed is modest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Reconsidering McDonnell Douglas at summary judgment could reshape proof in employment-discrimination litigation nationwide. The immediate dispute is an individual discharge, and a narrow correction would have substantially smaller consequences.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided on the merits, reconsidering or displacing the McDonnell Douglas burden-shifting framework at Rule 56 summary judgment would reshape routine federal employment-discrimination litigation nationwide, though the underlying dispute is a fact-bound single-employee termination appeal from an unpublished disposition.

Vasquez v. GuerreroA Texas death row inmate asks the Court to revive his bid for federal court review of a claim that his trial lawyers were constitutionally ineffective.awaiting the Court
0.20
0.64
0.35
0.40

Richard Vasquez v. Eric Guerrero, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Divisionscotus/73292081 · models differ by up to 0.44

A Texas death row inmate asks the Court to revive his bid for federal court review of a claim that his trial lawyers were constitutionally ineffective.

What happened

Richard Vasquez was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in Texas. Years later, his lawyers discovered an apparent inconsistency in the toxicology report used at trial to show cocaine in the victim's system. Vasquez sought permission to file a successive federal habeas petition raising an ineffective-assistance claim based on this discovery. The Fifth Circuit allowed him to proceed on that claim but ultimately ruled against him, holding he had not been diligent in discovering the problem earlier and had not shown, as the law also requires, that the new evidence would clearly establish his innocence. Vasquez asks the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case raises questions about a federal law that limits repeat habeas petitions by prisoners. One question is whether courts should measure a prisoner's diligence in finding new evidence by what the prisoner's own lawyers could reasonably have discovered, or by the prisoner's own personal awareness, and whether an exception applies when the prisoner's lawyers are accused of serious misconduct. Other questions concern whether certain claims of hidden evidence count as barred repeat claims, and what weight a federal court must give when local and state prosecutors disagree about whether a prisoner deserves relief.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference multiple times, most recently for the December 4, 2026 conference; the docket shows no decision yet. A motion by Vasquez to defer consideration of the petition, tied to a related appeal, is also pending without a recorded ruling.

What each outcome would mean

Vasquez, the petitioner, is asking the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's decision, which upheld the dismissal of his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case fully and decide the legal questions; that step alone would not determine who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Vasquez's ineffective-assistance claim unreviewed on the merits, as Eric Guerrero, the prison official named as respondent, has urged.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Vasquez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Vasquez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital case with both State forensic witnesses recanting and two successive Nueces County DAs saying relief is warranted; the QPs (AEDPA successive-petition diligence standard, successiveness of late-surfacing Brady claims, deference to a local DA over the AG) recur across capital habeas but are technical. Significant to the habeas bar and to Texas capital practice, not a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital conviction involving disputed forensic evidence, allegedly ineffective counsel, and contested prosecutorial positions creates substantial individual stakes; the successive-habeas questions could also affect access to review beyond this case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.70·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital habeas case involving an egregious IAC and Brady claim where the local DA concedes relief but the State AG opposes.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Capital case raising a recurring AEDPA successive-petition diligence question with a claimed circuit split, but a fact-bound vehicle with limited reach beyond capital habeas.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital prisoner's challenge to successive-habeas diligence rules and contested scientific evidence has substantial individual stakes and potentially broader consequences for access to review, although multiple vehicle problems may prevent a general ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling on AEDPA § 2244(b)(2)(B)(i) due-diligence imputation for successive ineffective-assistance claims or state-versus-local prosecutorial authority in federal habeas would be doctrinally consequential for capital postconviction practice, though confined to successive-habeas procedure.

Birks v. Clemente Javier Aguirre-JarquinThe Court declined to review a forensic examiner's bid to escape a wrongly convicted man's lawsuit over her disputed palm print identification.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.35
0.49
0.35
0.40

Donna Birks v. Clemente Javier Aguirre-JarquinNo. 25-1341 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500243 · models differ by up to 0.14 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to review a forensic examiner's bid to escape a wrongly convicted man's lawsuit over her disputed palm print identification.

What happened

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin spent fourteen years in prison, ten on death row, after Donna Birks, a latent print examiner, testified that a print on the murder weapon matched his palm. Years later an investigation found Birks had sent the required second check of her work to a colleague she considered unable to verify it properly, and reviewers concluded her identification was wrong. After new DNA evidence and another suspect's confessions emerged, Florida courts vacated Aguirre's conviction and the state dropped the charges. Aguirre sued Birks and others. The lower courts denied Birks qualified immunity, a legal protection for officials, on Aguirre's claim that she fabricated evidence, finding a jury could decide the question; the appeals court also chose not to review related fact-bound issues, leaving them for further proceedings.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether Birks could be held liable for violating Aguirre's rights without proof she knew her identification was false, whether it was already clearly established that her conduct was unlawful at the time, and whether the fabricated evidence actually caused Aguirre's conviction given his own trial testimony that he had handled the knife.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it on October 13, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Birks, the losing party below, asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the appeals court's ruling against her. The denial leaves the Eleventh Circuit's decision in place, meaning Aguirre's lawsuit against Birks continues in the lower courts, including the fact questions about her intent and whether her evidence caused his conviction. The denial does not mean the Court agreed Birks should lose; it simply leaves that question for the lower courts to resolve.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A death-row exoneree's Section 1983 suit against a latent-print examiner draws press attention, and a merits ruling on the mens rea for fabrication-of-evidence claims would reach wrongful-conviction litigation nationwide; but the likeliest grant form is a narrow per curiam on clearly-established law, and a denial leaves a fact-bound interlocutory ruling in place.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.49·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Forensic-evidence fabrication and qualified immunity after a vacated murder conviction have substantial civil-rights stakes, but the petition is an individual, fact-bound interlocutory dispute rather than a broad regulatory or structural case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves specific QI application for latent print analyst's subjective state of mind, limiting broader societal impact.

Westcott v. Voice of the ExperiencedLouisiana asked the Court to review a Fifth Circuit rule that repeatedly let prison-conditions injunctions expire before Louisiana could appeal them; the Court denied review.Civil proceduredecided
0.35
0.48
0.35
0.39

Gary Westcott, Secretary, Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections, et al. v. Voice of the Experienced, et al.No. 26-18 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000018 · models differ by up to 0.13 · topic: Civil procedure

Louisiana asked the Court to review a Fifth Circuit rule that repeatedly let prison-conditions injunctions expire before Louisiana could appeal them; the Court denied review.

What happened

Prisoners at Louisiana's state penitentiary sued over outdoor labor conditions in extreme heat, winning three successive preliminary injunctions against the prison system. Louisiana appealed each one, but under a federal prison-litigation statute, preliminary injunctions automatically expire after 90 days unless a court makes certain findings and finalizes the order first. Each injunction expired before the Fifth Circuit ruled, and the appeals court, following its own precedent, dismissed all three appeals as moot. The prisoners later won a bench trial, and the district court entered final judgment for Louisiana. The Fifth Circuit denied rehearing, over dissents from several judges.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a 90-day period is too brief to count as a full opportunity to litigate an appeal, which matters for an exception that keeps a case alive even after the original order expires, when the same dispute is likely to recur. It also asks whether that exception requires a chance for full review by the Supreme Court itself, rather than just by a federal appeals court.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and after full briefing including a response and reply, the Supreme Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Louisiana, as petitioner, asked the Court to reverse the Fifth Circuit's mootness rulings. With the petition denied, the Fifth Circuit's decisions dismissing Louisiana's three appeals as moot remain in place, and the question of whether the district court properly complied with the injunction statute in those earlier orders will not be reviewed by the Supreme Court. The prisoners' organization, which opposed review, keeps the benefit of that outcome, though the underlying case had already ended with a final judgment for Louisiana after trial.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 37%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Louisiana asks the Supreme Court to review a federal appeals court's rule. Under that rule, court orders about prison conditions, which by law expire after 90 days, become "moot" (no longer reviewable) before an appeal can be heard. We think the Court will more likely than not decline the case, but a grant is a real possibility: about a 37% chance. The Court asked the other side to respond even after it waived its reply, and six appeals judges dissented below. Both are signs of serious interest.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring mootness question that decides whether PLRA prison-conditions injunctions in the Fifth Circuit can ever be reviewed on appeal; important to prison litigation, narrow beyond it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably decline to hear Louisiana's appeal; I give some form of review or corrective relief about a three-in-ten chance. Louisiana argues that prison injunctions lasting only 90 days keep expiring before appeals can be completed, and the Court has asked the other side to respond. But Louisiana later won the underlying trial, making this an awkward case for resolving the broader legal question. If the Court intervenes, a short corrective order is more likely than full briefing and argument.

    Why this big-case score: A consequential appellate-jurisdiction question affecting recurring short-lived injunctions and prison litigation, but not a direct decision on prison conditions or the substantive validity of the injunctions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will likely deny Louisiana's petition for review, with about a one-in-four (28%) chance of granting it or summarily overturning the lower court. Louisiana challenges a Fifth Circuit rule that dismissed three state appeals of 90-day prison heat-safety injunctions as moot—meaning no longer a live legal dispute—after the orders expired before the appeals finished. Although the Fifth Circuit's rule conflicts with Supreme Court precedent recognizing that three months is too short to complete appellate review, the trial court has since held a full trial and issued a final remedial order, making these earlier temporary-injunction appeals a poor vehicle for Supreme Court intervention.

    Why this big-case score: Technical Article III mootness and PLRA preliminary-injunction reviewability question primarily affecting Fifth Circuit prison litigation rather than a broad national constitutional or regulatory dispute.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A procedural question (how the capable-of-repetition-yet-evading-review exception applies to PLRA preliminary injunctions that expire at 90 days) with real institutional stakes for prison-conditions litigation in the Fifth Circuit's three heavy-prison states, and an underlying Angola Farm Line heat case that draws press; but the petitioner already won final judgment, so a decision either way changes no one's present obligations.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions affect appellate review of short-lived injunctions, state prison administration, and protection against dangerous prison heat. The immediate vehicle concerns expired preliminary orders rather than the ultimate legality of prison conditions, limiting its likely breadth.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Procedural issue concerning mootness exceptions for preliminary injunctions.

Pitts v. BurkeThe Supreme Court declined to review two police officers' bid to escape a lawsuit over the fatal shooting of Thomas Gay.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.30
0.46
0.40
0.39

Jessica Pitts, Officer, et al. v. Taylor Burke, as Special Administrator of the Estate of Thomas Gay, DeceasedNo. 25-1062 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281346 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to review two police officers' bid to escape a lawsuit over the fatal shooting of Thomas Gay.

What happened

Officers Jessica Pitts and William Lewis responded to a call about Thomas Gay behaving erratically at his father's home. Lewis repeatedly used a taser on Gay, and Pitts then shot and killed him. Taylor Burke, representing Gay's estate, sued the officers for excessive force. The district court denied the officers' request for qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields officials from lawsuits unless they violated clearly established rights. The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, finding disputed facts that, if resolved in Burke's favor, showed the officers violated clearly established Fourth Amendment law. The officers then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The officers asked the Court to decide whether the appeals court wrongly treated certain lower-court rules about escalating police encounters as settled constitutional law, whether it defined the relevant legal rules too broadly rather than tying them to the specific situation the officers faced, and whether it improperly avoided deciding legal questions by labeling them factual disputes.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference multiple times, with the Court twice asking for additional briefing (a response and a reply). After being rescheduled once, it was considered at a conference on October 9, 2026, and the Court denied the petition on October 13, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The officers, Pitts and Lewis, asked the Court to overturn the Tenth Circuit's decision. The Court's denial leaves that decision in place, meaning the lawsuit against the officers continues in the lower courts without qualified immunity shielding them at this stage. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Tenth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed. Burke's estate may now proceed toward trial on the excessive-force claims.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound qualified-immunity petition with no circuit split; a summary reversal over an unarmed decedent would draw police-accountability coverage, and a plenary grant on the Barnes-reserved officer-created-danger question would be larger, but the likeliest outcome is a quiet denial.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fatal police shooting raises substantial civil-rights stakes, and clarification of qualified immunity or officer-created danger could affect police litigation nationally. The fact-intensive interlocutory posture makes a narrow disposition more plausible than a broad doctrinal ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An important but routine error-correction case regarding qualified immunity and pre-seizure conduct.

Marschner v. MarschnerA divorced veteran's ex-wife asks the Court to decide whether her divorce settlement's agreement that he indemnify her for lost retirement pay can be enforced.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.30
0.56
0.30
0.39

Roxane M. Marschner v. Richard A. MarschnerNo. 25-1349 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500251 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Agencies & benefits

A divorced veteran's ex-wife asks the Court to decide whether her divorce settlement's agreement that he indemnify her for lost retirement pay can be enforced.

What happened

Roxane and Richard Marschner divorced in 2016, agreeing Roxane would get a share of Richard's military retirement pay, including amounts later identified in follow-up orders. In 2021, Richard was medically retired and began receiving disability-based pay instead of longevity retirement pay, so Roxane received nothing. A North Dakota trial court ordered Richard to pay Roxane the equivalent amount as spousal support. The North Dakota Supreme Court reversed, holding that federal law bars state courts from enforcing such indemnification, even when the veteran agreed to it in the settlement.

What the Court is being asked

A federal law governs how military retirement benefits are divided in divorce and excludes certain disability-linked pay from division. The Court is asked whether that law still blocks a state court from enforcing a divorce settlement in which a veteran voluntarily agreed to make up the difference to a former spouse if his disability-related pay reduced her share, or whether the law only blocks a court from imposing such a requirement on its own.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition on October 1, 2026, after the case was distributed for conference more than once. It has since set the case for argument on January 19, 2027, and granted a motion to dispense with printing the joint appendix; no decision has been issued yet.

What each outcome would mean

Roxane, who lost below, asks the Court to reverse the North Dakota Supreme Court's decision. If the Court reverses, it would hold that the indemnification agreement can be enforced, favoring Roxane. If it affirms, Richard's win below stands, and the agreement remains unenforceable. If the Court vacates, it would send the case back to the North Dakota courts without deciding who should win.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 19, 2027
  2. Decided

If the Court affirms: the lower court's ruling stands. · If the Court reverses or vacates: the ruling is overturned or sent back.

The models' predictions

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 70%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring military-divorce question (roughly a quarter of two million military retirees waive retired pay for disability pay, and settlement indemnity clauses are standard drafting), with an entrenched state-high-court split; consequential for family-law practice and veterans' former spouses, but a technical preemption question of little general public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 62%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally recurring question about the security of military-divorce settlements and disability-benefit protections, with substantial household stakes but a bounded statutory and family-law reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 25%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Addresses the enforceability of contractual indemnification for VA disability waivers in divorce, which affects a specific subset of veterans but does not implicate broad constitutional or structural issues.

Brookins v. City of PhiladelphiaA mother whose son's death photo was taken and shared by a police officer asks the Court to revive her civil rights lawsuit against him.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.35
0.56
0.25
0.39

Karen Brookins, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Marcus Richard Boone v. City of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, et al.No. 26-433 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000433 · models differ by up to 0.31 · topic: Constitutional rights

A mother whose son's death photo was taken and shared by a police officer asks the Court to revive her civil rights lawsuit against him.

What happened

Marcus Boone died after jumping from a Philadelphia overpass in 2022. A police officer at the scene, Christopher Culver, photographed him on the ground and texted the photo to other officers; it later spread online and reached Boone's mother, Karen Brookins. Brookins sued Culver and the city, claiming the photo-taking violated her constitutional right to privacy and caused her emotional distress. The district court found Culver's conduct "reprehensible" and conscience-shocking but granted him qualified immunity, a legal protection shielding officials from liability unless they violated clearly established law. The Third Circuit affirmed, over one judge's partial dissent.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide what a plaintiff must show to win this kind of constitutional claim against a government official. Brookins argues that proving the official's conduct was shockingly wrong should be enough by itself. The lower court instead required her to also show that the specific right at stake—control over a deceased relative's death images—was a separately, clearly recognized right with deep historical roots. Brookins says other appeals courts only require the first showing, not both.

Where it stands

The petition was filed in September 2026. The city and officer respondents waived their right to respond, and amici curiae (outside parties, here law professors) filed a brief supporting Brookins. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it.

What each outcome would mean

Brookins, the mother, is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the Third Circuit's ruling against her. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Third Circuit's decision stands, meaning Culver keeps qualified immunity and Brookins's lawsuit over the photograph remains rejected.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Brookins' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Brookins' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case: we put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in twenty. A mother is suing a Philadelphia officer who photographed her dying son and shared the pictures as a joke. She asks whether outrageous official conduct alone violates the Constitution. Courts of appeals disagree on that question. But the officer won on "qualified immunity", a rule that shields officials unless the law was already clear. That makes the case a poor vehicle for settling the question.

    Why this big-case score: A clean ruling on whether substantive-due-process claims against executive officials need a fundamental right on top of conscience-shocking conduct would reshape a recurring §1983 doctrine across circuits, but the case itself is a narrow damages suit.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I put the chance it agrees to review it at about one in eight, or 12%. A mother challenges a police officer's sharing of a graphic photograph of her dying son. Her appeal raises a serious disagreement about when extreme government misconduct violates constitutional protections. But the lower court's ruling also concerns qualified immunity, a defense protecting officials unless the law clearly prohibited their conduct, which makes this a less straightforward case for resolving that disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: The question could affect constitutional remedies for serious executive misconduct nationwide, beyond death-scene photographs, but arises in an individual damages suit rather than a challenge to a major national program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in this case (less than a one-in-one-hundred chance of a grant, at 0.8%). Although a Philadelphia police officer's decision to photograph and share an image of a dying man was widely condemned by the judges below, the lower court ruled that the officer was protected by qualified immunity—a legal rule that shields officials from lawsuits unless prior court decisions clearly established that their conduct violated the Constitution. Because the mother's new legal argument about how the Constitution's Due Process Clause applies was never raised in the lower courts, and the respondents waived their right to file a response, the Court is expected to turn the appeal away without hearing it.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, resolving whether Rochin/Lewis conscience-shocking executive-action claims require a Glucksberg-rooted fundamental right would reshape Fourteenth Amendment substantive due process litigation under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 nationwide, though the immediate dispute is a single-officer tort claim.

Boysen v. PeaceHealthFormer hospital employees fired for refusing COVID-19 vaccination asked the Court to revive their lawsuit against the hospital and Oregon officials; the Court denied review.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.40
0.55
0.20
0.38

Sara Boysen, et al. v. PeaceHealth, et al.No. 25-1280 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73338270 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Constitutional rights

Former hospital employees fired for refusing COVID-19 vaccination asked the Court to revive their lawsuit against the hospital and Oregon officials; the Court denied review.

What happened

Sara Boysen and other former PeaceHealth employees were fired after refusing to be vaccinated against COVID-19 under PeaceHealth's policy and a related Oregon health authority mandate. They sued PeaceHealth, its executives, and Oregon's former governor and health authority director, arguing the vaccine was an unapproved "investigational drug" and that requiring it violated various federal statutes, an international treaty, contract terms, and the Constitution. The district court dismissed the case, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, relying on its recent decision in a similar case involving the same hospital, which held that none of the cited laws created rights enforceable in such a lawsuit and that a Supreme Court precedent upholding vaccine mandates foreclosed their constitutional claims.

What the Court is being asked

The petitioners asked whether the Constitution's guarantee of fair treatment by the government bars a state from conditioning a person's ability to keep working in a licensed profession on accepting an experimental drug and giving up the right to sue over any resulting harm.

Where it stands

The Court denied the petition for review on October 13, 2026, after considering it at conference.

What each outcome would mean

Boysen and the other former employees petitioned the Court to hear their case. By denying review, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's ruling in place, so the dismissal of their lawsuit against PeaceHealth and the Oregon officials stands. The denial is not a ruling that the lower court's reasoning was correct; it simply means the Ninth Circuit's decision is final and the case will not be reheard.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision on whether Jacobson lets a State condition licensed work on COVID-19 vaccination would be nationally watched, but the QP as framed (investigational-drug and PREP Act waiver theory), the damages-only posture over repealed mandates, and the antecedent state-action and qualified-immunity questions make any decision here narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could materially affect bodily-autonomy claims, healthcare employment mandates, and the interaction of emergency-use drug regulation with constitutional rights. The particular dispute is retrospective and has substantial vehicle limitations.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Independent Specialty Insurance v. Lower Cameron Hospital Service DistrictInsurers asked the Court to decide which law governs arbitration disputes over an international insurance policy, then jointly agreed to dismiss the case.Business & financedecided
0.30
0.45
0.40
0.38

Independent Specialty Insurance Company, et al. v. Lower Cameron Hospital Service District, et al.No. 26-2 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000002 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Business & finance

Insurers asked the Court to decide which law governs arbitration disputes over an international insurance policy, then jointly agreed to dismiss the case.

What happened

A Louisiana hospital district and related entities sued their insurers, including Independent Specialty Insurance Company, over unpaid hurricane damage claims. The insurers wanted the dispute sent to arbitration under international rules, arguing that even though the policy had been split into separate contracts with each insurer, they could still invoke an arbitration clause signed by a foreign insurer in the group. The district court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals both disagreed, ruling that state law controlled and blocked that argument, so the case stayed in court rather than going to arbitration.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asked the Court to decide whether federal rules or state rules should determine when a company that did not sign an arbitration agreement can still rely on it to force arbitration, in cases involving an international treaty on enforcing arbitration agreements. The petition noted that courts of appeals disagreed on this question and asked the Court to hold the case until it resolved a similar petition elsewhere.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court later asked the hospital district to respond after initially receiving a waiver. Before the Court acted on the petition, the parties jointly asked to dismiss it, and the Court dismissed the petition on October 26, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Independent Specialty Insurance Company and the other insurers, as petitioners, had asked the Court to take up the case and reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling that state law governed. Because the parties jointly stipulated to dismiss the petition, the Court did not decide the legal question. The Fifth Circuit's decision favoring the hospital district and against arbitration remains in place, and the underlying lawsuit continues in the lower courts without Supreme Court review of the arbitration issue.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 29, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesDismissedOct 26, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-26: the Court dismissed it. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 19%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A reserved-in-GE-Energy choice-of-law question (federal common law vs state law for nonsignatory estoppel under the New York Convention) with an acknowledged 4-2 split and real money for the Louisiana surplus-lines market, but technical and commercial; this petition is a tag-along to No. 25-1383, so any significance rides on the lead case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The choice of law for nonsignatory enforcement under the New York Convention reaches international commercial arbitration beyond this hospital-insurance dispute, but this petition is a follow-on vehicle with specialized insurance and contract-formation complications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a circuit split on whether state or federal law governs equitable estoppel under the New York Convention, which has significant commercial implications for insurers but lacks broad societal impact.

Vasquez v. GuerreroA death-row inmate asks the Court to decide whether his new claims about suppressed evidence count as a barred "successive" habeas filing.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.60
0.25
0.38

Richard Vasquez, Jr. v. Eric Guerrero, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions DivisionNo. 26-353 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000353 · models differ by up to 0.35

A death-row inmate asks the Court to decide whether his new claims about suppressed evidence count as a barred "successive" habeas filing.

What happened

Richard Vasquez was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in Texas. Years later, he says he discovered that prosecutors had known before trial that a toxicology report used against him was internally inconsistent, and that testimony about cocaine in the victim's system was unreliable. He tried repeatedly, in state and federal courts, to raise claims based on this evidence. The Fifth Circuit denied him permission to pursue these particular claims, and after he filed a further federal petition without that permission, both the district court and the Fifth Circuit rejected it, with the Fifth Circuit denying him a certificate of appealability needed to proceed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether claims like Vasquez's, based on facts the inmate says he did not know about when he filed his first federal habeas petition, must meet the strict legal requirements that apply to repeat ("successive") habeas filings, or whether they should instead be treated as timely because they only became apparent later.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, after the state's brief opposing review was filed in October. The docket shows no action since that distribution.

What each outcome would mean

Vasquez, the inmate, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, without yet determining who wins. If it denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision rejecting Vasquez's claims stands, and the state, represented by the prison system's director, keeps the benefit of that result. A denial would not mean the Court agrees the lower court was right, only that the case is not taken up.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Vasquez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Vasquez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Richard Vasquez's request to hear his death-penalty case (about an 8% chance it agrees). He argues that evidence-suppression claims he could not have known about earlier should not count as a barred "second" habeas petition. The Court has shown some interest: it pulled the lower-court record in his related earlier petition. Still, every federal appeals court that has ruled agrees with the Fifth Circuit, and Texas points to procedural obstacles, so a denial is likely, possibly with a written dissent.

    Why this big-case score: Capital case on a recurring AEDPA second-or-successive question Justice Sotomayor has flagged; nationally modest unless granted.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Richard Vasquez's appeal; I estimate about a one-in-forty chance it takes the case. His death sentence and allegations that prosecutors concealed evidence raise serious concerns. But other appeals courts largely agree on the disputed legal rule, and his earlier attempts to obtain review create procedural obstacles. The most likely result is a denial without explanation after the scheduled December conference, leaving the lower court's decision in place without endorsing its reasoning or deciding whether prosecutors violated his rights.

    Why this big-case score: A capital case asking a nationally consequential question about federal review of concealed exculpatory evidence, although presented through a narrow and procedurally complicated habeas appeal.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in this Texas death-penalty case, with only a 1.5% chance of granting the petition. Richard Vasquez asks the Court to allow a new federal challenge claiming prosecutors withheld evidence and used misleading testimony about toxicology tests at his 1999 murder trial, arguing that federal limits on repeat petitions ("second or successive" habeas applications) should not apply when the state hid the evidence earlier. However, the federal appeals court already rejected his request to bring these exact claims in 2023, and both state and federal courts found that the toxicology report was actually given to his trial lawyers and that the other evidence of fatal physical abuse was overwhelming, making this case a poor candidate for Supreme Court review.

    Why this big-case score: Capital habeas petition raising a recurring AEDPA question (whether Panetti v. Quarterman exempts newly discovered Brady/Napue claims from 28 U.S.C. 2244(b)), but severely limited by case-specific procedural and vehicle defects.

City of North Las Vegas v. JonesNorth Las Vegas asks the Court to revive qualified immunity for officers sued after a warrantless backyard search and dog shooting during a search for a fleeing suspect.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.30
0.48
0.35
0.38

City of North Las Vegas, Nevada, et al. v. Genoa Jones, et al.No. 25-1355 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500257 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Constitutional rights

North Las Vegas asks the Court to revive qualified immunity for officers sued after a warrantless backyard search and dog shooting during a search for a fleeing suspect.

What happened

Police searching a neighborhood for a domestic-violence suspect who had fled lost track of him for at least eighteen minutes. A K-9 unit then led an officer, Lieutenant Salkoff, to jump a wall into the walled backyard of Genoa Jones and Cornell Tinsley without a warrant. Their dogs attacked the police dog, and Salkoff shot and killed two of them. Jones and Tinsley sued the city and officers. The district court granted the officers qualified immunity. The Ninth Circuit reversed in part, holding that the search was not justified by "hot pursuit" because the officers had lost the suspect's trail for too long, and that this was already clearly established law; it affirmed on other claims, including the shooting itself. Rehearing en banc was denied over a dissent from eight judges.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether police can still invoke the "chasing a fleeing suspect" exception to the warrant requirement when they temporarily lose a suspect's trail but later believe, based on further police work, that they have picked it back up; whether the officers should be shielded from liability because no prior case clearly established that this kind of search was unlawful; and whether only this Court's own decisions, rather than lower federal appeals court rulings, can ever count as clearly establishing a right for purposes of that shield.

Where it stands

The case was distributed for conference in September 2026 and, after the Court asked for a response and received full briefing, it has since been distributed for conference again, most recently for November 13, 2026. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will take the case.

What each outcome would mean

North Las Vegas and its officers, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision reviving the lawsuit. If the Court denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands, and Jones and Tinsley's lawsuit over the backyard search continues in the lower courts. If the Court grants review, it will decide the legal questions itself after full briefing and argument; affirming would leave the lawsuit alive, reversing would restore qualified immunity and end that claim, and vacating would send the case back without resolving it for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the City of North Las Vegas' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The City of North Las Vegas' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think the Supreme Court will probably turn down this case, but there is about a one-in-four chance it takes it. Police officers searching for a fleeing suspect entered a backyard and shot two dogs. A federal appeals court said the officers can be sued, rejecting their "qualified immunity" (protection from lawsuits unless the law was clearly settled). The Supreme Court asked the other side to respond, which signals interest. It has often reversed this appeals court on such cases without full argument.

    Why this big-case score: A fact-bound qualified-immunity and hot-pursuit dispute over two dogs; QP 3 (only Supreme Court precedent clearly establishes law) would be large but is very unlikely to be the question taken.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear this challenge over police entering a backyard while searching for a fleeing suspect. I put the chance of intervention at about three in ten. The Court's request for a response and eight lower-court judges' objections make this more promising than an ordinary appeal. If the Court intervenes, it will probably issue a short ruling protecting the officers from damages, rather than hold a full hearing or broadly rewrite the rules governing police liability.

    Why this big-case score: The questions concern nationwide limits on warrantless police searches and qualified immunity, but the strongest review vehicle is a narrow correction of the immunity analysis rather than a wholesale doctrinal change.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is likely to deny review in *City of North Las Vegas v. Jones*, with about a one-in-four chance (25%) of taking the case or reversing the lower court outright. The case asks whether police officers had "qualified immunity"—legal protection that shields officers from lawsuits unless they violated clearly established rules—when they jumped over a family's backyard wall without a warrant after losing sight of a fleeing domestic-violence suspect for at least eighteen minutes and using a police dog to pick up a scent. Although eight judges on the appeals court argued that the officers should have been protected from the lawsuit, the Supreme Court turns down most appeals, and factual disputes over whether the neighborhood search actually dragged on for hours make the Court likely to leave the lower court's ruling in place.

    Why this big-case score: Fourth Amendment qualified-immunity and hot-pursuit case from the Ninth Circuit with an eight-judge dissent from denial of rehearing en banc, raising recurring police-pursuit and clearly-established-law questions of moderate institutional significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Fourth Amendment hot-pursuit and qualified-immunity dispute over a warrantless yard entry that ended with two pet dogs shot; a decision would matter to police practice and draw some press, but the likely form (a per curiam error correction or a denial) is narrow, and the sweeping third question (only this Court's decisions clearly establish law) is forfeited and will not be the ground.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The hot-pursuit issue affects residential privacy and police operations; the third question could broadly restrict which precedents establish constitutional rights for qualified immunity across civil-rights litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A standard qualified immunity case lacking national political importance, though notable for procedural signaling.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court first relisted the petition for another conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-relist-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 46%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Police officers and the City of North Las Vegas ask the Supreme Court to overturn a ruling that the officers can be sued for entering a backyard (where they shot two attacking dogs) while tracking a fleeing suspect. We think the Court is slightly less likely than not to take action — about a 46% chance. The Court asked for a response and has now put the case on a second conference, and eight appeals judges dissented below, signs that point toward a possible quick reversal without full argument; but most such cases still end in a denial.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound qualified-immunity/hot-pursuit dispute; stakes rise only if the Court took QP 3 (Supreme-Court-only clearly established law), which it is very unlikely to do.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: reverse without hearing argumentused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is slightly more likely than not to take this case: I put the chance at 58%. The likeliest result is a short decision reversing the lower court without full argument. Eight appeals-court judges objected to denying the officers qualified immunity, a protection against damages when the legal rule was not sufficiently clear. The Court has also asked for a response and reconsidered the petition. However, disputed facts about the search leave a substantial chance that it declines review.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally relevant limits on police searches and qualified immunity, but the likeliest intervention is a narrow, fact-specific correction rather than adoption of the petition's sweeping Supreme-Court-precedent-only rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I predict the Supreme Court will **deny** the petition for review, with **about a one-in-four chance (24%)** that it steps in (most likely by summarily reversing the lower court's ruling without full oral argument). North Las Vegas police officers are asking the Court to throw out a lawsuit filed after they climbed into a family's walled backyard without a search warrant and shot two pet dogs while searching the neighborhood for a fleeing domestic-violence suspect. Although eight judges on the federal appeals court dissented and argued the officers should be shielded by qualified immunity (a legal rule protecting police from lawsuits unless they violated clearly established law), key factual disputes about how long the search took and the lack of disagreement among different appeals courts make the Supreme Court likely to turn the case away.

    Why this big-case score: Routine § 1983 Fourth Amendment hot-pursuit and qualified-immunity dispute unless the Court were to reach Question 2 on whether circuit precedent can clearly establish law.

Davis v. LovelaceThe Supreme Court declined to hear a death-row inmate's challenge to how courts should weigh jury hesitation in assessing whether his trial lawyers' errors prejudiced his sentencing.Criminal lawdecided
0.35
0.58
0.20
0.38

Jimmy Davis, Jr. v. Greg Lovelace, Commissioner, Alabama Department of CorrectionsNo. 25-1410 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73521973 · models differ by up to 0.38 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear a death-row inmate's challenge to how courts should weigh jury hesitation in assessing whether his trial lawyers' errors prejudiced his sentencing.

What happened

Jimmy Davis, Jr. was convicted of capital murder in Alabama and sentenced to death in 1993, after a jury that initially split 7-5 toward life imprisonment ultimately recommended death 11-1. Davis argued in state and federal courts that his trial lawyers were ineffective for failing to investigate and present evidence of childhood abuse and the non-violent details of his only prior conviction. State courts and a federal district court rejected his claims, and a divided panel of the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, finding Davis had not shown prejudice under the governing legal test. The full Eleventh Circuit declined to rehear the case, over dissents.

What the Court is being asked

Davis asked the Court to decide whether judges evaluating whether a defendant was harmed by his lawyer's mistakes must take into account signs that the jury was reluctant to impose a death sentence, such as an initial vote favoring life imprisonment. He also asked the Court to decide whether the appeals court's ruling conflicted with the Court's own precedents on evaluating such harm in death penalty cases.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026 the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Davis, the inmate, asked the Court to take up his case and reverse the Eleventh Circuit's decision, which had ruled against him and in favor of Lovelace, the Alabama prison official named as respondent. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Eleventh Circuit's decision in place, meaning Davis's conviction and death sentence stand and his claim that his trial lawyers' errors prejudiced his sentencing does not succeed. The denial does not mean the Court found the lower court's reasoning correct; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A capital habeas petition raising a contested circuit split on jury hesitation in Strickland prejudice; life-or-death stakes for one petitioner and a doctrinal question of real but bounded reach, confined to AEDPA review of penalty-phase ineffectiveness claims.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Life-or-death stakes and a potentially recurring capital-sentencing prejudice question, but a fact-intensive habeas vehicle rather than a broad challenge to capital punishment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    It is a capital case involving an en banc circuit split, but fact-bound and subject to AEDPA deference, limiting national significance.

Mast v. DoeThe Supreme Court declined to review the Masts' challenge to a court order barring them from disclosing information identifying the family that sued them.decided
0.45
0.57
0.10
0.37

Joshua Mast, et al. v. John Doe, et al.No. 26-226 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000226 · models differ by up to 0.47

The Supreme Court declined to review the Masts' challenge to a court order barring them from disclosing information identifying the family that sued them.

What happened

Joshua and Stephanie Mast adopted a young Afghan girl they say was rescued as an injured orphan during a U.S. military operation; Richard Mast, Joshua's brother, served as their attorney. John and Jane Doe, who had also cared for the child and helped evacuate her from Afghanistan, sued the Masts in federal court. Early in that case, the district court issued an order, without hearing from the Masts first, barring them from disclosing information identifying the Does, citing safety concerns. The Masts challenged the order as an unconstitutional restriction on speech. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit agreed the order restricted speech based on its content, but upheld it anyway, on a rationale about protecting the government's ability to recruit foreign intelligence sources that no party had raised.

What the Court is being asked

The Masts asked the Court to decide whether an appeals court may uphold a lower court's order by relying on its own justification, one that neither side nor the lower court ever raised or argued about, rather than reviewing the reasoning the lower court actually gave or sending the case back for further proceedings on the new rationale.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 16, 2026 conference, and on October 19, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

The Masts asked the Court to take up their case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fourth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the order barring the Masts from disclosing information identifying the Does remains in effect. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Fourth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed. The Does, who defended the order below, keep the benefit of that ruling without further proceedings in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A widely covered Afghan-orphan custody saga, but the legal question is appellate procedure (party presentation) wrapped around a one-party protective order; a decision would be newsworthy for its facts more than its doctrine.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A speech restraint in private litigation raises consequential questions about strict scrutiny, appellate party presentation, and national-security rationales. The underlying international adoption dispute adds public significance, but the question presented is narrower than custody or evacuation policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves a novel prior restraint rationale on protecting foreign collaborators, but respondent waived response, indicating low actual stakes.

Hastings College Conservation Committee v. CaliforniaThe Court declined to hear descendants of a law school's 1878 founder challenge a 2022 law that renamed the school and ended their reserved board seat.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.30
0.46
0.35
0.37

Hastings College Conservation Committee, et al. v. California, et al.No. 25-1231 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73266074 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear descendants of a law school's 1878 founder challenge a 2022 law that renamed the school and ended their reserved board seat.

What happened

In 1878, California passed a law letting S.C. Hastings found a public law school in exchange for $100,000, providing the school would be named for him and that one board seat would always go to his heir or representative. In 2022, after findings that Hastings had financed violence against Native Americans, the legislature renamed the school and eliminated the reserved board seat. Hastings's descendants and an alumni group sued, claiming the 1878 law was a binding contract the state could not break and that the new law amounted to unconstitutional punishment of Hastings and his family. California's trial court, appeals court, and supreme court all ruled against them, finding no enforceable contract and no punishment of anyone.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a 19th-century state law establishing a public college's name and board structure, passed in exchange for a donor's payment, created contract rights that a later legislature could not undo. It is also asked whether a law that renames a public institution and changes its board eligibility rules, based on findings about a long-deceased founder's conduct, improperly punishes that person and his descendants without a trial, which would violate the ban on legislative punishment aimed at specific people.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it on October 19, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Hastings College Conservation Committee and the individual descendants, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the California courts' rulings in favor of the state and the college's leaders. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the California Court of Appeal's decision in place: the renaming and board changes stand, and the descendants' contract and constitutional claims remain rejected. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it will not review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A novel Bill of Attainder Clause theory and a Contract Clause reserved-powers question, but a fact-bound dispute over one law school's name and one hereditary board seat, with no amicus support; regionally newsworthy rather than nationally consequential.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential limits on state repudiation of donor arrangements and legislative punishment, with cultural salience from a public law school's renaming; the unusual founding statute and preservation disputes constrain broader reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile cultural issue regarding the renaming of a major public law school, but localized entirely to California and unlikely to shift national precedent.

PG Publishing v. NLRBThe Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's publisher asked the Court to overturn rulings that it bargained in bad faith with its newsroom union; the Court denied review.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.35
0.55
0.20
0.37

PG Publishing Company, Inc., dba Pittsburgh Post-Gazette v. National Labor Relations Board, et al.No. 25-1192 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281674 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's publisher asked the Court to overturn rulings that it bargained in bad faith with its newsroom union; the Court denied review.

What happened

PG Publishing, which owns the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, spent years negotiating a labor contract with the Newspaper Guild representing its newsroom employees. After bargaining stalled, PG declared an impasse and unilaterally changed employment terms. The National Labor Relations Board found PG had bargained in bad faith and improperly declared impasse, ordering it to restore prior terms and compensate employees for resulting financial harm. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the Board's decision and denied PG's request for rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The case raised three questions: whether labor law allows a finding of bad-faith bargaining based only on the content of an employer's contract proposals, without separate evidence of misconduct; whether the appeals court wrongly deferred to the Board's interpretation of its own authority instead of independently judging the issue; and whether the Board has authority to order an employer to pay employees for broader financial losses caused by unfair labor practices, beyond traditional backpay.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

PG Publishing asked the Court to overturn the Third Circuit's decision. Because the Court denied review, the Third Circuit's ruling stands: the Board's findings that PG bargained in bad faith and improperly declared impasse remain in effect, and PG must comply with the Board's order to restore prior employment terms and compensate the Guild's members, as the National Labor Relations Board and the Newspaper Guild had urged. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that decision in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the Thryv consequential-damages and Loper-Bright-for-the-NLRB questions would matter across labor law, but this vehicle would most plausibly yield a narrow fact-bound ruling on the bad-faith inference, and the paper's sale leaves only backpay at stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could affect nationwide collective bargaining, judicial review of NLRB decisions, and monetary remedies for unfair labor practices. Those systemic stakes exceed the individual newspaper dispute, although the vehicle is procedurally narrow.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An ordinary NLRB bargaining dispute with no major stakes beyond the immediate parties.

TitleMax of Virginia v. SpicherTitleMax asks the Court to review whether federal courts must step back from a Pennsylvania enforcement action against it under a rule favoring state proceedings over federal ones.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.30
0.58
0.22
0.37

TitleMax of Virginia, Inc., et al. v. Wendy S. Spicher, Secretary, Pennsylvania Department of Banking and SecuritiesNo. 25-1359 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500260 · models differ by up to 0.36 · topic: Civil procedure

TitleMax asks the Court to review whether federal courts must step back from a Pennsylvania enforcement action against it under a rule favoring state proceedings over federal ones.

What happened

Pennsylvania's banking regulator subpoenaed TitleMax, a car-title lender, over loans to Pennsylvania residents that allegedly carried interest rates far above the state's cap. After TitleMax complied, the state brought an administrative enforcement proceeding seeking tens of millions in penalties. TitleMax sued in federal court, arguing the proceeding improperly reached across state lines in violation of the Constitution's limits on state interference with interstate commerce. The district court declined to hear the claim, applying a doctrine that keeps federal courts from interfering with certain ongoing state proceedings, and the Third Circuit affirmed. TitleMax also lost parallel appeals in other circuits.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state's general interest in enforcing its consumer-protection laws is "important" enough to justify a federal court stepping back from a case, when the state is applying that law to transactions companies say happened in other states. TitleMax argues courts should weigh the state's interest against the competing interest in letting other states regulate business conducted within their own borders, rather than accepting any broadly stated state interest as sufficient.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court later asked for a response, which Pennsylvania's regulator filed opposing review. The case has not yet been scheduled for another conference in this record.

What each outcome would mean

TitleMax, the company facing the state enforcement action, asked the Court to take the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the lower court applied the right standard, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Third Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place the ruling that federal courts should not interfere with Pennsylvania's enforcement proceeding, and TitleMax would continue litigating in the state process.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the TitleMax of Virginia's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The TitleMax of Virginia's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely **turn down** TitleMax's request to hear this case — I put the chance it agrees to hear it at about one in eight (12%). TitleMax wants a federal court, not Pennsylvania's own enforcement proceeding, to hear its constitutional challenge to Pennsylvania's fines over loans made in other states. The Court asking Pennsylvania to respond is a modest sign of interest, and the lender points to disagreement among appeals courts, but the Court rarely takes up this kind of question about when federal courts should step aside.

    Why this big-case score: A Younger-abstention scope question with real federalism stakes for interstate enforcement actions, but doctrinal and procedural rather than a headline merits issue.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down these lenders' request for review; I put the chance of review or another grant-based action at 18%, roughly one in six. The dispute concerns whether federal courts must step aside while Pennsylvania pursues lending-law proceedings involving out-of-state companies. The Court's request for a response and an asserted disagreement among appeals courts make review plausible. But the lower ruling is nonbinding precedent, the facts complicate the legal question, and related litigation may provide a better case.

    Why this big-case score: Access to federal court for constitutional challenges to interstate state enforcement has consequences beyond consumer lending, but this is an abstention dispute rather than a decision on the substantive limits of state regulation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny TitleMax's petition for review, with only about a one-in-twenty-five (4%) chance of granting it. Although the Court asked Pennsylvania regulators to file a response after South Carolina supported TitleMax, the Court rarely grants review where, as here, the lower federal appeals court issued an unpublished, non-binding decision. Moreover, the Third Circuit had already ruled in an earlier case that TitleMax's car-title loans had sufficient ties to Pennsylvania, and a parallel appeal is still pending in the Fourth Circuit.

    Why this big-case score: Interstate federalism and Younger abstention challenge to state consumer-usury enforcement against out-of-state brick-and-mortar lenders, supported by one state amicus brief but arising from an unpublished Third Circuit affirmance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring federal-courts question (how Younger's important-state-interest prong treats one State's extraterritorial enforcement against out-of-state lenders) with real federalism stakes, but a doctrinal-procedural issue rather than a headline merits question.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns federal-court access for constitutional challenges to interstate financial regulation, with consequences beyond these lenders, but presents a technical abstention issue rather than the underlying regulation's validity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision clarifying whether Younger abstention's important-state-interest prong weighs horizontal federalism and extraterritoriality limits would meaningfully shape federal-court access for businesses challenging out-of-state administrative enforcement actions, though the question is a procedural abstention issue rather than a direct merits ruling on the dormant Commerce Clause.

Grace v. United StatesMarshall Grace asks the Court to review whether an appeals court could itself decide a disputed jury-selection issue instead of sending it back to the trial judge.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.55
0.25
0.37

Marshall Grace v. United StatesNo. 26-459 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000459 · models differ by up to 0.30

Marshall Grace asks the Court to review whether an appeals court could itself decide a disputed jury-selection issue instead of sending it back to the trial judge.

What happened

Marshall Grace was convicted of federal drug conspiracy charges after a trial in which prosecutors struck a Black potential juror, Edward Davis, using a peremptory challenge. Grace objected under the rule against race-based jury strikes. The trial judge, rather than ruling on the prosecutor's stated reason, questioned Davis directly and then denied the objection based on information the prosecutor had not known when exercising the strike. On appeal, the Fifth Circuit agreed the trial judge had used the wrong approach, but rather than sending the case back, the appeals court itself decided the prosecutor's original reason was not shown to be a pretext for discrimination, and upheld the conviction. The full court denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, when an appeals court finds that a trial judge failed to properly decide whether a juror strike was racially motivated, the appeals court may resolve that factual question itself, or whether it must instead send the case back to the trial judge to decide.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and the government waived its right to respond, but the Court later requested a response, due November 27, 2026. The case was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and the docket shows no action recorded since.

What each outcome would mean

Grace, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether appeals courts may make this kind of finding themselves; a grant would not by itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision upholding Grace's conviction stands, and the case ends there. A denial would not mean the Court agrees with the lower court's approach, only that it leaves that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 27, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Grace's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Grace's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn this case down; we put the chance it takes action at about one in five. Marshall Grace says the Fifth Circuit wrongly upheld the prosecutor's removal of a Black juror without the trial judge properly deciding whether race was the motive. The Court asked the government to respond, which shows some interest. A new 2026 Supreme Court ruling on juror-strike challenges could also lead the Court to send the case back for a fresh look. Still, most cases like this are denied.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring federal-criminal Batson remedy question with a claimed 4-2 split; procedural, not a headline issue.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Marshall Grace's appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of accepting it or sending it back for another look. Grace argues that appeals judges improperly decided whether a prosecutor excluded a juror because of race, instead of asking the trial judge to decide. The Court's request for a government response and conflicting appeals-court approaches improve his chances, but the case may not cleanly present that disagreement. Expect another conference listing after the response, followed most likely by denial without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A consequential jury-discrimination and trial/appellate factfinding question, but a procedural clarification rather than a wholesale change to Batson.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Marshall Grace's petition for review, with only about an 11% chance (roughly one in nine) of granting it or sending the case back to the lower court. During jury selection at Grace's federal drug-trafficking trial, the trial judge doubted the prosecutor's reason for removing a Black prospective juror—a challenge governed by *Batson v. Kentucky*, which forbids race-based jury strikes—and improperly questioned the juror himself before allowing the strike. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response to Grace's petition, the trial transcript shows that the judge explicitly rejected the claim of racial targeting and that the juror stated during questioning that "only God can judge people" and failed to disclose his son's prior arrest, making the case a poor vehicle for Supreme Court intervention.

    Why this big-case score: A plenary decision would clarify whether federal appellate courts may make Batson step-three pretext findings in the first instance or must remand, a recurring procedural question for criminal and civil jury trials though not a high-salience constitutional restructuring.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely **turn down** Marshall Grace's appeal, giving about a one-in-five chance that it takes some action for him. The case asks whether a federal appeals court can decide for itself if a prosecutor struck a juror because of race, rather than sending that question back to the trial judge. The Court has asked the government to respond, which is a sign of interest. A recent related Supreme Court decision (Pitchford v. Cain) also makes it possible the Court sends the case back for a fresh look, but most cases like this are still denied.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring federal-criminal procedural question about Batson step three on appeal; matters to trial practice but is narrow and procedural.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.56·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will most likely decline to hear Marshall Grace's case, although I put the chance of some relief at 28%, a little better than one in four. He argues that appeals judges improperly decided whether a prosecutor discriminated when removing a prospective juror, instead of returning that question to the trial judge. Conflicting appeals-court approaches and a recent related Supreme Court ruling make this petition stronger than most. If the Court intervenes, sending it back for reconsideration is likelier than a full hearing.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally consequential jury-discrimination safeguards and limits on appellate factfinding, but a comparatively narrow procedural question rather than a wholesale change to Batson.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely to deny Marshall Grace's petition for review, giving it only about a 3.5 percent chance of being granted. Grace challenges his federal drug convictions by arguing that the appeals court should have sent his case back to the trial judge after finding a procedural mistake in how the judge handled a *Batson* challenge—an objection that prosecutors improperly excluded a Black prospective juror because of race. Because the federal government waived its right to respond and the trial record shows no evidence of racial discrimination, the Court is overwhelmingly likely to turn the appeal away.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound direct criminal appeal challenging whether a federal appellate court may affirm a Batson step-three ruling on the existing record after the trial judge questioned a prospective juror sua sponte.

Greer v. Benton School DistrictThe Supreme Court declined to hear a substitute teacher's bid to revive her disability-retaliation claim against a school district that stopped assigning her to its schools.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.25
0.44
0.40
0.36

Brandi Greer v. Benton School DistrictNo. 25-1197 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281703 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Supreme Court declined to hear a substitute teacher's bid to revive her disability-retaliation claim against a school district that stopped assigning her to its schools.

What happened

Brandi Greer worked as a substitute teacher for Benton School District through a staffing agency, Kelly Services. After she filed an ethics complaint against her child's teacher, the District barred her from working at any of its schools. Greer sued the District under a federal disability-rights law, the Rehabilitation Act, claiming retaliation. A jury awarded her damages, and the trial court also issued an injunction in her favor. The Arkansas Supreme Court reversed, ruling that because Greer worked for a staffing agency rather than the District itself, she could not sue the District under that law. It also rejected her related state-law claims on separate grounds.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal law barring disability discrimination by recipients of federal funding lets someone who works through an outside staffing agency, rather than directly for the funded organization, sue that organization for retaliation. Greer argues federal appeals courts are split on this question. The District answers that no real split covers her situation, that the case also turns on separate issues she has not challenged, and that the lower court's reading of the law was correct.

Where it stands

The Court asked for and received a response from the District, along with a reply from Greer. The petition was distributed for a conference and, on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Greer, who lost in the Arkansas Supreme Court, asked the Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Arkansas Supreme Court's decision in place: Greer's retaliation claim against Benton School District fails, along with the jury's damage award and the injunction that had barred the District from excluding her. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Arkansas court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean statutory-coverage question (whether section 504 reaches non-employees) that matters to the disability-rights bar and to federally funded programs, but the stakes are modest, no amicus has appeared, and the underlying dispute is a $7,000 retaliation verdict.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.44·Chance the Court takes the case: 36%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could settle nationwide Rehabilitation Act coverage for independent contractors and other nonemployees, including disability advocates in schools. The statutory issue extends beyond this small damages dispute, but it is narrower than a major constitutional or institutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Independent Specialty Insurance v. Apex Hospitality GroupAn insurer's bid to have the Supreme Court decide which law governs arbitration disputes under an international insurance treaty ended when the insurer withdrew its case.decided
0.25
0.43
0.40
0.36

Independent Specialty Insurance Company v. Apex Hospitality Group, L.L.C.scotus/73550516 · models differ by up to 0.18

An insurer's bid to have the Supreme Court decide which law governs arbitration disputes under an international insurance treaty ended when the insurer withdrew its case.

What happened

Apex Hospitality bought hurricane insurance partly from Independent Specialty Insurance Company, a U.S. insurer, and partly from a foreign insurer. After a hurricane damaged its property, Apex sued only Independent Specialty in Louisiana court, not the foreign insurer. Independent Specialty asked the court to send the dispute to arbitration, relying on an international treaty, but Louisiana law generally bars arbitration clauses in insurance policies. The district court ultimately refused to order arbitration, and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed, following its own recent precedent that state law, not federal law, controls whether a company that did not sign the arbitration agreement can still enforce it.

What the Court is being asked

The case asked whether, under this international arbitration treaty, a court should use a federal rule or a state's own contract law to decide whether a company that is not a signatory to an arbitration agreement can still force arbitration based on it.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court asked Apex to respond. Before the Court took any further action, Independent Specialty and Apex jointly asked to dismiss the petition, and the Court dismissed it on October 20, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Independent Specialty, the insurer, had asked the Court to take up the case and reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling, which favored Apex by keeping the dispute in court rather than arbitration. Because the parties jointly agreed to dismiss the petition, the Court will not decide the legal question. The Fifth Circuit's decision stands, meaning Apex's lawsuit against Independent Specialty continues in court rather than being sent to arbitration.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesDismissedOct 20, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-20: the Court dismissed it. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision would settle which body of law governs nonsignatory enforcement of New York Convention arbitration agreements, a question GE Energy expressly reserved; significant to the international-arbitration bar and the Louisiana surplus-lines market after the 2020-2021 hurricanes, but technical and unlikely to draw broad public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.43·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The choice of law for nonsignatory enforcement of international arbitration agreements has national commercial significance and affects hurricane-insurance litigation, but this unpublished companion vehicle presents a technical issue rather than a broad public-rights dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Resolves a 4-1 circuit split on the New York Convention and equitable estoppel, important for international arbitration but technically narrow.

New Mexico v. NealNew Mexico asks the Court to review how courts decide whether two crimes count as the same offense for double jeopardy purposes.awaiting the Court
0.35
0.48
0.25
0.36

New Mexico v. Samuel NealNo. 26-37 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000037 · models differ by up to 0.23

New Mexico asks the Court to review how courts decide whether two crimes count as the same offense for double jeopardy purposes.

What happened

Samuel Neal was convicted of kidnapping, criminal sexual penetration, and aggravated battery after a sexual assault. He argued the convictions punished him twice for the same conduct. New Mexico's Court of Appeals vacated two of his three convictions on double jeopardy grounds. The New Mexico Supreme Court partly disagreed, reinstating the aggravated battery conviction but agreeing that the kidnapping and sexual-penetration convictions were the same offense, based on its review of the evidence, arguments, and jury instructions at trial rather than only the statutes' abstract elements. New Mexico, as petitioner, now asks the United States Supreme Court to review that decision, arguing it conflicts with how federal appeals courts and other state courts decide such questions.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked what information a court may look at when deciding whether a defendant's two convictions are really punishment for a single offense. One approach looks only at the crimes' statutory elements in the abstract. Another also considers how the charges were written in the indictment. New Mexico's approach goes further, examining the evidence, arguments, and jury instructions actually used at trial. The petition asks the Court to say which approach the Constitution requires.

Where it stands

Neal waived his right to respond, but the Court requested a response, which has twice been granted extensions, most recently to November 25, 2026. The petition has not yet been distributed for a conference since that response was requested.

What each outcome would mean

New Mexico, as petitioner, is asking the Court to take up the case and reject the New Mexico Supreme Court's approach. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide which method courts must use, with no outcome yet determined. If the Court denies review, the New Mexico Supreme Court's decision stands, leaving Neal's sexual-penetration conviction vacated and his kidnapping and aggravated-battery convictions intact, under New Mexico's existing approach.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up New Mexico's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: New Mexico's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    New Mexico asks the Supreme Court to reinstate a man's kidnapping conviction. The state's top court threw it out because convicting him of both rape and kidnapping punished the same act twice, which the Constitution's "double jeopardy" rule forbids. The Court has asked the man's lawyers to respond, which shows some interest. Even so, I think the Court will probably turn the case down, about a one-in-nine chance of review. The main reason is that the state court's ruling rests partly on New Mexico's own law, which the Supreme Court generally cannot override.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring Blockburger-methodology question with a claimed three-way split; important to criminal practice but doctrinally technical, and the split is mostly one outlier state.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 34%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to decline New Mexico's appeal, with about a one-in-three chance that it agrees to review the case. The dispute concerns when two criminal convictions count as punishing someone twice for the same offense. Courts use different methods, and the justices' request for a response shows interest. Still, details of New Mexico's statutes and the trial instructions could make this a poor case for announcing a national rule. A denial would probably come without an explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring constitutional rule governing multiple criminal punishments could affect prosecutions nationwide, but the dispute is technical and turns partly on New Mexico's distinctive doctrine.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is very likely to deny New Mexico's petition for review (an 88% chance of denial, or about a one-in-eight chance of a grant). New Mexico asks the Court to clarify how the Constitution's Double Jeopardy Clause—which forbids punishing a person twice for the same crime—applies when a defendant is convicted of overlapping state charges in a single trial. Although the Court asked Samuel Neal's lawyers to file a response, the case is a poor candidate for review because the New Mexico Supreme Court relied on state-law rules for interpreting state statutes and the state constitution, reinstated one of the two disputed convictions, and faulted the prosecution's case-specific jury instructions on the other.

    Why this big-case score: Doctrinally significant question on how Blockburger v. United States applies to multi-alternative state criminal statutes in single-trial cumulative-punishment prosecutions, though low national public profile.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    New Mexico asks the Supreme Court to overturn a state-court ruling that threw out a rape conviction. The state court found that the conviction punished the defendant twice for the same crime along with his kidnapping conviction. We think the Court will probably turn the case away, giving about a one-in-seven chance that it takes it. The Court did ask the defendant to respond, which shows some interest. But the state court also relied on New Mexico's own constitution and laws, which the Supreme Court generally cannot review. That makes the case a weak candidate.

    Why this big-case score: A clean ruling on what Blockburger compares would reach every multiple-punishment case nationwide, but the immediate stakes are one New Mexico sentencing.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to turn down New Mexico's request, with about a 28% chance of agreeing to review or otherwise grant relief. The case asks how courts decide whether two convictions punish the same offense. Different courts use different methods, which favors review. But this case also turns on New Mexico's own statutes and the prosecution's trial choices, making it a less straightforward test case. The Court will probably reconsider the petition after receiving the requested response and then deny it without explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A potentially consequential clarification of constitutional limits on cumulative criminal punishment, but a technical question with substantial state-law and trial-record complications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny New Mexico's request to review this criminal case, with only an 8% chance of taking it up (about one in twelve). Although the Court asked Samuel Neal's lawyers to file a response to the State's petition, the New Mexico Supreme Court's decision throwing out one of his overlapping convictions was based heavily on its own interpretation of New Mexico state statutes and jury-verdict rules under both the state and federal constitutions, making the case a poor fit for a nationwide ruling on constitutional double jeopardy (the rule against punishing someone twice for the same crime).

    Why this big-case score: State-court criminal double-jeopardy petition concerning how Blockburger applies to compound state statutes; modest doctrinal interest in criminal procedure, but zero amicus participation and heavily intertwined with New Mexico state statutory construction and general-verdict rules.

Williams v. Charleston County Sheriff’s OfficeFamilies of three traffic-accident victims ask the Court to decide whether a South Carolina sheriff's office can claim state immunity from their lawsuit.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.43
0.35
0.36

Randall Williams, as Personal Representative of the Estates of Shanice R. Dantzler-Williams and Miranda R. Dantzler-Williams, et al. v. Charleston County Sheriff’s OfficeNo. 26-624 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000624 · models differ by up to 0.13

Families of three traffic-accident victims ask the Court to decide whether a South Carolina sheriff's office can claim state immunity from their lawsuit.

What happened

Sheriff's deputies responding to a non-emergency call struck and killed Stephanie Dantzler and her daughters Shanice and Miranda Dantzler-Williams. Their estates sued the Charleston County Sheriff's Office and others. The district court dismissed the claims against the sheriff's office, ruling it shares the state's immunity from suit as an "arm of the state," and the Fourth Circuit affirmed. The Supreme Court earlier granted review, set aside that ruling, and sent the case back for the Fourth Circuit to reconsider in light of a new Supreme Court decision, Galette, about when government entities count as arms of a state. On reconsideration, the Fourth Circuit again held the sheriff's office immune, reasoning in one paragraph that Galette applies only to entities organized as corporations.

What the Court is being asked

The families ask the Court to decide two things: whether its recent ruling on state-entity immunity applies only to corporations, as the Fourth Circuit held, or more broadly; and whether the Charleston County Sheriff's Office is actually an extension of the state of South Carolina, shielded from suit, or instead more like a county agency that can be sued.

Where it stands

The petition for a writ of certiorari was filed on November 9, 2026, with the respondent's response due December 14, 2026. The Court has not yet acted on it.

What each outcome would mean

The families, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case again and reverse the Fourth Circuit's ruling that favored the sheriff's office. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the sheriff's office is immune from the lawsuit. If it denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands, leaving the sheriff's office immune from these claims and the families unable to pursue that part of their case against it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 14, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Williams' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Williams' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very probably decline to hear this case; I put the chance it steps in at about one in twelve. The families of three women killed in a crash with a sheriff's deputy are asking the Court a second time to rule that the county sheriff's office can be sued in federal court. The Court earlier sent the case back for another look, and the appeals court kept its ruling. That history raises the odds slightly, but the ruling is unpublished and rests on older binding precedent.

    Why this big-case score: Arm-of-the-state status of county sheriffs after Galette matters for section 1983 suits across the Fourth Circuit, but the decision below is unpublished and the dispute is state-specific.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.43·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this appeal, with about a one-in-four chance of taking action in the families' favor. The families argue that a county sheriff's office cannot claim the state's protection from lawsuits. Their strongest point is that the Court already sent this dispute back once, but the appeals court reached the same result. Still, the case turns partly on South Carolina's governmental structure. If the Court intervenes, a short corrective order is more likely than full briefing and argument.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially important limits on state sovereign immunity for locally funded sheriff's offices, but an unpublished, state-specific dispute after remand.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely deny review, with only about a one-in-thirty-three (3%) chance of taking the case. Although the Court previously sent this fatal sheriff's-deputy crash lawsuit back to the federal appeals court to reconsider after a March 2026 sovereign-immunity decision (*Galette*, addressing when state-affiliated bodies are immune from federal lawsuits), that ruling expressly left unincorporated bodies like county sheriffs' offices for another day, the appeals court relied on routine panel-precedent rules in an unpublished opinion with no disagreement among appeals courts, and no appeals judge even asked for a full-court vote.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision would clarify how Galette v. New Jersey Transit Corp.'s arm-of-the-state sovereign-immunity framework applies to unincorporated county sheriffs' offices in § 1983 suits, affecting law-enforcement accountability in several states without broad national political or economic disruption.

Ronnie Alexander v. Philip R. Taft Psy D and Associates, P.L.L.C., et al.A former pretrial detainee's challenge to his jail cell conditions and mental health care was denied review by the Supreme Court.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.30
0.52
0.25
0.36

Ronnie Alexander v. Philip R. Taft Psy D and Associates, P.L.L.C., et al.No. 25-1128 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281412 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Constitutional rights

A former pretrial detainee's challenge to his jail cell conditions and mental health care was denied review by the Supreme Court.

What happened

Ronnie Alexander was held in the Henderson County, Texas jail in March 2021. After telling officers he was suicidal, he was moved to a bare "suicide prevention" cell for five days, which he says lacked a toilet, shower, bedding, and adequate water. He sued the county, several officers, and a mental health contractor, claiming the cell conditions amounted to unconstitutional punishment and that he received inadequate mental health care. The district court dismissed his claims. A divided Fifth Circuit panel affirmed, with one judge dissenting. The full appeals court declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raised three issues: whether jail mental health providers' constitutional duties go beyond protecting detainees from violence and suicide; whether conditions imposed for suicide prevention can still count as unlawful punishment if they are excessive or deprive someone of basic necessities; and whether a court may refuse, as too speculative, to draw inferences about jail staff's intent to punish a detainee from the facts alleged.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, with the Court requesting a response from the respondents after the first distribution. The respondents opposed the petition, Alexander filed a reply, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Alexander, the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and reverse the Fifth Circuit's ruling. The county, officers, and mental health providers, as respondents, urged the Court to leave that ruling in place. Because the Court denied the petition, the Fifth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of Alexander's claims stands, and the case does not proceed further in the courts. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pretrial-detainee suicide-watch conditions and the Bell proportionality test matter to a large jail population, but the case is fact-bound, raises no clean split, and would draw limited attention outside the prisoner-rights bar.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could materially affect pretrial detainees' mental-health care, suicide-watch conditions, and pleading of punitive intent. Those are substantial recurring civil-rights stakes, although the defendant-specific allegations and defenses may confine any ruling's reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A local jail conditions case under Section 1983; while the facts are stark, it does not have broad national impact.

Gomez v. SaccoccioThe Supreme Court declined to hear a police officer's bid to revive his qualified immunity defense against a man he shot with a less-lethal round during 2020 protests.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.25
0.42
0.40
0.36

Eric Gomez v. David SaccoccioNo. 25-1314 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500215 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a police officer's bid to revive his qualified immunity defense against a man he shot with a less-lethal round during 2020 protests.

What happened

During curfew-related unrest in Phoenix in May 2020, Officer Eric Gomez shot David Saccoccio with a less-lethal round as Saccoccio tried to climb a fence away from police, breaking his arm. Saccoccio sued, claiming excessive force. The district court granted Gomez qualified immunity, a legal protection that shields officials from lawsuits unless they violated clearly established rights. The Ninth Circuit reversed, ruling that two of its prior decisions, read together, clearly established that Saccoccio's rights were violated. Gomez then asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The case asked whether appeals courts may combine general principles from two different prior cases, each involving different facts, to conclude that a right was "clearly established" for qualified immunity purposes, or whether they must instead point to a single closely similar prior case before holding an officer should have known his conduct was unlawful.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court denied the petition on October 19, 2026, after considering it at conferences in September and October.

What each outcome would mean

Gomez, the officer, asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling against him. By denying review, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Saccoccio's excessive-force lawsuit against Gomez can continue in the lower courts. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed and decides nothing about who should ultimately win the underlying case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An unpublished, fact-bound qualified-immunity dispute over a single less-lethal round at a 2020 protest; newsworthy mainly as protest-policing accountability, and only if the Court intervenes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Police use of impact munitions against protesters and qualified immunity have recurring civil-rights stakes, but this unpublished, fact-dependent individual damages case presents no demonstrated circuit split or challenge to qualified immunity itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves qualified immunity in excessive force case (often a flashpoint), but the fact-specific nature may limit its broader significance.

James Dwight Pavatt v. OklahomaJames Pavatt asked the Court to pause his execution while it considered his death sentence appeal; the Court denied the stay and denied review.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.15
0.67
0.25
0.36

James Dwight Pavatt v. OklahomaNo. 26A661 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000661 · models differ by up to 0.52 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

James Pavatt asked the Court to pause his execution while it considered his death sentence appeal; the Court denied the stay and denied review.

What happened

James Pavatt was convicted of murder in Oklahoma and sentenced to death in 2003. Decades later, he filed a new post-conviction application in Oklahoma courts arguing that prosecutors had used knowingly false information at his sentencing, which a juror's affidavit said influenced his vote for death. The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals denied this claim as procedurally barred, finding the facts underlying it had been discoverable for over twenty years. With his execution scheduled for November 12, 2026, Pavatt asked the Supreme Court both to hear his case and to stay the execution in the meantime.

What the Court is being asked

Pavatt's underlying petition asks whether the Constitution requires an exception to a state rule that normally bars using juror statements to challenge a verdict, when new evidence shows prosecutors gave a jury false information that affected at least one juror's vote for death. The stay application separately asks whether Pavatt has shown enough likelihood of success and enough harm from execution to justify pausing it while the Court considers that question.

Where it stands

Justice Gorsuch referred the stay application to the full Court, which denied the stay of execution and denied the petition for certiorari on November 12, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Pavatt, the applicant, sought both a stay and Supreme Court review; Oklahoma opposed both. The Court's denial of the stay means no pause was granted, and its denial of certiorari leaves the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals' ruling against Pavatt in place, without the Supreme Court deciding the underlying constitutional questions. The denial of certiorari is not a ruling that Oklahoma's procedural bar or Pavatt's claims were correctly decided; it only leaves the lower court's decision standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 12, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-12: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will **deny** James Pavatt's request to halt his November 12, 2026 execution in Oklahoma, with only about a 2% (one-in-fifty) chance it grants the stay. His argument asks the Court to stretch a 2017 ruling — which let courts hear jurors' testimony about racial bias in deliberations — to cover a juror who says prosecutors' false claims swayed the death vote. The Court rarely blocks executions this late and has kept that ruling narrow, so a stay is unlikely.

    Why this big-case score: A single capital execution is grave for the parties, but the legal question (extending Pena-Rodriguez to prosecutorial misstatements) is narrow and draws little attention beyond capital litigators.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.67·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to refuse James Pavatt's request to pause his November 12 execution; I put the chance of relief at about six in a hundred. He alleges that prosecutors misled the jury about who fired the fatal shots and wants jurors' later accounts considered despite rules generally barring them. The allegations are serious, but his request would extend an existing constitutional exception. I expect a quick response from Oklahoma and consideration by the full Court before execution.

    Why this big-case score: An imminent execution and an asserted constitutional exception to juror-impeachment restrictions create substantial stakes, although the immediate application concerns one sentence.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny James Dwight Pavatt's emergency application to stay his November 12, 2026 execution, with only a 3% chance (about one in thirty-three) of granting a stay. Pavatt asks the Justices to create a new constitutional exception to the long-standing rule that jurors cannot testify later to impeach their own verdict, relying on a juror's statement about how prosecutors' closing arguments affected sentencing deliberations in his 2001 murder case. Because the Court has strictly limited that exception to cases involving explicit racial bias during jury deliberations—and historically grants only about 3.5% of capital stay requests from prisoners—it is highly unlikely to halt the execution.

    Why this big-case score: Capital execution stay application arising from the high-profile 2001 murder of Rob Andrew (co-defendant of Brenda Andrew in Andrew v. White, 604 U.S. 86 (2025)), seeking to extend Pena-Rodriguez v. Colorado, 580 U.S. 206 (2017), to juror impeachment affidavits alleging reliance on false prosecutorial sentencing arguments.

Nguyen v. LouisianaA woman convicted of misdemeanor domestic abuse battery asks the Court to rule that she was entitled to a jury trial rather than a bench trial.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.30
0.48
0.28
0.35

Allison Nguyen v. LouisianaNo. 26-19 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000019 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Criminal law

A woman convicted of misdemeanor domestic abuse battery asks the Court to rule that she was entitled to a jury trial rather than a bench trial.

What happened

Allison Nguyen was convicted after a bench trial of misdemeanor domestic abuse battery, stemming from an incident in which she struck her boyfriend with her phone. Louisiana law gives defendants a jury trial only for crimes punishable by more than six months imprisonment; her charge carried a maximum of six months, so the trial court denied her request for a jury. The Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal and the Louisiana Supreme Court both left that ruling in place, though the appeals court sent the case back only to fix a sentencing detail unrelated to the jury issue.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a crime that carries no more than six months in jail still counts as serious enough to require a jury trial, given that a conviction also strips the defendant of her right to possess a firearm for years, carries a fine, and cannot later be cleared from her record.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed: Louisiana waived its initial right to respond, the Court later asked for a response anyway, and both a brief in opposition and a reply have been filed. The case has not yet been scheduled for a conference as shown by the docket.

What each outcome would mean

Nguyen is asking the Court to take up her case and overturn the ruling that denied her a jury trial. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether her bench trial satisfied the Constitution. If it denies review, the Louisiana courts' rulings stand, leaving her conviction and bench-trial procedure in place. A denial would not mean the Court agrees with those rulings, only that it leaves them undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Nguyen's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Nguyen's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case (about a 4% chance it takes it). Allison Nguyen was convicted of misdemeanor domestic abuse battery in Louisiana without a jury. She argues that losing her gun rights made the offense "serious" enough to require one. The Court asked Louisiana to file a response, which shows some interest. But a long-standing Supreme Court rule says that crimes punishable by six months or less generally do not require a jury.

    Why this big-case score: Whether the petty-offense presumption survives firearm-disqualifying misdemeanors would reach domestic-violence prosecutions nationwide, but this vehicle is thin and the question is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to turn down Allison Nguyen's request to review her conviction; I put the chance of accepting the case at 12%, about one in eight. Her argument is that losing firearm rights makes a domestic-violence misdemeanor serious enough to require a jury, even when jail time cannot exceed six months. The Court's request for Louisiana to respond shows interest, and Nevada has recognized a similar jury right. But procedural complications and limited evidence of a clear nationwide disagreement make rejection more likely.

    Why this big-case score: Whether firearm disabilities make a six-month domestic-violence misdemeanor serious enough to require a jury has substantial implications for criminal procedure and gun rights, but this petition presents a narrow and procedurally imperfect vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Allison Nguyen's petition for review, with only about a 1-in-17 (6%) chance of agreeing to hear the case. Nguyen was convicted by a Louisiana judge, without a jury, of misdemeanor domestic abuse battery, which carries up to six months in jail plus a ten-year state ban and a lifetime federal ban on owning firearms. Although the Supreme Court asked the State of Louisiana to file a response to her argument that losing gun rights makes the charge serious enough to require a jury trial under the Sixth Amendment, the case has serious procedural flaws because the state appeals court declined to revisit the jury issue after trial and the brief lacks outside support.

    Why this big-case score: A decision holding that federal or state statutory firearm prohibitions render misdemeanor domestic violence offenses 'serious' under Blanton would require jury trials across state misdemeanor courts nationwide, though the issue arises here in a routine local prosecution with narrow doctrinal reach.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn this case down — about a one-in-twenty chance it agrees to hear it. Allison Nguyen was convicted of misdemeanor domestic battery in Louisiana by a judge alone and argues she deserved a jury because the conviction also takes away her gun rights for good. The Court asked Louisiana to respond, a sign of some interest, but the petition is brief, the case is still partly open in the state courts, and the Court usually declines these requests.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring Sixth Amendment petty-offense question (does federal firearm disability make a six-month misdemeanor 'serious' under Blanton) with a state-court split; nationally relevant if taken, but a narrow procedural-rights question rather than a headline case.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to turn down Allison Nguyen's request for review; I put the chance it takes any action granting review at about nine in a hundred. Her argument is that a domestic-abuse conviction's firearm restrictions make the charge serious enough to require a jury, despite a maximum six-month jail term. The Court has asked Louisiana to respond, which shows interest, but questions about how the issue was presented and the unfinished sentencing proceedings make this a less attractive case to decide.

    Why this big-case score: The jury-trial consequences of domestic-violence firearm disabilities could affect misdemeanor prosecutions beyond this defendant, but the petition presents a specific procedural setting and substantial vehicle questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny Allison Nguyen's petition for review (a writ of certiorari, the formal request for the Court to hear an appeal), with about a one-in-twenty-two (4.5%) chance of a grant. Nguyen argues the Constitution guarantees a jury trial for a Louisiana misdemeanor domestic violence charge carrying up to six months in jail because conviction also triggers federal and state gun bans and cannot be erased from her record. Although the Court asked Louisiana to respond, lower courts are not genuinely divided over temporary state firearm restrictions or collateral federal consequences, making review unlikely.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, holding that federal or state firearm prohibitions convert six-month domestic violence misdemeanors into 'serious' offenses under Blanton would require jury trials in misdemeanor and parish courts nationwide.

Pesta v. BloombergA fired university professor asked the Supreme Court to revive his free-speech lawsuit against Cleveland State University officials; the Court declined.First Amendmentdecided
0.30
0.60
0.15
0.35

Bryan Pesta v. Laura Bloomberg, Individually and as President, Cleveland State University, et al.No. 25-1337 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500239 · models differ by up to 0.45 · topic: First Amendment

A fired university professor asked the Supreme Court to revive his free-speech lawsuit against Cleveland State University officials; the Court declined.

What happened

Bryan Pesta, a tenured professor at Cleveland State University, published a study using restricted federal research data. After other researchers complained, the National Institutes of Health found he had used the data outside the scope of his approval, and the university disciplined him and then stripped his tenure and fired him, citing research misconduct. Pesta sued university officials, claiming the real reason was retaliation for the content of his research, in violation of his free-speech rights. The district court ruled for the officials, finding Pesta was fired for misconduct, not for his speech. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that decision, and rehearing was denied.

What the Court is being asked

Pesta's petition asks the Court to clarify the legal test courts use to decide when a public employee's firing for speech-related reasons violates the First Amendment. He argues the Court should require the university to first show his statements were knowingly or recklessly false before weighing his free-speech interest against the university's interests, a standard he says the Court's earlier cases have applied inconsistently. He also argues the lower courts misapplied that balancing test to the facts of his case.

Where it stands

The respondents waived their right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Pesta, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Sixth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning the lower court's judgment against Pesta stands and his lawsuit does not proceed further. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case, without deciding the free-speech questions Pesta raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The reserved Garcetti academic-freedom question and the role of Sullivan malice in Pickering would matter if decided, and the race-and-intelligence research subject makes the case newsworthy; but the posture is a fact-bound, unpublished causation affirmance, so any decision on this record would be narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision defining constitutional protection for public-university research could materially affect academic freedom and employee speech nationwide, although this petition arises from a fact-specific misconduct and causation dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves First Amendment academic freedom dispute over a professor's firing; raises cancel culture themes but is highly fact-bound.

Endure Industries v. VizientThe Supreme Court declined to hear Endure Industries' bid to revive its antitrust suit against Vizient over how courts define a relevant market.Business & financedecided
0.30
0.55
0.20
0.35

Endure Industries, Incorporated v. Vizient Incorporated, a Delaware corporation, et al.No. 25-1385 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500287 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court declined to hear Endure Industries' bid to revive its antitrust suit against Vizient over how courts define a relevant market.

What happened

Endure, a medical-supply seller, sued Vizient, a group purchasing organization, claiming Vizient's contracting and rebate practices violated antitrust law. Endure argued the relevant market should be defined narrowly around hospitals buying through Vizient's purchasing channel. The district court granted summary judgment to Vizient, ruling Endure's proposed markets failed as a matter of law because some hospitals bought supplies outside that channel. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, treating evidence of this outside purchasing as decisive and declining to adopt a different approach used by other appeals courts.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a court can reject a proposed narrower market just because some customers can and do shop elsewhere, even when other evidence shows a distinct group of customers faces unique competitive constraints within that channel. It also asks whether such a market can be defined around sales made through a particular purchasing channel, rather than limited to one seller's branded products.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, the respondent waived its right to respond, and an amicus brief was filed. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Endure, which lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up the case. The denial leaves the Fifth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Endure's antitrust claims against Vizient remain rejected because the proposed markets were found legally deficient. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Fifth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case, without resolving the broader disagreement among appeals courts over how to weigh such evidence.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Market definition is the threshold question in most Sherman Act cases, so a merits ruling on Brown Shoe submarkets and core-customer markets would reach the whole antitrust bar; but this is a private supplier's dispute with a small petitioner, a fact-bound summary-judgment record, and no government interest.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect hospital purchasing competition and antitrust submarket definition across industries, but the dispute is a technical private enforcement vehicle rather than a broad constitutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private antitrust dispute over market definition in the medical supply industry; economically significant to the parties but lacks broad national importance or constitutional stakes.

Federal Express v. QualcommFedEx asks the Court to decide whether a law shielding patent agency decisions from court review also bars review of a skipped statutory check.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.40
0.35
0.35

Federal Express Corporation v. Qualcomm Incorporated, et al.No. 26-170 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000170 · models differ by up to 0.10

FedEx asks the Court to decide whether a law shielding patent agency decisions from court review also bars review of a skipped statutory check.

What happened

Qualcomm filed a patent office challenge against a FedEx patent, without naming a company called Roambee as a co-interested party, even though Qualcomm had ties to Roambee. FedEx argued the omission violated a legal requirement, but the patent board declined to resolve the dispute, reasoning it would not affect the case's outcome, and later ruled the challenged patent claims invalid. FedEx appealed, and the Federal Circuit held that a different law barring review of decisions on whether to open these proceedings also blocked review of this argument. The agency itself later agreed its approach had been wrong, but still argued courts could not review it.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the law making the patent agency's decision to open a review "final and unreviewable" also blocks a court from reviewing a claim that the agency skipped a required check on who has a stake in the case, where the agency itself now says it should have made that determination.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including responses from Qualcomm and the federal government and a reply from FedEx; the case was distributed for a conference and the government was asked to respond. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

FedEx, which lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether this kind of challenge can be reviewed by courts at all; a grant would not itself decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the Federal Circuit's ruling stands, leaving in place its conclusion that FedEx's argument cannot be reviewed and leaving Qualcomm's win intact.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Federal Express' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Federal Express' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down FedEx's request to hear this patent case — about a 6% (roughly one in seventeen) chance it agrees to take it. FedEx says the Patent Office wrongly refused to decide whether Qualcomm hid a partner company in its challenge to FedEx's patents, and that courts should be able to fix that. The Court asked the other side to respond, a modest sign of interest, but an earlier Supreme Court decision (Thryv) points strongly against FedEx and the government will oppose.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but technical question about judicial review of PTAB real-party-in-interest rulings; matters to the patent bar, little beyond it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this patent appeal: I estimate about a one-in-eight chance that it agrees to review the case. FedEx argues that judges must be able to correct the Patent Office's failure to identify everyone behind a patent challenge. The Court's request for a response shows interest, but earlier rulings restrict review of decisions to begin these proceedings, and the agency has already changed its policy. I expect a denial without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Meaningful patent-system and administrative-review stakes: whether courts can enforce real-party disclosure duties despite the bar on reviewing institution decisions. The immediate dispute is technical and the agency has already changed its prospective policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant Federal Express Corporation's petition for review, with about a one-in-eight chance (12% probability) of taking the case, and will most likely deny it. In this patent dispute against Qualcomm, the Patent Office refused to decide whether Qualcomm's challenge named all closely related companies ("real parties in interest") as required by statute, and the appeals court held that federal law bars courts from reviewing that refusal because decisions to start patent reviews are final and nonappealable. Although the Court asked Qualcomm and the federal government to file responses—showing initial interest after the Patent Office admitted its past practice was mistaken—the agency has already changed its policy going forward, there is no disagreement among different appeals courts, and FedEx refused Qualcomm's earlier offer to add the related company to its filings, making Supreme Court intervention unlikely.

    Why this big-case score: Significant administrative and patent-procedure question regarding judicial review under 35 U.S.C. § 314(d) of the PTAB's refusal to adjudicate disputed real-party-in-interest designations under § 312(a)(2), though confined to AIA trial practice.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring but technical question about the reach of 35 U.S.C. 314(d)'s no-appeal bar over real-party-in-interest compliance in inter partes review; it matters to the patent bar and the PTO, and would be the Court's fourth 314(d) case, but the practical relief is a remand for one RPI determination under a policy the Office has already rescinded.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.43·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question affects judicial oversight of patent-review proceedings and real-party-in-interest safeguards across patent litigation, but concerns a specialized statutory issue and a discontinued agency policy rather than an economy-wide substantive patentability rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Davis v. SmithAn Ohio warden asks the Court to decide whether federal courts could keep ordering a prisoner's release after he was retried and reconvicted in state court.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.30
0.40
0.35
0.35

Cynthia Davis, Warden v. David M. SmithNo. 26-176 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000176 · models differ by up to 0.10 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

An Ohio warden asks the Court to decide whether federal courts could keep ordering a prisoner's release after he was retried and reconvicted in state court.

What happened

David Smith was convicted in Ohio state court of attempted murder and other crimes based on a victim's identification of him. He won a federal writ of habeas corpus, a court order for release, after a federal appeals court found the identification process unconstitutionally suggestive. The order was conditional: Ohio could retry him within 180 days without using that identification. Ohio retried Smith, and a jury convicted him again. Smith then asked the same federal court to find that the state still violated the original order and to make his release unconditional. The district court agreed and ordered him released; the Sixth Circuit affirmed over a dissent arguing the federal courts had lost jurisdiction once Smith was retried and resentenced.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a federal court that granted habeas relief based on a prisoner's first conviction still has power to order relief after that prisoner has been retried, convicted again, and sentenced again in state court, or whether a challenge to the new conviction must instead start over in state court.

Where it stands

The warden's petition was distributed for a October 9, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked Smith to respond; the deadline for that response was then extended, at Smith's request, to December 2, 2026. The docket shows no action yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Davis, the warden, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Sixth Circuit's decision, which left Smith's release in place. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full briefing and argument and decide whether the lower federal courts had jurisdiction to order Smith's release after his retrial; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Sixth Circuit's decision affirming Smith's release stands, and the case ends without the Supreme Court resolving the question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 25, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 2, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Davis' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Davis' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 27%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Ohio is asking the Supreme Court to overturn a federal appeals court ruling that freed David Smith after his second state conviction. Ohio argues that federal judges lost power over the case once a state court retried and resentenced him. We think the Court will probably turn the case down, putting the chance it takes the case at about one in four. The Court asked Smith to respond, a sign of some interest. Two Justices wanted to hear the case the last time it came up, but the Court declined then too.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but technical question about federal habeas jurisdiction after a state retrial; important to state-federal relations in the Sixth Circuit, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to decline this case than to take it, but I put the chance of review or an immediate corrective ruling at about two in five. Ohio argues that federal judges lost authority over a prisoner's case after his new trial and conviction. The judges below instead said they were enforcing their original order. The Court's request for a response makes the petition worth watching, but the competing accounts and lack of a clear disagreement among appeals courts favor denial.

    Why this big-case score: The limits of federal enforcement of conditional habeas writs affect state criminal retrials and federal-state judicial authority, but the immediate dispute is a noncapital, record-specific prosecution rather than a broad new substantive right.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant review in *Davis v. Smith* (about a one-in-four chance, or 24%, of granting full review or summarily reversing the lower court). In this case, Ohio asks the Court to decide whether a federal court retains power to order a state prisoner's unconditional release after the state has already retried and reconvicted him, based on a finding that the state violated the federal court's earlier order excluding a witness's identification. Although Justices Thomas and Alito previously dissented when the Court declined to hear an earlier appeal in the same prosecution, the Sixth Circuit's decision is unpublished, rests on case-specific findings that the state trial court never formally vacated the first conviction or complied with the suppression order, and involves no conflict among the federal appeals courts.

    Why this big-case score: Significant federalism and habeas jurisdiction question concerning whether a federal district court retains authority to enforce a conditional writ after a state prisoner has been retried, reconvicted, and resentenced in state court, though confined to a technical procedural posture.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 40%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring but technical federal-habeas jurisdiction question (post-retrial supervision on the original petition) arising from an unpublished, fact-bound Sixth Circuit decision; real stakes for state-federal habeas relations, little public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns nationally applicable limits on federal enforcement of conditional habeas writs after a state retrial, with meaningful federalism and liberty stakes. Its practical reach is narrower than a general criminal-procedure rule and depends on an unusual enforcement record.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 65%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A technical AEDPA jurisdictional question under Magwood; highly significant for habeas practice but low public salience.

Guardado v. FloridaThe Court denied Jesse Guardado's request to stay his execution and denied his related petition challenging Florida's clemency process.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.12
0.58
0.35
0.35

Jesse Guardado v. FloridaNo. 26A623 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000623 · models differ by up to 0.46 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

The Court denied Jesse Guardado's request to stay his execution and denied his related petition challenging Florida's clemency process.

What happened

Jesse Guardado, a Florida death-row prisoner, was scheduled for execution on November 5, 2026. The Florida Supreme Court denied him relief on October 29, 2026. Guardado then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stay his execution while it considered a petition for certiorari (a request that the Court hear his case) arguing that Florida's clemency process denies him due process because the state has not granted clemency to a death-sentenced prisoner since 1983 and the current governor has said he will not grant clemency to murderers. Florida responded that Guardado delayed raising this challenge and that his claims lack merit.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether Florida's clemency process, which Guardado says routinely and automatically denies mercy to death-sentenced prisoners, provides so little meaningful review that it violates the constitutional minimum protections required for clemency proceedings. A stay would pause the execution while the Court decided whether to take up that question.

Where it stands

The Court denied both the stay application and the underlying petition for certiorari on November 5, 2026, the day the execution was scheduled.

What each outcome would mean

Guardado, as the applicant, asked the Court to pause his execution and then to review Florida's clemency process. By denying the stay and denying certiorari, the Court left the Florida Supreme Court's decision against Guardado in place and did not pause or stop the scheduled execution. The denial of certiorari means the Court will not review the merits of his due process challenge to Florida's clemency system.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-05: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to **deny** Jesse Guardado's request to halt his Florida execution, set for November 5, 2026. We put the chance of a stay at very unlikely, about 1 in 70. His argument is that Florida's clemency process (the governor's power to spare a life) is a sham, because no death-row prisoner has received clemency since 1983. The Court has turned down similar claims from Florida prisoners, and it rarely stops executions at the last minute. A short dissent from one Justice is possible but not expected.

    Why this big-case score: Individual capital stay on a recurring, repeatedly rejected clemency-due-process theory; life-or-death for the applicant but little doctrinal reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Jesse Guardado's request to pause his execution, scheduled for November 5, 2026. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of any relief if the request is decided rather than becoming moot. His application argues that Florida's clemency process offers no genuine chance of mercy. But the available filing does not clearly show that he was denied the minimal procedural protections the Constitution requires. The Court will probably consider the request as a full bench and issue a brief order.

    Why this big-case score: An imminent execution gives the application exceptional individual stakes; its challenge to categorical clemency refusal could affect Florida's broader capital process, but the requested order is case-specific.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Jesse Guardado's emergency application for a stay of his November 5, 2026 execution in Florida, with only a 2% chance of granting a stay. Guardado argues that Florida's executive clemency process—in which the governor may commute a death sentence to life imprisonment—violates constitutional due process because no death-row prisoner has received clemency since 1983. However, the Florida Supreme Court unanimously found that Guardado received clemency consideration, and the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly turned away identical challenges in recent Florida capital cases.

    Why this big-case score: Routine last-minute state capital post-warrant stay application raising a settled Woodard clemency due-process claim with no circuit split or broader doctrinal reach.

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted once a response was filed. Decided 2026-11-05: the Court denied the application. evt-brief-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely (about 99 in 100) refuse Jesse Guardado's request to halt his Florida execution scheduled for November 5, 2026. He argues that Florida's clemency process (the governor's power to show mercy) is a sham because no death-row prisoner has received clemency since 1983. Courts have consistently rejected this kind of claim, Florida says he waited too long to raise it, and the Court almost never stops executions at the last minute.

    Why this big-case score: Life-or-death for the applicant, but a routine Florida warrant-cycle stay application on a clemency due-process theory the federal courts have uniformly rejected; little doctrinal reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Jesse Guardado's request to pause his November 5 execution. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of relief if the Court reaches the request rather than dismissing it as moot. His argument that Florida's clemency process offers no meaningful chance of mercy raises serious stakes, but the supplied papers do not show a clear legal basis requiring intervention. Florida has opposed the request. The likely next step is consideration by the full Court, followed by a short order before the scheduled execution.

    Why this big-case score: An imminent execution and a potentially statewide challenge to meaningful clemency access create substantial stakes, although the legal issue is narrower than a challenge to capital punishment generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Jesse Guardado's application for a stay of his November 5, 2026 execution, with only about a 1.5% chance of granting relief. To win a stay, a prisoner must show a realistic chance that the Court will agree to hear his appeal and overturn the state court's ruling, but Guardado's claims about decades-old trial evidence are blocked by Florida's filing deadlines, and the Court has repeatedly rejected similar challenges to Florida's clemency process and 31-day execution schedule. Following standard practice in death-penalty cases, Justice Thomas will almost certainly refer the application to the full nine-Justice Court, which will deny the stay without any written dissents.

    Why this big-case score: Capital stay application pending execution on November 5, 2026, raising routine, procedurally barred post-warrant claims with no circuit split or amicus participation.

RiseandShine v. PepsiCoRiseandShine sued PepsiCo over the "RISE" trademark, and the Supreme Court is deciding whether a mark's inherent strength is a factual or legal question.Intellectual propertyawaiting the Court
0.30
0.45
0.28
0.34

RiseandShine Corporation, dba Rise Brewing v. PepsiCo, Inc.No. 24-1016 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/72483489 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Intellectual property

RiseandShine sued PepsiCo over the "RISE" trademark, and the Supreme Court is deciding whether a mark's inherent strength is a factual or legal question.

What happened

RiseandShine, which sells canned nitro cold-brew coffee under "RISE" marks, sued PepsiCo in 2021 claiming its "MTN DEW RISE ENERGY" drink infringed RiseandShine's trademark. A district court granted RiseandShine a preliminary injunction, but the Second Circuit vacated it, holding that RiseandShine's mark was inherently weak as a matter of law given its close association with coffee. On remand, the district court granted PepsiCo summary judgment, and the Second Circuit affirmed, again treating the mark's "inherent strength" as a legal question for judges rather than a factual question for juries.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, in deciding if a trademark infringement is likely to confuse consumers, the question of how distinctive or strong a trademark inherently is should be treated as a factual matter normally decided by a jury, or as a legal matter decided by judges. RiseandShine says every other appeals court treats this as a factual question while only the Second Circuit treats it as legal; PepsiCo says the inquiry has an inescapable legal component tied to defining the scope of trademark protection.

Where it stands

The Court granted certiorari, received merits briefing and multiple amicus briefs including one from the federal government supporting vacatur, and heard the case after it was set for argument on January 12, 2027. The case awaits the Court's decision following briefing completed in November 2026.

What each outcome would mean

RiseandShine, the side seeking to overturn the lower court's ruling, argues the Second Circuit wrongly treated trademark strength as a legal question, which led courts to rule against it without letting a jury weigh the evidence. If the Court rules for RiseandShine, finding this a factual question, the case would likely be sent back for further proceedings where a jury could reconsider the mark's strength. If the Court sides with PepsiCo and affirms, the Second Circuit's judgment granting PepsiCo summary judgment would stand, meaning RiseandShine's infringement claims against PepsiCo would remain rejected. A vacatur, which the federal government's brief supported, would set aside the lower court's decision and send the case back without resolving the issue for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. ArguedArgument Jan 12, 2027
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: RiseandShine wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: PepsiCo wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 80%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A 12-1 procedural split (judge vs. jury on trademark strength) with PepsiCo as respondent: consequential for trademark litigation practice and summary-judgment rates, but technical and low-salience for the general public.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 86%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide trademark fact-law rule matters to jury allocation and summary judgment, but the dispute concerns one subfactor of a broader likelihood-of-confusion test.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A significant procedural clarification for trademark litigation resolving a 12-1 circuit split, but technically narrow.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 79%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will probably side with the small coffee company Rise Brewing against PepsiCo, about four chances in five. The dispute is over who decides how strong a trademark naturally is: a judge, as the New York-based appeals court said, or a jury weighing evidence about how shoppers see the name. Nearly every other appeals court and the federal government treat it as a factual question. I expect the Court to vacate the ruling, meaning cancel it and send the case back for another look, most likely by a unanimous 9–0 vote.

    Why this big-case score: Doctrinally meaningful for trademark litigation (judge/jury allocation and summary judgment in the Second Circuit, a major trademark venue) and drew the main IP bar associations as amici, but a narrow sub-factor question with little salience outside IP practice.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to set aside the appeals court's ruling for PepsiCo and send the case back for another look. I put the chance of changing that judgment at 76%, with a unanimous vote expected. The central issue is whether judges or factfinders should assess how strongly consumers associate a trademark with a product. Consumer understanding points toward factfinding. But that would not mean Rise Brewing wins: PepsiCo could still prevail because the products look different or the evidence of confusion is insufficient.

    Why this big-case score: A nationwide rule about judges' and juries' roles in trademark disputes, but confined to one component of the infringement inquiry rather than the ultimate ownership of common words.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 88%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—nearly nine in ten (88% probability)—to disturb the lower court's ruling by vacating it, meaning wiping out the Second Circuit's decision and sending the dispute between Rise Brewing and PepsiCo back for a fresh look, most likely by a unanimous 9–0 vote. Twelve other federal appeals courts and the U.S. Solicitor General agree that how strong a brand name seems to everyday shoppers is a factual question ordinarily left to a jury rather than a pure legal question for judges, though PepsiCo can still argue on remand that no reasonable jury would find consumers confused.

    Why this big-case score: Resolves a 12-to-1 Second Circuit outlier rule on summary-judgment factfinding in trademark suits—consequential for commercial IP litigation in a major venue, though doctrinally technical.

Hughes v. LocureThe Court declined to hear a bid to revive a civil rights lawsuit against a sheriff's deputy's estate over a fatal off-duty crash.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.35
0.48
0.20
0.34

Denise Hughes, as Administrator of the Estate of Edwin Dewayne Moss v. Monique N. Locure, Administratrix of the Estate of Darian K. LocureNo. 25-1242 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73286453 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a bid to revive a civil rights lawsuit against a sheriff's deputy's estate over a fatal off-duty crash.

What happened

Denise Hughes, representing the estate of Edwin Dewayne Moss, sued Deputy Darian Locure's estate after Locure, allegedly intoxicated and driving without headlights at nearly three times the speed limit while off duty, struck and killed Moss in a 2021 crash. A federal district court allowed the civil rights claim to proceed, rejecting the estate's qualified immunity defense, a legal protection that shields officials from suits unless they violated clearly established rights. The Eleventh Circuit reversed, holding that existing case law left it unclear that Locure's conduct violated a constitutional right, so qualified immunity applied. One judge dissented, arguing the violation was obvious.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether it was already clearly established, through its own prior rulings and those of other appeals courts, that an officer can be held liable for a constitutional violation when the officer seriously injures someone through intentional misuse of a government vehicle, and whether the appeals court's contrary conclusion conflicts with that precedent and with how other circuits have ruled on similar facts.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after both sides filed briefs. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Hughes, representing Moss's estate, asked the Court to take up the case and reverse the Eleventh Circuit's ruling for Locure's estate. The denial leaves the Eleventh Circuit's decision in place, meaning Locure's estate keeps the qualified immunity protection it won, and the civil rights claim over Moss's death does not go forward, though the docket does not indicate whether other claims in the case remain active.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would settle whether Lewis footnote 13 clearly establishes a substantive due-process claim for an off-duty officer's drunken, unlit, high-speed driving, and would revisit the obvious-clarity path around qualified immunity. Real doctrinal stakes for section 1983 litigation, but a single-plaintiff interlocutory vehicle with no amici and no government party.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns accountability for fatal, non-emergency police driving and the obvious-clarity exception to qualified immunity, with potential national civil-rights significance; its particular facts and preservation and state-action questions limit its breadth.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves qualified immunity and excessive force, which draws some attention, but the vehicle issues make it a poor candidate for major impact.

Matthews v. LouisianaJuan Matthews, convicted of a 1992 murder, asks the Supreme Court to overturn Louisiana courts' rejection of his claim that prosecutors withheld evidence favorable to his defense.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.30
0.48
0.25
0.34

Juan Matthews v. LouisianaNo. 26-218 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000218 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Criminal law

Juan Matthews, convicted of a 1992 murder, asks the Supreme Court to overturn Louisiana courts' rejection of his claim that prosecutors withheld evidence favorable to his defense.

What happened

Matthews was convicted of second-degree murder in 1992 based largely on eyewitness testimony, with no physical or forensic evidence connecting him to the crime. Decades later, he obtained previously undisclosed police records, including witness statements that did not identify him as the shooter and notes questioning one eyewitness's account. He sought post-conviction relief, arguing the withheld evidence undermined confidence in his conviction. A Louisiana trial court denied relief, finding the evidence was not significant enough to matter. The Louisiana Court of Appeal affirmed, with one judge dissenting. The Louisiana Supreme Court declined to review the case, over one justice's dissent.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether the Louisiana courts used the wrong legal test in rejecting Matthews's claim that prosecutors improperly withheld favorable evidence. Matthews argues the courts should have asked whether the withheld evidence was significant enough to undermine confidence in the verdict, but instead asked only whether the evidence presented at trial was enough, on its own, to support his conviction.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, Louisiana has waived its right to respond, and the Court granted a later motion extending the time for any response to November 30, 2026. The petition has not yet been distributed for the Court's consideration of whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Matthews is asking the Court to take up his case and overturn the rulings against him. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case in full and decide whether Louisiana courts applied the correct legal standard; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the lower courts' rejection of Matthews's claim stands, leaving his conviction in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 30, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Matthews' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Matthews' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Juan Matthews, serving life for a 1992 New Orleans murder, asks the Supreme Court to overturn his conviction. His argument is that prosecutors hid evidence that could have helped him, and that Louisiana courts used the wrong legal test to decide whether that mattered. The Court asked Louisiana to respond after the State had declined to, which is a sign of interest. Even so, we predict the Court will most likely turn the case away. We put the chance that it takes or reverses the case at about one in six.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound Brady error-correction in a single non-capital Louisiana conviction; wider stakes only insofar as it disciplines Louisiana courts' recurring sufficiency-style materiality analysis.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Juan Matthews's request to review his Louisiana murder conviction; I put the chance of review at about one in six. The request for a response and four supporting outside briefs show meaningful interest. But the lower appeals court expressly used the required test for whether hidden evidence undermines confidence in a conviction, making this look more like a dispute over particular facts than a new legal question. If the Court intervenes, a short corrective ruling is likelier than full argument.

    Why this big-case score: A life-without-parole conviction and alleged recurring suppression-of-evidence errors give this substantial criminal-justice stakes, but the question chiefly concerns application of settled law to one record.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Juan Matthews's petition for review, with only about a 1 in 17 chance (6%) of taking the case. Matthews argues that New Orleans prosecutors violated his constitutional right to a fair trial in 1992 by withholding police notes that could have cast doubt on eyewitnesses who identified him as the shooter. Although the Court asked Louisiana to respond to the petition after four outside legal groups filed briefs supporting Matthews, the Court rarely steps in to re-weigh evidence in an individual criminal case when the state appeals court already cited the correct legal rules and three eyewitnesses identified the defendant at trial.

    Why this big-case score: Factbound state post-conviction Brady materiality challenge to a 1992 murder conviction; if decided, its impact would largely be confined to policing lower-court compliance with settled Kyles v. Whitley standards rather than announcing new constitutional doctrine.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will probably **turn down** Juan Matthews's appeal. We put the chance it takes the case at about one in eight (12%). Matthews says Louisiana courts wrongly upheld his 1992 murder conviction even though prosecutors hid evidence that pointed away from him. Brady v. Maryland is the rule that makes prosecutors share evidence favorable to the defense. Several groups back him, and the Court asked Louisiana to respond, which is a mild sign of interest. Still, the Court rarely takes fact-specific cases like this. If it does act, it may reverse in a short unsigned order without full argument.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound Brady error-correction for one non-capital prisoner, with a wider systemic claim about how Louisiana courts apply Brady materiality.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to decline Juan Matthews's request to review his Louisiana murder conviction. I put the chance of review or another favorable intervention at 14%, about one in seven. The Court has asked Louisiana to respond, and several outside groups support Matthews. But the dispute concerns how courts weighed withheld evidence, and the appeals court says it used the required fairness test. If the Supreme Court intervenes, a short ruling correcting the legal standard is more likely than full briefing and argument.

    Why this big-case score: A life-imprisonment case concerning recurring suppression of defense evidence, but principally a fact-specific application of established constitutional law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Juan Matthews's petition for review, with only a 1.5% chance of granting the case (about one in sixty-seven). Matthews, who was convicted of murder in Louisiana in 1992, argues that prosecutors violated *Brady v. Maryland*—the constitutional rule requiring the government to turn over favorable evidence to the defense—and that the state courts used the wrong legal test when they concluded the withheld police files would not have changed the verdict. However, the state waived its right to respond, the Supreme Court recently turned down a nearly identical Louisiana appeal backed by seven outside supporter briefs, and the Louisiana Supreme Court also rejected Matthews's claim on an independent state-law deadline rule because it was filed more than thirty years after his conviction.

    Why this big-case score: State post-conviction Brady materiality challenge to a 1992 non-capital murder conviction; while the recurring question of Louisiana courts' Brady materiality standard has drawn prior dissents from denial, this petition faces an explicit state procedural bar and is unlikely to produce a major precedent if decided.

Abrams v. United StatesA man convicted of investment fraud asks the Court to decide what a routine trial motion must say to preserve a full appeal of the evidence against him.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.30
0.42
0.30
0.34

James P. Abrams v. United StatesNo. 25-1236 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73272488 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: Criminal law

A man convicted of investment fraud asks the Court to decide what a routine trial motion must say to preserve a full appeal of the evidence against him.

What happened

James Abrams was convicted on 48 counts, including wire fraud and aggravated identity theft, after a jury trial in Pennsylvania federal court. At trial his lawyer moved for acquittal under a rule allowing such motions when evidence is insufficient, but said only that she was making the motion and would not elaborate. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals held that this general motion did not preserve detailed sufficiency arguments for full appellate review, so it reviewed his claims under a stricter "plain error" standard and affirmed his convictions on that basis.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a general trial motion challenging the sufficiency of the evidence, without identifying specific flaws, is enough to get a full, fresh review of that evidence on appeal, or whether a defendant must spell out each specific weakness to get anything beyond the more limited error review used for problems not raised below.

Where it stands

The United States opposed review, and Abrams filed a reply. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026, after an earlier conference in June 2026; the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear it.

What each outcome would mean

Abrams, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on the question and decide it, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the Third Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Abrams's convictions in place and keeping intact the stricter review standard applied to his case and others in that circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Abrams' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Abrams' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down James Abrams's appeal. We put the chance it agrees to hear the case at about one in eight. The case asks whether a defendant who simply asks the trial judge to acquit, without explaining why the evidence fell short, keeps the right to a full fresh look on appeal. Appeals courts disagree on this. But the government points out that Abrams never repeated his request at the end of the trial, and the Court turned away a similar case in May 2026.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring procedural question touching most federal criminal trials (preserving sufficiency review under Rule 29), but technical and low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down James Abrams's appeal, although I give it about a three-in-ten chance of agreeing to hear it. Federal appeals courts disagree about how specifically a defendant must challenge the prosecution's evidence at trial to preserve an appeal. The Court's request for an answer and support from outside legal groups make this petition stronger than most. But the appeals court's conclusion that the evidence strongly supported the convictions could make this a less suitable case to settle that disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring federal criminal-trial preservation rule with nationwide importance to defense practice, but not a broad constitutional or major public-policy dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to hear this appeal (about a one in four chance, or 25%). James Abrams was convicted of federal fraud and identity-theft charges and argues that his general request for an acquittal at the end of his trial was enough to get a fresh, full review of the evidence on appeal, rather than the much stricter "plain error" standard the appeals court announced. Although federal appeals courts are genuinely divided on how specific a trial objection must be under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29, the appeals court in this case also explained why the evidence of Abrams's guilt was overwhelming under either standard, making this a poor case for the Supreme Court to take up.

    Why this big-case score: Moderate stakes: resolves a recurring 7-4 circuit split over Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29(a) preservation in federal criminal trials, though purely procedural and technical with limited public salience.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring federal criminal-procedure preservation question affecting appellate review in many trials; doctrinally important to practitioners but low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The preservation rule affects sufficiency appeals throughout federal criminal practice and could resolve a substantial circuit disagreement. Its reach is national, but the question is procedural and does not directly decide substantive criminal liability or a major public-policy program.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves criminal procedure and appellate review standards, significant for practitioners but not necessarily broad public impact.

Allen v. SteinThe Court declined to hear Frederick Allen's bid to revive his copyright lawsuit against North Carolina over Blackbeard shipwreck footage.Civil proceduredecided
0.30
0.42
0.30
0.34

Frederick L. Allen, et al. v. Joshua Stein, Governor of North Carolina, et al.No. 26-114 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000114 · models differ by up to 0.12 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear Frederick Allen's bid to revive his copyright lawsuit against North Carolina over Blackbeard shipwreck footage.

What happened

Allen sued North Carolina officials, claiming they infringed his copyrighted photos and video of a shipwreck salvage project. After the Supreme Court previously ruled North Carolina was immune from the copyright claims, the case returned to the district court, which reopened the litigation and let Allen pursue a different legal theory for overcoming the state's immunity. North Carolina appealed, and the Fourth Circuit reviewed both that reopening decision and a later ruling against the state on immunity, ultimately reversing and ending the case in the state's favor. Allen asked the Supreme Court to review the Fourth Circuit's approach.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether an appeals court may review a procedural ruling that is not independently appealable when it is reviewing a separate, appealable order, if the two rulings are only loosely connected rather than tightly linked under the rule the Court set out in an earlier case. Allen also raised the separate question of whether the appeals court improperly reached its decision on a legal basis neither side had argued, warranting a summary reversal without full briefing.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference in September 2026, and after the state's response and Allen's reply, the Court considered it at a conference in October 2026. The Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Allen, who asked the Supreme Court to take the case, sought to overturn the Fourth Circuit's decision, which had ruled in North Carolina's favor and ended his lawsuit. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fourth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Allen's copyright claims against North Carolina remain dismissed. A grant would have meant the Court would hear full arguments on the procedural question and decide it, without that step itself determining who wins.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 13%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring but technical appellate-jurisdiction question (the scope of pendent appellate jurisdiction after Swint); the Blackbeard-shipwreck backstory and a second trip to the Court add newsworthiness, but the stakes for the law are procedural rather than substantive.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The scope of pendent appellate jurisdiction affects interlocutory litigation nationwide, but this petition presents a technical procedural question in unusually tangled copyright and sovereign-immunity litigation, not a direct reconsideration of copyright immunity.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Guo v. DespinsMei Guo and HK USA ask the Court whether a bankruptcy trustee can use a federal statute to pursue a state-law claim against their shell company.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.47
0.25
0.34

Mei Guo, et al. v. Luc A. Despins, Chapter 11 TrusteeNo. 26-194 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000194 · models differ by up to 0.22

Mei Guo and HK USA ask the Court whether a bankruptcy trustee can use a federal statute to pursue a state-law claim against their shell company.

What happened

Ho Wan Kwok filed for bankruptcy after a New York court found he beneficially owned a yacht, the Lady May, despite claiming to own almost nothing. The bankruptcy trustee, Luc Despins, argued that HK USA, which formally owned the yacht, was actually Kwok's alter ego, making its assets part of the bankruptcy estate. The bankruptcy court and district court agreed, and the Second Circuit affirmed, holding that a federal bankruptcy statute let the trustee bring this claim standing in the shoes of a hypothetical creditor. Guo and HK USA appealed to the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the law giving bankruptcy trustees the same rights a creditor with a court-ordered claim on the debtor's property would have also lets a trustee bring a legal claim, available under state law to any creditor generally, seeking to hold a company liable for its owner's debts. Petitioners say the law does not stretch that far; the trustee says it plainly does.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for December 4, 2026, after the respondent opposed review, an amicus brief was filed supporting the petitioners, and the petitioners filed a reply. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Mei Guo and HK USA, the petitioners, are asking the Court to reverse the Second Circuit's decision, which the trustee, Luc Despins, won below. If the Court grants review and later rules for the petitioners, the trustee would lose this basis for claiming HK USA's assets, including the yacht and escrowed funds, for Kwok's creditors, though the trustee's brief says other legal grounds might still support the same result. If the Court instead rules for the trustee, or denies review, the Second Circuit's decision stands, and the assets remain part of the bankruptcy estate.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Guo's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Guo's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this appeal, though not with certainty: we put the chance it agrees to hear the case at about one in ten. The case asks whether a bankruptcy trustee may sue on claims that belong to a bankrupt person's creditors as a group. Federal appeals courts disagree on this, and the Court asked the other side to respond, which shows some interest. But the disagreement is decades old, and this case's messy facts make it a weaker candidate for review.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring Bankruptcy Code question (who may sue on creditor-owned alter-ego claims under § 544(a)) with a long-standing split; it matters to bankruptcy practice but is technical and draws little public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.47·Chance the Court takes the case: 22%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn down this appeal than hear it, with about a one-in-five chance of review (22%). The dispute asks whether a bankruptcy trustee can bring claims that belong to creditors as a group. The Court's request for a response and an alleged disagreement among appeals courts make review more plausible than usual. But requesting a response is not a promise to hear the case, and an unresolved alternative legal basis could make this a less attractive case to decide.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring national bankruptcy question about trustees' control of creditor claims, with substantial recovery and settlement consequences, but a specialized statutory dispute rather than a broad constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Mei Guo v. Despins*, with about a one-in-seven chance (14%) of granting the petition. Although the case raises a genuine disagreement among federal appeals courts over whether the federal Bankruptcy Code allows a bankruptcy trustee (the court-appointed official managing a debtor's estate) to bring "alter ego" claims (lawsuits alleging that a shell company is merely a front for the debtor) on behalf of creditors generally, the case has serious procedural flaws, including alternative legal grounds supporting the lower court's ruling and an ongoing bankruptcy proceeding below.

    Why this big-case score: Commercial bankruptcy dispute over a Chapter 11 trustee's standing under 11 U.S.C. § 544(a) to bring state-law alter ego claims; implicates a recognized circuit split in bankruptcy administration but has modest broader public salience outside commercial restructuring practice.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Bankruptcy Code question (whether 544(a) lets a trustee prosecute creditors' general alter-ego claims) with real consequences for mass-tort and fraud bankruptcies and a long-acknowledged circuit split; significant to the bankruptcy bar, modest beyond it apart from the Kwok notoriety.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.58·Chance the Court takes the case: 24%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Trustee authority over creditor-owned alter ego claims affects bankruptcy asset recovery and control of litigation nationwide, although the dispute is specialized rather than broadly constitutional.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Younge v. Fulton Judicial Circuit District Attorney's OfficeYounge and the Fulton County DA's Office disputed whether an employer may rely on an affirmative defense never included in its answer, and the Court heard argument on that question.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.20
0.46
0.35
0.34

Jasmine Younge v. Fulton Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office, GeorgiaNo. 25-352 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73277468 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Civil procedure

Younge and the Fulton County DA's Office disputed whether an employer may rely on an affirmative defense never included in its answer, and the Court heard argument on that question.

What happened

Jasmine Younge sued the Fulton Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office under Title VII, claiming she was fired after announcing her pregnancy. The office's answer did not assert that Younge was exempt from Title VII as a member of the district attorney's "personal staff." Nearly a year later, after discovery had closed, the office raised that defense for the first time in a motion for summary judgment. The magistrate judge and district court allowed the defense, finding Younge was not prejudiced, and granted summary judgment for the office. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, applying its rule that an unpled affirmative defense may be considered at summary judgment so long as the plaintiff was not prejudiced. Younge petitioned for review, pointing to disagreement among the circuits over this practice.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a defendant who never included a defense in its answer can still rely on that defense to win a motion for summary judgment, without ever amending the answer to add it, and even if the rules governing late amendments would have blocked such an amendment.

Where it stands

The Court granted the petition on March 30, 2026. The case was briefed on the merits, amicus briefs were filed, and the Court heard oral argument on November 2, 2026. A decision has not yet been recorded in the docket.

What each outcome would mean

Younge, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to reverse. If the Court affirms, the Eleventh Circuit's rule stands: the DA's Office's win stands, and defendants in that circuit may rely on unpled affirmative defenses at summary judgment so long as the plaintiff shows no prejudice, without having to amend their answers under the usual rules for late amendments. If the Court reverses, Younge's case would return to the lower courts without the benefit of that defense, consistent with her position that defendants must plead affirmative defenses or formally seek to amend their answer under the normal standards. A vacate-and-remand would set aside the Eleventh Circuit's decision and send the case back without deciding the question for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

Petition

  1. Petition filed
  2. Sent to conference
  3. Court decidesTook the case

Merits

  1. Argued
  2. Decided
  • If reversed: Younge wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
  • If affirmed: The Fulton Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
  • If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 3 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted when the Court agreed to hear the case. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 72%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring, decades-old FRCP question touching everyday civil litigation in every district court, but technical and low-salience outside the procedure bar; the underlying employment dispute is individual, not systemic.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 76%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case should settle a recurring federal civil-procedure split, but it is unlikely to draw broad public attention beyond litigation practice.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    An important procedural rule circuit split, but not a blockbuster substantive issue.

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted once both sides' merits briefs were in. Awaiting the Court. evt-brief-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 78%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Transsubstantive FRCP question that matters to everyday civil litigation practice, but a technical pleading-procedure ruling with low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 39%full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case will govern a recurring nationwide pleading issue, but its technical civil-procedure focus limits general newsworthiness.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 75%full prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?Predicted after the case was argued. Awaiting the Court. evt-argument-judgment

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to rule for Dr. Younge, which we think is very likely (about 4 in 5). We expect it to throw out the appeals court's decision and send the case back, probably by a 7–2 vote with Justices Thomas and Alito dissenting. The district attorney's office won using a defense it never wrote into its formal answer to the lawsuit. At oral argument most Justices suggested the office first has to get permission to amend that answer under the ordinary court rules. Being able to show the plaintiff wasn't harmed is not enough.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but technical civil-procedure question (unpleaded affirmative defenses at summary judgment); it matters to litigators across the circuits, not to the public at large.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 91%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about a nine-in-ten chance—to disturb the ruling against Jasmine Younge. I expect a 7–2 decision setting that ruling aside and sending the case back. Several Justices suggested that the district attorney's office must meet the normal standards for adding a defense late, rather than merely showing that its delay caused no harm. This would give Younge another procedural opportunity, not a victory on her discrimination claim. The office might still win after the lower courts apply the correct standards.

    Why this big-case score: A broadly applicable federal civil-procedure rule affecting late defenses and litigation fairness, but not a decision resolving the underlying discrimination claim.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict it is very likely (a 90% chance, or nine in ten) that the Supreme Court will disturb the lower court's ruling by vacating the judgment (wiping it out and sending the case back for a fresh look) in a unanimous 9–0 vote. Under the federal rules governing civil lawsuits, a defendant must state any "affirmative defense" (a legal reason it is not liable even if the plaintiff's facts are true) in its initial answer, or else show "good cause" (a valid excuse for missing the court's deadline) to add it later. At oral argument, Justices across the Court rejected the lower court's shortcut allowing defendants to raise unpleaded defenses at summary judgment (a pre-trial ruling without a jury) whenever the plaintiff cannot prove surprise.

    Why this big-case score: Routine but practically significant Federal Rules of Civil Procedure question resolving a multi-circuit split on raising unpleaded affirmative defenses at summary judgment.

In re DevillierProperty owners asked the Court to order a federal judge to keep hearing their flooding lawsuit against Texas instead of sending it to state court; the Court denied the request.decided
0.25
0.55
0.20
0.33

In Re Richard Devillier, et al.scotus/73299074 · models differ by up to 0.35

Property owners asked the Court to order a federal judge to keep hearing their flooding lawsuit against Texas instead of sending it to state court; the Court denied the request.

What happened

Richard Devillier and other landowners sued Texas, claiming a highway barrier flooded their property during storms, violating the Takings Clause. After years of litigation, the Supreme Court in 2024 avoided deciding whether the Takings Clause itself lets property owners sue, because Texas said its own state law let them pursue the same claims, and sent the case back for further proceedings. On remand, a federal magistrate judge recommended, and the district judge ordered, that the case be sent back to the Texas state courts it had originally been removed from, concluding federal courts lacked jurisdiction. The property owners then asked the Supreme Court directly to intervene.

What the Court is being asked

The property owners asked the Court to use its power to enforce its own prior orders, arguing the trial judge misread the Court's 2024 decision by sending their case to state court instead of letting them continue pursuing their claims in federal court. They argued only the Supreme Court itself could fix this, since normal appeals of such a transfer are not allowed.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and was denied on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Devillier and the other property owners asked the Court to step in. Because the Court denied the request, the district court's order sending their case to Texas state courts stands, meaning their claims will proceed there rather than in federal court. Had the Court instead granted the request, it would have directed the district judge to keep the case in federal court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the district court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The underlying dispute (DeVillier v. Texas, 601 U.S. 285 (2024)) is a nationally known takings case and the forum fight matters to the takings bar, but this Rule 20 mandamus petition against a remand-to-state-court order affects chiefly these landowners; its denial settles no doctrine.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.55·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Federal-forum access for constitutional takings claims and enforcement of the Court's own mandate have substantial institutional stakes, although the requested remedy concerns a particular remand rather than ultimate compensation liability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-profile litigants from a recent SCOTUS decision, but a mandamus petition is procedurally routine.

Zavislak v. NetflixThe Court declined to hear a benefits plan beneficiary's bid to force Netflix to disclose certain administrative contracts under a federal pension and benefits law.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.25
0.43
0.30
0.33

Mark Zavislak v. Netflix, Inc.No. 25-1142 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281629 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear a benefits plan beneficiary's bid to force Netflix to disclose certain administrative contracts under a federal pension and benefits law.

What happened

Mark Zavislak, a beneficiary of Netflix's health plan through his spouse, asked Netflix for documents governing the plan, including contracts between Netflix and its claims administrators. Netflix gave him seven plan documents but refused to turn over four claims administration agreements, saying those contracts only addressed Netflix's business relationships with outside administrators, not participants' benefits. Zavislak sued. After a bench trial, the district court ruled for Netflix, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, applying its own prior rulings on what counts as a disclosable plan document.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a federal law requiring benefit plan administrators to disclose contracts and instruments that establish or operate a plan also covers contracts that merely govern how outside companies process and administer benefit claims, rather than contracts that define what benefits participants are entitled to.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, most recently in September 2026, after full briefing including a reply from Zavislak. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Zavislak, the beneficiary, asked the Court to take up the case and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling in favor of Netflix. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place: Netflix was not required to disclose the four claims administration agreements, and Zavislak's lawsuit seeking them does not proceed further. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower court was right; it simply leaves that ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A narrow ERISA disclosure question (whether claims-administration contracts fall under 29 U.S.C. 1024(b)(4)). Meaningful to plan administrators, TPAs and the benefits bar, and it would settle a real inter-circuit disagreement, but the stakes per case are document access and small statutory penalties, no amici have appeared, and public salience is low.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.43·Chance the Court takes the case: 16%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could materially affect ERISA beneficiaries' access to claims-administration contracts across employer health plans. The statutory disclosure issue has national reach, but this case concerns a narrow document category rather than benefit entitlement or the validity of ERISA itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A 1-9 circuit split on an ERISA disclosure provision affects plan administrators broadly, but it is a technical statutory issue rather than a blockbuster.

Galesburg Community Unit School District No. 205 v. N. T., Individually and as Parent and Next Friend of C. T., et al.A school district asks the Court to review how much deference federal courts must give special-education hearing officers when a parent lawsuit includes evidence of events after the hearing.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.40
0.28
0.33

Galesburg Community Unit School District No. 205 v. N. T., Individually and as Parent and Next Friend of C. T., et al.No. 26-171 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000171 · models differ by up to 0.12

A school district asks the Court to review how much deference federal courts must give special-education hearing officers when a parent lawsuit includes evidence of events after the hearing.

What happened

C.T., a young student with behavioral disabilities, was placed by his school district's individualized education plan in a private therapeutic day school rather than his neighborhood school's special classroom. His parents challenged that placement as too restrictive under a federal special-education law. An administrative hearing officer sided with the school district. The parents then sought review in federal district court, which held a trial, heard additional evidence about C.T.'s progress after the hearing, and reversed, ordering the district to keep C.T. in the local classroom with added support. The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The district asks the Court to decide how much weight a federal court must give a special-education hearing officer's findings when the court also considers evidence about what happened after the hearing. More specifically, it asks whether a law directing courts to consider new evidence lets a judge effectively start over and decide the dispute based on later developments, rather than giving the hearing officer's original decision the deference the district says the law requires.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, after which the Court asked for a response from the parents; both sides have now filed briefs, including a brief in opposition and a supporting amicus brief, and the case awaits the Court's decision on whether to grant review.

What each outcome would mean

The school district is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Seventh Circuit's decision favoring the parents. If the Court denies review, the Seventh Circuit's ruling stands, leaving in place the order requiring the district to educate C.T. in the local classroom with added supports. If the Court grants review, it would hear full briefing and arguments and decide the deference question itself; granting review decides nothing in advance about who wins. The parents' brief argues separately that the district waived its arguments below, which the Court could also consider in deciding whether to take the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A school district in Illinois asks the Supreme Court to decide how much a federal judge must defer to a state hearing officer in special-education disputes, and whether the judge may rely on new evidence about how the child fared later. The Court asked the family to respond, which is a mild sign of interest. We still think the Court will very likely decline to hear the case, giving it about an 8% (roughly one in twelve) chance. The main reason is that the dispute is tied closely to one child's specific facts.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring IDEA question about how much weight courts owe hearing officers, important to school districts and families nationwide, but presented on a fact-heavy placement dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this school district's appeal; I give it about a one-in-eight chance of accepting the case or otherwise granting relief. The dispute concerns how much respect judges must give special-education hearing decisions when parents present newer evidence about a child's needs. The Court's request for a response shows interest, but the case also turns on individual facts and possible limits on which objections were preserved. The likeliest result is a denial after further briefing, without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of judicial review in special-education placement disputes affects school districts and families nationwide, but the presented question is technical and this child's individualized record limits its broader reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny the school district's request to hear this case, with about a one-in-twenty (5%) chance of granting review. Although the Court asked the student's parents to file a formal response—showing initial interest in how much deference federal judges owe state hearing officers under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (the federal special-education law)—the school district failed to object in the trial court to admitting most of the new post-hearing evidence, making this a poor vehicle for setting a national rule.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, a ruling clarifying the scope of 'additional evidence' under 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(C) and the standard of judicial deference to state IDEA hearing officers would have significant practical impact on special-education litigation nationwide, though it remains a technical statutory-review question rather than a major constitutional or high-salience controversy.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    IDEA judicial-review standard (Rowley 'due weight' and post-hearing evidence) recurs nationally in special-education litigation, but this vehicle is a fact-bound unpublished placement dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could materially affect judicial review of IDEA administrative decisions and disability placements nationwide, but this is a technical evidentiary/deference dispute arising from one student's placement rather than a broad challenge to educational rights.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    IDEA special education case involving evidentiary rules in district court, practically important but not of massive national significance.

Guardado v. ComerfordThe Supreme Court denied Jesse Guardado's request to delay his execution and declined to hear his challenge to Florida's lethal-injection procedures.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.64
0.18
0.32

Jesse Guardado v. Richard Comerford, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections, et al.No. 26A634 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000634 · models differ by up to 0.49 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court denied Jesse Guardado's request to delay his execution and declined to hear his challenge to Florida's lethal-injection procedures.

What happened

Jesse Guardado, a Florida death-row prisoner, sued prison officials claiming Florida's lethal-injection protocol was being administered unreliably, citing drug logs showing recordkeeping errors, altered expiration dates, and possible use of unauthorized or improperly dosed drugs. He filed suit after completing clemency proceedings but before a death warrant was signed; the state then signed his warrant, and the district court held an expedited evidentiary hearing before ruling against him. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed, calling his challenge speculative and faulting him for not raising it sooner. Guardado asked the Supreme Court to pause his execution while it considered his appeal.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether the lower courts were wrong to let the timing of the execution warrant control how quickly Guardado's evidence could be gathered and reviewed, and whether the evidence he did gather showed a real risk that the state's execution procedure would cause severe, unconstitutional suffering. A second question concerns whether he was wrongly denied access to unredacted drug records needed to support his claim.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court received the stay application, the state's response, and Guardado's reply, then denied the stay of execution and denied the petition for review on November 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Guardado, the death-row prisoner, asked the Court to pause his execution and take up his case; Florida prison officials opposed both requests. By denying the stay, the Court allowed Florida to proceed with the execution without further review. By denying the petition, the Court left the Eleventh Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Guardado's challenge to the execution protocol did not succeed and the lower courts' findings against him stand.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-05: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Jesse Guardado, scheduled for execution in Florida on November 5, 2026, asked the Supreme Court to pause (stay) the execution while it considers his appeal claiming Florida mishandles its lethal-injection drugs. We predict the Court will say no — the chance of a stay is very small, about 1 to 2 in 100. Lower courts held a hearing and found the drug-log problems were paperwork errors, and the Court almost never halts executions over challenges to execution methods.

    Why this big-case score: Capital stay on a fact-bound Eighth Amendment maladministration claim against Florida's etomidate protocol; real stakes for the applicant and Florida's execution pace, but no doctrinal question the Court is likely to take up.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.64·Chance the Court grants the application: 8%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Court is very likely to deny Jesse Guardado's request to pause his execution: I put the chance of a pause at about eight in one hundred. His application raises serious concerns about Florida's execution drugs and limited access to evidence. But the lower courts already heard evidence and rejected key factual arguments, making emergency intervention difficult. I expect a rapid response from Florida and consideration by the full Court before the scheduled November 5 execution, probably ending in a short denial order.

    Why this big-case score: An imminent execution and alleged systemic flaws in Florida's lethal-injection administration create substantial human and statewide stakes, although the immediate dispute is fact-bound.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is extremely unlikely to grant Jesse Guardado's emergency request to halt his November 5, 2026 execution, with only about a 2% chance (roughly one in fifty) of a stay. After holding a seven-hour hearing and privately inspecting unredacted purchase records, a federal trial judge found that apparent errors in Florida's lethal-injection drug logs were clerical mistakes and that the sedative (etomidate) set aside for Guardado does not expire until January 2027. All three judges on the federal appeals court agreed that those factual findings were reasonable, leaving almost no prospect that the Supreme Court will step in to pause the execution.

    Why this big-case score: Capital execution-stay application raising recurring challenges to Florida's etomidate protocol and FDOC pharmacy-log alterations, but turning on fact-bound clear-error review after an evidentiary hearing rather than a broad doctrinal question.

Overton v. FloridaThomas Overton, facing a scheduled execution, asks the Supreme Court to pause it while it considers his appeal of Florida court rulings against him.awaiting the Court
0.15
0.60
0.22
0.32

Thomas M. Overton v. Florida, et al.No. 26A686 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000686 · models differ by up to 0.45

Thomas Overton, facing a scheduled execution, asks the Supreme Court to pause it while it considers his appeal of Florida court rulings against him.

What happened

Thomas M. Overton is a Florida death row prisoner whose execution the state has scheduled for November 19, 2026. The Supreme Court of Florida denied his request for relief in his state court case and also denied his request to stay the execution. Overton has now filed a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review that decision, and alongside it has filed this application asking the Court to stay his execution while that petition is considered.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to pause the scheduled execution while it decides whether to take up Overton's case. The underlying appeal argues that Florida's process for signing death warrants and deciding clemency requests violates constitutional guarantees that government power be properly separated among its branches, that legal proceedings be fair, and that people be treated equally under the law. It also raises claims under the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

Where it stands

The application for a stay of execution was submitted on November 14, 2026, to Justice Thomas, who handles emergency matters from the federal appeals circuit that includes Florida. The docket does not yet show any ruling on the stay request or on the related certiorari petition.

What each outcome would mean

Overton is asking the Court to pause his execution. If the Court grants the stay, the execution would not proceed as scheduled, and Overton's case would continue while the Court considers his certiorari petition. If the Court denies the stay, Florida would be free to carry out the execution as planned on November 19, 2026, regardless of how the certiorari petition is later resolved. Either way, this order would not decide the underlying legal questions about Florida's warrant and clemency process.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 16, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: Overton gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: Overton does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Thomas Overton, a Florida death-row prisoner scheduled for execution on November 19, 2026, has asked the Supreme Court for a stay, meaning an order pausing the execution while it considers his appeal. We predict the Court will refuse, and think a stay is very unlikely, about one chance in a hundred. His arguments attack Florida's clemency and death-warrant process, claims the Court has not shown interest in, and it has almost always turned down last-minute requests like this one from Florida prisoners.

    Why this big-case score: A life is at stake, but this is a routine end-stage Florida death-warrant stay application raising clemency/warrant-process claims with no broader doctrinal reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.60·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Thomas Overton's request to pause his scheduled November 19 execution. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of a pause, assuming the request still needs a decision. The filing raises constitutional objections to Florida's clemency and execution-warrant procedures, but provides little detail showing why the Court should intervene. The Court will probably obtain Florida's response and consider the request together, yet those review steps would not themselves signal that it will grant relief.

    Why this big-case score: An imminent execution creates irreversible individual stakes, and the application challenges Florida's clemency and warrant processes, but the supplied filing develops no clear nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny Thomas Overton's emergency request to halt his November 19, 2026 execution in Florida, with less than a one-in-a-hundred chance of a stay. Condemned prisoners rarely win last-minute stays from the current Court, and Overton's claims — arguing that Florida's clemency process (where the governor decides whether to show mercy) is unfair and overly secret — were unanimously rejected by the Florida Supreme Court as filed years too late and have repeatedly failed in recent Florida execution appeals.

    Why this big-case score: Active capital execution-warrant stay application raising broad Woodard clemency-sham and warrant-secrecy claims that would reshape state clemency review if ever reached, but presented in a routine, procedurally barred post-warrant posture with no circuit split or amicus participation.

Erik Charles Maund v. United StatesThe Court declined to hear Erik Maund's bid to restore a new trial after jurors saw evidence never admitted at his murder-for-hire trial.Criminal lawdecided
0.30
0.45
0.20
0.32

Erik Charles Maund, aka Erik Moore v. United StatesNo. 25-1318 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500219 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Criminal law

The Court declined to hear Erik Maund's bid to restore a new trial after jurors saw evidence never admitted at his murder-for-hire trial.

What happened

A jury convicted Erik Maund of conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire. Afterward, the district court discovered that jurors had received exhibits that were never admitted into evidence, including a recording in which a co-defendant said Maund's alleged accomplice "didn't know any of this shit" — information that undercut part of Maund's defense. The district court held a hearing, found the jury had considered this material, and granted Maund a new trial, calling the error "fundamental unfairness." The government appealed, and the Sixth Circuit reversed, holding the error was harmless because it believed the evidence against Maund was strong enough that the outcome would not have changed.

What the Court is being asked

The question is what a defendant must show to get a new trial after jurors are exposed to information outside the evidentiary record. One approach asks only whether the outside information probably swayed the jury against the defendant. Another approach goes further, asking whether the defendant would have been convicted anyway even without that information. Maund's petition says courts are split on which approach applies.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after the government waived its right to respond. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Maund, who lost in the Sixth Circuit, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Sixth Circuit's ruling in place: Maund's conviction stands, and he does not get the new trial the district court had ordered. A denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Sixth Circuit's reasoning — it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case, without the Supreme Court resolving the disagreement among lower courts that Maund's petition described.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A doctrinal question (the Remmer prejudice standard for extraneous jury information) of recurring importance to criminal trials, on a murder-for-hire record with some national press history; if decided it would matter to criminal defendants and trial courts, but it is not a headline constitutional or structural dispute.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The standard for prejudice from extraneous jury information could affect criminal trials nationwide and core jury-trial protections, but the presented dispute is a bounded procedural question rather than a broad substantive-policy controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A criminal procedure case concerning jury exposure to extraneous information, but embedded in a highly fact-bound murder-for-hire conviction with overwhelming evidence.

Patel v. United StatesThe Patels asked the Court to revive their claim that their guilty-plea lawyer's silence about related civil fraud liability violated their right to counsel; the Court denied review.Criminal lawdecided
0.40
0.45
0.10
0.32

Nita Patel, et vir v. United StatesNo. 25-1319 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500220 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Criminal law

The Patels asked the Court to revive their claim that their guilty-plea lawyer's silence about related civil fraud liability violated their right to counsel; the Court denied review.

What happened

Nita and Kirtish Patel pleaded guilty to health care fraud. The next day, the government intervened in a separate civil fraud lawsuit against them, and their plea admissions were later used to find them liable for millions of dollars in that case. The Patels argued in habeas corpus proceedings that their lawyer knew about the pending civil suit but never warned them that pleading guilty could lock in that civil liability, and that this failure violated their right to counsel. The district court and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals both rejected the claim, holding that this right only requires lawyers to advise clients about the direct consequences of a plea, not collateral ones like separate civil liability.

What the Court is being asked

The Patels asked the Court to decide whether the right to counsel requires a defense lawyer to advise a client about a consequence of a guilty plea that is not part of the criminal sentence itself, when that consequence is both closely tied to the conviction and severe. They pointed to a split among federal appeals courts and state courts on how broadly an earlier Supreme Court ruling about deportation advice extends to other serious side effects of a guilty plea.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the petition was denied on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Patels asked the Court to take up their case and overturn the Third Circuit's ruling against them. Granting review would have let the Court hear full arguments and decide whether their lawyer's silence about the civil fraud consequences violated their right to counsel. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Third Circuit's decision in place, meaning the Patels' convictions and the related civil liability judgment against them stand, and the lower court's rule limiting counsel's advice duty to direct consequences remains the law in that circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, a rule on whether the Sixth Amendment reaches non-deportation collateral consequences of a plea would touch every guilty plea; but the concrete stakes here (collateral estoppel in a civil FCA action) are narrow and the case draws little public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially important Sixth Amendment limits on plea counsel's duties concerning severe civil consequences, with implications beyond health-care fraud; this particular vehicle concerns private litigants' False Claims Act liability on collateral review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine criminal procedure question regarding collateral consequences of a guilty plea; United States waived its right to respond.

Donnie Ray Pearson v. GuerreroDonnie Pearson asked the Supreme Court to hear his case about a juror's possible bias, but the Court declined to take it up.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.30
0.32
0.30
0.31

Donnie Ray Pearson v. Eric Guerrero, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions DivisionNo. 25-1316 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500216 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

Donnie Pearson asked the Supreme Court to hear his case about a juror's possible bias, but the Court declined to take it up.

What happened

Pearson was convicted in Texas state court of a sex offense against a child. During jury selection, a juror sent a note saying she had been molested as a child but thought she could be fair; no one questioned her further, and defense counsel did not seek to remove her. She served on the jury that convicted Pearson. In later habeas proceedings, Pearson argued his trial lawyer was ineffective for not challenging or striking that juror. Texas courts and then a federal district court rejected the claim. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the juror was not the kind of biased juror the law presumes incapable of fairness, even though she had experienced the same type of crime as the one charged.

What the Court is being asked

The case concerns when a juror who was previously the victim of a crime similar to the one on trial must be treated as automatically unable to be fair, even if she says she thinks she can be impartial. Federal appeals courts disagree on how to make that judgment. Pearson's petition asked the Court to set a clearer standard and decide whether his juror's situation qualified, which would in turn affect whether his lawyer's failure to remove her amounted to constitutionally inadequate representation.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Pearson, as the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and ultimately rule that his juror should have been treated as biased, which could have helped his claim that his trial lawyer was ineffective. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fifth Circuit's decision in place, meaning Pearson's conviction and the denial of his habeas claim stand. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Fifth Circuit's reasoning; it simply declines to review the case further, leaving the lower court's ruling as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision fixing the implied-juror-bias standard (crime-victim jurors) would matter across criminal trials nationwide, but the case is a low-profile AEDPA habeas matter with a single private petitioner and no amici; moderate legal stakes, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An implied-juror-bias rule could affect criminal jury selection nationally, and the petitioner faces life without parole. The noncapital, fact-specific ineffective-assistance and federal-habeas posture limits its broader institutional and public significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An important Sixth Amendment question on implied juror bias, but presented in a routine state conviction on federal habeas review with limited national stakes.

Warden v. MichelinThe federal government asks the Court to review whether immigrants who win habeas cases over their detention can collect attorney's fees from the government.awaiting the Court
0.20
0.52
0.20
0.31

Warden, Moshannon Valley Correctional Center, et al. v. Adolph Michelin, et al.No. 26-145 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000145 · models differ by up to 0.32

The federal government asks the Court to review whether immigrants who win habeas cases over their detention can collect attorney's fees from the government.

What happened

Two men detained by immigration authorities, Adolph Michelin and Adewumi Abioye, separately won court orders requiring bond hearings after being held for over a year without one. Each then won an award of attorney's fees from the district courts under a federal law called the Equal Access to Justice Act, which lets prevailing parties collect fees from the government in civil cases unless the government's position was substantially justified. The government appealed, and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, consolidating the two cases, ruled that habeas cases challenging immigration detention count as "civil actions" under the fee law, and upheld the fee award in Abioye's case. The government asked for rehearing before the full appeals court, which was denied over several judges' dissents.

What the Court is being asked

The government asks the Court to decide whether a federal law letting people collect attorney's fees from the government in civil lawsuits also applies to habeas cases—court challenges to unlawful detention—brought by immigrants contesting their detention. The government argues the law's waiver of its immunity from such fee awards does not clearly cover this type of case, while Michelin and Abioye argue it does.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked the other side to respond; that response's deadline has since been extended to December 4, 2026. The government's petition itself asks the Court to hold the case until it decides a related case, Montoya Palacios v. Liggins, which already presents the same question.

What each outcome would mean

The government is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Third Circuit's decision favoring Michelin and Abioye. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the fee-shifting law covers these habeas cases, deciding nothing yet on its own. If it denies the petition, the Third Circuit's ruling favoring Michelin and Abioye stands, and the fee award to Abioye remains in place. The government has also suggested the Court could instead simply hold the petition until it rules in a similar pending case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Warden's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Warden's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 47%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The government asked the Supreme Court to set this case aside until it decides a nearly identical case, Montoya Palacios v. Liggins, about whether immigrants who win detention challenges can make the government pay their lawyers' fees. We expect the Court to do just that. If the government wins the other case, the Court will likely send this one back to the lower court to reconsider (which counts as a grant); if the government loses, it will deny. We see that as roughly a coin flip, slightly favoring denial (47% chance of a grant).

    Why this big-case score: A hold petition on EAJA fee eligibility in immigration-detention habeas; the question matters to detention litigation but is being decided in Montoya Palacios, not here.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.52·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I put the chance of Supreme Court intervention at about two in three. Most likely, the Court will wait for another case addressing whether people who successfully challenge immigration detention can recover lawyer fees, then send this case back for reconsideration under that ruling. The government expressly requests that approach, and the Court has asked the other side to respond. If the other ruling instead supports the existing fee awards, the Court will probably decline this petition without a separate opinion.

    Why this big-case score: Nationally significant for access to counsel and fee recovery in immigration-detention habeas litigation, but this follow-on petition concerns fee awards rather than the underlying right to release or a bond hearing.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 58%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is slightly more likely than not (about a 58% chance) to grant the federal government's petition, vacate (set aside) the lower court's ruling, and send the case back for a new decision. This case asks whether the Equal Access to Justice Act—a federal law that requires the government to pay a winning party's attorney's fees in "any civil action"—applies to habeas corpus petitions (lawsuits challenging unlawful detention) brought by immigration detainees. Because the Supreme Court has already agreed to decide that exact question in another pending case, *Montoya Palacios v. Liggins*, the Court will almost certainly hold this petition until *Montoya Palacios* is decided and then set aside the Third Circuit's ruling if the government wins the lead case.

    Why this big-case score: While the underlying question whether EAJA waives sovereign immunity for attorney's fees in immigration-detention habeas cases is significant, this docket is a follow-on hold petition awaiting the Court's merits decision in Montoya Palacios v. Liggins, No. 25-1223.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    A hold petition: the underlying question (EAJA fees in immigration-detention habeas) matters across many detention cases, but Montoya Palacios carries it, not this docket.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 66%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    Nationally consequential availability of attorney fees for successful immigration-detention habeas litigation, but a narrow fee-waiver question in a follower petition seeking a hold, not an independent challenge to detention authority.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves EAJA fee awards in immigration habeas; practically important for government liabilities but not a high-profile cultural or constitutional issue.

Theodore James Purdy v. KansasThe Supreme Court declined to review a Kansas man's claim that police testimony relaying a child's accusation against him violated his confrontation rights.First Amendmentpartly decided
0.30
0.42
0.20
0.31

Theodore James Purdy v. KansasNo. 26-221 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000221 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: First Amendment

The Supreme Court declined to review a Kansas man's claim that police testimony relaying a child's accusation against him violated his confrontation rights.

What happened

Theodore Purdy was convicted of rape and aggravated indecent liberties with a child after a three-year-old accuser did not testify at trial. Instead, a detective testified that the child had accused Purdy of inserting something into her vagina, offered as background explaining the police investigation rather than for its truth. The prosecution later cited this testimony in closing argument to corroborate Purdy's confession. Purdy argued in state postconviction proceedings that his trial lawyer should have objected on Confrontation Clause grounds. Kansas courts found the testimony was not hearsay and that any error did not affect the trial's outcome. The Kansas Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Kansas Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether prosecutors can get around a defendant's right to confront accusers by having a police officer repeat an absent witness's accusation under the label of explaining an investigation, when the accusation describes the very crime charged and is then used to help prove guilt.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Purdy, who lost in the Kansas courts, asked the Supreme Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Kansas Court of Appeals' decision in place, meaning Purdy's rape conviction stands and the testimony at issue was not found to violate his confrontation rights. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Kansas courts' reasoning; it simply means the case will not be reviewed, and no nationwide rule on this question was decided.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    9-8 en banc CA5 declared Stone v. Graham no longer good law and upheld mandatory Ten Commandments displays in every Texas public-school classroom; two dozen states have enacted or considered similar laws, so the decision either way reshapes Establishment Clause law nationwide.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 72%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The case could set nationwide rules for mandatory religious displays in public schools and define the continuing force of Stone after Kennedy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court takes the case: 90%·Prediction: take the casefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenges a state law mandating Ten Commandments displays in classrooms, where the lower court overtly declined to follow binding Supreme Court precedent (Stone v. Graham).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on 'course of investigation' testimony relaying an absent accuser's statement would reach a recurring trial practice in state and federal criminal cases, but it is a technical Confrontation Clause question with little public salience beyond the criminal bar.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could constrain the use of absent witnesses' accusations as investigative background across criminal prosecutions. The individual stakes are severe, but the collateral-review posture and disputed testimonial character make this a narrower vehicle than the constitutional question alone suggests.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Kevin Scott Karsjens v. GandhiThe Court declined to hear civilly committed plaintiffs' challenge to a $366,461.96 cost award imposed against them after their long-running civil rights lawsuit failed.Civil proceduredecided
0.15
0.46
0.30
0.30

Kevin Scott Karsjens, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, et al. v. Shireen Gandhi, et al.No. 25-1321 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500222 · models differ by up to 0.31 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear civilly committed plaintiffs' challenge to a $366,461.96 cost award imposed against them after their long-running civil rights lawsuit failed.

What happened

Kevin Scott Karsjens and other patients civilly committed under Minnesota's sex offender treatment program sued state officials in 2011 over conditions of their confinement. After years of litigation, the officials prevailed on all claims. The officials then sought to recover the costs of court-appointed experts used during the case. The district court denied those costs entirely, citing the plaintiffs' indigence and the potential chilling effect on future civil rights litigants. The Eighth Circuit reversed, finding the district court had overlooked an earlier agreement by the parties to split expert costs, and it directed that costs of $366,461.96 be awarded to the officials. The Eighth Circuit denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raises two issues: first, whether a court deciding how to divide litigation costs may weigh the discouraging effect a cost award could have on future civil rights plaintiffs; second, whether an appeals court may resolve disputed factual questions itself to support a cost award, rather than sending the case back to the trial court to sort out those facts.

Where it stands

The respondents waived their right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Karsjens and the other plaintiffs asked the Court to take the case and overturn the Eighth Circuit's ruling, which favored the state officials. Because the Court denied the petition, the Eighth Circuit's decision stands: the plaintiffs remain subject to the $366,461.96 cost award in favor of the officials, and the case will not receive further review by the Supreme Court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Eighth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Rule 54(d)(1) discretion question (whether a chilling effect on civil-rights plaintiffs may reduce costs) would matter to unsuccessful civil-rights plaintiffs generally, but the ruling would be a procedural, low-visibility one; the second question is fact-bound error correction.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.46·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect access to federal civil-rights litigation nationwide by defining discretion to withhold substantial costs from indigent losing plaintiffs. The immediate dispute is a narrow expert-cost allocation, not the validity of civil commitment.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant within civil rights litigation practice regarding cost shifting, but of limited broader public impact.

Ponzo v. United StatesChristopher Ponzo asks the Court to review whether a federal court may order him to forfeit $13.2 million without following required forfeiture procedures.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.20
0.36
0.35
0.30

Christopher Ponzo v. United StatesNo. 26-285 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000285 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Criminal law

Christopher Ponzo asks the Court to review whether a federal court may order him to forfeit $13.2 million without following required forfeiture procedures.

What happened

Christopher Ponzo pleaded guilty to fraud charges involving bribes paid to employees of a company that managed an energy-efficiency program. At his sentencing, the government first raised a specific forfeiture amount, $13.2 million, only after the hearing was otherwise over. A written forfeiture order followed weeks later, which the petition says Ponzo had no real chance to contest before it was entered. The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit agreed that several procedural steps required for forfeiture had been skipped, but ruled the errors were harmless and upheld the forfeiture order.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a court can finalize an order taking a defendant's property as part of a criminal sentence when the required procedures were not followed — specifically, when the dollar amount sought was disclosed only at sentencing, the forfeiture was not announced aloud at the sentencing hearing itself, the defendant was not given a chance to respond before the forfeiture motion was granted, and the order was entered without the defendant present or able to offer evidence.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, after which the Court asked the government to respond. The government's response deadline has since been extended twice, most recently to December 4, 2026, and no action on the petition itself is yet recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Ponzo, who lost in the lower court, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the forfeiture procedures used in his case were lawful, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the First Circuit's ruling upholding the $13.2 million forfeiture order against Ponzo would remain in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Ponzo's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Ponzo's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will most likely turn down Christopher Ponzo's appeal. We put the chance it agrees to take the case, or sends it back to the lower court for another look, at about one in ten. Ponzo argues a judge wrongly took $13.2 million of his property without letting him be heard at sentencing. The Court asked the government to respond, which is a modest sign of interest. But most cases that draw such a request are still rejected, and the government will likely argue any mistakes did not change the result.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but technical criminal-forfeiture procedure question (the Rule 32.2(b)(4)(B) issue McIntosh reserved); important to forfeiture practice, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.36·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Christopher Ponzo's appeal; I put the chance of review at about one in seven. He challenges a $13.2 million forfeiture, an order requiring him to surrender money tied to his crimes. The Court's request for the government's response signals interest, and his petition alleges conflicting rules about when forfeiture must be announced. But questions about whether he objected properly, and whether the procedural errors changed anything, make this a less attractive case for resolving that disagreement.

    Why this big-case score: A nationally applicable criminal-forfeiture procedure question with substantial individual property stakes, but narrower public significance than a major constitutional or institutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is unlikely to grant Christopher Ponzo's petition for review, with about a one-in-seven (14%) chance of taking the case. Ponzo challenges a $13.2 million criminal forfeiture order—a court order requiring him to hand over profits from a bribery scheme—arguing that the trial judge violated federal sentencing rules by entering the order after his sentencing hearing without giving him a chance to respond first. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response and the appeal raises a procedural question the Justices left open in a 2024 ruling, Ponzo failed to object to the delayed schedule during his sentencing hearing, making this case a flawed vehicle for resolving the issue.

    Why this big-case score: Resolving the post-McIntosh circuit split on whether Fed. R. Crim. P. 32.2(b)(4)(B) is a mandatory claim-processing rule or a time-related directive subject to harmless-error review would govern federal criminal forfeiture sentencing procedure nationwide, though its broader public salience outside federal criminal practice is modest.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 11%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring but technical criminal-forfeiture procedure question (Rule 32.2(b)(4)(B), reserved in McIntosh); meaningful to practitioners, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 18%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A potentially nationwide clarification of criminal-forfeiture notice, sentencing finality, and the opportunity to contest property loss, with $13.2 million at stake here; important procedural protections, but a specialized criminal-procedure dispute rather than a broad institutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
Abrahim Mohamed Fofana v. MullinFofana asked the Supreme Court to hear his case against federal officials; the Court declined.decided
0.35
0.45
0.10
0.30

Abrahim Mohamed Fofana v. Markwayne Mullin, Secretary, Department of Homeland Security, et al.scotus/73281680 · models differ by up to 0.35

Fofana asked the Supreme Court to hear his case against federal officials; the Court declined.

What happened

Abrahim Mohamed Fofana brought a case against Markwayne Mullin, identified as Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, and other officials, represented by the Solicitor General on behalf of the federal government. The case went through the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, which issued its decision on January 9, 2026. The docket record provided here does not describe the underlying facts of the dispute or explain the Eighth Circuit's reasoning. Fofana then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision, filing his petition on April 1, 2026.

What the Court is being asked

The record provided does not include the questions presented or other filings explaining the specific legal issue Fofana wanted the Court to decide. No document in this record describes the substance of his claim or the rule he wanted the Court to review.

Where it stands

The Court denied the petition on October 13, 2026, after considering it at the conference of October 9, 2026. That leaves the Eighth Circuit's decision in place.

What each outcome would mean

Fofana, as the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court chose not to hear it, so the Eighth Circuit's decision from January 9, 2026 stands as the final word in the case. This outcome is not a ruling by the Supreme Court that the lower court's decision was correct; it simply means the case ends there, with the result the Eighth Circuit reached remaining in effect for Fofana and the federal officials he sued.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grant would settle whether 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii) forecloses district-court review of non-discretionary eligibility findings (here a terrorism-related inadmissibility finding) underlying discretionary asylee adjustment, a recurring question Bouarfa expressly reserved; doctrinally significant for immigration reviewability, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Judicial review of statutory eligibility for asylum-based adjustment could matter beyond this litigant, including access to review of terrorism-related inadmissibility findings. The retrieved appellate opinion supports moderate national legal significance; the petition's exact framing is unavailable.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves technical statutory interpretation of immigration jurisdiction under 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii).

FS Medical Supplies v. Tanner Pharma UK LimitedFS Medical Supplies asks the Court to decide whether a business with both American and foreign owners can use diversity jurisdiction to sue in federal court.awaiting the Court
0.30
0.40
0.20
0.30

FS Medical Supplies, LLC v. Tanner Pharma UK Limited, et al.No. 26-339 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000339 · models differ by up to 0.20

FS Medical Supplies asks the Court to decide whether a business with both American and foreign owners can use diversity jurisdiction to sue in federal court.

What happened

FS Medical Supplies, a company with members from Texas, California, and China, sued Tanner Pharma UK and related North Carolina defendants over a contract dispute involving COVID-era medical supplies. FS Medical claims the defendants secretly cut it out of a profit-sharing deal worth hundreds of millions of dollars. The district court dismissed the case, ruling it lacked jurisdiction because FS Medical's Chinese member meant there was no American citizen on the plaintiff's side once foreign citizenship was factored in. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal.

What the Court is being asked

The law lets federal courts hear cases between citizens of different states even when foreign citizens are also involved as additional parties. The Court is asked whether a company that counts both American and foreign citizens among its members can still be treated as an American citizen for this purpose, when its American owners are from different states than the opposing side. FS Medical argues yes, pointing to a conflict among federal appeals courts. The lower court held no, reasoning that the company's foreign ownership disqualified it entirely.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 16, 2026 conference. Rather than granting or denying it then, the Court asked the respondents to file a response, due December 2, 2026 after the Court granted a request to extend that deadline. No decision on whether to hear the case has been made yet.

What each outcome would mean

FS Medical, as petitioner, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Fourth Circuit's decision. If the Court grants review and eventually rules for FS Medical, its lawsuit against Tanner Pharma UK and the other defendants could proceed in federal court. If the Court denies review, or grants review and rules for Tanner Pharma UK, the dismissal stands and FS Medical would need another path, such as state court, to pursue its claims. The Court could also send the case back without deciding the underlying question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 24, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 2, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up FS Medical Supplies' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: FS Medical Supplies' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn this case down, but the chance it agrees to hear it is real, about one in five. The case asks whether federal courts can hear a business lawsuit when a company with both American and Chinese owners sues American and British defendants. One federal appeals court said no and another said yes. That kind of disagreement interests the Justices, and they have already asked the other side to respond. Still, most petitions are denied even after that step.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring, technical diversity-jurisdiction question with real commercial reach for mixed-citizenship LLCs, but low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is more likely to turn this case away than hear it, but the chance of review is substantial: about one in three. The dispute asks whether a company with both American and foreign owners can bring certain lawsuits in federal court. Different appeals courts appear to answer that question differently, and the Supreme Court has requested a response. Still, that request does not promise a hearing, and the precise scope of the disagreement remains contested. Expect another conference distribution before a decision.

    Why this big-case score: A nationally recurring federal-court access question for internationally owned LLCs, but a technical jurisdictional dispute rather than a broad substantive-rights case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 14%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is likely to deny review in *FS Medical Supplies, LLC v. Tanner Pharma UK Limited*, with about a one-in-seven (14%) chance of granting the petition. The case asks whether a business organized as a limited liability company (LLC) with both American and foreign owners can sue both American and foreign defendants in federal court under the federal diversity-jurisdiction statute, which allows federal courts to hear disputes between citizens of different states where foreign citizens are additional parties. Although the Court asked the respondents to file a brief after they initially waived their right to respond—and the petitioner is represented by experienced Supreme Court counsel with outside support—the Fourth Circuit's dismissal relies on established precedent treating an LLC as having the citizenship of every one of its members, making review unlikely once the opposition brief is filed.

    Why this big-case score: Commercial contract and fraudulent-transfer dispute involving an asserted circuit split on 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)(3) diversity jurisdiction for dual-citizen LLCs; narrow procedural impact outside multi-member unincorporated entities with mixed domestic and foreign membership.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean federal-jurisdiction question (whether an LLC with a foreign member can invoke 28 U.S.C. 1332(a)(3)) that matters to federal-courts practice and to cross-border LLC litigants, riding a $200 million commercial dispute; significant within the field, little public newsworthiness.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 42%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationally applicable federal-forum rule for mixed domestic/foreign LLCs could affect substantial commercial litigation, but the presented issue is technical jurisdictional procedure rather than a broad change to substantive rights.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 35%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Important jurisdictional question affecting many LLCs, but technical and non-constitutional.

Tarquinii v. CaoA former Navy employee asks the Court to revive her job discrimination lawsuit after lower courts ruled she had not properly preserved one of her legal theories.awaiting the Court
0.22
0.35
0.32
0.30

Jawan N. Tarquinii v. Hung Cao, Acting Secretary of the NavyNo. 26-446 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000446 · models differ by up to 0.13

A former Navy employee asks the Court to revive her job discrimination lawsuit after lower courts ruled she had not properly preserved one of her legal theories.

What happened

Jawan Tarquinii, who worked as a human resources official at a Marine Corps base in Japan, sued the Navy under Title VII, the federal law barring workplace discrimination, alleging her supervisors harassed and fired her based on her race and sex. Representing herself, she opposed the Navy's summary judgment motion with detailed factual arguments but did not specifically label her claim as resting on a "motivating factor" theory, one of two ways Title VII lets plaintiffs prove discrimination. The district court granted summary judgment to the Navy, and the D.C. Circuit affirmed, holding Tarquinii had forfeited the motivating-factor theory by not expressly invoking it.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether, and under what circumstances, a worker suing over job discrimination must specifically name a particular legal theory when opposing a summary judgment motion in order to have a court consider whether her evidence supports that theory, rather than having the court simply evaluate whatever evidence she submitted.

Where it stands

The Navy waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it up.

What each outcome would mean

Tarquinii, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to hear her case. If the Court grants review, it will decide the question in full after briefing and argument; granting review itself would not decide who is right. If the Court denies review, the D.C. Circuit's decision affirming summary judgment for the Navy stands, leaving Tarquinii's discrimination claim rejected without further proceedings in her case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Tarquinii's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Tarquinii's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely decline to hear this case — I put the chance of review at about three in a hundred. A former Navy civilian employee asks whether a worker suing for job discrimination must spell out a "motivating factor" theory (that bias was one reason, not the only reason, for a firing) to keep it alive. The government did not even file a response, the lower-court ruling was a short unpublished one, and the case has procedural wrinkles, although skilled counsel and a claimed disagreement among appeals courts leave a small chance.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but narrow Title VII summary-judgment preservation question; matters to employment litigators, little public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I put the chance of taking it up in some form at about six in one hundred. Tarquinii asks whether workers alleging discrimination must expressly name a particular way of proving causation before a judge rules without a trial. The petition identifies disagreement among appeals courts, but the unpublished ruling and disputes over the evidence make this an imperfect test case. The government waived its response, and the Court has not requested one.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring employment-discrimination preservation question with nationwide procedural consequences, but not a challenge to Title VII's substantive coverage.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Tarquinii v. Cao*, with only a 2% (one in fifty) chance of taking the case. Former Navy employee Jawan Tarquinii asks the Court to decide whether a worker suing for job discrimination must specifically mention a "motivating factor" legal test—showing bias was at least one reason for her firing—at summary judgment, when a judge decides whether a case has enough evidence for trial. Although prominent Supreme Court lawyers filed her appeal, the government waived its response, no outside groups filed supporting briefs, the lower court's ruling is unpublished, Tarquinii made no legal arguments at all when representing herself in the trial court, and federal employees are governed by a different statutory provision than the private-sector law her petition relies on.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, resolving party-presentation and preservation rules for Title VII motivating-factor claims at summary judgment would meaningfully shape federal employment-discrimination litigation practice nationwide, though without major constitutional or public-policy salience.

Monsanto v. DennisThe Supreme Court vacated a California ruling against Monsanto in a Roundup cancer-warning lawsuit and sent the case back for reconsideration under its recent Durnell decision.Environment, energy & propertydecided
0.30
0.48
0.10
0.29

Monsanto Company v. Mike DennisNo. 26-139 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000139 · models differ by up to 0.38 · topic: Environment, energy & property

The Supreme Court vacated a California ruling against Monsanto in a Roundup cancer-warning lawsuit and sent the case back for reconsideration under its recent Durnell decision.

What happened

Mike Dennis sued Monsanto, claiming it failed to warn that its Roundup weed killer could cause cancer. A California jury agreed, awarding him damages later reduced to $28 million, and the California Court of Appeal affirmed, ruling that federal pesticide law did not preempt his claim. The California Supreme Court denied further review. While Monsanto's appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court was pending, the Court decided a separate case, Monsanto Co. v. Durnell, holding that federal law does preempt this type of failure-to-warn claim when the Environmental Protection Agency has not required a cancer warning. Monsanto then asked the Court to apply that ruling here.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether the lower court's decision, which let Dennis's warning-label claim go forward, should be set aside and reconsidered now that the Court has ruled on the same legal issue in another Monsanto case. Dennis's side told the Court it did not oppose this outcome, agreeing that the California court should take another look at the case in light of the new ruling.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted Monsanto's petition, vacated the California Court of Appeal's judgment, and sent the case back for further proceedings consistent with its Durnell decision.

What each outcome would mean

Monsanto, which lost in the California courts, asked the Supreme Court to act. By vacating the judgment and remanding, the Court set aside Dennis's win below without deciding the case itself. The California Court of Appeal must now reconsider Dennis's failure-to-warn claim applying the legal rule from Durnell, which could lead it to rule for either side depending on how that precedent applies to this record.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Oct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 94%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A $28M Roundup failure-to-warn judgment that a GVR in light of Durnell would unwind; real money for the parties and one more brick in the post-Durnell wave, but the doctrinal question is already settled and the order will be a one-line GVR.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 97%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The provisioned petition places a $28 million Roundup judgment at stake, with implications for related pesticide litigation, but seeks an application of an already announced companion decision rather than a new nationwide rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 95%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Cherry Grove Beach Gear v. City of North Myrtle BeachThe Supreme Court declined to hear a beach-equipment rental company's challenge to a city's claimed immunity from federal antitrust law over its beach rental monopoly.Business & financedecided
0.35
0.40
0.10
0.28

Cherry Grove Beach Gear, LLC, et al. v. City of North Myrtle Beach, South CarolinaNo. 25-1130 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281624 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court declined to hear a beach-equipment rental company's challenge to a city's claimed immunity from federal antitrust law over its beach rental monopoly.

What happened

Cherry Grove Beach Gear rented beach chairs and umbrellas in North Myrtle Beach, including delivery and setup on the sand. The City, which also sells and sets up its own beach equipment to help fund lifeguard services, amended its ordinances to bar anyone but the City from delivering and setting up rented equipment on the beach. Cherry Grove sued, claiming the City had illegally monopolized that market. The lower courts ruled for the City, holding that South Carolina law clearly authorized the City to displace competition this way, so the City was immune from federal antitrust claims under a doctrine shielding government action from such lawsuits. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether state law must spell out, more clearly than it did here, that a city may exclude private competitors when the city itself is also selling the service, rather than just regulating others who sell it. It also asks whether the Court should recognize a new limit on government immunity for situations where a city competes directly in a market it also controls through its own rules.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it, ending the case at the Supreme Court.

What each outcome would mean

Cherry Grove Beach Gear, the beach rental company, asked the Court to take up its case and overturn the Fourth Circuit's ruling for the City. Because the Court denied the petition, the Fourth Circuit's decision stands: the City of North Myrtle Beach keeps its exclusive right to provide on-beach rental setup and delivery, and Cherry Grove's antitrust claim does not go forward. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recognized market-participant limit on municipal Parker immunity would matter to municipal enterprises nationwide, but this dispute is two beach-gear vendors against one small city, the statute is idiosyncratic, and any ruling would likely be narrow; moderate stakes, not headline stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on municipal market participation could reshape antitrust immunity for public commercial services, but this vehicle concerns a localized beach-rental monopoly and distinctive South Carolina legislation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly localized dispute over municipal regulation of beach equipment rentals with no national economic impact.

Pesavento v. BoldenThe Court declined to hear Chicago police officers' and the City's bid to bar prejudgment interest on a wrongfully convicted man's noneconomic damages award.Civil proceduredecided
0.25
0.40
0.20
0.28

Angelo Pesavento, et al. v. Eddie L. BoldenNo. 25-1146 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281635 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear Chicago police officers' and the City's bid to bar prejudgment interest on a wrongfully convicted man's noneconomic damages award.

What happened

Eddie Bolden spent 22 years in prison before Illinois courts found his conviction unsound. He sued the City of Chicago and several police officers, and a jury awarded him $25 million for pain, suffering, and loss of a normal life. A federal district court later added $7.6 million in prejudgment interest, covering the years between his release and the judgment. The officers and the City appealed, and the Seventh Circuit agreed that such interest could be awarded on noneconomic damages, though it sent the case back to sort out how much of the award covered past, rather than future, harm.

What the Court is being asked

The petitioners asked the Court to decide whether courts are ever allowed to add interest, covering the wait between an injury and a final judgment, to a damages award that compensates purely for pain, suffering, and similar intangible harm, rather than only to awards that compensate for lost money.

Where it stands

The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026, after considering it at two conferences; the case had earlier been distributed for a May 2026 conference and then redistributed after the Court requested a response from Bolden.

What each outcome would mean

The officers and the City, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the Seventh Circuit's decision allowing interest on Bolden's award. Granting review would have let the Court decide whether such interest is categorically barred, with no outcome assured either side. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Seventh Circuit's decision in place: Bolden can continue pursuing prejudgment interest on his noneconomic damages, with the case returning to the district court to apportion past from future damages, as the appeals court ordered.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A dry federal-remedies question (prejudgment interest on noneconomic damages) with real dollar stakes for municipalities facing large Section 1983 wrongful-conviction verdicts, but narrow doctrinal reach and little public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Availability of interest on noneconomic damages matters to civil-rights plaintiffs and municipal budgets and could affect other federal damages actions, but the issue concerns a component of compensation rather than the underlying constitutional liability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Significant municipal liability context and IMLA amicus, but weak circuit split and case-specific vehicle issues.

Swift Transportation of Arizona v. MathewSwift Transportation asked the Supreme Court to pause a New Mexico court order while it prepared an appeal; the application was denied.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.20
0.36
—
0.28 2 of 3 models

Swift Transportation of Arizona, LLC v. Francis J. Mathew, Judge, First Judicial District Court of New Mexico, Santa Fe County, et al.No. 26A447 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000447 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Constitutional rights

Swift Transportation asked the Supreme Court to pause a New Mexico court order while it prepared an appeal; the application was denied.

What happened

Plaintiffs sued Swift over a fatal highway accident, alleging a Swift trailer was involved. After disputes over Swift's discovery compliance, the trial court appointed an examiner with broad power to demand "all documents and information" from Swift, including passwords. Swift challenged the order as an unconstitutional general search unsupported by specifics, but the trial court rejected that challenge. Swift then sought relief from the Supreme Court of New Mexico, which summarily denied its petition on August 20. With a contempt hearing looming over Swift's noncompliance with the examination order, Swift asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stay enforcement while it prepared a petition for certiorari.

What the Court is being asked

The underlying dispute concerns whether a court-appointed examiner, given essentially unlimited authority to demand a company's records and passwords, satisfies constitutional requirements that searches and seizures be specific and limited in scope. The immediate request before the Court was narrower: whether to temporarily block enforcement of the examination order, including a contempt hearing, while Swift pursued Supreme Court review of that constitutional question.

Where it stands

Justice Gorsuch, acting as Circuit Justice, denied Swift's emergency application for a stay on October 2, two days after it was filed.

What each outcome would mean

Swift, as the applicant, sought a pause of the state court's examination order while it pursued Supreme Court review. Because the application was denied, no stay is in place: the examination order and the trial court's contempt proceedings against Swift can go forward, and Swift must contend with that enforcement while separately pursuing its planned certiorari petition. The denial does not decide the underlying constitutional question about the examiner's authority; it only leaves the state court's order in effect for now.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 2, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-02: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A novel Fourth Amendment theory about a state court's Rule 706 examiner, pressed by a subsidiary of a NYSE-listed carrier, but at bottom a civil discovery-sanctions dispute in one wrongful-death case; little public salience unless the Court engages it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.36·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A compulsory examination of corporate electronic records raises potentially broader Fourth Amendment and civil-discovery questions, but this application concerns a case-specific discovery and contempt dispute in private wrongful-death litigation, not a nationwide policy.

City of Santa Maria v. CardenasA city asks the Court to reverse a lower-court ruling that let a man's excessive-force lawsuit proceed despite his earlier no-contest plea to resisting arrest.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.22
0.36
0.25
0.28

City of Santa Maria, California, et al. v. Adolfo CardenasNo. 26-94 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000094 · models differ by up to 0.14 · topic: Constitutional rights

A city asks the Court to reverse a lower-court ruling that let a man's excessive-force lawsuit proceed despite his earlier no-contest plea to resisting arrest.

What happened

Adolfo Cardenas led police on a chase that ended when Officer Andy Brice used a taser to stop him. Cardenas later pleaded no contest to resisting arrest and other charges, then sued the City of Santa Maria and Brice, claiming the taser use was excessive force. A federal district court ruled that a legal doctrine barring civil suits that would undercut a valid criminal conviction blocked his claim, since his plea's factual basis seemed to cover the same conduct. A divided Ninth Circuit panel reversed, holding the record did not clearly show which acts underlay the conviction, and alternatively citing a now-vacated circuit decision about an evidence rule. The city appealed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the appeals court was wrong to let the lawsuit continue, given that Cardenas's own lawyer had repeatedly stated in earlier proceedings that the police report covering all his actions, including the tasing incident, formed the basis for his plea. The city argues the panel ignored those statements and relied on a legal theory from a separate case that has since been withdrawn.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed, including a response and reply, and has been distributed for conference more than once, most recently rescheduled after conferences on November 6 and November 13, 2026. The docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

The City of Santa Maria and Officer Brice, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up the case and reverse the Ninth Circuit's decision, which favored Cardenas. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the lawsuit should have been allowed to proceed. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands, and Cardenas's lawsuit against the city and officer continues in the lower courts. A denial would not mean the Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning, only that it left that decision in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up the City of Santa Maria's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: The City of Santa Maria's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A California city asks the Supreme Court to throw out an excessive-force lawsuit. It argues the plaintiff's no-contest plea to resisting arrest bars the suit under the Court's 1994 Heck v. Humphrey decision. We expect the Court to turn the case down. We put the chance it takes any action for the city at about one in seven (15%). The main reason for going above the usual rate is that the Court asked the plaintiff to file a response. That is a sign some Justice took notice, but most cases where the Court asks for a response are still turned away.

    Why this big-case score: A fact-bound Heck v. Humphrey application from the Ninth Circuit; recurring for municipalities but the petition itself frames it as error correction, with the Rule 410(a) question already under en banc review below.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.36·Chance the Court takes the case: 28%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to decline to hear the City's appeal, although I give some form of intervention a 28% chance. The City argues that a man's conviction for resisting arrest prevents his later lawsuit alleging excessive police force. The Court's request for a response shows interest, and part of the lower court's reasoning rests on a decision now under reconsideration. But a separate, fact-specific reason could sustain the result. If the Court intervenes, sending the case back is more likely than a full hearing.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential for police-misconduct suits following no-contest convictions, but this unpublished, fact-sensitive decision and pending circuit reconsideration make a narrow procedural disposition more likely than a major doctrinal ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny the petition for review, with about a two-in-five (38%) chance of granting it. Police officers and the City of Santa Maria ask the Court to send this excessive-force lawsuit back to the Ninth Circuit because the appeals court relied on a precedent about no-contest criminal pleas (*King v. Villegas*) that the Ninth Circuit has since wiped out for rehearing by a larger panel of judges. Although that intervening change makes a "grant, vacate, and remand" order (a brief order sending the case back for a fresh look) a real possibility, the Court is still slightly more likely to deny review once the respondent points out that this is a premature mid-case appeal where the trial judge found factual disputes and can apply the updated law without Supreme Court intervention.

    Why this big-case score: Routine interlocutory Section 1983 excessive-force appeal primarily seeking a procedural hold and GVR in light of the Ninth Circuit's en banc rehearing in King v. Villegas; even if reached on the merits, the interplay of Federal Rule of Evidence 410 and Heck v. Humphrey for nolo contendere pleas is a technical question of moderate importance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 17%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound Heck application in an unpublished memorandum disposition; the broader Heck-erosion and Rule 410(a) issues give it some recurring significance for police-liability litigation, but the vehicle is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.37·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns the recurring interaction of no-contest convictions, police excessive-force suits, and Heck's favorable-termination rule. Municipal liability and civil-rights enforcement give it meaningful stakes, but the unpublished, record-specific ruling limits its likely reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine municipal excessive-force and Heck v. Humphrey factual-basis dispute arising from an unpublished Ninth Circuit disposition, with the broader Fed. R. Evid. 410(a) question mooted by the Ninth Circuit's en banc vacatur of King v. Villegas.

Winnemucca Indian Colony v. United StatesThe Supreme Court declined to revive a tribe's lawsuit seeking money damages from the federal government over a third party's upstream diversion of reservation water.Sovereignty & foreign relationsdecided
0.15
0.57
0.10
0.27

Winnemucca Indian Colony v. United StatesNo. 25-1170 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281654 · models differ by up to 0.47 · topic: Sovereignty & foreign relations

The Supreme Court declined to revive a tribe's lawsuit seeking money damages from the federal government over a third party's upstream diversion of reservation water.

What happened

The Winnemucca Indian Colony sued the United States for money damages, claiming the government breached its trust duties by failing, over many years, to recognize a lawful tribal government and, as a result, failing to stop a development company from diverting a stream that had supplied water to part of the reservation. The Court of Federal Claims dismissed the claim, finding no law required the government to pay damages for this, and also citing other jurisdictional bars. The Federal Circuit affirmed, agreeing the tribe had not identified a specific legal duty the government violated.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether rules recognizing a tribe's right to use water tied to its reservation, together with regulations controlling the sale of tribal trust land, create a specific duty requiring the government to pay money damages when it fails to stop a third party from diverting water before it reaches the reservation.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, with the government first waiving its right to respond and then being asked to respond; after full briefing, including an opposition brief and a reply, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The Winnemucca Indian Colony, which asked the Court to take the case, sought to overturn the Federal Circuit's decision against it. The denial leaves that decision in place: the tribe's claim for money damages over the water diversion remains dismissed, and the government is not required to pay damages on this claim. Had the Court instead taken up the case, it would have heard full arguments and decided the legal question itself, without that decision alone resolving who was right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single small tribe's Indian Tucker Act damages claim over an upstream water diversion, decided on a settled Navajo Nation threshold and shadowed by two independent jurisdictional bars; doctrinally live area but a narrow, fact-bound vehicle with low stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.57·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns water essential to a tribal homeland and potentially consequential limits on federal fiduciary liability for protecting tribal resources. Its broader significance is moderated by its damages posture, particular regulatory theory, and independent jurisdictional obstacles.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Justin Paul Dreiling v. United StatesThe Supreme Court declined to hear Justin Dreiling's challenge to a Federal Circuit ruling that dismissed his lawsuit against the judicial council that restricted a judge's participation in his case.Civil proceduredecided
0.05
0.42
0.35
0.27

Justin Paul Dreiling v. United StatesNo. 26-351 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000351 · models differ by up to 0.37 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to hear Justin Dreiling's challenge to a Federal Circuit ruling that dismissed his lawsuit against the judicial council that restricted a judge's participation in his case.

What happened

Dreiling, representing himself, sued the United States in the Court of Federal Claims, arguing that a law letting the Federal Circuit's Judicial Council temporarily bar a judge from hearing cases is unconstitutional, and that this had improperly kept Judge Pauline Newman from voting on one of his appeals. The Court of Federal Claims dismissed his case, finding it lacked jurisdiction because his claims did not seek money from the government, which that court generally requires. The Federal Circuit summarily affirmed, rejecting his arguments that the panel should have stepped aside and that the lower court's jurisdiction was wrongly limited. Dreiling then asked the Supreme Court to review that outcome.

What the Court is being asked

Dreiling asked the Court to decide three things: whether the law letting a judicial council restrict a judge from hearing cases is constitutional; whether judges on a panel deciding an appeal against that council must step aside because they also sit on the council; and whether his underlying claims fit within the specialized court's limited power to hear only claims seeking money from the government.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and on November 9, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Dreiling, who brought the case, asked the Court to overturn the Federal Circuit's decision against him. The denial leaves that decision in place: the Court of Federal Claims' dismissal of his lawsuit, and the Federal Circuit's summary affirmance of that dismissal, stand as the final word in his case. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning; it simply ends his attempt to have the Supreme Court review it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The subject matter (whether a judicial council may constitutionally bar Judge Newman from sitting under 28 U.S.C. 354) is genuinely newsworthy, but the vehicle is a pro se Tucker Act damages suit in which that question was never reached below; any decision would most plausibly be a narrow jurisdictional one.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision reaching the constitutional limits of judicial discipline could substantially affect federal judicial governance; this collateral Tucker Act suit is a narrow and procedurally obstructed vehicle for that question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises an issue related to Judge Newman's widely publicized suspension, but via a highly defective pro se petition.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se Tucker Act suit dismissed for want of a money-mandating claim; the Judge Newman suspension backdrop is notable but this vehicle does not reach it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Judicial independence and discipline raise substantial institutional stakes, but this collateral, nonmonetary Court of Federal Claims suit is a narrow and jurisdictionally obstructed vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Although this pro se petition suffers from a fatal threshold jurisdictional defect in the Court of Federal Claims, a merits ruling on the questions presented—whether judicial council suspension authority under 28 U.S.C. § 354(a)(2)(A)(i) violates Article III and the Impeachment Clauses, or whether Tucker Act jurisdiction extends beyond money-mandating claims—would have substantial structural and jurisdictional significance.

Nexstar Media v. NLRBNexstar asks the Court to review whether a federal appeals court applied the wrong legal standard when upholding a labor board ruling against it.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.15
0.32
0.35
0.27

Nexstar Media Inc., Authorized to Operate Television Station WROC-TV v. National Labor Relations BoardNo. 26-435 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000435 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Agencies & benefits

Nexstar asks the Court to review whether a federal appeals court applied the wrong legal standard when upholding a labor board ruling against it.

What happened

The National Labor Relations Board found that Nexstar's television station must recognize and bargain with a union after certifying producers as regular employees rather than supervisors, who are excluded from union protections. Nexstar argued the producers were supervisors and that the election process was flawed. The Second Circuit enforced the Board's order, applying what it called "considerable deference" to the Board's legal conclusions. Nexstar says this conflicts with an Eighth Circuit decision on similar producers and with a recent Supreme Court ruling ending judicial deference to agency legal interpretations, and notes the Second Circuit itself later described a different, non-deferential standard in another case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether courts reviewing labor board decisions must independently decide questions of law rather than deferring to the board's expertise, and whether the appeals court's deferential approach here conflicts with how other circuits, including one that addressed similar employees, have handled the same issue.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and the federal government, representing the labor board, waived its right to respond. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it.

What each outcome would mean

Nexstar, which lost below, is asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, without deciding in advance who wins. If the Court denies review, the Second Circuit's decision enforcing the Board's order against Nexstar stands, and Nexstar must bargain with the union. The petition also raises the possibility that the Court could vacate the lower decision and send it back for reconsideration without a full hearing, which would set that ruling aside without deciding the case for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Nexstar Media's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Nexstar Media's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single-station refusal-to-bargain test of certification resolved in an unpublished Second Circuit summary order; the only general stake is whether Loper Bright compliance by circuits reviewing NLRB orders needs policing, and the panel's substantial-evidence posture makes this a poor vehicle for that.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition could clarify independent judicial review of NLRB statutory interpretations and the supervisory exclusion for broadcast producers. Those questions extend beyond one station, but the evidence-specific summary order limits the likely breadth of a decision.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.65·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    High-stakes administrative law issue testing the application of Loper Bright and agency deference.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely turn this case away; I put the chance it takes the case, or sends it back to the lower court, at about one in twenty-five. A TV station owner says the appeals court wrongly deferred to the labor board about whether its news producers count as supervisors, who are not covered by union law. The government did not even file a reply, and the lower ruling was unpublished. The best hope is a quick send-back for the court to reconsider without deferring to the board.

    Why this big-case score: A fact-bound NLRA supervisory-status dispute over one station's producers, reached through an unpublished summary order; the Loper Bright standard-of-review angle is of broader interest but the Second Circuit has already corrected course in a published opinion.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to turn down Nexstar's appeal; I give it a 7% chance of obtaining review or a short order sending the case back. Nexstar argues that an appeals court gave too much weight to the labor board's legal views when deciding whether television producers can unionize. But the appeals court also relied on specific gaps in Nexstar's evidence. If the Supreme Court intervenes, a request for reconsideration is more likely than a full hearing.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of independent judicial review of labor-agency legal conclusions matters nationally, but this unpublished, fact-specific television-producer classification dispute is a narrow vehicle for that broader issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Nexstar Media Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board*, with only a 1.5% chance (about one in sixty-five) of granting the petition. Nexstar asks the Court to overturn a federal appeals court order requiring its Rochester television station to bargain with a union that includes news and digital producers, arguing that the appeals court gave too much deference to the labor board's findings. However, the appeals court's ruling was an unpublished, non-binding summary order based on specific workplace facts, the federal government waived its right to respond, and the same appeals court has already clarified in a separate published decision that it no longer defers to the labor board on legal questions.

    Why this big-case score: If decided on the merits, the case would clarify the boundary between de novo statutory interpretation under Loper Bright and substantial-evidence review of NLRB supervisory-status determinations under 29 U.S.C. 152(11), a moderately consequential labor and administrative law issue but applied here to a routine bargaining-unit dispute.

Lane Douglas Mitchell v. MississippiLane Mitchell asks the Court to review whether a second trial is barred after a judge ended his first trial with a judgment of acquittal.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.20
0.40
0.22
0.27

Lane Douglas Mitchell v. MississippiNo. 26-526 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000526 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Criminal law

Lane Mitchell asks the Court to review whether a second trial is barred after a judge ended his first trial with a judgment of acquittal.

What happened

Mitchell was tried in Mississippi for attempted murder. After both sides presented their evidence, the trial judge found that the prosecution's handling of a missing witness violated Mitchell's constitutional rights, removed the case from the jury, and entered a judgment of acquittal. The State appealed, and Mississippi's Court of Appeals, sitting en banc and divided, reversed, holding the ruling was really a procedural dismissal rather than a true acquittal, and ordered a new trial. Four judges dissented. The Mississippi Supreme Court first agreed to review the case, then dismissed its own review without further explanation.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the constitutional rule against being tried twice for the same crime blocks a second trial in this situation: a jury was sworn, both sides finished presenting evidence, and the judge then ended the case in the defendant's favor based on constitutional problems with how the evidence came in, without using the specific words that the prosecution's evidence was legally insufficient. Mitchell argues courts must look at what the ruling actually did, not the label used, and that other state courts apply inconsistent tests for telling true acquittals from other case-ending rulings.

Where it stands

The State has waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026, and the docket does not yet show any action taken at that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Mitchell, who lost in the Mississippi Court of Appeals, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the double jeopardy question itself, deciding nothing about who is right simply by agreeing to hear it. If the Court denies review, the Mississippi Court of Appeals' decision stands, leaving Mitchell facing a second trial on the attempted murder charge.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Lane Douglas Mitchell's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Lane Douglas Mitchell's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring but narrow Double Jeopardy characterization question (what counts as an acquittal after a mid-trial constitutional dismissal) in a single state attempted-murder prosecution; doctrinally tidy-up territory after Evans v. Michigan, low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.39·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A significant protection against repeated criminal trials, but presented through a fact-specific compulsory-process dismissal rather than a broad change to criminal procedure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine state criminal double-jeopardy dispute arising from an idiosyncratic mid-trial dismissal for an alleged compulsory-process violation; if granted, it would clarify the line between United States v. Scott procedural dismissals and Evans v. Michigan substantive acquittals.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case (a "denial" of certiorari), with only about a 2–3% chance it agrees to hear it. Lane Mitchell argues that the trial judge ended his attempted-murder trial with an acquittal, so Mississippi cannot try him again. But the judge ended the trial because a key witness failed to appear, not because the evidence fell short, and the Court's past cases generally allow a retrial in that situation. Mississippi did not even bother to file a response, and no outside groups have weighed in.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring but fact-bound double-jeopardy classification question (acquittal vs. Scott-type dismissal) in one state attempted-murder prosecution; modest doctrinal reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Lane Mitchell's request for review; I estimate about a one-in-forty chance it takes the case. He argues that another trial would violate the constitutional protection against being tried twice after an acquittal. But the first judge dismissed the charge because of a witness-related constitutional problem, rather than expressly finding the prosecution's evidence inadequate. Existing precedent may already resolve that distinction. I expect a short denial without further conference consideration or a separate written opinion.

    Why this big-case score: The scope of protection against retrial after a judicial acquittal is nationally important, but this noncapital prosecution presents a narrow, fact-dependent classification problem under established doctrine.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Lane Douglas Mitchell's petition for review, with only a 1% chance of taking the case. After a four-day attempted-murder trial in Mississippi, the trial judge dismissed the charge and entered a "judgment of acquittal"—a formal ruling clearing a defendant—because the injured victim did not appear to testify, which the judge viewed as a violation of Mitchell's constitutional right to compel witnesses in his defense. A divided Mississippi appeals court allowed a retrial, explaining that the constitutional ban on double jeopardy (being tried twice for the same crime) bars a new trial only when a judge finds the prosecution's evidence insufficient to prove guilt, whereas this judge twice rejected motions challenging the sufficiency of the evidence and dismissed the case over witness unavailability instead. Because the state court's ruling aligns with existing Supreme Court precedent and Mississippi waived its right to respond, the Court is unlikely to intervene.

    Why this big-case score: A merits decision would clarify the boundary between United States v. Scott and Evans v. Michigan for post-evidence constitutional dismissals labeled as acquittals, a recurring but procedurally narrow Double Jeopardy question.

Casarez v. Irigoyen FarmsA mother whose daughter died in a truck crash asks the Court to revisit a ruling that federal trucking law barred her negligence claims against the farm and store involved.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.25
0.40
0.15
0.27

Christina Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, Inc., et al.No. 25-1421 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73538544 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Business & finance

A mother whose daughter died in a truck crash asks the Court to revisit a ruling that federal trucking law barred her negligence claims against the farm and store involved.

What happened

Christina Casarez's daughter died when a tractor-trailer, driven by an exhausted independent contractor hauling produce from Irigoyen Farms to a Walmart distribution center, ran a stop sign. Casarez sued Irigoyen Farms and Walmart for negligence, arguing each company's own conduct—Irigoyen Farms releasing a visibly fatigued driver, Walmart's delivery pressures—contributed to the crash. California trial and appellate courts ruled her claims were barred by a federal trucking law that preempts state rules affecting motor carrier prices, routes, or services, finding neither a "safety" exception nor a limit to carriers, brokers, and freight forwarders helped her. California's supreme court denied review. Casarez then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to grant review, pointing to a later Supreme Court decision, Montgomery, that she says undercuts the reasoning below.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the California courts' reasoning about the preemption law's safety exception survives a more recent Supreme Court decision interpreting that exception, whether the preemption law can be invoked by companies like farms and retailers that are not carriers, brokers, or freight forwarders, and whether the case should be sent back for another look, summarily reversed, or left alone.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for November 13, 2026, after full briefing including responses from both Irigoyen Farms and Walmart and replies from Casarez; the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will act on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Casarez, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to act. If the Court denies the petition, the California ruling that her claims are barred stands, ending her lawsuit. If the Court grants, vacates, and remands—an outcome Walmart and Casarez both support but Irigoyen Farms opposes—the California Court of Appeal would reconsider the case in light of the intervening Montgomery decision without the Supreme Court deciding who is right. If the Court summarily reverses, as Casarez urges, her claims would proceed despite the preemption defense. If the Court instead grants full review, it would hear arguments and decide the legal questions itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Casarez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Casarez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 55%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We think it is slightly more likely than not (about 55%) that the Supreme Court will take some action for the petitioner here. Most likely, it will send the case back to the California court to reconsider ("grant, vacate and remand") in light of a 2026 Supreme Court ruling, *Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II*. That ruling rejected the reasoning the California court used to throw out a wrongful-death claim against a produce shipper. The Court asking a second defendant to respond also suggests it is taking the petition seriously.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring FAAAA preemption question for shippers in trucking-death suits, but the likely disposition is a remand applying Montgomery rather than a new rule.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely—about an 88% chance—to grant some form of review, most likely by setting aside the California judgment and sending the case back for another look. This would not decide who wins the wrongful-death lawsuit. A recent Supreme Court decision casts doubt on the lower court's reasoning about federal trucking law, and Walmart's filed response supports reconsideration. Differences between the businesses involved, and unresolved state-law defenses, make a final Supreme Court ruling less likely than a limited remand.

    Why this big-case score: The reach of federal trucking preemption affects highway-safety suits across supply chains, but the likely order merely returns this particular wrongful-death case for reconsideration rather than settling shipper and receiver liability nationwide.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 32%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Christina Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, Inc., et al.*, though there is a substantial chance—about one in three (32%)—that the Court grants the petition to send the case back to the California appellate court for a fresh look ("grant, vacate, and remand"). The case arises from a fatal highway crash and asks whether a federal trucking deregulation statute blocks state-law negligence lawsuits against a produce shipper and a retail buyer (Walmart). Because the California court relied on a narrow reading of the statute's safety exception that the Supreme Court unanimously rejected a few months later in *Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC* (2026), and because the Court specifically asked Walmart to file a response after Walmart initially waived one, a remand order is a live possibility; however, denial remains more likely because *Montgomery* involved a freight broker that hired the trucking company rather than a shipper or retailer several steps removed from the driver.

    Why this big-case score: Follow-on FAAAA preemption petition seeking primarily a GVR after Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, with commercial supply-chain relevance for shippers and retailers but no cert-stage amicus mobilization.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 80%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to send this case back to the California courts — very likely, about four chances in five. The lower court ruled that federal trucking law blocked a mother's wrongful-death suit over a fatal truck crash, but it relied on reasoning the Supreme Court rejected this year in a similar case, *Montgomery*. One of the companies being sued, Walmart, agrees the case should go back. The likely order is a "GVR": the Court grants review, vacates (erases) the ruling, and remands it for the state court to reconsider.

    Why this big-case score: A tragic but fact-bound FAAAA preemption dispute; Montgomery already settled the safety-exception split, and the shipper/receiver question (QP2) has no developed split.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.44·Chance the Court takes the case: 88%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to send this fatal truck-crash case back to California for another look. I put the chance of some grant of relief at 88%, mainly through an order setting aside the lower judgment without deciding who ultimately wins. A recent Supreme Court decision may undermine the lower court's reasoning about federal trucking law, and Walmart itself supports reconsideration. The Court is unlikely to hear full arguments or resolve the broader question about liability throughout freight supply chains.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially important for truck-crash victims and national freight supply chains, but the likely disposition applies an existing precedent through remand rather than announcing a broad new rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)full prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely (about a 92% chance) to grant the petition, vacate (cancel) the lower court's ruling, and send the case back to the California Court of Appeal for a fresh look—a routine procedure known as a "GVR" (grant, vacate, and remand). The California court threw out truck driver Christina Casarez's personal-injury lawsuit against Walmart and Irigoyen Farms by relying on lower federal court rulings that the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously overturned just four months later in *Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC* (2026), and Respondent Walmart itself has now filed a brief agreeing that the Supreme Court should send the case back under *Montgomery*.

    Why this big-case score: Routine post-Montgomery FAAAA follow-on from an unpublished California Court of Appeal decision; even if Question 2 on shipper preemption were reached on plenary review, stakes are sector-specific tort/preemption rather than a high-salience national or constitutional controversy.

Indian Harbor Insurance v. One Lakeside PlazaInsurers ask the Court to take up their dispute with a Louisiana property owner over who decides whether they can force arbitration under an international arbitration treaty.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.25
0.45
0.10
0.27

Indian Harbor Insurance Company, et al. v. One Lakeside Plaza, L.L.C.No. 26-53 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000053 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Business & finance

Insurers ask the Court to take up their dispute with a Louisiana property owner over who decides whether they can force arbitration under an international arbitration treaty.

What happened

After Hurricanes Laura and Delta damaged its property in 2020, One Lakeside Plaza sued its insurers, including Indian Harbor Insurance and several other domestic companies, for failing to pay its claim. The insurers asked the district court to compel arbitration under a policy clause and under an international treaty governing arbitration agreements, arguing they could enforce arbitration clauses found in contracts with two foreign insurers (since dismissed from the case) even though they themselves were not parties to those foreign contracts. The district court refused, holding that Louisiana law bars arbitration clauses in insurance policies. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, relying on its recent ruling in a similar case, Town of Vinton.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether federal rules or state law should determine when a company that did not sign an arbitration agreement can still rely on it to force arbitration, in cases governed by an international arbitration treaty. Indian Harbor says this question is identical to one already pending before the Court in Town of Vinton and asks the Court to hold this case until it rules there.

Where it stands

The petition has been distributed for conference twice, most recently for a conference after the snapshot date, and the docket shows no decision yet on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Indian Harbor and the other insurers are asking the Court to take up the case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case in full and decide the legal question, without deciding in advance who wins. If it denies review, the Fifth Circuit's decision applying Louisiana law stands, leaving in place the ruling that blocked the insurers from compelling arbitration, a result favoring One Lakeside. The insurers have also asked the Court to simply hold this case until it rules on the related Town of Vinton case and then resolve this one the same way.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Indian Harbor Insurance's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Indian Harbor Insurance's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Tag-along companion to No. 25-1383 (Town of Vinton): the underlying Convention choice-of-law question matters to international arbitration and the insurance market, but this docket itself would be resolved by a hold-and-dispose order, not a decision of its own.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.47·Chance the Court takes the case: 23%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal-versus-state-law rule could affect international-arbitration enforcement nationwide, but the underlying controversy is a technical insurance and contract dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves arbitration and the New York Convention, but is presented as a hold for a lead case.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 20%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A hold petition riding Town of Vinton (25-1383): the choice-of-law question for nonsignatory estoppel under the New York Convention matters to international arbitration and to the Louisiana surplus-lines hurricane docket, but this case itself would at most be GVR'd and draws little public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 25%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The choice between federal and state nonsignatory-estoppel law could affect international commercial arbitration and recurring insurance disputes nationwide. This petition is a follow-on insurance-contract vehicle seeking treatment consistent with a lead case, rather than a distinct broad public-law controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine arbitration dispute over state vs. federal common law involving a non-signatory, not presenting major national significance.

Jabateh v. United StatesA man convicted of immigration fraud and perjury asks the Court to revive his bid to overturn his fraud convictions through a post-conviction challenge.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.12
0.42
0.25
0.26

Mohammed Jabateh v. United StatesNo. 26-440 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000440 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

A man convicted of immigration fraud and perjury asks the Court to revive his bid to overturn his fraud convictions through a post-conviction challenge.

What happened

Mohammed Jabateh was convicted at trial of immigration fraud and perjury, based on false statements he made during a 2011 immigration interview, and sentenced to 30 years. On direct appeal, the Third Circuit agreed that the fraud statute, properly read, covers only written statements, not the oral statements Jabateh made, but it affirmed the fraud convictions anyway because trial counsel had not raised the issue and the error was not "plain" under the standard that applies when an issue is raised for the first time on appeal. Jabateh then filed a motion under a federal law allowing prisoners to challenge their sentences after direct appeal, arguing the fraud convictions were unconstitutional. The district court denied the motion, and the Third Circuit affirmed, holding that a rule against relitigating issues already decided on direct appeal barred relief.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a rule that normally stops prisoners from reusing post-conviction proceedings to relitigate issues already decided against them on direct appeal should also block relief here, where the appeals court's earlier ruling on the same issue actually favored the prisoner on the merits but still upheld the conviction because the error wasn't obvious enough to fix without an objection at trial.

Where it stands

The petition was filed on September 28, 2026. The government waived its right to respond, and the case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it.

What each outcome would mean

Jabateh, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to hear his case and reverse. If the Court denies review, the Third Circuit's decision stands, leaving his fraud convictions and consecutive sentence in place. If the Court grants review, it will decide whether the relitigation rule was correctly applied; Jabateh's petition also asks for summary reversal, a quicker route that would overturn the lower court's decision without full briefing or argument. A grant does not itself decide who wins.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Jabateh's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Jabateh's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely turn down this petition: about a 2.5% (one in forty) chance it takes the case. Mohammed Jabateh argues that an appeals court wrongly refused to reopen his immigration-fraud convictions, even though that court had earlier agreed his conduct did not fit the statute's words. The government did not even file a response, which usually signals the Court will deny. The petition also points to no disagreement among lower courts, which is what the Court normally looks for.

    Why this big-case score: A fact-bound collateral-review question about the relitigation bar in one prisoner's 2255 case; doctrinally interesting but narrow, with no circuit split pleaded.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I estimate a 3.5% chance it will grant review. Jabateh argues that two convictions added twenty years to his sentence for conduct the appeals court said the charged law did not cover. That is a serious concern, but his request faces an unusual procedural barrier because the issue was already considered on appeal. The latest ruling creates no clearly identified disagreement among appeals courts, and the government has waived a response.

    Why this big-case score: Twenty additional years of imprisonment and the availability of collateral relief for conduct outside a criminal statute are substantial stakes, but the nonprecedential ruling and unusual procedural posture limit the case's broader reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Mohammed Jabateh's petition for a writ of certiorari (a 2% chance of a grant, or about one in fifty). Although Jabateh raises a striking legal paradox—the Third Circuit held on his first appeal that the immigration-fraud statute did not cover his oral interview statements, yet upheld his 20-year consecutive sentence because the error was not "obvious" and then barred his post-conviction challenge under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 as an impermissible "relitigation" of the first appeal—the decision below is unpublished, creates no conflict among the federal appeals courts, and arises from a trial record involving severe wartime atrocities. Moreover, the United States waived its right to respond and no outside friend-of-the-court briefs were filed, strongly signaling that the Court will deny review without further briefing.

    Why this big-case score: Doctrinally interesting question on whether a direct-appeal plain-error affirmance triggers the § 2255 relitigation bar when the panel held the charged statute inapplicable to the defendant's conduct, but arising from a non-precedential Third Circuit opinion with no circuit split and extreme underlying facts.

Webb v. TrombleyThe Court declined to hear a prisoner's challenge to a federal law capping attorney's fees in his successful civil rights lawsuit against prison guards.Civil proceduredecided
0.18
0.45
0.15
0.26

Michael Webb v. Edmund Trombley, Corrections Officer, Great Meadow Correctional Facility, et al.No. 25-1346 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500248 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a prisoner's challenge to a federal law capping attorney's fees in his successful civil rights lawsuit against prison guards.

What happened

Michael Webb, an incarcerated man, sued Great Meadow Correctional Facility officers for beating him during an intake interview. A jury awarded him $15,000. His appointed lawyers then sought $206,977.50 in fees under a federal civil rights fee statute. The district court, citing a federal law limiting fees in prisoner lawsuits, capped the award at $22,500 — 150% of the judgment — following binding Second Circuit precedent. The Second Circuit affirmed, and the full court denied rehearing. Webb asked the Supreme Court to take up the fee-cap question.

What the Court is being asked

The case turns on how to read a law limiting attorney's fees for prisoners who win civil rights cases. Webb's petition argues that the statute, properly read, only guarantees payment for fees up to 150% of the judgment and says nothing about fees above that amount, while multiple appeals courts have read it as an outright ceiling barring any fee award beyond 150% of the judgment. The Court is asked whether that ceiling reading is correct.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after the respondents waived their right to respond. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Webb, the prisoner, asked the Court to overturn the Second Circuit's ruling that capped his attorney's fees. The denial leaves that ruling in place: Webb's lawyers remain limited to $22,500 in fees rather than the larger amount they sought, and the Second Circuit's interpretation of the fee-cap law continues to apply in that circuit. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply leaves that decision standing without the Court deciding the question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean statutory question about the PLRA's 150% fee cap that would matter to counsel for incarcerated civil-rights plaintiffs nationwide, but it is a fee-allocation rule with no constitutional dimension, a 5,000 verdict underneath it, and little public profile.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Removing the PLRA damages-linked attorney-fee cap would materially affect access to counsel and enforcement of prisoners' civil rights nationwide, but this is a specialized fee-shifting question rather than a broad constitutional challenge.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A technical statutory interpretation question on the PLRA attorney fees cap; important to civil rights litigators but low general salience.

Miguel Angel Delgado v. United StatesA former border officer asks the Court to review his federal convictions for excessive force and falsifying a report after two border incidents.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.20
0.40
0.18
0.26

Miguel Angel Delgado, Jr. v. United StatesNo. 25-1347 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500250 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Criminal law

A former border officer asks the Court to review his federal convictions for excessive force and falsifying a report after two border incidents.

What happened

Miguel Angel Delgado, Jr., a Customs and Border Protection officer, was convicted after a bench trial of two counts of depriving people of their constitutional rights and one count of falsifying a report about a use-of-force incident. The charges arose from two encounters at ports of entry in which people Delgado physically restrained suffered injuries, and from an allegedly false account he gave of one incident. The Fifth Circuit affirmed his convictions, finding the evidence sufficient to support the jury's findings on force, intent, and falsification. Delgado now asks the Supreme Court to take up his case.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raises four questions about how courts should evaluate this kind of case. It asks whether the appeals court wrongly limited its excessive-force review to the moments force was used rather than the full situation, contrary to a recent Supreme Court ruling. It asks what proof of intent is needed to convict someone of willfully violating constitutional rights. It asks how much injury is needed to turn this kind of violation into a more serious felony. And it asks whether the false-report conviction can stand if the underlying findings about unlawful force were themselves flawed.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and distributed for a conference in September 2026. The government, which had initially waived its right to respond, was then asked to respond; it has since received several extensions, with its response now due in late November 2026. No decision on whether to grant review has been recorded.

What each outcome would mean

Delgado, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case and overturn his convictions. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions raised; this would not itself determine who wins. If the Court denies review, Delgado's convictions and sentence, as affirmed by the Fifth Circuit, would remain in place, and the government's position would prevail without further Supreme Court proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Miguel Angel Delgado's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Miguel Angel Delgado's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A former border officer convicted of using excessive force and falsifying a report asks the Supreme Court to review his conviction. The Court asked the government to respond, which shows someone took a look, but most such petitions are still turned down. We predict the Court will **deny** review, with about a one-in-twenty chance it agrees to hear the case. The main reason: the arguments mostly dispute how the lower court weighed the evidence in this one case, which the Court rarely takes up.

    Why this big-case score: A single CBP officer's fact-bound § 242/§ 1519 conviction; the Screws willfulness and bodily-injury questions recur but this vehicle is narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review of Miguel Angel Delgado's convictions, with about a nine-in-one-hundred chance of taking the case. Asking the government to respond shows interest, but does not promise a hearing. Delgado argues that the courts used the wrong rules for excessive force and criminal intent. The lower-court opinion, however, discusses the wider encounters and separately addresses intent. Those features make this look more like a dispute about evidence than a clear legal conflict needing Supreme Court review.

    Why this big-case score: The petition concerns the boundary between civil excessive force and federal criminal liability for officers, but its evidentiary posture and multiple questions limit its likely reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny former Customs and Border Protection officer Miguel Angel Delgado, Jr.'s petition to review his convictions for using excessive force against two detainees and falsifying an official report, with only about a 1-in-17 chance (6%) that the Court grants review or sends the case back to the lower court. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response—likely because the Fifth Circuit appeals court did not mention a recent 2025 Supreme Court ruling (*Barnes v. Felix*) requiring courts to look at all surrounding circumstances in excessive-force cases—the appeals court's opinion actually examined the full video and witness record from Delgado's three-day trial before a judge, making the case a poor candidate for Supreme Court intervention.

    Why this big-case score: Routine criminal direct-review petition by a former CBP officer raising fact-bound sufficiency challenges to 18 U.S.C. 242 and 1519 bench-trial convictions; while excessive-force prosecutions under section 242 and post-Barnes v. Felix Fourth Amendment standards carry moderate doctrinal interest, this case turns heavily on deferential appellate review of video and witness evidence.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A federal civil-rights prosecution of a CBP officer; if decided, the Screws willfulness question would matter for every 18 U.S.C. 242 excessive-force case, but the record is a fact-bound sufficiency affirmance after a bench trial.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 9%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions could affect federal criminal accountability for police use of force, particularly subjective culpability and felony injury thresholds. The individual prosecution and fact-intensive sufficiency posture limit its likely reach absent a broad ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Focuses on criminal statutory interpretation of excessive force and mens rea under 18 U.S.C. 242, important for law enforcement prosecutions but not a broader political dispute.

Stanley Kappell Watson v. BradsherA debtor asks the Court to decide whether his false-imprisonment debt can be excused from bankruptcy discharge despite his genuine but mistaken belief his conduct was lawful.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.20
0.31
0.25
0.25

Stanley Kappell Watson v. Shenekka Bradsher, et al.No. 25-651 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279493 · models differ by up to 0.11 · topic: Business & finance

A debtor asks the Court to decide whether his false-imprisonment debt can be excused from bankruptcy discharge despite his genuine but mistaken belief his conduct was lawful.

What happened

Stanley Watson, a former county commissioner, accused Sheneeka Bradsher and Zarinah Ali of stealing his wallet at a bar and pressed police to arrest them. His wallet was later found in his own car. A state-court jury awarded the women damages for false imprisonment, slander, and battery. After Watson filed for bankruptcy, the women sought to have that debt excluded from discharge. The bankruptcy court found Watson genuinely believed the women had taken his wallet, discharged the slander and battery debts, but held the false-imprisonment debt nondischargeable. The district court and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed that result.

What the Court is being asked

The case turns on a bankruptcy law provision that keeps debts for "willful and malicious injury" from being wiped out. The Court is asked whether that kind of injury means simply causing harm in fact, or whether it requires intending to violate someone's legal rights. Relatedly, the Court is asked whether a debtor who honestly but mistakenly believed his actions were legally justified can still be found to have caused that kind of injury, or whether courts may find such intent simply from how excessive the conduct looked.

Where it stands

Watson filed his petition for certiorari on December 2, 2025. The Court distributed the case for its February 20, 2026 conference and, rather than acting then, asked the respondents, Bradsher and Ali, to file a response, due March 4, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Watson, the debtor, is asking the Court to take up the case and overturn the Eleventh Circuit's ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide what "injury" means under this discharge exception, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Eleventh Circuit's decision stands, leaving Watson's debt to Bradsher and Ali for false imprisonment nondischargeable.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Stanley Kappell Watson's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Stanley Kappell Watson's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about 7 percent, roughly one in fourteen. Stanley Watson wants a court judgment for falsely detaining two women he wrongly believed had stolen his wallet to be wiped out in his bankruptcy. Asking the other side to respond shows the Court took some interest. Even so, the question is technical, and this case's messy facts make it a weak vehicle for settling a disagreement among the appeals courts.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but low-salience bankruptcy-discharge question (11 U.S.C. 523(a)(6)) on a small private tort judgment; consequential for debtors and bankruptcy courts if decided, but not newsworthy.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.31·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review: I give this petition a 12% chance of being taken up. It asks whether bankruptcy can erase a debt for deliberately causing someone's confinement when the debtor believed his actions were justified. The Court's request for a response shows interest, but not necessarily support. Although the petition alleges disagreement among appeals courts, the detailed findings about the debtor's conduct may make this a poor case for settling the broader legal question.

    Why this big-case score: The intent standard for nondischargeable intentional-tort debts matters nationally to debtors and creditors, but this is a technical bankruptcy dispute with a fact-sensitive false-imprisonment vehicle rather than a broad constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Stanley Kappell Watson v. Shenekka Bradsher*, giving the petition a 4% chance of being granted. The case stems from an altercation at a Georgia lounge in which Watson, then a county commissioner, falsely accused two women of stealing his wallet—which he had actually left in his car—and demanded police detain them. After a state jury awarded the women $150,500 for slander, false imprisonment, and battery, Watson filed for bankruptcy. Lower federal courts ruled that two-thirds of the debt, tied to false imprisonment, could not be erased in bankruptcy because the injury was willful and malicious. Although the Supreme Court requested a response from the women, the Eleventh Circuit decision under review did not actually rule on the underlying bankruptcy-law question because Watson failed to properly preserve it on appeal, making the case a poor vehicle for Supreme Court review.

    Why this big-case score: Routine Chapter 7 bankruptcy dischargeability dispute under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(6) with limited national doctrinal impact beyond standard tort-debt litigation.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A recurring Bankruptcy Code discharge question with a real (if partly stale) circuit divergence, but a private tort-judgment dispute with modest national salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The proposed rule could affect dischargeability of intentional-tort debts nationwide, but this is a specialized bankruptcy question arising from an individual false-imprisonment judgment rather than a broad institutional or constitutional dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Raises a clean circuit split on the § 523(a)(6) 'willful and malicious injury' bankruptcy discharge exception, important to practitioners but lacking broader public salience.

Burford German Funding v. financialright claimsThe Court granted certiorari, set aside a lower-court ruling, and sent back a dispute over arbitrating discovery sought for German litigation, directing reconsideration in light of a newer decision.Civil proceduredecided
0.12
0.43
0.20
0.25

Burford German Funding LLC, et al. v. financialright claims GmbHNo. 25-1269 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73317900 · models differ by up to 0.31 · topic: Civil procedure (also Business & finance)

The Court granted certiorari, set aside a lower-court ruling, and sent back a dispute over arbitrating discovery sought for German litigation, directing reconsideration in light of a newer decision.

What happened

Burford German Funding and related entities funded financialright claims GmbH (FRC) to pursue antitrust claims in Germany. After a dispute arose, FRC sought discovery from Burford in Delaware federal court under a statute allowing discovery for use in foreign proceedings. Burford asked the court to send that dispute to arbitration under a contract clause, but the district court said it lacked jurisdiction to compel arbitration of this kind of discovery proceeding, and it granted FRC's discovery request. The Third Circuit affirmed, holding that such discovery proceedings are not the kind of ordinary lawsuits that arbitration law allows courts to send to arbitration.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a federal court that already has jurisdiction over a pending matter also automatically has jurisdiction to decide requests to pause that matter or compel arbitration of it, or whether such requests need a separate, independent basis for jurisdiction. Burford argued that a newly decided Supreme Court case addressing related jurisdictional questions should lead the lower court to revisit its ruling. FRC argued that the new case involved different statutory provisions and had no bearing on this dispute.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the petition, vacated the Third Circuit's judgment, and sent the case back for further consideration in light of its recent decision in another case, Jules v. Andre Balazs Properties.

What each outcome would mean

Burford, the funding entities, asked the Court to take up the case after losing below. The Court's action sets aside the Third Circuit's ruling that favored FRC and sends the case back for the lower court to reconsider its reasoning using the Jules decision as guidance. This does not decide who is right: the Third Circuit could reach the same conclusion again, or it could rule for Burford on the jurisdiction question, after which further proceedings over arbitration and discovery would continue in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 19, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Oct 19, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-19: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A first-impression, rarely recurring question (whether a 28 U.S.C. 1782 discovery application can be compelled to arbitration under FAA section 4) in a commercial fight between a litigation funder and a claims aggregator; the Third Circuit itself said the issue will not often recur. Modest interest to the litigation-funding and international-arbitration bar, little beyond it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.43·Chance the Court takes the case: 68%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The interaction of arbitration jurisdiction and foreign-litigation discovery matters to cross-border commercial litigation, but this petition primarily seeks application of a companion precedent rather than a new plenary ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine dispute over federal court jurisdiction regarding FAA motions.

St. Clair v. PettitA state prisoner's bid to have the Supreme Court decide whether a one-year filing deadline applies to his type of habeas challenge was denied.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.20
0.35
0.20
0.25

Michael St. Clair v. Willis Pettit, WardenNo. 25-1274 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73329541 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

A state prisoner's bid to have the Supreme Court decide whether a one-year filing deadline applies to his type of habeas challenge was denied.

What happened

Michael St. Clair, convicted of murder in Oklahoma in the early 1990s, later escaped, committed crimes in Kentucky, and was eventually sent back to Kentucky under a written agreement between the two states' governors for prosecution there. After his Kentucky cases ended, he was returned to Oklahoma custody in 2018. He then filed a federal habeas petition arguing that agreement required his release from Oklahoma custody. A federal district court dismissed his petition as filed too late, and the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals denied him permission to appeal. Oklahoma's prison warden is the respondent.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the one-year deadline that applies to habeas petitions challenging a person's underlying criminal conviction also applies to a different type of habeas petition, like St. Clair's, that instead challenges the terms of a custody-transfer agreement between states. Lower courts disagree: most courts to consider the issue say the deadline applies, but one court of appeals has held it does not. St. Clair also argues a recent Supreme Court decision about a related deadline question supports his position.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

St. Clair, the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and rule that the filing deadline should not have barred his petition. By denying review, the Court leaves the Tenth Circuit's decision in place: St. Clair's habeas petition remains dismissed as untimely, and the circuit disagreement over whether this deadline applies to his type of claim remains unresolved. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the Tenth Circuit was correct, only that it left that ruling standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Whether AEDPA's one-year limit reaches state prisoners' section 2241 petitions is a real, long-standing circuit question with systemic reach for habeas practice, but this vehicle is an idiosyncratic executive-agreement custody claim decided in an unpublished COA denial, so a decision would be narrow and lightly watched.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The limitations question could affect state prisoners challenging sentence administration nationwide, but this petition arises from an unusual interstate-custody agreement and an unpublished certificate-of-appealability denial, not a direct challenge to the convictions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Procedural issue concerning the statute of limitations for 28 U.S.C. 2241 habeas petitions.

Citizens Alliance for Government Integrity v. York CountyA nonprofit group's petition challenging South Carolina's refusal to hear its case over disputed solar-facility zoning permits was denied by the Court.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.40
0.20
0.25

Citizens Alliance for Government Integrity v. York County, By and Through Its Manager, Joshua Edwards, et al.No. 25-1299 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73372500 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Constitutional rights

A nonprofit group's petition challenging South Carolina's refusal to hear its case over disputed solar-facility zoning permits was denied by the Court.

What happened

A York County zoning board ruled that a company's proposed solar-panel manufacturing use was not allowed under local zoning rules. The petitioner, Citizens Alliance for Government Integrity, says county officials then let the company get building permits anyway, without any rezoning or other lawful approval. Citizens Alliance asked the South Carolina Supreme Court directly for an order blocking further permits. That court declined, in an unexplained one-page order, to take up the matter under its original jurisdiction. Citizens Alliance then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review that decision, after receiving an extension of time to file.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, and under what circumstances, local officials who issue land-use permits after a zoning board has ruled the proposed use prohibited can be found to have acted in a way that is arbitrary enough to violate constitutional protections against irrational government action. The petition says federal appeals courts disagree sharply on how to treat such permitting: some treat it as potentially unconstitutional, others require far more extreme misconduct, and still others bar this kind of claim entirely.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the county and officials waived their right to respond. After a supplemental brief from Citizens Alliance was filed, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Citizens Alliance asked the Court to take up the case. With the petition denied, the South Carolina Supreme Court's order declining to hear the original dispute stands, meaning Citizens Alliance's request for an order blocking the county's permits was not revived through this avenue. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the South Carolina court's decision or resolved the underlying disagreement among federal appeals courts; it simply leaves that lower court's order in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided on the question presented, a ruling would settle a decades-old circuit conflict over when executive land-use action violates substantive due process, which matters to every local government; the underlying dispute itself is one solar-panel factory in Fort Mill, SC, and the posture makes a merits ruling unlikely.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A merits ruling could materially affect constitutional challenges to local permitting nationwide, with concrete neighborhood environmental stakes here; this is nevertheless a localized dispute in an unusually constrained procedural vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A local land-use zoning dispute with a minor constitutional question; not of broad national importance.

Bernard v. IgnelziThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Pennsylvania man's bid to revive his lawsuit accusing a state judge of directing his warrantless home arrest.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.45
0.15
0.25

Walter A. Bernard v. Philip A. Ignelzi, Individually and as Judge, Court of Common Pleas, Allegheny County, PennsylvaniaNo. 25-1356 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73452191 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Pennsylvania man's bid to revive his lawsuit accusing a state judge of directing his warrantless home arrest.

What happened

Walter Bernard sued Judge Philip Ignelzi under a federal civil-rights law, claiming Ignelzi personally directed sheriff's deputies to arrest him at home without a warrant during a landlord-tenant dispute, and later had him jailed again. A federal district court dismissed the claims against Ignelzi, ruling he was protected by absolute judicial immunity, a legal rule that shields judges from being sued over their judicial acts. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, and also found Bernard had forfeited, or failed to properly raise, part of his argument. The Third Circuit denied rehearing, and Bernard then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether judicial immunity protects a judge from a lawsuit when the judge personally directs and oversees police officers carrying out a warrantless arrest of someone in their own home, rather than simply issuing orders from the bench. Bernard's petition argues that other appeals courts have ruled such hands-on direction of an arrest is not a judicial act and gets no immunity, while the Third Circuit ruled the opposite.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, where the justices considered it. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Bernard, the petitioner, asked the Court to hear his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Third Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Ignelzi keeps the protection of judicial immunity and Bernard's lawsuit against him remains dismissed. Had the Court instead granted the petition, it would have agreed to hear the case and decide the immunity question itself, without yet deciding which side was right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A clean-sounding judicial-immunity question (judge-directed warrantless arrest) with some doctrinal interest, but arising from a single landlord-tenant contempt fight on an unpublished opinion; if decided it would draw legal-press attention, not public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between judicial immunity and personal law-enforcement activity has meaningful nationwide civil-rights implications, especially for arrests at home. The dispute is nevertheless a narrow damages vehicle with preservation problems, rather than a broad challenge to judicial immunity itself.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    While the issue of judicial immunity for directing warrantless arrests is significant, the waiver of response suggests low probability of review.

Jason Tywann Bell v. GilleyThe Court declined to hear Jason Tywann Bell's request to wipe out a lower court ruling in his completed sentencing case because it had become moot.Civil proceduredecided
0.15
0.34
—
0.24 2 of 3 models

Jason Tywann Bell v. John Gilley, WardenNo. 25-1141 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281628 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Civil procedure (also Habeas & post-conviction)

The Court declined to hear Jason Tywann Bell's request to wipe out a lower court ruling in his completed sentencing case because it had become moot.

What happened

Bell was sentenced in 2003 after pleading guilty to attempted bank robbery and a firearm charge, receiving an enhanced sentence as a "career offender." Years later, relying on Supreme Court rulings that similar enhancement language was unconstitutionally vague, he challenged his sentence through a habeas corpus petition. A district court dismissed it, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the law gave him no avenue for that constitutional challenge and that this did not violate his right to seek habeas relief. While his appeal was pending, Bell finished serving his sentence, including supervised release.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, because Bell's case became moot after the appeals court ruled but before he could ask the Supreme Court to review it, the appeals court's decision should be erased and the case sent back with instructions to dismiss it as moot, rather than left on the books as a binding precedent.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the government filed a brief opposing it, arguing vacatur was unwarranted. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Bell, the petitioner, asked the Court to erase the appeals court's decision and send the case back for dismissal as moot. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fourth Circuit's ruling in place. That ruling, which held Bell had no legal avenue to pursue his constitutional sentencing challenge and that this did not violate his right to seek habeas relief, stands as precedent in that circuit. Warden Gilley, representing the government, had opposed vacatur and prevails by the denial.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 30%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A Munsingwear vacatur request: no opinion would issue, and the only stake is whether a published Fourth Circuit holding on post-Jones saving-clause access for constitutional sentencing claims stays on the books for a shrinking cohort of mandatory-Guidelines prisoners.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.34·Chance the Court takes the case: 38%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The surviving Fourth Circuit precedent affects federal prisoners' access to constitutional sentencing review, but the sole question here is case-specific mootness vacatur, not plenary resolution of the underlying habeas issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 15%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Munsingwear vacatur request for a mooted habeas petition, no broader legal significance.

Francisco Xavier Ortiz-Colón v. United StatesA man convicted of child pornography and minor-enticement offenses asks the Court to decide whether his convictions on both counts violated double jeopardy protections.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.20
0.35
0.15
0.23

Francisco Xavier Ortiz-Colón v. United StatesNo. 26-274 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000274 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Criminal law

A man convicted of child pornography and minor-enticement offenses asks the Court to decide whether his convictions on both counts violated double jeopardy protections.

What happened

Francisco Ortiz-Colón was convicted at trial in Puerto Rico on nineteen counts involving nine minor victims, including producing child pornography and coercing and enticing minors online, and was sentenced to 360 months in prison. On appeal, he argued, among other things, that convicting and punishing him separately for producing child pornography and for enticement, when the pornography production also served as the "offense" element of the enticement charge, punished him twice for the same conduct. The First Circuit rejected this and other claims, affirming his convictions, though it remanded on a separate issue. Ortiz now asks the Supreme Court to review the double jeopardy question.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether convicting and punishing someone separately for two crimes violates the constitutional ban on double punishment, when one crime's conduct is also used to satisfy an element of the second crime that requires proving the person committed some chargeable offense. A related question is whether that "chargeable offense" requirement counts as a formal element of the second crime or merely as one possible way of satisfying it.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the October 9, 2026 conference, and the government was asked to respond, with the response now due December 2, 2026 after an extension. The Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Ortiz, the petitioner, is asking the Court to take up and reverse the First Circuit's ruling that upheld his separate convictions and sentences. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments and decide whether his double punishment was constitutional, deciding nothing yet about who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the First Circuit's decision affirming Ortiz's convictions and sentence stands, and the government's position prevails.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 2, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Francisco Xavier Ortiz-Colón's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Francisco Xavier Ortiz-Colón's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted after the Court called for a response to the petition. Awaiting the Court. evt-order-call-for-response-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn this case down, and put the chance it agrees to hear it at about 1 in 20. Mr. Ortiz-Colón argues that being convicted and punished under two federal sex-crime laws for the same conduct violates the constitutional ban on being punished twice for one offense (double jeopardy). The Court has asked the government to answer the petition. That is a small sign of interest, but most cases where the Court does this are still rejected. Nearly every appeals court to rule on the question has decided it against his view.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring but narrow Blockburger/multiplicity question about stacking 18 U.S.C. 2422(b) and 2251(a) convictions; it affects sentencing in child-exploitation prosecutions nationwide but has low public salience.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review, with about a one-in-ten chance of taking the case. Ortiz-Colón argues that two federal convictions punish the same offense twice. The Court's request for the government's response shows interest, but most such requests do not lead to review. The apparent disagreement among appeals courts may not squarely address the same issue, and his failure to raise the objection at trial complicates the case. The likeliest result is denial without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: A recurring federal criminal-law question about duplicate convictions and statutory elements, with serious consequences for defendants, but focused on a narrow statutory pairing rather than a broad institutional or constitutional restructuring.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Ortiz-Colón v. United States*, with only a 4% chance of granting the petition. After being convicted in Puerto Rico of both enticing minors online and producing child pornography, Francisco Ortiz-Colón argued under the Constitution's Double Jeopardy Clause—which forbids punishing a person twice for the same crime—that those two charges overlapped. Although the Court asked the federal government to file a response, every appeals court to consider the issue agrees the two statutes require proving different facts, and Ortiz-Colón failed to raise this objection at trial.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound federal criminal appeal raising an unpreserved Blockburger double-jeopardy challenge to simultaneous convictions under 18 U.S.C. §§ 2251(a) and 2422(b), where every circuit to address the pair agrees they have distinct elements.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recurring federal sentencing/double-jeopardy question for child-exploitation prosecutions (§2422(b) with a §2251(a) predicate); real but technical and confined to one statutory family.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions affect cumulative federal criminal convictions, substantial sentencing exposure, and the treatment of incorporated predicate offenses. Their reach extends beyond this defendant, but the dispute is a relatively specialized statutory and double-jeopardy issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A criminal double jeopardy split concerning mandatory minimums, but relatively narrow in scope without massive national salience outside of criminal law.

Rahdar v. City of FriendswoodThe Supreme Court declined to review a pub owner's claim that police arrested him in retaliation for criticizing Friendswood's police chief.First Amendmentdecided
0.08
0.38
—
0.23 2 of 3 models

Fred Rahdar, et al. v. City of Friendswood, Texas, et al.No. 26-241 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000241 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: First Amendment

The Supreme Court declined to review a pub owner's claim that police arrested him in retaliation for criticizing Friendswood's police chief.

What happened

Fred Rahdar and Kobra Ghorbani ran a pub in Friendswood, Texas. After Rahdar publicly criticized the police chief, officers arrested him several times, including once in 2021 for blocking a police vehicle with his truck in a parking lot. Rahdar sued the city and several officers, claiming false arrest and retaliation for his speech. A federal district court ruled against him, finding the officers had probable cause for the arrest and that his evidence did not fit a narrow exception allowing retaliation claims despite probable cause. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, and then denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The case asked whether a recent Supreme Court ruling allows a broader range of evidence to show that police usually do not arrest people for certain conduct, even when officers had a valid legal reason for the specific arrest in question, as part of proving the arrest was really retaliation for protected speech.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026, and denied on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Rahdar and Ghorbani, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up the case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fifth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning the lawsuit against Friendswood and the officers remains dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Colorful First Amendment retaliation facts (billboard critic of a police chief, five arrests), but the QP is a narrow application question about Gonzalez v. Trevino's objective-evidence standard from an unpublished opinion; modest stakes beyond the parties unless granted.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.48·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could clarify evidence for retaliatory-arrest claims nationally, but this petition presents the issue through a narrow, fact-heavy dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    First Amendment retaliatory arrest case applying a recently decided Supreme Court standard.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound, unpublished Fifth Circuit section 1983 retaliatory-arrest dispute decided on forfeiture; the Nieves/Gonzalez question is recurring but this case does not present it cleanly.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary of First Amendment retaliatory-arrest liability has national civil-rights significance, but this unpublished, fact-intensive dispute has substantial preservation obstacles and principally seeks application of existing precedent.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine retaliatory arrest case with no major national implications.

Harvey v. City of RenoThe Supreme Court declined to review a landowner's claim that Nevada owed compensation for selling land she used to reach part of her property.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.12
0.35
0.20
0.22

Judith L. Harvey, as Trustee of the David T. & Judith L. Harvey Trust, and as Personal Representative of the Estate of David T. Harvey, Deceased v. City of Reno, Nevada, et al.No. 25-1254 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73300246 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to review a landowner's claim that Nevada owed compensation for selling land she used to reach part of her property.

What happened

Judith Harvey, representing a family trust, sued the City of Reno, Washoe County, Nevada's transportation department, and Green Acres Storage Partners over access to part of her property near Interstate 580. Harvey Trust said a 1987 highway project removed a bridge it had used to reach one corner of its land, forcing it to rely on a state-owned access road instead; when the state later sold that road to Green Acres, the corner became landlocked. Nevada courts dismissed the claims, ruling that Harvey Trust never owned or held a legal easement over the access road and that related claims were filed too late.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether the Constitution's requirement that government pay for property it takes applies when a state agency sells the only practical route to someone's land, even if that person never held formal legal rights to use that route.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Harvey Trust, the petitioner, asked the Court to overturn the ruling against it. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Nevada Supreme Court's decision in place, meaning Harvey Trust's claims remain dismissed and it receives no compensation. The City of Reno and the other opposing parties, who had urged the Court not to take the case, keep the win they secured in state court. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply ends the case without a ruling from the Court on the merits.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound local land-access dispute from an unpublished Nevada order; even a decision would reach only the narrow question of access-as-property, with little broader doctrinal or public consequence.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on loss of practical access through government land sales could affect landowners and transportation agencies nationally, but this vehicle centers on one parcel, contested access, and state-law easement and preservation questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A takings claim regarding landlocked property, but vehicle problems diminish its broader significance.

Crites-Bachert v. Providence Health & Services - OregonA surgeon denied hospital privileges for refusing a COVID-19 vaccine asked the Supreme Court to revive her lawsuit; the Court declined.Business & financedecided
0.12
0.45
0.10
0.22

Melanie Crites-Bachert v. Providence Health & Services - OregonNo. 25-1317 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500217 · models differ by up to 0.35 · topic: Business & finance

A surgeon denied hospital privileges for refusing a COVID-19 vaccine asked the Supreme Court to revive her lawsuit; the Court declined.

What happened

Dr. Melanie Crites-Bachert held surgical privileges at Providence Health & Services – Oregon. Providence required staff members to receive a COVID-19 vaccine, which was authorized for emergency use. When she refused, Providence suspended her privileges. She sued, arguing a federal law protecting informed consent to emergency-use products gave her a right to sue. The district court dismissed her case, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that federal drug law reserves enforcement to the government and that she had no private right to sue. The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing, and she asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a civilian can sue to enforce a right to informed consent before receiving a drug authorized for emergency use, the same way the law has been read to let members of the armed forces sue, or whether that right can only be enforced by the government itself.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Dr. Crites-Bachert asked the Court to hear her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place, meaning her lawsuit against Providence remains dismissed and she has no judicially recognized private right to sue over informed consent under this law. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling standing without deciding the underlying question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single physician's implied-right-of-action claim against a private hospital over a lapsed COVID-19 EUA vaccine mandate, affirmed in an unpublished memorandum; the topic once had public salience but the legal question is narrow and the EUA posture has aged out.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Recognizing a civilian private remedy for emergency-use-product consent rights could affect hospitals, professional privileges, and future public-health emergencies nationwide. The presented dispute is a statutory-remedy question, not a general adjudication of vaccine mandates.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A civil rights / informed consent claim related to EUA drugs, but framed as a lack of private right of action for civilians compared to military personnel.

Pitzka v. WisconsinThe Supreme Court declined to hear Mark Pitzka's challenge to his arson conviction, which rested partly on evidence from another pending, unresolved criminal case against him.Criminal lawdecided
0.08
0.38
0.20
0.22

Mark A. Pitzka v. WisconsinNo. 25-1333 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500233 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to hear Mark Pitzka's challenge to his arson conviction, which rested partly on evidence from another pending, unresolved criminal case against him.

What happened

Mark Pitzka was convicted of arson in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, after prosecutors introduced evidence of a second, still-pending arson charge against him in Dodge County as "other acts" evidence supporting his guilt. The Dodge County case was later dismissed after the Waukesha conviction. Pitzka argued on appeal that using an unresolved charge this way violated his constitutional rights, and that his trial lawyer was ineffective for not objecting more forcefully. Wisconsin's court of appeals rejected these arguments, and the Wisconsin Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

Pitzka asked the Court to decide whether letting a jury hear about a separate, still-pending and unresolved criminal charge against a defendant, as evidence supporting guilt in the case on trial, violates the defendant's rights to remain silent, to the presumption of innocence, and to counsel, before that other charge has been resolved.

Where it stands

Wisconsin waived its right to respond to the petition. The Court distributed the case for its September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, it denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Pitzka, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Wisconsin courts' rulings. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Wisconsin Supreme Court's decision in place, meaning Pitzka's arson conviction stands and the evidentiary ruling he challenged remains valid in Wisconsin. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single state criminal defendant's evidentiary claim from an unpublished per curiam decision, with no circuit split, no amici, and a waived response; a decision either way would be narrow and little watched.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional restriction on using pending-charge other-acts evidence could affect criminal trials nationwide, but this noncapital, individual arson case presents a narrow evidentiary vehicle rather than a broad institutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine state evidentiary issue dressed as a constitutional claim.

John Torsten Loop v. WashingtonA father asks the Court to revive his federal lawsuit challenging a restraining order that an arbitrator and state courts imposed limiting his contact with his child.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.15
0.39
0.12
0.22

John Torsten Loop v. Washington, et al.No. 26-369 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000369 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Civil procedure (also Constitutional rights)

A father asks the Court to revive his federal lawsuit challenging a restraining order that an arbitrator and state courts imposed limiting his contact with his child.

What happened

John Torsten Loop and his then-wife were ordered to arbitrate their divorce. The arbitrator, a retired judge working with JAMS, issued an award that included a restraining order keeping Loop away from his daughter for over two years; a state court entered that order over his objection, and Washington's appellate courts upheld it. Loop then sued the State of Washington, its Attorney General, JAMS, and the arbitrator in federal court, claiming the process violated his constitutional rights. The district court dismissed the suit for lack of jurisdiction under a doctrine that bars federal courts from reviewing matters that amount to appeals of state-court judgments, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked two questions. First, whether that jurisdictional bar should block a federal civil-rights lawsuit when the claimed injury comes from flawed procedures leading up to a state-court judgment, rather than from the judgment itself. Second, whether a state may let a private arbitrator decide an issue that substantially affects a fit parent's rights to their child without the procedural protections the Constitution otherwise requires before the state interferes with that relationship.

Where it stands

The petition and supporting amicus briefs have been filed, both sets of respondents waived their right to respond, and the case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference; the docket does not yet show any action taken at that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Loop, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it will hear full arguments and decide the two questions itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands, meaning Loop's lawsuit remains dismissed and the restraining order process is not reopened to federal constitutional review.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up John Torsten Loop's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: John Torsten Loop's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    QP2 (whether a State may delegate parental-rights adjudication to a private arbitrator without Santosky/Troxel-grade procedure) would matter to family-law practice nationally if decided, but this pro se vehicle was dismissed on Rooker-Feldman jurisdiction and QP2 was never reached below, so a decision on this docket would almost certainly be a denial with no writing.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision defining federal access and constitutional safeguards for privately arbitrated parental restrictions could have substantial consequences beyond this family, but the unpublished, individualized jurisdictional dispute limits its demonstrated national reach.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition challenging a state court family law arbitration decision under Rooker-Feldman; lacks national importance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely **deny** review (about a 2% chance of a grant). John Loop wants to revive a federal lawsuit challenging a restraining order that a private arbitrator issued in his divorce. The lower courts dismissed it under the "Rooker-Feldman" rule, which bars federal courts from acting as appeals courts for state-court judgments. The appeals court's ruling was short and unpublished, Washington did not even file a response, and the case is a poor vehicle for deciding the broader legal questions.

    Why this big-case score: Rooker-Feldman scope and arbitration of family-law matters are recurring issues, but this vehicle is a pro se plaintiff's unpublished, fact-bound dismissal; stakes are modest beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.39·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline John Torsten Loop's request for review; I estimate a 2.5% chance that it accepts the case or orders another form of relief. He challenges restrictions on his relationship with his child and the refusal of federal courts to hear his claims. Five outside groups or individuals filed supporting briefs, but the case has substantial procedural obstacles, including whether it effectively asks a federal trial court to overturn a state judgment. I expect denial without an explanation or separate writing.

    Why this big-case score: A broad decision could affect parental-rights safeguards in private family-law arbitration and access to federal civil-rights remedies, but this petition arises from an individual dispute and an unpublished jurisdictional ruling.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *John Torsten Loop v. Washington*, with only a 1% chance of granting the petition. After a private arbitrator and a Washington state court issued a restraining order in his divorce case, Loop sued the state and the arbitrator in federal court, where his lawsuit was dismissed under the *Rooker-Feldman* doctrine—a legal rule barring lower federal courts from reviewing state-court judgments—and because the defendants are legally immune from suit, making this unpublished appeal a poor vehicle for Supreme Court review.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound pro se § 1983 challenge to a state-court domestic-relations arbitration restraining order dismissed under Rooker-Feldman and sovereign/arbitral immunity; attracts five family-law and due-process amici on the abstract delegation theory, but carries limited systemic stakes given severe vehicle flaws and the Court's recent Rooker-Feldman decision in T. M. v. University of Maryland Medical System Corp.

Cummins v. IllinoisThe Supreme Court declined to review a man's challenge to police entering his home without a warrant to check on his safety.Criminal lawdecided
0.20
0.35
0.10
0.22

Christopher R. Cummins v. IllinoisNo. 25-1030 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281318 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review a man's challenge to police entering his home without a warrant to check on his safety.

What happened

Police responding to a noise complaint at Christopher Cummins's home in the middle of the night found a door ajar, loud music, a barking dog, and lights on, but got no response after repeated knocking and phone calls. Learning Cummins had a prior drug conviction, officers entered without a warrant to check on his safety. He was later charged with firearm offenses. A trial court suppressed the evidence from the search, but the Illinois Appellate Court reversed, finding the officers reasonably believed an emergency existed. The Illinois Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether the state appellate court correctly applied the Supreme Court's existing rule allowing police to enter a home without a warrant when they reasonably believe someone inside needs emergency help. Cummins argues the officers had no actual indication that anyone was hurt or that an emergency was underway, so the rule should not have excused the warrantless entry here.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference, and the Court asked Illinois to respond after initially receiving a waiver of response. Illinois filed a brief opposing review, Cummins replied, and after a later conference the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Cummins, who lost in the Illinois Appellate Court, asked the Supreme Court to take the case. Because the petition was denied, the Illinois Appellate Court's ruling stands: the warrantless entry was lawful, the suppression order is reversed, and the firearms evidence may be used against Cummins as his case proceeds in Illinois courts. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with that ruling; it simply leaves the lower court's decision in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 7%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound application of the settled Brigham City emergency-aid standard to a noise-complaint welfare check; if decided it would matter to police welfare-check entries nationwide, but the petition frames no rule, alleges no split, and sits in an interlocutory posture.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The limits on emergency-aid entry into a home have substantial privacy and policing implications, but this petition presents a fact-specific application in an interlocutory prosecution, not a developed nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine Fourth Amendment suppression issue in a state criminal case.

Colorado Bondshares v. Marin Metropolitan DistrictA bondholder's bid to revive its claim that a Colorado special district must repay its bonds was denied by the Supreme Court.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.40
0.10
0.22

Colorado Bondshares, et al. v. Marin Metropolitan District, et al.No. 25-1334 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500236 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Constitutional rights

A bondholder's bid to revive its claim that a Colorado special district must repay its bonds was denied by the Supreme Court.

What happened

Colorado Bondshares and UMB Bank bought bonds from Marin Metropolitan District, secured by a special tax assessment on district land. Century at Landmark later bought the taxed parcel knowing about the assessment and a related lawsuit, then joined the district in suing to invalidate the bonds. A Colorado trial court and the Colorado Court of Appeals agreed, ruling that charging Century the assessment would violate due process because the land had not been benefited by the bond-funded improvements, and that the district need not repay the bondholders under an unjust-enrichment theory because it had already spent the money. The Colorado Supreme Court declined to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

Colorado Bondshares asks the Court to decide two questions. First, whether the lower court wrongly read constitutional case law as barring the special assessment here, even though Century bought the land knowing about the assessment and the lack of benefit. Second, whether the lower court wrongly read precedent as excusing the district from repaying the money it borrowed, simply because the district says it already spent the money.

Where it stands

After an extension of time to file, Colorado Bondshares filed its petition on May 27, 2026. Both respondents waived their right to respond. The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Colorado Bondshares and UMB Bank, the bondholders, asked the Court to take the case and overturn the Colorado Court of Appeals' ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that ruling in place: the district is not required to impose the assessment on Century or to repay the bondholders under an unjust-enrichment theory. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that the case will not be reviewed, leaving Century and the district's win intact.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Real stakes for Colorado metropolitan-district bondholders (about $30M of bonds) and some doctrinal reach on the Takings-versus-due-process footing of special-assessment law, but no salience beyond municipal finance.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Special-assessment financing and municipal restitution could affect bondholders and local infrastructure funding beyond this dispute, but the unpublished decision concerns an unusual failed-development transaction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves a localized state-law dispute regarding special district debt and unjust enrichment, lacking national significance.

Guam v. YbanezGuam's government asked the Court to review a Guam court ruling that dismissed a corruption appeal after disqualifying the Attorney General's office; the Court denied review.Criminal lawdecided
0.15
0.40
0.10
0.22

Guam v. Richard Y. Ybanez, et al.No. 26-119 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000119 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Criminal law

Guam's government asked the Court to review a Guam court ruling that dismissed a corruption appeal after disqualifying the Attorney General's office; the Court denied review.

What happened

Guam prosecutors indicted several officials of a public transit agency on corruption-related charges. A trial court disqualified the entire Attorney General's office from the case, finding a conflict of interest because one office division had advised the transit agency while another prosecuted it, and dismissed the indictment. The Attorney General, representing the People of Guam, appealed to the Supreme Court of Guam. That court likewise disqualified the Attorney General's office from handling the appeal unless conflict-free substitute counsel appeared within 30 days. When no substitute counsel appeared, the Guam Supreme Court dismissed the appeal entirely.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to say that courts may not summarily disqualify an entire Attorney General's office that holds exclusive or shared authority to prosecute crimes, and to apply that limit to state and territorial courts, so that criminal cases are not thrown out as a result of such disqualifications.

Where it stands

One respondent, Anthony P. Chargualaf, waived his right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and on November 9, 2026, the petition was denied.

What each outcome would mean

Guam, acting for the People of Guam, asked the Court to take up the case. With the petition denied, the Supreme Court of Guam's dismissal of the appeal stands, meaning the disqualification of the Attorney General's office and the dismissal of the underlying criminal case against Ybanez, Cruz, Sablan, Susuico, and Chargualaf remain final. Had the Court granted the petition instead, it would have agreed to hear full arguments on the disqualification question, without yet deciding who was right.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Court-ordered disqualification of an entire elected prosecutor's office resonates nationally (echoes of recent high-profile DA disqualifications), but a decision here would likely be narrow and territory-inflected.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.44·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect public-prosecutor disqualification beyond Guam, but the dispute is procedurally and factually narrow.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Procedural/ethics issue regarding disqualification of a territorial AG's office, primarily of local concern.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Territorial prosecutorial-disqualification dispute of real local political salience in Guam, but narrow, fact-bound, and of little national doctrinal reach.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Office-wide prosecutor disqualification affects Guam's public-corruption enforcement and could implicate other sovereign prosecutors, but this record is dominated by local ethics rules, ineffective screening, and appellate procedure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Involves territorial separation of powers and prosecutor disqualification, but lacks national importance or a strong federal question.

Linda Kay Robison v. CollinsA veteran's widow asks the Court to let survivors challenge erroneous VA benefit decisions made during the veteran's lifetime.awaiting the Court
0.12
0.33
0.18
0.21

Linda Kay Robison v. Douglas A. Collins, Secretary, Department of Veterans AffairsNo. 26-631 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000631 · models differ by up to 0.21

A veteran's widow asks the Court to let survivors challenge erroneous VA benefit decisions made during the veteran's lifetime.

What happened

Gerald Robison received VA pension benefits instead of service-connected disability benefits in 1999, despite being found 90% disabled. He died in 2007. In 2020, his widow, Linda Kay Robison, asked the VA to revise that decision, claiming it contained a clear and unmistakable error. The Board of Veterans' Appeals ruled she lacked standing to raise such a claim because she, not her husband, was not the original claimant. The Veterans Court affirmed, and the Federal Circuit dismissed her further appeal, concluding it lacked jurisdiction because her argument only challenged how existing precedent applied to her case rather than raising a new legal question. The Federal Circuit also denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether two veterans-benefits statutes, read together, allow a surviving spouse to seek correction of an erroneous VA decision made during the veteran's lifetime, in order to recover benefits that were due but unpaid when the veteran died, or whether existing circuit precedent correctly bars survivors from raising such claims at all.

Where it stands

The petition for certiorari was filed on November 11, 2026, and a response is due December 14, 2026. The Court has not yet acted on it.

What each outcome would mean

Linda Kay Robison, the widow, is asking the Court to take up her case and reject the lower court's rule. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear the case in full and decide whether survivors may raise this kind of claim, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies the petition, the Federal Circuit's dismissal stands, leaving in place the rule that bars Robison and similarly situated survivors from seeking this kind of correction, and leaving the Secretary of Veterans Affairs's position undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 14, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Linda Kay Robison's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Linda Kay Robison's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case — I put the chance of review at under one in a hundred. A veteran's widow asks whether a surviving spouse may reopen an old VA benefits decision for "clear and unmistakable error". The appeals court below did not rule on that question; it dismissed her appeal for lack of jurisdiction in an unpublished decision. No other courts disagree on the issue, and the Court has already turned away the same question twice.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring but narrow veterans-benefits question (survivor standing to bring a CUE claim); matters to surviving spouses, little wider reach, no split possible.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.33·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Linda Kay Robison's request for review. I give it about a **2-in-100 chance of being accepted**. She asks whether a veteran's surviving spouse can challenge a serious error in an old benefits decision to recover money that should have been paid. The issue matters to survivors, but this case reaches the Court through a procedural dismissal, and the petition largely renews arguments against longstanding precedent. I expect denial without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The ability of veterans' survivors to recover unpaid benefits has meaningful national consequences, but the question concerns a specialized statutory remedy rather than a broad constitutional or institutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is overwhelmingly likely to deny review—meaning it will decline to hear the appeal—with fewer than a one-in-a-hundred chance (0.8%) of taking the case. A veteran's widow asks the Court to let survivors reopen a deceased veteran's past benefit decision for "clear and unmistakable error" (an obvious legal or factual mistake in an old agency ruling). However, the Court recently turned down the same question, no appeals courts disagree, and the lower court dismissed this case on narrow procedural grounds.

    Why this big-case score: Specialized Title 38 statutory question with meaningful fiscal and procedural consequences for VA survivor benefits if decided, but narrow doctrinal scope and low general public salience.

Nwosu v. 1600 West Loop SouthThe Court declined to hear a restaurant patron's bid to revive her civil-rights lawsuit over a shawl an employee placed on her at dinner.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.12
0.40
0.10
0.21

Blessing Nwosu v. 1600 West Loop South, L.L.C., et al.No. 25-1340 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500242 · models differ by up to 0.30 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear a restaurant patron's bid to revive her civil-rights lawsuit over a shawl an employee placed on her at dinner.

What happened

Blessing Nwosu, a Black woman, was dining at the Bloom & Bee restaurant when a hostess placed a wool shawl on her, saying her dress violated the dress code. Nwosu says the shawl was forced on her without warning and that white patrons dressed similarly or more casually were not stopped. She sued the restaurant's owner under a federal civil rights law protecting contract rights, along with other claims. The district court granted summary judgment to the restaurant, finding her claim did not involve a type of harm the law covers. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, reasoning that a restaurant guest must show treatment severe enough to force her to leave, and Nwosu stayed for the meal.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a patron can still sue over discriminatory treatment at a restaurant even if she chose to stay and finish her meal rather than leave, or whether staying defeats her claim as the lower court held. Nwosu also argues the appeals court wrongly resolved disputed facts against her instead of in her favor, as is required when courts decide cases without a trial.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Nwosu, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up her case. With the petition denied, the Fifth Circuit's ruling against her stands, and her discrimination claim against the restaurant's owner remains dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision in place without the Supreme Court reviewing it further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound, unpublished per curiam Fifth Circuit affirmance in a single-plaintiff section 1981 restaurant dress-code dispute; the underlying question (what a dining contract's 'benefits and privileges' cover) would matter if reached, but this vehicle is small and lightly briefed.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on racially unequal restaurant service under Section 1981 could affect commercial civil-rights protections nationally, but this unpublished, single-incident case presents a relatively narrow vehicle rather than a broad governmental-policy dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    This is a fact-bound dispute over the application of summary judgment standards in a § 1981 public accommodation case without a deep circuit split.

Cara Elizabeth Liberto Dodson v. The Lutheran Village at Millers Grant, Inc.The Supreme Court declined to hear a former nursing-facility employee's bid to revive her religious-accommodation lawsuit over a COVID-19 vaccine mandate.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.08
0.44
0.10
0.21

Cara Elizabeth Liberto Dodson v. The Lutheran Village at Millers Grant, Inc.No. 26-115 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000115 · models differ by up to 0.36 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Supreme Court declined to hear a former nursing-facility employee's bid to revive her religious-accommodation lawsuit over a COVID-19 vaccine mandate.

What happened

Cara Elizabeth Liberto Dodson worked at The Lutheran Village at Millers Grant, a skilled nursing facility. After it adopted a COVID-19 vaccine mandate, it denied her request for a renewed religious exemption and terminated her when she remained unvaccinated. She sued under Title VII, the federal law barring religious discrimination in employment. The district court granted the employer summary judgment, finding accommodating her would have caused undue hardship, and separately denied her request to submit a late medical expert's affidavit opposing that motion. The Fourth Circuit affirmed both rulings.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks the Court to decide whether the lower courts were wrong to rule, without a full trial, that exempting Dodson from the vaccine mandate would have placed too heavy a burden on the employer, and whether the trial court wrongly refused to let her introduce a medical expert's opinion that she says was essential to opposing that conclusion, even though she identified the expert after the discovery deadline had passed.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and on November 9, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Dodson, as petitioner, asked the Court to overturn the Fourth Circuit's decision, which upheld summary judgment for Lutheran Village. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fourth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Lutheran Village's win stands and Dodson's lawsuit remains dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound private employment dispute over a single employee's COVID-19 vaccine religious accommodation, affirmed below in an unreasoned unpublished per curiam; no legal question of general significance is squarely presented.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.36·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could clarify Groff's treatment of health-and-safety burdens, but this COVID-era dispute and its discovery issue are highly fact-bound.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    COVID-19 vaccine mandate religious accommodation claim, but highly fact-bound posture (summary judgment, Rule 56(d)).

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound application of Groff v. DeJoy to one employee's COVID-19 vaccine accommodation claim, decided below by unpublished per curiam; narrow stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.44·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision on the proof needed for health-and-safety undue hardship under Title VII could affect religious accommodations across healthcare employers, although this petition has substantial case-specific evidentiary and scheduling complications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine Title VII religious accommodation and discovery dispute; fact-bound and vehicle issues.

Cesari S.R.L. v. Peju Province Winery L.P., et al.An Italian winemaker asks the Court to restore its trademark infringement win against a California winery, arguing the appeals court wrongly revived outdated legal standards.awaiting the Court
0.12
0.35
0.15
0.21

Cesari S.R.L. v. Peju Province Winery L.P., et al.No. 26-527 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000527 · models differ by up to 0.23

An Italian winemaker asks the Court to restore its trademark infringement win against a California winery, arguing the appeals court wrongly revived outdated legal standards.

What happened

Cesari, an Italian winery, registered the trademark LIANO for wine. Peju, a California winery, later sought to register LIANA for wine; Cesari opposed, and a trademark office board found the marks likely to cause confusion and refused Peju's registration. Peju continued using LIANA anyway, and Cesari sued for infringement. The district court ruled Peju could not relitigate the confusion question and, after a trial, awarded Cesari profits and fees. The court of appeals vacated that judgment, holding the trademark office's earlier decision did not resolve the same issue as the infringement case, and sent the case back.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a federal appeals court may deny carry-over effect to a trademark office ruling by comparing how the agency and the courts weigh different factors, when the Supreme Court has said both apply the same basic standard for likely confusion. It also asks whether a product use that is narrower than what a trademark application broadly covers can defeat treating the issue as already decided, when the governing rule says uses that fall within the application's scope should count as the same issue.

Where it stands

The petition was filed in October 2026, and Peju waived its right to respond. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it.

What each outcome would mean

Cesari, which won in the trial court, is asking the Court to take the case and reverse the appeals court's decision. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the trademark office ruling should have blocked Peju from relitigating the confusion issue; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies review, the appeals court's decision vacating Cesari's judgment stays in place, and the case would continue in the lower courts without the earlier trademark office ruling automatically deciding the confusion question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case (very unlikely to be heard, about a 1-in-40 chance). An Italian winemaker argues that a federal appeals court ignored a 2015 Supreme Court ruling on when a trademark office decision binds later court cases. But the appeals court's ruling was an unpublished order that sets no precedent. The winery on the other side did not even bother to file a response. The dispute is between two private wine companies over similar brand names.

    Why this big-case score: Narrow application of B&B Hardware issue preclusion to one private wine-mark dispute, decided below by non-precedential summary order.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this wine-trademark dispute; I put the chance of review or another grant of relief at about one in forty, or 2.5%. Cesari argues that an earlier trademark-registration ruling should prevent its opponent from disputing consumer confusion again. But the appeals court's decision is narrow, turns on the particular products, and does not establish a clear nationwide conflict. I expect a short, unexplained denial after the December 4 conference, without another conference or a request for the federal government's views.

    Why this big-case score: Clarifying when federal trademark-registration decisions bind infringement courts would matter nationally to trademark owners, but the dispute concerns a technical preclusion rule in private commercial litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Cesari S.R.L. v. Peju Province Winery L.P.*, with less than a one-in-one-hundred (0.8%) chance of granting the petition. Although the Italian winery Cesari argues that the Second Circuit conflicted with Supreme Court precedent when it refused to treat a 2004 Trademark Trial and Appeal Board registration decision as binding in this trademark infringement lawsuit, the decision below is a non-precedential summary order that merely sends the case back to the trial court to evaluate customer confusion in the real-world marketplace. Furthermore, the respondents waived their right to file a response, and the full Supreme Court already denied Cesari's request to pause the lower court's ruling in October 2026.

    Why this big-case score: Private commercial trademark dispute over whether a 2004 TTAB registration refusal precludes likelihood-of-confusion litigation in an infringement suit, arising in an interlocutory posture from a non-precedential Second Circuit summary order.

Bart Xavier Pestarino v. Danielle Tetrault PestarinoThe Court declined to hear a Nevada man's challenge to a Washington domestic violence protection order and related federal statutes.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.15
0.45
0.01
0.20

Bart Xavier Pestarino v. Danielle Tetrault PestarinoNo. 25-1249 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73292885 · models differ by up to 0.44 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a Nevada man's challenge to a Washington domestic violence protection order and related federal statutes.

What happened

Bart Pestarino was subject to a domestic violence protection order (DVPO) entered against him by a Washington state court in 2024, following his wife Danielle Tetrault Pestarino's allegations of physical violence during their marriage. Washington's Court of Appeals affirmed the order, relying on unchallenged findings of physical abuse. The Washington Supreme Court denied further review. Pestarino, representing himself, then petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing that the state law and related federal statutes were unconstitutional. Tetrault Pestarino, also representing herself, opposed the petition, arguing his arguments were meritless and mostly raised for the first time on appeal.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state can impose serious consequences normally associated with criminal punishment—such as loss of parental rights, firearm restrictions, and arrest without a warrant—through civil proceedings that lack the protections given to criminal defendants, using a lower standard of proof. The Court is also asked whether Congress can enforce such state orders nationwide through federal law without requiring those baseline protections.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after full briefing. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Pestarino, as the petitioner, sought Supreme Court review after losing in Washington's courts. The denial means the Court will not hear the case, leaving in place the Washington Court of Appeals decision affirming the protection order against him. The denial is not a ruling that the lower court was correct on the constitutional questions raised; it simply leaves that court's decision as the final word in this case. Tetrault Pestarino, who opposed review, keeps the protection order she obtained.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions nominally reach every state civil-protection-order regime and 18 U.S.C. 922(g)(8), but the vehicle is a pro se private family dispute on an unpublished state intermediate-court opinion; a decision here would be a routine denial with no wider footprint.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A broad ruling could materially affect civil protection orders, firearm restrictions, parental interests, and interstate enforcement. Those substantial potential consequences are distinct from this individual dispute's low likelihood of obtaining review.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition challenging state family court and civil protection orders; highly fact-bound and lacks national significance.

Larry Steven Wilkins v. United StatesThe Court declined to hear a Montana landowner's bid to revive his long-running lawsuit over public use of a road easement crossing his property.decided
0.15
0.35
0.10
0.20

Larry Steven Wilkins v. United States, et al.scotus/73500234 · models differ by up to 0.25

The Court declined to hear a Montana landowner's bid to revive his long-running lawsuit over public use of a road easement crossing his property.

What happened

Larry Steven Wilkins sued the United States in 2018, seeking to limit public use of a road easement across his Montana property that the government had acquired in 1962. After years of litigation, including an earlier trip to the Supreme Court over whether the Quiet Title Act's filing deadline was jurisdictional, the district court again ruled against Wilkins on remand, holding his claims were filed too late. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, applying the "law of the case" doctrine and separately concluding, after its own review, that the public's long history of using the road put Wilkins on notice of the government's position years before he sued. Wilkins asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The case raised two questions: first, whether a lower court may treat its own earlier rulings as settled once the Supreme Court has reversed a related part of the case; and second, whether a deadline for filing a property dispute against the government can start running based on ordinary or even unauthorized use of land by members of the public, rather than only based on the government's own actions.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Wilkins, the property owner, asked the Court to take up the case; the government opposed review. The denial leaves the Ninth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Wilkins's lawsuit remains barred as untimely and the dispute over the easement's scope stays unresolved in his favor on the government's terms. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit's reasoning on either question Wilkins raised; it simply leaves that court's judgment standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 8%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Second trip of a single-landowner Quiet Title Act dispute over one Montana forest road; the questions (law of the case after a reversal, accrual from third-party use) are procedural and factbound, with modest reach beyond western QTA litigants.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 6%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Quiet Title Act accrual affects private owners facing federal easements, and the remand question implicates lower-court compliance with Supreme Court judgments. The immediate dispute is a single road easement, with no demonstrated nationwide policy disruption.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 4%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound procedural dispute on remand regarding the QTA statute of limitations.

Chaffins v. SharpA mother asks the Court to revive her civil rights lawsuit over her child's warrantless removal, which lower courts dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.10
0.45
0.05
0.20

Leanda Chaffins v. Shannon Sharp, et al.No. 26-455 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000455 · models differ by up to 0.40 · topic: Civil procedure

A mother asks the Court to revive her civil rights lawsuit over her child's warrantless removal, which lower courts dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.

What happened

Leanda Chaffins says North Dakota human services officials removed her child without a warrant or court order in September 2022, with a report of abuse filed only afterward. She sued the officials and others involved under federal civil rights law, seeking damages and other relief for the removal, arguing the violation happened before any state court was involved. The district court dismissed her case, holding that federal courts should defer to the related state custody proceedings and that a doctrine barring review of state-court judgments also applied. The Eighth Circuit affirmed without reaching the merits of her constitutional claims, and rehearing was denied.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether federal courts may decline to hear civil rights claims over conduct that happened before any state court proceeding began, just because state custody or termination proceedings were filed later. It is also asked whether a separate rule barring federal review of state-court judgments blocks claims for damages over earlier official conduct, when the plaintiff is not asking a federal court to overturn what a state court decided.

Where it stands

The petition has been fully briefed. All respondents have filed waivers of their right to respond, and the docket shows no indication yet that the Court has acted on the petition itself.

What each outcome would mean

Chaffins is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the dismissal below. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full briefing and argument on whether her claims can proceed in federal court; a grant alone would not decide who is right. If the Court denies the petition, the Eighth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of her lawsuit would stand, leaving the respondents' win in place and her claims unable to proceed in federal court as currently framed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Chaffins' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Chaffins' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se parent's section 1983 suit over a warrantless child removal, dismissed below on Younger and Rooker-Feldman grounds and affirmed in an unreasoned Rule 47B per curiam; the abstention-in-child-welfare theme is real but this record could not carry a decision of any breadth.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The availability of a federal damages forum for allegedly unconstitutional child removals has substantial recurring civil-rights and family-integrity stakes, but this record presents an individual, procedurally complicated dispute rather than a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se petition regarding an arrest, very low stakes for national law.

Samuel Collin Robinson v. Katherine Lyman FreemanA father's petition asking the Court to strike down Colorado's child-custody factors as unconstitutionally vague was denied.decided
0.12
0.45
0.00
0.19

Samuel Collin Robinson v. Katherine Lyman Freeman, fka Katherine Lyman Robinsonscotus/73369987 · models differ by up to 0.45

A father's petition asking the Court to strike down Colorado's child-custody factors as unconstitutionally vague was denied.

What happened

Samuel Collin Robinson and Katherine Lyman Freeman divorced, and parenting time for their children was later set by a Colorado district court under a plan giving Freeman most of the time. Robinson filed a motion to modify parenting time, arguing the controlling factors should not control because Colorado's statutory "best interests" factors lack objective standards. A magistrate denied the motion without a hearing for failing to address the statutory factors, and the district court upheld that order. The Colorado Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Colorado Supreme Court declined further review.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state custody law that lists factors for judges to weigh, without spelling out how to measure or apply them, is so vague that it denies parents fair notice of what is required, violating constitutional guarantees of fair legal process. Robinson also asks whether a modification request can be rejected simply for not restating those factors.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Robinson, the father, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Colorado Court of Appeals' decision upholding the denial of his motion. The denial means the Court will not hear the case, leaving the Colorado Court of Appeals' ruling in place. That ruling upheld the lower courts' rejection of Robinson's modification request and left the existing parenting-time arrangement, favoring Freeman, undisturbed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the statute is constitutional, only that it leaves the lower court's decision standing.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The question as framed (a facial vagueness attack on every state's best-interests factors) would be enormous if ever decided, but the actual controversy is one parent's motion to modify parenting time denied under a state particularity rule, unpublished below, with no split, no amici, and no response; the realistic decision is an unremarked denial with no doctrinal footprint.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.45·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Invalidating best-interests parenting-time factors on federal due-process grounds could affect family-law adjudication broadly. The immediate dispute concerns one family's modification motion, and the record shows no organized national attention. Stakes are distinct from the very low grant probability.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition challenging state child custody and parenting time statutes; presents no split of authority and lacks national significance.

Greene v. Kansas Department of RevenueThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Kansas family's claim that the state violated their constitutional rights by keeping seized property after the tax assessment behind it was overturned.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.08
0.34
0.15
0.19

David Greene, Jr., et al. v. Kansas Department of Revenue, et al.No. 25-1339 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500241 · models differ by up to 0.26 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Kansas family's claim that the state violated their constitutional rights by keeping seized property after the tax assessment behind it was overturned.

What happened

Kansas tax officials assessed a $460,000 tax against David and Marcia Greene in 2012 and seized property worth $62,500. In 2014 a state tax board found the assessment invalid, and courts later confirmed no tax was owed, but the state did not return the property until 2023. The Greenes sued, arguing the continued retention of their property violated their constitutional rights. A Kansas trial court dismissed the claim, and the Kansas Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that taxation cannot amount to the kind of "taking" the Constitution restricts. The Kansas Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide whether a government's continued retention of property, after the legal basis for taking it has been invalidated, by itself violates constitutional protections against depriving someone of property without due process. The petitioners say federal appeals courts disagree on which constitutional provision governs this kind of claim, and that the Kansas courts' approach conflicts with that body of law.

Where it stands

The Kansas Department of Revenue waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026 the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

The Greenes, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the Kansas Court of Appeals' decision. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that decision in place, meaning the Kansas courts' ruling against the Greenes stands and their claim does not proceed further. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Kansas courts' reasoning; it simply leaves the lower court's judgment as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single-family damages dispute over a Kansas tax levy already returned in 2023; the retention-of-seized-property split it gestures at is real but this vehicle does not present it, so a decision here would be narrow and little noticed.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.34·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The constitutional limits on retaining property after a tax assessment fails have meaningful implications for property owners and government accountability. This individual damages dispute presents a broader recurring issue through substantial pleading and defendant-specific barriers.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A standard Fifth Amendment takings claim concerning retention of property; lacks broad national significance or apparent deep division.

Gengshu Scott He v. RubioThe Court declined to hear a federal employee's bid to let courts, rather than the Labor Department, decide if a workplace-injury law barred his damages claim.decided
0.12
0.30
0.15
0.19

Gengshu Scott He, et al. v. Marco Rubio, Secretary of State, et al.No. 26-405 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000405 · models differ by up to 0.18

The Court declined to hear a federal employee's bid to let courts, rather than the Labor Department, decide if a workplace-injury law barred his damages claim.

What happened

Gengshu Scott He, a former State Department employee, and his family sued the government for incidents involving a State Department security officer, including an alleged confrontation at their Virginia home. Lower courts dismissed He's own tort claims, ruling that a law covering federal workers' job injuries required the Labor Department to decide first whether it covered his claims, since He had declined to seek that agency's determination. The court of appeals also dismissed his discrimination and retaliation claims, but allowed his family's separate assault claim to proceed. He asked the Supreme Court to review the dismissal of his own claims.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether, when a federal employee sues the government for common-law harm and does not claim any disability, death, or injury connected to his job duties, a court must still let the executive branch decide first whether a workplace-injury compensation law applies before the employee's lawsuit can go forward. Federal appeals courts disagree on how much deference such a law requires.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference after the government waived its right to respond. The Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

He asked the Court to take up his case. With the petition denied, the lower court's decision dismissing his claims stands: He's tort, discrimination, and retaliation claims remain dismissed, and the disagreement among federal appeals courts over how much deference the executive branch gets in these cases remains unresolved by the Supreme Court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that ruling in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn this case down. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about 1 in 80. A former State Department employee argues that courts, not the Labor Department, should decide whether the federal workers' compensation law blocks his tort lawsuit. Appeals courts disagree on this, but the disagreement is decades old. The government did not even bother to file a response. His own claim was rejected in a short unpublished order, which makes the case a weak candidate for review.

    Why this big-case score: A FECA/FTCA channeling question that recurs for federal employees, but technical and narrow; the individual tort facts carry little broader stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review; I put the chance of any grant at about one in forty, or 2.5%. The employee raises a potentially important disagreement over whether courts or the Labor Department first decide which workplace injuries belong in the federal compensation system. But the challenged ruling is unpublished, he declined the agency process, and the government waived a response. I expect no further conference distribution and no separate statement from a Justice.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential for federal employees' access to tort remedies and the allocation of FECA coverage decisions between courts and Labor, but a specialized statutory dispute rather than a broad constitutional case.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny this petition for review, with less than a one-percent chance (0.8%) of granting it. Former State Department employee Gengshu He asks the Court to decide whether federal trial courts must let the Department of Labor determine first if the Federal Employees' Compensation Act (a workers' compensation law for federal employees) covers his tort lawsuit against the government over a confrontation with agency security officers at his home. Although He argues that federal appeals courts disagree on how much deference courts owe the Department of Labor on that coverage question, the federal government waived its right to respond, the lower court resolved He's claim in a brief unpublished order after He declined to submit a claim to the Department of Labor, and his family members' related claims are still moving forward in the trial court.

    Why this big-case score: Routine single-employee FTCA/FECA preemption dispute arising from an unpublished D.C. Circuit summary affirmance with a government waiver, though the underlying question of judicial deference to Department of Labor FECA coverage determinations affects federal-employee tort litigation across circuits.

Rydberg v. United StatesA man convicted of health care fraud asks the Court to decide whether a federal workers' compensation program counts as a "health care benefit program" under the fraud statute.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.12
0.30
0.15
0.19

Christopher Rydberg v. United StatesNo. 26-441 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000441 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Criminal law

A man convicted of health care fraud asks the Court to decide whether a federal workers' compensation program counts as a "health care benefit program" under the fraud statute.

What happened

Christopher Rydberg was convicted of conspiring to commit health care fraud, money laundering, and defrauding the United States, based on a scheme that billed a federal workers' compensation program (FECA) and Blue Cross Blue Shield for unnecessary compound drug prescriptions. He argued that FECA, a no-fault workers' compensation system, is not a "health care benefit program" under the fraud statute because it is not a "plan" or "contract." The district court rejected this argument, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed, citing its own precedent that the term should be read broadly. The Fifth Circuit also denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a workers' compensation program like FECA fits the legal definition used in the health care fraud statute, which covers any "plan or contract" providing medical benefits. Rydberg's petition also asks the Court to reject the Fifth Circuit's practice of reading that definition broadly, and to clarify how a rule favoring defendants when a criminal law is unclear should apply.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The petition has been distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Rydberg, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full arguments and decide whether FECA counts as a health care benefit program, a ruling that could affect his convictions and sentence. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's decision affirming his convictions stands, and the case ends without the question being resolved.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Rydberg's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Rydberg's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down this case (roughly a 1-in-40 chance it agrees to hear it). Christopher Rydberg was convicted of health-care fraud. He argues that the federal workers'-compensation program he was accused of defrauding does not count as a "health care benefit program" under the fraud statute. The appeals court rejected his argument in a short, unpublished decision and said any error didn't matter anyway. No other courts are said to disagree, and the government didn't bother filing a response, which usually signals a denial.

    Why this big-case score: Narrow statutory question (whether FECA is a 'health care benefit program' under 18 U.S.C. 24(b)) affecting a niche set of health-fraud prosecutions; the lenity QP is broad but poorly presented here.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Christopher Rydberg's appeal: I estimate about a two-in-a-hundred chance of review. He argues that the federal workers' compensation system is not covered by the health-care fraud law used against him. The petition identifies no direct disagreement between appeals courts, and his conviction also involved a private insurer, complicating the case. I expect denial after the December 4 conference, without another round of consideration or a separate written objection from a Justice.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential for federal workers' compensation fraud prosecutions and criminal statutory interpretation, but the concrete question concerns one benefits scheme and a factually complicated conviction.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Christopher Rydberg's petition for review (a 99.2% chance of denial, or a 0.8% chance of being heard). Rydberg, a former pharmacy executive convicted of a $90 million kickback and billing scheme, argues that the Federal Employees' Compensation Act—a federal workers' compensation program—does not count as a "health care benefit program" under the federal health-care fraud statute. However, no lower federal court has ever agreed with that interpretation, the appeals court decided his case in a short unpublished opinion that sets no precedent, his conviction also rested on defrauding a private insurer (Blue Cross Blue Shield), and the federal government waived its right to respond without the Court asking for a reply.

    Why this big-case score: Routine federal health-care fraud and workers'-compensation statutory interpretation challenge with no circuit split, arising from an unpublished Fifth Circuit affirmance.

Mike Singh Sethi v. United States Court of AppealsThe Court declined to hear a lawyer's challenge to his six-month suspension from practicing before a federal appeals court over fabricated legal citations in briefs.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.12
0.38
0.05
0.18

Mike Singh Sethi v. United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, et al.No. 26-296 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000296 · models differ by up to 0.33 · topic: Constitutional rights (also Civil procedure)

The Court declined to hear a lawyer's challenge to his six-month suspension from practicing before a federal appeals court over fabricated legal citations in briefs.

What happened

Attorney Mike Singh Sethi filed immigration-appeal briefs containing fake case citations and misquoted opinions, which the Ninth Circuit traced to unchecked use of generative artificial intelligence by a firm employee. After ordering Sethi and a colleague to explain why they should not be disciplined, the Ninth Circuit issued a published order suspending Sethi from practicing before it for six months, fining him, and imposing other requirements, partly based on findings that his later explanations to the court were themselves misleading. Sethi asked the Supreme Court to review that suspension.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raised two questions: whether the appeals court could rely on conduct and statements made after the original disciplinary charges, without separately notifying Sethi that this later conduct itself could be punished, and whether the court could suspend him for failing to meet a specific disclosure requirement about how citation errors arose that the petition says was announced only in the final ruling, with no earlier rule or notice requiring it.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and the Court denied it on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Sethi, the attorney suspended by the Ninth Circuit, asked the Supreme Court to overturn that suspension. With the petition denied, the Ninth Circuit's order stands: the six-month suspension, fine, and related requirements remain in effect, and the Supreme Court will not review whether Sethi received adequate notice of the charges against him. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the suspension was proper, only that it will not consider the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    One lawyer's six-month circuit suspension; the AI-hallucination backdrop is newsworthy, but a decision would set at most a procedural-notice rule for federal bar discipline, not a broad doctrine.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.40·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potential guidance on notice in federal attorney discipline and AI-source disclosure has profession-wide significance, but this vehicle concerns one lawyer's suspension and fact-specific candor findings.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Novel issue regarding attorney discipline for AI-hallucinated citations, will attract legal press but is a fact-bound disciplinary matter.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A published circuit sanction for AI-hallucinated citations is topical, but the questions are fact-bound applications of In re Ruffalo notice and FRAP 46/47 to one attorney, with no split and no broad legal consequence.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.38·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could shape federal attorney-discipline notice requirements and correction duties for AI-generated citations nationwide, but this is a fact-specific professional suspension rather than a broad challenge to AI use or immigration policy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Narrow, fact-bound attorney discipline case.

Ricky Darnell Patterson v. MichiganThe Supreme Court declined to review a Michigan driver's challenge to his impaired-driving charge based on his blood THC level.Criminal lawdecided
0.12
0.32
0.10
0.18

Ricky Darnell Patterson v. MichiganNo. 25-1263 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73309407 · models differ by up to 0.22 · topic: Criminal law

The Supreme Court declined to review a Michigan driver's challenge to his impaired-driving charge based on his blood THC level.

What happened

Ricky Patterson was charged under Michigan law after a motorcycle collided with his car; the responding trooper testified Patterson passed field sobriety tests, but a blood test showed THC in his system. A district court found probable cause that Patterson was impaired, and the circuit court held that his THC level supported a finding that he drove under the influence of marijuana. Michigan's Court of Appeals and Supreme Court both declined to hear further appeals, leaving the circuit court's ruling in place. Patterson then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

Patterson argues that without any national or state standard defining how much THC in a driver's blood counts as impairment, he had no fair warning that his THC level could lead to a conviction. He also argues this kind of dispute will keep recurring in future cases without ever getting full court review, so the Court should decide it now even though his own case has not reached a final judgment.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026 the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Patterson, as the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Michigan courts' rulings in place, meaning the finding that Patterson's THC level could support an impaired-driving charge stands, and his case can proceed on that basis. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Michigan courts' reasoning; it simply leaves that outcome undisturbed without deciding the underlying question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A national THC-impairment threshold for drivers would matter widely, but the case as framed is an interlocutory, fact-bound due-process challenge to one Michigan prosecution with no reasoned opinion below; if decided it would most plausibly be decided narrowly.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional notice rule for cannabis-impaired driving could affect prosecutions across states, but this petition presents an interlocutory, fact-specific Michigan prosecution rather than a developed national conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine, highly fact-bound state criminal appeal regarding notice of a THC limit; no broader significance or federal interest.

Reguli v. HetzelTwo women ask the Court to revive their civil rights lawsuit against prosecutors and officials over a criminal case that Tennessee courts later said was not actually a crime.awaiting the Court
0.12
0.42
0.00
0.18

Connie L. Reguli, et al. v. Tracy Hetzel, et al.No. 26-501 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000501 · models differ by up to 0.42

Two women ask the Court to revive their civil rights lawsuit against prosecutors and officials over a criminal case that Tennessee courts later said was not actually a crime.

What happened

Connie Reguli and Wendy Hancock were prosecuted in Tennessee after Hancock kept her child from state custody during a dependency dispute; Reguli was Hancock's attorney. Tennessee appellate courts later vacated both convictions, finding the charged conduct did not meet the statute's terms. Reguli and Hancock then sued the prosecutors, police officials, a state agency lawyer, and the city, alleging the officials knowingly brought charges that omitted an essential element of the crime. The district court dismissed all claims, citing prosecutorial and qualified immunity. The Sixth Circuit affirmed, reasoning in part that the officials may have made a reasonable mistake about what the law required.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether officials who bring charges by leaving out a required part of a criminal law can still be shielded from liability by being treated as having made a reasonable legal mistake. It is also asked whether prosecutors who draft an indictment this way can claim the broad immunity usually given to advocacy work, and whether an appeals court may decide a case using a legal theory neither side argued or briefed, based on facts it altered from what the plaintiffs had alleged.

Where it stands

The petition was filed on October 9, 2026, and the response was due November 16, 2026. All named respondents have since filed waivers of their right to respond, and the docket shows no further action since.

What each outcome would mean

Reguli and Hancock, as petitioners, are asking the Court to overturn the Sixth Circuit's ruling, which affirmed dismissal of their suit and left the lower court's judgment for the officials and the city in place. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on these immunity and procedure questions and decide the legal issues itself, without presuming either side correct. If it denies review, the Sixth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of the lawsuit stands, and the case ends in the officials' favor.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Reguli's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Reguli's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound §1983 malicious-prosecution/immunity dispute between private plaintiffs and local Tennessee officials; the Heien/Chiaverini and Buckley questions have some doctrinal reach, but as framed they are case-specific error correction.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.42·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Limits on civil liability for allegedly knowing prosecution of noncriminal conduct could affect police, prosecutors, and child-welfare officials nationally, but this petition presents a fact-specific Tennessee dispute with several independent immunity grounds.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine error-correction petition by a private individual raising fact-specific Fourth Amendment and immunity issues with no significant national importance.

Redding v. MullinThe Supreme Court declined to hear a former TSA employee's bid to revive her disability-accommodation lawsuit against the federal government.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.10
0.26
0.15
0.17

Stephanie M. Redding v. Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland SecurityNo. 25-1336 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500237 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Supreme Court declined to hear a former TSA employee's bid to revive her disability-accommodation lawsuit against the federal government.

What happened

Stephanie Redding worked for TSA as a Federal Air Marshal until medical conditions made her unable to meet flight requirements. TSA reassigned her to a lower-paying job at another agency and closed her accommodation case days later. Redding says TSA knew, but never told her, that accepting the reassignment would end her pending disability-retirement application, and that TSA closed her case before required training was finished. A federal district court dismissed her Rehabilitation Act lawsuit, finding she had not shown she could do her prior job's essential functions. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the reassignment was "manifestly reasonable" and that this ended the inquiry.

What the Court is being asked

Redding asked the Court to decide whether an employer meets its duty to work in good faith with a disabled employee seeking accommodation when it proposes a job move while hiding that accepting it will cost the employee a separate retirement benefit, and when it ends the accommodation process before required training and evaluation are complete. She also asked whether courts may treat an employee's participation as voluntary consent when the employer concealed facts material to that choice.

Where it stands

The Solicitor General waived the government's right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Redding, as petitioner, asked the Court to reverse the Fourth Circuit's decision against her. The denial leaves that decision in place: the lawsuit remains dismissed, and the Fourth Circuit's ruling that TSA's reassignment was reasonable, ending further inquiry into the agency's conduct, stands as the final word in her case. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Fourth Circuit; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed without deciding the underlying question.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single federal employee's Rehabilitation Act failure-to-accommodate claim dismissed at the pleading stage; the dual-track retirement/accommodation issue is niche and the vehicle turns on case-specific concessions.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.26·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An accommodation-process ruling could affect disabled employees nationally, particularly federal employees navigating reassignment and disability retirement. This individual employment dispute presents narrower practical stakes than a broad challenge to disability-rights protections.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine employment discrimination (Rehabilitation Act) dispute over the interactive process; not a matter of broad public or constitutional significance.

Rogne v. City of CatoosaThe Supreme Court declined to hear a property owner's bid to revive his lawsuit seeking compensation for a city's years-long occupation of his land.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.10
0.30
0.10
0.17

John Rogne v. City of Catoosa, OklahomaNo. 25-1320 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500221 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a property owner's bid to revive his lawsuit seeking compensation for a city's years-long occupation of his land.

What happened

John Rogne says the City of Catoosa built a barrier fence on his property in 2011 after issuing a cease-and-desist order, blocking his use of the land for six years without paying him anything. He sued in Oklahoma state court claiming an unconstitutional taking without compensation. The state courts ruled against him, holding he had not exhausted administrative remedies and that the city's later rescission of its order left no live claim. Rogne then refiled in federal court, arguing Oklahoma's savings statute let him do so because his first case failed on procedural grounds, not on the merits. The federal district court and the Tenth Circuit disagreed, ruling that the state court's decision counted as a ruling on the merits, so the suit could not proceed.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state court's refusal to hear a compensation claim—because the property owner hadn't used an administrative process, and because the government later voluntarily ended its occupation—counts as a decision on the substance of the compensation claim itself, as opposed to a procedural dismissal that would let the owner refile.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Rogne, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up his case. The denial means the Court will not review the Tenth Circuit's decision, so that ruling stands: Rogne's federal lawsuit remains dismissed, and he cannot pursue his compensation claim further under the theory he raised. The City of Catoosa's win in the lower courts is unaffected. A denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Tenth Circuit's reasoning, only that the case will not be reviewed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single Oklahoma landowner's post-Knick preclusion fight with a small city over a rescinded cease-and-desist order and a barrier fence, decided below in an unpublished Tenth Circuit order; the framing is fact- and state-law-bound, so even a decision would reach few litigants beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Compensation for an alleged six-year municipal occupation raises meaningful property-rights and federal-forum stakes, but the vehicle centers on one owner's litigation history and Oklahoma's savings statute rather than a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound, local takings dispute over a temporary barrier fence; unlikely to have national significance.

Catherine Elizabeth Chollet v. United StatesTwo Missouri tax attorneys convicted of tax crimes in North Carolina ask the Court to send their case back for a new look at where they could be tried.awaiting the Court
0.10
0.28
0.12
0.17

Catherine Elizabeth Chollet, aka Liza Chollet, and Michael Elliot Kohn v. United StatesNo. 26-516 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000516 · models differ by up to 0.18

Two Missouri tax attorneys convicted of tax crimes in North Carolina ask the Court to send their case back for a new look at where they could be tried.

What happened

Michael Kohn and Catherine Chollet, Missouri tax attorneys, were convicted in the Western District of North Carolina of conspiracy and of aiding false tax returns, based on a tax strategy they marketed to clients, most of whom lived in North Carolina. They argued at trial and on appeal that they prepared and filed every return from Missouri, so North Carolina was the wrong place to try them. The Fourth Circuit affirmed, pointing to conduct in North Carolina by clients, an insurance agent, and his office manager, plus acts supporting a related scheme. Two days later, the Supreme Court decided a different case, Abouammo, addressing where criminal venue lies. The Fourth Circuit denied rehearing without addressing it.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether, in light of its intervening ruling limiting criminal trials to places where a defendant's own conduct making up the crime occurred, the Fourth Circuit should reconsider whether Missouri-based tax preparers could be tried in North Carolina based on other people's actions there and on acts tied to a separately charged scheme.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, and the docket shows no action on it since.

What each outcome would mean

Kohn and Chollet, who lost below, are asking the Court to send their case back to the Fourth Circuit for reconsideration under the new venue ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it could vacate the Fourth Circuit's decision and return the case for the lower court to reconsider venue, deciding nothing itself about who should win. If the Court denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's ruling upholding their convictions and North Carolina venue stands.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 1, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Catherine Elizabeth Chollet's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Catherine Elizabeth Chollet's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 10%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Two Missouri tax lawyers convicted in North Carolina ask the Supreme Court to send their case back to the appeals court. Their argument is that a June 2026 Supreme Court decision on venue (the rule about where a crime may be tried) undercuts the reasoning that kept their trial in North Carolina. We think the Court will most likely refuse: about a one-in-ten chance it sends the case back. The appeals court already saw that decision when it refused to rehear the case, and the government did not even file a response.

    Why this big-case score: A fact-bound GVR request applying Abouammo's venue rule to one tax-preparer prosecution; consequential for two defendants, little reach beyond them.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 12%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal; I put the chance of any favorable review at about one in eight. Two tax lawyers argue that a new Supreme Court decision requires another look at where they could lawfully be tried. But their tax offenses involve different conduct, the appeals court already had a chance to reconsider, and the government waived its response. If the Court intervenes, it will probably send the case back for reconsideration rather than hear full arguments.

    Why this big-case score: Criminal venue protects an important constitutional right and the challenged convictions affect substantial prison sentences, but this petition seeks a narrow, case-specific remand applying an existing decision to tax-preparer offenses.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will deny review in *Chollet v. United States*, giving the petition only a 3% chance of being granted. Two Missouri tax attorneys convicted in North Carolina of helping prepare false tax returns ask the Court to send their case back to the Fourth Circuit (`vacate and remand`) under *Abouammo v. United States* (2026), a recent decision on where criminal trials may be held (`venue`). Denial is very likely because the federal government waived its response, the Fourth Circuit already rejected this argument on rehearing, and the attorneys directed tax advice and documents into North Carolina.

    Why this big-case score: Narrow, fact-intensive GVR petition seeking application of Abouammo v. United States, 608 U.S. 597 (2026), to multi-district venue in a 26 U.S.C. § 7206(2) false-tax-return prosecution; limited doctrinal reach and low public salience beyond the parties.

Campo v. Uber TechnologiesThe Court declined to hear a wrongful death case in which Molina's estate sought to revive claims against Uber dismissed without a jury trial.Civil proceduredecided
0.05
0.28
—
0.17 2 of 3 models

Yesit Campo, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Arlevys Molina, et al. v. Uber Technologies, Inc., et al.No. 25-1292 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73363395 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a wrongful death case in which Molina's estate sought to revive claims against Uber dismissed without a jury trial.

What happened

Arlevys Molina was struck and killed by a rideshare driver, Orlando Baez Castillo, who was working with Uber Technologies and related Rasier entities. Molina's estate, represented by Yesit Campo, sued Castillo and the Uber companies for wrongful death. A Florida trial court granted summary judgment for Uber and the Rasier entities, ending the case against them before trial. Florida's Third District Court of Appeal affirmed that ruling, and the Florida Supreme Court declined to take up the case further.

What the Court is being asked

The estate asks the Court to decide whether ending its case against Uber and the Rasier companies by summary judgment, rather than letting a jury hear the evidence and draw its own conclusions from it, violated the estate's right to a jury trial and to fair legal process.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, and the Court denied it on October 24, 2025 (though the docket's final entry records the denial as issued October 5, 2026). Uber waived its right to file a response before the case was decided.

What each outcome would mean

Campo, representing Molina's estate, asked the Court to take up the case. A grant would have meant the Court would fully hear the case and decide whether the estate's jury-trial and due-process claims should proceed, without yet deciding who is right. The denial instead leaves the Florida courts' rulings in place: the summary judgment for Uber and the Rasier companies stands, and the estate's claims against them remain dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single Florida wrongful-death vicarious-liability dispute; the jury-right framing is foreclosed and would affect no one beyond these parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fatal-accident suit implicates rideshare accountability and civil jury access, but the presented questions focus on this evidentiary record rather than a developed nationwide conflict. A broad constitutional ruling would matter well beyond these parties.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine civil procedure challenge to state court evidentiary rulings with no broad impact.

F.E.B. Corp. v. United StatesThe Supreme Court declined to review a company's bid to overturn a ruling that the United States, not the company, owns Wisteria Island near Key West.Civil proceduredecided
0.12
0.27
0.10
0.16

F.E.B. Corp. v. United StatesNo. 25-1294 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73364890 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Civil procedure (also Environment, energy & property)

The Supreme Court declined to review a company's bid to overturn a ruling that the United States, not the company, owns Wisteria Island near Key West.

What happened

F.E.B. Corp. and the United States have fought for years over who owns Wisteria Island, land created from dredged material dumped off Key West in the 1920s and 1940s. A federal law gives states title to such coastal lands unless the United States built them up for its own use. After an earlier appeal sent the case back for trial, a district court found the United States intentionally created the island for naval purposes, including storing dredge spoils, protecting the harbor, and future military development. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that decision, applying a deferential standard of review to the trial court's factual findings. F.E.B. then asked the Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

F.E.B. asked the Court to decide how closely appeals courts should scrutinize a trial court's factual findings when those findings rest entirely on historical documents rather than witness testimony or credibility judgments. F.E.B. argued that appeals courts should examine such findings more critically than the usual deferential review, and that the lower court wrongly accepted a merely "plausible" reading of the evidence instead of applying tougher scrutiny.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The Court distributed the case for its September 28, 2026 conference and denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

F.E.B., which lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up its case. The denial leaves the Eleventh Circuit's ruling in place, meaning the United States keeps title to Wisteria Island and the deferential standard of review the appeals court applied to the trial court's findings remains unchanged. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision standing without further review.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A quiet-title fight over one 25-acre spoil island off Key West; the only question of general reach is a Rule 52(a) standard-of-review point that Anderson settled forty years ago, so even a decision would be procedural and narrow.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.27·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The immediate dispute concerns title to Wisteria Island, but a ruling changing appellate review of documentary factfinding could affect civil bench trials broadly. The supplied petition does not establish a nationwide conflict or wider present controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Wain v. Kimberly Nell BunnellThe Supreme Court declined to hear a Kentucky couple's bid to sue two state judges over rulings in their foreclosure case.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.12
0.35
0.01
0.16

Douglas Wain, et ux. v. Kimberly Nell Bunnell, Chief Regional Judge, 22nd Judicial Circuit Division 9, Fayette County, Kentucky, et al.No. 25-1271 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73318742 · models differ by up to 0.34 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a Kentucky couple's bid to sue two state judges over rulings in their foreclosure case.

What happened

Douglas and Elisa Wain lost a long-running foreclosure case in Kentucky state court. After unsuccessful state appeals and recusal requests, they sued the trial judge, Kimberly Bunnell, and an appeals judge, Jacqueline Caldwell, in federal court under a civil-rights law, alleging bias and due-process violations, including that Judge Bunnell ruled against them just days after being served with the lawsuit naming her as a defendant. The federal district court dismissed the suit, finding the judges protected by judicial immunity, a legal rule shielding judges from being sued over their official rulings. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed and upheld the dismissal.

What the Court is being asked

The Wains ask the Court to decide whether judicial immunity still protects a judge's ruling when that ruling comes soon after the judge was personally named as a defendant in a civil-rights lawsuit by the same people the ruling affects. They argue that due-process rules requiring judges to step aside when they have a personal stake in a case should limit immunity in that situation. The judges respond that the Wains never raised this specific argument in the lower courts and that established immunity rules fully cover the judges' actions.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Wains, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the Sixth Circuit's ruling. With the petition denied, the Sixth Circuit's decision stands: the lawsuit against Judges Bunnell and Caldwell remains dismissed, and the judges keep the benefit of judicial immunity from the Wains' claims. Had the Court instead granted the petition, it would have agreed to hear the case and decide the immunity question itself, without yet determining which side would ultimately prevail.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The abstract question (whether Caperton/Williams due-process limits carve into absolute judicial immunity) would matter if decided, but this vehicle is a pro se, official-capacity suit independently barred by the Eleventh Amendment and section 1983's injunction proviso, so any decision here would be narrow and little-watched.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision creating a due-process exception to judicial damages immunity would affect judicial accountability nationally. The presented dispute nevertheless concerns an individual foreclosure and overlapping immunity and preservation obstacles, rather than a demonstrated conflict among appellate courts.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine pro se civil rights action seeking to circumvent absolute judicial immunity.

Tomasa Gabriella Bolanos-Reynoso v. Department of AgricultureThe Court declined to hear a former federal employee's bid to revive her whistleblower retaliation claim against the Department of Agriculture.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.10
0.28
0.10
0.16

Tomasa Gabriella Bolanos-Reynoso v. Department of AgricultureNo. 25-1289 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73358594 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear a former federal employee's bid to revive her whistleblower retaliation claim against the Department of Agriculture.

What happened

Bolanos-Reynoso, a longtime federal employee, raised concerns about financial mismanagement at the Department of Agriculture's civil rights office. She says she was then demoted and given a poor performance rating in retaliation. She pursued relief through the Merit Systems Protection Board, which denied her claim, finding she lacked a reasonable belief she had disclosed a violation of law, rule, or regulation. She argues the Board never separately analyzed whether her disclosures also showed gross mismanagement, a second, distinct category the whistleblower law protects. The Federal Circuit affirmed without issuing a written opinion and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a federal employee who reports wrongdoing that could fall into two separate protected categories under the whistleblower law is entitled to have the review board actually decide both, rather than rule only on one and treat that as resolving the whole claim.

Where it stands

The Department of Agriculture waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Bolanos-Reynoso asked the Court to take up her case. With the petition denied, the Federal Circuit's decision affirming the Board's ruling against her stands, and her whistleblower retaliation claim does not proceed further in the courts. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that outcome in place without the Court deciding the underlying question about whether both disclosure categories must be addressed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single federal employee's WPA reprisal appeal from a nonprecedential Rule 36 affirmance, with no circuit conflict alleged; even a grant would yield at most a narrow procedural remand.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential for federal whistleblower adjudication, but this petition principally concerns an alleged omission in one employee's administrative review rather than a demonstrated categorical limitation on the statute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine whistleblower dispute over MSPB procedures with no broad national impact.

Myslow v. United StatesThe Court declined to hear an Air Force officer's bid to let military appeals courts review a post-conviction firearms ban attached to his court-martial judgment.Criminal lawdecided
0.12
0.30
0.05
0.16

Parker C. Myslow v. United StatesNo. 25-1148 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73281677 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Criminal law (also Firearms)

The Court declined to hear an Air Force officer's bid to let military appeals courts review a post-conviction firearms ban attached to his court-martial judgment.

What happened

Parker Myslow, an Air Force second lieutenant, pleaded guilty at a court-martial to drug-related offenses and was sentenced to dismissal from service. Attached to his judgment was a document called a "First Indorsement," which stated that his convictions triggered a federal law barring him from possessing firearms. Myslow argued military appellate courts could review and correct that firearms determination, including an argument that it violated his Second Amendment rights. The Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals, following a prior ruling in another case, held that military appeals courts lack authority to review the indorsement because it is part of the judgment itself, not a later error in processing. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces denied further review, leaving that ruling in place.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a law giving military appeals courts power to fix errors occurring in a court-martial's processing after judgment also covers a firearms-ban notice attached to that same judgment, or whether that notice is instead considered part of the judgment and therefore outside the appeals courts' power to review.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Myslow asked the Court to overturn the ruling that military appeals courts cannot review his firearms ban. The United States, representing the government, opposed review, arguing the lower courts were correct and that other avenues exist to challenge or correct the firearms restriction. Because the Court denied the petition, the ruling that military appellate courts lack authority to review the firearms notice stands, and Myslow's case ends without that review. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower ruling was correct, only that it left it in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A military-justice jurisdiction question about Air Force post-judgment indexing paperwork, on a regulation the Air Force has since withdrawn; Second Amendment framing raises the stakes only slightly because the holding below is jurisdictional, not a ruling on section 922.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Military appellate access to relief from firearms indexing has meaningful constitutional stakes, but the question is a narrow procedural gateway involving an Air Force practice that both briefs say has been discontinued by a temporary memorandum.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A narrow question of military appellate procedure regarding firearm ban indorsements.

Child v. Unum Life Insurance Company of AmericaThe Supreme Court declined to hear Denise Child's bid to revive her long-term care insurance claim against Unum after lower courts ruled against her.Civil proceduredecided
0.10
0.32
0.05
0.16

Denise J. Child v. Unum Life Insurance Company of AmericaNo. 26-337 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000337 · models differ by up to 0.27 · topic: Civil procedure (also Business & finance)

The Supreme Court declined to hear Denise Child's bid to revive her long-term care insurance claim against Unum after lower courts ruled against her.

What happened

Denise Child, quadriplegic since 1980, enrolled in a group long-term care insurance policy through her employer in 2003 without Unum asking any health questions, under what is called "guaranteed issue" coverage. She paid premiums for eighteen years. When she filed a claim in 2021, Unum investigated her health history, determined her condition predated the policy's effective date, and denied the claim. A federal district court and the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals both ruled for Unum, holding that Iowa law did not require covering losses that existed before coverage began.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks whether a federal court handling a case under its diversity jurisdiction (hearing a state-law dispute because the parties are from different states) wrongly overrode Iowa's insurance regulations. Child argues Iowa rules bar an insurer from waiving health questions when issuing guaranteed-issue coverage and then investigating an applicant's health only after a claim is filed. She contends the lower court instead relied on a general legal doctrine, not grounded in Iowa law, to allow that after-the-fact investigation.

Where it stands

Unum waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Denise Child asked the Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Eighth Circuit's ruling in place, meaning Unum's denial of Child's claim stands and Child does not recover benefits under the policy. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    One insured's long-term-care claim under Iowa law; the guaranteed-issue/post-claims-underwriting question has some reach across NAIC-model states but no split, no federal interest, and little public profile.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential for guaranteed-issue long-term-care coverage under similar state insurance frameworks, but presented through one Iowa contract dispute with no demonstrated square split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Technical Erie doctrine and state insurance law dispute with no national profile.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single-insured diversity dispute over Iowa long-term-care insurance law; of interest to the guaranteed-issue LTC insurance niche, with no constitutional, federal-statutory, or split-resolving dimension.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Guaranteed-issue long-term-care coverage has meaningful consequences for disabled insureds and potentially wider relevance under similar state insurance rules, but this vehicle concerns an Iowa-law contract dispute rather than a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine diversity case regarding the interpretation of a state insurance contract and state statute, lacking broader national stakes.

Roofing Designs by JR v. Royal American ConstructionThe Court sent a contractor's lawsuit back to a lower court to be reconsidered under a new Supreme Court ruling on when bankruptcy disclosure mistakes bar later claims.Civil proceduredecided
0.08
0.28
0.10
0.15

Roofing Designs by JR, L.L.C., dba Roofing Designs v. Royal American Construction, Incorporated, et al.No. 25-1367 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500268 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court sent a contractor's lawsuit back to a lower court to be reconsidered under a new Supreme Court ruling on when bankruptcy disclosure mistakes bar later claims.

What happened

Roofing Designs sued, and was sued by, Royal American Construction over a construction project, also bringing in Hartford Fire Insurance as a third party. While that suit was pending, Roofing Designs filed for bankruptcy and listed its claim against Royal American as worth nothing, without mentioning its claim against Hartford at all. After the bankruptcy plan was approved, a federal district court ruled that Roofing Designs could not pursue its claims because its bankruptcy filings contradicted its litigation position, a result called judicial estoppel. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, and rehearing was denied.

What the Court is being asked

Roofing Designs asked the Court to hold its case until it decided a separate case, Keathley, about the standard for finding that a bankruptcy disclosure mistake was not innocent, and then to send this case back for another look under whatever rule Keathley set. Royal American and Hartford answered that Keathley did not adopt the rule Roofing Designs wanted and that the lower courts' findings already support the result under Keathley's standard.

Where it stands

The Supreme Court granted the petition, set aside the Fifth Circuit's judgment, and sent the case back to that court to reconsider in light of its recent decision in Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc.

What each outcome would mean

Roofing Designs, which lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to act. The Court's order does not decide who is right. It wipes out the Fifth Circuit's ruling against Roofing Designs and requires that court to re-examine the case using the standard set out in Keathley. Royal American and Hartford, who had the earlier victory, argued the same result should follow anyway; whether it does will now be decided again by the Fifth Circuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesSent it back (GVR)Oct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court sent it back for reconsideration (GVR). evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 75%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A two-party construction-subcontract dispute whose only live question is whether an unpublished Fifth Circuit judicial-estoppel ruling gets a GVR in light of Keathley; no new legal question, no institutional parties, no public stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 82%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The dispute affects bankruptcy disclosure and access to commercial claims, but this petition principally seeks application of an intervening precedent rather than a new nationwide rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 92%·Prediction: send it back for reconsideration (GVR)used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine petition likely to be GVR'd in light of the recently decided Keathley case; applies established law rather than breaking new ground.

Honeycutt v. JPMorgan Chase BankThe Supreme Court declined to hear a former employee's bid to revive her challenge to an arbitration award favoring her former employer, JPMorgan Chase.Business & financedecided
0.05
0.30
0.10
0.15

Patrice Honeycutt v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., et al.No. 25-1298 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73369988 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Business & finance

The Supreme Court declined to hear a former employee's bid to revive her challenge to an arbitration award favoring her former employer, JPMorgan Chase.

What happened

Patrice Honeycutt arbitrated an employment dispute with JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. and related entities. A first arbitration award for Chase was vacated on appeal because the arbitrator failed to make required disclosures. A second arbitration, before a different arbitrator, again resulted in an award for Chase. Honeycutt asked the Superior Court to set aside that award, citing arbitrator partiality, nondisclosure, and failure to apply the correct legal standard. The Superior Court confirmed the award, the California Court of Appeal affirmed, and the California Supreme Court denied further review. Honeycutt then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

Honeycutt's petition raises three questions: whether a court can uphold an arbitration award after acknowledging uncertainty over which law's standard of review applies, without resolving that uncertainty; whether a court can reject claims that an arbitrator was biased or failed to disclose conflicts without using an objective test for apparent bias; and whether fairness in adjudication requires a court to address information suggesting a lack of neutrality that surfaces during the proceedings, even if not raised as a formal claim.

Where it stands

Chase waived its right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Honeycutt, who lost in the California courts, asked the Supreme Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the California Court of Appeal's decision in place, meaning the arbitration award in favor of Chase remains confirmed. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private employment-arbitration dispute from an unpublished state intermediate-court opinion, with no circuit split alleged, no government party, no amici, and a waived response; stakes end with the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Arbitrator-disclosure and federal/state review standards have consequences for employment arbitration, but the petition presents an unpublished, fact-specific dispute without a developed interjurisdictional conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Acosta-Tapia v. BlancheThe Court declined to hear Rene Acosta-Tapia's challenge to a Ninth Circuit ruling against him.decided
0.25
—
0.05
0.15 2 of 3 models

Rene Acosta-Tapia v. Todd Blanche, Attorney GeneralNo. 26-79 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000079 · models differ by up to 0.20

The Court declined to hear Rene Acosta-Tapia's challenge to a Ninth Circuit ruling against him.

What happened

Rene Acosta-Tapia brought a case that reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which ruled against him on January 15, 2026. He asked the Ninth Circuit to reconsider, and it denied rehearing on February 26, 2026. Acosta-Tapia then asked the Supreme Court to review the decision. The respondent is Todd Blanche, the Attorney General, representing the federal government. The record here does not describe the underlying facts of the dispute beyond this procedural history.

What the Court is being asked

The record available here does not include the petition's questions presented, so the specific legal issue Acosta-Tapia asked the Court to decide is not described in this record.

Where it stands

The government waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's conference of September 28, 2026, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Acosta-Tapia, as petitioner, asked the Court to review the Ninth Circuit's decision against him. The Court's denial means it will not hear the case, and the Ninth Circuit's ruling against Acosta-Tapia stands as the final word in this litigation. A denial of this kind does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that decision in place without the Supreme Court deciding the underlying question itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Individual immigration petition for review dismissed in an unpublished CA9 memorandum; high personal stakes (removal) but low national significance absent a granted jurisdictional question.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗
  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Unpublished, fact-bound immigration dispute dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Low public salience, but the underlying question (how Riley v. Bondi's 30-day clock applies to reinstatement/withholding-only cases, and whether equitable tolling rescues petitions filed on the old understanding) affects a sizable class of noncitizens; a decision would matter to the immigration bar, not the front page.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The provisioned record contains no questions presented, petition text, or lower-court reasoning; the caption and procedural history do not establish the substantive stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine petition from a private party against the Attorney General where the SG waived response.

Stevens-Reynolds v. Wilshire InsuranceThe Court declined to hear a Louisiana policyholder's bid to revive her hurricane-damage insurance lawsuit after lower courts ruled against her.Civil proceduredecided
0.04
0.25
—
0.14 2 of 3 models

Diana Stevens-Reynolds v. Wilshire Insurance Company, et al.No. 26-87 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000087 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a Louisiana policyholder's bid to revive her hurricane-damage insurance lawsuit after lower courts ruled against her.

What happened

Diana Stevens-Reynolds sued Wilshire Insurance Company and IAT Insurance Group over damage to her rental properties and a motel caused by Hurricanes Laura and Delta. A federal district court ruled against her on several issues before trial, excluded her expert witness for failing to make required disclosures, and after a trial found Wilshire had not acted in bad faith in handling her claims. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed. Stevens-Reynolds then asked the Supreme Court to take up her case.

What the Court is being asked

Stevens-Reynolds asks the Court to decide whether courts can exclude a party's expert evidence over a discovery dispute without first deciding whether the violation was intentional or in bad faith, and without considering lighter penalties; whether a court can later grant judgment against a party on technical issues that the excluded expert evidence was needed to address; and whether courts must resolve conflicting evidence about whether required materials were actually turned over before imposing such a sanction. Wilshire responds that these arguments were not properly raised in the lower courts and that the rulings were correct.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026, and on November 9, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Stevens-Reynolds asked the Court to take up her case and reverse the Fifth Circuit's decision, which had upheld rulings in Wilshire's favor. With the petition denied, the Fifth Circuit's decision stands, leaving in place the exclusion of her expert evidence, the dismissal of her motel-related claims, and the trial court's finding that Wilshire did not act in bad faith. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning, only that it will not review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound pro se challenge to an expert-exclusion discovery sanction in a single hurricane-insurance dispute; no reach beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A rule governing case-ending expert exclusions could affect civil litigation nationally, but this petition arises from an individual insurance dispute and presents substantial preservation and record-specific vehicle problems.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine discovery sanction dispute in a private civil case; no broader public significance.

Merritt v. Texas Farm BureauThe Supreme Court declined to hear a former insurance agency manager's bid to revive his claim for unpaid overtime pay.decided
0.08
0.30
0.05
0.14

Jerry Merritt v. Texas Farm Bureau, et al.No. 26-6 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000006 · models differ by up to 0.25

The Supreme Court declined to hear a former insurance agency manager's bid to revive his claim for unpaid overtime pay.

What happened

Jerry Merritt worked as an agency manager for Texas Farm Bureau and related companies, classified as an independent contractor with full control over his schedule. After retiring, he sued under the Fair Labor Standards Act, claiming he was really an employee owed overtime pay. A trial court agreed he was an employee and found he worked 816 hours of overtime, but a jury decided the companies never knew, and had no reason to know, that he was working those extra hours. The trial court upheld that verdict, and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed, rejecting Merritt's argument that being allowed to work unlimited hours meant the companies automatically owed him overtime regardless of their knowledge.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a worker who is given free rein to work as many hours as he wants is automatically owed overtime pay for those hours, or whether the worker must separately prove his employer actually knew, or should have known, that he was working extra hours.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on October 9, 2026, and on October 13, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Merritt, the employee who asked the Court to take up his case, sought to overturn the Fifth Circuit's ruling in favor of the companies. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fifth Circuit's decision in place: the jury's verdict that the companies owed Merritt no overtime pay stands, and his lawsuit remains over. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single plaintiff's FLSA overtime claim after a jury verdict, on a knowledge requirement every circuit applies the same way; the question would matter broadly only if the Court took it, and nothing about this vehicle suggests it will.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The employer-knowledge requirement can affect overtime recovery in flexible or misclassified employment nationwide, but this individual insurance-manager dispute has a fact-dependent trial record and no demonstrated circuit split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine FLSA overtime dispute with no circuit split, turning on the application of the knowledge requirement to specific facts.

Becker v. United StatesA Navy lieutenant convicted of murdering his wife asks the Court to review whether excluding her texts about her mental health unfairly limited his defense.Criminal lawawaiting the Court
0.07
0.24
0.12
0.14

Craig R. Becker v. United StatesNo. 26-529 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000529 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Criminal law

A Navy lieutenant convicted of murdering his wife asks the Court to review whether excluding her texts about her mental health unfairly limited his defense.

What happened

Craig R. Becker, a Navy officer, was convicted by court-martial of premeditated murder in the death of his then-wife, who fell from a seventh-floor window in Belgium, along with related offenses. His defense was that she died by suicide. At trial, the military judge excluded text messages in which she described being "terrified" of losing her memory and mental faculties, ruling them hearsay and unfairly prejudicial. The Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals agreed those rulings were legal errors but still upheld the conviction, finding the messages only weakly relevant. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces declined to review the case further.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether excluding the wife's statements about her mental health from evidence violated Becker's constitutional right to present a full defense, particularly given that prosecutors were allowed to introduce their own evidence about her state of mind without similar restrictions.

Where it stands

The United States waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the justices' conference on December 4, 2026, which falls after the snapshot date, so the docket does not yet show any action taken at or after that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Becker, who lost in the military appellate courts, is asking the Court to take up his case and overturn his conviction. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the evidentiary exclusion violated his right to present a defense, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the military appeals court's decision upholding Becker's conviction and life sentence remains in place, and the case ends there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Becker's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Becker's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound evidentiary ruling in a single court-martial murder conviction; no broad doctrinal stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A grave individual criminal case raising the right to present a defense, but the question is a fact-specific application of settled evidentiary principles rather than an identified national rule conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    If decided, the case would clarify the application of Chambers/Holmes right-to-present-a-complete-defense principles to Military Rule of Evidence 403 exclusions of state-of-mind hearsay in courts-martial, a narrow evidentiary question of modest national salience beyond the military justice system.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.07·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely decline to hear this case — a grant is about a one-in-two-hundred chance. A Navy officer convicted by a military court of murdering his wife argues that the trial judge wrongly kept out her messages about fearing memory loss, which he says supported his suicide defense. The dispute turns on the particular evidence in one trial rather than a legal question dividing lower courts, and the government did not even file a response, which usually precedes a routine denial.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound evidentiary challenge to one court-martial murder conviction; no split, no amici, no broader rule at stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.24·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Craig Becker's request to review his murder conviction; I put the chance of review at about one in eighty, or 1.2%. He argues that excluding his wife's messages about her mental health undermined his defense that she died by suicide. The issue is serious, but the petition mainly challenges how established evidence rules were applied in this particular trial, rather than showing a clear disagreement among courts. The government has waived a response, and the Court has scheduled its first consideration for December 4.

    Why this big-case score: A life-without-parole murder conviction and the constitutional right to present a defense carry substantial individual stakes, but the petition concerns a fact-specific military evidentiary ruling rather than a demonstrated nationwide rule conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Lieutenant Craig Becker's request to review his Navy murder conviction, with less than a one-in-one-hundred chance (0.8%) of taking the case. Becker argues that the military trial judge violated his constitutional right to present a defense by excluding two ambiguous text messages from his late wife that he claimed suggested suicide, but the judge reasonably found from surrounding messages that she was actually expressing fear of Becker's own abuse. Because the case involves a routine, fact-specific evidence ruling rather than a disagreement among lower courts, and the federal government waived its right to file a response, the Court will almost certainly turn the appeal away without comment.

    Why this big-case score: Factbound court-martial M.R.E. 403 dispute over excluding two ambiguous text messages in an individual murder trial, with modest doctrinal interest only because it invokes post-FY2024 NDAA certiorari jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1259(3) over an unreviewed CAAF denial.

Kamani v. StoneThe Court declined to hear a pet owner's bid to revive emotional-distress and fraud claims against a veterinary clinic over her dog's death.First Amendmentdecided
0.04
0.18
0.20
0.14

Moneesha Kamani v. Michael A. Stone, DVM, and His Marital Community/Domestic Partnership, et al.No. 25-1285 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73344703 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: First Amendment

The Court declined to hear a pet owner's bid to revive emotional-distress and fraud claims against a veterinary clinic over her dog's death.

What happened

Moneesha Kamani's dog died after being treated and repeatedly discharged by a Washington veterinary clinic, Animal Emergency and Specialty Center, and its veterinarian, Michael A. Stone. Kamani sued, alleging intentional infliction of emotional distress and fraud, pointing to altered medical records and a letter from the clinic threatening criminal and civil action if she posted negative reviews. A trial court dismissed these claims at summary judgment, meaning it found no factual dispute requiring a trial. The Washington Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Washington Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

Kamani asks the Court to decide two things: first, whether courts may treat threats of criminal charges and lawsuits used to silence someone's social media posts as legally unimportant, despite free-speech protections and state laws shielding public commentary from retaliatory suits; and second, whether a court may dismiss a case before trial by brushing aside evidence in the record and applying legal requirements that do not otherwise exist.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Kamani, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up her case. The denial means the Court will not review the matter, so the Washington Court of Appeals' decision affirming dismissal of her claims stands. This is not a ruling that the lower court's reasoning was correct; it simply leaves that decision in place. The clinic and Stone, who prevailed below, keep that result, and the case does not proceed further in the courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private pet-owner's intentional-tort suit against a veterinary clinic, arriving from an unpublished Washington Court of Appeals opinion with no amici and no organized interest; the questions presented are fact-bound and the case would matter to almost no one beyond the parties even if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition raises potentially broader questions about threats aimed at consumer reviews, but presents them through an unpublished, fact-intensive state tort dispute involving veterinary care rather than a clean national speech-law conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private dispute from a state court over the application of state anti-SLAPP laws and First Amendment protections; lacks broad national significance.

Wilson v. Charles Randall WattsThe Court declined to hear a disbarred lawyer's bid to overturn a punitive damages judgment that Alabama's courts upheld without a written opinion.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.05
0.22
0.15
0.14

Robert T. Wilson, Jr. v. Charles Randall Watts, et al.No. 25-1304 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73378855 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a disbarred lawyer's bid to overturn a punitive damages judgment that Alabama's courts upheld without a written opinion.

What happened

Robert T. Wilson, Jr., a disbarred lawyer, was sued by Charles Randall Watts after Wilson took trust funds meant for Watts, and by Mark E. Wilson over an unrelated loan. A jury awarded Watts $200,000 in compensatory damages and $800,000 in punitive damages, and awarded Mark Wilson a separate judgment. Wilson asked the trial court to reduce the punitive award as excessive; the court held a hearing and denied the request. The Alabama Supreme Court affirmed without issuing a written opinion, citing a rule allowing affirmance when an opinion would serve no significant precedential purpose.

What the Court is being asked

The case asks whether a state supreme court violates a losing party's right to fair legal process by affirming a large punitive damages award without writing an opinion explaining why the award meets constitutional limits, and whether the lack of a detailed, reasoned explanation at each stage of the case amounted to a denial of fair process.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Wilson, the disbarred lawyer, asked the Court to take the case and overturn the Alabama Supreme Court's unexplained affirmance of the punitive damages award. Mark Wilson, a respondent, opposed review, while Watts did not file a brief opposing it. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Alabama Supreme Court's affirmance in place, meaning the $800,000 punitive damages award against Wilson stands as upheld without further review by the Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private two-party dispute over an $800,000 punitive award against a disbarred lawyer for converting trust funds; no split, no government party, no amici, pro se petition. Denial would draw no attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional requirement for reasoned state appellate review of punitive damages could affect civil litigation broadly, but this petition arises from an individual trust-fund dispute and a record-specific disagreement about review already supplied.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine challenge to a state court's affirmance of a punitive damages award without a written opinion; not a novel issue of law.

Rubicon Real Estate Holdings v. City of PontiacThe Supreme Court declined to hear a real estate developer's bid to revive constitutional claims against a city over delayed marijuana-business permits.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.06
0.30
0.05
0.14

Rubicon Real Estate Holdings, LLC, et al. v. City of Pontiac, Michigan, et al.No. 26-359 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000359 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to hear a real estate developer's bid to revive constitutional claims against a city over delayed marijuana-business permits.

What happened

Rubicon Real Estate Holdings bought a Pontiac, Michigan property hoping to lease it to medical marijuana businesses. The city rezoned the property, but the city clerk delayed approving licenses for Rubicon's prospective tenants, who eventually walked away, collapsing the deal. Rubicon, along with its manager Joseph Brown and his separate design company, sued the city and the clerk, also claiming the city retaliated against Brown's design business after Rubicon sued. A federal district court granted summary judgment to the city and clerk on all claims, and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, finding no constitutional violation.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide whether the lower court was wrong to reject the developer's claims that the city's delays violated its property rights, denied it fair procedures, amounted to arbitrary government conduct, took its property without compensation, and unlawfully retaliated against it for suing the city.

Where it stands

The city waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and the Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Rubicon and its co-plaintiffs, as petitioners, asked the Court to overturn the Sixth Circuit's ruling in favor of Pontiac and the city clerk. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Sixth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the lower courts' dismissal of all the developer's claims stands and the case is over. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound local zoning and licensing dispute over medical-marijuana facilities in one Michigan city; the constitutional theories are framed as error correction, so even a decision would carry little beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The asserted interference with land development and retaliation for litigation raise meaningful property and speech interests, but the presented dispute depends heavily on local licensing rules, particular delays, and municipal policymaking authority rather than a clearly demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An unpublished local property dispute over takings and due process. Very low stakes.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound dispute between a private developer and one city over permitting delays for a medical-marijuana project; the legal doctrines (due process, takings, First Amendment retaliation, Monell) are applied, not unsettled.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Meaningful property-rights and retaliation issues arising from a failed local development, with potential implications for municipal liability; the fact-bound licensing dispute and diffuse questions limit broader significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Venkatraman v. Bank of AmericaA man who lost money to scammers asks the Court to revive his lawsuit against Bank of America over how courts decided the bank owed him no duty.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.04
0.32
0.05
0.14

Venky Venkatraman v. Bank of America, N.A.No. 26-367 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000367 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Business & finance

A man who lost money to scammers asks the Court to revive his lawsuit against Bank of America over how courts decided the bank owed him no duty.

What happened

Venky Venkatraman alleges he was tricked by scammers into depositing $94,345 in money orders and cashier's checks into Bank of America accounts controlled by third parties in January 2023. Bank of America returned about $26,000 but not the rest. He sued in Texas state court; the bank moved the case to federal court. The district court dismissed his claims, allowed one amendment, then dismissed the amended complaint with prejudice, finding the bank owed him no legal duty and that his fraud, contract, and consumer-protection claims were inadequately pleaded. The Fifth Circuit affirmed, holding that banks owe no duty to prevent third parties from using their own accounts for fraud, regardless of Venkatraman's long customer history with the bank or its later efforts to help him recover funds.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a bank can be automatically cleared of any duty-of-care question simply because fraud proceeds passed through accounts titled to other people, even when the person harmed is the bank's own longtime customer and points to the bank's control over those accounts, possible warning signs, and its later partial repayment.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take the case.

What each outcome would mean

Venkatraman, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to fully hear the case and decide the legal question; granting review does not decide who is right. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's ruling affirming dismissal of Venkatraman's claims with prejudice stays in place, and Bank of America's win below stands, ending his lawsuit.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Venkatraman's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Venkatraman's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly decline to hear this case, with a chance of well under one in a hundred. A Texas man who was scammed into depositing about $94,000 into fraudsters' Bank of America accounts sued the bank and lost. The appeals court held that, under Texas law, a bank owes no duty to someone who is not the customer on the account in question. The Supreme Court rarely reviews questions of state law. No other court has disagreed with the ruling, the decision was unpublished, and the bank has not even filed a response.

    Why this big-case score: Single-plaintiff Texas-law bank negligence claim over ~$68,000; no federal question, no split, unpublished summary-calendar ruling.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal; I put the chance of taking action in the petitioner's favor at about one in 250, or 0.4%. The case concerns whether Bank of America owed a duty to a longtime customer who sent money to scammers' accounts. Although fraud prevention matters widely, the petition mainly challenges how Texas law was applied to an individual complaint, without showing a clear disagreement among courts. A refusal to hear it would not endorse the bank's conduct.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially important to fraud victims and receiving banks, but this vehicle concerns Texas tort duties and a thin individual pleading record rather than a nationwide federal liability rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny review in *Venky Venkatraman v. Bank of America, N.A.*, with a grant probability of 0.2% (about one in five hundred). After scammers persuaded Venkatraman to deposit $94,345 into third-party accounts at Bank of America, lower federal courts dismissed his lawsuit under settled Texas state law holding that banks owe no legal duty of care to protect people who deposit money into strangers' accounts. Because this case involves a routine state-law dispute decided in a non-binding opinion without any disagreement among lower courts—and Bank of America did not even file a response—the Justices have no reason to take it up.

    Why this big-case score: Routine diversity tort dispute applying settled Texas law on bank duties regarding deposits into third-party accounts; unpublished summary-calendar per curiam opinion with no circuit split.

Saeed v. ArizonaA doctor convicted of fraud and sex offenses after a second trial asks the Court to take up his claim that the retrial violated double jeopardy protections.Habeas & post-convictionawaiting the Court
0.04
0.32
0.05
0.14

Muhammad Saeed v. ArizonaNo. 26-512 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000512 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

A doctor convicted of fraud and sex offenses after a second trial asks the Court to take up his claim that the retrial violated double jeopardy protections.

What happened

Muhammad Saeed, a physician, was tried on charges including fraudulent schemes, sexual abuse and assault, and prescription-fraud counts. A jury acquitted him of the prescription-fraud counts but could not reach a verdict on the remaining counts. At a second trial on those remaining counts, Saeed argued the state improperly relied on the same prescription-practice evidence and theories the first jury had rejected. He was convicted on all remaining counts. Before sentencing, he asked the trial court to vacate the judgment on double jeopardy grounds; the court denied the motion. The Arizona Court of Appeals dismissed his appeal for lack of jurisdiction, reasoning no sentence had yet been entered, and the Arizona Supreme Court denied review.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide whether a defendant who has been found guilty by a jury, but not yet sentenced, can immediately seek federal court review of a claim that the prosecution improperly reused issues an earlier jury had already resolved in his favor, rather than having to wait until after sentencing and a full appeal. It also asks whether a conviction obtained that way can be treated as invalid even before any sentence is imposed.

Where it stands

The state waived its right to respond to the petition. The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of December 4, 2026, and the docket does not yet show any action taken at or after that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Saeed, the convicted defendant, is asking the Court to take up his case; Arizona, which won below, opposes review. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear full briefing and argument on whether defendants in Saeed's situation may seek immediate federal court review before sentencing, and decide the question on the merits. If the Court denies the petition, the Arizona Court of Appeals' dismissal stands, Arizona's position prevails, and Saeed's double jeopardy claim would need to proceed through any ordinary sentencing and appeal process instead.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 10, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Saeed's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Saeed's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single state defendant's request to extend Abney-style interlocutory double-jeopardy review to a post-verdict, pre-sentence window; narrow procedural question with no split alleged and little reach beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.26·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect the timing of constitutional double-jeopardy challenges by state defendants, but this petition presents a narrow post-verdict, presentence setting with substantial finality and vehicle obstacles rather than a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An obscure state criminal case with procedural and jurisdictional flaws; unlikely to draw national attention.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly turn this case down. The chance it agrees to hear it is well under one in a hundred. Muhammad Saeed, convicted in Arizona but not yet sentenced, argues his trial broke the rule against being tried twice for the same thing. Arizona did not bother to respond. The appeal comes up before the case has finished in the state courts, and it does not point to courts disagreeing on the issue. Those are two of the things the Justices look for before agreeing to hear a case.

    Why this big-case score: Single-defendant state criminal case (DUI-practice counsel) seeking an idiosyncratic interlocutory double-jeopardy remedy; narrow stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.32·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Muhammad Saeed's request for review; I put the chance it takes the case at about one in one hundred. He argues that protections against being tried twice should allow immediate relief after a guilty verdict but before sentencing. His case, however, comes through a disputed state procedure rather than a federal challenge to detention, and he has not been sentenced because of his continued absence. Those complications make this a poor case for deciding a broader constitutional rule.

    Why this big-case score: A new posttrial, presentence route to federal double-jeopardy relief would matter to criminal procedure, but this petition arises from an unusually tangled individual prosecution.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will **deny** Muhammad Saeed's petition for review, with a **less than one in a hundred (0.5%)** chance of a grant. After a first jury acquitted Saeed of prescription-drug fraud charges but could not reach a verdict on sexual-assault and fraudulent-scheme charges, a second jury convicted him of the remaining counts while he remained outside the country, and Arizona appellate courts dismissed his pre-sentencing appeal for lack of jurisdiction because he has not yet been sentenced. The Supreme Court almost never reviews state criminal cases that lack a final sentence, present no conflict among lower courts, and have seen the state waive its response.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound state criminal issue-preclusion dispute arising in an unappealable pre-sentence posture with an absent defendant, no circuit split, and a misframed § 2241 habeas question on direct review.

James C. "Chris" McNeil, et al. v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyTwo self-represented former tenants ask the Court to review South Carolina's refusal to let them use electronic court filing in their landlord dispute.Constitutional rightsawaiting the Court
0.03
0.35
0.02
0.13

James C. "Chris" McNeil, et al. v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyNo. 26-562 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000562 · models differ by up to 0.33 · topic: Constitutional rights

Two self-represented former tenants ask the Court to review South Carolina's refusal to let them use electronic court filing in their landlord dispute.

What happened

James McNeil and Meaghan Poyer, representing themselves, sued their former landlord and property managers in South Carolina state court over a security deposit, lease issues, and related claims. Because South Carolina's electronic filing system is limited to licensed attorneys, they had to file paper documents by hand, which they say were scanned into lower-quality, non-searchable images that degraded photo evidence central to their privacy claims. The trial court eventually dismissed their case entirely as a sanction for what it found to be abusive and frivolous filings. The South Carolina Supreme Court separately declined to order the trial court to rule faster on their motions. McNeil and Poyer then petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court, naming the circuit court as respondent.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether it violates constitutional guarantees of fair treatment and equal legal process for a state court system to let only lawyers file documents electronically, while requiring people representing themselves to file paper copies that come out lower-quality once scanned into the court record.

Where it stands

The petition was filed on August 19, 2026, and docketed on October 28, 2026. The respondent's response is due November 27, 2026; the Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

McNeil and Poyer, as petitioners, are asking the Court to take up their case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the electronic-filing rule violates their constitutional rights, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies review, the South Carolina Supreme Court's decision not to intervene in the filing dispute stands, and the underlying case dismissal remains as decided by the South Carolina courts, leaving McNeil and Poyer without further recourse in this proceeding.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 27, 2026

If the Court takes the case: briefing, argument, and a decision follow. · If the Court turns it down: the lower court's ruling stands.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will almost certainly turn this case down (about a 3-in-1,000 chance it agrees to hear it). Self-represented litigants are challenging a South Carolina county court's rule that lets only lawyers file electronically. However, the decision they appeal is only the state supreme court declining to order the trial judge to act, because a hearing was already scheduled. That is not a final ruling on their constitutional claim. The issue is also local, with no conflict among courts.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se challenge to one county's attorney-only e-filing access, arising from a state supreme court's refusal to entertain mandamus; narrow, local, interlocutory.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.35·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; the chance of accepting it is about three in a thousand. The petition argues that people without lawyers receive inferior treatment because they cannot file electronically and their paper evidence loses quality when scanned. That concern could matter widely. But the state ruling being challenged declined an emergency request to force action, rather than deciding the electronic-filing question. Those procedural obstacles make this a poor case for resolving the broader issue.

    Why this big-case score: A constitutional decision on unequal electronic filing and preservation of self-represented litigants' evidence could affect many state courts, although this petition arises from a narrow mandamus proceeding in a private civil dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny this petition (about a 99.8% chance of denial or dismissal, and only a 0.2% chance of review). The petitioners, representing themselves without a lawyer in a South Carolina landlord-tenant dispute, asked the state supreme court for an extraordinary order (a writ of mandamus) to force the trial court to rule on their motions and allow them to file documents electronically in color rather than on paper. Because the state supreme court declined that request on routine state procedural grounds—noting a trial hearing was already scheduled—and the trial court has since dismissed the entire lawsuit for litigation misconduct, the U.S. Supreme Court has no reason or clear legal basis to step in.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se state-court procedural dispute arising out of a residential security-deposit and landlord-tenant lawsuit dismissed under state Rule 11; minimal broader legal or public significance even if reached.

Hameed v. Drug Enforcement AdministrationA physician whose DEA registration was revoked asks the Court to review whether the agency ever made the legally required decision on his proposed corrective action plan.awaiting the Court
0.08
0.25
0.06
0.13

Haroon I. Hameed v. Drug Enforcement Administration, et al.No. 26-561 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000561 · models differ by up to 0.19

A physician whose DEA registration was revoked asks the Court to review whether the agency ever made the legally required decision on his proposed corrective action plan.

What happened

Haroon Hameed, a pain physician, faced a DEA proceeding to revoke his controlled-substance registration based on findings that he abused drugs and alcohol while treating patients. He waived a hearing, accepted responsibility, and proposed a monitoring plan as his corrective action plan, asking DEA to defer proceedings while discussing changes to it. A DEA division official's letter denied the request while calling itself a "limited, preliminary determination," saying the agency's Administrator would later issue the final decision. More than three years later, the Administrator's final order revoked Hameed's registration, mentioning the plan only once. The D.C. Circuit denied his petition for review in an unpublished decision, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The case concerns a law requiring the Attorney General to actually decide whether a revocation proceeding should be stopped or paused so a registrant's proposed corrective plan can be revised. The Court is asked whether that requirement was satisfied here, given that the only response to the plan came from a lower official in a letter the agency itself called preliminary, and the final order never took up the plan itself.

Where it stands

The federal government, representing the Drug Enforcement Administration, waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it up.

What each outcome would mean

Hameed, who lost below, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments on whether the agency satisfied the law's requirement to decide on his corrective action plan, without yet deciding who is right. If the Court denies review, the D.C. Circuit's decision upholding the revocation of Hameed's registration would stand, and the case would end there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Hameed's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Hameed's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly decline to hear this case — the chance it takes it is well under one in a hundred. A doctor is challenging the DEA's revocation of his licence to prescribe controlled substances, arguing the agency never properly ruled on his plan to fix the problems. The lower court's ruling was brief and unpublished, no other courts disagree on the issue, and the government did not even file a response. Expect a denial in early December with no Justice writing separately.

    Why this big-case score: First-impression reading of a 2016 CSA procedural provision touching all DEA registrants, but arising from one physician's fact-bound revocation with an unpublished judgment, no split and no amici.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I put the chance of any grant of review at about one in a hundred. A physician argues that the drug-enforcement agency failed to make a required decision about his proposed rehabilitation plan before revoking his registration. That raises a potentially important procedural question, but the lower court issued an unpublished ruling, and the petition identifies no disagreement among appeals courts. I expect a routine denial, without further conference consideration or a separate judicial explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially consequential procedural protection across DEA registration proceedings, but a narrow statutory question arising from one physician's fact-specific, unpublished loss.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court is **very unlikely** to hear this case, denying review with **99.2% probability** (less than a **1 in 100** chance of a grant). A pain-management physician whose federal drug-prescribing registration was revoked after practicing while impaired argues that the Drug Enforcement Administration never issued a proper final ruling on his proposed rehabilitation plan before ending his registration. Although the petition raises a clear procedural question, no federal appeals courts disagree on this rule, a three-judge D.C. Circuit panel unanimously rejected the claim in a brief non-binding order, the federal government waived its right to respond, and the agency independently revoked his registration for failing to take full responsibility for his misconduct.

    Why this big-case score: Routine individual DEA practitioner registration revocation affirmed in an unpublished Rule 36 order; narrow procedural question under 21 U.S.C. § 824(c)(3) affecting DEA show-cause practice with low public salience.

White v. U.S. Bank National AssociationThe Supreme Court declined to review a homeowner's challenge to a Washington state court ruling that reformed a deed of trust on his property through summary judgment rather than trial.Civil proceduredecided
0.12
0.25
0.01
0.13

Alvin B. White, Individually and as Trustee for the White Revocable Living Trust dated January 6, 2010 v. U.S. Bank National Association, as Legal Title Trustee for Truman 2016 SC6 Title TrustNo. 25-1310 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73392441 · models differ by up to 0.24 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to review a homeowner's challenge to a Washington state court ruling that reformed a deed of trust on his property through summary judgment rather than trial.

What happened

Alvin White owned residential property in Kitsap County, Washington, subject to a deed of trust. U.S. Bank Trust, N.A. sued to reform the deed, claiming its legal description was erroneous; U.S. Bank National Association later replaced it as plaintiff. The case went to cross-motions for summary judgment, where the trial judge examined a disputed promissory note, commented on its signatures and indentations, and found it appeared authentic, then ruled for the bank without a trial. White objected, arguing this resolved disputed facts without proper trial procedures. The Washington Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Washington Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

White asks the Court to decide whether a judge can resolve genuinely disputed facts about property rights, such as whether a document is authentic, by weighing evidence and making findings during summary judgment, rather than sending those disputes to a trial. He also asks whether doing so violates guarantees of fair procedure before property is taken and the right to a jury trial in certain civil cases.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

White, the homeowner, asked the Court to reverse the Washington Court of Appeals' decision, which had sided with U.S. Bank. By denying the petition, the Court leaves that lower court ruling in place: the reformation of the deed of trust and the judgment against White stand. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the trial court's procedure was constitutional; it simply leaves the state court decision undisturbed without the Court deciding the constitutional questions White raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The QP nominally asks whether summary judgment may resolve disputed facts at all, which would be sweeping if ever decided, but the concrete vehicle is a one-property Washington deed-of-trust reformation dispute in an unpublished state intermediate opinion; any realistic disposition is a denial or, at most, a narrow per curiam.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A broad constitutional limit on summary judgment would affect civil litigation nationally, but this petition presents that ambition through a private deed-of-trust reformation dispute and an unpublished state appellate decision. The score measures stakes, not grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An obscure, pro se-style petition over a state-court property dispute.

William David Jones v. Defense Supply CenterA former defense agency employee asked the Court to review his barment from a military installation, but the Court declined.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.06
0.25
0.05
0.12

William David Jones v. Defense Supply Center, Defense Logistics Agency, Richmond, VirginiaNo. 26-173 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000173 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Agencies & benefits

A former defense agency employee asked the Court to review his barment from a military installation, but the Court declined.

What happened

William David Jones, a former employee of the Defense Logistics Agency's Defense Supply Center in Richmond, was barred from the installation after an investigation into alleged threats against agency employees. He sued in federal district court under the law governing review of agency actions, arguing the agency's barment decision was unsupported and improperly reviewed. The district court ruled against him, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that decision. Jones, representing himself, then asked the Supreme Court to take up his case.

What the Court is being asked

Jones raised two issues. First, he argued the lower courts wrongly let the agency rely on documents outside the official record it had used to make its decision, when review of agency action is supposed to be limited to that original record. Second, he argued the military commander who barred him lacked authority to do so, since she stated under oath that he had broken no law and that she had no jurisdiction over him.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference in June 2026; a motion filed alongside it was denied. The agency waived its right to respond, the petition was distributed again for a later conference in September 2026, and the Supreme Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Jones, as the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Fourth Circuit's ruling against him. The Court's denial means it will not hear the case, leaving the Fourth Circuit's decision in place. That decision upheld the lower court's ruling against Jones and left his barment from the installation standing. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the lower courts were correct; it simply leaves their rulings as the final word in this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se APA challenge to one individual's installation debarment; the record-rule exceptions question is real in the abstract but this vehicle is fact-bound, unpublished below, and would set no rule of general application.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The APA record-supplementation question could affect judicial review across agencies, but this petition presents it through an individual military-installation debarment dispute with substantial factual and vehicle complications.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Quaid v. GranetThe Supreme Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive privacy claims over criminal-record disclosures made during a property dispute.Civil proceduredecided
0.04
0.22
0.10
0.12

Randy Quaid, et ux. v. Craig Granet, et al.No. 26-249 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000249 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive privacy claims over criminal-record disclosures made during a property dispute.

What happened

Randy and Evgenia Quaid sued several people and entities connected to a long-running dispute over Santa Barbara property, after a sheriff's employee allegedly accessed their criminal history records and the records were passed along to a prosecutor and then to private lawyers involved in related state litigation. A federal district court dismissed their claims, mainly on the ground that California's litigation privilege shields communications made in connection with judicial proceedings, and it also dismissed other claims on separate grounds, declared the Quaids vexatious litigants, and awarded costs. The Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that the claims "all stem" from obtaining and disclosing the records in court and that amendment would be futile.

What the Court is being asked

The Quaids ask the Court to decide whether a court may treat a legal privilege that shields litigation-related communications as also covering the earlier, separate act of improperly obtaining and routing restricted law-enforcement records, simply because those records were later used in a court filing, without separately examining whether that earlier conduct was unlawful on its own.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and on November 9, 2026 the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

The Quaids, as petitioners, asked the Court to take up and overturn the Ninth Circuit's ruling. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ninth Circuit's decision in place: the dismissal of the Quaids' privacy-related claims against the private parties and law firm respondents stands, and they may not amend their complaint to pursue those claims further. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Celebrity petitioner guarantees minor tabloid coverage, but the dispute is personal fact-bound litigation over a long-sold house with no doctrinal stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A private property-related dispute with a highly case-specific procedural history and no visible broader institutional stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition alleging misapplication of state litigation privilege; very low national significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound application of California's litigation privilege to one plaintiff's privacy claims, reviewed from an unpublished memorandum; the celebrity petitioner draws attention, but the legal stakes are low.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The boundary between litigation privilege and unauthorized acquisition of government-held personal information has meaningful privacy stakes, but the petition presents a narrow California-law dispute through an unpublished, fact-specific decision and a procedurally limited vehicle.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Foley v. Orange CountyThe Court declined to hear a Florida couple's bid to void a years-old judgment they said wrongly addressed a claim they never brought.Civil proceduredecided
0.03
0.22
0.10
0.12

David W. Foley, Jr., et ux. v. Orange County, Florida, et al.No. 25-1308 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73391039 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a Florida couple's bid to void a years-old judgment they said wrongly addressed a claim they never brought.

What happened

David and Jennifer Foley sued Orange County, Florida, and various officials over a dispute involving their toucan-breeding business and a permit enforcement action. A federal district court dismissed their complaint on grounds that it duplicated earlier litigation, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed. The Foleys then asked the district court to void that judgment, arguing it had actually decided a different claim than the one they pleaded. The district court denied that request, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed again, relying on its earlier ruling in the case to reject the challenge. The Eleventh Circuit also ordered the Foleys to pay the other side's attorney's fees for pursuing the appeal.

What the Court is being asked

The Foleys ask the Court to decide whether a rule allowing judges to void judgments that go beyond the claims a plaintiff actually raised can be sidestepped by a court's reliance on its own earlier ruling in the same case. They argue that once a prior ruling is challenged as having decided the wrong issue entirely, courts must examine that question directly rather than treating the earlier ruling as settling it automatically.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, after the opposing parties waived their right to respond. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Foleys asked the Court to hear their case. With the petition denied, the Eleventh Circuit's ruling against the Foleys stands: the original dismissal of their lawsuit remains in place, their later motion to void that judgment stays denied, and the fee award against them remains in effect. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that the case will not be reviewed further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se collateral attack on the dismissal of an eighteen-year-old local zoning dispute over an aviary and toucans; the Rule 60(b)(4) / law-of-the-case question affects nobody beyond the parties as framed.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect the boundary between void judgments and ordinary legal error across federal civil litigation, but this petition arises from a fact-specific, long-running local property dispute and presents no clearly demonstrated conflict on its precise procedural question.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly specific, fact-bound procedural dispute over FRCP 60(b)(4) with no significant legal implications.

Charles Kakembo Sessanga v. City of DeSoto Police DepartmentA man whose civil rights lawsuit over his criminal prosecution was dismissed before trial asks the Court to revive it.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.04
0.28
0.03
0.12

Charles Kakembo Sessanga v. City of DeSoto Police Department, et al.No. 26-378 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000378 · models differ by up to 0.25 · topic: Civil procedure (also Constitutional rights)

A man whose civil rights lawsuit over his criminal prosecution was dismissed before trial asks the Court to revive it.

What happened

Charles Kakembo Sessanga was prosecuted in Texas for a child sexual abuse charge and was acquitted by a jury; the criminal case was later expunged. He then sued the City of DeSoto's police department, several officers, and a prosecutor, representing himself, claiming they pursued the prosecution without probable cause and malicious intent. A federal magistrate judge recommended dismissing the case before any defendant was served, and the district court agreed, dismissing it with prejudice (meaning it cannot be refiled) and denying leave to amend. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that a grand jury's indictment generally shields officers from liability unless the plaintiff shows the process was tainted, and that the prosecutor was immune from suit.

What the Court is being asked

Sessanga asks the Court to decide whether courts can dismiss a civil-rights lawsuit filed by someone representing himself, at an early screening stage and before any fact-finding, for not including specific details that only the defendants would have access to. He also asks whether the rule shielding officers from liability when a grand jury indicts someone should still apply if the plaintiff claims officers withheld evidence or misled the prosecutor, and whether a prosecutor's offer of a lighter plea deal can count as evidence that the case lacked a solid basis.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on December 4, 2026. The docket does not yet show any action taken at or after that conference.

What each outcome would mean

Sessanga, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions he raises, without yet determining who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of Sessanga's lawsuit stays in place, and the case remains closed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Charles Kakembo Sessanga's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Charles Kakembo Sessanga's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case, at roughly a 1-in-125 chance of review. Mr. Sessanga, who is representing himself, sued police officers and a prosecutor after he was acquitted. The lower courts dismissed his complaint before any evidence-gathering. The appeals court's ruling was unpublished and turned on the specific facts. The other side has not filed a response, and the Court almost never takes a case without first asking for one. Expect a routine denial after the December 4 conference.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound pro se § 1983 malicious-prosecution dismissal from an unpublished per curiam; little reach beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case, with roughly a one-in-a-hundred chance of agreeing to review it. The petitioner says he was unfairly denied a chance to gather evidence for his police-misconduct lawsuit. But the appeals court's actual opinion allows such cases when supported by enough factual allegations; it found this complaint insufficient. That makes this look more like a dispute about this particular complaint than a clear disagreement between courts. Expect no further conference consideration or separate statement from a Justice.

    Why this big-case score: A ruling on pleading police misconduct before discovery could affect civil-rights litigation nationally, but this petition also presents substantial case-specific pleading and amendment questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in *Sessanga v. City of DeSoto Police Department* (about a 0.5% chance of a grant). Representing himself without a lawyer, the petitioner asks the Court to revive his civil-rights lawsuit alleging malicious prosecution after a Texas jury acquitted him of child-abuse charges. Both the federal trial court and the Fifth Circuit dismissed his suit before the defendants were even served because a grand jury indictment creates a legal presumption of probable cause (sufficient reason to bring charges), and his complaint pleaded no concrete facts showing that police misled the grand jury. Because the lower court's ruling is unpublished, applies settled pleading standards, and raises no genuine conflict among federal appeals courts, the Court is almost certain to deny the petition without further briefing.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se § 1983 malicious-prosecution screening dismissal with no genuine circuit split, institutional stakes, or broader legal significance beyond the individual dispute.

Hauber v. Honkamp Krueger &Ryan Hauber asked the Court to review his discovery-sanction case dismissal; the Court denied review, leaving the dismissal in place.decided
0.03
—
0.20
0.12 2 of 3 models

Ryan Hauber v. Honkamp Krueger & Co., P.C.No. 26-462 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000462 · models differ by up to 0.17

Ryan Hauber asked the Court to review his discovery-sanction case dismissal; the Court denied review, leaving the dismissal in place.

What happened

Ryan Hauber sued his former employer, Honkamp Krueger & Co., alleging disability and medical-leave discrimination. After his lawyer withdrew, Hauber represented himself and filed a motion asking the court to accommodate his PTSD. While that motion sat undecided, the district court dismissed his case with prejudice as a sanction for discovery violations, calling his noncompliance willful, and the accommodations motion was dismissed as moot along with everything else pending. The Eighth Circuit affirmed, and rehearing was denied. The district court later denied Hauber's motions to reopen the judgment.

What the Court is being asked

Hauber asked the Court to decide whether it violates basic fairness for a federal court to end a self-represented disabled litigant's case as a discovery sanction while his supported request for help participating in the case remains unresolved.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for conference twice, in September and again in November 2026, with a supplemental brief and a motion to delay consideration filed in between. The Court denied the petition on November 9, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Hauber, representing himself, asked the Court to take up his case and reverse the lower court's decision against him. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Eighth Circuit's ruling in place: Hauber's lawsuit against Honkamp Krueger remains dismissed with prejudice, and the question he raised about resolving accommodation requests before imposing case-ending sanctions goes undecided by the Court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se former employee's ADA suit against an Iowa accounting firm, dismissed with prejudice as a Rule 37(b)(2) discovery sanction (plus a $500 monetary sanction) and affirmed by the Eighth Circuit; a fact-bound sanctions appeal with no stakes beyond the parties and no question of general importance.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition's 46 pages yielded no readable text, no questions presented were provisioned, and the docket alone does not identify the legal issue or its broader stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An ADA claim by a private individual; likely fact-bound and low salience.

Dittmer v. DittmerThe Supreme Court declined to review a couple's challenge to Illinois protective orders they say violated their constitutional rights.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.03
0.30
0.01
0.11

Ronald Dittmer, et ux. v. Katie DittmerNo. 25-1245 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73291758 · models differ by up to 0.29 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to review a couple's challenge to Illinois protective orders they say violated their constitutional rights.

What happened

Katie Dittmer obtained orders of protection against her parents-in-law, Ronald and Irene Dittmer, under the Illinois Domestic Violence Act, after incidents including a prayer walk Irene took near Katie's home and emails Ronald sent to Katie and her husband. An Illinois circuit court found by a preponderance of the evidence that Ronald and Irene posed a risk of future harm and entered two-year protective orders, including surrender of firearms. The Appellate Court of Illinois affirmed, finding Ronald and Irene had not properly raised their constitutional arguments below. The Illinois Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

Ronald and Irene ask the Court to decide whether the protective orders against them improperly restricted their religious practice, speech, gun rights, due process, and equal protection. They also ask whether the Illinois Domestic Violence Act itself is unconstitutionally vague or broad, whether their trial lawyer's failure to raise these constitutional arguments should excuse not raising them earlier, and whether the state courts ignored evidence of procedural errors in handling their case.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Ronald and Irene, who lost in the Illinois courts, asked the Supreme Court to take their case. The denial means the Court will not review the matter, so the Illinois Appellate Court's decision upholding the protective orders against Ronald and Irene stands. Katie's position, which prevailed in the Illinois courts, remains in effect. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning, only that it left that decision in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition contesting two-year Illinois orders of protection arising from an intra-family dispute; no institutional party, no split, no rule of general application at stake.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.30·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision on constitutional limits to protective orders could affect religious expression, firearms restrictions, and civil protective-order practice beyond this family. The actual dispute is highly fact-specific and presents substantial preservation problems; the stakes score is not grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se domestic dispute over an order of protection; entirely private stakes with no broad legal implications.

Gasper v. EIDPThe Supreme Court declined to hear a retiree's challenge to how his pension plan calculated his court-ordered benefit share after his divorce.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.05
0.24
0.05
0.11

David Gasper v. EIDP, Inc., fka, E. I. DuPont De Nemours & Company, et al.No. 25-1362 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500263 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Supreme Court declined to hear a retiree's challenge to how his pension plan calculated his court-ordered benefit share after his divorce.

What happened

David Gasper's 2013 divorce produced a court order dividing his pension, which the plan approved. When Gasper sought retirement benefits in 2019, the plan administrator required him to choose among benefit options that, he says, changed the payment structure the divorce order had set, reducing his share and shifting costs. Gasper appealed within the plan and received three denial letters, which he says gave shifting and inadequate reasons. He then sued in federal district court, which ruled against him, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that ruling in December 2025.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a court may uphold a benefit-plan administrator's denial of benefits by relying on reasons or plan provisions the administrator itself never gave during the internal appeal process, rather than only the reasons it actually stated. The Court is also asked whether a plan administrator may replace a retiree's already-finalized, court-ordered pension division with a different benefit form that the plan documents do not authorize.

Where it stands

Gasper filed his petition in March 2026. The respondents waived their right to respond, and after being distributed for conferences in June and September 2026, the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Gasper, the petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Fourth Circuit's ruling for EIDP (DuPont) and the other plan-related respondents. Because the Court denied the petition, it will not hear the case, and the Fourth Circuit's decision upholding the benefit reduction and the lower courts' handling of his claims remains in place. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning; it simply leaves that outcome standing, with no further review by the Supreme Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single participant's dispute over a $385/month reduction in his own pension annuity, turning on whether "may" in a North Carolina domestic-relations order is permissive; the Chenery/ERISA framing is the petitioner's recharacterization rather than the ground the panel decided, so even a grant would resolve little of general consequence.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.24·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The ERISA notice and QDRO questions could affect pension administration beyond these parties, but the record centers on one divorce order and survivor-annuity cost allocation rather than a demonstrated nationwide change in benefits law.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly fact-bound private ERISA QDRO dispute with no broader public impact.

Basso v. RodriguezThe Supreme Court declined to hear Joseph Basso's challenge to a Maryland attorney-fee ruling, leaving the lower court's decision in place.Civil proceduredecided
0.05
0.24
0.05
0.11

Joseph Basso v. Jose Rodriguez, et al.No. 26-121 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000121 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to hear Joseph Basso's challenge to a Maryland attorney-fee ruling, leaving the lower court's decision in place.

What happened

Joseph Basso sued two real estate sellers, Jose Rodriguez and Javier Szuchman, over an undisclosed flooding defect in a home he bought, and won a jury verdict finding fraud and consumer-protection violations. Basso then sought statutory attorney's fees and separate sanctions against the sellers. A retired judge denied the fee request in a one-page order, and the Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed. Basso later argued the judge may have been practicing law as a county attorney around the time he signed that order, which he says made the retired judge ineligible to serve. The Maryland Supreme Court granted review on one issue, dismissed it on procedural grounds, and denied reconsideration.

What the Court is being asked

Basso asks the Court to decide whether due process required a hearing or disqualification when evidence surfaced, only after the state appeal, suggesting the judge who decided his fee request was not legally eligible to sit at the time. He separately asks the Court to summarily send the case back to Maryland's courts in light of a new Maryland Supreme Court ruling about how detailed a trial court's written explanation for a fee award must be.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the respondents waived their right to respond. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Basso, who asked the Court to take up the case, sought to overturn the Maryland Appellate Court's ruling upholding the denial of his attorney's fees. The denial means that ruling stands, so Rodriguez and Szuchman are not required to pay the statutory fees or face further review of the judge's eligibility or the fee memorandum's adequacy in this case. The denial does not mean the Court found the lower court's decision correct; it simply leaves that decision in place without deciding the questions Basso raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Private residential-fraud/attorney-fee dispute from a state court; the judicial-recall-eligibility angle has local Maryland interest but no national stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on the constitutional status of an allegedly ineligible recalled judge could matter beyond the parties, but this vehicle is fact-bound and largely concerns Maryland fee procedure.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine error-correction petition regarding state court judge qualifications and attorney fees, with no national implications.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single homeowner's fight over statutory attorney's fees after a Maryland fraud verdict; the Caperton question is framed around one retired judge's employment and would not reach beyond this record even if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.24·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on the federal due-process consequences of a recalled judge's concurrent legal practice could affect judicial administration nationally, but this petition arises from an individualized Maryland fee dispute with contested timing and no demonstrated interjurisdictional conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    State court attorney fee dispute and judicial qualification issue with no broad national impact.

Ekladyous v. National Highway Traffic Safety AdministrationThe Court declined to hear a driver's bid to revive his challenge to federal headlight regulations after lower courts ruled it was filed too late.Agencies & benefitsdecided
0.05
0.28
0.00
0.11

Albert Ekladyous v. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, et al.No. 26-314 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000314 · models differ by up to 0.28 · topic: Agencies & benefits

The Court declined to hear a driver's bid to revive his challenge to federal headlight regulations after lower courts ruled it was filed too late.

What happened

Albert Ekladyous, representing himself, asked the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C. to review headlight safety rules issued by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. He argued the agency never adopted a technical performance standard that a 2021 infrastructure law told it to use for new "adaptive driving beam" headlamps, which automatically dim for oncoming traffic. The appeals court dismissed his case, holding that any challenge to the 2022 rule itself came too late under a 59-day filing deadline, and that he had not identified any separate, ongoing agency failure. The full appeals court declined to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an appeals court may treat a claim that an agency never carried out a specific, ongoing legal duty as if it were instead a late challenge to a rule the agency already issued. It is also asked whether a claim that the agency adopted a different technical standard than the one Congress specified counts as the kind of ongoing failure that can be reviewed regardless of filing deadlines that apply to completed rules.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's November 6, 2026 conference, and on November 9, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Ekladyous, who lost in the lower court, asked the Court to take up his case. The denial means the Court will not review the question, so the appeals court's dismissal of his case stands. The agency's regulation remains in place, and Ekladyous's challenge to it is over. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se challenge to NHTSA's adaptive-driving-beam rule dismissed in an unpublished timeliness order; the headlamp-standard question has some regulatory interest but the case as postured is narrow and fact-bound.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.28·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The proposed agency-inaction rule could affect judicial review beyond automotive lighting, and the underlying standard concerns nationwide road safety. But this unpublished jurisdictional dismissal is a narrow vehicle, and the record does not establish wider institutional attention.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition challenging an unpublished untimeliness dismissal by the D.C. Circuit; raises no issues of national importance.

Chaganti v. Cincinnati InsuranceThe Court declined to hear a policyholder's challenge to Ohio courts applying a shortened filing deadline to his insurance lawsuit.Civil proceduredecided
0.04
0.24
0.05
0.11

Naren Chaganti v. Cincinnati Insurance CompanyNo. 25-1291 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73361381 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a policyholder's challenge to Ohio courts applying a shortened filing deadline to his insurance lawsuit.

What happened

Naren Chaganti sued Cincinnati Insurance Company in 2024 for breach of a business insurance contract covering damage that occurred in 2010. At the time, Ohio's statute of limitations for such suits was 15 years, but a 2012 law shortened it to 8 years. An uncodified part of that law, not printed alongside the main statute, said the shorter period applied even to claims that arose before 2012. Ohio trial and appellate courts sided with Cincinnati and dismissed Chaganti's suit as filed too late. The Ohio Supreme Court declined to review the case.

What the Court is being asked

Chaganti asks whether it violates constitutional fair-notice requirements for a state to rely on a provision that was passed as part of a bill but never printed in the official law books, to apply a shortened filing deadline retroactively to claims that already existed before the new deadline took effect.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026 the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Chaganti, the policyholder, asked the Court to take up his case after losing in the Ohio courts. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Ohio Court of Appeals' decision in place, meaning Chaganti's lawsuit against Cincinnati Insurance remains dismissed as filed too late. The denial does not mean the Court agreed that Ohio's approach was correct; it simply leaves that ruling standing without deciding the constitutional question Chaganti raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single pro se assignee's time-barred 2010 insurance claim under an Ohio limitations amendment; the notice theory is idiosyncratic, no amici, no split, no government party, and the affected class is small.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.24·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling imposing a constitutional code-publication requirement could affect state transition provisions and accrued civil claims beyond insurance, but the presented dispute concerns an Ohio limitations amendment and a single assignee's insurance claim rather than an identified nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition challenging state court application of a statute of limitations, involving no significant federal or public interest.

Hamp's Construction v. TelleA construction company asks the Court to revive its claim for extra payment after a flood-control project ran into unexpected ground conditions the government did not disclose.awaiting the Court
0.04
0.14
0.15
0.11

Hamp's Construction, LLC v. Adam R. Telle, Acting Secretary of the ArmyNo. 26-464 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000464 · models differ by up to 0.11

A construction company asks the Court to revive its claim for extra payment after a flood-control project ran into unexpected ground conditions the government did not disclose.

What happened

Hamp's Construction LLC contracted with the Army Corps of Engineers to improve a Louisiana flood-control canal. While working on one section, the bank collapsed and showed other signs of instability, forcing Hamp's Construction to switch to costlier, barge-based equipment. Hamp's Construction sought extra payment and more time, arguing the government's contract documents, including soil borings and drawings, should have warned of these conditions. The Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals denied the claim, finding the contract contained no representation about conditions at the specific spot where the problems occurred. The Federal Circuit affirmed, agreeing that the boring logs provided did not indicate what a reasonable contractor would expect to find at that location.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether a government construction contract can be read as making no representation at all about ground conditions in a work area, when the contract as a whole, including drawings, boring samples taken elsewhere on the site, and other project materials, arguably suggested the area was suitable for the planned work. The case also asks whether courts may treat the simple absence of a soil test at the exact spot where problems later arose as enough by itself to defeat such a claim.

Where it stands

The petition was filed, the government waived its right to respond, and the case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take it up.

What each outcome would mean

Hamp's Construction, which lost in the Federal Circuit, is asking the Court to take up the case and reverse that ruling. If the Court grants the petition, it will hear the case in full and decide the contract-interpretation question; a grant alone would not decide who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Federal Circuit's ruling stands, leaving Hamp's Construction without the additional payment and time extension it sought, and the Secretary of the Army's win in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 15, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Hamp's Construction's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Hamp's Construction's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single contractor's $3.9M Type I differing-site-condition claim under FAR 52.236-2, decided on forfeiture and substantial-evidence grounds with no circuit split possible (Federal Circuit exclusive jurisdiction). Routine government-contracts dispute; recurring clause, but no public or doctrinal stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.23·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Potentially consequential for allocation of latent-site risk in federal construction contracts, but the petition presents a specialized, contract-specific dispute with a preservation obstacle rather than a broad constitutional or institutional controversy.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Highly fact-bound contract interpretation dispute lacking broad legal significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly decline to hear this case (well under a one-in-a-hundred chance of review). A construction company wants the Court to revisit a ruling that the Army did not owe it extra money when a canal bank proved unstable. The dispute turns on how to read one contract's soil reports and drawings, not on a legal question dividing the lower courts. The government did not even file a response, and the Court has not asked for one.

    Why this big-case score: A single contractor's $3.9M differing-site-conditions claim turning on the reading of one contract's boring logs and drawings; limited interest beyond the government-construction bar.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.14·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal: I put the chance of review at about six in a thousand, or 0.6%. A construction company says the Army should pay for unexpected unstable ground that made its canal project more expensive. But the appeal largely challenges how existing rules were applied to this particular contract, and important arguments were not properly preserved in the lower proceedings. The government waived a response. I expect a routine denial without an explanatory opinion.

    Why this big-case score: Recurring federal construction-contract risk allocation, but a roughly $4 million dispute with substantial factual and preservation limitations rather than a demonstrated systemwide doctrinal conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review—leaving the lower court's ruling in place—with less than a one percent chance (about one in two hundred) of taking the case. Hamp's Construction asks the Justices to revive a nearly $4 million federal contract claim after canal banks collapsed during an Army flood-control project in Louisiana. However, the federal appeals court unanimously rejected the claim based on project-specific soil evidence, several key arguments were forfeited—meaning raised too late—in the earlier proceedings, no federal appeals courts disagree on the legal rule, and the government waived filing a response.

    Why this big-case score: Routine Contract Disputes Act dispute over Type I differing site conditions under FAR 52.236-2; a merits decision on implied subsurface representations from partial boring logs would matter to federal construction procurement specialists but carries limited broader legal or public salience.

Goodley v. Supreme RiceThe Court declined to hear a federal rice inspector's bid to revive her lawsuit against the rice mill where a forklift injured her.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.05
0.20
0.05
0.10

Rachel E. Goodley v. Supreme Rice, L.L.C., et al.No. 26-27 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000027 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Court declined to hear a federal rice inspector's bid to revive her lawsuit against the rice mill where a forklift injured her.

What happened

Rachel Goodley, a federal grain inspector, was injured when a forklift operated by a Supreme Rice employee ran over her foot while she inspected rice at Supreme Rice's mill. She sued Supreme Rice and its insurer in Louisiana state court for her injuries; the case was moved to federal court. The district court ruled that Louisiana's workers' compensation law gave Supreme Rice immunity from the lawsuit, because Supreme Rice had contracted with her employer, a federal inspection agency, to fulfill its obligation to have the rice inspected under a sales contract. The court of appeals agreed and upheld that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether a state can treat a federal inspector, sent to a private business to perform official government inspections, as if she were that business's own employee for purposes of a state law that would block her from suing the business over an on-the-job injury. Goodley argues the inspection work was not something Supreme Rice could ever have been obligated to perform itself, since federal law required an independent inspection, so the legal rule should not have applied to shield Supreme Rice from her lawsuit.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026 the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Goodley asked the Court to take up her case. With the petition denied, the court of appeals' ruling stands, meaning Supreme Rice and its insurer remain shielded from her tort lawsuit under Louisiana's workers' compensation law, and Goodley's case does not proceed further. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply leaves that decision in place without reviewing it.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se tort suit by one federal grain inspector against a rice mill, decided below in an unpublished, expressly fact-bound Fifth Circuit opinion on Louisiana's two-contract statutory-employer defense; the preemption framing in QP 2 was waived below and no other court is shown to have confronted it, so the stakes are confined to the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The federal-inspector question potentially affects federal employees working at private facilities, but this dispute concerns a narrow Louisiana tort-immunity defense and a particular rice-inspection arrangement, not an established nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound application of state workers' compensation law to a federal employee, lacking broad national significance.

Houssam Eddine Hamrit v. Citigroup Global MarketsHamrit asks the Court to review a federal appeals court's dismissal of his appeal as frivolous without notice or briefing.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.22
0.05
0.10

Houssam Eddine Hamrit v. Citigroup Global Markets, Inc., et al.No. 26-432 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000432 · models differ by up to 0.19

Hamrit asks the Court to review a federal appeals court's dismissal of his appeal as frivolous without notice or briefing.

What happened

Hamrit sued Citigroup over a disputed brokerage account debit. A district court found he had agreed to arbitrate, ordered arbitration, and stayed the case. Hamrit refused to begin arbitration, maintaining he had never signed an arbitration agreement, and the district court eventually dismissed his lawsuit with prejudice for failure to prosecute. Hamrit appealed that dismissal. Citigroup asked the appeals court to dismiss only part of the appeal, arguing certain earlier rulings could not be reviewed. The appeals court granted that request and also dismissed the rest of the appeal, ruling it had no arguable basis, without asking for additional briefing. It later denied Hamrit's request to reconsider.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an appeals court goes outside normal procedure when it dismisses an entire appeal as having no legal or factual basis, on its own initiative, without giving the appellant notice or a chance to respond, while acting on a request that had asked only to dismiss a smaller, different piece of the appeal.

Where it stands

Citigroup waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices may decide whether to take the case; the docket shows no action since.

What each outcome would mean

Hamrit is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants review, it would hear the case and decide whether the appeals court's dismissal process was proper, deciding nothing yet about who should ultimately win. If the Court denies review, the appeals court's dismissal of Hamrit's appeal stands, leaving the district court's dismissal of his lawsuit in place and ending that case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 7, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Houssam Eddine Hamrit's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Houssam Eddine Hamrit's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case. We put the chance it agrees at well under one in a hundred. Mr. Hamrit is representing himself. He argues that a federal appeals court wrongly threw out his appeal as "frivolous" (without legal merit) without warning him first. The other side did not even bother to file a response. The issue concerns only his own case, and nothing suggests the courts disagree on the legal rule. Petitions like this are almost always turned down.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se challenge to a Second Circuit summary frivolousness dismissal of one litigant's failure-to-prosecute appeal; no broader stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal: I put the chance of review at about two in a hundred. Hamrit argues that the appeals court ended his case without first letting him address its reason for dismissal. That raises a real fairness concern, but the petition identifies no direct conflict among published court decisions, and the trial record describes repeated warnings and refusals to proceed. I expect an unexplained denial after the December 4 conference, without another conference or separate written opinion.

    Why this big-case score: Notice before appellate dismissal matters beyond this litigant, but the petition concerns a narrow, unpublished procedural ruling and does not seek review of arbitration law generally.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny this petition for review, with a grant probability of half of one percent (about 1 in 200). After a federal judge ordered the petitioner, who is representing himself without a lawyer, to resolve his dispute with Citigroup in arbitration, the petitioner refused to start arbitration for more than seven months, leading the judge to dismiss the lawsuit for failure to prosecute (failing to move the case forward) and the appeals court to dismiss his appeal as frivolous (lacking any arguable legal basis). Because Citigroup waived its right to file a response, no outside groups filed supporting briefs, and the case involves a fact-specific procedural dispute rather than a disagreement among federal appeals courts, the Supreme Court will almost certainly decline to hear it.

    Why this big-case score: Private arbitration-refusal dispute raising a narrow procedural challenge to a Second Circuit motions-panel dismissal order; low national or doctrinal salience even if decided.

Lugo v. Birmingham Jefferson County Transit AuthorityA former transit authority employee asks the Court to review the dismissal of her workplace discrimination and retaliation lawsuit.awaiting the Court
0.05
0.22
0.03
0.10

Diana Y. Lugo v. Birmingham Jefferson County Transit AuthorityNo. 26-545 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000545 · models differ by up to 0.19

A former transit authority employee asks the Court to review the dismissal of her workplace discrimination and retaliation lawsuit.

What happened

Diana Lugo worked as a customer service representative for the Birmingham Jefferson County Transit Authority, scheduling rides for disabled passengers. After she was disciplined several times and eventually fired, she sued, representing herself, claiming race and national-origin discrimination and retaliation under federal civil rights and disability laws. She argued she was punished for complaining about mistreatment and for advocating for disabled riders, not for poor performance. The district court found insufficient evidence to let a jury decide her claims and granted summary judgment to the transit authority, meaning it ruled against her without a trial. The court also denied her request to reconsider that ruling. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

Lugo's petition raises three issues: whether the appeals court used too strict a test for comparing her treatment to coworkers of other backgrounds, in a way that conflicts with other appeals courts; whether the appeals court wrongly avoided weighing conflicting evidence that she says should have gone to a jury rather than being decided by a judge; and whether advocating on behalf of disabled customers counts as protected activity under disability-rights retaliation law, a question she says other appeals courts answer differently than the Eleventh Circuit.

Where it stands

The case is a petition for certiorari, asking the Supreme Court to take up the case. The petition was filed in October 2026, and the transit authority's response is due in late November 2026. The docket does not yet show any further action.

What each outcome would mean

Lugo, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Supreme Court to take up her case and reverse the rulings against her. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to hear the case and decide these questions itself, without yet deciding who is right. If it denies the petition, the Eleventh Circuit's decision affirming summary judgment for the transit authority stands, and Lugo's lawsuit remains dismissed. A denial would not mean the Supreme Court agrees with the lower courts, only that the case will not be reviewed further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 25, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Lugo's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Lugo's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se single-plaintiff employment-discrimination and retaliation dispute from an unpublished per curiam affirmance of summary judgment; the comparator and third-party-advocacy questions have some doctrinal reach, but this vehicle and posture give the case little stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Comparator standards and ADA advocacy protection have broad potential importance, but this unpublished, record-specific employment dispute is a weak vehicle for deciding either issue.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se employment discrimination and retaliation dispute arising from an unpublished Eleventh Circuit per curiam affirmance of summary judgment with no institutional, political, or national policy salience.

Silva v. BlancheGina Silva and others asked the Court to pause their removal from the United States while their case continued; the Court denied the request.Immigrationdecided
0.03
0.25
0.02
0.10

Gina Silva, et al. v. Todd Blanche, Attorney GeneralNo. 26A606 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000606 · models differ by up to 0.23 · topic: Immigration

Gina Silva and others asked the Court to pause their removal from the United States while their case continued; the Court denied the request.

What happened

Gina Silva and other applicants faced removal from the United States. They asked the Supreme Court to step in and stop that removal while their underlying case proceeded, after apparently failing to secure relief from the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. The respondent in the case is Todd Blanche, the Attorney General, representing the federal government. The docket does not describe what happened in the courts below beyond identifying the Third Circuit as the lower court.

What the Court is being asked

The question was whether the applicants should be allowed to remain in the United States temporarily, without being removed, while the courts continue to consider their underlying legal claims.

Where it stands

The applicants submitted their stay application on October 16, 2026, to Justice Alito. On November 2, 2026, Justice Alito denied the application. The docket does not show any further proceedings.

What each outcome would mean

Silva and the other applicants asked the Court to pause their removal. Granting the stay would have temporarily blocked the government from removing them while their case continued, without deciding the underlying legal questions. Denying the stay, which is what happened, leaves the government free to proceed with removal while the applicants' broader case continues elsewhere. Either way, the decision on the stay itself does not resolve the merits of their underlying claims.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 2, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-02: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Gina Silva and others, representing themselves, asked the Supreme Court to pause ("stay") their removal from the United States while they keep challenging a Third Circuit decision. We predict the request will be denied. A grant is very unlikely, roughly one chance in a hundred. Individual emergency requests like this are almost always turned down by the single Justice who handles that circuit, here Justice Alito, often without even asking the government to respond.

    Why this big-case score: Individual self-represented stay-of-removal application from the Third Circuit; consequential for the applicants but no broader legal question is visible on the record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.25·Chance the Court grants the application: 7%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny this request to pause the applicants' removal from the United States. I estimate about a seven-in-one-hundred chance of a full grant. The available record shows only that the request reached Justice Alito, not why the applicants believe removal should be stopped. Emergency relief is uncommon, and this record provides no specific reason to expect an exception. I expect a short order, probably without a written explanation, within weeks of submission.

    Why this big-case score: Removal has serious personal stakes, but the docket alone identifies no broadly consequential legal question or system-wide relief.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Gina Silva and her family are very likely to have their emergency request for a stay of removal (a temporary court order halting deportation) denied, with only a 1% chance (one in one hundred) that the Supreme Court grants relief. Representing themselves without a lawyer, the applicants ask Justice Alito to block their deportation to Colombia after the Third Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the denial of their asylum and related protection claims. Because the lower court's unpublished ruling rested on routine factual findings and arguments that were not properly raised before the immigration board, rather than a broader legal disagreement among federal courts, the Supreme Court is almost certain to deny the stay without requesting a response from the government.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se emergency application for a stay of removal following an unpublished Third Circuit per curiam decision affirming the BIA's denial of asylum, withholding of removal, and CAT relief on exhaustion, waiver, and substantial-evidence nexus grounds; no circuit split or broader policy impact beyond the individual applicants.

Green v. United StatesJohn Green asks the Court to decide when his conviction became final for purposes of challenging it through a habeas petition.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.18
0.08
0.10

John O. Green v. United StatesNo. 26-531 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000531 · models differ by up to 0.15

John Green asks the Court to decide when his conviction became final for purposes of challenging it through a habeas petition.

What happened

John Green was convicted, along with co-defendant Thomas Selgas, of conspiring to defraud the United States. Both men appealed, and the Fifth Circuit consolidated and rejected their appeals. Each then separately asked the Supreme Court to review his case; the Court denied Green's request in January 2023 and Selgas's request in March 2023. Green later filed a habeas petition, a type of challenge to his conviction, arguing it was timely because his conviction was not final until Selgas's review was denied. The district court disagreed, ruling the one-year filing deadline started when Green's own request was denied, making his petition too late. The Fifth Circuit refused to let Green appeal that ruling.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked when a conviction becomes final for starting the one-year clock to file a habeas challenge, where co-defendants whose appeals were combined each separately asked the Supreme Court to review their cases and the two requests were decided months apart. The Court is also asked whether reasonable judges could disagree about this question, which would mean Green should be allowed to appeal the denial of his habeas petition.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take the case. The United States has waived its right to respond.

What each outcome would mean

Green asks the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it will decide the finality question and whether Green may appeal; this does not decide who wins. If it denies the petition, the lower courts' rulings stand, leaving Green's habeas petition dismissed as filed too late and without further appeal.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Green's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Green's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound question about Section 2255(f)(1) finality in a rare posture (co-defendants filing separate cert petitions on different dates), reached through a COA denial; it would matter to very few litigants.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The finality rule could affect collateral-review access for jointly tried defendants, but the petition concerns a narrow timing configuration, identifies no circuit split, and arises from unpublished rulings.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine individual 28 U.S.C. § 2255 timeliness and COA dispute arising from an unpublished single-judge Fifth Circuit order with narrow procedural stakes and no circuit split.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn down (deny) John Green's request to hear his case — roughly a 1-in-100 chance of it being taken. Green argues his deadline to challenge his federal conviction should have started only when the Court rejected his co-defendant's later appeal, not his own. The issue is narrow, there is no disagreement among lower courts, the government did not even bother to file a response, and the lower court's ruling was an unpublished refusal to allow an appeal.

    Why this big-case score: Narrow, self-described one-off question about § 2255(f)(1) finality for co-defendants with staggered cert petitions; affects one petitioner who has already served his custodial sentence.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case: I estimate about a one-in-one-hundred chance of review. Green argues that his deadline to challenge his conviction should have waited until the Court rejected a codefendant's separate appeal. The lower courts instead counted from rejection of Green's own appeal. The petition identifies no disagreement among federal appeals courts, and the government waived a response. I expect denial without further conference consideration or a separate explanation from any Justice, leaving the lower-court ruling in place.

    Why this big-case score: Access to federal postconviction review matters, but the questions concern a narrow timing problem involving separately denied codefendant petitions, with no identified circuit split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny John O. Green's petition for review, with less than a one-in-one-hundred chance of a grant (0.5%). After Green and a co-defendant lost a joint criminal appeal, each asked the Supreme Court to review his conviction separately, and the Court denied Green's request two months before his co-defendant's. Green then waited more than a year after his own denial to file a post-conviction challenge under a federal statute with a strict one-year deadline. Because existing law ties that one-year clock to a defendant's own case, no appeals courts disagree on the rule, and the federal government waived its right to respond, the Court will almost certainly decline the case.

    Why this big-case score: Narrow, fact-bound 28 U.S.C. 2255(f)(1) limitations question from an unpublished single-judge COA denial with no circuit split or broader public salience.

John Paul Gomez v. RyanGomez asked the Supreme Court to revive his civil rights lawsuit against Ohio judges and officials; the Court declined to hear the case.Civil proceduredecided
0.04
0.22
0.01
0.09

John Paul Gomez v. David Ryan, et al.No. 25-1258 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73303792 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Civil procedure

Gomez asked the Supreme Court to revive his civil rights lawsuit against Ohio judges and officials; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Gomez, representing himself, sued Ohio judicial officers and a police officer, claiming their conduct during state custody and related proceedings violated his constitutional rights. The federal district court dismissed his claims, ruling some were barred under a doctrine that limits federal courts from reviewing state-court judgments, and that the rest failed to state a valid claim. The court also denied him permission to amend his complaint and barred him from future filings without restrictions. The Sixth Circuit affirmed that decision. Gomez then asked the Supreme Court to take up the case.

What the Court is being asked

The petition raised two questions. First, whether a rule that normally keeps federal courts from reviewing state-court judgments should also block claims that allege separate constitutional harms caused by officials' conduct, not by the judgment itself. Second, whether a court may deny permission to fix a flawed complaint, and bar someone from filing future lawsuits, without first giving them a chance to amend it.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Gomez, who lost in the lower courts, asked the Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Sixth Circuit's decision in place: Gomez's lawsuit stays dismissed, his request to amend remains denied, and the restrictions on his future filings stand. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower courts were right; it simply leaves that outcome undisturbed, without the Supreme Court deciding the underlying legal questions itself.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se litigant's section 1983 suit against Ohio judges, a clerk, and a police officer arising from state custody proceedings, dismissed under Rooker-Feldman and immunity with prefiling restrictions; the Rooker-Feldman scope question has some doctrinal interest but this vehicle carries no stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling could affect federal civil-rights access, amendment practice, and prefiling restrictions, but the petition concerns an individual domestic-relations dispute and offers no demonstrated broad practical impact beyond those procedural questions.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se Section 1983 petition against local officials; unlikely to establish broad precedent or attract national attention.

Emberton v. Superior Court of CaliforniaThe Court declined to hear a San Francisco property owner's bid to revive her lawsuit challenging the city's code-enforcement searches of her property.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.03
0.22
0.02
0.09

Mihal Emberton v. Superior Court of California, City and County of San Francisco, et al.No. 26-290 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000290 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear a San Francisco property owner's bid to revive her lawsuit challenging the city's code-enforcement searches of her property.

What happened

Mihai Emberton, representing herself, sued the City and County of San Francisco over code-enforcement actions involving a fence and other structures on her property, arguing that inspections and violation notices amounted to unconstitutional searches and seizures. A California trial court sustained the city's demurrer (a motion arguing the complaint fails to state a valid claim) against her complaint. The California Court of Appeal denied her petition challenging that result, noting it also appeared to exceed court word-count rules. The California Supreme Court denied review. Emberton then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to clarify when a government inspection of property counts as a search requiring constitutional safeguards. It asks whether that question turns on whether the property was visible to the inspector without trespassing, or instead on whether the inspection deprived the owner of the right to keep others out, regardless of visibility or where the inspection happened.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on November 6, 2026. On November 9, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Emberton, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up her case after losing in the California courts. The denial means the Court will not review the case, so the California Court of Appeal's rejection of her challenge, and the underlying trial court ruling favoring the city, remain in place. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning, only that it chose not to hear the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se homeowner's dispute with San Francisco code enforcement over a front-yard fence and trellis, reaching the Court from a summary state-court writ denial; no split, no institutional party, no doctrinal question the Court could reach on this record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The proposed Fourth Amendment rule could affect municipal inspections and observation of residential property broadly, but the supplied record presents an individual fence and code-enforcement dispute without a demonstrated appellate split or a developed appellate merits opinion.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine pro se petition regarding a local code enforcement dispute with no national significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se dispute over municipal code enforcement against a fence; the questions are framed as abstract Fourth Amendment doctrine but the stakes are one property owner's.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Residential privacy and municipal inspections have broader importance, but this petition arises from an individual fence and code-enforcement dispute without a developed appellate merits ruling or demonstrated interjurisdictional split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se petition arising from a local San Francisco residential fence/arbor/gas-line code-enforcement dispute; interlocutory state-court posture with no broader doctrinal or public-policy significance.

Coleman v. Merit Systems Protection BoardA former Pentagon bomb squad supervisor asks the Court to revive his whistleblower retaliation claim against a federal personnel board.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.19
0.05
0.09

Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection BoardNo. 26-427 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000427 · models differ by up to 0.16

A former Pentagon bomb squad supervisor asks the Court to revive his whistleblower retaliation claim against a federal personnel board.

What happened

Richard Coleman worked as a supervisory explosives specialist for the Pentagon Force Protection Agency and received hazardous duty pay. The agency discontinued that pay in January 2015 and later revised his position description to remove references to it. Starting in February 2015, Coleman made a series of disclosures to agency officials, Congress, and others, arguing the pay cut was unlawful and that his position description contained errors, including a duplicated signature the agency called "sloppy work." The Merit Systems Protection Board dismissed his retaliation appeal for lack of jurisdiction, finding his disclosures came after the pay decision and so could not have caused it. The Federal Circuit affirmed, and Coleman, representing himself, now petitions the Supreme Court.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide whether an agency's repeated refusals, after an employee's disclosures, to restore pay or fix a disputed personnel document can count as their own separate retaliatory actions, rather than being treated as just the lingering effects of an earlier decision made before the disclosures occurred.

Where it stands

The Merit Systems Protection Board waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026, and the docket shows no action since then.

What each outcome would mean

Coleman, the petitioner, is asking the Court to take up his case and reverse the Federal Circuit's ruling. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal question itself, without yet deciding who wins. If it denies review, the Federal Circuit's decision stands, leaving Coleman's retaliation appeal dismissed and the Board's finding that it lacked jurisdiction in place.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Coleman's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Coleman's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will very likely turn down this case — we put the chance it agrees to hear it at well under one in a hundred. Richard Coleman, a federal employee representing himself, says the Merit Systems Protection Board wrongly refused to hear his whistleblower complaint about an inaccurate job description and lost hazardous-duty pay. The government declined even to file a response, the lower court's ruling was unpublished, and the questions turn on the facts of one dispute rather than a broad legal conflict the Justices usually look for.

    Why this big-case score: A pro se federal employee's fact-bound whistleblower-jurisdiction dispute over one position description and hazardous duty pay; nonprecedential below, no broader stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.19·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Richard Coleman's request to hear his federal employment dispute; I put the chance of review at about one in 200. He argues that continued denial of hazardous-duty pay after he reported wrongdoing should count as a new act of retaliation. But the case turns heavily on his particular employment history and does not show a clear disagreement between appeals courts. I expect a brief denial after the November conference, without a separate statement from any Justice.

    Why this big-case score: The potential rule concerns federal whistleblower remedies and continuing pay denials, but the presented dispute is an individual, fact-bound hazardous-duty-pay case without a demonstrated appellate split.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is virtually certain to deny review in *Coleman v. Merit Systems Protection Board*, with a 0.3% chance of a grant (about one in three hundred). Petitioner Richard Coleman, representing himself without a lawyer, asks the Court to revive his whistleblower appeal challenging the Pentagon Force Protection Agency's 2015 decision to stop paying him a 25% hazardous-duty pay supplement. The lower tribunal and the federal appeals court dismissed his case in an unpublished decision because the agency stopped the extra pay before he made his whistleblower complaints, meaning the complaints could not have caused the pay cut, and the government has already waived its right to file a response.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se federal-employee whistleblower appeal challenging a nonprecedential jurisdictional dismissal over a 2015 hazardous-duty-pay discontinuation; even if decided on the merits, its impact would be confined to narrow WPEA timing and continuing-violation pleading rules before the MSPB.

Sohilbhai Shaukatali Momin v. BlancheThe Supreme Court declined to hear Sohilbhai Momin's challenge to a Fifth Circuit ruling in his case against the Attorney General.decided
0.08
—
0.10
0.09 2 of 3 models

Sohilbhai Shaukatali Momin v. Todd Blanche, Attorney GeneralNo. 26-55 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000055 · models differ by up to 0.02

The Supreme Court declined to hear Sohilbhai Momin's challenge to a Fifth Circuit ruling in his case against the Attorney General.

What happened

Sohilbhai Shaukatali Momin petitioned the Supreme Court after losing before the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which ruled against him on April 9, 2026, in a case involving the Attorney General. The docket does not describe the underlying dispute or the Fifth Circuit's reasoning. Momin then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. The government, represented by the Solicitor General on behalf of Attorney General Todd Blanche, opposed the petition after receiving two extensions of time to respond. Momin filed a reply before the Court considered the case.

What the Court is being asked

The record does not include the questions presented or the parties' briefs, so it does not show what legal issue Momin asked the Court to decide.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of November 6, 2026, and on November 9, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Momin, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case after losing in the Fifth Circuit. The Court's denial means it will not hear the case, so the Fifth Circuit's April 2026 decision against Momin remains in place. A denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply leaves that ruling standing, with no further review at the Supreme Court level. The case does not proceed to briefing or argument at the Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downNov 9, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-11-09: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Paid individual immigration petition for review from CA5 against the Attorney General; nothing on the docket suggests stakes beyond the petitioner.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 5%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The provisioned record contains no questions presented, petition, opposition text, or lower-court opinion; the caption and briefing chronology alone cannot establish the scope or significance of the issues.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An ordinary immigration petition for review from the Fifth Circuit.

Scroggins v. City of ShreveportThe Supreme Court declined to hear Felicia Scroggins's bid to revive her employment discrimination lawsuit against the City of Shreveport.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.03
0.22
0.01
0.09

Felicia Scroggins v. City of Shreveport, LouisianaNo. 26-80 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000080 · models differ by up to 0.21 · topic: Employment & discrimination

The Supreme Court declined to hear Felicia Scroggins's bid to revive her employment discrimination lawsuit against the City of Shreveport.

What happened

Felicia Scroggins, a former employee, sued the City of Shreveport claiming she was denied promotions within the Shreveport Fire Department due to unlawful discrimination. The district court granted summary judgment to the city, finding no genuine factual dispute requiring a trial. Scroggins, representing herself, appealed to the Fifth Circuit, which affirmed the district court's ruling, though one judge dissented, concluding the record showed real factual disputes. The Fifth Circuit denied rehearing, and Scroggins then asked the Supreme Court to take up her case.

What the Court is being asked

Scroggins's petition raises three issues: whether the lower courts wrongly decided the case without a trial despite disputed facts that should go to a jury; whether the appeals court applied the wrong standard for weighing an employer's stated reasons against claims that those reasons were a cover for discrimination; and whether the appeals court was too strict in treating some of her arguments as waived, given that she was representing herself without a lawyer.

Where it stands

The city waived its right to respond to the petition. The Court considered the petition at its September 28, 2026 conference and denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Scroggins asked the Court to take up her case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Fifth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the city's win on summary judgment stands and Scroggins's lawsuit remains dismissed. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower court was correct; it simply leaves that ruling as the final word in her case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single-plaintiff employment-discrimination suit against one city; even a summary reversal on summary-judgment standards would be narrow, fact-bound, and lightly covered.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.06·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound employment-discrimination dispute with limited significance beyond ordinary summary-judgment administration.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Fact-bound employment discrimination case concerning summary judgment application.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single pro se Title VII promotion dispute against one city fire department, affirmed below on forfeiture with no circuit split alleged; the only readers are the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Employment-discrimination summary judgment and treatment of pro se litigants have recurring importance, but this petition principally challenges factual and preservation rulings in one municipal promotion dispute rather than identifying a concrete inter-circuit conflict or seeking a new nationwide rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine pro se employment discrimination case involving fact-bound error correction; very low significance.

Scroggins v. City of ShreveportA former Shreveport firefighter asks the Court to revive her disability discrimination lawsuit after lower courts dismissed it on summary judgment.awaiting the Court
0.04
0.20
0.02
0.09

Felicia Scroggins v. City of Shreveport, LouisianaNo. 26-383 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000383 · models differ by up to 0.18

A former Shreveport firefighter asks the Court to revive her disability discrimination lawsuit after lower courts dismissed it on summary judgment.

What happened

Felicia Scroggins worked for the Shreveport Fire Department for over two decades before the City fired her in January 2023, citing years of absences tied to what she describes as a disability. She sued, raising claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act, a retaliation claim under Title VII, and a procedural due process claim. A federal district court granted the City's request for summary judgment, ruling Scroggins was not a "qualified individual" under the ADA and had not shown her firing was retaliatory or that she was denied required procedures. The Fifth Circuit affirmed in a brief unpublished opinion, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an employee who has already returned to work and is performing her job under an accommodation can still be ruled unqualified for ADA purposes mainly because of her past absences and predictions about future attendance, without letting a jury weigh evidence of her actual return and ability to work. The petition also asks whether the lower courts improperly resolved disputed facts against Scroggins rather than leaving them for a jury, as the rules for deciding summary judgment require.

Where it stands

The City has waived its right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's November 13, 2026 conference, and the docket does not yet show any action taken on it.

What each outcome would mean

Scroggins, as petitioner, is asking the Court to take up her case and reverse the rulings against her. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to hear the case and decide the legal questions, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's decision affirming summary judgment for the City stands, and Scroggins's lawsuit remains dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Scroggins' case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Scroggins' petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We expect the Supreme Court to turn this case down. The chance it agrees to hear it is very small, under one in a hundred. Felicia Scroggins is representing herself. She argues that lower courts were wrong to throw out her disability-discrimination claim against the City of Shreveport before trial. The appeals court rejected her claim in a short, unpublished order. The City did not bother to file a response. The Court rarely takes cases that ask only whether lower courts got one person's facts wrong.

    Why this big-case score: Fact-bound pro se ADA/summary-judgment dispute with a single municipal employer; no split asserted, no broader stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this case; I estimate less than a one-in-a-hundred chance of review, or 0.7%. A former Shreveport firefighter argues that courts wrongly dismissed her disability-accommodation lawsuit despite her return to limited-duty work. Her petition mainly disputes how existing rules were applied to her evidence, rather than showing disagreement among appeals courts. Other reasons supporting dismissal make the case harder to review. I expect no further conference scheduling or written explanation from the Court.

    Why this big-case score: Disability accommodation and municipal employment have recurring importance, but this unpublished, record-specific dispute presents no demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny review in *Felicia Scroggins v. City of Shreveport, Louisiana* (a 0.2% chance of a grant, or about one in five hundred). Representing herself without a lawyer, a municipal firefighter challenges a federal trial court's summary judgment—a ruling ending the case before trial because the judge found no genuine factual dispute—after she missed nearly two-thirds of her shifts over five years. Because the federal appeals court affirmed in a two-sentence unpublished order, the case presents no disagreement among appellate courts, the City waived its response, and an independent ruling that the City had a non-pretextual reason for discipline makes the case unsuitable for Supreme Court review.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se fact-bound employment dispute challenging summary judgment and an unpublished one-sentence Fifth Circuit affirmance under settled ADA and Rule 56 standards.

Watson v. MasonHenry Watson asked the Court to review his Wisconsin homicide conviction, but the Court declined to hear the case.Criminal lawdecided
0.03
0.16
0.05
0.08

Henry L. Watson, III v. Kenya Mason, WardenNo. 25-1279 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73335108 · models differ by up to 0.13 · topic: Criminal law

Henry Watson asked the Court to review his Wisconsin homicide conviction, but the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Henry Watson was convicted in Wisconsin state court of homicide by negligent handling of a dangerous weapon, after a bullet he fired at a man who allegedly threatened him instead killed a bystander. The jury acquitted him of a related charge involving the man he says threatened him, finding he acted in self-defense, but convicted him on the count involving the bystander's death. Wisconsin courts, including the court of appeals, held that state law barred a self-defense claim for that count. Federal courts then denied Watson's request for habeas relief, a procedure that lets state prisoners challenge convictions in federal court, and the Seventh Circuit declined to let him appeal further.

What the Court is being asked

Watson asks the Court to decide whether the jury instructions and the state law were applied in a way that unconstitutionally prevented the jury from considering his self-defense claim and relieved the state of its burden to disprove self-defense, and whether his trial lawyer's handling of the case amounted to constitutionally inadequate representation.

Where it stands

The state chose not to respond to the petition. The Court considered the petition at its September 28, 2026 conference and denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Watson, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case. The denial means the Court will not review it, leaving in place the lower courts' rulings that upheld his conviction and denied him federal habeas relief. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with those rulings, only that it chose not to hear the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se state-prisoner habeas petition after an unpublished Seventh Circuit COA denial; the questions turn on one Wisconsin statute and one Wisconsin jury instruction, with no live doctrinal dispute and no institutional party on either side.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.16·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A serious individual liberty claim involving self-defense and negligent harm to a bystander, but the presented vehicle is an unpublished habeas certificate-of-appealability denial with Wisconsin-specific instructional issues and no developed interjurisdictional conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se state habeas petition with no apparent circuit split and waived response.

Zhong v. Superior Court of CaliforniaJohn Zhong and Catherine Li asked the Court to review California courts' refusal to disqualify the judge handling a city enforcement case against them, and the Court declined.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.03
0.20
0.01
0.08

John Zhong, et al. v. Superior Court of California, Los Angeles County, et al.No. 26-95 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000095 · models differ by up to 0.19 · topic: Constitutional rights

John Zhong and Catherine Li asked the Court to review California courts' refusal to disqualify the judge handling a city enforcement case against them, and the Court declined.

What happened

John Zhong and Catherine Li are defendants in a Los Angeles nuisance lawsuit the City of Diamond Bar filed over alleged short-term rental violations. They sought to disqualify the assigned judge, arguing his rulings and a tentative decision against them showed bias. The Superior Court struck their disqualification request as untimely and legally insufficient. The California Court of Appeal denied their petition for writ review, and the California Supreme Court denied further review and a stay. Zhong and Li then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the case, while separately seeking an emergency stay of further proceedings before the same judge.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether a state court violates constitutional fair-trial protections when it turns down a request to remove a judge without a detailed written explanation addressing the federal constitutional standard for bias, where the people raising the claim say the facts, if true, show the risk of bias was too high to be acceptable.

Where it stands

The Court denied the stay application on September 4, 2026, and denied the petition for certiorari itself on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Zhong and Li, as petitioners, asked the Court to hear their case and separately sought emergency relief pausing proceedings before the challenged judge. The Court denied the stay application, leaving the state court free to proceed before that judge while the certiorari petition remained pending. The Court then denied certiorari, leaving the California courts' rulings in place. That means the decisions declining to disqualify the judge and allowing the underlying nuisance case to continue stand, and the City of Diamond Bar's position in those rulings prevails.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se due-process challenge to a local code-enforcement judge's non-recusal; no split developed, no national stakes, no institutional petitioner.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A nationwide due-process rule for reasoned judicial-disqualification decisions could matter, but this local interlocutory dispute is unlikely to attract broad attention.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Challenging a state appellate court summary denial of a judicial disqualification motion is heavily fact-bound and rarely of national significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se, four-page due-process challenge to a California trial judge's refusal to recuse in a municipal short-term-rental nuisance case; interlocutory posture, no split, no institutional party, nothing beyond the parties turns on it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional requirement for reasoned recusal decisions could affect state courts broadly, but this record concerns an individual municipal-enforcement dispute and does not substantiate a systemic conflict or extraordinary judicial interest.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition challenging a state court judge's failure to recuse with unpreserved federal claims; negligible national significance.

Schmidt v. City of OmroA Wisconsin homeowner asked the Court to hear his claim that a judge should have told him about his appeal rights before dismissing his lawsuit; the Court denied review.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.03
0.20
0.00
0.08

Dan Schmidt v. City of Omro, Wisconsin, et al.No. 25-1293 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73363408 · models differ by up to 0.20 · topic: Constitutional rights

A Wisconsin homeowner asked the Court to hear his claim that a judge should have told him about his appeal rights before dismissing his lawsuit; the Court denied review.

What happened

Dan Schmidt sued the City of Omro, a bank, and an insurer, Employers Mutual Casualty Company (EMC), claiming a neighboring bank's new parking lot flooded his property and damaged his home. A Wisconsin trial court dismissed his claims against EMC and its adjuster, finding he had no legal right to sue them. The written dismissal order did not tell Schmidt about his right to appeal. He later missed the deadline, and Wisconsin's Court of Appeals dismissed his appeal as untimely, reasoning that the phrase "with prejudice" was enough notice. The Wisconsin Supreme Court denied further review. Schmidt, representing himself, then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

Schmidt asked the Court to decide whether the Constitution's guarantee of fair treatment by the states requires a trial judge to specifically tell a party about their right to appeal, in civil lawsuits over property damage and injury, not just in criminal cases. He also asked whether courts can excuse that requirement simply because the dismissal order used the words "with prejudice."

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026 the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Schmidt, who brought the case to the Court, asked it to reverse the Wisconsin Supreme Court's decision and reinstate his appeal against EMC and its adjuster. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Wisconsin courts' rulings in place: Schmidt's appeal remains dismissed as untimely, and EMC and its adjuster remain out of the lawsuit. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the Wisconsin courts' reasoning, only that it will not review the case further.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se homeowner's tort suit against an insurer, dismissed below as an untimely state appeal; the QP would extend criminal-appeal admonishment doctrine to civil dismissals, but the case is fact-bound and would settle nothing beyond itself.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.20·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A constitutional duty to advise civil litigants of appeal rights could affect state-court practice broadly, but the presented dispute concerns a fact-specific Wisconsin appeal-finality problem in private tort and insurance litigation.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine pro se petition arising from a state civil tort dismissal, raising no significant legal questions.

Nancy Roncati Dowden v. Deutsche Bank National TrustA homeowner facing foreclosure asks the Court to pause a Connecticut court ruling against her while she pursues further review.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.15
0.05
0.08

Nancy Roncati Dowden v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as TrusteeNo. 26A680 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000680 · models differ by up to 0.12

A homeowner facing foreclosure asks the Court to pause a Connecticut court ruling against her while she pursues further review.

What happened

Nancy Dowden, the applicant, is involved in a foreclosure dispute with Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, acting as trustee. The matter was decided by the Supreme Court of Connecticut, which ruled against Dowden. Dowden has now applied to the United States Supreme Court for a stay, asking a single justice, Justice Sotomayor, to pause enforcement of the Connecticut court's decision. The docket record provided here does not describe the underlying facts of the dispute, the specific grounds for the Connecticut court's ruling, or the arguments Dowden makes in her application beyond the request itself.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to temporarily block enforcement of the state court's ruling against Dowden while she seeks further review, so that whatever the state court ordered does not take effect or continue while that review is pending.

Where it stands

Dowden filed her stay application on November 11, 2026, and it was submitted to Justice Sotomayor. The docket does not yet show any ruling on the application.

What each outcome would mean

Dowden, the applicant, is asking the Court to pause the Connecticut Supreme Court's ruling in favor of Deutsche Bank. If the stay is granted, enforcement of that ruling would be paused while Dowden pursues further review, leaving her in possession or otherwise unaffected by the judgment for now. If the stay is denied, the Connecticut court's decision would remain in effect, allowing Deutsche Bank to proceed with enforcing it. Either way, this would be a temporary order; it would not decide the underlying dispute, which could continue through further proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: Nancy Roncati Dowden gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: Nancy Roncati Dowden does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A homeowner representing herself asked Justice Sotomayor to pause a Connecticut court hearing in a dispute with a bank over her house while she prepares an appeal to the Supreme Court. The request will almost certainly be denied: about a one in a hundred chance of success. Such stays (temporary pauses of a lower court's proceedings) are rarely granted to private parties, and this dispute turns on its own facts in a state case that is still ongoing, which the Court seldom steps into.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se stay application in a single-property Connecticut foreclosure dispute; no stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Nancy Roncati Dowden's request to pause her Connecticut foreclosure proceedings. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of relief, assuming the request does not become moot. Her allegations that disability prevented meaningful participation, and the threat to her home, are serious. But the unfinished state case and fact-specific disputes make Supreme Court intervention unlikely. I expect a brief order, probably without explanation, around the November 16 hearing rather than a ruling on the underlying mortgage dispute.

    Why this big-case score: Potentially severe consequences for one homeowner and important disability-access interests, but a fact-specific, unpublished foreclosure dispute without a demonstrated conflict of authority.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is overwhelmingly likely to **deny** Nancy Roncati Dowden's emergency stay application, with only a half-percent (about one in two hundred) chance of granting any relief. Dowden, representing herself without a lawyer, asks Justice Sonia Sotomayor to halt an ongoing Connecticut state-court mortgage foreclosure hearing based on disability-accommodation and fair-hearing objections. However, the Supreme Court generally may review state cases only after a final judgment—meaning a decision that finishes the state lawsuit—and here the Connecticut courts have decided only initial liability, while state law still provides an automatic pause on losing the home once a final foreclosure judgment is appealed.

    Why this big-case score: Single-property pro se residential foreclosure stay dispute turning on case-specific state continuance and finality rulings, with negligible broader impact unless the Court unexpectedly reached ADA Title II / § 1257 finality doctrine.

Veto v. BoeingA former Boeing employee asked the Court to revive his wrongful termination lawsuit against Boeing; the Court declined to hear the case.decided
0.03
0.18
0.01
0.07

Christopher Veto v. The Boeing Companyscotus/73318133 · models differ by up to 0.17

A former Boeing employee asked the Court to revive his wrongful termination lawsuit against Boeing; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Christopher Veto, a former Boeing employee, sued Boeing in federal district court claiming he was wrongfully fired after reporting what he said was illegal drug use at a Boeing facility in Long Beach, California. The district court granted summary judgment to Boeing in October 2024, finding Veto lacked an objectively reasonable belief that his complaints disclosed a legal violation and that no evidence corroborated his claims. The Ninth Circuit affirmed that decision in February 2026. Veto, representing himself, then asked the Supreme Court to take up the case.

What the Court is being asked

Veto's petition raises many issues, including whether federal drug law overrides California law as applied to Boeing, what penalties Boeing should face for alleged safety and disclosure failures, whether Boeing operates as an illegal monopoly, and whether the Ninth Circuit mischaracterized his case. At its core, the petition asks the Court to find that the lower courts were wrong to reject his claim that he was legally protected when he reported suspected drug use at his workplace.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026. On October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Veto, as the petitioner, asked the Court to hear his case after losing in the lower courts. The denial means the Court will not review the case, so the Ninth Circuit's decision affirming summary judgment for Boeing stands. This is not a ruling that the lower courts were correct on the merits; it simply leaves their decision in place, with no further review by the Supreme Court. Boeing's win in the courts below remains final.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se single-plaintiff employment-retaliation dispute resolved on an unpublished Ninth Circuit memorandum; the respondent is a household name but nothing about the petition's questions would matter beyond this litigant if decided.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Workplace whistleblower protection and aviation safety have public importance, but this petition presents an individual wrongful-termination dispute rather than an established vehicle for the sweeping regulatory remedies it requests.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition with legally incoherent claims.

Mazza v. Bank of New York MellonThe Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive their appeal of a bank's ejectment judgment against them, filed two days late.Civil proceduredecided
0.04
0.18
0.00
0.07

Mark Mazza, et ux. v. Bank of New York MellonNo. 25-1331 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500232 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a couple's bid to revive their appeal of a bank's ejectment judgment against them, filed two days late.

What happened

Mark and Lisa Mazza, representing themselves, lost a foreclosure case and a later ejectment judgment to Bank of New York Mellon over their Pennsylvania home. After the district court denied their motion challenging that judgment, they filed their notice of appeal two days past the deadline, saying they relied on a paralegal's mistaken advice and were away on a preplanned vacation. The district court denied their request for more time, finding no excusable neglect, and the Third Circuit affirmed. The Mazzas also argued the judgment itself was never properly entered under court rules, meaning their appeal was not really late at all.

What the Court is being asked

The Mazzas ask the Court to decide whether the lower courts were wrong to refuse them extra time to appeal, given their explanation for the short delay and their argument that the bank suffered no harm from it. They also ask whether federal appeals courts disagree with each other about how forgiving judges should be toward litigants who miss filing deadlines for reasons like this, and whether that disagreement needs to be resolved. Separately, they argue the judgment was never formally entered the way court rules require, which they say means their appeal deadline had not even started running.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

The Mazzas asked the Court to take up their case and overturn the Third Circuit's ruling, which had sided with the bank by upholding the denial of more time to appeal. By denying the petition, the Court left the Third Circuit's decision in place, meaning the Mazzas' appeal of the ejectment judgment remains barred as untimely and the bank's position stands. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning, only that it chose not to review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se homeowner's decade-long foreclosure/ejectment fight reaching the Court as a two-days-late notice of appeal under Rule 4(a)(5); even decided, it would settle an abuse-of-discretion call on one unpublished record.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Appeal-extension standards have recurring procedural importance, but this petition concerns fact-specific postjudgment litigation over one household's property rather than a demonstrated categorical conflict with broad consequences.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition arising from a routine residential foreclosure dispute and a missed appellate deadline; presents no issues of national importance.

Lowery v. Cheboygan Area SchoolsA former school bus driver asks the Court to revive his lawsuit claiming Michigan wrongly denied him unemployment benefits during summer breaks.Agencies & benefitsawaiting the Court
0.02
0.18
0.02
0.07

Marlin D. Lowery v. Cheboygan Area Schools, et al.No. 26-386 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000386 · models differ by up to 0.16 · topic: Agencies & benefits

A former school bus driver asks the Court to revive his lawsuit claiming Michigan wrongly denied him unemployment benefits during summer breaks.

What happened

Marlin Lowery drove a school bus for Cheboygan Area Public Schools. When his hours were cut each summer, Michigan's Unemployment Insurance Agency denied his benefits under a state law that blocks summer unemployment pay for school employees who have assurance of returning to work in the fall. After losing before an administrative judge and in state court, Lowery sued the school district and state agency in federal court, arguing his constitutional due process rights were violated. A federal district court dismissed his complaint for failing to state a valid claim, finding he had no protected property interest in benefits he was never found eligible to receive. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal, and later denied his request for rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

Lowery's petition raises several issues: whether the Michigan law denying summer benefits to school employees conflicts with an older federal law meant to extend unemployment coverage to school workers, whether a later Michigan amendment should have changed the outcome, and whether he was treated differently because of his sex in violation of equal protection guarantees, since he says a female coworker received benefits he was denied.

Where it stands

The respondents waived their right to file a response. The petition was distributed for the Court's December 4, 2026 conference, where the justices will decide whether to take up the case.

What each outcome would mean

Lowery, the petitioner, is asking the Court to hear his case and reverse the Sixth Circuit's decision. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to hear the case and decide the legal questions Lowery raises, without yet deciding who is right. If the Court denies the petition, the Sixth Circuit's ruling affirming dismissal of Lowery's lawsuit stays in place, and his claims remain dismissed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 8, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Lowery's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Lowery's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se school bus driver's individual unemployment-benefits dispute, dismissed below for failure to state a federal claim; the questions presented are idiosyncratic to the petitioner and no institutional party, split, or doctrinal question is in play, so even a decision would have no reach beyond this claimant.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.22·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on seasonal school-worker unemployment eligibility could affect many workers, but this record presents an individual benefits dispute and alleged disparate treatment without a demonstrated national conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.10·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely refuse to hear this case. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about 3 in 1,000. A former school bus driver, representing himself, challenges Michigan's rule that denies summer unemployment benefits to school workers who are expected back in the fall. The appeals court rejected his claim in a short, unpublished order. The state declined to file a response, and the case raises no conflict between courts. Cases like this are almost always turned away.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se claim over one school bus driver's summer unemployment benefits under a long-standing, federally sanctioned between-terms denial rule; no broader stakes.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Marlin Lowery's request to review the denial of unemployment benefits connected to his school-bus work. I estimate a three-in-a-thousand chance of any grant of review. The lower court found that key arguments were not properly raised and that his complaint did not adequately state a constitutional claim. The petition shows no clear disagreement among courts requiring Supreme Court intervention. I expect a routine denial after the scheduled December conference, without additional consideration or a separate opinion.

    Why this big-case score: School employees' unemployment benefits have meaningful practical stakes, but this procedurally defective individual suit presents no demonstrated national conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny this petition for review, with a grant probability of 0.2% (about one in five hundred). The petitioner, a Michigan school bus driver representing himself without a lawyer, challenges the denial of state unemployment benefits during summer school breaks. Because the state respondents waived their right to file an opposing brief and the federal appeals court below dismissed the case in a routine, unpublished order after finding that the petitioner forfeited his main constitutional arguments and raised his sex-discrimination claim too late, the Supreme Court has no clean legal question or conflict among lower courts to resolve.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se challenge to a state school-break unemployment benefits denial with forfeited claims and no circuit split.

Andron Miguel Francis v. Allstate InsuranceThe Court declined to hear Andron Miguel Francis's bid to revive a lawsuit against Allstate after Georgia courts dismissed his appeal as untimely.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.02
0.18
0.01
0.07

Andron Miguel Francis v. Allstate Insurance CompanyNo. 25-1218 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73246321 · models differ by up to 0.17 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Court declined to hear Andron Miguel Francis's bid to revive a lawsuit against Allstate after Georgia courts dismissed his appeal as untimely.

What happened

Francis sued Allstate Insurance Company in Georgia state court. The State Court of Gwinnett County granted summary judgment for Allstate in April 2024, and later denied Francis's motion for reconsideration. Representing himself, Francis tried to appeal, but the Georgia Court of Appeals dismissed his discretionary appeal as untimely. The Georgia Supreme Court denied further review in September 2025. Francis then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the case, arguing that the dismissal unfairly cut off his right to appeal.

What the Court is being asked

Francis asks the Court to decide whether dismissing his appeal over a missed filing deadline violated his right to fair treatment under the law, and whether courts' strict enforcement of filing rules against people representing themselves without a lawyer unfairly blocks them from appellate review. He also argues courts are supposed to read filings from self-represented litigants generously rather than reject them over technical mistakes.

Where it stands

The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026, after considering it at a conference on September 28, 2026. Allstate had waived its right to respond to the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Francis, as the petitioner, asked the Court to hear his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Georgia courts' rulings in place: the dismissal of his appeal as untimely stands, and the underlying summary judgment for Allstate remains final. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower courts were right — it simply means the case ends here without the Supreme Court reviewing the question Francis raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petitioner's individual insurance dispute against Allstate, lost on a state procedural default; the generalized pro se access-to-appeal questions carry no precedential stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A ruling on constitutional limits to procedural barriers for self-represented civil appellants could affect many litigants, but this record presents an individual insurance dispute without a developed showing of systemic exclusion or a conflict among courts.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A case-specific procedural default dispute involving a pro se state-court appellant; no broader significance.

Doe v. KennedyThe Court declined to hear a vaccine-injury claimant's bid to overturn lower court rulings on her compensation case.decided
0.02
0.18
0.00
0.07

Jane Doe v. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Secretary of Health and Human ServicesNo. 25-1300 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73372297 · models differ by up to 0.18

The Court declined to hear a vaccine-injury claimant's bid to overturn lower court rulings on her compensation case.

What happened

Jane Doe, representing herself, filed a claim under the federal vaccine injury compensation program, arguing that vaccines she received caused and then worsened her multiple sclerosis. The United States Court of Federal Claims awarded her damages but, according to her petition, did not include everything she believes she is owed, and she says earlier attorneys and a special master mishandled her case, including missing deadlines and excluding evidence. She appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which ruled against her, upholding the lower court's handling of her case. She then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.

What the Court is being asked

The petition asks the Court to decide whether a judgment can stand when the petitioner says the proceedings below were marred by misconduct, mishandling of evidence, and missed deadlines she attributes to circumstances beyond her control, and whether a ruling can stand that she says relied on records obtained in violation of privacy laws.

Where it stands

The Secretary of Health and Human Services waived the right to respond to the petition. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the petition was denied on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Jane Doe asked the Court to take up her case. The denial means the Court will not review the Federal Circuit's decision, so that court's ruling against her stands, leaving the lower courts' handling of her compensation claim and damages award in place. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court found the lower courts correct on the merits of her claims; it simply leaves those decisions as the final word in her case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single claimant's Vaccine Injury Compensation Program damages dispute, affirmed below in a nonprecedential order on a timeliness ground; the petition raises grievances rather than a legal question, so a decision either way would carry no doctrinal or public consequence beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Vaccine-compensation procedure and medical-record privacy have broader importance, but this petition chiefly seeks correction of an individual damages proceeding behind a disputed review deadline.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A frivolous petition alleging judicial collusion and health fraud.

Blevins v. Alabama State BarThe Supreme Court declined to review an Alabama lawyer's challenge to his law license suspension over a fee dispute.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.03
0.12
0.05
0.07

Jerry M. Blevins v. Alabama State BarNo. 25-1344 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500245 · models differ by up to 0.09 · topic: Constitutional rights

The Supreme Court declined to review an Alabama lawyer's challenge to his law license suspension over a fee dispute.

What happened

Jerry Blevins, an Alabama attorney, had a fee dispute with a client in 2017 and filed a declaratory judgment action under a state law governing disputed attorney fees. The circuit court resolved the fee dispute in 2018. In 2022 the Alabama State Bar brought disciplinary charges against Blevins over the same fee dispute. A disciplinary board found him guilty of failing to communicate and charging an excessive fee, and suspended his law license for six months. Blevins argued that because he had relied on the state fee-dispute law, disciplining him violated his right to fair process. The Alabama Supreme Court rejected that argument and upheld the discipline, then denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked whether the Alabama Supreme Court's reading of the state fee-dispute statute, and the way that reading was applied to Blevins, deprived him of fair notice and a fair process before his law license was suspended, as the Constitution's guarantee of due process requires.

Where it stands

The Alabama State Bar waived its right to respond to the petition. The Court distributed the case for its September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Blevins, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up his case and overturn the Alabama Supreme Court's ruling. Denial, which is what occurred, leaves the Alabama Supreme Court's decision in place: Blevins's six-month suspension and public reprimand stand, and the Alabama State Bar's position prevails. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed that the lower court's interpretation of the statute was correct; it simply leaves that ruling undisturbed without deciding the constitutional question Blevins raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A single attorney's six-month suspension for a fee dispute, turning on one Alabama statute; no split, no amici, no institutional party beyond a state bar. Denied or granted, it would move nothing outside this docket.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Professional-license discipline matters substantially to the petitioner, but the presented dispute concerns reliance on a particular Alabama fee-dispute statute, without a demonstrated broader conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine, fact-bound procedural due process challenge to state bar disciplinary proceedings.

Michelet Michael Smith v. Keeley Anne SmithThe Supreme Court declined to review Michelet Michael Smith's challenge to an Arizona appeals court ruling in his divorce case.Civil proceduredecided
0.02
0.18
0.00
0.07

Michelet Michael Smith v. Keeley Anne SmithNo. 26-66 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000066 · models differ by up to 0.18 · topic: Civil procedure

The Supreme Court declined to review Michelet Michael Smith's challenge to an Arizona appeals court ruling in his divorce case.

What happened

Michelet Michael Smith and Keeley Anne Smith's divorce case was decided by the Maricopa County Superior Court, which issued a decree of dissolution. Smith, representing himself, appealed, arguing that hearing time limits violated his right to due process, that a problem with notice of a change in his legal counsel was wrongly dismissed as a technical error, and that he was denied a chance to complete the court record before the appeals court relied on its absence to reject his claims. The Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed the divorce decree, and the Arizona Supreme Court denied further review.

What the Court is being asked

Smith asks the Court to decide three related questions about fairness in state court proceedings: whether a state court can treat a federal constitutional claim as given up over a minor citation error when the court understood what he meant; whether a court can call a notice problem "technical" and harmless without specifically finding that it caused no harm; and whether it is fair for a court to deny a request to complete the case record and then use the missing material against the person who asked.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Smith, who lost in the Arizona Court of Appeals, asked the Supreme Court to take up his case. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Arizona Court of Appeals' decision in place, meaning the divorce decree and the rulings against Smith's due process arguments stand. The denial does not mean the Supreme Court agreed with the lower court's reasoning; it simply ends his effort to get the case heard there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

The models predicted this case at 2 points. Below are the predictions for the highlighted step; choose another marked step on the timeline to see its predictions.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se cert petition from a private divorce decree affirmed in an unpublished Arizona memorandum decision; the stakes reach no one beyond the two parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The questions invoke generally important due-process principles, but the unpublished, record-bound domestic dispute is unlikely to have broad legal or public significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downfull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se state family law dispute with no broad legal or national significance.

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition from an unpublished Arizona intermediate-court memorandum decision in a private marital-dissolution appeal; the questions are fact-bound due process grievances with no doctrinal reach beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.18·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A decision could affect procedural protections for self-represented family-law litigants, but the questions arise from an individual dissolution proceeding and particular waiver, notice, and missing-record rulings rather than a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A routine state family law (divorce) dispute with no national significance or broad federal implications.

Matsumura v. Court of Appeal of CaliforniaA doctor whose California medical license was revoked asked the Supreme Court to review that decision; the Court declined to hear the case.decided
0.03
0.15
0.01
0.06

Kenneth Matsumura v. Court of Appeal of California, First Appellate District, Division Five, et al.No. 25-1301 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73374809 · models differ by up to 0.14

A doctor whose California medical license was revoked asked the Supreme Court to review that decision; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Kenneth Matsumura, a California-licensed physician who developed a cancer treatment, had his medical license revoked by the California Medical Board after proceedings finding problems with his record-keeping, his treatment of three patients, and his fees. Matsumura, representing himself, says the process was unfair and that the board acted for financial reasons. His appeal was rejected by a California appeals court, which said he had not provided the lower court record; he says court staff mistakenly refused to accept it. The California Supreme Court denied review without comment. Matsumura then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the case.

What the Court is being asked

Matsumura's petition asks the Court to find that federal courts may step in when a state licensing action cuts off a medical treatment that benefits patients in another state or members of a Native American tribe, particularly where federal healthcare spending could be affected. He frames this as a matter the Constitution's provisions on federal judicial power and interstate commerce address.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and on October 5, 2026, the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Matsumura, the petitioner, asked the Court to review the revocation of his medical license. By denying the petition, the Court leaves in place the California Supreme Court's denial of review, which followed the appeals court's rejection of his appeal and the original license revocation by the Medical Board. This denial is not a ruling that those decisions were correct; it simply means the Supreme Court will not review them, and the license revocation stands.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se challenge to one physician's California license revocation, reaching the Court on an incoherent Article III / Commerce Clause theory after a state procedural default; no doctrine, split, or class of litigants turns on it.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    An individual medical-license dispute with potentially broader tribal-health and federalism implications, but the petition does not establish a developed conflict or substantiate its claimed national medical and fiscal effects.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Sanders v. City of Long BeachThe Court declined to hear a homeowner's bid to revive his lawsuit over flood damage he blamed on the City of Long Beach's pump maintenance.Civil proceduredecided
0.03
0.15
0.00
0.06

Leslie Sanders v. City of Long Beach, CaliforniaNo. 25-1235 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73272489 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a homeowner's bid to revive his lawsuit over flood damage he blamed on the City of Long Beach's pump maintenance.

What happened

Leslie Sanders, a Long Beach homeowner, sued the city after a February 2019 flood damaged his home, arguing the city knew a drainage pump was faulty and failed to fix it or warn residents. The Los Angeles County Superior Court ruled against Sanders in 2023. The California Court of Appeal affirmed that judgment in August 2025 and denied rehearing in September 2025. The California Supreme Court denied review in November 2025. Representing himself, Sanders then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

What the Court is being asked

Sanders argues the trial judge wrongly blocked him from introducing evidence and from challenging a city witness's inconsistent statements, and that the judge showed bias favoring the city. He asks the Court to decide whether these rulings violated his rights to a fair proceeding, to present evidence, and to confront witnesses, and whether the lower courts' decisions conflict with established legal rules on government liability for known dangerous conditions.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied it on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Sanders, as petitioner, asked the Court to hear his case. The denial means the Court will not review the matter, leaving the California Court of Appeal's ruling against Sanders in place. The City of Long Beach's win in the lower courts stands. The denial is not a ruling that the lower court was correct on the merits; it simply means Sanders's case ends without further review by this Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se homeowner's flood-damage negligence suit against a city, lost on state-law evidentiary and credibility rulings in an unpublished state intermediate appellate opinion; no doctrinal question of general reach, no split, no party beyond the two litigants affected.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Important property-loss and fair-hearing interests for affected homeowners, but the petition presents a localized municipal flooding and trial-evidence dispute without a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A highly fact-bound, state-law evidentiary dispute raised by a pro se petitioner.

Wray v. RTXA former RTX employee asks the Court to revive his whistleblower retaliation lawsuit after lower courts dismissed it.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.12
0.03
0.06

Jarin M. Wray v. RTX CorporationNo. 26-352 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000352 · models differ by up to 0.09

A former RTX employee asks the Court to revive his whistleblower retaliation lawsuit after lower courts dismissed it.

What happened

Jarin Wray, representing himself, worked for Collins Aerospace, a division of RTX Corporation, until RTX fired him in September 2024. Wray says he was fired for reporting what he believed was fraud involving an RTX contractor's business ties to China. He sued RTX, asserting violations of numerous federal laws, including whistleblower-protection statutes. The federal district court dismissed the case, finding most of the statutes Wray cited do not allow individuals to sue and that his remaining claims did not meet legal pleading requirements. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal, and later denied Wray's request for rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

Wray asks the Court to decide whether businesses operating in the United States that have ties to a foreign country can still claim the protections of American law while taking adverse action against someone who reports wrongdoing, and what actions a former government or military officeholder may take to address a perceived threat to the Constitution from foreign influence on the federal government.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference on November 13, 2026. The docket does not yet show any decision on whether the Court will hear the case.

What each outcome would mean

Wray, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case in full and decide the legal questions, without yet deciding who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of Wray's lawsuit would stand, leaving the case over and RTX's win in place. A denial would not mean the Court agrees the lower courts were right, only that the case ends there.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Wray's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Wray's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly decline to hear this case (about a 3-in-1,000 chance it agrees). A former Collins Aerospace employee, representing himself, sued RTX for firing him after he made whistleblower complaints. The trial court dismissed the case, and the appeals court affirmed in a short unpublished order. The petition asks broad, abstract questions about national security and whistleblowers rather than pointing to a specific legal conflict that the Justices need to resolve, so it is scheduled for a routine conference and will likely be turned away there.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se individual employment-retaliation dismissal affirmed by unpublished per curiam; questions are abstract and raise no legal issue of general importance.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline review of Jarin Wray's case against RTX. I estimate a 0.3% chance of any grant of review. The lower courts dismissed his whistleblower lawsuit for problems with the available legal claims and required allegations, and the petition does not identify a clear disagreement among appeals courts. I expect denial without an explanation, usually after the scheduled November conference, with no additional conference distribution or request for the federal government's views. This would not decide whether his factual allegations are true.

    Why this big-case score: Whistleblower protection at a defense contractor has potential public importance, but this record presents an individual pleading and exhaustion dispute, not a developed national legal conflict; the broader national-security assertions are allegations, not findings.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is virtually certain to deny Jarin M. Wray's petition for review (`denied`, with a 0.2% chance of a grant, or about one in five hundred). Representing himself without a lawyer, Wray sued his former employer, RTX Corporation, alleging he was fired for reporting alleged business ties to China, but a federal trial court dismissed his lawsuit for failing to meet basic filing requirements—such as completing required federal agency complaint steps before suing—and the appeals court summarily agreed. Because the petition raises no disagreement among lower courts, presents sweeping political arguments rather than a focused legal question, and RTX did not even need to file a response before the case was sent to the Justices' conference, the Court will turn the appeal away without comment.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se employment-dismissal appeal turning on unpreserved or unexhausted pleading defects under settled statutory standards, carrying minimal legal or public policy significance beyond the individual dispute.

Tatyana Evgenievna Drevaleva v. United StatesThe Court declined to hear a former VA employee's bid to revive her workplace discrimination case, which lower courts had dismissed as barred by an earlier ruling against her.Civil proceduredecided
0.02
0.15
0.00
0.06

Tatyana Evgenievna Drevaleva v. United States, et al.No. 25-1328 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73500231 · models differ by up to 0.15 · topic: Civil procedure

The Court declined to hear a former VA employee's bid to revive her workplace discrimination case, which lower courts had dismissed as barred by an earlier ruling against her.

What happened

Tatyana Drevaleva, a former probationary employee at a New Mexico VA hospital, lost an earlier discrimination lawsuit over her 2017 termination after taking leave to travel to Russia. After that case ended, she filed a new suit in the District of Columbia challenging a Merit Systems Protection Board decision in her case. The district court dismissed it, ruling it was barred because the same issues had already been decided against her. The D.C. Circuit affirmed, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

Drevaleva asked the Court to decide whether a prior dismissal can block a later lawsuit when, she says, the earlier court never fully examined the facts and legal rules involved, and whether courts must consider newly discovered facts before applying that bar. She also raised questions about whether the agency reviewing her firing had authority over her case and whether courts were required to reexamine the facts of her termination independently.

Where it stands

The government waived its right to respond, and the petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference. A related emergency application for an injunction was denied by the Chief Justice on July 16, 2026. The Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Drevaleva, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up her case. With the petition denied, the D.C. Circuit's ruling stands, meaning her lawsuit remains dismissed and the earlier decision against her continues to bar her claims. Had the Court granted the petition instead, it would have agreed to hear the case and decide the legal questions itself, deciding nothing about who was right merely by taking it up. The earlier denial of her emergency injunction request left her without court-ordered reinstatement while the case proceeded, a separate, temporary matter now closed along with the underlying case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se, fact-bound res judicata dispute over one former VA probationary employee's MSPB appeal; no institutional stakes beyond the parties, and the D.C. Circuit order below is unpublished.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.15·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Claim preclusion and federal employment-discrimination review have broader importance, but this petition centers on one employee's repeated litigation and identifies no developed inter-circuit conflict. Its personal stakes are substantial; its demonstrated systemic stakes are limited.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition raising fact-bound employment claims, not of national significance.

Adkins v. SyndicateThe Supreme Court declined to hear Dora Adkins's bid to revive a lawsuit against a hotel operator over alleged chemical exposure.decided
0.02
0.13
0.01
0.05

Dora L. Adkins v. Rosslyn Syndicate, LCNo. 26-152 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000152 · models differ by up to 0.12

The Supreme Court declined to hear Dora Adkins's bid to revive a lawsuit against a hotel operator over alleged chemical exposure.

What happened

Dora Adkins sued Rosslyn Syndicate, LC, which operates a hotel, after two stays there she says exposed her to chemical and food poisoning. The district court screened her proposed complaint under existing filing restrictions imposed because of her history of lawsuits, and denied her motion to file it, her motion to expedite, and her request for an emergency injunction, finding her claims implausible. The Fourth Circuit affirmed and separately ordered Adkins to explain why it should not bar her from further filings or impose sanctions, citing her litigation history. Adkins asked for rehearing, which was denied.

What the Court is being asked

Adkins asked the Court to decide whether the lower courts were wrong to block her complaint before it could proceed, whether the appeals court violated her right to fair notice by raising the possibility of a filing ban at the same time it ruled against her, and whether courts can use such restrictions to turn away claims of physical injury without reaching their merits.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's October 9, 2026 conference, and on October 13, 2026 the Court denied it.

What each outcome would mean

Adkins, as petitioner, asked the Court to overturn the Fourth Circuit's decision. The denial leaves that decision in place: the lower courts' refusal to let her file the complaint, their denial of emergency relief, and the appeals court's affirmance all stand. Rosslyn Syndicate faces no further proceedings in this case before the Supreme Court. The denial does not mean the Court agreed the lower courts were right, only that it will not review the case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 13, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 13, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-13: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se personal-injury dispute with a hotel, reaching the Court on an unpublished per curiam affirmance of the denial of leave to file an emergency complaint; no legal question of general application, no split, no government party, and no public attention.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.13·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The individual emergency-relief dispute has limited apparent systemic reach, although a decision establishing safeguards for prefiling restrictions could affect access to courts more broadly.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition seeking error correction of routine procedural orders.

Gnanam v. Nathaniel Chibuzor KeitaA Florida couple who lost a landlord-tenant lawsuit ask the Supreme Court to overturn that judgment, arguing it was entered in violation of the tenants' bankruptcy case.awaiting the Court
0.02
0.12
0.02
0.05

Palanikumar V. Gnanam, et ux. v. Nathaniel Chibuzor Keita, et al.No. 26-602 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000602 · models differ by up to 0.10

A Florida couple who lost a landlord-tenant lawsuit ask the Supreme Court to overturn that judgment, arguing it was entered in violation of the tenants' bankruptcy case.

What happened

Palanikumar and Mullairani Gnanam, former landlords, lost a Duval County lawsuit brought by their tenants, Nathaniel Chibuzor Keita and Lana Paige Tompkins, over a lease dispute. A trial judge entered judgment against the Gnanams in 2024, and an appeals court affirmed and awarded additional fees in August 2025. The Florida Supreme Court declined further review the same month. While the case was on appeal, Keita filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy; the Gnanams say this was hidden from them and from the state courts, and that later orders continued to enforce the judgment despite the bankruptcy. They represent themselves throughout.

What the Court is being asked

The Gnanams ask the Court to decide whether a state court can enforce a judgment, and reject a challenge to that judgment, without accounting for a federal bankruptcy filing by the party who won the judgment — specifically, whether doing so conflicts with federal rules that automatically pause collection efforts once someone files for bankruptcy, and with federal rules about what a bankruptcy discharge wipes out. They also ask whether the state courts denied them a fair chance to raise these arguments.

Where it stands

The petition for certiorari was filed January 14, 2026, after the Court granted two extensions of time to file. The docket shows no indication yet of a response being filed or any action by the Court.

What each outcome would mean

The Gnanams, as petitioners, are asking the Court to overturn the Florida courts' rulings against them. If the Court denies review, the judgment and fee awards against the Gnanams, which Keita and Tompkins won below, would stand. If the Court grants review, it would hear full arguments and decide the legal questions about bankruptcy's effect on the state court proceedings; a ruling could then affirm the lower decision, reverse it in the Gnanams' favor, or send the case back without resolving it for either side.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 9, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 9, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Gnanam's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Gnanam's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict the Supreme Court will very likely turn down this case. We put the chance it agrees to hear it at about 4 in 1,000. The petitioners, a couple representing themselves, lost a county-court money dispute in Florida. They argue the judgment is void because the other side secretly filed for bankruptcy, which pauses lawsuits against the person filing. The state appeals court affirmed without writing an opinion. The case raises no broad legal conflict, so the Court is very unlikely to take it.

    Why this big-case score: A private county-court judgment/garnishment dispute between individuals, framed around one debtor's undisclosed Chapter 7 filing; no stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.12·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline this appeal: I estimate a 0.4% chance it agrees to review any part of it. The petition challenges a private landlord-tenant judgment using bankruptcy law, but the bankrupt person was owed the judgment, rather than owing it. Separate questions about who may collect that asset remain possible. Still, the petition does not present a clear conflict between appellate courts, and several complaints concern later proceedings rather than the judgment being appealed. I expect no written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Bankruptcy supremacy matters broadly, but this petition principally challenges fact-bound rulings in a private landlord-tenant judgment and collection dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny review in this case, with less than a one-in-five-hundred chance (0.2%) of granting the petition. The case arises from a $24,973 Florida county-court landlord-tenant security-deposit and garnishment judgment in which the landlords represent themselves without an attorney. Although the landlords argue that one tenant's later personal bankruptcy voided the judgment against them, federal bankruptcy law protects the person who filed for bankruptcy from creditors rather than wiping out debts that other people owe to that person, and the case presents no conflict among lower courts.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se state county-court residential landlord-tenant and garnishment dispute ($24,973.51 judgment) with severe vehicle defects and no broader doctrinal significance.

Schultz v. BOFKA Virginia debtor asks the Chief Justice for emergency orders blocking a foreclosure sale and a district judge's ruling while his related appeals continue.awaiting the Court
0.03
0.08
0.03
0.05

Paul Schultz v. BOFK, N.A.No. 26A684 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000684 · models differ by up to 0.05

A Virginia debtor asks the Chief Justice for emergency orders blocking a foreclosure sale and a district judge's ruling while his related appeals continue.

What happened

Paul Schultz, a pro se bankruptcy debtor, has been litigating for years over claims by creditor BOKF, N.A. and a related entity, Clear Sky Financial, concerning a loan and a property called Kapalua. The bankruptcy court granted BOKF relief from the automatic stay that normally protects a debtor's property during bankruptcy, clearing the way for a foreclosure sale scheduled for December 17, 2026. Schultz sought a stay first from the bankruptcy court and the district court, both of which denied his requests, and from the Fourth Circuit, which denied a related mandamus petition and has a rehearing petition still pending. Schultz now brings this application directly to the Chief Justice, the Justice assigned to handle emergency matters from the Fourth Circuit.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to temporarily pause two things while Schultz's appeals continue: a federal district judge entering a final ruling on his bankruptcy appeal, and any enforcement of the bankruptcy court's order that would allow his home to be sold at foreclosure. Schultz argues the district judge should not rule because a pending challenge to her continuing to handle the case has not yet been resolved, and that losing the home before that challenge is decided would make later review meaningless.

Where it stands

The application was submitted to the Chief Justice on November 10, 2026, and docketed November 13, 2026. The docket shows no order yet granting or denying the requested stay.

What each outcome would mean

Schultz, the applicant, is asking the Court to pause the lower proceedings. If the Chief Justice grants a stay, the district judge's ruling and the foreclosure sale would be put on hold temporarily while Schultz's appeals proceed, without deciding who is ultimately right. If the stay is denied, the district judge could rule and the foreclosure sale could proceed as scheduled, while Schultz's underlying appeals continue separately. Either way, this request does not decide the merits of Schultz's claims against BOKF or his challenge to the judge's participation.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 14, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: Schultz gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: Schultz does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly refuse this request — about a one-in-a-hundred chance of any relief. A man representing himself asked the Chief Justice for a stay (a temporary order freezing things) to stop a bank's foreclosure sale and pause his bankruptcy appeal after a lower appeals court turned him down. Requests like this from self-represented litigants in private property disputes are denied nearly every time, usually in a one-line order with no explanation, and two similar requests he filed days earlier were quickly denied.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se debtor's bid to halt a single residential foreclosure and a district-court bankruptcy appeal; no question of general importance.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Paul Schultz's request to pause a bankruptcy appeal and prevent a foreclosure while lower courts consider his challenge to the judge's participation. I estimate about a two-in-one-hundred chance of obtaining at least some of the requested relief. Losing a home is a serious concern, but the application presents a complicated, fact-specific dispute and does not clearly show why immediate Supreme Court intervention is warranted. I expect a brief denial, probably without an explanation.

    Why this big-case score: Serious consequences for one homeowner, but an individualized bankruptcy and recusal dispute without a demonstrated nationwide conflict.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 0%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Chief Justice Roberts will almost certainly deny this emergency request, with only about a two-in-a-thousand (0.2%) chance of granting any stay. Paul Schultz, representing himself without a lawyer, asks the Supreme Court to pause a bankruptcy appeal and block a December 17, 2026 home foreclosure while he seeks rehearing of a refusal to disqualify—remove from the case—the federal district judge assigned below. Because lower-court requests remain pending, routine appeal routes exist, and the Chief Justice just denied two similar emergency requests by Schultz, solo denial without full-Court action is overwhelming.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se bankruptcy recusal and residential foreclosure stay request pending circuit rehearing; personal stakes for one debtor, no broader legal or public salience.

Watkins v. United States District CourtA man seeks emergency Supreme Court orders stopping child-support enforcement and restoring his suspended licenses while he pursues a separate mandamus petition.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.02
—
0.05
0.04 2 of 3 models

Allen Watkins v. United States District Court for District of ArizonaNo. 25A622 · scotus/73279700 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Business & finance

A man seeks emergency Supreme Court orders stopping child-support enforcement and restoring his suspended licenses while he pursues a separate mandamus petition.

What happened

Allen Watkins, representing himself, says an arbitration award from February 2024 should have been confirmed by the United States District Court for the District of Arizona under federal arbitration law. He says the district court refused to confirm it and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has not acted on his mandamus petition, which he says it improperly converted into an appeal. Meanwhile, Arizona and Illinois child-support agencies have suspended his driver's licenses and garnished income, which he says has caused severe financial hardship for him and his children.

What the Court is being asked

Watkins asks a single justice to pause all child-support enforcement actions against him, including wage garnishment and license suspensions, and to order his licenses reinstated immediately, while a separate request asking the Court to order lower courts to confirm his arbitration award is pending.

Where it stands

The application for a stay was submitted to Justice Kagan, the circuit justice for the Ninth Circuit, on November 18, 2025. The docket shows no order yet resolving the application.

What each outcome would mean

Watkins, the applicant, is asking for emergency relief. If granted, the order would pause enforcement by the Arizona and Illinois child-support agencies and restore his suspended licenses temporarily, while his related mandamus petition and the underlying arbitration dispute continue in the lower courts. If denied, the current suspensions, garnishments, and other enforcement actions would remain in effect while those proceedings continue. Either way, the stay decision itself would not resolve whether the arbitration award must be confirmed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: Watkins gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: Watkins does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se stay application against a federal district court (a mandamus posture out of the Ninth Circuit) with no counsel, no amici and no identifiable public stake; whatever the disposition, it affects one litigant.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The snapshot identifies a stay application but supplies neither its underlying dispute nor the relief's practical reach, so its stakes cannot be placed reliably.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se application against a district court, lacking any indicia of national importance or legal significance.

Perkins v. United States District CourtCassandra Perkins asked the Supreme Court for emergency injunctive relief against a federal district court and others; the Court denied the request.Civil proceduredecidedpossible leak
0.02
0.05
—
0.04 2 of 3 models

Cassandra Perkins v. United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, et al.No. 26A256 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000256 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Civil procedure

Cassandra Perkins asked the Supreme Court for emergency injunctive relief against a federal district court and others; the Court denied the request.

What happened

Cassandra Perkins, representing herself, filed an application for emergency injunctive relief against the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia and other defendants. The filing refers to and incorporates an earlier, separate petition for certiorari Perkins had filed concerning a dispute with United Health Group Optum. In this application, Perkins asked the Court to step in immediately, citing claimed harms including possible homelessness, harm to her professional standing, and loss of due process, and asked for an expedited hearing. The application came out of proceedings in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.

What the Court is being asked

Perkins asked a single justice to order immediate relief to stop alleged ongoing harm from the lower courts and named defendants while her broader case continues, without waiting for the normal course of appeals or a full hearing.

Where it stands

Justice Thomas, to whom the application was submitted, denied the application on August 28, 2026. The docket shows no further action.

What each outcome would mean

Perkins, as the applicant, sought emergency court intervention. Had the application been granted, it would have temporarily paused or blocked the challenged actions of the district court and other defendants while Perkins's underlying case continued elsewhere. Because it was denied, no such pause takes effect: the challenged proceedings and conditions Perkins objected to remain in place for now, and the denial does not decide the merits of her broader claims, which may continue in other proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 31, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedAug 28, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-08-28: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se, IFP-linked application to enjoin the district court hearing the applicant's own ADA employment suits; no doctrinal question, no party or public constituency beyond the applicant.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.05·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itpossible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The sparse record presents an individual procedural dispute rather than an application likely to establish a broadly significant rule.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itpossible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Farr v. GrantJoan Farr asked the Court to revive her lawsuit against Alexandra Grant, entertainment-industry figures, and federal agencies; the Court declined to hear the case.decided
0.02
0.08
0.00
0.03

Joan E. Farr v. Alexandra Grant, et al.No. 25-1306 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73389313 · models differ by up to 0.08

Joan Farr asked the Court to revive her lawsuit against Alexandra Grant, entertainment-industry figures, and federal agencies; the Court declined to hear the case.

What happened

Joan Farr, representing herself, sued Alexandra Grant and grantLOVE LLC, attorney Scott Sims and his firm Ziffren Brittenham LLP, WME IMG, and several federal agencies, alleging a decades-long conspiracy that violated her constitutional rights, including denying her the ability to hold public office. The federal district court in Missouri dismissed her case entirely. The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed that dismissal, and later denied her request for the full court to rehear the case.

What the Court is being asked

Farr asked the Court to decide whether the lower courts were wrong to dismiss her case without letting it go to trial, whether the evidence she presented should have been enough to let her claims proceed, whether the Missouri court had authority to hear the case at all, and whether various constitutional and procedural errors occurred along the way.

Where it stands

The respondents all waived their right to file responses. The case was distributed for the Court's conference on September 28, 2026, and the Court denied the petition on October 5, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Farr, as petitioner, asked the Court to take up her case and reverse the lower courts' rulings against her. By denying the petition, the Court leaves the Eighth Circuit's decision in place, meaning the dismissal of Farr's lawsuit stands and the case will not return to trial. The denial does not mean the Court agreed with the lower courts' reasoning; it simply means the Court chose not to review the case further, and no court has ruled on the underlying merits of Farr's claims at this level.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se serial litigant's conspiracy suit against federal agencies and private entertainment-industry parties, dismissed below on the pleadings and affirmed per curiam; no legal question of general importance and no institutional stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.08·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The petition concerns an individual's civil-rights and jurisdictional dispute. Its broad constitutional framing and prominent names do not establish a generally consequential legal question on the supplied record; this stakes assessment is separate from grant likelihood.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition alleging a 25-year conspiracy to deny the right to run for President; patently frivolous.

Hall v. Eastern Panhandle Anesthesia AssociatesA former anesthesiologist asks the Court to revive his appeal after the Fourth Circuit dismissed it for lack of jurisdiction over his discrimination and retaliation claims.awaiting the Court
0.03
—
0.03
0.03 2 of 3 models

Timothy Hall v. Eastern Panhandle Anesthesia Associates, et al.No. 26-542 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000542 · models differ by up to 0.00

A former anesthesiologist asks the Court to revive his appeal after the Fourth Circuit dismissed it for lack of jurisdiction over his discrimination and retaliation claims.

What happened

Timothy Hall sued his former employer, Eastern Panhandle Anesthesia Associates, and several other hospitals, agencies, and officials, alleging disability discrimination, retaliation for whistleblowing, and related claims under federal and state law. The district court dismissed most claims with prejudice, dismissed two defendants without prejudice for improper service, and ordered Hall's claims against his former employer sent to arbitration, staying that part of the case. Hall appealed, but the Fourth Circuit dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction, reasoning that the order was not final because the arbitration stay left part of the case still pending. The court of appeals later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether an appeals court may treat an order sending part of a case to arbitration as blocking an appeal, without first considering that the state court which originally ordered arbitration in an earlier, related lawsuit had later lifted that order and dismissed the case. The petition also asks whether a company can send a worker's discrimination and whistleblower claims to arbitration based on that earlier, since-dismissed state court arbitration order, when the worker argues the arbitration agreement does not clearly cover those kinds of legal claims.

Where it stands

The petition was filed on October 19, 2026, and the respondents have filed waivers of their right to respond, meaning they do not plan to file opposing briefs unless the Court requests one. The case has not yet been scheduled for the justices to consider at a conference.

What each outcome would mean

Hall, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide whether the appeals court wrongly dismissed his appeal and whether his claims were properly sent to arbitration. If the Court denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's dismissal stands, leaving Hall's claims against his former employer in arbitration and the rest of his case dismissed, with no appellate review of those rulings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 16, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decides
  • If granted: The Court takes up Hall's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Hall's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A self-represented individual's private dispute with a medical practice out of the Fourth Circuit; nothing on the docket suggests stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    No questions presented, petition text, or lower-court opinion was provisioned; the caption and docket skeleton do not establish the issue or its broader stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se employment-termination and disability-discrimination dispute arising from an unpublished Fourth Circuit per curiam disposition and an interlocutory district court order compelling arbitration as to the former employer while dismissing time-barred and non-employer claims.

Katherine L. Hobbins Forester, et al. v. Adam Gerol, et al.Applicants facing Wisconsin criminal proceedings asked a single Justice to block their arrest pending appeal; the Justice denied the request.Habeas & post-convictiondecided
0.02
0.04
—
0.03 2 of 3 models

Katherine L. Hobbins Forester, et al. v. Adam Gerol, et al.No. 26A245 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000245 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Habeas & post-conviction

Applicants facing Wisconsin criminal proceedings asked a single Justice to block their arrest pending appeal; the Justice denied the request.

What happened

Katherine Lou Hobbins Forester and James Hobbins Forester, representing themselves, face Wisconsin criminal prosecutions and related bond conditions. They filed a federal habeas petition challenging their custody, which the district court dismissed, also declining to issue a certificate of appealability (permission needed to pursue certain habeas appeals). The Seventh Circuit denied a certificate of appealability and related emergency motions, finding the applicants had not exhausted state-court remedies or shown that doing so was impossible. The applicants then sought rehearing in the Seventh Circuit and, with hearings scheduled in Wisconsin courts, asked the Supreme Court's Circuit Justice for emergency relief to stop enforcement of appearance requirements while the appeal proceeded.

What the Court is being asked

The application asks whether an order temporarily blocking arrest, detention, or other enforcement is needed to preserve the applicants' ability to obtain federal court review, while they argue that Wisconsin's court processes have been ineffective at addressing their claims in time, and that the lower federal courts were wrong to require a showing that using state remedies was impossible rather than just ineffective.

Where it stands

The application was submitted to Justice Barrett on August 17, 2026, and she denied it on August 27, 2026. The underlying appeal and rehearing request continue in the Seventh Circuit.

What each outcome would mean

The applicants, Katherine and James Hobbins Forester, asked for emergency protection from arrest and other enforcement while their appeal continued. Denying the application, which is what happened, leaves the Seventh Circuit's orders in place and does not stop the Wisconsin proceedings or appearance requirements the applicants sought to block. It does not decide the underlying legal questions about exhaustion of state remedies or the habeas claims, which remain before the Seventh Circuit. Had the application been granted instead, it would have temporarily paused enforcement while that litigation continued.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofAug 29, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedAug 27, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-08-27: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se emergency application challenging state pretrial bond conditions; no doctrinal question, no public profile, no downstream significance beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score 0.04·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A fact-bound, pro se pretrial habeas and bond dispute presents little national or doctrinal significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 0%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
Akerman v. Merit Systems Protection BoardMartin Akerman asked the Chief Justice to order preservation and production of federal employment records while he pursues further appeals; the Chief Justice denied the request.Employment & discriminationdecided
0.03
—
0.02
0.03 2 of 3 models

Martin Akerman v. Merit Systems Protection Board, et al.No. 26A612 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000612 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: Employment & discrimination

Martin Akerman asked the Chief Justice to order preservation and production of federal employment records while he pursues further appeals; the Chief Justice denied the request.

What happened

Martin Akerman, representing himself, has pursued a long-running dispute over his federal employment records, including documents about administrative leave, notice leave, and a disability-retirement application he says contained false information from his employer. A federal district court denied his request for a preliminary injunction ordering production of these records, finding part of his request outside the lawsuit and insufficient evidence of urgent harm. The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals later denied reconsideration and an administrative injunction. Akerman then asked the Supreme Court to step in while he prepares a petition asking it to review the appeals court's refusal to grant interim relief.

What the Court is being asked

Akerman asked the Chief Justice, acting as the justice responsible for emergency matters from the D.C. Circuit, to order preservation and production of specific employment and disability records, and to restore a procedural window that closed in April 2026, while his case continues in the lower courts.

Where it stands

The application was submitted to the Chief Justice on October 20, 2026, and denied on November 3, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Akerman, the applicant, sought the injunction; the Merit Systems Protection Board and other federal respondents opposed it. Denying the application, which is what happened, leaves in place the lower courts' refusals to order preservation or production of the disputed records while Akerman's case proceeds. It does not decide the underlying disputes over his employment records or benefits claims, which remain pending in the lower courts and agencies.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 3, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-03: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Martin Akerman, representing himself, asked the Supreme Court to order (an "injunction") the Merit Systems Protection Board and other federal respondents to act or stop acting while his case continues. We predict the request will be denied, with about a 2% chance of any relief. The Court almost never grants injunctions at this stage, especially to individuals without lawyers in personal employment disputes against the government. The application's text could not be read, so this forecast rests on the docket and on past patterns.

    Why this big-case score: An individual federal-employment dispute brought by a self-represented applicant; no broader legal question is visible on the record.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny Martin Akerman's request for an emergency injunction, an order temporarily requiring or preventing action while litigation continues. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of some relief, excluding cases that end because the request no longer matters. The most likely result is a brief denial in November without further briefing or explanation. This forecast is limited: the application was fetched but its text could not be extracted, so the applicant's arguments and claimed urgent harm could not be assessed.

    Why this big-case score: The docket identifies an injunction application against the MSPB and others, but the application has no extracted text, so the substantive stakes cannot reliably be assessed.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court is virtually certain to deny Martin Akerman's emergency application for a stay (a temporary halt to lower-court proceedings while an appeal continues), estimating only a 1% chance that relief is granted. The Supreme Court grants emergency stays only in exceptional cases of national importance where the lower court clearly erred and irreversible harm would otherwise occur. Here, a self-represented litigant is asking the Court to intervene in the middle of an ongoing federal employment and public-records lawsuit after both the trial court and the appeals court rejected similar emergency requests, and the Supreme Court has already turned down his previous related applications.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se interlocutory stay application arising from an individual federal employment/FOIA dispute with no broad legal or policy significance.

Alejandro Evaristo Perez v. DisneyA Texas man asks the Court to revive his copyright and fraud claims against Disney, after lower courts dismissed his case and his appeal.awaiting the Court
0.03
—
0.01
0.02 2 of 3 models

Alejandro Evaristo Perez v. Disney Corporation, et al.No. 26-517 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000517 · models differ by up to 0.02

A Texas man asks the Court to revive his copyright and fraud claims against Disney, after lower courts dismissed his case and his appeal.

What happened

Alejandro Evaristo Perez, representing himself, sued Disney and several related entities in federal district court in Houston, claiming they infringed his copyrights and conspired against him, including by having Amazon remove his self-published novels. The district court dismissed his claims in 2023 and 2024, finding it lacked personal jurisdiction over most Disney entities and that he failed to state a claim against one. The court entered final judgment for Disney. Perez appealed, but the Fifth Circuit granted Disney's motion to dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction in October 2024. Perez, acting without a lawyer, then petitioned the Supreme Court to review that outcome.

What the Court is being asked

The petition does not clearly identify a specific legal rule or clearly defined issue for the Court to resolve. It asks the Court to either help arrange a large financial settlement from Disney or to rule that Disney must pay billions of dollars in damages and that lower-court judges involved in the case be removed, based on the petitioner's reading of a copyright case from a different federal appeals court.

Where it stands

The petition for certiorari was filed on November 7, 2024, docketed in October 2026, with a response from Disney due November 16, 2026. The docket does not yet show any Court action on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Perez, the petitioner, is asking the Court to take up his case and rule in his favor. If the Court grants the petition, it would agree to hear the case and decide the question itself, though that would not yet determine who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the Fifth Circuit's dismissal of his appeal stands, leaving the district court's judgment for Disney in place and ending this case.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 26, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 16, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Alejandro Evaristo Perez's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Alejandro Evaristo Perez's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se private suit against Disney from an unexplained Fifth Circuit judgment; no sign of an issue reaching beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 3%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    No petition, questions presented, or lower-court opinion is available in the provisioned record; the party names alone do not establish the stakes or breadth of the dispute.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition by a private individual against a large corporation, raising no apparent issues of national importance.

Samuel Collin Robinson v. Katherine Lyman FreemanA man asks the Court to review Colorado courts' handling of a civil protection order that required him to give up firearms without, he says, adequate notice or a hearing.awaiting the Court
0.03
—
0.01
0.02 2 of 3 models

Samuel Collin Robinson v. Katherine Lyman FreemanNo. 26-538 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000538 · models differ by up to 0.02

A man asks the Court to review Colorado courts' handling of a civil protection order that required him to give up firearms without, he says, adequate notice or a hearing.

What happened

Samuel Collin Robinson and Katherine Lyman Freeman share a long-running Colorado family-court case. In 2025, Freeman sought a civil protection order against Robinson concerning contact with their son at church. A magistrate issued a temporary protection order the same day, including a firearms relinquishment requirement, which Robinson says was entered without notifying him or holding the required hearing. A later hearing made the order permanent. Robinson's challenges to the district court and the Colorado Court of Appeals were rejected, the latter on mootness and then jurisdictional grounds, and the Colorado Supreme Court denied his petition without explanation.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked to decide whether state magistrates and the firearms-relinquishment statutes they relied on satisfy constitutional due process requirements of notice and a chance to be heard before a person can be ordered to give up firearms, and whether a recent Supreme Court ruling on disarming people found to pose a credible safety threat applies when no such threat was found. The petition also asks whether rulings based on earlier, allegedly flawed findings can validly support a later permanent order.

Where it stands

Robinson filed his petition for a writ of certiorari on May 22, 2026, and the response is due November 23, 2026. The docket shows no further action since filing.

What each outcome would mean

Robinson, as petitioner, is asking the Court to take up and reverse the result reached by the Colorado courts. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case in full and decide the due process and firearms-relinquishment questions, without yet determining who wins. If it denies the petition, the Colorado Supreme Court's decision not to intervene stands, leaving the permanent protection order and its firearms relinquishment requirement in place as issued by the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 30, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Nov 23, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Samuel Collin Robinson's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Samuel Collin Robinson's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Private, pro se dispute from a Colorado Supreme Court original proceeding; no sign of issues reaching beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    No question presented, petition text, or lower-court opinion is provisioned; the caption and docket skeleton do not establish the subject or stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se petition from a Colorado Supreme Court original proceeding arising out of a recurrent private domestic-relations and parenting-time dispute; no national legal significance or broad public stakes.

Frank Michael Monte v. United StatesFrank Michael Monte, III, asked Justice Alito to pause a lower court action while his case against the federal government continued; the application was denied.Criminal lawdecided
0.03
—
0.01
0.02 2 of 3 models

Frank Michael Monte, III v. United StatesNo. 26A532 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000532 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Criminal law

Frank Michael Monte, III, asked Justice Alito to pause a lower court action while his case against the federal government continued; the application was denied.

What happened

Frank Michael Monte, III, is pursuing a case against the United States that reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. The docket does not describe the underlying dispute or what the Third Circuit decided. Monte then applied to the Supreme Court, asking Justice Alito, the justice who handles emergency matters from that circuit, for a stay — an order pausing some lower court action while the case continued.

What the Court is being asked

The Court was asked to temporarily pause whatever action or order was in effect below while Monte's case kept moving through the courts. The record does not say what specific order or deadline the stay would have paused.

Where it stands

Monte filed the stay application on October 10, 2026. Justice Alito denied the application on October 23, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Monte, as the applicant, asked for the stay against the United States. Had it been granted, the lower court action or order Monte wanted paused would have been put on hold temporarily while his case continued in the lower courts, without deciding the underlying dispute. Because Justice Alito denied the application, that pause did not happen: whatever order or proceeding Monte sought to halt remains in effect, and his case continues in the lower courts on its existing schedule.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 23, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 23, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-23: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se criminal defendant's stay application from a Third Circuit appeal; no sign of issues reaching beyond the individual case.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application has no extractable text, and the snapshot identifies neither the underlying dispute nor the relief's practical stakes; the caption and stay request alone cannot support a significance score.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Routine pro se emergency stay application arising from post-conviction and supervised-release proceedings in an individual federal criminal case with no broader legal or public policy significance.

Nichloson v. U.S. Bank National AssociationHomeowners facing eviction asked a justice to pause the sheriff's enforcement of a writ of possession while their appeal continued; the request was denied.decided
0.02
—
0.02
0.02 2 of 3 models

Micahiel Nichloson, et al. v. U.S. Bank National AssociationNo. 26A602 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000602 · models differ by up to 0.00

Homeowners facing eviction asked a justice to pause the sheriff's enforcement of a writ of possession while their appeal continued; the request was denied.

What happened

Micahiel Nichloson and James Buckman, defendants in a Florida foreclosure case brought by U.S. Bank National Association, faced a writ of possession allowing their eviction from a Miami property. They asked the district court to stay enforcement pending appeal; the court denied the motion, finding it lacked authority to stay a state-court judgment or enjoin state enforcement proceedings, and that the applicants had not shown they would suffer irreparable harm from enforcement of the federal order itself. They then sought a stay from the Eleventh Circuit, which had not ruled. They asked the Supreme Court to step in temporarily.

What the Court is being asked

The applicants asked a single justice to pause enforcement of the eviction while the appeals court decided their own pending stay request, so they would not be removed from the property before that court acted.

Where it stands

Justice Thomas, acting as circuit justice for the Eleventh Circuit, denied the stay application on November 3, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Nichloson and Buckman, as applicants, asked for temporary relief pausing their eviction while the Eleventh Circuit considered a stay motion already pending there. Granting the application would have paused enforcement of the writ of possession until the appeals court ruled or until a further order. Denying it, which is what happened, leaves the writ of possession in effect, meaning U.S. Bank can proceed with enforcement unless the Eleventh Circuit itself grants a stay. The denial does not resolve the underlying appeal or the foreclosure dispute, which continues in the lower courts.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 3, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 3, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-03: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The applicant, representing themselves, asked the Supreme Court to pause (stay) proceedings in a Florida federal case against U.S. Bank. We think the request is almost certain to be turned down: about a 1-in-100 chance it is granted. The Court rarely grants these requests in private disputes with no wider legal importance. It grants them even more rarely when the applicant appears not to have asked the court of appeals first, and when the applicant has no lawyer. We expect Justice Thomas to deny it alone, without asking the bank to respond.

    Why this big-case score: A self-represented litigant's stay request in a single private mortgage/foreclosure-type dispute with U.S. Bank; no broader legal stakes are visible.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to deny the applicants' request to pause a lower-court proceeding or decision involving U.S. Bank. I estimate about a one-in-twenty-five chance of a complete grant. The available record shows only the request's submission to Justice Thomas, with no request for a response or other sign of escalation yet. The application itself is unreadable, so its legal arguments and claimed harm cannot be assessed. I expect a short order without an explanation, probably in early to mid-November.

    Why this big-case score: The application has no extractable text and the snapshot identifies neither the legal question nor the threatened harm; the caption alone cannot establish the stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will **deny** the emergency application for a stay in *Micahiel Nichloson, et al. v. U.S. Bank National Association*, placing the chance of the Court granting a stay (a temporary order pausing lower-court proceedings) at **0.5% (1 in 200)** — virtually certain denial. The applicant, representing himself without a lawyer (*pro se*), asks Justice Thomas to pause a federal district court order that sent a removed state-court dispute with U.S. Bank back to Florida state court. Because the Supreme Court almost never grants emergency relief directly from a federal trial court without a prior ruling from a federal appeals court, and no response from U.S. Bank has been requested, Justice Thomas is expected to summarily deny the request alone without a written opinion.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se emergency stay application seeking to halt a federal district court order remanding a removed state-court foreclosure/ejectment action (U.S. Bank National Association v. Nichloson, S.D. Fla. No. 1:26-cv-25796) without prior Eleventh Circuit disposition.

Smith v. BrownA homeowner asked the Chief Justice to pause a Maryland eviction while she seeks Supreme Court review; the Chief Justice denied the request.decided
0.03
—
0.01
0.02 2 of 3 models

Denise Smith v. Brown, Savage, Britto, Stitely & Callahan, LLP, et al.No. 26A619 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000619 · models differ by up to 0.02

A homeowner asked the Chief Justice to pause a Maryland eviction while she seeks Supreme Court review; the Chief Justice denied the request.

What happened

Denise Smith lost a Maryland foreclosure dispute involving Nationstar Mortgage and related parties. After a 2018 auction, a bankruptcy court entered a 2019 consent order setting payment and default procedures. Smith says Nationstar's counsel told her to withhold payments and then used her nonpayment as a default, while a bankruptcy judge later declined to rule on that claimed default. Maryland's courts denied her appeal on procedural grounds, and the Supreme Court of Maryland denied review and reconsideration. With a writ of possession pending, Smith asked the Chief Justice, acting as Circuit Justice for the Fourth Circuit, to stay enforcement while she prepares a Supreme Court petition.

What the Court is being asked

The application asks whether enforcing the Maryland possession judgment should be paused temporarily so Smith can pursue a petition asking the Court to review whether Maryland's appellate filing rules were applied in a way that unfairly blocked her from getting a hearing on her federal due-process claim about the disputed loan default.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice denied the stay application on November 3, 2026, shortly after it was filed and submitted to him.

What each outcome would mean

Smith, the applicant, asked for the stay. Granting it would have temporarily paused enforcement of the Maryland possession judgment against her while she prepared a certiorari petition, without deciding who is ultimately right. Because the Chief Justice denied it, the possession judgment favoring Nationstar and the other respondents remains enforceable, and nothing currently blocks execution of the writ of possession while Smith's case continues elsewhere.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 3, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-03: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Denise Smith, representing herself, has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to pause (stay) a decision from Maryland's highest court in her dispute with a law firm. We predict the request will almost certainly be **denied**, with about a 2% chance of success. Requests like this from people without lawyers, in private disputes coming from state courts, are very rarely granted. The Chief Justice will probably deny it alone without asking the other side to respond. We could not read the application itself because the file had no extractable text.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se private dispute against a law firm out of the Maryland Supreme Court; no sign of stakes reaching past the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 3%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to refuse Denise Smith's request to pause a Maryland court action. I estimate about a three-in-one-hundred chance of granting at least some of the requested relief. Such pauses require strong legal grounds and urgent harm that cannot otherwise be repaired. The record shows only the request's submission to Chief Justice Roberts, not its arguments: the filing's text could not be extracted. I expect a short denial without an explanation, probably by mid-November.

    Why this big-case score: The application has no extracted text, so its federal question, requested stay's reach, and underlying stakes cannot be responsibly assessed from the caption alone.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court grants the application: 0%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will deny Denise Smith's emergency application for a stay—a temporary court order halting lower-court action—with a probability of grant of 0.2% (almost certainly denied). Smith, representing herself without a lawyer, asks Chief Justice John Roberts to halt enforcement of a Maryland state-court foreclosure and eviction order concerning her Bowie, Maryland home. However, the foreclosure sale was finalized years ago, the Maryland appellate court dismissed her appeal in April 2026 because she failed to file a required brief, and a federal court recently rejected her parallel claims as legally barred. Because the case involves a routine state-law property dispute with a clear procedural default and no national legal question, Chief Justice Roberts is almost certain to deny the request alone without asking the opposing law firm to respond.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se emergency stay application arising from a long-running Maryland residential foreclosure and eviction dispute with no broader doctrinal or policy significance.

Schultz v. McCarthyA bankruptcy litigant's emergency request to pause a federal district judge's ruling in his appeal was denied by the Chief Justice.decided
0.02
—
0.02
0.02 2 of 3 models

Paul Schultz v. Kevin McCarthyNo. 26A657 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000657 · models differ by up to 0.00

A bankruptcy litigant's emergency request to pause a federal district judge's ruling in his appeal was denied by the Chief Justice.

What happened

Paul David Schultz, a debtor in a long-running bankruptcy dispute, sought to stop the district judge handling his appeal against trustee Kevin McCarthy from ruling on the merits. Schultz had asked that judge to recuse herself, alleging she wrongly reframed his disqualification argument; she declined, and the Fourth Circuit denied a related mandamus petition while his rehearing request remained pending there. Schultz then asked the Chief Justice, as the circuit's designated justice, to temporarily block the district judge from deciding the appeal while that rehearing process continued.

What the Court is being asked

Schultz asked for a temporary order pausing the district judge from issuing a final ruling in his bankruptcy appeal, so that his pending request asking the appeals court to reconsider his recusal argument could be resolved first. He argued that without this pause, the judge could decide the case before his challenge to her continued involvement could be reviewed, making that review meaningless.

Where it stands

The Chief Justice denied the stay application on November 10, 2026, eight days after it was filed.

What each outcome would mean

Schultz, as the applicant, asked the Court to pause proceedings before McCarthy's case could be decided below. With the application denied, no pause is in effect: the district judge Schultz sought to have removed remains free to rule on the merits of his bankruptcy appeal, and his related rehearing request continues before the Fourth Circuit on its own schedule. Had the stay been granted, the district judge would have been temporarily blocked from issuing a merits ruling until the appeals court acted on Schultz's pending rehearing and recusal arguments.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 10, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-10: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Paul Schultz, representing himself, asked the Supreme Court to pause ("stay") a lower-court ruling while his appeal in the Fourth Circuit continues. We expect the request to be **denied**. The chance it is granted is very small, about 1 in 70. Requests like this from people without lawyers, in what appears to be a private dispute, are almost always turned down quickly by the Chief Justice without explanation. We could not read the application itself, because its text could not be extracted.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se stay application in what appears to be a private bankruptcy-related dispute; no broader legal stakes visible.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 7%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    I expect the Supreme Court to deny Paul Schultz's request to pause a lower-court action. I put the chance of receiving at least some relief at about seven in one hundred, excluding cases that end because the request no longer matters. Similar requests by private applicants usually fail. The available record shows only the initial submission, and the 61-page application has no readable extracted text, so its specific arguments and practical stakes remain unknown. I expect a short order without a written explanation.

    Why this big-case score: The application has no extracted substantive text, and the arrival docket does not identify the underlying dispute or consequences of relief; stakes cannot be responsibly placed from the caption alone.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    We predict that the Supreme Court will deny Paul Schultz's emergency application for a stay (`denied`), with less than a one-in-one-hundred chance of a grant (`0.5%` probability). Representing himself without a lawyer in a personal bankruptcy dispute against bankruptcy trustee Kevin McCarthy, Schultz asks Chief Justice John Roberts to halt lower-court proceedings after the federal appeals court refused to force the trial judge to step aside for alleged bias. The Supreme Court almost never grants emergency relief in routine personal bankruptcy disputes or requests to disqualify a judge, so Chief Justice Roberts will likely deny the application without asking the trustee for a response or referring the matter to the full Court.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se stay application arising from the Fourth Circuit's unpublished denial of a mandamus petition seeking a district judge's recusal in an individual Chapter 7 bankruptcy appeal, carrying no broader doctrinal or public-policy significance.

Gilmore v. WalmartBridget Gilmore asks the Supreme Court to pause a federal appeals court mandate in her employment lawsuit against Walmart.Civil procedureawaiting the Court
0.02
—
—
0.02 1 of 3 models

Bridget Gilmore v. Walmart, IncorporatedNo. 26A163 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000163 · models differ by up to 0.00 · topic: Civil procedure

Bridget Gilmore asks the Supreme Court to pause a federal appeals court mandate in her employment lawsuit against Walmart.

What happened

Gilmore sued Walmart in federal district court in Louisiana; the case reached the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on appeal. In February 2026 the Fifth Circuit granted Walmart's motion to dismiss the appeal. Gilmore's request for rehearing by the full court was denied in March. She then filed a series of motions asking the appeals court to preserve evidence, vacate its order, correct the docket, strike Walmart's filings, stay the mandate, and recall the mandate, arguing the clerk's office mishandled her filings. The Fifth Circuit denied these motions, and some later filings were marked "received, no action taken" because of filing errors. Gilmore, representing herself, then applied to the Supreme Court for a stay.

What the Court is being asked

Gilmore asks the Court to pause enforcement of the Fifth Circuit's mandate—the formal order that returns the case to the lower court and makes the appeals court's decision effective—while she pursues further review. She says the appellate docket contains processing errors and inconsistencies that make the record unstable, and that pausing the mandate would preserve things as they are without deciding who should ultimately win the underlying appeal.

Where it stands

The application for a stay was submitted to Justice Alito on July 22, 2026, and the case was docketed on August 5, 2026. The record shows no entry recording a decision on the application.

What each outcome would mean

Gilmore, who lost in the Fifth Circuit, is asking the Supreme Court to act. If the Court grants the stay, the Fifth Circuit's mandate would be paused temporarily, keeping the current docket record in place while Gilmore seeks further review; this would not decide the underlying appeal against Walmart. If the Court denies the stay, the mandate would take effect, leaving the Fifth Circuit's dismissal of Gilmore's appeal in place. Either way, the Supreme Court's action here would not resolve the merits of Gilmore's case against Walmart.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 4, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rules
  • If granted: Gilmore gets the relief requested for now, while the case continues in the lower courts.
  • If denied: Gilmore does not get the relief requested for now, and things stay as the lower courts left them while the case continues.

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Awaiting the Court. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se stay application against a private employer after a procedurally dismissed Fifth Circuit appeal; no legal question of general importance is presented and no one beyond the parties is affected.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The caption and stay-submission entry disclose neither the legal question nor the threatened harm, so the case's substantive stakes cannot be placed responsibly.

  • GeminiBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se procedural dispute regarding appellate docketing; lacks broad national significance.

In re FarrJoan Farr asked the Court to order relief in her long-running case against a former celebrity manager and others, and the Court declined to take it up.decided
0.02
—
0.01
0.01 2 of 3 models

In Re Joan Farrscotus/73500218 · models differ by up to 0.01

Joan Farr asked the Court to order relief in her long-running case against a former celebrity manager and others, and the Court declined to take it up.

What happened

Joan Farr, representing herself, filed earlier lawsuits against Alexandra Grant, grantLove LLC, attorney Scott Sims, the law firm Ziffren Brittenham LLP, and WME IMG, LLC, among others. A federal district court in Missouri dismissed her case, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed that dismissal, later denying rehearing. Farr then asked the Supreme Court to step in through a petition for a writ of mandamus, an order directing a lower court or official to act, filed alongside a separate petition for certiorari she describes as pending. Her petition says she seeks to act as "next friend" for actor Keanu Reeves and to have him and other parties added to the case.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether Farr may act on behalf of a third party in pursuing this case under an exception that sometimes allows one person to litigate for another who cannot act for himself, and whether, if the case were sent back for trial, that third party and additional parties should be added to the lawsuit.

Where it stands

The United States and the other respondents waived their right to respond. The petition was distributed for the Court's September 28, 2026 conference, and on October 5, 2026 the Court denied the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Farr, as petitioner, asked the Court to order relief in her favor and to let her add Reeves and other parties to the case. By denying the petition, the Court left the Eighth Circuit's decision affirming dismissal of Farr's case standing, meaning Grant, grantLove LLC, Sims, Ziffren Brittenham LLP, WME IMG, and the government defendants prevail, and Farr's case is not revived or sent back for further proceedings.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Petition filed
  2. Court decidesTurned it downOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted once the petition was distributed for conference. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court turned it down. evt-petition-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se Rule 20 petition for a writ of mandamus arising from a dismissed private civil suit in the Western District of Missouri that the Eighth Circuit affirmed; no legal question of general importance, no government interest, and no plausible downstream significance.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The docket identifies an original mandamus petition, but no substantive question or requested remedy is readable: no documents were provisioned, and all 22 pages of the retrieved petition yielded no extracted text. The caption alone cannot establish significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se mandamus petition with minimal legal footprint or public interest.

Boddie v. United States District CourtA trust's successor trustee asks the Court to review whether courts can bind and sell her trust's property in an FTC enforcement case without making her a party.Business & financeawaiting the Court
0.03
—
0.00
0.01 2 of 3 models

Beckie Boddie v. United States District Court for the District of MarylandNo. 26-424 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000424 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Business & finance

A trust's successor trustee asks the Court to review whether courts can bind and sell her trust's property in an FTC enforcement case without making her a party.

What happened

Beckie Boddie, successor trustee of a family trust that owns a lot in the Sanctuary Belize development, was never named as a party in the underlying FTC enforcement action against the development's operators. A federal district court entered orders establishing a redress plan, later changed its financial terms, and approved selling the property to a third party, ending Boddie's original purchase contract. When Boddie tried to challenge these orders, the district court repeatedly struck her filings because she was not a party. The Fourth Circuit affirmed denial of her bid to intervene and dismissed the rest of her appeal, finding she lacked standing to appeal as a nonparty.

What the Court is being asked

The Court is asked whether it violates constitutional due-process protections for a federal court to dispose of a nonparty property owner's real estate without notice or a hearing, while also blocking any appeal on the ground that the owner was never a party. The Court is also asked whether the law letting the agency seek injunctions in such cases allows a court to rewrite a nonparty's private contracts and dispose of that nonparty's property.

Where it stands

The petition was distributed for the Court's conference of December 4, 2026. The docket shows no action on it since that distribution.

What each outcome would mean

Boddie is asking the Court to take up and reverse the result below. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear the case fully and decide whether the property disposition and the bar on her appeal violated due process; granting does not itself decide who is right. If the Court denies the petition, the Fourth Circuit's dismissal of Boddie's appeal stands, leaving the property sale and redress-plan orders in place without further review by the Court.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 16, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesConference Dec 4, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Boddie's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Boddie's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.03·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se third-party claimant's petition from an unpublished per curiam denial of mandamus in the FTC's Sanctuary Belize receivership; no legal question of general reach and no party but the petitioner is affected.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 1%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    No questions presented, petition text, or lower-court opinion was available; the caption and docket dates alone do not establish the substantive stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se petition against a district court, lacking broad significance.

Shaikh v. Fox News NetworkA man asks the Court to revive his lawsuit accusing major media companies of spying on him through hacked devices and mind-reading technology.awaiting the Court
0.01
—
0.02
0.01 2 of 3 models

Ahmed Shaikh v. Fox News Network, LLC, et al.No. 26-583 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9026000583 · models differ by up to 0.01

A man asks the Court to revive his lawsuit accusing major media companies of spying on him through hacked devices and mind-reading technology.

What happened

Ahmed Shaikh, representing himself, sued five media companies—Fox News, Paramount Global, Warner Bros. Discovery, NBCUniversal, and Disney—claiming they hacked his devices, planted hidden cameras, and used technology to read his thoughts for use in broadcasts. A federal district court dismissed the case, finding the claims "patently insubstantial" and therefore outside its jurisdiction. The court did not rule on Shaikh's request for sanctions against Disney. The court of appeals affirmed, agreeing the allegations had no plausible foundation, and later denied rehearing.

What the Court is being asked

Shaikh raises two issues. First, he argues the lower courts wrongly treated his claims as too insubstantial to even give the court jurisdiction, when courts elsewhere have let similar surveillance-technology claims proceed as ordinary disputes over the facts of the case. Second, he argues that once a court decides it lacks jurisdiction over a case, it should still be able to rule on pending requests for sanctions against a party, rather than treating itself as powerless to act on them.

Where it stands

The petition was filed and docketed in November 2026, with the respondents' response due December 3, 2026. The Court has not yet acted on the petition.

What each outcome would mean

Shaikh, who lost in the lower courts, is asking the Court to take up his case. If the Court grants the petition, it would hear full arguments and decide the jurisdictional and sanctions questions; a grant alone would not determine who wins. If the Court denies the petition, the lower court's dismissal of Shaikh's lawsuit against the media companies stands, and the case remains closed.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 11, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Sent to conference
  2. Court decidesResponse due Dec 3, 2026
  • If granted: The Court takes up Shaikh's case. A grant alone decides nothing yet about who is right.
  • If denied: Shaikh's petition ends and the lower court's decision stands. That is not a ruling that the lower court was right.

The models' predictions

Will the Court take the case?Predicted when the petition was docketed, before anything else happened on the docket. Awaiting the Court. evt-petition-arrival-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court will almost certainly turn down this case (roughly a 1-in-500 chance it agrees to hear it). Mr. Shaikh, representing himself, sued Fox News and other media companies. He claims they used hidden cameras and mind-reading technology to watch him. The lower courts threw the suit out because the claims were too far-fetched to give a federal court authority to hear them (a lack of "jurisdiction"). The only legal question the appeals court noted was one he never argued there. Expect a routine denial at the first conference.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se claims that media companies read the petitioner's thoughts via hidden cameras, dismissed below as wholly insubstantial; no stakes beyond the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court takes the case: 2%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to decline Ahmed Shaikh's request to review his case against Fox News Network and other defendants. I estimate about a two-in-one-hundred chance that the Court takes some action granting review. Most comparable paid petitions are unsuccessful, and the docket appears to list Shaikh as representing himself. However, the petition and the lower court's reasoning are unavailable, so the legal issue and its importance cannot be assessed. I expect ordinary scheduling followed by denial, probably in early 2027.

    Why this big-case score: Neither the petition nor its questions presented nor the decision below is provisioned; the caption alone cannot establish the legal stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court takes the case: 0%·Prediction: turn it downused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is virtually certain to deny review in *Ahmed Shaikh v. Fox News Network, LLC*, with a grant probability of 0.1% (one in a thousand). Representing himself without a lawyer, Shaikh sued five major television networks, alleging they accessed hidden cameras and used government mind-reading technology to broadcast his thoughts. The federal appeals court affirmed the dismissal of his lawsuit as factually frivolous and lacking federal court jurisdiction (legal authority to hear the case), leaving no preserved legal question warranting Supreme Court intervention.

    Why this big-case score: Pro se civil suit dismissed as patently frivolous under Bell v. Hood, with any diversity-jurisdiction question held abandoned on appeal.

Givey v. BlancheA pro se applicant asked a single Justice for emergency witness protection and an order forcing the Justice Department to accept a criminal complaint; the Justice denied it.First Amendmentdecidedpossible leak
0.02
—
0.01
0.01 2 of 3 models

Ryan P. Givey v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General, et al.No. 26A434 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000434 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: First Amendment

A pro se applicant asked a single Justice for emergency witness protection and an order forcing the Justice Department to accept a criminal complaint; the Justice denied it.

What happened

Ryan P. Givey, representing himself, has pursued a series of federal lawsuits since 2022 claiming he is a whistleblower who has been targeted by officials and private parties, and demanding that the Department of Justice accept a criminal complaint and place him in witness protection. A federal district court and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals rejected his requests, including an emergency injunction he sought from the appeals court. Givey then asked the Supreme Court, through Circuit Justice Samuel Alito, to grant similar emergency relief while a related petition remained pending.

What the Court is being asked

The question is whether a single Justice should order emergency, temporary protection measures and compel a federal agency to take a specific law-enforcement action while the underlying case continues, before the full Court has considered the merits of Givey's broader petition.

Where it stands

Justice Alito denied the application on October 1, 2026, shortly after it was filed. The related petition referenced in the application remains a separate matter before the Court.

What each outcome would mean

Givey, as the applicant, asked the Court to order emergency protective measures and compel government action. Justice Alito's denial leaves things as they were: no injunction, no order requiring the Department of Justice to accept Givey's criminal complaint, and no witness-protection arrangement. The underlying dispute, including Givey's related Supreme Court petition and his lawsuits against federal officials, continues separately and is not resolved by this denial.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 1, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se civil-rights suit against the Attorney General, the FBI Director and a U.S. Attorney, dismissed below for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction; the application asks a Circuit Justice for an injunction. Whatever the disposition, it decides nothing beyond this litigant.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application has no extractable text; the caption and submission entry do not identify the substantive dispute, scope of relief, or public stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court grants the application: 0%·Prediction: deny itpossible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se injunction application against the DOJ; routine and highly likely to be summarily denied with no broader impact.

In re ValovA Virginia homeowner facing eviction under a civil-contempt order asked the Chief Justice to block enforcement while state courts reviewed his case; the application was denied.Constitutional rightsdecidedpossible leak
0.02
—
0.01
0.01 2 of 3 models

In Re Nikolay M. ValovNo. 26A437 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000437 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: Constitutional rights

A Virginia homeowner facing eviction under a civil-contempt order asked the Chief Justice to block enforcement while state courts reviewed his case; the application was denied.

What happened

Nikolay Valov, a co-owner of a house in Alexandria, Virginia, was held in civil contempt by a state circuit court for interfering with a court-ordered sale of the property. The contempt order let him avoid eviction if he met several conditions, including paying for repairs and vacating at scheduled times for contractors and showings. A court officer later said Valov missed a payment deadline and filed a notice to vacate. Valov pursued emergency relief in the Virginia Court of Appeals and Supreme Court of Virginia, without success in getting possession-protecting orders, while an eviction writ was sought in circuit court.

What the Court is being asked

Valov asked the Chief Justice, acting as the circuit justice for the region covering Virginia, to temporarily block any enforcement action that would remove him from the home while state court proceedings continued, so that his claims about inadequate legal process and improper government interference with his home could still be reviewed.

Where it stands

The application for emergency relief was submitted to the Chief Justice on September 28, 2026, and denied on October 1, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Valov, the applicant, asked the Court to pause enforcement of the eviction mechanism while his state-court challenges proceeded. Because the application was denied, no order from the Chief Justice protects his possession of the property, and the state court eviction process may proceed under the existing contempt order and notice to vacate, while Valov's related proceedings in the Virginia courts continue on their own track. The denial does not decide the underlying constitutional questions Valov raised.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 2, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 1, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-01: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se application for an injunction pending appeal from a Virginia county circuit court civil case (CL25-2218), captioned In Re the applicant, with no counsel, no amici and no identifiable public stake; whatever the disposition, it affects one litigant.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 4%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The docket identifies an individual applicant seeking an injunction in a Virginia state-court matter, but the 73-page application has no extracted text. The subject, threatened harm, and broader stakes cannot be responsibly assessed.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itpossible leakused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    A pro se application from a state trial court with no media coverage.

Schultz v. GoldA bankruptcy litigant's emergency request to pause a federal district judge's upcoming ruling while he pursued recusal arguments was denied by the Chief Justice.Business & financedecided
0.02
—
0.01
0.01 2 of 3 models

Paul Schultz v. H. Jason GoldNo. 26A658 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000658 · models differ by up to 0.01 · topic: Business & finance

A bankruptcy litigant's emergency request to pause a federal district judge's upcoming ruling while he pursued recusal arguments was denied by the Chief Justice.

What happened

Paul Schultz, a debtor in a long-running bankruptcy dispute, sought to have the federal district judge handling an appeal involving trustee H. Jason Gold removed from the case, arguing the judge's impartiality was reasonably in question. After the judge denied his recusal motion, Schultz asked the Fourth Circuit for mandamus relief, which was denied, and he then filed a petition for rehearing there. Fearing the district judge would issue a merits ruling before the rehearing petition was resolved, Schultz asked the Supreme Court to step in.

What the Court is being asked

Schultz asked the Circuit Justice to temporarily block the district judge from issuing a final ruling in the underlying appeal until the Fourth Circuit finished considering whether that judge should be removed from the case for appearing partial. He argued that without such a pause, the question of whether the judge could keep handling the case would become moot once she ruled.

Where it stands

The application for a stay was submitted to the Chief Justice on November 2, 2026, and denied on November 11, 2026.

What each outcome would mean

Schultz, the applicant, asked the Court to pause the district judge's handling of the underlying appeal while recusal proceedings continued in the Fourth Circuit. Denying the stay, which is what happened, means no pause was ordered: the district judge remains free to rule on the appeal while Schultz's rehearing petition proceeds separately in the Fourth Circuit. The denial does not decide whether recusal was warranted or resolve the underlying bankruptcy dispute between Schultz and Gold; it only means the Supreme Court did not grant the temporary relief Schultz requested.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 12, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedNov 11, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-11-11: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 2%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Paul Schultz, representing himself, asked the Supreme Court to pause ("stay") a lower-court ruling in a bankruptcy dispute with a bankruptcy trustee. We predict the request will be denied — the chance of it being granted is very small, about one in fifty. Emergency requests from individuals without lawyers almost never succeed, the dispute appears personal rather than raising a broad legal question, and the Court has shown no sign of interest (it has not asked the other side to respond).

    Why this big-case score: Self-represented individual seeking a stay in a personal bankruptcy dispute with a Chapter 7 trustee; no broader stakes visible.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is very likely to reject Paul Schultz's request to pause proceedings or an order in his bankruptcy-related case. I put the chance of receiving at least some of that relief at about six in one hundred, excluding a decision that the request no longer matters. Similar requests from private applicants usually fail. The record shows only the request's submission, with no response requested yet. The application itself could not be read, so this forecast relies mainly on the docket and historical patterns, not its legal arguments.

    Why this big-case score: The application has no extractable text; the caption and bankruptcy-appellate origin alone do not establish the relief's scope or substantive significance.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.01·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The Supreme Court is almost certain to deny Paul Schultz's emergency application for a stay (1% chance of a grant). Schultz, representing himself in ongoing personal bankruptcy litigation, seeks emergency relief after a federal appeals court refused to remove the trial judge overseeing his bankruptcy appeal. The Supreme Court grants emergency stays only when at least four Justices are likely to take up the case and reverse the lower court's ruling, and routine judicial-disqualification disputes in personal bankruptcy cases almost never meet that bar.

    Why this big-case score: Routine pro se bankruptcy stay application following an unpublished Fourth Circuit denial of a mandamus petition seeking district-judge recusal.

Holloway v. PolkA mother asked a Justice to pause a Texas custody order and related enforcement while her appeal of a fee-based dismissal proceeds; the application was denied.Constitutional rightsdecided
0.02
—
0.00
0.01 2 of 3 models

Elisha Holloway v. Bryan PolkNo. 26A449 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/9526000449 · models differ by up to 0.02 · topic: Constitutional rights

A mother asked a Justice to pause a Texas custody order and related enforcement while her appeal of a fee-based dismissal proceeds; the application was denied.

What happened

Elisha Holloway sought to appeal a Texas trial court order that gave Bryan Polk sole custody and restricted Holloway to supervised visits. Texas appellate courts dismissed her appeal after she did not pay a $205 filing fee, and denied her request to reconsider her claimed inability to pay. The Texas Supreme Court declined further review. Separately, the trial court later issued an order and writ directing law enforcement to locate the children and deliver them to Polk, relying on the original custody order; Holloway's attempt to appeal that attachment order was also dismissed, since Texas courts held such orders are not appealable. Holloway then asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stay enforcement while she pursues a petition for review there.

What the Court is being asked

Holloway asked a single Justice to temporarily block enforcement of the custody and attachment orders while the Court considers her petition asking it to review whether Texas courts violated her constitutional rights by closing off her only appeal over an unpaid fee before deciding her request to be excused from paying it.

Where it stands

The application for a stay was submitted to Justice Alito on September 27, 2026, and he denied it on October 5, 2026. The underlying petition for a writ of certiorari, referenced in the application, is not itself reported as decided in this record.

What each outcome would mean

Holloway, naming herself Applicant, asked the Court to pause enforcement of the custody and attachment orders while her broader appeal continues. Granting the stay would have temporarily blocked enforcement of those orders against her, preserving the children's current situation during further review. Denying it, which is what happened, leaves those orders in effect and enforceable by Texas authorities while Holloway's separate petition for certiorari, if still pending, proceeds on its own schedule.

Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofOct 6, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗

Progress at the Court

  1. Court rulesDeniedOct 5, 2026

The models' predictions

Will the Court grant the emergency application?Predicted when the application arrived. Decided 2026-10-05: the Court denied the application. evt-motion-disposition

  • ClaudeBig-case score 0.02·Chance the Court grants the application: 1%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se stay application from a Texas state-court civil matter by a serial self-represented litigant; no doctrinal question is visible, no institutional party is involved, and the outcome matters only to the parties.

  • CodexBig-case score —·Chance the Court grants the application: 6%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    The application has no extractable text, and the caption and submission entry do not identify the underlying dispute, requested stay's practical consequences, or broader stakes.

  • GeminiBig-case score 0.00·Chance the Court grants the application: 0%·Prediction: deny itused in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗

    Pro se civil filing by an applicant designated as a vexatious litigant.

411 cases · 1194 scores · 4 with a possible leak · 1 predicted cases have no score and aren't listed